Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

New video here. There's a lot I could say about this one but should probably let the video do the talking for now. I'll check in again soon with other updates, etc.

Till then, enjoy! Or maybe "enjoy" isn't the right word, but you know—suffer in style.

–Natalie

Files

CONSPIRACY | contrapoints

Context note: This video discusses misinformation for the purpose of pointing out that it is misinformation. Support this channel: https://www.patreon.com/contrapoints Follow me: •Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/contrapoints.bsky.social •Xitter: https://twitter.com/ContraPoints •Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/contrapoints/ •Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ContraPoints/ •Website: https://www.contrapoints.com/ •Tumblr: https://www.tumblr.com/blog/nataliewynn •Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPoints •Alt/livestream channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPointsLive •Donate: https://paypal.me/contrapoints Check out my other videos: Twilight: https://youtu.be/bqloPw5wp48 The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/EmT0i0xG6zg The Hunger: https://youtu.be/RTRT794IQBg Envy: https://youtu.be/aPhrTOg1RUk J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/7gDKbT_l2us Voting: https://youtu.be/t3Vah8sUFgI Justice (Part 1): https://youtu.be/smQsfNw_7V4 Cringe: https://youtu.be/vRBsaJPkt2Q Shame: https://youtu.be/K7WvHTl_Q7I Canceling: https://youtu.be/OjMPJVmXxV8 Opulence: https://youtu.be/jD-PbF3ywGo Music: Zoë Blade: http://www.zoeblade.com/ OVXX: https://open.spotify.com/artist/5kysZzGC0WtDlkwSX4P1St?si=wlqg4z_wQeSZd2lXmHmEmg Bibliography: [Will add this after I have slept] ▬ Contents▬ 00:00 Part 0: Diagrams 06:14 Part 1: Just Asking Questions 21:23 Part 2: The Rabbit Pill 45:42 Part 3: Conspiracism 50:34 –Intentionalism 1:05:53 –Dualism 1:15:40 –Symbolism 1:28:58 Part 4: The Ritual 1:59:00 Part 5: It's a Big Club and You Ain't In It 2:20:16 Part 6: ?????

Comments

John Daniel

omg not a near 3 hour cinematic 😍 thank youuuuu

highclass_lady

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

Ilo

HELL YEAH

ekhowo

The way I jumped in here ASAP

Sisabisk

YEEEEES, SLAY THE QUEEN

He_football

I was having a shitty day until I saw this

Cove

What a blessed day. ❤️

Ruby Power

MOTHER HAS RETURNED 🙌🏼

Ashton

Can’t wait for this permanently alter my brain chemistry 🥹

Jessica Cheeri

This is going to be fantastic! Watching now

Khaegar

She's BACK. MOTHER IS BACK.

Rebekah J

Lez goooooooooooo

vasilis

Motherrrrrrrr

Lukas

just in time for my break!

Whitters

Fuck yeah. About to watch the shit out of this, you brilliant human.

val

just when i have exams tomorrow.... but after that i WILL be seated

Jenna

YAYYYYYY

SophieT

Wooohoooo!!! Congrats on getting it out!! Take a huuuuuge breath and take the chillest bath *ever*!!

Adam Lees

Let’s fucking gooooo

Trellis

Captain, I’m afraid we are so back

Sam Angarita

Just made my week. Congrats on getting it done hun! Look forward to this.

Fabri

Thanks, hope you get some rest!

Freycray

This is like Christmas but cuntier

Jenny Rodriguez

Oh no, I'm at work! Still 2 hours to go, oh well, I'll have it on the background and then rewatch later.

greydomovoy

thank you!! in all honesty did refresh your youtube page and google time EST around 45 seconds before getting the notification 🐑💕i have been restless

Scheppen

YOU DID IT!!!!💘 I can't wait to settle in and eat this up!!

Jon Skoog

Yes! I'm so excited! I wish I wasn't at work, so I could watch right at this moment!

Sloane

Can’t wait to watch this one

Raven

Can’t wait to watch it!! 💓 Hope you can get some much-needed rest now.

Jon Stewart

Thank God. That fizz has been burning a hole in my fridge

V

Finally!!!

Kenny Le

On my birthday, no less! Best present (aside from the ones my kids get me) EVER!

Joshua White

Literally as I walk into my shift.

India

Uh oh😆😆😆

mateja gibert

The way I screamed when I saw this notification pop up. So excited to watch this!! Thank you, Queen Natalie 🙇🏻‍♀️

Ra mrkur.

Thank you, thank you great mother and teacher, Congratulations on the new release. 💜🤍

Andrea

:D :D :D so excited! Will get right to watching it! See you on the other side!

Joshua White

Well I will be getting nothing done at work tonight.

Oscar Q.

Time to skip work to watch mother🙌

Miriam Costan

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa 🥂🥂🥂🥂it feels privileged to be here this early

yoo na

I am on vacation in Paris and I just sat down for a dinner reservation when i saw this notification. Do you think this michelin star restaurant will mind if I watch this while i eat by myself? Heavily considering. I can't wait to watch this. Thank u for blessing me.

Ruby Power

Nearly 3 hours?! Surely this could qualify to have letterboxd reviews

Cheralyn

It appears we have a NEW national holiday

Nora

Dark mother, we adore you!

dbear

My body is ready. Thank you so much.

MJayBee

Yay ❤️

SophiaRuby

Mother has blessed us 🙏

ilkyaz Dokur

Great mother, feeds her children! Thank you!❤️

SpakeO'Divil

I gotta get a tasteful beer and sit back and absorb this.

e ponce

What an auspicious day!

savannah

be glad and rejoice, for a contrapoints video has dropped 🙌

Kodo Elder-Groebe

Damn it right after I start my 8 hour shift 😭😭😭 Can't wait to come home and watch it ❤️

Theo Stratford

The mother plane has crashed into the cuntagon

emflomo

By a lucky coincidence I called in sick to work today for a self care day and this is exactly what I needed

Connor Johnson

it feels like u can predict my interests! I will forever support your work. so excited. ❤️❤️

soph

I have never been more ready to suffer in style in my life (as opposed to the non-stylish suffering i have been experiencing for the past... 9 years atp...)

Xev Masias

Solved! What a relief!

natalie b.

oh my goodness, Ethel Cain tour announced/New Album/B-Sides of Preacher’s Daughter AND Contrapoints video on Conspiracy on the same day? Transsexual consumption is peaking, I fear. YAY

Chey Wells

as someone who grew up in a household obsessed with Alex Jones, Loose Change, Bohemian Grove, and colloidal silver, I truly cannot wait to watch this video 20 times

Bogo

Regardless of what we see in this video, we remember who the real Dark Mother is.

Aqua Burton

Finally, something good to watch while not doing my job

Autumn Cooper

AAAAAHHHH! I can’t wait to get home from work 😭

Spencer Frye

Thank you so much mother thank you thank you

Merry Iris

I'm so excited to spend 2+ hours tonight watching this!!!

Jukey

WOOOOOO! OUR PRAYERS ARE ANSWERED! 🙇

Simon

Ok then

Patryk Zep

seeing the amount of excited reactions across all platforms to all your new videos makes me wonder if you sometimes turn the notifications on and relish in the chaos for a bit 😂 happy watchday everybody!!

Josh

FEEL THE RAIN ON YOUR SKIN

Patrick R.

[suffering in style]

M

Wonderful!!! Thank you Natalie!

SV Reyes

Who knew I could hold my breath that long?

Jaololpes

Love you Nat! Thank you

Sean Callahan

My life has now hit the ‘play’ button again we are so back

Maíra Macário

Fuuuuuu! I'm in class right now, how can I pay attention when I know mother awaits meee????

Anton

PLANS CANCELLED WE ARE SAT

Marzlz

WHEN JESUS SAYS YES NOBODY CAN SAY NO🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼

Specks

Thank you for your work Natalie! Looking forward to diving into this :)

Denise D

*passes everyone popcorn*

Kevin Spicer

First new video as a subscriber!! feels so good.

Evan Pitkin

Hope the QAA gang makes an appearance.

Grady Wiehe

I’m not watching this. I would’ve had it gone up even one day sooner. But now…it’s too late…JK ILY ❤️

Laura Bea

I literally picked out a specific drinks and food menu so that I can optimally enjoy watching this lmao CANT WAIT

Freyja

Yes!!!! Now I have plans for my date night 🥰

filipa 🫧

girl never say sorry for a deadline pushback ever again. you built a freaking movie from the ground up

TimBob RN

Date night with my sweetie! Snacks, white claw, and contra ! Let’s goooooo !

Ella Bar

Thank you Natalie! Can't wait to watch it!

Christopher

wow my favorite video just dropped cant wait to watch it

Rosa Writings

This is exactly what I thought the topic would be when you started working on it last like August... So proud I'm a certified contrapoints mind reader

Lilian

Anyone else excited because this means we may get more gaming content soon….!

Grace Douglas

I know what I'm doing tonight!! Congrats Natalie!! Pop a bottle and go find a beach!!

Robert Snader

29:05; They probably are tired and dejected from the NASA medical staff turning them all but inside out during their physical evaluations.

Andrew May

“So buckle your seatbelt, Kansas. We’re gonna take the rabbit pill and find out just how deep Dorothy’s hole goes” and then the fan tossing made the wait ALL WORTH IT. Brava, my lady.

Tomek

Mother provides for us

FourChambersGames

Need more Ambition streams. They're my happy place LOL :(

Alex Aversa

Awesome. So timely, i just spent a couple weeks staying with the biggest conspiracy theorist ive ever met, an older woman in australia who was like obsessed w this sort of conspiracization of especially american politics. I found it quite sad because these theories are designed to take advantage of lonely isolated people like her. I hope you tell me how i can save her! Lol

Norah Luz

Spring has sprung indeed and here are the beautiful blooms

Joanne Griffin

My husband and I have assigned this as our holiday watch for Eid. We are so so excited! ❤️

Leon

omgg im recovering from top surgery rn and basically bed bound so this timing is amazing!!!!

Milanko Doroski

The video arrived right around prime time where I‘m living. Coincidence? I think not.

Mina Y.

I told my family to shut up and have my bowl of popcorn and my notepad. I'm so ready

Robert Snader

1:02:00 THANK YOU; this moment of realization is how I have described "becoming an adult" for a long time LOL.

Jenavive!

Welcome baaaaaaaaaaaack holy shiiiiiiiit I can't waaaaaaaaait

Cherry Bee

Thank-you Natalie! Cheered up my Monday can't wait to watch 💖

Emma Stephenson

I'm half an hour in and already want to know every detail of the bts construction of the theory wall - each frame reveals new minute details, such good set dressing as always

frogsmore

I'm only 20 min in, and I already feel a desperate need to go outside and hang with my ducks. Help!

Michael Lemmen

Wonderfull. I won’t be able to see it unit later in the week but suffice it to say, I will be on reddit as soon as possible to bleat its praises.

Rose Dombegh

THERE IS STILL GOOD IN THE WORLD THANK YOU NATALIE!!!!!!!!

Solange Luftman

Woo thank you! So excited to watch it later today

Johnny Silverhand

I hope we get a behind the scenes for this. Would be cool to see how she made the costumes and the conspiracy board

Connor V

Surely I'm not the only one to notice how similar the alien galactic empire queen outfit was to the pickle in Pickle Surprise

Ninini

I'm so fucking exciteeed, almost 3 hours of heaven ♥️

Eddie

So exited! ❤️❤️

yadongon

it's happening!!!!

Joe

THE GAGA LOOK AT 21:21

RarelyOnline

I knooow! We helped fund this, Kevin 😭

Eric Phillips

Before I watch, I want to say that my new email closing is "Suffering in style" until further notice.

Viviane P.L.

The world is healing contra came back

william kirkpatrick

I wondered if the delay was because of realizing it's time to leave the country. My sister went to Mexico.

Kristian Gendron

Also I will enjoy if I want to. I am not a sheep; get out of my room mom!! (Conclusion to the video had me fist pumping. Thank you mysterious Natalie I am so parasocially attached)

flyx

When Hitler's translated speeches trend on Tiktok, we must face the truth that it was not Idiocracy that predicted the bleak future we live in, but Iron Sky.

Eleanor Elsinore

I am, too, far too parasocially obsessed. 😅

dreamer

Suffered in style ✨️ Ready to do it all over again soon of course! Worth the wait ❤️ The visuals of this one were sooooo good!!!!! Happy I turned on the tv for the première 🍿Thank you Natalie for doing what you do and making this Monday less bad 🥰

Sean Callahan

Mother has returned. She ate and left absolutely nothing…..or did she? Chat, drop your conspiracies below!

Ian Albert

This was a tough one to watch. With many issues, there are negative ways to look at it and positive ways, and you can often find that silver lining, find reasons to hope, or at least keep it in perspective. But current events and the beliefs leading to them are pretty much purely, unequivocally dark. It can't even be chalked up to "we're not sure what will happen." We *do* know, very very well. I watch analyses like this in hopes I missed something, that there is actually reason to believe it will get better soon. And nobody who's intellectually honest is telling me that. Humanity has an illness that seems to need to run its course once again. The only place I'm finding to put my hope and energy is into the individuals in my life and in myself. At least it is good to know others understand what is going on.

Jason

Another banger! Love it

Jack OD

A little disappointed to see no reference to Naomi Klein’s Doppelgänger, especially with the Naomi Wolf references in here. Covers a lot of similar territory, and parts of it tbh with more depth. Natalie I’d definitely recommend you give it a read!

Irina Mirinda

Maybe this is not the place, but this has brought me to tears at the family losing section. I made lots of jokes about conspiracy theories and the like, but I never really stopped and realized how many people are no longer in my life because they went bananas. In all cases, they had some form of guilt or humiliation complex around the world that pushed them further, and were really mad and angry at me for pointing out the mistakes in their patterns of thought. I must have missed hundreds of hours explaining the moon landing and why my nation didn't invent wifi and stuff like that. I entered this expecting some jest and some "America sucks" and now I need to discuss this video with my therapist

SophieT

Mother does NOT take her belt off, she simply looks disapprovingly.!

SophieT

Congrats!

devotion

Can't help it - your humour is just too good

Jon Gilbert

incredible work, Natalie. just finished my first watch, and it's a lot

MJ

My brain keeps auto-correcting Bilderberg to Build-a-Bear and now I’m just imagining stuffed animals in Venetian masks

Sofía Pedoggi

not even 2 minutes in, and I'm already thinking, GOD I MISSED HER SO MUUUUCH

Fruit Basket Case

Dorothy’s hole was indeed very deep (Just finished watching; thank you parasocial mother for shedding light across this madness)

Andrew May

Doppelgänger was pretty central in the Granola Fascism tangent video. I’d say she’s a fan!

A.E. Kieren

gonna write about you in my gratitude journal

Andrew May

I’ve only watched once, but I am so confused by that couch she’s sitting on. The shape, the thing on the corner to the left—what multi-dimensional furniture am I seeing?!

M. A.

Hi Mother, this was a great video that helped me a lot with my research. Just wanted to point out that Dorothy's hole is not a pyramid, it's an inverted funnel. Get it right!

Jack OD

Oho well I guess I'll have to watch that one!

Pamela Boudreau

"Hey, we're Satanists. And we're partying." Ha!

Kristian Gendron

It’s enough to put me back on my best behavior

Avery

Hey Nat, it's been over a year, and you still haven’t addressed the genocide in Gaza. Given that you’ve covered nationalism, fascism, racism, social justice, and in this video, topics like 9/11, the Iraq invasion, and scapegoating, the silence is disappointing. You’ve spoken about antisemitism, yet ignoring the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians raises questions about your stance on Zionism. As an American taxpayer, your money helps fund this apartheid state—so why stay silent?

ts_babyjane

watch the last live stream, she talks about it for like an hour

Giorgos Terzakis

This might sound like schizoposting, but has anyone heard of u/_9MOTHER9HORSE9EYES9? It was a series of seemingly random comments in several unrelated reddit posts in 2016 or sth. They construct a speculative narrative of a dark conspiracy, which I think comments a lot on conspiracy culture. Quite a rabbithole and more of a post-meta-speculative-conspiracy lore, but really worth checking out. Awesome video, Natalie!

ts_babyjane

i love that the tangents have become a way to pregame ideas for the big videos!

Ted(dy)

She actually directly addresses Gaza in the video. Not like you actually care enough to watch, of course.

Lee S.

It's one of my favorite tangents - as someone who's been adjacent to crunchy culture my whole life it was so revelatory of things that have made me uncomfortable over the years but I couldn't fully conceptualize or articulate

Fina Joliat

I grew up not too far from the place where the wef is held and i did pay you to make this video, so the wef did in some way pay you for this. Doesnt that make you go hmm?

ts_babyjane

also watch 2:09:50 mark in the video she literally just posted. There's also another livestream from years ago, pre October 7th where someone asks her about the conflict and she says that to criticizing the government of israel is not anti-semimetic. it's sooo weird to me that people will watch someone talk so concisely and empathetically about progressive politics and then assume she must be secretly harboring bigotry. like,

Scoott

I’m sure I’m probably reading too much into a joke… but is CuriosityStream/Nebula another sponsor to be skeptical of?

ongoingwow

Worth the wait, as always. Please enjoy a well earned rest and try to forget the horrors for a while!

Anthi Papadimatou

Natalie doesn't need to prove anything regarding her stance on Palestine. And for sure she is not obliged to make a whole video about the genocide in Gaza in order to prove that she is not pro-Israel. Wtf.

Anthi Papadimatou

Such an amazing video once again Natalie! And a brilliant -and much needed- analysis on politics and political thought (because in the end of the day it is about politics) in the late capitalism, post-truth era. Beyond the binary of the liberal/left vs the right. Thank you a lot!

CrystalJade

You’ve been through so much. I hope you’re not frazzled by it all. I love the analysis. As terrifying it is, it was beautifully done. Loved the appearance of unchosen tangents topics. A great synthesis of so much material. I love your belief in psychoanalysis, as it’s really helped me. It’s like finding a new perspective. That wholeness and unity are ideals sustained only by fantasy. Thank you for all your hard work. It’s epic. I loved it! There has to be a break after this. Go somewhere sunny and warm. Even just for a short while. Take care ❤️

Marissa

Finding the hidden people was fun. Very Hill House of you.

Elaine Krauss

I'm about an hour in, and it's another incredible video as always, but what's with all the AI art? (See 52:35 for one quick and clear-cut example) Is it part of the bit...?

SuperMaria

As a patron and die-hard fan: I miss the days when we still had the psychic energy to be empathetic and even flirty towards the dumbest people on earth. We're in Contrapoints eye rolling era now, which I completely get because I lose my patience at the SituationTM all the time, it's not like I manage any better. But it's so sad how we got to the point that even Natalie's seemingly inexhaustible empathy for humanity ran out in this specific video. Fair enough that she starts yelling at the audience after so many years of doing this. Still: ☹️. Aside from that, the video is amazing. It will take a few rewatches to digest entirely (still processing Twilight tbh—one a year is too much, if anything) Any chance we could do a livestream/AMA specifically about the video? I have so many questions about the behind the scenes and I would so love to hear about it. A very big thank you for all the work. So grateful for everything you've put out over the years.

Damon Harris

You never disappoint! I love how some of the tangent stuff made it in. Not much though. Damn girl, you really don’t believe in coasting, not even a little. All of Granola Facism could have been a section. I still think that Tangent needs to be released to the general public. As someone who was born poor white trash from Kentucky, I also approve of your southern accents. I like how the MTG voice was a little different than the generic working-class populist voice. It’s the attention to detail that gets me Mother.

Sam B

I was wondering if you'd seen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OFyn_KSy80 A deep dive into the conspiracy theories that have driven geopolitics in Europe for the last two decades and were the catalyst for the Ukraine War.

ts_babyjane

she posts 1 video a year, does she need to attach an addendum at the end like "update, here's my views on every progressive issue that has come up in the past year so i don't get canceled"? every time i've assumed that she believed the "correct" progressive/left take about something i've been right. like she is pro-palestine, and i would've known whether i checked her twitter or patreon or not, because she's spent years making videos about what she believes and why. i can use my critical thinking skills. like, also just who tf cares what contrapoints thinks? i promise u no one purposefully watching a contrapoints video is gonna be just now learning about the current ongoing gen0slide in gaza. like, idk, maybe i'm wrong i don't think netanyahu is regular viewer of her channel. lol

ts_babyjane

she's joking about how all of her youtube friends (like lindsay ellis) are on there and for years they've begged her. also maybe a jab at a specific other youtuber who's big on there

Avery

Anthi, Natalie isn’t obligated to make a whole video, but when you cover global injustices and discuss topics like nationalism, fascism, and racism multiple times, ignoring the genocide in Gaza for over a year feels like a huge missed opportunity. It’s not about proving anything, it’s about taking a stance on one of the most urgent human rights crises of our time

Ted(dy)

I was a little shaken at her anger toward the end. I’ve been watching the AMA streams for years it’s not like i’ve never seen her angry. but in a video like this? shook me a little. we’re really all getting to that point, and I don’t know how we’ll come back from it (if we do at all)

Avery

Anthi, maybe ContraPoints is a little too complicated for you, though-- you could always follow someone like Logan Paul if that’s more your speed. Guess you’ll fit right in with his audience’s average intellect

Clayton

“Why stay silent?” is hilarious after people refer to multiple times she has addressed it, including in the video you should be watching right now. You got your answer, she has not been silent, now stop moving the goalpost.

CrystalJade

Watergate spaces are liminal!

Damon Harris

I love the call backs to the Jordan Peterson video and Gender Critical. I sometimes still randomly laugh out loud at the thought of you drinking from the teapot!

Ted(dy)

I *really* appreciate that you didn’t mention JKR as an example of a former progressive turned belligerent conspiratorial bigot after facing mass public ridicule. Ty for sticking to your word on not talking about her anymore.

Ted(dy)

Ok so this account is clearly a bot

Pierre Brown

Loved this video!! One thing I've also found interesting is how baseline stupid a lot of these theorists/MAGA can be: If the elite/the rich are out to get/influence/harm the lower, middle, and average class, why on earth would anyone ever exalt and align with people like Trump and Elon, aka people that did not rise from the lower class, people who have been born into the upper/influential class? Even Vance's chewed glue faced ass attended a high class institution. Lmao. Definitely agree that when this phase of "Let's return to our good old fashioned fears of everything we wish we could be or wish didn't exist because the world is too scary for me with the gays and the (insert other undeserving community/minority) breathing all over the place" is over, so many people will act like simping for Elon wasn't a real thing.

Delaney Caballero

conspiracy theory that this video took over a year not because of research, but because of the amazing costume/set/makeup design

a.

mother's home and she's taking off her girdle!

Viviane P.L.

A good book to this discussion is Doppelganger by Naomi Wolf( actually Naomi Klein , I did what she just complained), it has many of the points Natalie brought up like (Also in tangent published at patreon title Granola Facism)

Avery

I guess we have different standards for what ‘"speaking out" actually means. No goalposts are being moved, just pointing out how the issue was barely touched. But keep defending the bare minimum if that makes you feel better

pjkc

Damn I think this is the darkest Contrapoints video I can remember... (maybe Cringe comes close). Great video, the "morally average" segment was emotionally devastating / cathartic in a perfect way -- really captures the thing people try to avoid facing by using a facade of good and evil.

Avery

Live streams are only for paying patrons, so not everyone can access them. It’s a shame that important discussions are behind a paywall. These issues should be addressed in the main videos so that more people can see and understand them, not just those who can afford it

no

check out yuri slezkine's 'the house of government', early soviet hist through the lens of milenarian cult

Lizzie Hibbert

Natalie, all I can say is you’re amazing, you make me cleverer and more thoughtful with every video you make and I’m so so grateful you exist and do what you do

Avery

Shut upppp’—that’s your comeback? Pathetic. Maybe actually think before you speak next time instead of just whining because you can’t handle the conversation

Avery

Wow, so now you think Natalie has to add an ‘update’ at the end of every video just to avoid being canceled? She’s been pretty clear about her views for years, but I guess you wouldn’t know that since you’re too busy pretending like you’re the authority on what she should say. If you’re still this clueless about Gaza, maybe try using some critical thinking because I certainly haven’t seen any in your weak arguments

Vinni

doing backbends in the bedroom to this on .5x speed

Avery

Criticizing the Israeli government isn’t antisemitic-- that’s just basic logic. It’s funny how you ignore all the progressiveness she talks about and then assume she’s secretly bigoted. Maybe instead of jumping to conclusions, you should take some time to actually get educated on the issue

Kai Lewen

I am, as a person who lives in these USAs, 1,000,000% that Jhonny the crypto zoologist is looking for Mothman as a companion pet to their rescued bear, golden retriever, gator, and squirrel.

Avery

A quick mention at the end of a 2-hour video isn’t addressing Gaza. But hey, if you think watching the last few minutes qualifies as understanding the issue, maybe it’s time to get educated

MJayBee

Natalie, this video was brilliant 👏👏👏 RIP your sanity in service of us.

JANA KEITH-JENNINGS

So worth the wait! Incredible work Natalie! Thank you❤️

Nath François

Aaaaaand Natalie scores once again with the impeccable production value, clear and enlightening explanation, and most importantly the mommy voice. Will the cut tangent you mentioned on everyone getting Eyes Wide Shut wrong become an actual Tangent (once you've had some rest obviously).

Jacob Ford

I am curious if we need more patience, or more people to take a turn.

Nath François

Well at least she got a lot of mileage of the goat skull she got for the satanism video.

Jacob Ford

What would you like Natalie to say about Gaza, Avery?

Kai Lewen

Dude. Like. Are we really into the era of doubting if Contra is a channel that supports Zionism? Because if that's where the internet is going, I'm taking a shot and peacing out from The Discourse. So what, HBomb or FD hasn't made a video on it either; we have Noah, Elliot, Bad Empanada, Lily, even the talking skull screaming about it to the rooftops, doing fundraisers and keeping this fresh on everyone's mind. Please focus your energy on the people who are doing the work, and support their actions.

Dakota Kennedy

I appreciate you and the work that you do so unbelievably much. This incredibly well-thought analysis, the costumery, the makeup, the writing, the presentation, I mean it really is just poetry in motion. I adore watching your videos for so many reasons, but something that really sticks out to me is that I often find myself feeling uncomfortable with certain media or certain behaviors or certain beliefs while struggling to adequately outline and articulate why. I can usually get close, yes, I can usually grasp the general silhouette of my discomfort but then your videos often provide a finer resolution to the edges. I will watch your videos and find myself pausing the video and shouting to my empty room "Yes!!! that's EXACTLY it!!!" in the sort of ecstatic relief that can only come from commiseration and agreement. Ever since your Twilight video, you've inspired me to start reading and learning again, so I can have a better familiarity with the origins of my own opinions- and so that I have a better framework to test out my own thoughts to see if they can hold up to criticism or if they start taking on water. And I can easily identify that this video is yet another one of your master works because it not only taught me things, but it also made me feel something. Hats off to you, I hope you feel immensely proud of this work, even if the content itself is less-than-pleasant.

Avery

Just because other creators are talking about it doesn’t mean ContraPoints silence is okay. It’s not about doubting her—it's about calling out the fact that she’s got a huge platform and isn’t using it to speak on one of the most brutal human rights crises happening right now. The genocide in Gaza is too big to ignore, and the fact that she’s silent on it while discussing everything else is a problem. We’re not asking for perfection, just consistency when it comes to addressing major issues. If she wants to claim to be progressive then she should speak up on this too. It’s not just about backing a few-- it’s about holding everyone, especially those with influence, accountable. Honestly, judging by the responses to my comments, it’s pretty clear where most of her fanbase stand on genocide, and it’s not a good look!

Gordon

a hog farm in the phillipines bro

Evelyn G

Literally just started researching for an essay about applying renaissance critiques of pre-modern thinking to conspiracy theories last week. Insane timing

chippyshouseparty

Absolutely amazing. I've been so frustrated in dealing with conspiracy theorist coworkers since around 2019, and this while video summarized and articulated my feelings in a way i've never been able to.

chippyshouseparty

side note, did anyone else's name not appear in the credits? i don't want to seem ungrateful, just wondering if i'm the only one.

Ygrec32

One of the things I kept getting stuck on is the mindset of folks who propagate "new" conspiracy content. Like the law enforcement officers who created those training tapes. Some of that content isn't regurgitated, but rather purely original. Is it cynical opportunism or is it truly unexamined fan fiction masquerading as "connecting the dots," where these folks genuinely think they're positively contributing to the corpus? I don't know that the video definitively answers the question. For me, this is definitely where my empathy fails. It simply appears to me as insanity. In any event, this was an excellent video with a clear call to action. I am going to head straight to reddit and theorize about the inevitability of smashing.

Rickpat

One word on the appeal of the punitive daddy dom: Ponography

Johnny DeMartino

As a bassist I both LOVE the fact that you got a bass bow for the waterphone, but also I’m crushed that you got the German bow not the French bow. Kidding aside this is a MASTERPIECE

rk

Brilliant and Illuminating! Brava! 🥂

Honoria Valemon

Marvelous! On your A game. You explained many things I did not understand, like what they mean by “communist”

helen

3 hour contrapoints video the week I’m recovering from top surgery thank god

Moonie Bonzo

I'm absolutely DYING for your Eyes Wide Shut hot takes.

Dane

Some of your best work yet

Dane

Wondering if the Premier warning banner about footage not being analyzed for stabilization in the mediamancy bit was left in there on purpose? Simple editing mistake or intentional comment on the instability of the mindset of truthers and their string charts? Symbolism will be your downfall

william kirkpatrick

just finished. Its jaw-dropping. The best part is the end which I will not spoil.

Jessie Lees

Loved it! Reminded me of being a kid watching conspiracy theory documentaries with my mom. We'd end up laughing so hard when they got to the insane turning point that went off the deep end. Reminder for me to be grateful for growing up being taught to be more reasonably skeptical.

Mollygdala

Feeling vindicated by the analysis of Law and Order. I once told my aunt (who watches it daily) that I felt like it was gratuitous to the point of fetishism and she got so angry it nearly ruined Christmas lol.

Elsie Hupp

Hillary Clinton shot JFK.

Karen Lowe

Thank you for so eloquently describing how just because Israel does war crimes doesn’t mean Jews deserve to be the target of so many conspiracy theories - and the fact that there are a lot and have been lots for a long time. I think there’s a mentality that hmm, these sorts of rumors go back so far, and there are so many of them, there must be a grain of truth to them….

Jace Walker

Another masterpiece. Loved the whole thing! This is something I would normally never comment on, but I was excited to see my name at the end of the video as a $15 tier member but it wasn't there :(

Cole

I keep hearing "the Build-a-Bear Group" and wondering what their evil global teddy-bear conspiracy is

Igor Alves

Conspiracy (and every sort of addiction for that matter) is a way to fill that human void inside us with meaning. And the best way to fight it is to actually find meaning in other things. Finding a reason to stay alive, something that brings you joy. Finding a community that will empower you and not enable you in your addictions. Easier said than done but I do think it’s a first piece of the puzzle to combat conspiracy and help loved ones who might be too deep in tinfoil already

Murguly Mátyás

This touched me on many levels, because I was a conspiracy junkie in the early 2000's (I was a troubled teen/young adult), but got out from the hole. Since then, I try to understand how people get on the train - how I got on the train. I developed some similar ideas* like you in this essay, so strangely, this essay made me happy. Also if anybody have a question about how I was one the dumdum, feel free to ask away. I worked trough my shame on therapy long ago. *Altrough my ideas were less refined. I'm a biotechnologist, so my philosofical vocabulary and knowledge is on the level of a hobbiist.

Rose Dombegh

Yeah me too ... it felt cathartic in a way ... but also scary, because I can't understand this level of stupidity, and if SHE can't understand it then ... who can?

Anthi Papadimatou

Avery, enough with your condescending behaviour. I'm following Natalie since 2018 so please stfu. Enough with people like you, thinking your are progressive leftists when the only thing you do is going around telling people what they should do and how they should behave according to your very high ethical standards. If you don't like that Natalie hasn't address this issue specifically the way you want (because I think that even in this video you can clearly see her stance) then just stop seeing her content. It's as simple as that. And, btw, get a fucking life also.

Crystaline

JFK is our dead anime mom has me SCAREEEMING 🤣 it’s gonna carry me through the rest of the year ilysm bless bless

Avery

Your meltdown is noted. If you think calling me names strengthens your argument, it doesn’t. This isn’t about me—it’s about genocide. If you’ve been following Natalie since 2018, maybe take some notes on how to construct a coherent point instead of just ranting. Prioritizing your loyalty to a YouTuber over the reality of mass slaughter is telling. Get over yourself

Andrea

Ah too bad. Did you watch until the very end? There were two sets of names, the first set larger, the second set in smaller font?

Andrea

There were some other people in the comments saying the same

Andrea

Who specifically?

Andrea

Avery that's just super condescending and insulting and has no place here.

Katsognathus

Great video once again, I very much 'suffered in style' <3

Anthi Papadimatou

Avery, you started insulting people and being ironic. Apparently you don't like when other people use the same methods to you. How surprising...

The Mad Jay Woman

People get so bent out of shape when I describe SVU as trash “you’re just shitting on something women like, this is meaningful to victims!” Yeah I don’t think the salacious plot lines are repping actual survivor experiences, maybe take off the dark romance goggles Debbie

Tree

Oh my. I adore all your stuff. Its just so great, and so well timed.

CrystalJade

This was like an entire phenomenology! So many levels. I’m sure some sort of AMA in place of a tangent in future would go down well. Whenever you feel up to it. Kind of like to package all of the after effects of going down these conspiracy rabbit holes neatly into a box. If it might help of course!

Ann C

Excellent new video, and as others have noted, well-timed. How much did you have to add or change to reflect current events? One of my brothers-in-law has fallen into the conspiracy theory mindset, and he's constantly sending me links to videos and articles that prove his points. Occasionally, I send him information to debunk the latest crazy video he's sent me, but I usually ignore it in the interest of family peace. I loved the references to Ancient Aliens, a show I often watch. I always enjoy it when the narrator says, "...is it possible [insert wild speculation about the presence of aliens on earth]. Ancient Astronaut theorists say YES."

Ann C

Mine wasn't listed either.

Lara

Congratulations!!! And thank you! I saw it posted while I was in class and I was excited all the rest of the day to go home and watch. So grateful for your work!!!!!

Tantacrul

I'm sure this has already been caught - I skimmed through the comments to check and probably missed someone else already pointing this out - but at 1:18:59, there's an Adobe shake-stabilisation warning, which I think too obviously reveals our agenda to smooth over the truth.

annadante

thanks for the rec! I watched it right after this video and as someone from a post soviet union country this was one of the best rundowns of what happened here.

a. j. archer

so nice to see you frolicking in the bathtub with the unsettling effigy of an older WOMAN #lovewins

Javi

I can understand the time you spent putting this together! Especially considering how every passing day could add another chapter

Avery

Oh, sorry, was I supposed to be civil while my people are being slaughtered? My bad!

K

Really loved this!! for obvious reasons, also been thinking a lot about the consolidation of conspiracy thinking into a more or less unified political phenomenon, so 'conspiracism' was a helpful term. the video also helped me to think about whether the seeming dominance of conspiracy/social panic is something new or a continual repetition of ingrained patterns of thought in western political culture. this quote from de certeau is helpful i think in getting at the ambiguity of that distinction in the first place: "Normally, strange things circulate discreetly below our streets. But a crisis will suffice for them to rise up, as if swollen by flood waters, pushing aside manhole covers, invading the cellars, then spreading through the towns. It always comes as a surprise when the nocturnal erupts into daylight. What it reveals is an underground existence, an inner resistance that has never been broken. This lurking force infiltrates the lines of tension within the society that it threatens. Suddenly, it magnifies them; using the means, the circuitry already in place, but reemploying them in the service of an anxiety that comes from afar, unanticipated. It breaks through barriers, flooding the social channels and opening new pathways that, once the flow of its passage has subsided, will leave behind a different landscape and a different order. Is this the outbreak of something new, or the repetition of a past? The historian never knows which." Thank you for your hard work!

Lux

2:35:00 I really appreciate that you address the systematic exploitation and discrimination of non-human animals, which is often ignored—even in progressive circles—due to speciesist thinking and carnism. Thank you so much for that! Morality is largely a social construct. This means that one can be considered morally average at a given time and still act in a way that is evil and ethically indefensible. The banality of evil. I also find it inappropriate to associate veganism with a martyr complex. Couldn’t the same argument be applied to other activists fighting against exploitation and discrimination (as often happens)? Is it merely about moral superiority and a self-punishing tendency, or is it about empathy, genuine concern for the well-being of other living beings, respect for the inherent value of life, and the pursuit of justice? I think you know the answer. Animals have no voice. And who truly bears the severe consequences? We, when we choose to live vegan, or the animals, when we don’t? Who suffers more? Even if certain exploitative relationships and their intrinsic mechanisms can be historically and socially explained, this does not justify their continuation or excuse them. I know this from personal experience, and what I now regret is not having gone vegan sooner—having made excuses, been ignorant, and prioritized my habits over the well-being of others. I lacked the courage to be consistent, and with that, the necessary empathy. I repressed the cruel reality and the consequences of my actions. We could be in their position. Thank you for this profound essay; I will certainly listen/watch it many more times. All the best, and a huge Go Vegan!

Wissa

Conspiracy perfectly compliments ENVY imo. I feel a lot of similar themes, the scapegoating of popular figures, for example. I consider these two videos to be sisters of sorts. I think the main factor that ties what makes both these things so dangerous is the will to punish others. The cause of our own misery is projected onto someone, and in our psychosis we believe destroying them will bring us back up. I wonder sometimes in envy itself is innately conspiratorial, like something inside us believes we’ve been robbed. Or maybe this is me trying to make too many connections between things! I’m just asking questions…

Avery

If critical thinking were a muscle, yours would’ve withered away ages ago. Imagine being more upset over tone than an actual genocide happening in real time. But hey, go ahead—crawl back to your safe space where reality doesn’t hurt your feelings

Darren DM

Excellent film. (Or video? What do we call it these days?) As usual you've managed to articulate something that I had an inkling of but hadn't completely put together in my aged brain. I remember seeing the David Icke interview live. It was all anyone talked about the next day. The Wogan show was one of the most popular shows on British TV at the time. Overnight Icke became a byword for looniness. I did feel bad for his kids, though. IIRC, he has his family on the show with him, all wearing the same turquoise tracksuits (because turquoise was attuned to the universe or something). Amazing.

10 Ten 235 J

Big fan of the video as an IRL Freemason! 😅

Nat Molyneaux

I was very pleased to see a return of Michelle Remembers (FORCED ENEMAS)

Zachary Paul

Excellent video, I wonder if you had ever run across this quote by Alan Moore in your research, would have been a perfect punctuation to your conclusion right before credit roll:   'The main thing that I learned about conspiracy theory, is that conspiracy theorists believe in a conspiracy because that is more comforting. The truth of the world is that it is actually chaotic. The truth is that it is not The Iluminati, or The Jewish Banking Conspiracy, or the Gray Alien Theory. The truth is far more frightening - Nobody is in control. The world is rudderless'

Elias Tsirides

Loved the video and the outfits! especially the liturgical mother Miranda inspired one ! That conspiracy wall must have been sooo much work, but totally worth it since filming in front of it happened till the sun came up and then some!!

Elias Tsirides

the part when the mannequin arm came off and Natalie not knowing what to do with it, starting "eating" it, fitting the anthropovore vibes XDD I was dead XD

Verdana

Absolutely phenomenal video (as usual). Excellent work! I even got my mom to watch it which is saying a lot because she hates most YouTubers. You really know how to bridge that generational gap lol. I'm sure this has already been pointed out to you but at 1:19:00 there is a Premiere export error that was left in. As a fellow creator I know how infuriating it is to pour months into a video only to accidentally let some tiny mistake slip through the cracks, trust me. My honest advice is to use the YouTube editor to add a blur over the blue bar that premiere put there (I've basically done the same thing before lol). It won't necessarily fix the problem fully but it will hide the text and it might also make the shot look slightly nicer. Who knows, if it's just a blur of blue in the middle of the screen perhaps folks will think it was an intentional creative decision of some kind ;)

Tyla Stark

Thank you for doing what you do. I can't imagine the mental toll this one took. I hope it reaches some of the people that need to hear it the most. (Also give us those Eyes Wide Shut hot takes pretty pleeease 😂)

Marinousky

Avery, what would meet your standards as a ‘statement’?

Morhzov

“Suffer in style” is now my 2025 tattoo

Bridie

By Naomi Klein, Naomi Wolf is the doppelgänger

Paul

45 mins in and this is amazing ❤️

Mark van der Laan

Hi Natalie, Mark from the Netherlands here, just finished watching the video, and first off congratulations with the video, very informative as always. I've come across the conspiracy theorists a lot in my line of work including Janet Ossebaard, but I really liked your point that it's almost impossible to "reason" with them, because of the cognitive differences, that's something I always tell my colleagues, don't try to think about it in any logical sense, because there isn't any. Keep up the good work!

Damon Harris

So was the March 22nd thing a misinterpretation, or was it deliberately ironic? Either way it’s hilarious. I spent all day Saturday convinced something was wrong with my notifications, only for the video to come out two days later and teach me one of my new favorite words, Apophenia.

Darron Perry Jr

That was fantastic, thank you! I feel like shit now.

Chris Manning

I never conceptualized conspiracism as its own religion, like a death cult with evil gods and its own form of magic. Mediamancy is such a fascinating concept, it’s straight out of a scifi dystopia.

Viviane P.L.

Yes, thanks, I just did what she complained about in the beginning of the book

Juniper

*jennifer coolidge voice* ‘oh mother mother mother mother’ should I be worried? My grandfather was both a free mason..and a Jew… In all seriousness, what an incredible video and production, I think your close friend Hillary Clinton will love it. My brother is a conspiracy nut, and even though I still am not a fan of him, now being able to understand his thinking, and how it stems from the same existential feeling we all experience, has definitely helped. My word Natalie, you are amazing. Will be watching this again in the coming days, with a notebook and pen in hand :)

Suzie

Been thinking a lot about this stuff for the past 3 years. I was just wondering why I hadn't seen the latest apocalyptic response from these sorts but then I realized they are running countries now and are incredibly busy. I guess the apocalypse will have to wait. Gotta catch all the pedos, as they look in the mirror, and for that split second they realize... But then their dog barks and snaps them out of it, they proceed to yell at their wife about making food.

nat

You have no idea how badly we needed this…(amazing video!!!!)

Ruby Valentine

I was about to say, I really liked that bit, the eyeball anger. It was confronting, and unsettling, and perfectly timed. I'm looking forward to watching this whole thing again very soon.

Ruby Valentine

Wait there are people? Hidden people?! 😍

Ruby Valentine

Are you a patreon troll bot who has only skim read an LLM summary of the video just posted? It's a beautiful piece of work, try watching again.

Ruby Valentine

I'm sorry, I lost a friend too. And I live in Australia. I hope you get some of these people back x

OanaHere

The last 2 minutes of this video should be a required watch for everyone. There are no adults. And weirdly that gives me comfort. Thanks for the video!

Lonovve Vega

"There is no plan, unless we make one" really hits hard

Chris B

Thank you so much for dedication and hard work you put into this. As always a pleasure to watch - funny as hell and intellectually stimulating as usual! Hope you get a chance to focus on something less soul wrenching and relax for a bit, now that it is out in the world!❤️

Conor Mcvarnock

Man I nearly joined the Freemasons once, kind of sorry I didn't now., or at least got my (then) friend to teach me the funny handshake. Would have been fun to try and pull it the next time I got arrested.

Conor Mcvarnock

“All through my life I've had this strange unaccountable feeling that something was going on in the world, something big, even sinister, and no one would tell me what it was." "No," said the old man, "that's just perfectly normal paranoia. Everyone in the Universe has that." "Everyone?" said Arthur. "Well, if everyone has that perhaps it means something! Perhaps somewhere outside the Universe we know..." "Maybe. Who cares?" said Slartibartfast before Arthur got too excited. "Perhaps I'm old and tired," he continued, "but I always think that the chances of finding what out really is going on are so absurdly remote that the only thing to do is to say hang the sense of it and just keep yourself occupied.” ― Douglas Adams, The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy

Frenki

Conspiracy theories always tend to be, in ethos at least, intrinsically based off mythology. Since perhaps the very beginning, we have speculated about the order of reality, reason (which sometimes I think is the Ouroboros of Western philosophy mainly) faith etc. I see it as an attempt to mitigate as you point it out yourself, navigate the troublesome realisation, that’s the very foundations of our realities are anything but that. The currents of our experiences, its antagonistic realtionship with material conditions, form this small vacuums in which mythology comforts us. I saw this happen to my mom as the pandemic began, she was adamant that the government was keeping inside to control us. (And just like any myth, there is truth to power dynamics between economic classes and genders) But as I tried to explained to her, it’s just easier to assume that due to a plethora of factors, we are still incapable of dealing with crisis of any kind, let alone a pandemic, so the truth of a real concern of mismanagement by people who are culpable as we might have been in their situation, gets processed in the battle of good vs evil. My parents thankfully are really proactive and listen to my gentle critiques, but I am aware that is not the case for many others. Therefore I really enjoyed the video. Or did I enjoy the video? Did George Soros and the Bolshevik Jew elite poisoned my local water source, to gain basic empathy? Is there another third purple pill they do not want us to find out? These are the truths in plain sight. P.s I hope all queer people in this community that are living in the US, are thriving, or at the very least in good company within their communities.

Liz

Still working through it, but would love to know 1) do you recommend Odyssey elixir drinks? 2) would love to know where your dress (with the lace and dark tie) in the Conspiracism chapter is from

thalia

this was amazing!!!!!! release the eyes wide shut tangent, your takes are so insightful, i find myself subconsciously nodding along like “… yes… why, yes…”

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

I think it was a testament to the practical impossibility of planning and executing a large-scale conspiracy, in a very «as above, so below» style (i.e. planning and execution is hard enough for one person)

Damon Harris

So now we have to go back and reverse-interpret the symbols from the announcement to indicate that actually Natalie always intended to drop on the 24th.

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

I once saw two uprooted bouquets of white «busy lizzie» flowers aggressively stuffed into the mail slots on the front gates of the freemason building in Oslo. Now that I have a mason here, what was that all about? It seemed like some kind of threat.

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

A little history revision never hurt anyone (according to revised history)

abz

outstanding work! (also yes please the EWS tangent)

Rose Dombegh

I watch Contrapoints for the fashio-- I mean, the philosophy

Liz

I'm now on part 5 and the black dress with golden accents and the keyhole neckline is also 🔥

10 Ten 235 J

I think I know what that's about. Not sure, as things can differ regionally, but I think it's their version of a very hopeful and positive symbol; the opposite of a threat. Why would flowers be a threat; and on their own front door?

10 Ten 235 J

I would just recommend trying not to get arrested. 😂

Mara S

Any conspiracism that fundie evangelism baked into me evaporated after I spent time working with Ivy League MBAs and DoD consultants in my first job. They’re all just… guys. Good, meh, or bad people, but no that much smarter or more cunning than anyone else. Now as a project manager, I’m just too aware of how hard it is to get more than 2 people to commit to a schedule much less a 5D chess plot to run the world

David

Great job on the video! Lot's of fun little morsels I'm going to be thinking about. I find it interesting that you focused only on right-wing conspiracy. I've been thinking about conspiracies a lot, not because of the right, but because I'm starting to see it on the left. People think that somehow Kamala is going to assume office, or that the Oct 7 attack is a hoax... It's not as far-reaching, but it's still concerning. Hopefully people see the pattern in themselves, even if they're not directly called out.

Amanda Jones

Gorgeous video. Can you tell us about the tarot cards at the end? Did you choose them deliberately?

Audrey M

great video!

mando

Will there be a transcript soon?

chypre

Are you doing Tunisian crochet? 🧶 😮

Sam D.

Finally got the time to watch this to the end. It's an amazing tour de force! I'm a retired therapist and I've been studying this stuff for several years (thank you Coronavirus). What I love is how well and deeply you tie together so many of the psychological currents, including the very, very, dark underbelly, but not without compassion. And how deftly, deeply American these insights are. We are such a freakin' weird country lol. Also, the visuals are GORGEOUS! And you! You were gorgeous too! I am going to watch this again, to pick up all the nuances I know I missed, especially the visual ones. And I'm sending it right to my daughter. Also, best wishes for your health and well being- I know this can't have been a picnic.

Camille Lussier

Exactly… conspiracy theorists wayyy over estimate the competence of human adults as well as our ability/willingness to cooperate and plan in groups

Nathan

As if living through Hurricane Helene wasn’t sad and weird enough on its own, the public response was extremely disheartening. Even people who aren’t full blown conspiracists were clearly looking for someone to blame, not necessarily for the hurricane itself but for the relief effort. I saw so much misinformation and fear mongering in the weeks following the devastation. “Why has nobody cleaned up all the wreckage?” “Why won’t the city release a timeline for water restoration? What are they hiding??” Uhh, probably nothing. This was an unprecedented event that nobody knows how to handle. That’s what makes it a disaster. But that’s really hard for people to accept. And that’s not to mention the lithium mining/weather machine shit which was truly maddening.

michaela

Finally finished it! Super well done and appreciate the callbacks! 🫖

Sean Hannan

I found this oddly uplifting? Connecting all of the dots made the irrationality of conspiracy a bit less, well, threatening.

Autumn Cooper

Thank you!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Tsubasa

Why did you chose this position from The Opera Game?

RamblesAboutStuff

It's been less than 48 hours and I've somehow managed to already watch this video several times. It felt like watching all the Tangents rolled up into one megavideo that tied everything together and brought it to a whole new level (made me wanna rewatch some Tangents - they're gonna hit pretty different now...). There's so much to unpack and also, so much of what was said resonated with my own experience. I'm not going to bore you with all the stories so I'll just bore you with two of them: - Story number one: I remember back in the day enjoying conspiracy theories. I didn't believe in them really, but anytime I found a new one I was entertained. I'm talking "is it possible..."-aliens-something-something theories (I was an X-Files fan, so that checks out), and Da Vinci Code-adjacent theories that essentially felt like giant escape games (giant puzzles, if you will). For me too, it stopped being fun when it went from harmless fantasy about the world to harmful beliefs and then full-blown propaganda, which leads us to... - Story number two: I remember when I was told about the "children in furniture" conspiracy theory. It was at a party and the person who told me about it was dead serious. It wasn't "guess what batshit claim I just learned about online?", it was "Did you know that..." I felt sad for this person because I thought "This is obvious bullshit but if they believe the way the story's being framed, there's nothing I can do." I think I just said something like "Really? Do you really believe that? It doesn't sound true." and all I got back was something along the lines of "That's what they want you to think." I still feel sad when I think about it.

Avery

I’m a real person with genuine concerns. My comment was rooted in disappointment, not trolling. Dismissing that with sarcasm only proves the point: people get more defensive about critique than they do about genocide

JoyOfResistance

This is stunning and thought provoking as always, thank you so much for your time and creativity! Here's two thoughts I had watching this video: First of all, I'm not sure if I agree with some of the broad conclusions you work with about humans (I had the same issue with some universal human truths you proposed in your last video about sex and desire). Your outlook on humanity feels, understandably, bleak, but I myself (as a psychologist) try to separate systemic causes from what we conclude as universal truths about humans; for example, there's this American darling idea of 'power corrupts' in media all the time. But does it? Really? Or does our power system just reward people with certain characteristics? I tend to lean towards that second school of thinking (that's by the way, why I also feel that billionaires are in fact *not* the same as we are, because that kind of behavior speaks of a nature that is not common - and psychopathic traits that, unfortunately, are rewarded by our inhuman capitalist systems). My second thought is that I feel that (especially in queer/left spaces) at the moment, there's this pattern of blaming ourselves as leftists or 'white cis men' for everything that's happening now (see your bit about dominant men) - and I don't think this is a helpful way of thinking as well. Fascism is an extremely powerful, infectious way of thinking and though I am fascinated why we, as white Western people, fall victim to it, again and again - it's no-one's 'fault' for not fighting back hard enough (look at how the communists for example fought against fascism in Germany since 1919, should we blame them for 'not trying hard enough'?) So much factors are at play that are bigger than us individuals or communities, I think we should stop this new bourgeois leftist hobby of basically scapegoating ourselves :D (I even think that the right has more power - and responsibility - to keep fascism in check and separated from conservative thinking. And realize that the short term success of attaching themselves to fascism, will destroy them in the end. But I don't see much of that kind of self reflection on that side to be honest). And the same goes for men. Yes, as queer people we often have suffered at the hands of a$$hol3s (I have as well, for many years and very violently), but like billionaires, I believe that these are cases of individual sickness, that go undetected in our patriarchal systems, yes, but that doesn't mean that giving men power turns them into domineering bastards. Again, you let a system off the hook there that rewards the wrong people ánd lean into neoliberal individualist thinking where everything is to blame on the individual. Which, I find, is not helpful or healing. In the end, patriarchy knows no gender. And I think we (especially as queers/leftists/marginalized people) should not go the same way of creating our own false enemy. And lastly, for me, what counters these ways of thinking is stepping back a bit. Not focusing on the large scale, but the little. As people, we're not meant to act on a global scale (and I think our brains go a bit in meltdown if we try), so for myself, at the moment, the thing that helps most is sizing down. I take care of a few handicapped people in my surroundings (who are damaged most by what is happening), have started a communal garden project for people who can't pay for food, help my friends who are burning out with their kids and cooking. Yes, taking care of yourself is important, but also (again) a very individualistic way of thinking, while turning our love and humanity outwards, I think, in these times, is the most healing, connecting and rebellious thing of all.

BaFi

This was so great to watch! Thank you. Part 6 was the most interesting for me. It is most fun when you go deep and analyse inner workings and motivations. Your level of execution, research, expertise, art, introspection and humor is insane. I cannot even imagine the amount of work that must have gone to making this. I wonder about the toll it must be taking on one person... I wish you to rest well ❤️ I can't wait to watch the video again!

ibi

I started watching this a bit before suhoor and and ended up staying up way too long after to finish but I wanted somewhere to post my random thoughts. Every ContraPoints video is like a Rorschach test that somehow makes me think of every political thing I've had in my head recently. Aliens: my friend's brother is a Nazi now (not a card-carrying one but he thinks Hitler made good points and such) and one thing I find fascinating about his beliefs is that he is always talking about the Anunnaki people. he almost seems to believe it half as a joke but he's gotten worse and worse over the years - last time I was in his vicinity he wouldn't stop talking about how the Left lied about Hitler, and how Hitler noticed Jews didn't die in WW1. fascinating how the alien stuff coincides lol. Narrative logic: it's interesting how much storybook logic conspiracy theories employ. the trope of decoding the enemy's secret symbols to defeat them is literally the plot of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, or even arguably Fullmetal Alchemist. Perversion: as a bit of a masochist I feel like I am constantly noticing how masochistic some right-wing memes and comics are. I think I've seen several drawings of liberal female politicians (from AOC to Nancy Pelosi to Hillary Clinton) wearing high-heeled shoes stepping on men. what's going on there, I wonder. Entrapmentainment: the "pedophile-catching" genre of video is shockingly pervasive on Twitter, I've seen it multiple times. one I think about a lot is this one of I believe Lil Pump finding a pedophile and like shaving his head and feeding him spicy chips (?) and making him apologize to chat. this type of punitive video I think is soul-rotting in a way I can't describe. You correctly point out it isn't about concern for the victim it's about finding an enemy you can punish (or torture) guilt-free. Populism: I basically hate conspiracy theorists in all forms which is why I remain kind of skeptical of populism in all forms, including left-wing ones. I do love Bernie and I think he's honestly impressive in how he channels and reframes populism in productive ways but I worry sometimes that it can take a negative turn in less capable hands. when Nina Turner lost her election in 2021 and blamed "evil money" it raised a yellow flag to me. similarly I think fellow Bernie voters have been at least a little deluded on the popularity of our candidate. one instance I think about a lot is the way people talk about the 2020 primaries, when a few moderate candidates dropped out and endorsed Joe Biden, who went on to win big. some takes on it were normal but others veered into conspiracy when in reality Bernie simply just lost because not enough voters wanted him as their candidate. a blackpilling loss but sometimes you just have to take your losses in stride. After revolution: the bit about how after the revolution you have to create a new establishment resonated strongly with me. the founding narrative of America is one of revolution and I think a lot of American cultural output identifies with rebels and the common people, but now that the post-revolution government is the establishment people either rebel against their idea of the establishment, or they claim that the current establishment isn't what the original founders intended. Grains of truth: after October 7, 2023, I started reading a book on the Arab-Israeli conflict in Palestine and one bit that stuck out to me was how many grains of truth to anti-semitic conspiracies there are. prior to the founding of Israel, wealthy European Jews formed an organization called the World Zionist Organization that lobbied England for the creation of Israel. during the British Mandate over Palestine, Zionists literally contacted the son (?) of the Prime Minister to ask for preferential treatment in the area. I'm pretty sure the Rothschilds might have even been mentioned by name in the book. some of this is a bit oversimplified (Europeans also wanted Jews out of Europe) but imagine being a conspiratorially minded person and reading this, your eyes would pop out. reality is less black-and-white - the original Zionist project was unethical but was itself partially motivated by oppression in Europe and cynically used the power of the imperial force that was Britain to gain an advantage over local Arabs who had no such connections. Britain's imperial objectives (and Europe's distaste for Jews) ultimately coincided well with the organization. Aesthetics of the elite: it's actually maddening how often people will make aesthetic comparisons to The Capitol in the Hunger Games when it's not how they dressed that was the problem! I've even seen leftists do this about The Met Gala, which is literally a charity fundraiser for the Metropolitan Museum of Art. it's not malaria nets but it's not like they're just holding a party to flaunt their wealth. people like things like the Olympics and the Met Gala because they're fun events to watch and it really isn't anything more sinister than that. Fake electors: it's also maddening how few people really know the details of the fake electors plot by Trump. insane that he got away with trying it. Crank realignment: some time last year I remember reading an NYT article about the "crank realignment" theory wherein the Republican party, rather than being a conservative party, is becoming the party for dumb cranks. it used to be that cranks came in both left-coded and right-coded varieties but now with Tulsi Gabbard, Elon Musk, and RFK Jr. a part of the Trump cabinet, it seems like the modern iteration of the Republican party is the party of conspiracy theorists. The oppressor in yourself: You make a point that by making out your oppressor to be irredeemably evil you fail to recognize the oppressor in yourself. I think this is a really important point and something that must be considered by everyone. It's why I like rehabilitative justice and dislike the death penalty. It's also why I'm a little unconvinced by calls to execute the rich or kill/castrate all rapists. everyone seems to just want someone to hurt rather than improve society. Morally average: I relate a lot to you in that I basically agree vegans are correct and yet I take the path of least resistance concerning meat-eating. it reminds me of the Michael Brooks quote "be kind to people, be ruthless with systems" - ultimately it makes more sense to target an immoral system. Main character syndrome: I've thought/said this before but I think a primary motivator for people in general but especially the modern citizen is the search for a story or narrative to tell yourself. I think that's why Republican rhetoric has actually been beating the left so handily - they tell a way better story. particularly a story that lets you be the main character. it's why affirmative action is unpopular, it's why systemic critique of historical racist policies is unpopular, etc. it feels like a weak narrative. and conspiracies are another way to give yourself a strong narrative. The logistics and solipsism of conspiracies: besides being convinced for a few days in 8th grade by some videos on the Illuminati I've only ever truly deep-dived into one "conspiracy theory", which I put in quotation marks because it's less a conspiracy theory and more a denial of genocide - the denial of the Uyghur crisis in China. something that resonated really strongly with me that you said is that honestly afterwards I felt a little untethered from reality, despite coming in skeptical (of the denial) and coming out feeling like I was right to be skeptical. it's an interesting example because honestly the typical hallmarks of conspiracism aren't here. it's actually a pretty easy sell - America, with its history of unethical covert operations and propaganda, is using its global influence to convince the world that its largest geopolitical rival is mistreating some of its own population. there are so many grains of truth to it, links to think tanks, real examples of American propaganda and media manipulation. but ultimately once you look further into it you realize how much you really have to swallow to believe that no wrongdoing occurred. for all the denialists' claims to be true you have to believe that the CIA has absurd levels of power and secrecy it simply does not have. and it's at this point that the conspiracy theory starts to resemble other conspiracy theories in their unwillingness to honestly and truly consider the *logistics* of their conspiracies. how much coordination and coercion would need to be going down for their theory to make any sense. and once you assign your enemy (in this case the CIA) that much power I frankly start to question why you simply don't just devolve into pure solipsism. If your shadowy power is so powerful it can control your entire media diet besides the people you agree with, why can you even access those dissidents at all? the enemy is simultaneously all-powerful but also easily unraveled by you, the freethinker. I've never gotten a great answer to this. anyway no one probably read this but I wanted to get my thoughts out. fun video, loved seeing your YouTube recommendations in the side at point (A.G. Cook mentioned!)

Tree

Damn, Im listening to it again, closely, its so good.

Astrid Budolfsen

Love it. Not as much as the Twilight video. But still a masterpiece. As usual it gave me words for things that I have thought and felt and gave me understanding and framework to understand something important. I do think that you are a little less happy and your perverted humor is toned down. Maybe it is the subject matter. Maybe I have grown used to it. I for one, love your weird, dark, twisted, perverted humor, and I dont think you need to tone that part down ever.

James

The Bechdelcast podcast did an amazing episode about EWS a while ago. Highly recommended.

Lambda

This was an absolutely fascinating and captivating experience to watch, between this and ‘Envy’ this may be my all-time favorite work you have done. I sometimes have fallen victim to many of the fallacies of the described conspiracy mindset in the past due to an overt distrust I have in formal authority figures and humans in general. The breakdown of intentionalism, dualism, and symbolism was helpful in being able to deconstruct illogical thoughts I have had in the past and how to identify the behavior in the future. I absolutely loved the imagery used throughout the costumes and set design in this video. The Gaga outfit was spectacular. Thank you mother.

Divad Abelhczejen

This was so good. I laughed out loud multiple times

Matt Warmka

Went to double check to see if your name was there and realized mine wasn't either. Maybe Patreon had issues processing payments or something last time around.

jim davies

Tend to instinctively eye-roll at CT - but it's mainly because I love the real deal so much for its, um, educational value. Mildly bummed nobody ever cites Horace Greeley Hjalmar Schacht just for the name alone - or Reinhard Gehlen boss-bouncing from the SS OstFront to the BND & his crappy paranoid intel massively shaping the Cold War along the way - or Licio Gelli & the P-2 Lodge literally running Italy for ages (& yup, Unga-Bunga Berlusconi is/was P-2 hooked up too).

Lina7

I think i'd love to do the French subtitles for that one too, Natalie. Though I don't know how I could send them to you. I did the Twilight french subs on captionfy, loved it, heavy work, but I can't seem to find any way to reach out to you afterwards, on info@contrapoints.com or here. Bluesky maybe

Elsie Hupp

I’m imagining an alternate-universe Mariska Hargitay raised by a single-mother Jayne Mansfield rather than a single-father Mickey Hargitay. She’d probably be more feminist, for one! Though she might also be a classical violinist rather than a fake cop haha https://youtu.be/rFEIOO8YIWY

tala

great video! the use of AI for dead anime mom JFK (and another anime girl visual if i recall correctly?) is kinda disappointing to me tho

AlexLuna

this video is incredible. some of your best work. take time to rest after this and restore your energy and sanity. you deserve it.

Neil

“Do you know what a MILF is?” “…I doooo…”

Neil

I come for the philosophy but I stay for the humour.

Makenna Sullivan

Natalie this is one of your best, now go sleep for a month

Wolfebrayne

Although my first thought was that this isn’t your best work, I know that if I had to spend more then 10 minutes dealing with these morons and their batshit crazy ideas, I’d be on the floor curled up into a ball, crying and shitting myself. That you were able to rationally deal with the topic at all is incredible. Take a break, and maybe for the next video focus on something that makes you happier! Thank you for all you work, you truly are a NATIONAL TREASURE

Andy Pfau

Funny, I do the opposite!

Jupiter Foxx Monroe

i want you to know that i hate and despise the topic of conspiracy theories in general and was actually my main reason for despising shane dawson before all the weird things he got exposed for - and yet i still watched this video. and liked it. for you. you made sense of all the why's (it never clicked for me that this was titillating outrage for perverts) that i've never had the stomach to contemplate bc the mere mention of these goons repels me.

Amy Morrison

I'm so proud that my name is in the Patreon list for this video I could just burst. :) Amazing amazing work. Doing this research would have broken me. Please naps for as long as you need.

Ivee Baker

there is no other youtuber, content, or media that i want to watch more than a video essay from mother herself. thank you for all your hard work & making our brains bigger with style. i've been a follower for about 3 years now, and you never disappoint

Ravenqueen

Thank you so much!! It is a masterpiece! I have shared it with so many other people who love your work! I hope you can rest a bit and let us know if you need help for a much needed vacation, I am happy to chip in 😽

Rose Dombegh

lmao I wonder what the woman would have said about it

Kai G

We live in a timeline that parodies the writings of Robert Anton Wilson and Robert Shea. Another great video, but needs more fnords.

Jace Walker

Unfortunately not in either

Hanna Lisowska

The only thing I dislike about this video is that you reminded me of Mel Gibson's existence

Neil

Something MILFtoast

Colton Royle

It's time to talk about anti-natalism...

Grady Wiehe

The absolute height of comedy 🤣

Jon Fraaza

This is my favorite video you've ever made. Truly outstanding work!

Helen

❤️❤️❤️ Always art. Always informative. Always worth the wait. Thank you for your hard work & hope you’re doing okay, Natalie. Log off for a while now. Go to the woods. Maybe Paris. I dunno, just want you to have some joy in a difficult world. Love to you. X

Kristina Foster

This was such a lovely treat, thank you Contrapoints!

Void WL

Cool how the satanism tangent is revealed as being things you were researching for this video

Void WL

Sophie from Mars did a video called “conspiracy on the left” a few years ago which is good

Void WL

They’re probably talking about philosophy tube. She is Natalie’s ex and Natalie also has a “copied my style” grievance against her (4chan users also came up with some worse rumours — frankly transphobic rumours — in an attempt to completely ruin Abigail’s reputation. Natalie has explicitly denied these worse rumours but she confirmed the idea that they dated and broke up. Which frankly is completely mundane, public figures become each others exes all the time)

Elen Lebet

I'm upset Avery isn't demanding contrapoints make a statement about the war in Ukraine. 🤡

misslcd

Afrer watching this masterpiece twice in the last two days, I finally got around to watching Eyes Wide Shut for the first time 👀. Consider me #influenced The tone of this video in particular is just so evocative, I can feel your anger, fear, despair seeping through the screen, particularly at the end of part 5. What it must have cost you to make this video is evident, and truly appreciated from the bottom of my heart. That you still managed to find humour throughout, and in Part 6 were able to look empathetically at conspiracists and walk yourself back from the brink is so admirable. Conspiracy is the easy way out, compassion is hard and exhausting and a constant practice. Will be meditating and wishing you love, health, safety, peace ❤️

Scoott

Thanks for the info. I had seen the nastier rumors, glad to hear they’re likely false. Honestly… I don’t see that much overlap in style? Though I’ll admit I don’t follow Natalie as closely as I follow PT.

Maida Monaghan

My new favorite video of yours! I've watched/listened to this three times now and shared it with my brother. Several members of our family have fallen deep into right wing conspiracy theories and while we're beyond trying to change them, your video explores how that happens and whats going on there in a way that (at least for us) helps ease the anger and anxiety we feel about them. Also, I'm glad you show covers for the books you reference because I recognized Behold a Pale Horse, a book I've seen in my dads library for 30 years but never actually picked it up to see what its about. Time to have a conversation about Conspiracy- daughter's home and she's taking her belt off? Your work is inspiring, thank you!

Leanne Howard

Incredible work as always. I selfishly keep hoping that your videos get longer and longer, because I never want them to end. Set design and costuming on the next level (I loved when you turned on The Lights (TM) for Capitalism). But most of all, hope you are now able to do something entirely for your own wellbeing. Something peaceful. Be safe and well <3 Thank you Natalie

B-Ribs

Brilliant! Loved this video! Thank you so much for you and your team's hard work, research and production efforts!

Nassim Tanha

I kept thinking of the origins of Totalitarism by Hannah Arendt and how the people feeling left out of the political processes will find solutions in the fascism and populist movements and how this is the natural result of systemic failure of the "democracy" of the time.

Abi

Thank you for staying alive to make this. I mean that very seriously and sincerely. You staying above the ground means more than you know to literally millions of people. I can’t thank you enough for how much impactful your work has been, how much it makes me feel as if there’s a shred of hope. You’ve sacrificed a lot to create the work you’ve done, and we, your audience, undoubtedly see only glimpses of what that sacrifice has cost you, but I hope you know that your life and breath and existence are rare treasures on this earth. Please take care of yourself, and thank you, thank you, thank you for this video.

Grady Wiehe

I literally don’t know how you do it. How you engage so deeply with the bs and retain a modicum of sanity. Bless

Leo Kyle

Tremendous! My favourite take was the idea that 9/11 trutherism was amplified by or came out of a repressed guilt on the part of Americans for being so pro-war in the aftermath of 9/11. - makes so much sense.

Marzlz

You having to clarify that you don’t wanna castrate anyone when talking about misogyny 😭 😭

jinsgoldenratio

oh man I'd love to see the cut tangent about Eyes Wide Shut too haha

RTT12

I was today years old when I learned that Americans say Jean-Paul "Sart". Is there no end to your depravity?

Deconstruction Interactive

Amazing video! I love the ending. You are literally the first person I have seen try to formulate a solution out of conspiracism. Lots of good food for thought. It did make me think -- your conclusion, that there are no adults, that it's just us, also feels like a fundamentally atheist position, owning up to the terrifying responsibility of living on our own without a higher power. I wonder if that's a huge blocker for many people -- without conspiracies, without God, life can be completely terrifying (also a very existentialist perspective). One thing that occurs to me as I'm writing this is that even if everything in politics and the economy were hunky dory (and it never would be), conspiracism would still flourish because it is so intimately tied to our search for meaning.

Ish The Dark Lotus

I saw the images shared to promote conspiracy theories, and I just realized that it is so much easier with AI-generated images today. You can literally type in a prompt about anything, and a realistic image can be generated, and this can easily be shared by bots on social media.

a malicious lawn ornament

I would love to know what the random cinéma vérité segments are about. Weren’t they in Envy, too?

Hellvetika

Need a behind the scenes video of the construction (and assumed later deconstruction) of that conspiracy wall

Hellvetika

I too am not a good enough person to go vegan. Although ive drastically cut down my meat consumption, I can’t give up dairy. Im an addict, it’s not my fault.

Theo Stratford

Think it’s a nod to Natalie’s taste for the liminal. Watergate hotel is super fucking liminal hey how are you. Like when she’s walking to Royal Farms in the Twilight video. They’re just a nice little transition

Filip Åsberg Montgomery

I want to say wow perfect timing, natalie does it again dropping this on the same day the signal chat leaked… but then I just realized that conspiracies are the de facto state of politics right now… anyway eerily relevant: Meanwhile, Mike Waltz, whose fault this is, went full conspiracy theorist: “I’m not a conspiracy theorist, but of all the people out there, somehow this guy, who has lied about the president. . . gets sucked into this group.” As a rule of thumb, if someone starts off with “I’m not a conspiracy theorist,” understand you’re about to hear the most paranoid, whacked-out theory you’ve ever heard. Waltz held that he’s “never met” Goldberg, so he has no idea how he could have added him to this chat. Well, Mike Waltz has a public Venmo, so you can see who he’s paid, and he’s clearly spent a lot of time with journalists (h/t The American Prospect for that scoop).

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

I wish I could show you a picture; the flowers looked like they had been brutally ripped out of a flower bed—complete with roots and lots of dirt—and stuffed carelessly into the mail slots. If this was a positive message, then the messenger must have been a kind-hearted gorilla. To me it seemed less like a kiss than eating someone’s face off.

Leslie

as a kid who grew up in DC and went to Comet pizza & ping pong that shooting was a real jump scare, idk how i never heard about that 😭🫣

Squalor

Great video. Captions need to be fixed tho

Rebecca Sacks

This was such an amazing and important video. I especially appreciate how thoughtfully you approached the "socialism of fools" issue. Although it seems such a small thing, managing to have an even-handed discussion of the antisemitism without it devolving into discussion of Jewish practices or the state of Israel is rare. Your handling of the matter was deft, and as a left-leaning (leftist? I dunno) Jew who has felt pretty politically homeless for a minute, I was relieved to get to observe it.

R. Nowadays

lol so right. I cannot say I enjoyed this, but it is a great video.

Theodora

Killed it with the set and costume design on this one!

Alejandra

My take might be very unsavoury here, but I loved this video and my only criticism is that Natalie avoided one very important part of the web of why people are falling for conspiracists SO much nowadays: NEW AGE IDEOLOGY. Conspirituality is a real thing, I witnessed it in so many of my relatives and even myself almost fell for it. Apparently it is very scary to antagonize astrology, but astrology forces you to think in a way that makes you incredibly susceptible not only to propaganda but to any scam or charlatan. This applies to tarot too. This topic requires more time than I have in a comment but essentially it erodes your critical thinking because you always start from the conclusion (you are this zodiac sign, I drew this tarot card, I manifested this thing) and you rationalize your way backwards cherry-picking whatever connection that makes sense to you. Think of it as the laws of Fives: “Everything is directly or indirectly connected to 5” try to disprove that. You can’t because you can indirectly connect anything to the number Five. This is New Age/Wellness/Spirituality for you. It is no coincidence that the current attention economy brought such a wave of new age thinking, and why 95% of people in the wellness sphere are scammers or they fell for the scam and are just repeating it onto others. It’s all a Get rich quick scheme. Of course, the way this people start falling for any conspiracy is alarming!! I really wishes Natalie had pointed this incredibly dangerous pipeline in her videos, since so many of her audience is people primed to fall for New Age ideology. My guess is there’s a lot of LGBTQ+ people who are in vulnerable moments of their lives, and the word “spiritual”sounds safe and alluring, they fall for the comfort of thinking the universe will finally make sense, when it’s everything but. Best case scenario you lose a ton of time and money on wishful thinking. Worst case scenario you end in a cult and/or filled with conspiracies, many of them are even more heinous when you add the “spiritual”component to it since it becomes religious and not just political. They are questioning the ontology itself of the universe, there’s no arguing again that (i.e.: Higher vibrations manifest good things, lower vibrations ,manifest bad things. I want to be 5D, others are lowers 3D, they don’t get it, etc.)

10 Ten 235 J

Is it possible that you're projecting a prejudice like the conspiracists in the video, tinting your reading of things that could be read more charitably, instead? Having read every conspiracy theory about the Masons before joining, and now seeing it as a thoroughly wholesome thing, I have found on the other side of it profound lessons about the power of illusion and perspective.

Cole

Having grown up in a very New Age community, I think it's important to distinguish between "New Age ideology" and what you're describing, which I might call divination, magical thinking, or supernatural beliefs. I agree these can sometimes be the start of a slippery slope towards a disconnect from reality, but then again so can most forms of religion or hardcore ideology. New Age ideology has been around since the 60's, I don't think we can blame it for the current wave of conspiracy fervor that has arisen over the past decade or two. Before New Age ideology, conspiracies grew out of nationalist movements, religious sects, revolutionary factions, and plenty of other ideologies. The reason conspiracies are so popular now, as I see it, is because we're living more and more of our lives online, increasingly funneled by highly targeted algorithms into information silos where we are only presented with content that we agree with (and that will make us most likely to spend money).

Luiza Lodder

The ROI on your videos is through the roof, contra

Oliver 'Kannik' Bollmann

Awesome, as always. One of the big drivers that I think makes Americans much more susceptible to conspiracies comes from the heavily "patriotism" that makes it impossible to criticize the country. There's so much bombardment from a young age and from many sources of how amazing/special/awesome/roxxors the country is that it becomes ingrained that "There can't be something wrong with the system, our our policies, or our views, because America is the perfect country. So it must be nefarious forces that are causing bad things." Or, at least, its easier to deal with that than to look within.

Adam

I listened to a lecture at my uni about Rene Girard. So much thematic overlap!! Haven't been this passionate about one of your videos in a long time (and they've always been very engaging).

Noah

Politically homeless is EXACTLY how it feels

Neil

She was probably about to say it was some kind of satanic acronym.

SevenTrees

really great work. outfits check, intelligent analysis check, iconic scene design check

Bogo

I’ll keep my praise to one topic else I’d be here all day: the production on this was god damn fire.

Rob

We’ll need an AMA soon, I have questions to submit. I want to hear the three page tangent on EWS. Also want to hear your take on how to respond to people falling into conspiracism.

kristina

Its church time

Samantha Fieldman

yayyyy natalie congratulations on this piece love the vid

Rhymes With Mason

This is so so so good. Also you look gorgeous in this golden lighting.

Kiki

Incredible video. I would read it as a book, except I would be so sad to miss all of the incredible visuals (girl the sets!). It was great to see the content from the tangents sprinkled in, too!

George Costanzo

Ugh you’re always right on time with these. My sister recently had two kids and left her job as a nurse to raise them full time. She started feeling disenchanted with the healthcare system and jumped on the RFK train early. Now she’s terrified by literally everything, and has fallen into this pattern of thinking in a big way. It’s difficult to have a conversation with her that doesn’t devolve into accusations of “their” nefarious intentions and theories on what “they” are hiding from us. It’s been really difficult to put my feelings of loss into words, and at least this video has helped me do that. It’s really heartbreaking.

Chloë Joan López

The post-modern emasculation in films like The Matrix and Fight Club was a whole zeitgeist unto itself. “Vorsprung durch technik,” sang Bono ironically on an album that wasn’t pushed nonconsensually onto everyone’s music player. But all that came to a dead stop on one clear September morning. All that alienation found vindication and a new purpose: nuke them all. The diagnosis of our florid conspiracist moment as displaced guilt for the Iraq war is not one I’ve seen before but it has to be right. Did the terrorists win after all?

Chloë Joan López

“Daddy’s home” is a comfort to those whose parents were wantonly cruel or wantonly neglectful or wantonly indifferent. Daddy wielding the belt of justice is less scary than daddy beating you because he’s an out-of-control fuckup. It also makes the idea of God or Nature being an out-of-control fuckup completely intolerable.

RTT12

After a few videos that weren't quite so relevant to me, this one hits the nail on the head. A great one. Thank you!

RTT12

Yes! We want it!

Krazy Dreamer

Exactly! This makes sense to me why "the idea of God or Nature being an out-of-control fuckup" became "completely intolerable" to me as growing up, my own father's irrational rage tantrums created a complete distrust and disrespect for authority figures in me.

frankgrim3z

Globalism (tangentially related to this topic) is in itself a topic worth exploring on subsequent videos (since its a new term that most alt right influencers are exploiting rn)

Lauren Alyson

This was SO GOOD!!!! Took a few days to watch the whole thing but loved it! Helped put a lot of things in perspective and helped me understand how people are the way that they are a little better you know *gestures to everything going on right now.*

Chancellor Kingsmyth

I am truly and genuinely curious as to how you managed to hold my focus that long but I can only assume it's witchcraft.

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

That could be! But I had a second look at the picture I took, and I’ve got to say, there is more soil than anything else on that door, and one of the «bouquets» (i.e. 2/3 soil and 1/3 plant) has been dumped on the door handle so that it will fall to the ground it someone opens it, making the entrance even more of a dirty mess. If someone left me flowers in this way, I would be rather pissed. Who pours the entire contents of a flower pot onto—and into—someone else’s door in good faith?

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

Oh, and I also just noticed a utility knife that has been jammed into a sign on the door. It doesn’t really matter that much anyhow. Thank you for answering!

Courtney

So excited to see this! I hope you are okay and doing well.

Hannah

Hey Natalie, incredible video!! I know this wasn’t the main point of the video 🫠 but just wanted to chime in about the being omnivorous because of moral averageness and not wanting to be a martyr part. I would argue that vegans don’t necessarily have a martyr complex, rather that (at least often) a psychological shift has occurred in which they don’t see animals/animal biproducts as food anymore - and watching videos or whatever you’ve done for some reason wasn’t sufficient for this psychological change to occur. I’ll leave this here in case you’re interested :)) https://www.academia.edu/40768015/If_Veganism_is_not_a_Choice_The_Moral_Psychology_of_Possibilities_in_Animal_Ethics

Viviane P.L.

I rewatched the Incel video from 6 years ago and there's actually a lot of resemblance between the toxic hypervigilant and prone to catastrophic thinking type of forums. I guess that conspiracies are somewhat hopeful in contrast to incels. There's something to be done. The individual problems are systemic but the top ones can be taken off. Somehow both are a non-logical way to deal with frustration and self loathing, the different languages they use and relationship between members may be one of the greatest differences

Mina Y.

Hope your recovery is going well ❤️

surek

This is really frighteningly similar to modern theories on the development of psychotic episodes that I learned about in my cognitive behavioral psychotherapy training. It connects acute stress due to personal setbacks which lower self esteem to the development of delusions which stabilize self esteem e.g. because the patient is the only one able to recognize the signs. Simply helping patients with their stress and raising their self esteem in healthy ways helped reduce the psychotic delusions (although they did not make them go away). But I also really think that "the Left" does something similar. So many of us constantly argue that we know the facts, that the "others" are so stupid and so on. But all that knowing and thinking and analyzing often just makes us more comfortable with still not doing something or doing something and dealing with our projects failing.

Shannon Ellison

Hi Natalie, homeschooled libertarian Christian prepper childhood here, and I have to tell you how important and useful this video you’ve made is to me. I have felt, crawling out of the cult I was raised in and trying to save my loved ones still in it, that I am utterly alone and insane, trying to unpick this tangled bullshit. Attempting to understand and argue (productively) with conspiracists is my passion, my responsibility (as I was one). Your organization and thoroughness here is the most incredible gift to drop in my lap now; it took you a long time, and it was worth it. It was worth it. This is desperately important work. I feel 10x less alone and hopeless than I did before. Thank you.

10 Ten 235 J

I mean, the way you're describing it it almost sounds like someone outside is vandalizing the Masons, rather than it being some kind of internal exchange. Many such cases of this as well.

Kamel Al-Sharif

By far the most shocking/thought-provoking part of the video for me was how 9/11 conspiracy theories took off as a way of U.S. Americans trying to cope with manufactured consent for the invasion of Iraq. From our side of the world there are similar trends at play, believing that 9/11 was an intentional plot that the government can use to justify the invasions of Iraq/bombings of literally anywhere in SWANA. It's impossible to detangle this from Protocols of Elders of Zion/Jewish conspiracies because of Israeli colonialism and aggression...the irony being we're better at separating between anti-semitism (because we are semites) and anti-zionism, but conspiracies and the Israeli government give cause for blurring the distinction. Also at the end in terms of "what we can do" about people who think they're redpilled....I think you might find hopelessness because you're trying to reason with people purely logically. It reminds me an earlier video on cults where you covered the emotional impetus to these logical gymnastics. You don't reason with conspiracy theories with reason; you do it by appealing through emotion, similar to how you deal with people with addiction. Logically, you can never approach your parents with how same-sex activity exists in nature, for example. You first approach it with the harm homophobia has done to you as their child and lay the groundwork for them to accept or have the emotional bandwidth to be open to logic or reason.

Mina Y.

I just did a rewatch and caught your mention of having bipolar disorder and as someone who was just very recently diagnosed I dunno I feel a lot of comfort knowing there are other people out there with this condition, I know absolutely no one with it and all I’ve heard is disdain and anyway thanks for being open about it 🩵

Tempest

Time to make some fjords

Barry

This was really brilliant and my favorite of your Politics, Philosophy and Economics series of Theatre. I really liked that stuff around "antisemitism being the socialism of fools" and the risk of socialist movements turning nationalist. The line about populists not wanting equality and just to be ruled by people who look like them was great. Anyway, awesome costumes around the cult of Hilary, the Lady Gaga red outfit lady and the cultist in black did a bang up job of staying still during that part. I remember doing life modeling and sitting still like that isn't easy so props to those props. Anyway thanks. This was fucking great. Love you. Bye.

Anna

Fancy seeing you here, Kamel!

Camila Barreiro

As a lowly barnacle, I'm so appreciative of my whale!

RM

Fantastic watch!

Erica Mercier

ok random but blaire white posted an epstein conspiracy video two days later.... coincidence???

Marinousky

Dear Avery, I am feeling a lot of empathy for you. It would be wonderful to be able to talk about your feeling of disappointment in good faith. Sadly, I think you ran into a bit of a dog pile. People on the internet tend to be reactive and assume the worse of whoever is on the other side of the screen… you have no idea how many times I’ve seen someone being called a ‘bot’ for disagreeing. I’d hope contrapoints fans behaved better than to get into a comment fight with someone whose people are being genocided but the internet is going to internet. Anyway, I hope you are doing as well as you can be. Take care, A stranger on the internet

Anne Estipona

are you the real Tati Westbrook?

Tati Westbrook

Girl I wish. I’d be rich and delusional- the recipe for a happy life.

Doctor Tony

I love this video. I wish we, the ContraPoints community, had a resource that described how to put this knowledge into action. I get that that ask is kinda lazy, and maybe there is no "easy button" for that type of work.

Noah

You are no different than you were before your diagnosis and just as capable of living the kind of life you want :)) I HIGHLY recommend watching Taylor Tomlinson's Look At You comedy special! I found it genuinely moving <3

Timbofication

After watching a few times I don't have anything terribly meaningful to contribute except that I NEED to hear the eyes wide shut tirade that got cut for time

ContraPoints

I just went to Comet for the first time last night! Cute place. Sad to think of it having been a crime scene.

ContraPoints

will get to that. the wall is still up at the moment lol

Hellvetika

It’s just decor now

Sweety

I hope people sit down and watch the video for the first watch (instead of just listening) because your set/costume design and gags make it so worth it.

HK225

Anyone else scroll to the end once a day just to listen to the outro credit music? Why is that so familiar?

ContraPoints

It's Zoe Blade's rendition of a waltz called "On the Hills of Manchuria!"

BaFi

My food choices are almost vegan, but god, do I love to dress in leather 😭

Jenavive!

I was one of the folks who was not included in the patron credits! Also, this video was amazing and I shared it with family because my uncle is a conspiracist now? I haven't been able to get out of my head the image of the whirlpool, I think it's from the Witch Trials video -- he's in his.

Teodor Dysthe Lyngstad

Oh! If that’s a regular occurrence, then it’s certainly the most likely cause

Jayce

My boyfriend worked at Wayfair at the time of the missing children conspiracy and said that the thing with the prices was just that they were out of stock and it was easier to put in random high numbers so people wouldn’t buy it than change the listing to sold out.

Jayce

Or maybe he’s a part of the deep state and lied to me 🤔

Pup Scout

Hi! May I ask an annoying question? I find Youtube/Google to be contemptible, given its ill effects preventing competition and inviting people to watch extremist content. And I find your work to be decidedly un-contemptible. Hence my becoming a subscriber here. In addition to posting your videos to Youtube, would you consider hosting your videos on an un-contemptible platform as well? At this point, anything not owned by Google or the IDF will do. :3

baolo amore

this video stopped my introusive thoughts

Lullike

On why people develop a tendency towards conspiracy therories, I see an interesting pattern in my family. On my father's side, the family is/was members of Jehovas Witnesses and quite fanatically so. Some left the JW, but all who did, became susceptible to conspiracy theories subsequentely. It seemed to me while they could consciously decide they did not want this one weird and scary and irrational thing any longer, their way of thinking remained in those same patterns and they filled it with diffferent content.

jclare

I've been a fan of yours since the very beginning. Whenever it's been a while since I've seen one of your videos, I am gobsmacked all over again by your detailed research, intelligence, theatricality, humanity, and wickedly wonderful sense of humor. You are a gift, Natalie.

lélé_la_désossée

Hello bonjour, Thank you so so much for all the work you put in this incredible video, it is such a great experience for us. I wanted to ask other patreons if you guys saw the Janet Ossebaard "documentaries" ? the fall of the cabal experience. I begun to watch it , it was a very long video from her xhannelafter seeing Contra's and was curious about it, but it seems since then (a month ago or so), they disappeared from youtube.

gretta_splinter

You need to read Clay McLeod Chapman's "Wake Up and Open Your Eyes." It's a horror novel in which the conspiracist rabbit hole becomes the poral for a mass demonic possession, the apocalypse of which we see through Noah (a toothless blasé liberal with right-wing conspiracist in-laws). It's an insanely good read, stuck with me as much as your video: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/204640265-wake-up-and-open-your-eyes

crow

This and your twilight video are genuinely good documentaries of professional length and quality that I loved watching and rewatched with my family. You're an absolute pro and your videos keep getting better and better.

Max Oakland

What platforms like that exist?

Max Oakland

A logical explanation? Sounds like a conspiracy is afoot!

Max Oakland

I always do that with her videos. She makes it worth it!

Max Oakland

I’d also love to know and I don’t think Contrapoints knows either. THat’s the problem we are facing as a society. If we could cut off the propaganda, that would make a huge difference. But we’d have to have power to do that. And a lot of it

Pup Scout

Nebula is probably the best Youtube alternative out there, and it's a worker-owned service to boot. But Vimeo's not bad either.

Nehir Güler

There’s always been talk that Kubrick didn’t get to release the exact version he wanted. Some say around 24 minutes were cut, possibly including a more intense version of the ritual scene. Who knows for sure, but even the version we did get feels full of quiet tension and hidden meanings. One moment that really stuck with me: The two old men from the Christmas party show up again at the end, in the toy store. And Helena, the daughter, just walks off behind them. Her parents are deep in conversation and don’t even look back. But she does. She stares at them for a bit before disappearing into the crowd following right behind those two old men from Christmas Party. That gave me chills. Knowing how detail-obsessed Kubrick was, that kind of moment probably wasn’t random. Some people think it symbolizes a kind of trade, like Bill saw too much, and something had to be given up in return. It's subtle, but it fits the whole vibe of secrecy, power, and unsettling quiet control that runs through the film. And the fact that the mansion used for the ritual scenes allegedly belongs to the Rothschild family? I mean… that might add another layer. Anyway, maybe there’s no single "truth" here. But Kubrick definitely wanted us to notice and to keep questioning. I don’t wanna come off sounding like "isn't it weird bla bla bla bla?" but it kinda is 😅

terrorist hamster

this is such a good video. i'm so glad you made it, one because hell yeah it's a banger and who wouldn't want great content, two because i teach english as a foreign language and unit two for 11th year is media literacy - it leans heavily on the ability to identify conspiratorial language. it's now part of the "additional study content" in my google classrooms!

Balderdasch

I watch this like every week twice a week if i feel especially heinous

Jon Patel

Not being vegan is pretty evil actually, but you are an incredible video essayist so you may yet be spared when the animals rise up.

Jon Patel

Ok this actually sounds nuts, now I actually believe the child thing.

José Bogado

Contra you are my biggest idol in the whole both rotten and blessed space. Your content is deep and both enjoyable and digestive for a good size of the population which you chose as your audience. Your content is embellished by jewels and fine works of art, but not for the amusement of it visible properties, but to engage your audience. At the same time you have an incredible good taste. I could keep throwing you my flame thrower, but I would love to speak to you first my dearest. By the way I love the conspiracy video 🛸🧞

Casper

I want to love u but I am too stupid

DavidDarko

The attraction of conspiracies, is not a half-baked attempt to understand anything at all. These people deliberately eschew researching academic articles, and make no effort whatsoever to gain a basic understanding of political economy. You cannot understand anything at all, unless you understand the prevailing economic conditions that govern all policy decisions. The USA, must continue uindefin8ite genocd

DavidDarko

What they don't tell you is, that you have to take the red pill as a suppository

Alex F

A tiny thing I liked is that the video length for the "Father Almost Sacrifices Son" YouTube video joke is 22:10, which is chapter and verse in Genesis when Abraham picks up the knife. Very smooth, Natalie <3

Rose Dombegh

Wow Natalie was spot on. The future really IS using AI to bring back Hitler.

demlet

Freakin awesome. Natalie, you are on another level.

Noorjutt25

Nice ❤️❤️❤️ videos

Melissa Sedgwick

What if evolution happens through electricity and early humans just got struck by lightning jump starting brain activity. Just a thought lol. Evolution, it's practically in the name. And what if Thors hammer was magnetized?

ContraPoints 𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫

Hᴇʟʟᴏ Melissa , I’ve selected you for my sᴘᴇᴄɪᴀʟ ɢɪᴠᴇᴀᴡᴀʏ! ᴋɪɴᴅʟʏ ᴄᴏɴᴛᴀᴄᴛ me ᴏɴ my ᴛᴇʟᴇ•ɢʀᴀᴍ ʜᴀɴᴅʟe TheContraPoints

frogsmore

"Symbolism will be your downfall." Talk about leading with a TRUMP! <3