Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

I've been receiving feedback for a while now that many patrons aren't as enthusiastic about the AMA streams as they used to be. The main issues seem to be that they're repetitive (a lot of the same questions come up across multiple streams), and that they're excessively parasocial (the format enables people to ask personal questions, treat the streams as a therapy substitute, etc).

I could use a change of pace myself, and I think it would be worth trying out a new type of Patreon-exclusive content. What I have in mind is copying my fellow YouTuber Jenny Nicholson, who posts monthly "Rambles"—basically vlogs about topics that higher tier patrons can vote on.

I would call my vlogs "Tangents," after my tendency to get sidetracked in AMA streams. 2+ patrons would get access to monthly Tangents, 15+ patrons would get to vote on the topics for them. I envision these as mostly unscripted vlogs with simple editing, not unlike the main channel videos I made five or six years ago.

These would be a bit more work for me than the AMA streams, but my guess is that they would also make your Patreon subscription more worthwhile, and that to me is worth it.

Regardless, I will still do one final AMA stream this month (will post the stream link and question invite in a few minutes), and of course I value your feedback above all else.

Would you like to try out "Tangents" as a replacement for the AMA streams? We could always switch back to the AMA reward if Tangents turn out to be less popular.

Let me know what you think! And thanks as always for your support!

<3

Natalie

Comments

LadyTato

Do you think you’ll do a tangent on Hogwarts Legacy? As you’re in the gaming space I know personally I’d love your view on the discourse.

Izzy Wakeman

I personally like the AMAs, but if you wanted to try something else or scale them back, maybe you could just do AMAs soon after a big video release. A lot of people might have various questions about the themes and ideas and stuff

Filip Åsberg Montgomery

LOVING the tangents so far! I remeber showing my dad your videos and he was so amazed that ”she can just talk this fluently snd effortlessly about really complex topics for so long!” And i was like I mean she has a script. But these tangents really do seem completely free form, it’s so impressive

Anonymous Mouse

Loving the tangents! Subscribed because I wanted to hear your thoughts and was pleasantly surprised as the quality and length. I’m enjoying them!

Nancy F

Kept my Brutish, hairy, stinky lover awake just now with me loudly laughing at so much of this. Potentially laugh a minute even! 🌅 I must have lost more than half of my concentration span since you last uploaded, because it’s taken me this long to finish. Two weeks!!! Nearly had to slow the speed down! Ugh I need to read more books… anyway. The absolute best content from my favourite, much worth the wait sweetheart. Keep doing those gorgeous colour backdrop moments. We stan!

Chad Langford

That’d be great! Some others on here do that and it works out well

Nicole M

Love this idea!

Diane

I do love rambles

Felix

Let's switch it up yeah

Colleen W.

Yes please to Tangents!

Jeez Louise

Is “trangents” too on the nose?

Kazimir

Fantastic plan. Great way forward for everyone I hope.

Marissa Collins

Yes!! I'm a Jenny Patreon and I love her rambles. They're also great for me to watch any time, and I don't feel like I have to clear time on my calendar for a certain date/time.

Jacob Freedman

I'm up for it! I prefer videos to streams. Less FOMO

BrittaAL

I love this idea! :)

Will

Yes please to Tangents!!! I’ve been a Patron of Jenny’s for three years now and I can honestly say I love her Rambles just as much as her actual content. Would love to see you do something similar!!!

Blair Hesse

Whatever makes it easier on you we're in!

C Jose

YES TO THE RAMBLES

Laura Bea

Yes please!!! Honestly I support you because I think your content is great, but I have never watched an AMA because I find the parasocial stuff weird, so I don’t really get anything out of the support. Which is fine, because the content is the reward. However, extra content that I can engage with would be awesome ! :)

Caitlyn Mills

This is brilliant! I would personally enjoy that more!

Evirenia

Hell yeah! I would love that!

Mars Hall

I would love to try out Tangents! Honestly, I just enjoy hearing your take on things. 😁

Steffi

Love the idea!

Arben

Yeah, I haven't voiced them but I've had those same concerns. I do think the ama streams are still fun to listen to, but I can't remember the last time I've heard an insightful new question whereas I can remember many instances of thinking "why would you think it's okay to ask that here". I like Jenny's rambles and think that moving to tangents is a good idea for everybody involved.

pinh3d_ (Jack)

I would love to hear ramblings on niche subjects tbh. Rabbit holes like Jenny's are the best, too! (See Jenny Nicholson - there's something wrong with Hallmark's YouTube channel)

Ted(dy)

I think it’s a very good idea

Matthias

That sounds like an interesting idea. I use the AMAs how other people might put on the radio, do that works perfectly fine for me but the new concept would be fun too.

Sadie

Personally I love AMAs because we get to hear your thoughts on a wide variety of topics 🙂

Hellvetika

But what is your favorite breakfast food

Robert Korte

Tangents are a great idea. ❤️

Pendleton

That sounds like an improvement.

Joel Eblin

I would love the tangents. Jenny's rambles is my favorite example of what Patreon creators can do to make their Patreon special. I would follow Jenny's example of posting them to a second channel that is in kids mode so they can't be shared. It'll remove the process of trying to take down public playlists of the hidden videos.

susan tiss

I think this sounds like an excellent idea.

Raye

I'm here for it!

Oliver G

I think this is a great idea! I love the AMAs but it definitely has felt like they’ve been running out of steam for a while now

Coalbanana

I would absolutely love this!

Bjørn Rosland

It sounds interesting, but I think I will miss the AMA streams. But if everyone would like to have Tangents, then it's fine by me.

NickyT

I like it. Agree with the complaints raised

Libra Frills

I like the idea of Tangents !

The Horny Cinephile

Def down to try tangents! But I will say - I love the AMA streams. I rarely watch them live but I always listen to them later, and even though the questions are often repetitive, I feel like you have changed and grown each time and I enjoy watching you move through life.

Yonatan Zunger

I like it! This sounds like a great plan. And honestly, nucleating parasocial relationships is... not good. Very not good, as I can say from experience. Hearty support to getting yourself far away from that.

Ricky G.

Sounds like a great idea. I love the AMA streams quite a bit and support either idea. Hope you have fun deciding which one to do!

Mycah S

I would love that. The other problem with the AMA stream imo is that it’s a bit long to watch back later

Sara Arpagaus

I'd love the idea...specially now that your main videos become more "production" (i love them, don't get me wrong) it would be a nice change to have a video where you just...speak ;)

Sadie

I feel the same way

Seth Insua

Love the idea of Tangents, but also like that AMAs allow a range of subject matter - plus a certain informality. Really enjoy the video game streams too. Keep up the great work!

Perro Callejero

Sounds good! I enjoy the less scripted, stochastic nature of the AMAs—but the parasocial aspect, not so much.

kelly m

Tangents sound like a great idea! I really liked your tangents on the AMAs so that's perfect. Maybe you could still have AMAs but only once yearly or very occasionally since I enjoy that format as well :)

Deconstruction Interactive

<3 -- yes, I would love to see tangents and will probably watch them more than I have been watching AMA streams!

Jess Tuffs

i agree with your points on ama’s and i feel i would definitely engage more with the tangents videos! looking forward to the first one ☺️

Gene Younkin

Tangent streams sound fun! I’m eager to see how those work out.

Roland G. McIntosh

I would love a Tangent! This seems healthier and more rewarding.

Hannah Pate

Yes! I would MUCH rather have Tangents instead of ama streams. I'm not much of a streaming person anyway.

Costa J Hayes

This sounds like a great idea. Do what works best for your mental health. The AMAs are/were getting a bit repetitive. Enjoy your work so much.

CoffeePoints

Wow people have been criticizing Natalie's streams?? How dare 😡

James Chesson

The tangents idea sounds really good!

Grace Carroll

Sounds like a great idea Natalie. It makes me sad sometimes when I can see that certain AMA questions are making you uncomfortable. And I always prefer the tangents anyway! Looking forward to the first one 💞

Jessica Cheeri

I much prefer the AMA as it is, the community in chat is pretty important to me too. I've thought for a while though that there should be some sort of FAQ compilation so that people asking the same things could be directed to the answers Could be a hybrid version, where you do screen the questions, select a number of them and still do it live. I've seen that at convention panels. Still, it's the flow of the stream I like more than anything else. If I miss one live I don't usually watch the recording. I mean, it's worth a try, but my sense is it's probably not something I'll be as interested in

Liz Jones

I love Jenny’s ramble videos so I’m definitely in favor of this change!

Daphna

I love the streams but this sounds great!

zef fox

love this idea!

Wangled Teb

I like the Tangents idea! would also make me feel less shitty abt not being able to or forgetting to make it for them live lol

Jazz Jackrabbit

I like the AMAs. My only problem with the recent ones is that you haven't had background music on. 😛

Paul Williams

I like this new idea, but I’m an old white cis male. It’s clear that your trans and non-binary fans enjoy and and find value in the previous format. An important part of this is the interaction they get to have with you and each other. I suggest you do exactly what you proposed, but perhaps continue to host a regular gathering where the focus is on then and maybe you just highlighting their comments and the responses of other listeners. That takes the pressure off you to preform. And supporters like me can enjoy the new format without feeling guilty about taking anything away from those who benefitted from the old. Helping others is something we support too. ❤️

Rachel Quin

I think it's a great idea to try. Basically, it's great to just hear your thoughts and opinions on whatever topics interest you the most. Looking forward to it :^)

Susana Sabino

Okay, I love this! I've honestly gotten a bit bored and haven't even watched the past few AMA streams bc they do get repetitive. The idea of getting "low effort" vlogs or simple videos is great! I absolutely vote for it.

ibi

When thinking about it, a lot of the stuff that I tend to like about the AMA streams is stuff that isn't inherent to an AMA - I like the updates, the comfy stream feel where I can just put it on while drawing, the lowkey insights into what's coming, rambles on topics that haven't been covered in videos/addendums to previous topics, etc. I imagine I could get that from non-AMA streams/videos :0 I agree with the comments about the parasocialness of the AMA streams. Tangents don't sound bad as long as they're sustainable! They do sound like work. I'm currently on the $15 tier just for the question-asking ability so I would have to see whether or not I'd wanna continue with the change or drop down. I wouldn't mind non-AMA streams either every so often, especially if there was a format that worked. (sry this is a disorganized comment, just putting down random thoughts and feelings in case they're helpful)

Lise

Love this idea! I get a lot out of Jenny’s patreon for this reason.

Timid and Meek

Definitely, I would love it! 1. A snobbish as it sounds, it would be more intellectually stimulating... not gonna lie, listening to "Have you watch/read [insert anime/film/books] and if so what are your thoughts" or for MONTHS... have been so boring. And some of the more parasocial questions feels like a waste of time... As a $2 Patron, I'm like "we're here for your exclusive hot takes, not census data!!!" 2. I suppose it can actually help you as well with sort of workshopping and building various talking points that may someday be presented/repurposed/developed further on the main channel? Sort of like a monthly occasion for you to develop a bunch of prototype arguments to be polished and refined later on. IDK if that's how's it gonna work, but it may also be a more productive endeavor for the channel in the long run. This definitely has incentivized me to keep the patronage.

Branuck

This sounds like a lovely idea. I haven't paid much attention to the AMAs, but I do find myself missing hearing your thoughts on different subjects.

ibi

also I should say that while I do rly like AMA streams, I am also several vods behind lmao

Sadie

Yesssss

Ryan Storey

I don't mind either way. I enjoy the AMA streams because it's just fun to hear you ramble on about whatever is tangentially related to the question, and they're just chill, cozy vibes. If you were to keep the AMA streams, you could add some ground rules to those submitting questions. As in, "AMA, but please no questions about X, Y, or Z". This might cut down on the invasive people who just want to ask about who you're dating or whatever. I like the idea of "Tangents" though, as it would cater to the strengths of the AMA streams without the repetitiveness and invasive parasocial vibes. I think it's worth keeping AMA streams because I know plenty of people here enjoy them, but maybe not monthly. Maybe just once in a blue moon whenever you feel up to it.

Carneece

Love the tangent proposal! I think AMAs have fulfilled the best of what they can be - at least for now. Frankly I've become increasingly uncomfortable watching AMA streams because of the invasiveness of some questions (or simply ones that creep too personal), so reframing the input of patrons to decide on topics that you already find interesting feels like a much better dynamic, both as a supporter and as a viewer. Sounds exciting!

João Lopes

I like the tangents idea a lot. Q&A's I've watched were pretty good, but was never able to get to them live (I'm on the other side of the pond), so they were still synchronous. Whatever you feel fits best, is the way we should go :)

ContraPoints

yeah I agree that something would be lost with the AMA streams—maybe I could still do them but less often. We'll see how the Tangents go and then maybe I'll throw in an AMA stream whenever I get nostalgic for it!

ChatN

Sounds like an upgrade

Maurine Tritch

You have the best streams on the internet, why would you change it??? Sometimes the same question comes up but it's often in a slightly different form and your answers can change. Some questions I think are dumb you have great answers for. I wonder if there's a way to group the "have you seen?"--when you haven't--together so you can run through them relatively quickly. For the really annoying questions maybe a FAQ of questions that people shouldn't ask because you won't answer, it's on your FAQ.

Ashton

I like this idea!

edward

It feels more like a victim of your own success I remember when you were at 100,000 subscribers three years ago we felt a little bit closer as a para social relationship now you’re like a c iest celebrity

Deviant Ollam

Certainly a valid change of pace. Could you tangents and rambles be seeded or informed at all by some pre-submitted questions at times? A way of having some more interaction but in a manner that's more controlled and curated.

Diego

I like the AMAs, but as I mostly never can catch them live from Europa the rant seems like a fun idea to explore! Apart from that I'd also really enjoy some game streams instead of the AMA, as I find them always so hilarious.

The Doom Merchant

I'm very into the idea of the tangents. Jenny's rambles are my favorite of all the patreon bonuses I get. As much as I've enjoyed the AMAs I've caught, I'm mostly in agreement that the questions have become more and more invasive and inappropriate as they have gone on, and my discomfort with watching you deal with that has left me not watching them anymore. I'd be happy to see a change, frankly, and in my amateur opinion, it would probably be healthier for you and disincentivize the weirdos who feel entitled to answers to weirdo questions.

BassPope

I think that sounds good! As long as it’s not too much work for you, but I personally would be happy to see some more structured mini-videos. Just stay well! x

Sabrina Duncan

Honestly I’ll miss the AMA’s but totally understand the need to shake things up. Honestly (and hopefully this is helpful) I feel like you (and other chatters / and questioners) keep me up on the general goings on. I often find myself listening with you in the background then randomly you say something and I am like … the hell is that … I often find good books, music, old weird blended hotdog YouTube videos, etc). not sure that is anyone else, maybe just me, but you do seem to keep you finger on the pulse of a lot of things I miss. I always appreciate that.

Alison Crow

While I'll miss the community "hangout" feel of the AMA streams, this could also be a good change. I'm for it :)

Jessica Cheeri

I'm interested in seeing how it goes, don't get me wrong, feels like it also solves your often state desire to have some shorter (more column length?) videos out too. It's such a cozy space though, I know I don't have to tell you how chatty I am in the chattybox there and I'm mutuals on twitter with some of the other regulars now. Nothing's permanent though, obvi, so sure lets test it

BorisS

Bring on the tangents!

Liz Ard

Not a big fan of AMAs in general so yeah a tangent sounds great. I find those easier to watch when you couldn't catch them live too since there's less of a direct interaction happening.

Megan Speer

The thing I love about the ama streams is the tangents, so definitely yes!

Emma Hing

I absolutely love Jenny's rambles, please please please yes. It would be wonderful to get your rambles/tangents on any slew of topics (funny to serious) each month. Right now I don't really do the AMAs because of your listed reasons.. would love a tangent/ramble instead.

Jack Shields

I think this is a great idea and support the new format

Will E.

i love this idea.

Gamourtian

naur i love the ama streams thoo

Everybody's Talking At Once

I'd prefer the Tangent option, for all the reasons you outlined (and also because I'm big fan of Jenny's "Rambles" as a format; getting some similarly loose content from you would be a blast).

Derek Bayne

tangents sound awesome. let's do it.

Diana.H.

Jennius idea.

Merelyflowers

Hell yes! Jenny's Rambles are the gold standard of Patreon content. I would love to see you do something similar.

Hellvetika

(It's eggs benedict, because it is difficult to make yourself at home)

highclass_lady

I love listening to your tangents from past AMA streams. I used to be a microinfluencer & some of my friends were also microinfluencers so I understand how parasocial works & have experienced it's extents from the other side (to the capacity that someone can without being on a similar scale). Yet as a fan who found you recently, I'm going to miss the option of getting to ask more questions in future AMAs (I had a whole list of questions I was looking forward to asking going several months out) but I get why evolving your Patreon content & giving new ideas a try should at least have a proper chance. I also saw some suggestions to alternate between AMAs & newer options or switch to 1 AMA per year, &/or doing the tangents also as livestreams, any of which could potentially be a more ideal compromise, either way, I look forward to finding out what all that comes next will be like!

Ro

this sounds so awesome! I got into patreon to support your content creation tbh, I don't care much about streams. But these tangents seem like something I'd be into 👀

Lorena

You could also do a book club or discuss a song, article or anything honestly. I like your AMAs and have no complaints either way honestly

Gian Balangue

I love the idea of the Tangents! Jenny's Rambles are always really fun

Camille Hoffman

Great idea! More gaming content is also a solid bet. I can't be the only patron who wants to see more ambition: a minuet in power.

Diana Gibson

I love that idea! I think AMAs might still be fun for some patrons, but I think having them less frequently would address some of the issues as well - for instance, one AMA annually would be a fun treat for me, but monthly is generally unappealing and I usually don't watch them. I would definitely watch Tangents, though!

Deanna

Yessssss I'd love this, fantastic idea!!!

Cheri Attix

Yes yes yes!! Tangents please!!

JBlake

Love it! Thanks for the update :D

Baztey

If patreons are making the same questions would it be a good idea to make a FAQ video or post maybe?

Silas Snider

This sounds fantastic! Love the tangents idea

Ella Marie Rosenzweig

I'll be honest, I love the AMA's and keep a list of questions that I want to ask. As a trans woman, I struggle within loneliness and being able to connect with other trans women. And so to be able to find out what another trans person thinks or experiences is really nice. That said, you do you.

Eve Hickey

I would love to see Tangents! I don't view the AMAs often for the reasons you listed, and would love to see what you would do with that kind of unscripted format.

Lynnferno

I love this idea! I also agree with some other people's suggestion to still do the occasional AMA as a treat.

MikeF

I like the tangents idea. I don’t really watch the AMAs anymore so I think this could be an interesting, new reward for patrons.

Isaac

I like this idea, I love Jenny’s Rambles.

Isaac

Yes yearly AMA feels right

Yousuf Kazmi

With Jenny the top tier post the questions and the 5+ tiers then vote, winner becomes the next Ramble Video. The voting becomes a thing in it's own right, especially when it's close! Should work really well and finish with channel news (still reading theory..!)

Iana Nelson

Tangents sound interesting, the gaming streams are fun to for some live interaction that has a focus on the game at hand. They seem to be a lot less problematic than some of the questions that come up in the AMAs.

run_away

Fully approve of tangentpoints. It'll be fun to see the difference in topics between Jenny Nicholson and Natalie lol. Two brilliant women with completely different personalities and interests.

AdVix

I love Jenny's rambles and would love your tangents. Yes please

Jason F

Love this idea! I often can't make the AMAs live, but when i have, I've always loved the rants! I did enjoy the cozy chill vibe of the AMAs and small updates from your end. Hopefully there might be ways to carry qualities from AMA into the new format as it emerges. <3

Traci

I vote for tangents! I love that format from Jenny and look forward to them every month.

run_away

I'm 100% on board with tangents but I do like the contrapoints chat during the AMAs. That's a big part of the draw of the AMAs for me. I'm not big into discord but I'd be interested for a 'Points fan chat channel or an occasional watch party, for whatever that's worth.

Gogo the Game Mistress

Love this. As an *elder millennial* I never got AMAs. Hearing your brilliant mind ramble about something you want to talk about would be more up my alley.

Frankie

I love Jenny's ramble videos so I'm sure i'd enjoy this

Jackson Bassford

I definitely like this idea, I love the AMA's but yeah it's definitely getting repetitive with the mostly same cycle of questions

Squeaky Francis

I love Jenny's rambles. Would love to add Tangents to the watchlist.

tvetekel

I still enjoy the AMAs but agree with the points raised here. I'm not a patron of Jenny's and haven't experienced that kind of ramble-perk, but I would be happy to try out a "Tangents" reward tier. And of course the old AMAs will always be there for both old and new patrons to enjoy, so the change to "Tangents" doesn't feel scary.

Scott M

I love this idea, I'm much more likely to watch a tangent than an ama stream.

Savannah

Love hearing your thoughts on various topics, so would definitely enjoy!

Ruth Sangree

Natalie I ADORE this idea. I would support you and Jenny regardless, but her "Rambles" definitely make me feel like I'm getting something special in return each months and I always enjoy them, and I know I would enjoy getting them from you. It would also be great for those of us who can't usually make the AMAs because of timing, etc.

D.A.R.

I'm sure I'll be in the minority, but I don't think it's a good idea. First, yes, they tend toward the parasocial and somewhat redundant from one AMA to the next; but that's a bad thing? With ContraPoints videos we get the creative personae, but with AMAs we get Natalie. Second, vlogs also tend to take on more of the creator's persona than the creator being candid. Could we perhaps alternate from month to month?

Sadie

Agreed

Opinionated Online

I like the AMAs. I understand if you want more control over the questions if they're too personal or redundant, but I like the format where it's not edited and a variety of topics are talked about. Maybe, you could alternate between them, and do around 8-10 tangent videos a year and 2-4 AMAs a year.

highclass_lady

I agree, still having 1 AMA each year would be super nice, it would still allow an AMA as an option, but less of a strain on you (I would hope ❤️) & doing so might also help to reduce the repetitive questions

sarah

That sounds great!

Michele Fullarton

I do like the ama streams but rarely have the ability to join. Tangents seem like a really great idea to me, definitely something I would watch!

Annabelle_Thann

I think this is a great idea! I often miss the streams and feel like I'm missing out somewhat on the perks of being a patron (although I am primarily here to support you). Someone above mentioned alternating month to month, which could be fun too

Franco del Rosario

I definitely agree with the criticisms against the AMA structure (too repetitive, excessively parasocial), although I am a little worried about the work that a pre-recorded vlog-style video entails, even with simple editing. Having that much deliverables (on top of your main videos and all the other Patreon rewards you do) sounds very tiring. Would you maybe consider the “Tangents” video to still be an interactive livestream. Will probably be a lot shorter than a typical AMA (maybe like 30 mins? You could just prepare some points beforehand, while also letting the chat sort of dictate the flow of the discussion.) But I’m definitely happy to support whatever!

C

I would love some tangent videos!

claudia

I would love tangent videos! my proposal would be – if they take a lot of work, perhaps you could do one month tangent video, one month gaming livestream? tbh, i'm always just happy for more contra content, no matter what kind.

Joseph Flores

Absolutely love the tangent/ramble idea. Jennys rambles are my favorite Patreon exclusive content.

Cabbage

YES PLEASE TANGENTS

Halcy

I think the "Tangents" videos sound like a great idea and something I would enjoy.

PittOfSnakes

(lifelong lurker) I think this is a good idea! Tbh the tangents were always my fav part of the AMAs anyways. Just like hearing ur random opinions on stuff in the background when I'm tidying or whatever, same with jenny's stuff. Yeah having a poll on the subject and just rambling sounds good 🙂

jawblia

yes tangents <3

Jonathan

love love love this idea!! i’m here for whatever you choose

godliath

I'm totally in favor of moving away from the AMA format (some of the questions always seemed inappropriately personal/parasocial imo) but I want to second the suggestion I saw further up the comments of doing the tangents in a livestream format instead! It'd be less work for you while retaining aspects of what people enjoy about AMA streams.

SuperHumbleEmperorGodKing

Tangents are definitely something I'm more interested in seeing. The AMA's are... yeah, getting a bit stale.

Tall Jeff

Yes please, as ever Jenny Nicholson is very wise and we should follow her example sivako!

Gavia

Yes!

Timid and Meek

I've seen the comments and I also would like to add that I agree that livestrems (instead of edited videos) give that feel of bonding within a community, which can be quite meaningful for some people. I fully support the Tangents idea still because I think it's a needed change of pace, but I think the idea of Tangents being a livestream is not at all bad as well. One example that comes to mind is Khadija Mbowe's Livestreams where she talks about trending issues. It's a livestream, but she's also prepared research for it, and makes the experience quite smooth. But I support both Tangents as a lightly edited vlog or a livestream. Tangents as an idea in general is better than the current AMAs.

Kayj Morrill-McClure

Sounds great to me. I don't usually watch the AMAs (oddly feel that I shouldn't be asking questions) and would enjoy rambles on different topics.

Peter Ciccolo

Yes, please. Bring on the Tangents.

June Walker

I definitely preferred the livestreams to the AMAs. But some pre-recorded tangents could be cool, as long as they're not too much work for you. I would eagerly watch a harpsichord acquisition vlog :)

Konni

My thought is, you can still preserve the live format with this. You don't need to edit anything, that never bothered me.

Aly

Ditto what everyone else has said about doing it live! I always enjoy listening to you talk about random things, researched or not!

Pentalis

Tangents are good. They have a title and I get to pick the ones I want to see. My favorite part of the AMA streams was to hear you go on a tangent.

Logan Rand

I'm always super into the tangents, so this sounds great to me. Seems like a good idea to reduce the parasocial weirdness too... sorry for the times I've gotten parasocial myself. I think you're right, the AMA format makes it too easy.

David Makyavelski

I‘m for tangents. But I‘m gonna miss the AMA also. Maybe do one every once in a while like other patrons already suggested. A lot of your responses to questions were really thoughtprovoking. I don’t know. I liked the streams

jclare

I love this idea of tangents! And I also support the idea of no to low edits, so that you can just say what’s on your beautiful mind!

Crescent Minor

This sounds like a great idea. For how often I put your old essays on just to listen to and think, some more informal musings sound like fun, and sound easy to background.

Anneli Samuel

I like both the AMAs and the idea of Tangents! Certainly curious about you trying out the latter but wouldn't mind just AMAs either.

Rob Myers

Super into this. Much as I love you as a creator , I've no desire for a parasocial relationship(?). I am a patron in the original sense of the word in that I support your content. I like the idea of Vlogs.

Jack Beck

Yeah let’s switch it up!

Luiza

Woohoo for vlogs! <3

Bipp

I don’t want you do overtax yourself with extra work, but I would much prefer vlogs to ama’s. Tbh your voice is very asmr-y so tangents sound great.

Aleksandra Chrzanowska

love this idea!! i liked the AMAs a lot but the new format sounds so much more in tune with what i enjoy most about your work (while also setting parasocial boundaries), as it wouldn't focus as much on personal stuff people want to know about yourself, but rather your opinions and bright reflections on broader more general topics (so kinda like YouTube videos without the theatrics, which sounds like it would beautifully compliment your main channel content!). i hope you'll find this new type of content more fulfilling and enjoyable as well! good luck <3

Jessica Rossman

Tangents would be awesome! That’s mostly why I tune into the AMAs anyways.

ts_babyjane

i would be down for that if it means we get more stuff, i love the AMA streams because we get to keep up on your thoughts about various and random/mundane subjects and you often give really interesting takes about things i wouldnt expect. still tho, i can tell youre burnt out on them because we’ve been getting less and less. (and they have gotten super long so i get it !) so if you like tangents and we get them like once a month im sooo down. :)

Andrew Blee

Yes, that would be a cool experiment.

rnbrocker

Sounds good! I like that you can watch them anytime, and don't have a feeling that you are missing out on something. (You could also keep the game streams coming. Nintendo is adding the classic three Mario Party games to Nintendo Switch Online soon, so these could be fun. ^<^')

SophieT

I would miss the live aspect of the AMAs. They're a way to chat with other CP Patreon fans and to kind of hang out with you, but I absolutely love the idea of something new that works better for you.

Martyś

Tangents sound like a super cool idea, I'm looking forward to them!

Anouk Jones

Love this idea and respect the desire to avoid problematic parasocial interactions.

AJ

This sounds like a great idea Natalie!

Ren ☆

I adore Jenny’s rambles, I was -just- thinking how fun it would be if you did something like that

Sandra Dans

Sounds suuuper fun, i'd be into it!

Bridget Schiffler

I love Jenny’s rambles, and think tangents would be a great shift - I love watching the q&a streams but I agree, they can get a bit parasocial.

Tanner Gore

“To be a streamer is to be a fourth grade substitute teacher” (– Hasan Piker, I think) and what do we fourth graders truly want the substitute teacher to do? Go on tangents!!!

Sophie

I would love to try Tangents, sounds like a great idea!!

Kamil Dzielinski

I've never enjoyed the streams, so this would be a very welcome change 💜

Anda Handerson

I love Jenny's rambles! It's the only Patreon-exclusive content that I consistently watch. I would be very grateful if I could also look forward to your Tangents! I'd find it a bit harsh if only 15+ Members could vote on the topic. Maybe you could reconsider and change it so only 15+ Members can propose the topics but some lower tiers can vote on them too?

Matt Henriksen

Absolutely believe I would prefer it

Adam Iaizzi

The rambles sound more fun! As a non-freeloader, I don't get much out of watching other people ask questions, but rambles sound really interesting.

Kat

I would love those! I watch on mobile so I don't have the chat open, (which would only even help if I watched these live) so it kinda sucks when you're answering a question I am interested in only to get stopped by having to respond to something in the chat. I would very much appreciate hearing you go through your thoughts on a topic uninterrupted since that is my favourite aspect of the AMAs.

Icebear is defiant

I don't watch the AMAs but I also don't feel I'm owed bonus content (zero shade at people taking a more transactional view of their membership). I contribute at a level that's sustainable for me as a thank you for what you've already done and with a hope that you'll make more art. Yes some part of me views it as transactional, but you creating what you think is good in a way sustainable for yourself is more of what I hope for. That said…Tangents sounds like something I would enjoy. — Tim

Oscar Thompson

tangents all the way! That's what I watch the AMA's for anyway :P

Icebear is defiant

Eep. The "…we get Natalie" and "…creator being candid" is kind of a demonstration in miniature of the parasocial problem, no? EDIT: Rereading this, I sound like I'm judging. That isn't my intent. I also like candid and authentic creator and celebrity moments. I'm not immune and low levels of parasociality aren't necessarily bad. So I could be wrong.

Adventuress

I don't really watch the AMAs because I'm on the wrong side of the world for the live events, so Tangents sound like a really nice alternative!

Cole

I will definitely miss the interactivity of the Q&As. Sometimes participating in the chat is as much fun as the Q&A itself. If Q&As are gonna go away I'd rather replace them with more gaming livestreams (maybe Patreon-only special gaming streams?) or something where we can interact with each other in real time

Chris Lam

I like the idea of tangents. Keen for Nat's hot takes. Hope you feel like you can skip over previously covered topics.

Onrustig

huge fan of this idea

Sophie

Great idea! I love hearing you speak on various podcast appearances you do so this would feel similar :)

Stella Bogdanoff

Tangents sounds cool but can you please keep the option to pay to ask you something? Maybe put it at a higher tier and reply to people privately? I think the reward of getting direct communication and being able to get your opinion on something is so so valuable ❤️

Janine

That seems even more excessively parasocial though

Bored Lacanian

Oooh I LOVE this concept, it's as if I came up with it myself. The tangents were always my favourite part of the streams, and though last year I watched them religiously, the repetitiveness of the questions always interrupting the tangent flow soon made them too tedious to sit through in their entirety. However: my initial thought when I started reading this was that they, too, would be streams, but it appears you're thinking of them as minimally prepared content? I personally would like the idea of the topics flowing more organically and allowed to either take up more time or dwindle according to your mood or live feedback from viewers. Plus, there's also the thrill of catching a stream live and tuning in to watch or participate, which, in a non-AMA based stream, I feel would work much better in amping up excitement. I feel like it's the perfect middle ground, and none of the appeal of AMA streams would be lost. I hope you give this some consideration. But, regardless, whatever you decide to do, having pure Contrapoints content to look forward to on a monthly basis certainly sounds delightful!

Bored Lacanian

Ok but can we please get a grip? This whole platform, and the AMA streams specifically which have been going on for many years, are built on the very concept of monetizing parasociality (and that's fine). We are clearly parasocially invested in some way or other or we wouldn't be here discussing this at all. Now, I have my own frustrations with what questions this dynamic has led to and its effect on the content--indeed, after a while it gets quite repetitive and some questions are borderline insufferable, not because they are parasocial per se, but because of the weird style of parasociality they exhibit--I would probably say there are healthier and less healthy ways of being parasocial. And wanting to talk to a person whose work you adore, and whose personality you have maybe gleaned over the years, but who, because of their success, is completely inaccessible to you approaching them like a normal person--it's not excessive or extreme *by itself*. It's fairly reasonable. Let's not demonize the concept completely, lest we risk deluding ourselves--not saying it out loud because we now realize it's A BAD, is not going to make it disappear.

Dr. Alex

Love the idea. Some of the AMA questions felt a little too insular or personal. We are here to support your creative vision and hear your well-informed takes on philosophical and political topics. If we are here for something else, we should [look honestly at our own behavior and try our best to] find that somewhere else.

LilliClare

love tangents™️!!! would love to see these!!

Jacob Dysart

Definitely down for that. I'll confess that the AMAs have really never interested me. I'm more into your perspective than personal details. At this point I'm just thinking of your patreon as a way to give a little money for the great youtube content- if there was something I was really into that you were doing here exclusively that would be really sick!

Sadie

Glad someone said it!

Carbonite Cass

This is gonna be great! I'm all for it but I also have so many questions I was looking forward to asking. Guess its on me for waiting to pony up the cash lol. but seriously how do you know every girl I was ever in youth group with and what a coincidence that you hired them all for the hunger. Small world, I guess.

Tory Eisenlohr-Moul

Yes. Honestly I stopped watching the AMA because the level of paradoxical vibes was cringe.

Rachel

literally over a month late to this, but this is SUCH a great idea!! I honestly never watch the AMAs for the exact reasons you've described here, but I religiously watch Jenny's rambles and would 10000% do the same from you. I think monthly rambles are the best bang for the patreon buck and hopefully because of the minimal editing they are not too much work on the part of the creator either.

Edward Nuber

I like ama streams so I hope they can stay in one format or another

Jan

How about monthly tangents, but swapping for something more AMA only during the month of a video release? Probably the best time for new interesting questions and for us to get BTS insight! Otherwise, great new idea <3

Nicola Callahan

YES! I'd be so excited! Jenny's rambles have kept me a patron of her's for awhile!