Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey friends!

Nine months in the making, it's finally done!

Whenever I'm working on a video people ask me what it's about. Sometimes it's easy to answer that question. "Envy" is about envy. But this video I've had a hard time summarizing. If I had to say it's about one thing, I'd say it's about desire.

This project began as two separate ideas. One—a video about addiction. Two—what if Plato's symposium, but with lesbians? I can't really explain why I decided to combine them into one video, except that intuition told me to.

This video contains acts one and two of an originally planned three-act video. I decided to shelve the third act because of time constraints—to complete all three acts in a single video would have required at least another couple months of work.

So this video ends on a pretty dark note. It's a video about how Justine gets into her situation, but not about how she, or anyone else, gets out of it. That was the topic of act three, which I might eventually produce, depending on the reception of this video.

I know a lot of people are pretty frustrated with my infrequent uploads. I promise it's not because I'm lazy, it's just that a video like this takes many months to produce. But because of audience frustration, as well as my own exhaustion, I've decided that my next couple videos will be some comparatively minimalistic video essays that I can produce more quickly.

In the meantime, I hope my efforts paid off in this video. I'm so thankful that so many of you have stuck it out and continued supporting me over the months I've been at work on this. As always, hope you like it, and let me know what you think!

❤️❤️❤️

Natalie

Files

The Hunger | ContraPoints

"I spread out my hands to you; I thirst for you like a parched land." –Psalm 143:6 Support this channel: https://www.patreon.com/contrapoints ✿Donate: https://paypal.me/contrapoints ✿Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/contrapoints/ ✿Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ContraPoints/ ✿Website: https://www.contrapoints.com/ ✿Twitter: https://twitter.com/ContraPoints ✿Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPoints ✿ContraPoints Live: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGh4... Check out my other videos: Envy: https://youtu.be/aPhrTOg1RUk J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/7gDKbT_l2us Voting: https://youtu.be/t3Vah8sUFgI Justice (Part 1): https://youtu.be/smQsfNw_7V4 Cringe: https://youtu.be/vRBsaJPkt2Q Shame: https://youtu.be/K7WvHTl_Q7I Canceling: https://youtu.be/OjMPJVmXxV8 Opulence: https://youtu.be/jD-PbF3ywGo Men: https://youtu.be/S1xxcKCGljY Transtrenders: https://youtu.be/EdvM_pRfuFM Beauty: https://youtu.be/n9mspMJTNEY Gender Critical: https://youtu.be/1pTPuoGjQsI The Darkness: https://youtu.be/qtj7LDYaufM

Comments

Morgaine

I've watched this multiple times, and it's caused me to tear up with each watch. This video was so profound and relatable, I think it's your best one yet because of how dark the tone is. As someone who experiences pretty much all of the topics this video touches on, thank you!

Stormbourne

Just wanted to leave another comment on this because every time I watch it again I find something new to love. I think my current favorite thing is that, despite virginia's firm insistence that she has curbed her hunger, that she has fed herself and no longer longs for something to fill her life, inside the person that she's starving to death is howling, screaming, and clawing at the walls. That one took a while to really sink in for me. But she's still hungry. She's still got the hunger too. She's just convinced herself that she's beyond it and above it. But on the inside, she's screaming. Really good. Know this one is quite old now but it's one of my favorites.

Alex Moody

It is unbearably sweet that you want to make shorter videos so you can upload more frequently, just to appease your fans. No one with sound judgment thinks you're lazy!! Stop being so apologetic god dammit. Idk if this is relevant info but I've finally come on board as a patron (instead of throwing you a little money in bigger amount occasionally) after watching The Hunger. You inspire me to create :')

Arica Schuett

Rewatching and I just noticed Virginia's camisole under her lowcut dress. Your attention to detail is remarkable.

RJ Blue

So, when this video came out I remember watching it and thinking “Oh no, I have a feeling this will hit very differently in a few years.” It was a rare moment of clarity. At the time I was in a really difficult place, and although it wasn’t “void”, I was struggling with substance abuse and wasn’t sure how to get out of it or if I even wanted to. I’m now in a much better position — it’s been a year since I decided to even try to change things and a couple months since I last used at all, and oddly a combination of a healthier version of religion/spirituality and acknowledging that my romantic relationship had fizzled out was what helped me get there — and I really credit this video for being one of the first things to reach me in that haze I was in. It was an account of addiction that truly made sense to me and didn’t trigger that sense of shame and defensiveness, and it made me wonder if maybe there was a reason to try finding my way out of that fog in the first place. I’m now encountering The Hunger, the yearning, in a way I hadn’t for quite a few years. It’s a complicated experience, but it’s real, and it’s one I’m so profoundly grateful to know I’m not walking through alone. Part 2 (in the form of the Twilight video) has been so comforting and helpful for where I am right now as well, but this one will always hold a special place in my heart. Thank you for the gift of being super-fucking-vulnerable with us, it means more to me than I could ever convey in a comment. ❤️

Agnes

❤️

Nadia

Wow

Nadia

It’s finally here

Camilo Vargas

00:11 where I am now! Oh dear, Here we go!

Ravennerd

I haven’t been this hyped for a video in a long time. Thank you

Jenna

yay!!! much love 💓💓

stushi

So excited for this

Sean

Omg yay! My boyfriend and I are stuck at home with covid so this is a bright spot in the day for sure ❤️

draugven

Very excited for this! And definitely understandable that the videos take months to produce!

reenng

thank you for all your work gorge <3

Deviant Ollam

We aren't disappointed in you ever, just always hoping that you're happy with things on your end. Thank you for the update and the upload. 💚👍

Grace Carroll

Can't wait to watch this when I get home, you're a legend honestly 💜

C Jose

🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

Seb Jones

Oh. She’s in the bath again 😍

Wangled Teb

OMG anytime I see an update from you in my inbox it makes my day haha can't wait to watch this!

Emily Leonard

Take absolutely as long as you need for these videos!! They’ve got all the glamour and production value of a Baz Luhrmann movie with the added benefit of making people less racist. (And less transphobic. And less shitty on social media. And less radicalized. I could go on.) Hope you treat yourself with as much love and care as you do with your videos. Thank you for everything!

support!

I feel like what you really need is a side channel. Keep the main for historical videos and new longer form stuff. And the second for shorter stuff like snacks. Contrasnacks

Andrei Nicolae

Same. Going to buy chips and cola 0. Screw it.

Carneece

Let’s go girls 💅🏻

Fox E.

Justine’s unyielding irritation is incredible and the whole truth.

Eric Williams

Never rush your work. Quality over quantity!

Jana Temple

Brilliant! Yes, we've all been to Cincinnati.....

CoffeePoints

9 months in the making 😯 the same amount of time it takes to make a human baby

Scoobydoober911

I seriously considered canceling dinner plans to watch this now

Paul Coghill

Really, a steamed hams reference goddammit 🤣

Wangled Teb

Update it was fantastic omg

Lasagna

Just finished and holy fuck this was good. I'm scared the shift to a more narrative-based style won't go down as well with people (I've seen people complain about other creators making a similar turn in their content) but this may be my new favourite Contrapoints video

Kleopatra

I am hyped for the saga of Justine and the Contraverse <3 Beautiful and meticulous work, makes sense this took so long to make!

Pixie Nixx

I'm a sl*t for the void too 🖤 Absolutely loving this so far Mother Void. Thank you, it's absolutely always worth the time it takes you to make these videos.

Cozzy

Natalie, i just finished the video. I don't know if you read these but if by chance you do, I hope you understand this was art. Pure and simple. This was such an uncomfortable yet brilliantly poignant way to portray addiction. You raised levels of empathy within me I didn't think I have. I know I'm bordering on parasocial but please never think just because you're by yourself filming and editing in your home that it's anything other than art and an AMAZING accomplishment that you should he immensely proud of. This level of quality of production and storytelling just doesn't exist on this platform, period. (At least I've not seen it). You touch the hearts of millions with your stories and I for one am grateful for your art and lessons. Congratulations on a great essay and hope you're getting a much deserved break.

Hannah K

Just finished too, you knocked this out of the park. ❤️

King Scene

Oh no it's partly about addiction where you're probably coming from a similar place to me and that is the problem <3

Jonathan Lum

WHAT THE FUCK HOW DID YOU MAKE THIS I LOVED IT BUT NATALIE ARE YOU OK?????? THIS WAS WORTH THE WAIT. TAKE ANOTHER YEAR FOR THE NEXT VIDEO I DON'T CARE WHAT THE FUCK?????? GOATED SLAY GORGE 666

The3rdMonocleThisWeek

Excellent video. I think it might need a flashing lights warning tho?

Laura Dowd

Just finished. Absolutely incredible. And the imagery bowled me over!

highclass_lady

Just finished watching, what a chilling but truthful portrayal of addiction so far, thank you so much for making such art ❤️

Sara Arpagaus

Just finished the first, of what i am sure will be many viewings. I love your videos and the style, which, honestly puts some stuff they do in hollywood to shame. But mostly, i love the courage you show in each and every one of your videos to tackle..the darkness! I hope Justine gets out of that dark place..it's the video in which i liked her best ;) But i am also looking forward for some more easier essays, because after all is said: i like to listen to what you think, wether you want to give it straight or in art!

Jessica Cheeri

Wow! That was an amazing video! I can see why you were concerned about the color and light levels this morning because that was vital to the visuals (I've always admired your light/color work anyway and it keeps getting better) This is part of why Justine is one of my favorite characters of your cast (Tiffany being the other). She always feels like someone who has so much inner conflict; probably everyone's got something going on inside they don't really want to talk about, but that's what makes people interesting Congratulations! This was fantastic and I'd love to see more of Justine's story

Rosie Shotton

this uploaded while I was in the club and me and my friend chanted 'natalie' to the rhythm of 'I wanna love you' by Akon lmao;.... will watch the video when I wake up, bet its brilliant

Marcin Wierzbicki

Amazing video. I'd love to see the cultural background&politics&country as one of the factors of addiction as cope explored more - only when I left my home country for a less conservative one I feel more like a human and stopped smoking cigarettes, for example. Love your vision.

Whatever

Congratulations. Your video was exceedingly good. Also, the visuals and editing were fantastic.

PupperoNova

Damn. What a video to digest. A brilliantly artistic way to show the exhaustion of modern discourse, along with the relief to the pain many of us feel that is, in itself, incredibly destructive. The dialogue did a fantastic job illustrating the BS of “free speech” dialogue and how ridiculous it is for a political majority to claim that anything that goes against their words is threatening their right to speech. And just how fucking EXHAUSTING it is to exist in that dialogue for long periods of time without reprieve. I hope you are okay Natalie, you’ve been open about struggles with addiction in the past and I think a lot of your audience probably has struggled as well.

Matt Close

Yay new video! 😎✌🏼🖖🏻🤘🏻🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️

Kaleb Collins

Natalie, this video is truly artistic and beautiful and creepy and deeply devastating, but in all the wonderful ways. I can see how personal the last act of the video is and i hope you continue this story bc i think it's really impactful. Excited to see where you go next, i am on board. Love ya

Jana Temple

I'm going to be watching this quite a few times, I'll bet... Brilliant work and the timing is good for the US political climate. Dark because it is absolutely necessary. Bravo, love you...

Andrew L Butula

I absolutely loved the video! Aside from the insight which, obviously, the podcast may have been your funniest piece of writing yet, and as someone who's had my own issues with addiction the second half really hit hard, and is going to stick with me for a while. That said, Natalie? May I call you Natalie? "I've decided that my next couple videos will be some comparatively minimalistic video essays that I can produce more quickly." I look forward to your next Cannes worthy film, tentatively scheduled for Q1 2023 and will happily continue to support your Patreon in the interim.

Ray

I loved it. Thank you Mother.

Ashton

Very amazing editing, beautiful visuals

Dawn Anthes

I’m finding it difficult to put into words what I’m feeling right now after watching that. That was beautiful and painful in all the right ways. Thank you for that.

Addi_Oh

Time well spent 💙

Al

this was by far your best work, even better that envy. And the Jackie Jackson parts had me roaring with laughter

Rachel Quin

Someone once said that art can only be art if it serves no purpose other than its own existence. You dance on the knife's edge between art and the dialectical. I am in awe, Ms. Wynn.

Serena

when u release a vid it is as exciting 2 me as when beyoncé released her self titled album unannounced

Ted(dy)

you’ve outdone yourself yet again. im 2/3rds through my second watch

Chris Bowers

A wonderful video with a mix of some elevated production skills (lighting, editing) and some of the best talking-heads dialogue thus far Natalie. Not only do I hope you create a third (synthesis?) chapter to this but I applaud you for pointing how exhausting being a contemporary leftist is. I hope you enjoy much needed rest even as I hope to see your future work. Brava.

Pepper

beautiful video. really, truly looking forward to hearing more from you on addiction.

Kate

Immediately thought of Florence and the machine when I saw the title of the video. “We all have a hunger” “I thought that love was in the drugs But the more I took, the more it took away And I could never get enough” Really though, amazing acting and a horrifically accurate depiction of addiction and how everyone fills the emptiness and shame they feel in different ways. This one resonated with me personally being that I am a lesbian who grew up in a hyper religious family and I still struggle with the overwhelming shame and self loathing even years after being away from that. The character Virginia reminds me of the women in videos my mother would send me of “ex-gay” testimonies in hopes that I would become that. I am glad every day that I decided to not live a lie. As for the addiction focus of this video, I had a hard day yesterday and took a fuckload of klonopin after having been “California sober” for over a year and woke up to this video dropping. Kinda needed this rn thank you.

Dave L

That was really good.

BC

Yes please on a part three…and also yes please on taking as much time as you need to make the magic happen and take care of u. 💜✨

Ba Tran

mother this is beyond amazing

Ryan Storey

I love that we finally a ContraPoints-styled takedown of the phony evangelicals who cloak their bigotry behind "love the sinner, hate the sin" bullshit. It drives me absolutely mad. I'd rather these people just call me a f*ggot and be honest. But appropriating the aesthetics of compassion while telling me that they're "praying for my eternal soul", and that they hope I'll be "saved" and repress every part of my being so that they don't have to be reminded that queer people exist... It's so fucking patronizing, and a lot of them just don't get that.

The Spiral Lab

I'm just here to support you. I love your work. but for me anyway, this isn't transactional. You make what you want to make, when you want to make it, and I just want to offer my small contribution to help make it possible. I hope you are ok. ❤️🌀

Joseph

Fuck yes. This is such a great time, and halfway through the video, a great video I specifically needed to see!

Stormbourne

I grew up in an environment I still sometimes hesitate to call a cult even though in every way that matters, most people believe (justifiably) that Mormonism is a cult. The level of anguish it caused me when I lost my faith was intense and painful, and it's easy to see how an environment like the one America cultivates, of being constantly reminded of inadequacy and sin, being told you're a loathsome being just for existing and you're lucky god will take pity on you, can lead to a spiral like the one in this video. Even for the people who aren't being told that their love or gender is a sin .... but especially for those of us who are. The Florence song has been mentioned, but there's one about religion called "Poor Issac" that closes with the line "I don't know if there is water, all I know is there's a thirst," and that's what the video reminded me of in the first half. The human thirst for meaning and purpose, for connection, for everything to have a reason and to be able to just go forward knowing someone else has things in hand, or not thinking at all. I hope you're doing well, and I'd love to see an act 3 if you decide it's in the cards. Thank you for the video.

Tasha J

I'm not here to expect things on a timeline. Your stuff is just awesome and I want to support pretty videos that say important things. And as someone who is horribly depressive and is impossible at relationships, yeah, this spoke to me (even as a cis-gendered straight woman.)

Lexi

Just finished and it was so stunning. Can’t say anymore until I watch it 3 or 4 more times. And while I love any and all content you put you, I do not mind the longer waits for videos. No one is doing it like you. I’ll wait as long as I need too.

Mazen

💕💕

Branovices

Felt personal and even hard to watch sometimes, but also well done and with trademark humor even through the pain. Watched it with a friend and we discussed it a lot. Love your work, Natalie! Please take care of yourself too though ❤️

Danosaurus.

Brilliant insight and wit as usual, but uncomfortable at points because it's truthful and identifiable to me. Thank you again Miss Wynn!

Joe Johnston

Amazing video. I was worried that the lack of new videos was caused by personal distress because that is the way of this naughty world. Bowie may an art project of his mortality and this feels like a work in the same vein.

Woody Sims

Natalia Wynnfred. You are a filmmaker. Most of your videos have been feature-length films that you have made pretty much by yourself end to end. They are going to take a long time. I can’t stop the assholes complaining about time between uploads, but I can tell you I will be contempt sitting back and letting you do what you do. Keep making great things like this. I will be waiting patiently for whatever wonderful, thoughtful, and beautiful thing you put out next.

Robert Daniel Pickard

You're a goddamn genius. Like if Cronenberg made movies about real problems

Rupour

This was such a unique and special video. I really want to see a conclusion to this. Even though I've never struggled with addiction, this video really spoke to me. All of the little details came together to form something beautiful. Even the very last thing in the video, the Picardy third chord, can be viewed as a longing for hope in the context of the narrative. Seriously, great work!

Nolan Segrest

No, this wasnt autobiographical... not even a little.

Aristana Scourtas

This video shook me and I am still talking about it with my partner. Thank you so much for all of the energy and immense effort you put into this work of art. A third installment would be phenomenal.

Cassie Dee

oh no it hurts. I love it.

Jordan C.

Can’t wait to curl up with a glass of wine and get into this tonight! I always learn so much from your videos, and I’m sure this one will be no exception. Thanks for all the time and care you spend to make such excellent content! It is well worth the wait.

Chris Perez

I was honestly sobbing throughout the second act... That was beautiful Nat. Also your production design and editing has always been incredible but this was just on a-whole-nother level. I'm extremely proud to support your work in the little way that I can right now

Eric J

Yaaay waking up to this feels like Christmas! Can’t wait to watch!

Sarah Manthey

I don't know about less radicalized. I can hope she makes the regressives less radical. But Left-Tube has made me less of a centrist, in the direction of the left.

Lauren Michelle

Light and fluffy this was not, (though not without humor) but damn... What a powerful piece of filmmaking. Dark and moving, and thoughtful. As someone who has experience with addiction I felt this in my bones. Thank you Natalie.

Frankie

You have a really incredible way of making experiences that are completely foreign be something I feel I can almost understand. This video, Tiffany Tumbles, and your old Gender Dysphoria video all managed to create a real empathetic connection for me beyond what any other creator has ever managed. I was glued to the screen completely breathless for the second act. There's an incredible degree of authenticity to it, in a way that lets me understand addiction far more than I ever did before. Amazing work as always!

Sarah Manthey

That was a really hard watch. Too real. Far too real. Impressive, powerful, caring. And too real.

D.A.R.

Unsolicited but well meant criticism: Lucy's lines were hard to hear; maybe a voice-over or whatever they call it when the actor lip-sinks her own lines?

Joel Keene

The second act is really hard to watch, shockingly beautiful but way way too real

D.A.R.

I always assume you don't read these, anyway, and, frankly, I probably wouldn't either. But I appreciated it more on a second viewing. Yes, lesbians arguing in The Symposium, is clever. Is the second act something along the lines of Augustine's Confessions, only backwards? I posted a pic of Joni Mitchell's "Blue" on Twitter, because this is obviously a more, um, nakedly personal work. Maybe that's why Act III didn't get completed yet?

Tall Jeff

My dear my darling one, the wages of sin is death, but it’s good work if you can get it.

The Doom Merchant

Man. Intense, artful, thoughtful, painful. Incredible.

David Baraboo

this is so worth the wait, v v v v v good, best to date

Tall Jeff

Quote the Spartans, “If”

Lսсу

Wow. Compare this to Tiffany Tumbles, and see how far you’ve come. Also, you’re practically making movies at this point, and filmmakers don’t put out movies in nine months even with an entire crew, whose names in the credits number as many as your patrons.

Dave L

That last line from Psalm 143, "And in Thy mercy cut off mine enemies, and destroy all them that harass my soul; for I am Thy servant." Well played, Natalie.

Sophie

This was so beautiful and heartbreaking. You are so talented.

Nick Desrosiers

Holy shit. This goes so far beyond a youtube video or essay, this is a film. If its to get stuff of this caliber, keep taking your time its worth it.

stushi

Not sure if you'll read this, but. Man. Wow. That 2nd half. That was a work of cinema. It is immediately clear why this took as long as it did, and it is astounding to me that you did it all by yourself. At the same time, it felt so raw and personal that I completely understand why you maybe felt like you HAD to do it all by yourself. I'm glad this exists, I'm glad you exist, and I'm glad that within my otherwise seemingly meaningless existence I get to experience such meaningful works of art. Thank you, and looking forward to part two, whenever it may come.

zandy

Holy hell, the editing on this video is incredible

S. R.

This touched me very deeply. I am reflecting on my own experiences, and this is what I think. When the void between humans feels insurmountable, don't think Classical. Think paleolithic. Turn to the wolves. Justine should adopt a puppy.

Stormsdream

Haunting and wonderful. Take as much time as you need to create videos. I hope you continue to make the things that interest and haunt you in whatever form they take, taking as much time as they need.

Crescent Minor

I didn't use tonight. It's the first time in a while. I feel safer than I have in a while. I'm not going to hurt myself.

Gian Balangue

Absolutely gorgeous, and definitely worth the wait with the amount of writing and performahnce and of course editing that went into this. I really hope we see Act 3!

Crescent Minor

Mm ... I hate to be skeptical at the suggestion of an animal's love. But, struggling to take care of yourself while also being responsible for someone else's life is, take it from an addict with a special needs pet, possibly very anxiety-inducing.

Daphna

Incredible. I think probably the best one atm

Will E.

i mean this from the bottom of my heart and as someone who has watched your videos repeatedly, this is your masterpiece and I hope you are incredibly proud of it. it’s something so impactful that I will had a hard time watching it casually like I can do with some of your other videos. I was and still am deeply impacted by it and i am so grateful you have decided to share your body of work with us.

S. R.

You're right, and getting a dog was actually super anxiety-inducing for me! But I don't only mean the love is what helps - I mean the whole package of a shared life and bond. It forced me to get out of bed in the morning to feed and potty her, go outside 2-3 times a day for walks, take better care of myself because I was responsible for her, clean my house so she wouldn't eat something bad, and think about the next ten years or so of my life because she'll be alive about that long. So it turned out to be a productive kind of anxiety, which is already one step above the void. I know this wouldn't work for everyone. If you really think you couldn't take care of an animal and/or it'd be abused in your situation... Then no, do not get an animal. But I also think avoiding responsibilities and connections to the world when you struggle to take care of yourself isn't the best route either. We need tethers to the world. And so, if you're already looking to philosophy and history to find answers regarding meaning for your life, I just wanted to put out there that "befriend dog" has been an important connection for our species for tens of thousands of years.

Evan

natalie, this is one of the best videos you've ever made. i was one of those fans that was unhappy with infrequent uploads, but now i feel like booboo the fool because a video of this quality takes time. i get that now. make what you want to make, i'll be supporting you all the way

Carl Pyrdum

Not gonna lie, while I was thinking about whether the subaltern can speak, I also was kind of thinking that beer from a Starbucks venti plastic cup is a baller move.

Gabe

Thank you for sharing so much with the world. Even though my situation is different from yours I'm seeing some similarities that make me feel less alone and that makes it easier. I wish you all the best and that you find comfort.

Efi C

God, I've really missed Justine!

BexNeko

Act 2 really hit home with me, I hope that at some point in time you feel ready to make Act 3. The lighting and set design in this gave serious Lynchian vibes throughout and as Act 1 transitioned to Act 2 it made a lot of sense. Thank you Natalie and I hope your health problems get better

Ugooo

You should be proud Natalie, as other people said, it's a masterpiece. Take the time you need and be kind with yourself 🙂. I'll always happily wait, I know it's always worth it =)

Drewwww

Such a cathartic, moving masterpiece. felt so much empathy for myself and for anyone else struggling with addiction and shame. love your videos so much!

Carl Pyrdum

Though, also... intense desire for the fake women Contrapoints pretends to be.

Sergio Augusto

I defs appreciated the freshness of this being more of a performance and not another essay (though of course I love those, you're brilliant at them). In the "lore" of Contrapoints characters who is Justine supposed to represent? Is that the persona closest to Natalie? Anyway, it was very well performed. Some imagery was funny rather than scary...but some of it was really striking and disturbing as well. I also wish we had better audio for Lucy's dialogue. The last bathtub scene was very heartbreaking and just excellently done. I'm sad that you're leaving Justine in this very dark cliffhanger, though it's very effective. I hope when it feels right to you we can see her redemption in Act 3.

Grace Carroll

So many things that I love about this video. - the musical leitmotifs from previous videos throughout when the topic leant in that direction - nat's ACTING, genuinely so brilliant - Jackie Jackson I mean, need I say more - a painful and brilliant representation of addiction - the costumes on absolute point 👌 - the set design as always

Cameron

This video was incredible Natalie. Happy I've stayed on as a patron for so long. I'd go so far as to say it's your masterpiece. Going forward though I do think it might be better for everyone if you do some easier content for the rest of this year, at least. I can easily see how this became such a mammoth task to make, given how utterly dense it is. I'm glad to hear that you are thinking that way.

Nando Rossi

I can’t wait to watch this. NGL, I was one of the people getting frustrated (as someone supporting for years) but I get it. Supporting your work means funding projects with a long timeline. Maybe more concrete previews would help us feel better as stakeholders… More minimal essays that produce faster are welcome & a good idea too, but I hope they don’t replace the mega-productions :)

Christine Valentine

Wow! Unfortunately, this gift "presented" itself to me when I was? Eh? Like one and a half "sheets to the wind" plus a little herbage. I only could process about 23%, but sooo looking forward to watching it many, many times more. That unprocessed 77% is going to be wonderful when I get there...I have no doubt. Thank you

Paul Reece

Your videos are so timely to my own life it’s scary. Wish I had some advice to Justine but I’m kinda in the same boat 😅

Yousuf Kazmi

The Hunger Act 3 to join Justice Pt2 in Contra Lore. Talking of Law, Supreme Justice Nyatalie to preside over the judgment and rehabilitation of Justine in Act 3 ? The new video hits it's targets well, but I think it was also very a cathartic one to make for Nat. Now back to the Livestreams & AMAs! :) (when mentally recharged)

ingerfieee

i've never seen anything quite like this and i'm completely blown away. it was definently worth the wait, you're great

Simon-Nagy Gabor

Wonderful video, so beautiful! Absolutely worth the wait.

Julschi

Wow, this video hit hard. Love it. Beautiful.

Diego

The parallelization of erotic love and spirituality, as means to fill our yearning for something meaningful was very interesting for me. It seemed to me like The Void functioned as an aid for the lack of that fulfillment that neither romantic partners nor god can truly compensate. It left me sad, but deeply touched and thinking. I loved that you managed that through the expansion of Justine's character. I had not at all anticipated, that the video would suddenly turn from a dialogue oriented essay to an artful short film about addiction. That unexpectedness kind of triggered a heavy emotional reaction for me - and I love that you did something so narrative driven here. I'm intrigued by Justine and I would love to see how her story could continue.

Raoul (just me)

this felt very personal, yet you made it also entertaining ('are those clothes even yours?'). the music, especially the piano was wonderful. sign me up in the church of Sappho please. great work

Laura Wiman

Wonderful - I particularly like open discussion of shame. I find that shame gets inherently underrepresented in most conversations (shame is the thing you don't talk about) so I always appreciate that about your angle. Some outstanding shots in this video too. Also looking forward to shorter vids, I don't want the work I support be unreasonably difficult to make ~

An actual, flammable witch

Are you smoking, young lady? Totally unacceptable! What would I even do with myself if you got sick? Are you trying to kill me? I would die of grief. Is that what you want, your poor, old patron dying of grief? For shame! I didn't raise you in a purely satirical sense just to have you run off and get the black lung. Promise me you'll quit.

Naomi Hatchman

Jackie's antics really cracked me up!

An actual, flammable witch

Your aesthetic and humor fulfill a proverbial hunger of mine that I can't express how much I appreciate. I genuinely love you for the unique, intelligent, and beautiful person you are. (Strictly parasocially, of course.) Never once was I frustrated with the time it took. I trust you and your vision because they are genuine, delightful, and so incredibly rare. I can't wait for the next 16 hours to be released. I hope it's just footage of you eating and drinking with acrylics on.

Furkan Kurtulus

Girl please get some rest and then leave the house! Love your work❤️

Martin Tepper

No pressure or expectation from my side for any kind of schedule, happy to just throw money at you and leave you to it ;)

Opinionated Online

Honestly, this might be the best video that you've ever done. It feels like a legit movie. Even though it's heavy, I can't wait to watch it again!

Laura Audet

This was so harrowing and moving that I stared at the screen for about 5 mins after it ended. Thank you for this incredible piece of filmmaking. The cinematography, lighting, music and sound are pure art, and everything about it is so hauntingly raw and beautiful. Not only that, but it feels like a lot of personal experience and past pain went into this. All of these things together make it a masterpiece. ❤️

Diana.H.

Great video, again. The format was a bit less engaging to me but I really liked the content and enjoyed the deep dive into religion as a band-aid for shame. The cinematography's getting better every time. And so are the wigs.

Wissa

I was startled by how good the scene transitions were, especially involving the glass of void.

Derek Bayne

This was spectacular. As a humble $2/mo patron, I can assure you many of us have no problem waiting for content like this. Please give us the conclusion! There are so many questions!

Stephanie Eller

This new video is AMAZING. I hope you make the third act someday soon. I also think art just takes time. You shouldn’t apologize for that. What’s that Miracle Max quote? “You hurry a miracle, you get lousy miracles.”

Rachel Anne

No wonder its taking you so long. You aren’t making “YouTube videos” anymore. You’re making art films which you distribute on YouTube. Attempts to discuss “The Hunger” in terms of its “arguments” or “entertainment value” must both fall flat. This is something else altogether.

Irina Culic

Thank you! Stay healthy and take good care of yourself! Yes, do the continuation when you feel right about it.

Rakuen9

When I heard you say that this was your best video to date I was a bit skeptical, because Envy set such a high bar, but after watching it several times today, I am getting more and more of the nuances, and you were right of course. I can't say how much I appreciate your humour when discussing very difficult topics and the mess of emotions I feel when laughing out loud sometimes. I am curious about act 3, and will be looking forward to watching it if and when you make it. Also, my 5 $ a month contribution isn't much, but it's given as a thank you for all your work thus far and not as an expectation of future work. I hope you can find a way to be more satified with your output, but as a viewer, I don't mind the wait. Your videos are full of so much things to process and I find myself rewatching stuff from years ago, not because there's no new content, but because they are so full of ideas that I need to revist internally myself. Thank you for the video! It's great!

Josh Sanders

This was an amazing watch, but it was also difficult. I wasn't prepared for some of the arguments and how accurate if felt to things from my real life. So well produced, writen, and acted. These videos always challenge me, but they are completely worth it. Thank you for the video. However, it's time for some fluffy cotton candy for emotions.

Mars

Long time watcher, first time patreon. This was an incredible video and I really appreciate that you are pushing the concept of a “YouTube video” into something with film-level production, acting, writing, etc. these aren’t “video essays”. They are films, at least in my eye. I love that you are “presenting” aspects of these themes with characters and story. This lends to more inner thought and insight, at least for myself. All this is to say, great work! I’ll keep watching your works no matter how long they take to make, and I don’t know why it took me this long to become a patreon. P.S. if you decide to do some more “Contrapoints Live”, I’ll gladly tune in :)

Elly Button

Thank you for all your hard work, Natalie. The care and integrity you uphold in your essays and presentations have resonated with us for so many years. This one in particular struck a chord with me, as I've been battling an addiction in the wake of losing my mom at a young age in a very traumatic way. The hopelessness of being unable to connect and communicate with others during my grief has mirrored the struggle of meaningfully conversing with those in America who value their fellow man below all else, but it's times like these we end up having to work the hardest. Thank you for reminding me that we are all in this life together and have the power to overcome the darkness within and without. Please remember you make a positive difference in so many people's lives, no matter how the pressure may make you feel like you don't do it enough. Okay, sorry for the soapbox! Continue on, my dear! 🥰

Trip Wootten

I'm subbed here because my partner and I love what youre doing and we want you to continue making the content you want to.

Mel Vitta

I think this is one of your most challenging videos in a while. I'll be honest I wasn't sure how I felt about it at first, it was a lot. I see this as much more of a personal art piece than an essay, which is great. I'm here for that, if you want to focus more on making videos as art rather than what you've been doing for the past few years, that's great. Definitely looking forward to the next part.

Marije

I just can't stress enough how incredibly much I appreciate you and honestly all of your videos. Became a patron since the J.K. Rowling video because I almost dare say looking forward to watching that one is what saved my life. Thank you so much. Your new film really gives me a lot to think about and it was so captivating that I just thought it would never end and I wouldn't be able to stop staring at the screen - it was really powerful and I look forward to the next part.

John Voigt

A masterpiece, simple as

Srachachacha

However long it takes it takes. I’m always happy to watch what you create. This one is haunting.

Jordan Frisbie

I was like of course she releases this in middle of my friend's wedding so I can't watch lol Absolutely loved the visual effects in this work of art. Also is Justine trying be an "Ice Cold Motha****er" from your video talking about you have be cool when you're angry in debate? It was pretty fun especially to see SUCH a transformation of the character from her last collapsing display lol

Eevea

This video came at such a good time for me. I was raised a repressed queer “son” of a preacher. Always too scared to say anything and buying into the idea, like Virginia, that I just had to bear the cross of my transness and bisexuality and “trust god” to get me away from the temptations. Eventually I got away from the church in my late teens early 20s. Lately I’ve had to be around my conservative family a lot the past month due to a family emergency and almost losing my dad. Being around them and seeing their judgment of my “lifestyle” had me looking for Christian answers to myself again. I could feel myself wanting to be part of their world again to be loved by them again. Then back to forming “Christian” arguments in favor of being who I am. In short it’s been a roller coaster I decided to get off literally on Friday. Seeing this video at this time in my life really helped me. I was Virginia as a teen. Self hating and brainwashed. I could have continued to be her for so much longer, but I’m so glad I didn’t. I live happy as myself, a trans woman, with a loving partner and a loving dog family. I’m happier than I’ve ever been. Thank you so much for this video, Natalie. It’s my favorite video you’ve done. I was literally in tears watching it the first time after what I’ve gone through this past month and in my life.

lead sharp

I had to be a patron after that.

BorisS

Great video and probably the best of the dialogue ones that you've done. Would love to see part 3 at some point.

Iana Nelson

It's a raw and powerful piece! The first act was hard for me as a trans woman listing to all of that rhetoric from Jackie and Virginia. Justine said some powerful things but as in the real world it got buried under the avalanche of nonsense from the other two. And yet I couldn't help but laugh at the absurdity of it all! Jackie constantly opening new food and drink items amused me way more than it should have. Then the second act hit, and boy was that painful to watch for entirely different reasons. I could feel the pain and desperation coming off of Justine in waves and I hurt for her.

Moonie Bonzo

Thank you so much for this video, without oversharing on your forum, this touched on so many issues I've been dealing with my entire life in many ways and I just feel seen and understood. I hope you feel the love of your fans, because this video is such an accomplishment. I hope you make a part 3 one day!

Ted(dy)

the problem with this is that social media consultants right now will tell you this is a bad idea - you shouldn’t separate your audience. everything should be in one place. im not sure the same rules would apply to Natalie but it’s something to think about

Zackary Kelley

Dude you’re the best, thanks for sharing your genius with us !

Ted(dy)

the return to character dialogue, in my opinion, is the best decision she’s made in years. the video was genius. I think it might change things for her. I think more people will watch this one

Ted(dy)

yes yes yes

Sy Lindberg

You make movies. Of course it takes months to make a movie

Ted(dy)

i feel the same way, it’s fucking uncanny how every video she releases somehow is right on track with what i happen to be dealing with at the moment. im so grateful for her work

peter annear

Thanks so much for this work Natalie. It engaged and moved me very deeply. I completely understand the desire to touch a higher plane whether spiritual, love, pleasure, pain or intimacy. And.. of course when that all crashes down, chemistry. Justine tore my heart out in this one, Jackie and Virginia each touched my experience too. It's so hard to balance such a brutal exchange. I've watched this twice and will watch many more times. There is more. Thank you for the kindness and beauty in your work. I hope you are ok and taking care of yourself after this gruelling journey. Much love <3

kaybeezeey

This fucking rules, Natalie - congrats on all your hard work on this awesome work of art!

Cai

Allow me to add myself to the pile which says: no frustration here. Your work is so interesting and produced with such care. I want to support you to make the things you want to make, as you want to make them. I don't support the grumpiest segment of audience to grump at you. Also, this video made me sad. So to totally undercut what I just said, I would like to see a part 3.

Aaryn S. Ricucci-Hill

I am upping my subscription because if that's what it takes to complete the third part it's worth it. This piece was something that struck a chord with me and hard. I'd love to see how Justine comes out the other side as maybe that would inspire hope for the rest of us.

Andrew May

I am pretty unsettled by this, but I like that kind of unsettling. I am regularly floored by your work and stand in awe of the catharsis you craft. It's so deliciously complicated. That's why I joined here. You have—here but throughout your oeuvre—helped me better appreciate how theater (and art in general as a human endeavor toward meaning) is so fundamentally, deeply, messily, frustratingly meaningful. You don't shy away from the skeletons that many of us would rather keep in our closets; you're pulling up the rug and asking why we've kept all we're swept there. This piece in particular made me go back to watch other dialogue videos to study how you've continued (completed?) this arc. It's a gorgeous evolution, and there's much to discover yet. I'm unnerved by this confrontation with suffering, but I'm also feeling more whole and human and alive in having participated in what you've created and shared. You've given me much to contemplate and reflect on. Thank you for this; I can't wait to see how act III turns out.

Zac Kenney

I really hope you do end up producing act three eventually! It’s incredible. A cerebral roller coaster that tackles the “groomer” accusation, conversion therapy, addiction (and by extension faith-based recovery programs), and one of my favorite subjects, libertarian podcast hosts being big dumb dumbs. I’m hooked. I must know how this ends. I love the essay format too though and can’t wait for the quickies in the mean time. I’m just glad you’re taking your time and uploading what you want when you want. Adore you lots Natalie.

Harry mann

Absolutely visually stunning, quietly confronting, and still good for a laugh. Enjoyed every moment.

Grace Carroll

I've now watched this video four times. I can't say I fully understand all of it yet, but as someone who hasn't had the experiences this video explores, I feel like it's important for me to keep trying. As a former classicist I am loving the Anne Carson influence on the lesbian symposium - the fragmented, partial absence of the LGBTQ+ community in classical texts is bittersweet in itself. I feel like part of the brilliance of the dialogue is that justine is absolutely correct, but it seems as though she is losing the argument, purely because love and desire defy reason (and religion can be used as a way of reasoning love, especially same sex love, out of existence). I find the second act difficult to watch because I know that Natalie has struggled with addiction and it feels like a very raw representation of those feelings. However, it's not that I don't understand or empathise, it's more that I'm struggling to thematically connect the first and second acts (perhaps because I have been in a gay relationship, but I have not experienced addiction). I'll be interested to hear more from Natalie in the next AMA. She continues to be the most sophisticated creator on this platform and a person for whom I have nothing but respect and admiration. And it goes without saying, but this piece is so so incredibly aesthetically captivating. Looking forward to my next rewatch 💜

Leau Grégoire

Dialing it back for a while sounds like a great choice, I can't begin to imagine what it's like to create productions of this scale and quality on a regular basis. Forget the frustrations of the audience, we want you to take care of yourself and rest! Honestly I think it might be good if you WERE lazy. I'd happily wait a couple years for a video if it meant you'd take it easy on yourself. stop crunching, gorg. As for The Hunger - I’ve been ravenously devouring your videos ever since a friend introduced me to you via Telegram Nyatalie stickerpack, and this one might just be my new favourite. You’ve dazzled me. The tradwife cosplay. The horror TV. The sublime lightning in every single shot that makes me want to cry because it’s so wonderfully colourful yet it feels so somber. Lucifer preying on vulnerable women in bathrooms. I could go on and on. Oh, I do so hope you eventually produce the third act! I need the catharsis! You simply cannot take my hand and walk me into this dark pit only to leave me there by myself - forever! Woe! I'm hungry, mother. Always hungry. also i want to make a justine/lucifer edit and i could really use the extra footage u__u

ts_babyjane

this vid is great. excited for video essays tbh. excited for patreon amas i love just hearing you talk about everything

Catherine Clavering

If you want to take 9 months to make something intensely complicated that makes me cry, I'm alright with that. I'd like to see part 3 at some point but it seems like it would be a lot of emotional labour.

saltkettle

Hi Natalie, I just wanted to thank you again for the incredible work you continue to share. I'm floored that you regularly produce multiple feature length art films per year with such a small team. As someone who has worked on films and knows a bit about what it takes to make them, I'd be happy to subscribe monthly to like, one of these every two years, so I hope you never feel pressure from my direction to continue at this mad pace. I hope that you're able to take breaks, and go on vacations, and live your life, and that your art enriches your life instead of consuming it. I do worry about you quite a lot. I hope you have fun making your video essays and I look forward to watching them. I don't know if enjoyed is the right word for my reaction to this video, but I did burst out laughing when Justine asked if the run away lover was a Capricorn. A Hit! I think it was incredibly vulnerable, and am honestly curious if youtube videos can be submitted for like film awards? It's an incredibly compelling portrayal and at the cliffhanger I was like, someone needs to go help Justine, she's in danger. Anyway, it was an interesting combination of topics, which I think is a really good lens to look through instead of separating things out and investigating them free of context. I'll be thinking a lot about this in the coming months. Thanks again for all that you do!

EveryonesFavoriteCousin

Your best work yet. I immediately came here to patreon to increase my monthly contribution when I finished the video. Unbelievable that people have access to this level of quality content for free. You're a genius, Natalie.

Bipp

I really like how you’re stretching the boundaries of what everyone expects from a Contrapoints video. I love your normal essays and look forward to more, but I also love seeing something more sensual, visual, and open for interpretation like this !

Koii

I’d take work like this over more consistent content any day. It was hard for me to say what this was about at first but it might be the only content I’ve seen that perfectly captures the deep frustration that comes from wanting to live your life and having people assume things about you, how that pollutes your psyche leaving you empty…and the subsequent attempts to fill that void with whatever’s available. I mean one of the only things that kept me going for a long time was knowing that there is a certain handful of people with a similar experience with contra being the most effective tool I’ve come across for justifying my existence. this doesn’t have to be about anything. It’s an accurate snapshot into the mind of anyone trying to live their life who society has deemed unworthy of that simple sadness and dysfunction as I think contra put it in another of her vids. ❤️❤️❤️

Conri Connell

Really a gorgeous video. The Hunger leapt beyond your usual informational video essays (which I obviously love) into a creative and logical conclusion for Contrapoints, something philosophical and spiritual. It has the air of your typical style of content, but it allows an audience to grapple with their own interpretations and ideas of “The Hunger,” desire. It seems plausible that you’ve been struggling with your formula lately, the intellectual goal of enlightening people away from ideological incorrectness (TERFs, Incels, Nazis, oh my), and that said format has grown creatively and intellectually limiting. This video really grows beyond providing a solid ideological conclusion. It doesn’t even provide a quickly apparent antagonist; what is the hunger? You leave that for the audience to answer for themselves. You push past academics into art, giving viewers the tools to interpret and answer questions for themselves. I’ll always love Contrapoints videos, and you can continue making short form video essays dealing with more surface level topics; I’ll watch them and love the shit out of them. (I can’t tell you how many times I’ve rewatched every single one of your videos. I’ll never get tired of it.) I also want you to know though, that The Hunger is what I consider to be your opus. It truly is the product of thought and meticulous intention. Not just thought of the topic itself, which is obvious in every one of your videos, but this is thought about what you’re producing, about what is important to create. I’m glad you came out on the other end of that thought with the answer, with this answer. It’s a terrible thought that I think gnaws at the mind of any producer of content, and what you created really proves that your creations are worthy. You transformed Contrapoints from a step by step instruction on how to battle fascists, to entering the void with Mommy Lucifer (is this Praxis?). You’ve gone from instructing an audience to impressing them, you’ve really created art, and I’m afraid that’s the most altruistic thing.

RebeccaC

You’re content is amazing and should not be rushed. Please don’t stress about getting videos out “on time”.

Alyssa Bauer

This is a masterpiece, I would love to see a part 3 PLEASE

Alex

Just joined today after admiring your work for some time. Keep it up and continue to listen to your intuition as it seems to be serving you quite well.

Electro_Static

Religion being the first intoxicant discussed was way close to home with many born again christians that I have met.

Hannah Pate

Loved it so much that I wanted to be a patron

Mikaela Cortez

Hi Natalie! Excited to watch The Hunger! Can you recreate your previous videos but in today's verbiage? I'd love to see the early work of 2017 Ms. Wynn! Love and Peace!

Thalia Sassman

As always, it's beautiful, hard hitting, deeply personal, and has an edge setting it apart from the rest. Your work always comes at the right time, and not a moment sooner. Thank you.

KF5TQN

Quality takes time. The end, amen.

Avynn Donaghe

I don't feel the need to comment on almost anything but this is one of the most powerful things I've seen posted to YouTube. You've managed to hit the nail so hard on the head that this literally made me cry and there are very very very few things that have earned that accolade. I hope that the massive amount of comments here and the amount of attention this video has gotten gives you the inspiration to complete this work with the third act. This was a wonderful video that has transcended it's medium and I really look forward to the completion of this project. Thank you.

Devany Simon

Hey lady - so I can say safely that more frequent uploads that need to compete with your overall quality / mental health...shouldn't be a question. A certainly isn't one we're asking for. Even when I recommend ContraPoints to new friends, I always add "her videos are all basically movies; so there's plenty of content. On top of that - all her videos are worth rewatching; you'll end up seeing something new even after the fifth rewatch". Keeping up the quality / quantity is one thing - keeping up with YOURSELF is a big second thing. Don't push yourself if it's unsustainable. What you produce has more insight and care than most of what I consume...so just do what you need to, and keep being your fantastic self. Be good to yourself, even if you can't see it or believe it right this second: You. DESERVE. To. Be. Treated. Well. By yourself, and by those around you - so keep being your fabulous self. And keep knowing you're wonderful.

Franco del Rosario

So I'm already at my 4th casual rewatch and I keep finding a new little detail, foreshadowing, or joke that I missed every time. What an impressive, jam-packed, immersive video!

Millie

Loved this! Great video. Would definitely love to see the continuation if you want to make it.

Millie

Also very much not the point, but god I am so jealous of that bathtub. I'm tall and large and regular bathtubs are just so dang small.

Isabella Hamilton

You're incredible, Natalie. <3 Is there an official discord server for Contrapoints?

Jojo

For the record, I love your little arthouse films, and I don’t mind your long production times. The most important thing is that you find an arrangement that is sustainable for you.

Claire Sparks

I loved this so much, all around incredible! The cinematography specifically was stunning. I'd love nothing more than to see a part 3!

RTT12

I think it's great that this video resonates with so many people in these comments. You seem to have created something that a lot of people have been looking for. Personally, I think I may not have gotten the point (which is ok). The discussion in the beginning is extremely stereotypical, which seems to be on purpose, but what exactly is the purpose? It's not really coming across as parody or satire - beside Miss Liberty everyone seem to be represented sorta realistically. So why am I watching a rehashed debate with two straw men of the US right for half an hour? The production value is top notch. Your movie making is really getting better and better, but this one is sadly not my cup of tea. Either there wasn't that much meat on it, or I missed it. I read up on Plato's Symposium, but it doesn't help me like it more.

Rachel

This video was insanely good. It's unbelievable that this was made by mostly one person and is available for free on the internet; I feel like I should have paid a $15 ticket to view this. This video also made me extremely sad and I've never personally struggled with addiction; I sincerely hope you are doing okay.

Andy Madison

Loved it— please take good care, you’re important and worthy.

Deconstruction Interactive

This is SO good!! I was suprised by the longer dialogue, but liked the Socratishness of it. I really liked your exploration of addiction and desire and identity. Desire as longing is something I've definitely experienced and read about and watched before, but I think it's an idea that gets lost in the Discourse today. Thank you so much for raising this point. It's a very powerful connection between the desire for a romantic partner, belonging, meaning, a community. I wish more folks would talk about religion as a salve for this kind of desire, rather than just some fundamental metaphysical truth about the universe. I look forward to more videos, short or long, and to part 3 whenever it's ready -- no rush!

Andy Thompson

After Envy I don’t see how even a single person could think you’re lazy 💜

Eric Kaplan

way better than black swan!

Monotreme Dreams

This was absolutely outstanding. You pour so much of yourself into you videos. I cried a lot in this video. Also, I adored your Bach preludes. Just exquisite. I don't mind if your updates are infrequent, you're giving us incredible feature films every time! Please do what you need to in order to look after yourself. You work so hard, and you deserve time away from your projects as well. Be gentle with yourself. (I struggle with that one a lot, but I am trying) 💙💜

Colleen W.

I feel like this deserves to be your most successful video. It's haunting and provocative and I also laughed out loud at Jackie's antics multiple times. To see act three someday would be dreamy but take your time! I know it's extremely parasocial but I hope you can feel the genuine support from this community.

run_away

One million views in four days. Natalie is a legend.

Emma Bjork

This was really good, I think the best you've done in a while. I liked seeing the dialogue format make a return! I think a lot of my favorite videos of yours are the more artistic types where you tell a story - the story of a self-loathing trans person in Tiffany Tumbles, the story of someone experiencing gender dysphoria in one of your older videos, and now the story of someone seeking relief from the pain of being from a marginalized community, attacked by reactionaries and unrecognized by family. I'm excited for the stripped down videos you have in mind, but I'm also looking forward to seeing the conclusion of this story - I hope you decide to make it!

Jimmbalaya

Love it, but you really killed us with that cliffhanger, *gorge*

selkie

I think you did a great job guiding the viewer through addiction, and hopefully some people will come away with more empathy for addicts as a result. I'd imagine this was a difficult one for you since you've mentioned your own issues with addiction, so I hope you're managing that as best you can. It feels really personal, but in a good way. I'm glad you made this.

BorisS

Really love that there's a trailer for this movie.

Phil Collins

I loved the work. Personally I never get annoyed if you don't upload frequently because you put a TON of work into making each production, and you just can't rush it. 10/10 once again, Natalie. :)

run_away

Finally had the time to sit down and watch this properly. As much as I love this video, Lucifer's muffled voice was driving me up the wall. Really really wish that her dialogue had been dubbed over. Other than that, though, it's gorgeous. Such a beautiful, sumptuous video. As an alcoholic I do relate to some of it. For me, my ADHD is so heavily tied to my addiction that I can't really think of the decision to drink alcohol as a choice between happiness and unhappiness. Rather, there is a reality that I can't function in society without chemical intervention. I can't hold a job or do basic things like go to the grocery store. Because I was undiagnosed for so long, I never knew that amphetamines would make me be able to meet the lowest standard of productivity needed to live. So I took the only option I had, which was alcohol. Once I was diagnosed and correctly medicated, I was able to cut back. I live with the knowledge that if I'm ever unable to take the Adderall equivalent I take now, alcohol will be my only option. It will be that or homelessness or suicide. All of the same addiction-related emotions are there, though. Pain, shame, loneliness, terror. It's just that I perceive them less as existential hopelessness and more as the side effects of these chemicals that I have to use to correct dysfunction.

Chris Reynolds

I never thought a video could leave me feeling both so triggered and so relieved all in one. I grew up a closeted gay in catholic school who then became a meth addict throughout half of my undergrad and masters (haven’t touched it since 2017). I cannot thank you enough for this video - i don’t know how to explain it but the way you presented void and our desperate attempts to fill some existential hole with meaning or just negate it entirely was a very cathartic thing for me - I feel like my shit choices weren’t just because I was dumb, but because I was spiritually lonely. I’m mostly very happy nowadays, with a lot of thanks to you and your videos.

Maya Gaster Moll

i absolutely love this video. its your most theatrical yet, in a way, because there is less direct monologue to the audience than ever, and yet it feels as rich and informative and True as any other of my favorite of your works. the visuals and design are impeccable, it all works together wonderfully together and the symbolism/themes come through so well. and as always i love getting to hear your piano performances.

Dekuinthelake

Thank you so much for making this. On the final leg of my mental health journey right now, and part of that is figuring out hoe I can love my pretransition self. I'm trying not to feel pain and shame when I look at old pictures of myself or remember how deeply caught up in addiction I was. I was triggered by the video, obviously. But I was able to pause at the bathtub OD scene, walk around, take a breath, and finish. And I'm very glad I did because I had a massively positive takeaway. Addicts aren't weak or stupid or bad. I was addicted to booze and pills. I was in pain and running away from myself. "Just quitting" was never the cure and would never work because the root of the cause was deep unhappiness with my life and gender. As soon as I started transition, the day drinking stopped. This video helped me remember that I wasn't a failure for being an alcoholic and I don't need to keep hating that part of myself. It wasn't really my fault, just the situation I was in. I'm glad I'm out of it now. And I'm especially glad this piece of art exists to remind me to be kind to myself.

Philippa Taprogge

This was a hard watch. Utterly brilliant in writing and acting, but hard to digest. Since I started taking estrogen, emotions hit differently - I cry a lot more. But this... kinda took me a step beyond. On T I would've probably cried at the end of this. Now I'm just left overwhelmed. Thank you for making this video and also, what have you done...

kelly m

the tradwife dress is so pretty

Raine

The moment that really jarred me and is still sticking with me is after Jackie misgenders and deadnames Justine, we see Lucifer walking through the door and up the stairs as if the transphobic abuse has literally opened the door for addiction to form. Not sure if that's how it was meant but that was extremely powerful, this video is haunting and I'd love to see a conclusion.

Lays Guerrero

Good things worth the wait. Don't be too hard on yourself about time, you do everything by your own.

Artemi

That was well worth the wait. The dialogue, the production, all so meticulous. I loved the contrasting speaking styles of the direct and acerbic Justine, to that of verbose, befuddling, and yet somehow still beguiling Virginia. All the while Jackie being Jackie in middle of it all 😂 I feel like Jackie represents not just libertarians but also just the average person. Half informed, half listening, full contradicting options and strongly held if not fully thought out beliefs. I am definitely guilty of being a dumb dumb sometimes😅 Justines description of erotic love was an epiphany for me. She put words to a feeling I could never I expressed myself. Truely beautiful. Thank you. Lucy was one of the best interpretations of Satan I've seen. Awe and dread in the same instance. I'm no coward or superstitious but if Lucy suddenly appeared to me like she did to Justine, I would pee myself and call her mommy for sure. Truely a terrifying beauty😅 Looking forward to act 3, whenever it happens it will be worth the wait. Some video essays in the meantime sound cool too😊 Thank you and take care of yourself, Natalie.

Alice

Hi Natalie, I wanted to wait till I could give the video a second viewing before offering my thoughts. Overall, I thought this was an amazing video; in terms of production, it’s easily the best I’ve seen from a YouTube creator working mostly on her own. The snippets of crazy divine/satanic stuff and the void-drinking sequence were particular highlights. I loved your performances, and the emotional moments between Virginia and Justine were strong. The philosophical arguments between them and Justine’s struggles were very compelling, and I can’t wait to see how they resolve! My main critique is that I think it would be a better video if you cut or condensed 5-10 minutes of dialog. I think it’s a waste of time to have Virginia & Jacky derail the conversation; people like them would obviously do that in real life, but this is a philosophical dialectic where we should just get to hear both sides present their strongest arguments. This is a particular issue early on with the digression about cancel culture. I also thought most of the dialog between Lucy & Justine was clunky & unnecessary; we’ve all seen plenty of characters succumb to addiction, and the visuals tell that story beautifully. Anyways, I’d like to add my voice to the chorus of folks encouraging you to finish the conclusion to this before working on other projects. But it’s your channel, and I’ve enjoyed the chance to spend years watching you chase your muse. Keep up the good work!

Terrence Edwards

Wow, you can really tell why this took longer because it's clear this was a very ambitious project. I like the use of the dialogue as a launch point for a narrative story. It's a good melding of the metaphysical with the physical. I enjoyed that a lot. I'll echo the comments, however, that some of the dialogue could have been condensed or streamlined. It did drag in the middle for me. Good work all around.

noa

Incredible work, and always well worth the wait

Rebekah

I believed that the dialogue was in real time - so well done. I *felt* the avalanche of ‘freedom’ rhetoric and frustration that hits the core when you have to try and parse it

Ruby Valentine

Art takes time. Stuff being a content robot x

Michael Sanders

I was spurned here by the need for information on when part two was coming out. I might've gotten way too invested in this story. So excited to see how the two motifs resolve together.

Leon

Why did I wait so long to watch this? it was brilliant! Combining the two acts made sense, and I'm looking forward to act three.

Daniel Loizos

Dear Natalie, I wanted to write and tell you that your work is valuable, and worth waiting for. As far as I know, you're writer, actress, designer and builder on your video essays. My point is take your time. Best wishes, Daniel