Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey all!

Here's my retrospective on the Twilight video.

On the last one some of you expressed a desire for longer content, so I have allowed myself to ramble more. I hope that's as good for you as it is for me.

Thank as always for your support,

Natalie

P.S. In my last post I said I would be posting the Conspiracy retrospective this week too—but I've changed my mind. I think a "retrospective" video is more interesting if enough time has passed for meaningful retrospection. So I think I'll hold off on that until the video reaches its first birthday. Up next, there's a main channel video I'm very determined to finish by the end of this year. So I'm going to get to work on that!

Files

Retrospective: Twilight

Comments

Rich K

I watched this one on my laptop while doing the dishes!

Honoria Valemon

Middle school librarian when the twilight movies came out and there was renewed interest in the books. I think people GREATLY overestimate the impact of novels on girls’ understanding of relationships. Most of my Twilight-mania girls who were otherwise pretty mature and sensible (that’s a LOT of pages and you need space, quiet, and time to yourself to read) who frequently didn’t date or weren’t interested in dating, but they loved the over the top Romance and drama. Girls who had really unhealthy ideas about relationships usually learn them from real life, either first or secondhand. So I think it’s fine you didn’t address it. It’s one of those things that sounds like it should be true, but isn’t most of the time.

Ethan Good

For the record, I always watch your videos on my big TV, often with friends and popcorn.

quidvis

I find that most of my waking life is like a liminal royal farms walk lately. I also relish the possible fact that the Twilight video might avoid the book burnings because on the surface it's just about Twilight. PS I watched this on a 4k projector my ex somehow left in the divorce. And trust me, on that, I definitely see it.

Neil

Just pausing the video for a second to hold space for the line “Why do these vampires shop at banana republic?” This is cathartic deadpan-shade humour & is very good for one’s blood pressure. Thank you. Resuming now…

Jena and Zee's Wedding Fund!

Pocketing the dream logic creation tidbit for my own writing. (And…the bit about trying to contain the pre-writing mania documents. Is there any other way than collecting and color coding the best lines of every possible relevant source in one place, just in case?!) Echoing what some others have said — I’ve watched this one with my partner and some friends on the big TV several times since it’s come out. It’s an eventttt and I always catch something new. Thanks as always🩸

S. R.

The twilight video was extremely interesting to me as someone who grew up in fanfic world from the livejournal era, following to ao3 and tumblr. I feel like we have had these arguments about desire - straight women consuming/making gay porn (harming gay men?), is porn bad, fiction vs reality, the importance of representation in porn, think of the children, top/bottom discourse, racialized sex dynamics, abuse discourse, what exactly counts as a pedophile, what exactly counts as consent - in cycles for eons ("but what are your thoughts on yaoi?"). Your video felt very grounded in all sorts of research and historical context while also being fresh and at times lyrical about desire, which I think sometimes people forget in the midst of moral and rational and philosophical arguments is actually at the crux of it. After your video I looked up Jacob/Edward fanfics on ao3 and they were, as expected, extremely #problematic.

Linnea

For what it's worth I always appreciate the lighting/costumes/sets of your videos, and I really love the vastness in scope of Twilight. You brought to light so much that I felt about love, sex, fantasy, desire, etc. but that I could never find the words for, and for that I am very grateful.

Milena Gonçalez

Natalie, as a Fine Artist and Special FX artist, I have to say that I always loved watching your videos on the Tv. Me and my ex would make it a “movie night”. What amazes me really is your research. You must own so many books, where do you keep them all?

Al Mutanabbi

Thank you for the longer video, Mother <3 I advertised the Twilight video to friends and family members as 'the best thing I watched in 2024 all media included', so the effort you put in lighting and set design do not go unappreciated <3 Just a quick note on the orientalism: I appreciate you naming the specific origins of all the elements you use. I personally loved seeing a Moroccan caftan featured in my absolute favorite YouTube work yet, and appreciated more your naming it correctly in this video.

nb

In this house we watch all your new videos projected onto a 120” screen with surround sound turned all the way up. Just to say your cinematography and attention to detail are massively appreciated, and you make some incredible choices.

Adventuress

Unrelated to this tangent, sort of - has Natalie ever thought about compiling her essays and video scripts into a book? I feel like a collection of her essays would be really nice to have

Ana Cecilia Alvarez

LOVE these. give me more of how your mind works, why you make the choices you make, your creative process! we need a hunger retrospective!!!!!!!

Shawn Coughlin

The last 1-2 min reminded me of this old twentieth century debate that happened between psychoanalysis and art history. Freud writes a book in 1910 about the Renaissance painter Leonardo as a case study of psychosexual narcissism. Freud hinges his whole argument on a journal entry from Leonardo in which he recounts a childhood dream where a vulture inserted its tail into baby Leonardo’s mouth. Many art historians at the time ate this up. Loved it. Then in 1956, the art historian Meyer Shapiro writes that Freud’s argument sucks because Freud was working from an inaccurate German translation of Leonardo’s journals. In the original Italian text, Leonardo’s dream is about a kite (another type of bird) and not a vulture. Shapiro adds that Freud’s unfamiliarity with Renaissance culture limits his ability to interpret the dream in context. I think about psychoanalysis and how when it’s right it sings, but when it is mistaken, the failure is spectacular. In the 1990s, another historian Micheal Ann Holly wrote about this spat, but admits that, despite Freud’s biographical, sociocultural, and translation errors, his argument still resonates because it nevertheless ‘makes sense.’

Ashton

Finally sitting down to watch this. Twilight has been my favorite video of yours since it came out and is certainly the one I’ve watched the most. It’s almost a piece of comfort media for me at this point, so seeing it finally get a retrospective is very exciting 🧛‍♀️💛

max murphy

im going through so much shit in my life rn. your videos are the only thing keeping me sane. thank you for your work ❤️

Alvaro Altamirano

I liked the lighting of the video the whole time

pjkc

Those notes for the background research holy fuck it just keeps going. Your dedication is impressive as always

Cherry Bee

Only lovers left alive ! Great movie 🤓 Also remember enjoying A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night Another vampire movie released at a similar time. Twilight is one of my favorites of yours. Thankyou for giving us an insight into the process of creating it 💗

Nora

I agree that Twilight is the best, but I love them all!

thesourcabbage

Oh no I'm watching this on a 5" phone screen doing the dishes 😭 Forgive me, Mother!!

Jon Patel

Ornamentalism over Orientalism 😂

misslcd

"Some people are born straight, others have straightness thrust upon them" - I felt this in my bones. As a cis woman with only hetero experiences I'd never really thought about or had to question or justify my gender or sexuality, although in the last couple of years I've been in sex therapy and have really had to dig into all of this. I'm so in awe of queer people and the level of self-awareness and introspection that comes with figuring out your identity. Imagine we were all assumed asexual at birth, and everyone had to come out, unless actually asexual? DHSM has definitely got to go! Watching the Twilight video sparked so many lightbulb moments for me, whatever I've paid my therapist I probably owe Natalie just as much!

CrystalJade

Sometimes the best thoughts occur in mundane distraction. I notice you make many references to obsessional feelings or behaviours. Though I'm never one to question, have you ever thought about what drives this feeling? Obvious truths are obvious because they follow a certain metonymy. On the other hand metaphor drives new meaning. Like the oil that greases the wheels. Even so, oneness is an illusion that never stops not being written. This seems to be a twighlight message, even if it only creates reflections.

Poogey Watson

I will never forget the thrill that ran through my body when I saw your new video was about Twilight.

Mayaohmy

Twilight is my favorite video of yours too! And, proud to say, I’ve watched not only on a 5 inch screen, but ALSO on a giant projector hehe. And the lighting still looked great :) Cheers!

XYA|6782

I do love this new idea of retrospective as it gives me an insight of where your mind was at when making the video and your micro or macro inspirations, but I would personally have to say I love the BTS/Outtakes more I don't know it just feels more personal. It also depends on the video too as I would love both the BTS/Outtakes and retrospective for the conspiracy video, if you ever come to make them.

highclass_lady

Natalie has sent a thank you note for everyone's birthday wishes which says: "Thanks to everyone who wrote such kind birthday messages - I've been reading them the last couple days and appreciate you all so much! Parasocially yours, Natalie" If you'd like to see it, I've shared it on r/ContraPoints!

Madison

My life was crazy this summer, so I'm finally catching up on your videos from the past few months. I really enjoy both retrospectives you've put out so far!

Andrew May

What you’re doing is essentially lead guitar work, I think you’re the first great lead guitarist who is a woman, but you’re using video essays and not the instrument.

Jonathan Gordon

As a new Patreon supporter I am working through your superb videos. They are an essential antidote to the lure of easy thinking and illiberalism. Thank you.

Wayrocket

I watch your videos on the T.V while high so I always really enjoy the lighting and the visuals.

Leah

I’m a ballet dancer who is currently rehearsing for The Nutcracker. Since your use of Tchaikovsky in the Twilight video, I cannot dance the snow scene without thinking of Jacob imprinting on Renesme and all of that weirdness. I will also think about Twilight the next time I perform in Swan Lake. 🥲 Will you think of the ballet dancers? There are…..1 of us!

jackie charbonneau

Twilight literally changed my life. (the video essay, i've never read the book/movie)

João Guilherme Viana

I think you might like the novel Insolación by Emilia Pardo Bazán! (The 2020 translation "Sunstroke" is a good one)

Gart Kundalini

just finished Harriet Tubman: Live In Concert by Bob the Drag Queen and i'm starting on When God Was a Woman by Merlin Stone

demlet

Your whole Twilight essay is brilliant, but I have to tell you, it's been probably more than a year since I watched the video and the Royal Farms part is what I still think about the most.

Ahri Clevinger

Natalie, a majority of great thinkers through history have been insane in precisely this way. The rest of us can only wish we cared about anything this much, much less about ostensibly Twilight of all things.

Gart Kundalini

read Girl on Girl: How Pop Culture Turned a Generation of Women Against Themselves -- was okay -- moving on to How to Do Nothing by Jenny Odell

kaitlyn gentilin

Completely agree twilight is your best video! I listen to it monthly on my phone while doing the dishes (literally. You read me so hard)

patroclus

why don't you just staple your script together a works cited page and submit the damn thing as a dissertation to get your PhD?

Yasemin Elrabaa

“Cultural appropriation of the Other assuages feelings of deprivation and lack that assault the psyches of radical white youth who choose to be disloyal to western civilization. Concurrently, marginalized groups, deemed Other, who have been ignored, rendered invisible, can be seduced by the emphasis on Otherness, by its commodification, because it offers the promise of recognition and reconciliation.”

Corey Snidal

I love the hunger! Though not quite an essay video that you usually do, it's just as educational and I love your artistry.

The Scary Kendrick

Very late to this, but I consider Twilight your magnum opus, from the first watch.

The HieroThot

Just in case you were worried that nobody caught the Rocky Horror Picture Show reference (“I didn’t make it for you!”), it was not lost on me and I give this reference the Charles Atlas seal of approval.

Utkarsh Gaur

Twilight is my favourite work of yours. It's coherent and cohesive - not just in the content but also the aesthetics. And it is layered in a way that rewards multiple viewings. My favourite part about it is that it is saying something new. And also that you are not afraid to be prescriptive. In comparison, when I look for a prescription to engage with in Saw, I am (as of yet) unable to find one, which creates a lack. Anne Carson would approve of the dream logic (if she were in the habit of approving or disapproving content). "Ode to Sleep" is an enjoyable section in her book "Decreation".

Daniel Verdin

Babe, backups are like beers, one is none. Lmk if you'd like me to help you with a solution to that :)