Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi all,

Here's the link for today's AMA livestream. Sorry this is short notice, I forgot to post the general announcement in advance. As usual, I will answer questions from the comments on a separate post (from a couple days ago) for $15+ Patrons. The stream will begin at 5pm ET and will likely run for 4+ hours. The replay will remain linked here—most patrons just watch the replay, so don't worry about missing it live!

Looking forward to chatting!

–Natalie

Files

ContraPoints Patreon AMA Stream #62

Comments

Ruby Power

Thank you mother contrapope, this is perfect timing

Arben

Let’s gooooo!!!! 🥳

Evelynn

Mother 😍

Bored Lacanian

Lucky I saw this, I would've been sad to miss it, let's goo!

Lauren V

Sadly I’m at work for the whole duration of the livestream, but I’m excited to watch the replay afterwards! I am especially interested to see how you answer my question ngl 👀 but I saw so many excellent questions so I’m sure it’s gonna be awesome regardless

Minauno HF

She giveth answers huance more ✨

Jae Jane

Yay 🤩🤩

Mars2Venus

Shit’s got me saying wahoo + yippee. May even throw a hurray in there.

Aqua Burton

Very glad I have something to pass the time while at work. Thank you mother

freff

Well I can't go to bed now

Alvaro Altamirano

I'll have to excuse myself for not attending my brother's 30st brithday dinner party for this.

chemistrini

Can a 15+ patreon please ask her for the song she uses at the start of Canceling?(she uses the song pretty often but havent been able to find it or shazam it)

420stink69

foaming at the mouth waiting patiently 20 minutes

Diego

Ohh, thank you so much for starting it a bit earlier. Actually will be able to catch that live from Germany 💜

Ayse Emre

Night time in the Netherlands. But who needs sleep anyway.

Lina7

Do you know if we can ask questions live ?

Will

Mother, I'm learning how to be patient... again

starwen

Reading the weird and the eerie as I wait!

The Haff

Sound is fine ❤️

Mario

you sound fine to me

Armany Habed

Perpetually late to everything individuals rise up and unite!!!!

Simoné

and it would also be about Austrian society/elite (in 1925)

Nour Maged

Can you do a tangent on American academia lol

Armany Habed

Your thoughts on "The Substance" make me feel so validated Ms. Wynne, thank you

S C

What are your thoughts on Adolescence and how it portrays incel thinking?

Jake

♥️

CrystalJade

Envy, inequality, lack (or difference), desire, ideology. They seem to name at least adjacent concepts. It seems like what comes before each might matter most. The quality of the predicate. Maybe that's what distinguishes envy. Is there ever a justifiable envy?

Delfina

I was deep in a niche tumblr fandom around 2015-2017, and looking back, the bizarre Moral Rules that that community viciously enforced with each other was also very religion-coded. I rly can't overstate how extreme it was, and it was all over a couple anime series...

Kai Lewen

Oh wow I made it in time !!!

Lucas Amodeo Newman

Question: My favorite video of yours is The Aesthetic - at the risk of pulling you into the stratosphere, how deep does your deconstructive attitude towards the apparently material features of the world go? Transcendence and performance figure deeply in the space you leave for play in gender expression - but do you mainline psychedelia and mysticism in your interpretation of so called "physical reality?" If not, do you find your inability to take that leap cognitively dissonant or do you have some other reconiliation?

BabyDreamDoll

I’ve never been able to join the live, sigh finally 😭💕

Rose Dombegh

Silly question from a newbie -- how does one join an AMA stream?

BaFi

Visit Prague in Eastern Europe

ContraPoints

Hey all, I predictably didn't get through all the questions tonight, so I will answer the rest in a second stream in a week or two!

highclass_lady

Hi Natalie, to bookmark for next time, the last question you answered was from Ila D, & you answered all the questions posted before hers except for the very 1st one posted which was still a Placeholder but has since been filled in! I also left bookmarks in the replies for you!

Monika Singha

Darn, missed it but will watch every minute. Cheers!

ContraPoints

The audio on this badly needs noise reduction. I'm going to download it and reupload a corrected version ASAP.

Paige Cirtwill

No seriously it was insane, half the blogs were like 22 year olds with “minors DNI” in their bio and posts like “if you ship a minor w an adult you should be shot :)” just pure hatred over anime characters

Teageen

There should be a link button in the email notification that says Watch now

Teageen

Or go to the post she makes about the Livestream in Patreon and look for the link in that

Aderyn Albarelli

4:3 ratio is for nostalgic purposes. 😎 I never saw eyes wide shut, I will now view it aspirationally. 💅

arnivold

As someone who keeps vampire schedule (sleep from 10am-4:30pm), honestly some people just have wonky circadian rhythms. I wouldn't feel pressured to keep a "normal" sleep schedule, especially since you have a job where you set your own hours. I work night shift and it feels more natural to me than any daytime jobs I had in the past and got fired from

Divdesmit Pieci

Totally agree to that. Prague is gorgeous.

a. j. archer

i prefer the electrically anomalous audio tbh #LetHerSpeak #GhostRights

A

You can visit Armenia !

Michaella Cipriani

Loved the Gerard tangent! Hoping to hear more in a later video! Some questions that come to mind: - In the absence of any actual enforcement of international law, do states interact with other states in basically the same unending cycles of retributive violence that characterized interactions between individuals in pre-legal societies? What does it take to break cycles of retributive violence between states? (Is there an option other than scapegoating…?) - Could the common practice of torturing/driving mad/killing the female protagonists of operas and ballets be fictionalized and stylized versions of earlier human sacrifices? “Rite of Spring” is super obvious about it. Carmen is too with its implied conflation of femicide and ritual animal sacrifice in the form of bullfighting. Is something related going on in Giselle and Lucia di Lamernoor and Tosca and Traviata and a zillion other 19th century works…? - How has Gerard influenced Peter Thiel and JD Vance? Thiel studied under Gerard at Stanford, cites him as a major influence, and said his understanding of Gerard’s mimetic theory of desire led him to invest in Facebook. Vance is Thiel’s protogé, and has name-dropped Gerard in speeches. If Thiel and Vance understand scapegoating the same way Gerard does, are they thinking strategically about their scapegoating of minorities? Do they literally wake up in the morning say to themselves “Time to deport some children/incarcerate some homeless people/withhold some trans peoples’ passports so society can achieve social cohesion through the ritual of the scapegoat”? That level of self-aware cruelty seems cartoon-villain-ish, but I guess wouldn’t put it past them. Btw: Have you read Barbara Ehrenreich’s book “Blood Rites”? It’s another really interesting take on the origins of animal and human sacrifice. Basically, Ehrenreich points out that humans spent the vast majority of our history in the middle of the food chain. We developed the weapons and hunting strategies needed to kill large people-eating predators, initiated a mass-extinction of those predators, and clawed our way to the top of the food chain relatively recently. She notes that many cultures have “Siegfried-killing-the-dragon” and “mouse-outsmarting-the-lion” type myths, which she interprets as dramatizations of the historical moment when humans figured out how to kill large people-eating predators. She sees paranoia about animal predation as a basic fact of human psychology that’s repressed in the modern world but that still shows up in dreams and art. Even those of us who have never been chased by predatory animals have nightmares about being chased by lions and tigers and bears and sharks. Spectacular battles between humans and human-eating animals, aliens, mutants etc are ubiquitous in movies. Ehrenreich sees the human fascination with human and animal sacrifice as stemming from our dual identification with both sacrificer and sacrificial victim, which in turn comes from our historical dual roles as predators and as prey. Sacrifice terrifies us because we identify with the sacrificial victim, and the sight of their blood reminds us of our own vulnerability to predation. At the same time, we identify with the sacrificer, and their act of violence reassures us of our status as predators rather than prey. Ehrenreich also has a theory about how patriarchy helps men reassure themselves of their status as predators by designating women as prey. It’s a really interesting book.

Chupaacabra

Re: metaphor of politics with the child being beaten - I don't think Trumpists believe that they are the child being beaten by daddy, they are a little golden child watching Daddy beat the troublemaker child. They fear and are excited by the idea of being the troublemaker who will be beaten, while getting to enjoy watching "justice" be dispensed by Daddy to someone who ostensibly deserves it

william kirkpatrick

I am watching Brigitte Empire's "Is it JK Rowling's black mold?" video and I thought I would check if the new Q&A is on here ....now I gotta start checking my email more often just to never miss Cuntpiss AGAIN.....and I support Natalie taking as long as she damn wants......my whole 4part grid is Peter Levenda, Naomi Klein, Brigitte Empire and Natalie.....so she added Brigitte into my world by taking a long time and I can stand on a square ....also Bob Woodward. He is a good reference when I just feel like I just want to scream, I feel like Bob Woodward helps give a cold objective look at things without absolutley freaking out

william kirkpatrick

I forgot I wanted to say I am not subscribe to anybody's Patreon but Contrapoints and I am sorry for coining "cuntpiss" I don't know why I think thats funny.

william kirkpatrick

21:03 LISZT.......LISZT!........who do we want recorded? LISZT!........holy shit.......I haven't smoked crack for a long time. Couperin I think is a big figure and is more along the lines of improvisational so there is a Lully-Couperin-Chopin-Joplin-Jelly Roll Morton-Dr. John-Allen Toussaint pipeline......but the political implication of Liszt, the hypersexuality, becoming a monk, a pretty young student banging the door down and camping out outside while Wagner was having a premier.e......seems like its happening right now.......ok back to the show

Lear91

Natalie, I’ve watched all your videos and just subscribed to your Patreon because literally everything you say is interesting. I spend hours watching your takes - please keep illuminating us, we love you

william kirkpatrick

hahaha I am so friggin' freaked out that it is possible contrapoints (natalie) read my last post and I feel so proud of myself at the same time. So I want to return focus to the piano. Who is Liszt but the spirit of the Bach-Busoni Chorale Prelude in g major with the 16th notes? I will have it by the end of the summer and send it to you.......also I got a Wendy Carlos bio before and it was so complicated. Can you just play a fender rhodes or some patch and pretend you'r wendy carlos? Have you and Zoe ever hung out all night and recorded music together drunk?

william kirkpatrick

I cannot believe Dave Chappelle just popped up and I am listening but I have this nausea WTF now I am nauseous. I wouldn't be. But the fact that he is so insensitive to trans issues as being something that is just affecting a certain percentage of the human race, no matter how brilliant he is. This is just like how straight male "leftist" (not) youtubers are bashing Natalie. Its just misogyny. Transphobia IS mysogyny.

william kirkpatrick

jesus christ ......did contrapoints actually pick up an old thing I tried to tell her and reinsert it on top here.?If so I am OK. I live in eternity. I am straight but I had a gay piano teacher starting age 11. So I rode the Caltrain I left my horrible father's house and hung out with my gay piano teacher .....He was actually from denver but he studied at Peabody and I guess decided he wanted to study with Nathan Schwartz..........but even now I got to get out of sebastopol, where my mom followed my sister who decided to have a baby here....... and go back to san francisco where I can resume living the life of a normal healthy adult male playing ballet classes and in the various san francisco hotels like the four seasons and the fairmont, but more importantly my friends, the SF Conservatory, and who ever pops off from them and just live in SF and play wonderful music........For some reason I am posting this here. But people trying to axe natalie. You probably have no life at all. You probably have no life at all. You never heard of Schopenhauer or Aleister Crowley. Will? Will. You have no Will. So you want to say that Natalie is apologizing for Netanyahu.......FU U U U U CKCK UUUUUUUU! Natalie is the biggest force we have for ending Netanyaho. Natalie is Luke Skywalker

Jovana Todorovic

Yeah, this is definitely not a place for me anymore. I guess all the people whose opinion I cared about already left. Stay safe or whatever.

Alexa barrett

This was a bop. Anyone else think that the voting isn't necessary and that the maker should just decide what she wishes to cook at any given time?

Sam

Do you like Videodrome? That would be an interesting tangent. Especially in the age of AI