Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey all!

Here it is!

I won't offer an explanation as to why this video took so long to make, because I think the video speaks for itself in that regard. It's been six months because this video took six months to make.

This is me giving it everything I've got. I don't think I've ever worked so hard on anything. 

It will probably be quite a while before I do another video this big, and I'm going to need to rethink some things about my process—but we can talk more about that soon. For now, enjoy the video, and thank you all so much for backing this project!

All my love,

Natalie

Files

Envy | ContraPoints

Starting at the surface with celebrity gossip, then spiraling into the inferno of the human psyche. Virgil, get me out of here. Support this channel: https://www.patreon.com/contrapoints ✿Donate: https://paypal.me/contrapoints ✿Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/contrapoints/ ✿Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ContraPoints/ ✿Website: https://www.contrapoints.com/ ✿Twitter: https://twitter.com/ContraPoints ✿Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPoints ✿ContraPoints Live: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGh4... Check out my other videos: J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/7gDKbT_l2us Voting: https://youtu.be/t3Vah8sUFgI Justice (Part 1): https://youtu.be/smQsfNw_7V4 Cringe: https://youtu.be/vRBsaJPkt2Q Shame: https://youtu.be/K7WvHTl_Q7I Canceling: https://youtu.be/OjMPJVmXxV8 Opulence: https://youtu.be/jD-PbF3ywGo Men: https://youtu.be/S1xxcKCGljY Transtrenders: https://youtu.be/EdvM_pRfuFM Beauty: https://youtu.be/n9mspMJTNEY Gender Critical: https://youtu.be/1pTPuoGjQsI The Darkness: https://youtu.be/qtj7LDYaufM

Comments

Day Magee

Quite simply, your masterpiece. Inspired me to begin writing my own analyses, hare-brained or otherwise even if only for myself, and thereby rediscovering and re-falling-in-love-with writing as (one of) the centre(s) of my fine art practice. You rock.

Sabrina Penna

For anyone still reading the comments, I found ContraPoints last year in 2023, watched this more than 2 years after it was made. This video is one of the best things I've ever seen. I hope you enjoy it.

CassieWasRight

So the first time I watched this (back when it came out) I was too distracted by wanting Natalie to talk about restorative justice (which would still be cool but I recognize that's probably not going to happen) and I wasn't really paying close attention to the Nietzsche parts, but this time around I'm struck by the use of the French word Ressentiment. I'm pretty sure Nietzsche was writing after the Franco-Prussian War, where France was militarily crushed so thoroughly that they basically had no hope of coming back. The resentment around that (the French could also, after all, look back to the Napoleonic era as a time of great national glory barely within living memory) fueled a political tendency called revanchisme, where the French yearned for an unachievable revenge against the Germans. Nietzsche was writing in that political climate, so it wouldn't surprise me if that informed him. Revanchisme continued into the 20th century (while Nietzsche, notably, did not) and was an important part of how France approached world war I and particularly the post-War Treaty of Versailles

CassieWasRight

Also! The number of foreshadowing bits to the Twilight video! Truly spectacular

Soy

i love watching your videos its like someone wise told me something true

Rose Dombegh

Rewatching this (after talking to my mom), I wonder how much transphobia directed from ciswomen to transwomen stems from envy. I think many ciswomen feel threatened by/envious of transwomen bc transwomen sometimes perform womanhood (through social signaling, beauty standards, etc.) better than ciswomen. This is often accompanied by a feeling of "why did [part of stereotypical womanhood here] come so easily to her and yet remains so difficult for me?!" I've certainly felt the latter. Many cultural aspects of "womanhood" have never spoken to me, and I can have an almost despairing response of "what's wrong with me?!" when trans friends talk about being drawn to makeup, styling their hair, etc. They were drawn to these things despite being actively discouraged; I can hardly bring myself to care even while society encourages it. Obviously this doesn't justify bigotry. But I wonder how much quiet transphobia could be resolved if people just recognized it in themselves as envy.

frogsmore

Five years later, and I still find Natalie's 'Envy' intimidatingly brilliant.

Stansky

A rushed video will forever be bad. A delayed video is eventually good.

Tia Sarkar

Thank you for everything you do!

hyukz

AAAAAAAAAAA

Aviv

IT’S HERE

Spuggy Bear

Omg it really came 😭😭😭😭

Liam

It hath arriiiived 🤩🤩 Thank you!!

MzMilena

And I have no doubt that it’s absolutely worth it. Thank you. ^_^

Quizoid

Yeeeeeah! 😆

MsReni

Congratulations on finishing this huge project!

RJ Blue

Aaah I’m so proud of you!!!!! I’m SO excited to watch, please go take a well-deserved rest ❤️

Brenna

YEEEEAAAHHHHHHH!!!!

Jo Der

woo!

Jacinda

I am so excited!!

Ivy M Villela

FANTASTIC news for my Saturday morning, thank you!!

Sean Hicks

Don't worry about it gorg we love you

Tate Robinson

NP Nat, the video dropped right when it was meant to

Rachelle Walker

Congratulations!!!! Can’t wait to watch, I know it’ll be well worth the wait ♥️

dripdrylowfi

Your content is always a gift!! Thank you :)

TroubledTrout

I just said to myself "wouldn't it be great if the video is released by the time I have cooked dinner" - and it did! Get some rest Nat.

Sean Hicks

Also that Zoe Blade lacrimosa mix is fire

Percy

Just in time for dinner. Thx

Courtney

But.... I was just about to go to work... *sob* Looking forward to tonight, then!

Luis

I used to study Art History when I was younger and the attention, love and thought you put into your videos remind me a lot of the stories written about Michaelangelo's painting of the Sistine Chapel. I hope you get to savor life now that the video is over.

Iris W.

wooooo!! hopefully it’ll feel good for you to finally take a break lol

Eve Q

Congratulations Natalie! Enjoy the feeling of the grass

Matthew Foweraker

How long? Damn, I have DnD to run! Seriously though, nice to see your stuff again.

Libra Frills

Ive been having an awful week so THANK YOU you saved my evening. Cant wait to dive into this

NoxMelodia

Don’t worry even a little bit about it! It took as long as it needed to and there’s nothing wrong with that. Now take some time to rest and recharge!

run_away

Congratulations on releasing this!!!

Shupostekud

Congrats Natalie. Well looking forward to this after re watching the back catalogue.

Tiefling Tears

Girl, it's my bedtime WHY Looks like I'm not sleeping now.

Arinbjörn Brandsson

Thank you dark mother ♥️ I hate that I can't watch it till tomorrow, but I know it'll be worth the wait! And congratulations on the release, ofc!!

The Bilderberg Group

Wooo congrats on finally having this monkey off your back. What a relief it must be for you. I'm excited to dig in.

Fabian

Im so excited!!!!

Amanda Newell

It takes as long as it takes! Love your work, thank you for sharing your thoughts, to hell with the haters

ROTHICK

sooooo amped!!!!!!! fuck the haters I’m so stoked!

SexySoleWrinkles

OMG OMG OMG!!1!! Congrats on the release, I can't wait to watch this tonight!

Nyatalie's Shrimp

I see, Jameela Jamil's character in The Good Place is very much based on her)))

AstroMostra

Oh Mother you made a film, you are a film-maker

EMA

Always thrilled for whatever you’ve been cooking up— no matter the wait!💖

Equalize

we will observe ... thx for publishing generalizations pointing out fictional temperature fantasies (predatory everythingisms)

Kimberley Challis

Arrrrrgghhhh, I am at a festival but I would rather be at home watching this! ♥️

Ash Gabrielle

I hope you know that after all the work you've poured into this, you owe yourself at least a month off from working at all!

Cybernetics Anonymous

Please take care of yourself. You're brilliant, and I know that always comes with a sort of torture. You've created art, and it's changing the world.

Johnny DeMartino

I can’t wait to watch! Now please go on vacation for at least two months, gorge! ❤️❤️

Nyatalie's Shrimp

...I love Natalie Wynn so much... Where is my shock thing? :D

Julia Rittenberg

6 months is a shockingly short time for a feature film of this amazing quality!! You are the best!!

Edward Newton

Haven't watched it yet, just letting you know I'm backing because I care about people getting to see and hear your take on the world. Sometimes that's gonna take six months. I'm down for the ride.

Coco Starr

I've put on a silk dress and my new snake lingerie to watch the video, doing my part to be your ideal viewer! Much love 😘😘

tagliatelle grande

Wow, this looks amazing, so excited to watch. I know I would rather you take the time to make things the way you feel is right, it always seems to pay off in your videos!

Nyatalie's Shrimp

My ex-girlfriend used to tell me she would never date a woman who's an artist just like her, because the envy would be too strong. I wonder if gay men have the same level of unhealthy competition as gay women do.

Sonja

Only six months for 108 well-made minutes. That's highly productive.

Velvet Vandal

YOU HAVE OUTDONE YOURSELF. This is just sublime.

Isaac

Wow

Rachel G

This is fantastic! Great job!

Thew

This feels like the capstone of every video since Beauty. I'm tempted to rewatch and take notes

Mara S

Blessed & highly favored to get a GRWM in the middle of a philosophy essay ✊

Liz Mednick

As always, absolutely worth the wait. Exceeds expectations which how is that even possible. Love it love it love it. And learned some stuff.

Eric Williams

Yay Nyat! Take a well deserved break

Ash Yaeger

Hey how are you!?! Thank you for this amazing piece! What an incredible work! Now please take care of yourself gorge! :)

Chris Reynolds

This is your best video, exceeded all expectations. Will be discussing with friends for weeks to come. Take the most well deserved break ever ❤️❤️❤️

Nauman

wtf i love neechuh now

jennifer convertibles

this one took some turns I didn't expect in the BEST way!! (also these looks are stunning!)

Katherine Elmore

The body positivity part (just passed, still watching) is the realest thing, and I'm glad you used it as an example. As a fat woman (who kind of hates that terminology too) I have honestly felt more actual hatred towards my self image from fat acceptance activists than I ever actually got from thin people. Thin people say your body is wrong, activists say you're morally wrong for being in pain. I can live with someone not liking how I look, but someone telling me I am a moral failure isn't so easy to brush aside. I had a professional fat acceptance advocate once tell me that I shouldn't date because I hated my body too much. This person's ideal that body positivity = morality had corrupted her own ideals that she was now telling a fat person not to date... because they're fat. There's a lot to be said about how treating freeing yourself from hurtful internalized ideas as a moral obligation, rather than a personal good, can be weaponized against the very same people harmed by the systems you're trying to overcome. A fat woman who doesn't aggressively love her body has morally failed at fat acceptance. A lesbian who wants a monogamous marriage has failed at queerness. A woman who presents femininity has failed as a feminist. The big societal issues that cause people to act these ways also cause real harm, but it's easier and more accessible to target your ire as moral outrage against individuals you see as betraying the cause than at a tangible political or cultural goal.

Sum Weeaboo

Thank you thank you thank you!

Nyatalie's Shrimp

I wanna be her? I wanna be hers? I wanna be her AND hers! (c)

Percy

Ok, so this is now my favorite Contrapoints video. Also, "the Left" will maybe lose its shit about it. And I'm not saying that as someone not on the left. I'm an anarchist. But there was some overdue outcallimg that will for sure run the right people the wrong way. So thanks, this was totally worth the wait. I hope you'll take some weeks off now, you deserve it.

Wangled Teb

Wow I think this was my fav video of yours holy crap... This actually helped me a lot tbh like... I don't really wanna get into anything super personal but I recently decided to go back to school and get my social work degree to become a counselor back on the reserve where I grew up, and the head of the Native Studies dept basically told me at one point that the whole field of "helpers" is nothing but a scam and that applying individualistic solutions to a problem of one entire society oppressing and attempting to destroy another (or well thousands of societies really) just wouldn't work because it doesn't do anything to address the underlying problem? But he didn't really give me any like, actual constructive ideas and so I've spent a lot of the last year struggling with this. Like am I just going to be making things worse or oppressing my own people (his words) by trying to help them survive and excel in the world when I should be fighting to completely end capitalism, colonialism and Indigenous genocide? But like... How would I even do that? I felt totally impotent- that's the perfect word for it, like you said. But I think watching this actually helped me figure a lot out so thank you Nyatalie! You're a genius and a queer icon <3

noplanetb

This is a masterpiece and now I hope you have the most relaxing rest of all time ❤️

Nic James

I don’t care if it’s a 10 minute video or a 2 hour video. Don’t care if it’s a week between videos or a year between videos. As long as I can afford it, you’ll have my Patreon support. Thanks for doing what you do.

Jessica Cheeri

Congratulations on a truly fantastic video! It was like the overarching meta-point of a lot of your work over the last few years and so much in it that I'm going to have to watch it so many more times. Also just visually! Wow, just the way your use of light and color and even just the visual depth it's resplendent. Love your fashion too (that outfit in the Nazar room, I need to know where you got that) Anyway I know I'm gushing a bit, so I'll end here just saying I'm proud of you. You've had quite the rough time of it in the last couple years and you still made amazing art

Liz Jackson

I re-watched a bunch of your other videos today in anticipation of this one, and I'm so glad I did, because this felt so much like a culmination of themes that have been in other videos. This felt like a mega-sequel to Opulence, Incels, Shame, Justice, Cancelling and Beauty. Amazing work! I hope you take a good long holiday, you deserve it.

governmentfunding

You've outdone yourself again! Loved this video. May your comment section overflow with lavish praise!

Taylor

un triomphe. oui. absolument. such an inspiring video! I hope you have a well-deserved holiday, queen :)

Vigilant Veggie

Betch. I'm 11mins in and got tingles the second you pulled out that violet wand and cut to the opening title.

Justas Petrosius

Thank you dark mother, now I finally have the motivation to read Nietzsche!

Franco del Rosario

I just finished watching this video, and this is a masterpiece. The visuals and production are as beautiful and impressive as ever, but the research that had to be put into this is just difficult to fathom. You referenced some of the greatest works of mankind across generations and culture (from On the Genealogy of Morality to Spongebob Squarepants) in a way that I think would speak to all folks across the political spectrum. I hope you go and take a long extended vacation after this video to de-compress and unwind. Congrats, and enjoy another success!

Vince Whitacre

Really great work Natalie. And it took 6 months to make - honestly looks like it took more. So yeah. Enjoy kicking your shoes off for a bit. You've more than earned it.

Evan Benner

Envy AND Justice (Part 2)?! Thank you!

Gabrielle W.

Omg I’m so excited!!!!! Watching now!!!!

Flirtual

This paired beautifully with your talk with Noam Chomsky. From the MLK and makeup tutorial segments, am feeling more hopeful for the future (and the work it'll take to get there)

Tegan

Just finished. Brilliant. It has given me a lot of thoughts. A lot. And I love that.

Ugino

"Self-help but make it ContraPoints" happened to be precisely what I needed today

Camilo Vargas

Loads of love! Your determination is admirable. Now is time to get a well-earned rest.

xx

Such an incredible video! It was so beautiful, funny, and well researched.

Eric Jakows

This is truly you at your best and well worth the wait. I know I pay for your Patreon, but I almost felt dirty watching this "for free" because it's such a tour de force. It deserves the largest screen possible for viewing. It's not only one of my favorite videos of yours but one of my favorite videos on YouTube, period. Now get some rest because you've well earned it.

Alexis Bushnell

OMG I absolutely loved this. Incredible. I can't even explain how good it is.

Lisa T.

I can't tell you how much I loved this. It's a masterpiece. A dissertation on envy in cat ears which. :) It will definitely requires multiple re-watches to absorb it all. (And I finally got my name is an video. Yay!) Thank you!

Thew

The Gay Tangent put words to a lot of feelings I've been unable to cleanly articulate for a while now, that's gonna take some processing on my part, oof

Zuffer Canis

Thank you fur all that you do Nyaaatalie I struggle with this & having a elaborate breakdown of this does bring me a piece of mental peace. Much love ❤🐶👅💦

MarkusWitherX

When you brought up SpongeBob unironically in a political video essay I had to storm out the room I couldn't handle it. Also RIP me for forgetting to update my Patreon information this month, causing my name to fall out of the credits T_T This was an amazing video Natalie!

TheAbbeFaria

The world is burning, COVID rages. But I can watch the Philosopher Queen do her makeup while discussing advanced Nietzschean philosophy. Maybe it's not all that bad after all. Thanks Natalie. I needed this today.

Elaine Lentz

Hi! I'm highly enthusiastic about the landing of Envy, a wonderful, comprehensive work I'm sure I'll be rewatching for months to come as I have for so many of your videos. I would like however to submit a gentle nudge about the publicizing of your upcoming videos. While I understand it is fairly ubiquitous, not everyone does or want to use Twitter because it's so hard to evade toxicity on the platform. I have noticed neither the trailer or updates regarding the posting date for Envy were posted on patreon and perhaps this is something that might be changed in the future? I don't want to sound demanding or ungrateful, my point is just that I would love to receive the same level of information as a patron as a Twitter follower might get. For your consideration *hat swirling thing* (pardon me for my broken english, I do however tremendously enjoy your attempts at french).

mac stroud

congrats natalie! now take a break!

Audrey B

I'm incapable of listing all the artful ways this video brought me joy, but damn! What I will say is that my brain was firing with the joy of thought the entire time! I left feeling very refreshed and with the will to embrace life. (why yes my skin care routine is in fact listening to Natalie's beautiful brain and face)

Lulzquirrel

After much guessing, what we have is Opulence pt. 2, Cancelling Pt. 2, Justice Pt. 2 and some hecking self affirmation rolled into a youtube make-up video. So, what can one say but YES.

CableKnitWit

It was worth it. I’m sorry it cost you so much. Please take a break- I’ve watched the video and it justified all the effort you put into it. I’ll be sad if you modify your process too much. If your process is incompatible with a consistent regular release schedule, then the thing id compromise on would be the schedule. The process is gold.

carororo

This was so good!! Thank you so much. It's also always interesting to me when I recognize a train of thought in your YouTube videos that you mentioned off-hand in an AMA stream, now with the "full picture". There's so many other things that were amazing but i'll keep it short for now I hope you can take your own advice from the end and get a well deserved rest!!! Or like, at least a nap or something. 💖💖💖💖

Henry Anderson

Congratulations on the video! We understand why it took to long and now we just want you to rest.

Jaq M

Very good thank you

Devany

My favorite video of yours to date! And something I needed to hear right now <3

Yvonne

Congratulations Natalie! I've learned so much from this video.

Equalize

do we predict "temperature" as what "temperature generalizations predict between future contra points" #observed generalizers #observed read=write #observed thought experiments as #observed nonfiction disproves fiction

Alistair Woodcock

The content, style and humor of this video coming together is absolute perfection. I just finished watching and already know I'll be watching it again soon

Camila Steele

Thank you for the film Natalie!! Please go on vacation!

AlanCrow

Next video: a Socratic dialogue with catgirl Spongebob

Aj

Love the vid. Thanks for making it.

Theo Doe

The video so obviously explains the length of time you took to make it, it is definitely the best video you have put out😊

Andrew Sasala

Love you Nat, and I loved the video! You should be so proud of yourself and we’re so proud of you!!!

CodeTako

This was fantastic. Nice job to everyone involved.

Francesca Zadra

Wow, you were looking so Tilda Swinton towards the end there! Brava!

Max Barbee

Thirty minutes in and it’s already just so good. You’re hitting on something incredibly truthful and accurate. It’s like an even deeper dive into multiple previous video topics mixed into one sweeping, comprehensive statement. And your video production skills are better than ever, I love the visual style so far. Hope you’re doing ok, or at least good enough! We, your Patrons, wish for you to now take some time for yourself!

Benjamin Hitov

This is amazing. You are a force for good.

chinmoku

Incredible work! Thank you!

Cloud D'bussy

Definitely one of my favorites. The cat girl muckbaung. Absolutely iconic. My only note is that the speed at which you flash text on screen made me feel like a silly little bimbo that doesn't know how to read. Which might not be entirely untrue.

Branddt1

Thanks natalie that was epic :D

Scott M

Our exhalted and most holy night-Mother has truly blessed us with this GRWM

Aria

Good to see you again, I wondered if you decided to "look for better opportunities"

Cory Capron

This is one of your best videos and I love it just as is. Listening over the June stream and processing the finished work, I can't help but notice that Envy almost could have been broken into multiple smaller episodes. I don't say that as a criticism, just that you can still explore ideas on this scale moving forward without creating 90+ minute videos. Just present chapters as episodes with a little bit of self-containment framing.

Fabia

Great food for thought! ♥️ I believe that life is fundamentaly unfair but we have a hard time coping with the feeling that our lot in life is mostly beyond our control. Some are born powerful, rich and beautiful, some are born weak, poor and ugly. You have done an excellent job analysing the psychology of the downtrodden and I would be very interested in the flipside: the ideology of the powerful (meritocracy, entitlement, "might is right"...). Liebe Grüße 😘

Adam Iaizzi

Excellent work on this one, it was well worth the wait! I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of new content you produce next!

ESP

The video is a masterpiece. Thank you for trusting your instincts and waiting until it was ready to share with us. Deadlines are dumb anyways.

Rachel

All of your hard work has clearly paid off! Congratulations on all your success. Now please take so much time off to relax and be a person (and stream????? Only if you want to but I miss your streams)

ChalkyChalkson

Took two session to get through it, but dang this was great. Especially the music, in the beginning I was already impressed by the jazz, but when you kept using "Also sprach Zarathustra" to lead to Nietzsche my brain started spiralig... I spent a good hour or two thinking about all the parallel of Nietzsches Zarathustra and this videos topic of interest. Darn you youtubers that bait me into learning and thinking about things using art! (and that's despite me having a bit of a distaste for Strauß)

Samantha Rei

Excellent video. Please tell us where your dresses are from, because searching the internet is hard.

Jordan C.

Incredible video! This made me reflect on my own envy excuses start to unpack those habits. Should be required watching for everyone! Thank you so much for your hard work to make this video 🙏

Lexi

*looks at bank balance* *looks at FFS costs [uk]* "Now am I Jealous of Natalie or Envious... hmmm" ❤

Lexi

I was suprised you buried your usual levels of video production behind that long intro on the stairs... Between your video work and Zoe's music its an inspiration to work harder at my own video essays

Onrustig

Excellent! Amazing how much content you go through in under two hours, and how much I now have to think about. I need that gown of Optics Of Envy, who are you wearing?

Andrew Hanson

Mary Antoinette set was incredible. Also, a video concept that draws in Fred, Spongebob, Nyatalie and that much Evil Milf worship is a thing of beauty.

Kathleen

Excited to get to see the video! I am also desperate to know where she got the first dress

Naomi Alderman

ugh this is great. I literally did a gasp of excitement when I saw you'd done a new video. One of the interesting things about the Nietzsche's WORST BULLSHIT about Jews and Judaism is that actual Judaism is a lot less interested in eg "forgiveness" as a moral imperative than Christianity is. Forgiveness + rewards and revenge in the afterlife are *amazing* things for your slave class to believe in, and the version of Christianity that became the state religion of Rome benefited from those beliefs. Judaism by contrast says that forgiveness is a process that can only begin with sincere apology from the person who has acted badly or cruelly toward you. There is no moral imperative toward forgiveness. So there, Nietzsche, yet another occasion on which "Judeo-Christian" really means "Christian and I don't know much/anything about Judaism".

Iana Nelson

The work you put into this really shows! I loved it, but I hope you find your way back to a more sustainable process for your own well-being. I never really thought about (or realized to be honest) the differences between jealousy and envy. And your discussion of your own feelings toward other trans women really opened my eyes about my own feelings towards other trans-women as well. I don't think it's full on toxic envy because I would never want to take away what they have, but my inner child is absolutely crying and yelling, "It's not fair!"

Riley Wildman

This video was GREAT, and a lot of it resonated with me on a personal level. Your points about the left reminded me of Justine in an old video saying something along the lines of, "It's almost like if they don't have actual achievable political goals, then they aren't accountable for anything."

Midramble

Is there a reading list to go along with this video? Got a lot of audible points to spend

Johnni Medina

Maybe your best one yet. I’m been reeling all day and think I’m about to begin my first rewatch already. You’re an amazing human with a beautiful brain and a painfully gorgeous face ❤️

Andrés Urrutia

Though I think this is maybe one of your best videos, I do think you really need to improve your work process ^^''. Maybe you should hire editors, subtitlers, Idk, more people. That's all, I love the video! <3

Melissa B

Here's me focusing on a complete throwaway line, but I think Big Bird might be at least as yellow as Pikachu.

Andre Serpa

I'm just starting my 2nd viewing (this will take many viewings to digest it all) but i profoundly appreciate the amount of research and time you took to explain complex ideas without rushing it. Personally, i was struck by your mention of same sex relationships as i lived this quite strongly during the first year of mine. And this is not easily understood by my straight friends, as the competition aspect is not so strong for them. Loved the Rosebud reference in the beginning, the care for the soundtrack when talking about Nietzsche's Beyond Good and Evil and the amazing aesthetics of the beheaded queen. Really incredible amazing work.

Becky Satathite

Yay! Just in time (almost) for my birthday Aug 6! You're the best!

Eric Davies

I really appreciated the positive aspect of your conclusions since (as you pointed out a few times) the source material can be pretty bleak

Amy Ashlyn

This is the pinnacle 💗 It's amazing!!! Thank you so much. It resonates so beautifully 😍 You are a genius. I have never been so uplifted by any video ever before. True art. True intellect. True being! 💖💖💖

TheTimCaucus

Half wondered if a big flashing “fuck you Nietzsche” card would appear at some point

e ponce

Goddamit that was great. Take care of yourself Nat- you are not the makeup vlogger we deserve, but you are the catgirl Nietzsche we need. <3

GGN

great job gorg ❤️❤️

Kt

Aaand this was worth every second of waiting. Envy was fantastic and I am so happy you took your time to make it just right. ❤️

An actual, flammable witch

I think this is your most powerful piece yet. Your voice and expertise continue to develop and astonish me. Your composition, structure, comedy, and makeup are at their best. I like to think of constructive criticism to put here. I do this because I admire and respect you. I sincerely believe you are in the process of reinventing philosophical discourse. You are wholly unique, and it feels trite to attempt to criticize you. Although, I'll say what everyone's thinking: Pikachu is a bougie sellout, and easily the worst Pokemon. Do you even Wooper, bitch? Pikachu wishes it was Mimikyu, and Mimikyu LITERALLY wishes it was Pikachu. Get it together, Nat. Next time, do your research.

Nick Helf

Me, before you posted: Wow, I wonder what's taking so long, I hope she's okay. Me, after watching the opening montage with all those sets and costumes: Ah, okay, fair.

Jess Johnson

Once again I'm getting cheap therapy from a Youtube video, thanks for making this Contra!

veritanuda

Once again, a sumptuous and compelling video experience. Really Nat you knock it out of the park but boy you really do put all the work in, and it shows it. I am glad I stumbled across you all those years ago and can support you even if it is not much. Trust me when I say I really do appreciate and what you do. *hugs*

Lívia Russi

I can't stop watching. It's so funny, beautiful, clever... and the video, well, is cool. Jk :) Thank you for your hard work Nat

Zackary Kelley

Absolutely incredible, so lucky to be alive at the same time as this genius

KSCHatch

This video took so long to create because it is Perfect.

Kat

A movie quality video produced in only six months during a pandemic? We're spoiled.

David Thornthwaite

This was brilliant and fearless. Thank you! And please don't apologise for the time your videos take to make. I follow your work for its quality.

The Staff of Harmony & Strife

You really nailed the aesthetic and did a lot of really, really beautiful work. Fabulous job. I am really, really proud to be a supporter.

Atar

Loved it

JoyOfResistance

Grüß Gott, Dr Freud here, I can't help but wonder if this video should actually be about addiction - as it feels like envy is a part of the puzzle, but also an essay mask to hide behind. There's a returning interest in people blackpilling themselves that I find especially curious (as I can really see how it relates to addiction), the mention (maybe even envy) of SpongeBob, not for his wild and childlike creativity (as miss Wynn clearly showcases similar talents again and again) but for his lack of self-hatred and self-doubt. Just some thoughts from my Austrian couch. Anyway, I wish you all the best, strength and health - and good luck writing your story 💕

Rachel Muir

Wonderful, Natalie, thank you for all the effort; it was worth the wait. Two thoughts; one, I think you should remove "ex-philosopher" from your page, after having wrestled with Fred on the mat of good and evil, (clearly, and demonstrably, he was licked), and 2), do you ever find it odd/revealing that philosophy often seems to be about emotions and language rather than logic and science? Being a science-y kind of girl, this continues to surprise. Now go catch up on your sleep. RCM

Arlen Guillen

Brava! I'm looking forward to the behind the scenes video for this one.

Lays Guerrero

This video is one of the greatest thing I ever watched.

Moira Tagle

Never heard someone describe the thrill of reading nietzsche after growing up in a christian household so well! I guess that seems very specific but that part really spoke to me! The rest of the video was great too, but, man, I just felt seen!

Aaaaaaaaaaaron1

This is big brain shit, I love this video so much. I've never read Nietzsche and I didn't know that THAT was his assessment. One can see how fascists take that and run with it in spite of Nietzsche's actual message. Does Nietzsche decide that there is value in ideologies born from resentment? How does the story end, did he find true love? I mean, turning the other cheek is better than beheading someone for Mars. We should still practice the clarinet once in a while even as we channel our inner SpongeBob...? Or am I just holding on to the comfort of my own envy-borne squidward sublimations?

Pythos Richthofen

Another fantastically, detailed, and in depth analysis of a vexxing problem for humanity. The use of Sponge bob characters to make a point was nothing short of brilliant. Also, YOUR own honesty about your own situation was quite something to see. You MIGHT find there are cis women that DO like gender non conforming or trans people. Try not to let gender norms compel you when it comes to dating and potential life partners. Again...terrific video. Was very happy to see a video from you as well.

Franc Fernandez

You’re brilliant. Have watched this a couple of times. ❤️‍🔥 Take as long as you need always.

Benjamin Summerour

Thank you so much for this Nyatalie! I've watched the whole thing three times and the makeup finale at least 6. Haha. This is your masterpiece and a culmination of everything you've done. Your work has meant so much to me over the last three years and your message here is exactly what we need to hear in a year like 2021. I also hope that the achievement of this video can finally settle that there's no need to expect a video or a livestream every month. I think that everyone supporting you here only wants to see you thrive and it has never been more evident. We don't expect the greatest artists to pump out a masterpiece every few weeks and you have earned the right to move through this space completely on your own terms. I'm so proud of you and so grateful for all that you've given to the world, thank you gorg. 💖😻💖😻💖😻💖😻💖😻💖😻💖😻

Isabelle Lenore

It was SO good, I know I'm going to watch it many more times. As a fellow catgirl, I especially appreciate Nyatalie's appearance.

Isabelle Lenore

6 months is actually a very fast turnaround time for making an independent feature length film, which this essentially was. I think you shouldn't worry about that, especially because the consensus among your patrons and viewers tends to be that they don't mind waiting for your content. I'm personally very grateful for you and your work!

MyUrsusMaritimus

I am so happy to see you back again. I was worried that you weren't well, and had given up on the philosophy and intellectual analyses. From my own experience of writing, I know that any sort of thorough treatment of a subject really takes it out of you. And I could afford to be boring as fuck, since it was academia and that is kind of the norm anyway. You make your treatices into pieces of art, and I can not even start to imagine the amount of work that goes into it. Respect. Also, you look just stunning. Cosmetics is not something I concern myself with, but I know magic when I see it♥️

Erin Kraus

I just want to say that the video was excellent … your talent is really remarkable… and I hope you give yourself some credit for your overall fabulousness… you’re such an incredible combination of brains, humor, and beauty.. just want to point that out since you have a tendency to dwell on the negatives 😉

floofpants

This was awesome nya!

Kathryn Boschmann

Absolutely loved this video! The research, the breakdown, the jokes, the filming - *chef's kiss*. This quality of work takes a lot time. Hope you're able to take some time to rest and find a system that feels more sustainable! ❤️

a time management skill

Just finished this one! I need to lie down and re-think some life choices, I think

Ana Fernandez

It was worth the 6 months for sure! Much love and well deserved rest!

Alex Wood

I didn't even know I needed this video.

Cosmo

It was so good, I chose to become a patron. All of your videos are absolutely stunning and thoughtful, but this one I will be thinking about and rewatching for a long time

Wissa

I’m still hyped for that ten minute sexuality tangent 👀 but please rest and relax.

KD Kinetic

This was fucking amazing! My friend sent me this video, I had never seen your work, and I was simply blown away. As an artist there were some things in here I really needed to hear. THANK YOU for all of your hard work and dedication.

Logan Rand

So fantastic and well worth the wait. The abrupt entry into (very intriguing well thought out) Spongebob psychology was the best!

Cabra

Absolutely worth the wait. Love the return of over-the-top outfits and settings. Don't get me wrong, the last few videos were still up to snuff, but you had some real inspired moments in this vid. Never thought anyone would sell me on Nietzsche.

Dave Goodwin

Natalie, this video convinced me to become a patron. I enjoyed it so much that I felt guilty for not paying for it and I’ll increase my support when I can afford to. I don’t know if I can put my finger on it exactly, but you came off as more like, the real Natalie in this video, and I was just hanging out in your opulent mansion, enjoying your company, as you forced me to use my brain while making me laugh. Like, the character tropes took a backseat because they have become canon at this point, and we got down to philosophical business in this video, but in such a comfortable setting. Thank you for existing. Thank you for putting your heart into every video that you create. Kurt Vonnegut advised writers to: Find a Subject You Care About, Do Not Ramble, Keep it Simple, Have the Guts to Cut, Sound like Yourself, Say What You Mean to Say, Pity the Readers [watchers]. You somehow put out an almost two hour video that followed all of these tenets. This is mastery of your art form on display. I’ve always admired you for having the strength to be true to yourself no matter what the haters say. You are seriously the most charming entertainer on YouTube and your work is pushing an agenda of what I feel is honest, truthful, critical, yet loving. You are able to tackle these huge subjects in a way that is so entertaining and without stooping to the polarizing, cynical level of so many other public figures seem to feel they are obliged to in order to build their brand. You are truly open-minded and inquisitive in a way only a true Philosopher can be. That you’re able to balance all of this, with being a such a MILF... It is what makes Contrapoints so special to me. ♥w♥

jen

As one biological woman to another (sorry, just really wanted to borrow that line), this was lit. Seriously, your work is outstanding, and I hope you know how much you are appreciated. I like to think your videos are making me a better and more engaged person, but we'll see :p In terms of blending entertainment with deep academic/philosophic/political ideas though, you pretty much nailed it as usual. ♥♥♥

who is counting

I need to say this: I am a bit shocked (and not in a good way) by Natalie's conservative(-ish) turn in this video. I don't really have the time to go into details, but most of the comments seem to be uncritical to say the least. Two digs are particularly terrible (but still funny): the male gaze joke and the ad hominem argument against the deconstructivist academics. Really Natalie? E: not to mention what I take to be the main conclusion of the video that the fight for justice and equality has (some of) its roots in envy.

The Doom Merchant

Finally set aside the time to sit down and watch. Absolutely phenomenal work, you should be proud of yourself. Definitely one of the ones I'll be rewatching numerous times. As groups on all sides of the political spectrum backslide into puritanical hysteria, I think there's a real danger that a failure or refusal to acknowledge negative feelings in ourselves--without, as you said, *endorsing* those feelings--puts us in a position where the sheer force of these negative emotions (envy specifically in this case) poisons us against accepting that any process of change is a series of steps. Demanding that the situation be fixed all at once is even less productive than doing nothing at all, because they tend to have the same outcome: nothing gets done. One can be aware of their envy and turn it into something productive, but denying that it's even there when it IS risks warping your worldview into something impossible to do anything with.

Sabrina Strix

I'm not even sure if a month is enough time to fully respond to this.

Aly

It's funny, we know this was originally supposed to be the sequel to Justice, but to me it's the sequel to Cringe. Envy is the flip side to cringe. Both are rooted in our self concept and an awareness of our place on the social hierarchy. We cringe at those below us, and envy those above us. People we cringe at remind us that we are not at the same place as those we envy (at least in our minds)

space bear

It's wild how Shame, Cringe and Envy all have been released around a time where their themes have reflected some underlying fears, desires and changes I've grappled with. I can't tell you, Natalie, how these videos have helped me as I've come out (to myself and others), started dating, and started examining my own accountability in certain situations. I think you nailed it with your ending, if I understood correctly: at some point, one must take responsibility for one's own brain, and life is too short to spend it envious and afraid. I can see why this video took so long, and had such a personal cost. So happy for you and proud of/for you, thank you for putting your work out there (to say the least) and I really hope you're getting some much-needed rest/being kind to yourself. 🖤

Alice

Your videos always prompt a lot of self-reflection, and this was especially true for Envy. It took a second viewing to sort out everything that got stirred up for me. One thing I feel okay sharing is I’m a femme trans girl, and the first person I ever dated was a butch trans woman. We broke up after a couple months because I had to admit I wasn’t attracted to her; she just was one of the few people on earth I didn’t have to worry about envying. She deserves better than that, and I hope I can risk envying a femme or cis partner I’m really attracted to.

Anders Schröder

Loved the video. I just started reading Nietzsche's Beyond Good and Evil, and literally in the introduction he compares truth to a woman, concludes that no other philosopher had even gotten her, and that he alone is the exception. Basically, he calls himself the only Chad. Very incel fantasy.

Abigail Keyes

The "Ideology of resentment" section? BRILLIANT. The nazar scene? LOVED IT. Nietzsche cat girl? INSPIRED. <3

Diana.H.

The video is wonderful and I've watched it 3 times. It's your best video in my opinion. However, I really, really hope you're taking time for yourself. That was basically a whole movie you wrote and produced in 6 months and that's a really intense rythme. You're a beautiful creator but an even more beautiful soul. Take care of both. Take care of yourself as you would a sister, Sister. Lots of love.

Cake_Break

mmmmmmmm. more piano, please. it helps digest the gluttony of information.

Ken Hall

I completely lost it at her "sliving" cat chow to the strains of Monostatos and his slaves dancing. And then I stopped to think about it and realized Monostatos is a character driven almost entirely by envy. In fact, most of the plot of The Magic Flute is arguably driven by envy. The detail in this video is seriously amazing.

Rebecca Shelley

you are just phenomenal :) keep going, you're doing what you should be doing!!

Olivia Engel

And it is PHENOMENAL. Ive already watched it twice.

Jodie vander Heide

I've watched it 3 times so far and recommended it to everyone I can! Thank you thank you thank you so much for all you put into your videos. I know that you really give your all to the project and that this year / the pandemic have sucked immensely and been really isolating. Take as much time as you need to recover after this one, it's well deserved and we all want you to be well! ❤️

bunny

I can barely sit to watch an average length movie but have managed to watch "Envy" like 3+ times by now!! Everything about this video essay is 100% on point and came at just the right time, for me at least!! Envy is something that I've been reflecting on a ton in my own life and in the world at large and your video came along and put everything into a beautifully presented and hilarious analysis! Before I was like--jealousy seems to be at the root of every ugly thought and every bad thing that i see in myself and others---huh, why?? And then you popped in and broke it all down, gave me a crash course on neitzche and coined the word "squidwardian". *chefs kiss*, truly! Thank you for all you do, i've been a longtime fan and i'm glad to finally support you here on patreon<3

emma

cannot even tell you how many times i’ve seen this as i’ll get to the credits and scrub the mf location slider right back to the beginning. thank you for this.

Samira

I miss you! AMA?! 😜

Robert Bell

Just wanted to thank you for this. I loved the call to a doable personal change at the end. Say yes to it.

Eric Williams

Never forget the real lesson here: “Sluts never did nothing to nobody.” —Natalie Wynn, 2021

Danielle Corsetto

Absolutely nobody should be questioning why this video took as long as it did! How did you EVEN get that magic mirror effect?! Amazing!! Everything about this was so good (and thank you for teasing us by waiting til over halfway through the video to treat us to Nyat). <3

Alejandra Roig

NATALIE INJECT THIS SHIT STRAIGHT INTO MY VEINS. I love your videos so much every time I finish one I immediately want to rewatch, there is just so much good content ❤️

EZ

I've watched this several times and the initial facial expression looks like me watching my crush, lol. I wonder what elements of envy I contain for her. Maybe admiration and awe.

EZ

Note on Jameela Jamil: she's disabled. She has Ehlers-Danlos (although people are trying to spread the idea that she's faking, which, great) so she probably does have actual food intolerances and sleep issues that she's had to address and is relieved that she even managed to address. I have it and am dating someone else with the same disorder (we bonded over it) who was living in a DV household a few years ago, and I felt the same way-- thank god that at least I'm not living under abuse and can maintain my access improvements, because I barely freakin' pulled it off as it is! (And yes, he got away.)