Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

For about two years I've been keeping a notes document for a potential main channel video called "The Male Gaze," which I was able to plunder for this Tangent, along with a lot of the research for the main channel video I've been working on already.

As usual, things got out of hand, it's more than an hour long, should really just be turned into a main channel video at some point—et cetera. I did at least remove a ten minute ramble from the middle, what was the "subjectification" section. Maybe I'll upload that as its own Subtangent, or just do a whole separate video on identity.

This one did get more academic than usual, it's probably the most academic content I've ever made. Hopefully I'm still communicating clearly and not getting weighed down by the citations.

Enjoy, and as always let me know what you think! On this topic I'm particularly interested in feedback, hearing different perspectives.

-Natalie

P.S. Here's the video link, in case embedding doesn't work: https://youtu.be/fNB-WGNLGG4?si=OJ_lkZ4Hqh70lKw-

P.P.S. Like I said last month, there will be no October Tangent as I try to force myself to finish the main channel video, which realistically will be out in November, along with a Tangent that month. Might have to keep that one simpler!

Files

Tangent: The Male Gaze

Thanks so much for your support! ▬ Contents▬ Part 1: Alleged Psychosexual Dimorphism 09:00 Part 2: The Male Gaze According to Laura Mulvey 16:38 Part 3: Objectification 21:23 Part 3.5: Jeffrey Dahmer 27:49 P̶a̶r̶t̶ ̶4̶:̶ ̶S̶u̶b̶j̶e̶c̶t̶i̶f̶i̶c̶a̶t̶i̶o̶n̶ ̶3̶3̶:̶0̶0̶ Part 5: The Female Gaze 33:08 Part 6: Feminine Narcissism 42:52 Part 7: The Lesbian Gaze 49:44 Part 8: The Genderfluid Gaze 58:47 Part 9: Beyond Complaining 1:03:07

Comments

Hellvetika

Typical. Always the gays, never the male straights.

Wesley

Wow I was just thinking about the male gaze and then you posted this 🥰 how cool. Excited to watch it

queertheoryxyz

I soo needed the thrill of a new contrapoints video today 💖🌈🍉✨🌻 thank you for posting 🙏

val

oh ive been waiting for this one

L E

Thank u madam points

Jason

Yesss I'm so excited to listen to this as a great way to end a subpar week. Look forward to your main channel video when you finish :)

keratin10000mg

November is shaping up to be a good month for video essay drops. If predictions hold, we'll see new Contrapoints as well as Jenny Nicholson's Starcruiser. Looking forward to both.

Tyler Ray

My day is always made when Natalie posts a new video.

Madeline Methvin

Thank you for keeping us posted! Hope you’re taking good care of yourself and your heart is full 💛

Dana Fried

Honestly this is high enough quality and well-researchrd enough you could drop it as-is on your main channel with a new intro and nobody would know the difference. One of your best yet (disclaimer: I'm only a fourth of the way through)

John Silva

I don’t understand why feminists are always so upset about the mail gays. My mail carrier is a homosexual and I think he’s a perfectly nice guy.

Beth Fisher

SHRIEKED in excitement at the notification!!

Eric Kaplan

if you posted a sub-tangent that was ten minutes on subjectification -- id watch!

Frankie

I'll listen to this at work instead of my coworkers. Win/win.

Sacha

YAY

matogato

Damn, that's some dope Cuban links you're wearing. Now I'm trying to figure out what my inability to stop staring at it says about my gaze...

João Pedro

Hey contra! So, i would like to point out that the lightening of the video sometimes are kinda off, kinda flashy. Maybe you'd like to know. Love you! Great video!! ♡

Alex Moody

Omg! I just got caught up with the last tangent and already here's the next. Love this :D

Lily Rafton

I'm in the middle of my high school certificate exams (basically australian SATs but you have to write essays) so thanks for the distraction <3

Alecxy

I haven’t finished watching yet. But “heterosexual women like men whom they can identify with, men who have something feminine in them” is spot on. I think the reason for that is women tend to accept their sexuality which is not a singular spot in the spectrum. Even for heterosexual women, I believe we often view our own sexuality with a sense of fluidity, perhaps even subconsciously. I believe men find it more challenging to recognize this fluidity in their own sexuality due to patriarchal norms.

siverharloe

For some reason, youtu .be connections just spin and spin and then time out for me. Only youtube .com/watch?v=blahblahblah links fork for me. It's very sad making. I tried to figure out the blahblahblah from the link in post, but I must have used the wrong part of the link because I only got a "this video doesn't exist anymore" message. EDIT: okay, I got it, the trick was to throw out the ?si=stuff on the end, then I could form a link to youtube .com/watch?v= from what was after the slash in the provided link.

Mel A

Its difficult to disentangle "what she finds attractive" from "what men find attractive" because i think so many minds of girlsform and grow up with the idea of being observed. I know i spent a long time trying to find what i think is sexy and move away from what teenage me thought boys finds sexy.... And yet in admiring my current appreance i still experience it as someone else admiring me. I guess ive never noticed before how much my internal gaze of myself feeels external in a way. Though its interesting that for men, they Think that they are seeing themselves through women's eyes when they chase abs and muscles. Its almost like men chase their own ideal via proxy of attributing it to women, and many women chase a male (or otherwise external) ideal of desire via proxy of attributing it to themselves.

David

Couldn't we just say that this is all Jesus's fault and call it a day?

Pierre Brown

Ooooooh, Natalie. You hit on some very relevant points on the gay male experience (in my own life at least). So in a general sense, I find your points about typical homosexual attraction is similar to/a threat to the heteronormative images of men; the muscles, emotional withdrawal, and being primarily sex driven in regards to relationships have been my experience. I am no saint nor blind myself so I’m not trying to put myself on some “I’m not like other homos” milk crate. I watch porn, I can experience lust based on looks. However I have also received criticism that I am “softer” in personality than expected while also not being “fem”; not having as high of a libido/initiating interest in sex; being “more of a nerd than a gay” (whatever tf that means). I also think my attraction and lust to men purely on a physical level is different than the stereotypical; I find stockier/average weight/“thicker” men far more attractive than the typical, muscly man. I am a bottom, but I overwhelmingly prefer sexual acts that do not require phallic penetration. Magic Mike to me looks like a circus act, whereas Moonlight was so intensely hot to me because the romance towards the end of the movie made high-value of physical intimacy. It’s been a weird ride for me as a gay man in this world so far and I resonated with some much of your thoughts regarding homosexuality being influenced by patriarchy/male-gaze/media.

Kylee Webb

I think this is my favorite tangent of yours. It would be great if this would be a main channel video. Great work, Natalie! I don’t think I’ve ever been more seen (but not too much lol).

Evan Michael

Yesssss I was WAITING for you to bring up Lucy Neville! I read it after you mentioned it on a stream years ago and it really shifted my perspective on slashfic and objectification in general. Anyway, wonderful tangent. Can't wait for the main channel vid!

Cristina Anderson

you pointing out some heterosexual women are attracted to being attractive made me realize thats EXACTLY how i feel. Just embodying the role of the perfect beautiful sexy woman of the male fantasy. Society making sexual attraction divided by gender has really messed us all up huh But this was a fantastic video! Im going to watch it again now :)

colopop

I liked your point at the end about men opening themselves up to the "feminine world". My recommendation for a starting point would be, ask your mom what her favorite book is and read that book. Both of my parents read a lot, and I do as well, but I realized that I had never read a single book by my mom's all-time favorite author (Margaret Atwood) until earlier this year. There is definitely a sense of shame in that realization, but there's also an opportunity to learn.

Welcome to Heaven

I find this topic so freaking interesting, and you did a wonderful job. I think the female gaze does exist, and it's unfortunate that a lot of the porn communities that are created for (mostly) women by women often get destroyed. Some examples: - The once thriving porn community on tumblr, full of black and white gifs, fantasy captions, and fandom NSFW fanart. - The Femgaze_hentai subreddit, which was recently closed to protest the Reddit API changes. AO3 and other fanfic sites truly are some of the last remaining places mostly used by women with LOTS of very, very hardcore NSFW erotica (even some more "intense" and sadistic desires (like those you described mostly men as having) can found in tags like "dead dove: do not eat" and "whump"). I feel like female gaze in a community really only develops when there isn't much interference from the male gaze, because the dehumanizing & objectifying content a lot of men casually post drive women away from the community, and it winds up being just another place where the men sit around together and say "where are all the women? Welp, I guess women just don't like porn." Also, I love that quote by Margaret Atwood you included. I think about it all the time and agree that a lot of women have been forced into becoming our own voyeurs. What an uncomfortable feeling it is, and it's so sad that some women feel bad about "gazing" because of the violent associations they have with being gazed at. Love your demands at the end! Thank you for the lovely video.

Trejon Dunkley

As a bisexual woman, I can definitely say there's a difference between how I want to attract men vs women. With men, I delight in being delicate, difficult, sexy, vampy, impossible to ignore, ready for seduction. With women, I definitely take on a more butchy, seducer role, and yes, I feel like my desire for women is more leering and predatory, even as I try to avoid it. As a bisexual woman, I both feel weird that I'm NOT jealous or uncomfortable when my male partner sees boobs, I don't see it as inherently dehumanizing or unfaithful to me, cuz like, I get it, I feel the same way. I also sometimes feel like a bad feminist when I join in on the desire of women, even when it's women who are asking to be desired, like at a burlesque show (which, in and of itself, speaks to a somewhat universal desire for women to want to feel sexy and seductive).

Luen Tobar

Make your November tangent just a shitpost about the astrology girlies

Najeeb Khadim

As a gay guy I have pretty complicated feelings on sex and objectification (this is probably oversharing a bit but hey). Initially as a teenager I had a lot of discomfort with the idea of being found sexually attractive, the way someone on grindr would talk to me with lust. I do wonder if part of this is men not expecting to be seen this way, whether part of discomfort was a subconscious thought that this isn't how men should act sexually. To use the terms of the video, I was a seer experiencing discomfort and being seen. I do have concern about how objectification can exist in gay spaces though, partly because it seems like it can hinder other connections and can encourage spaces of seeing each others as means to an end rather than people with separate internal realities. I've met many gay men who see other men as just sex objects and it's kind of clear this is a method of dealing with having been treated in the same way. Idk, I do have lingering feelings that it's hard to feel like a person when involved in anything sexual and I do think Kant has a slight point when he talked about marriage safeguarding against sexual objectification with the idea that marital love presents one partner fully seeing the other as a means to an end. The exact details here are obviously oversimplified or wrong, but certainly I don't think anxieites of sexual or a sexual gaze in isolation is concerning, uncomfortable and often alienating both from peers and even from ones self. Idk there's a lot here. I don't know how true it is that gay men get more sexual enjoyment, quite often it actually doesn't seem like enjoyment; it's sex for sex's sake which I've had many people admit to me they didn't want to do, they just felt they should or even that sex was just an excuse to be held.

Maeve

all i can hear in the beginning is "female gays" and "male gays," which is also cool

Cristina Anderson

Something else that i just thought of, it feels like the difference is that men are only allowed to engage with the erotic, and women are only allowed to engage with the romantic, when humans need both. So then women try to access the erotic purely through the romantic, and we end up with women who's context for sexuality is pining and hand grazing like you mentioned. And men who have no experience imagining a deep romantic connection with a partner and just see something to have kinky sex with Just some random general thoughts :)

fern

babe we need the dworkin video

Jessica Cheeri

This was a fascinating one for me on a few levels. I have to say that I connect more with the feminine stereotype on the adult media thing of preferring the longer, usually written, character driven (and costumed) stuff because it just engages with my brain better. It's easier to project into and can pace the story as I need to. Not knocking video on that, some of my fav social media mutuals make it, just it's not usually made for me. (Incidentally, an exception is kink video producer Pandora Blake, and I would highly recommend following their patreon since they've done a few essays now on the gender/gaze/adult media intersect) The part about a lot of men refusing to try to identify with women. That's something I'm really interested in since I'd describe my own personal trans gender expression as a sort of "effeminate-femininity". I just notice from marketing, from clips of righttube, and the GOP (especially Trump, but didn't start with him) and too many Democrats, that there's a sort of packaged masculinity product sold to men that takes a concept from the old Brannon Masc Scale, "Don't be a sissy", and makes a social religion out of it. And that's got to be scary to a lot of men, it's a shame culture. Some guy's a wrong drink order or an ad on instagram away from being laughed at by his bros. Can't tell me that doesn't work its way back into sexuality. I've certainly seen a lot of the literature (in this case darker force femme erotica). Ah, but I may be on my own tangent now

Laura Bea

6 pints in and I’m heading home to eat chicken nuggies and watch this…can’t wait!

Anais Van Ertvelde

This! I know so many bisexual women - including myself - who feel like they act way more "gazey" or objectifying towards women then towards men - and often feel shame because of it. I think part of it is being so used to the objectification of women that it comes more easily to everyone. It even prevented me for years from taking my bisexuality seriously because I thought it was just a given that women's bodies are there to be found visually attractive. But another part of it is that I do would like to visually objectify men more (the feminine narcistic pleasure of being someone's visual desire is quite alien to me, possibly because as a very visibly disabled woman constantly being looked at is even more complicated) but straight cismen in general don't like being visually objectified one bit. So this desire of mine to visually consume them just falls flat because it is met from the other side with emotions ranging from indifference over discomfort to hostility. It makes sense to me that this desire then finds an outlet in "boys who like boys" because these boys do want to be (visually) desired.

M

"You may just have to represent yourself." Yes! Gladly!

Andee Blacksugar

Nuanced, scholarly and entertaining. Thank you for your peerless work!

Declan

Is that a goddam Herzog AI voice?!

IHateBerwald

I just wanna say I was bating my breath for you to namedrop Portrait Of A Lady On Fire and it made my week❤️❤️

Austin F

a thought i have about the male gaze vs the 'female gaze': there's a certain type of fictional character i've noticed attracts both gay men and bi/straight women. it's a man that's vulnerable in some way, but not like a tiny pretty twink. there's a sizeable corner of the internet where calling a fictional man "pathetic" is more of a compliment than an insult. typical traits of this type of man include being old, depressed, unkempt, openly unhappy, and functioning very poorly. bonus points if he presents himself as functional, but the truth is less dignified. (examples: harry from disco elysium, obi wan kenobi from star wars, the older version of wolverine from xmen, soldier 76 from overwatch, grunkle stan from gravity falls, etc. animated men are more common here but live-action ones are very available too) out of all of the spaces i've been in that have involved sexualizing men, the ones for gay men and the ones for women are often almost entirely separate. but in these spaces, i've found a much more equal ratio. in these spaces, these men are sexualized in a way that is a lot more like the male gaze, no matter the gender of the person writing it. the phrase "fuck the old man" is very common, lol. i'm not sure if there's any element of posturing to this, but at the very least, everyone involved does seem genuinely into it.

godliath

This was a wonderful video! I really enjoyed the academic aspects of it, and you described the nuances of the subject so well. It was especially interesting to consider it alongside my experiences as someone who is ace and bi, and also nonbinary maybe. Something this video reminded me of was this great Tumblr post I read not too long ago describing why straight women are drawn to romances with an "alpha" love interest (macho, aggressive, rippling abs, borderline abusive depending on your POV, etc.). This is something I've struggled long to understand because my ideal male love interest is the complete opposite of this, personality-wise. I thought the post did a great job breaking down this trope in an empathetic way, and there's more than one overlap with concepts you discuss in the video. https://www.tumblr.com/darlingofdots/716389876510162944/this-is-obviously-not-exclusively-a-cishet-woman

ingerfieee

that you are able to put all of these complex thoughts and feelings into words, wow, i am simply blown away. great great video, thank you natalie❣️

Philip

Sexologist Jack Morin observes two ways gay male and female desire differ in "The Erotic Mind" 1) gay male tend to fantasize about encounters with multiple partners, whereas women do less (especially lesbians) 2) women often incorporate a sense of place in their fantasies, especially exotic or idyllic locations. Also, he notes that yearning and eroticization of body parts are universal to all people. I think his concept of the "erotic paradox" comports well with a lot of what is observed in this tangent. Thank you for posting!

Veronika Volkov

Two words, Thoren Bradley. All you need to know about hetero femme sexuality. As a woman who loves muscular men and especially big biceps, I’ve always resented the narrative that women “don’t actually like muscles”. I was actually convinced of that so much so that I didn’t realize what actually turned me on until my late 20s. I can show you some instagram account with comments with plenty of women drooling over muscle men.

JoshuaAnolick

Great video! In the description you express concern that you might be getting bogged down in citations. I don't think this is a problem at all. As a heavy consumer of video essays I usually feel starved for the kind of substantive scholarship you provide here. At one point you bring up Lacan and say you will get to him later, but unless I missed something you don't mention him again. I was always a bit bothered by the fact that Mulvey cites Lacan but uses the word 'gaze' in a way that is pretty different from Lacan's concept. I've never read Berger's explanation of the male gaze, does he fill this gap? Regarding your dissatisfaction with theoretical explanations of sexual fetishes, have you read The Denial of Death by Ernest Becker? He makes an explicit attempt to improve on Freud's explanation and suggests that a fetish is formed to make sexuality abstract and avoid the anxieties of becoming emotionally engulfed in the biological process of copulation: "The fetish object represents the magical means for transforming animality into something transcendent and thereby assuring a liberation of the personality from the standardized, bland, and earthbound flesh. Such a liberation gives one the courage to perform the sexual act, as he is not bound to it in an animal way but already transcends it symbolically." I feel like this theory also has some interesting implications for the question of why men are more likely to have fetishes.

Øyvind Rønningstad

This is such a fantastic video, truly eye opening for me. I would love to hear more about the way you use "introverted" in this video, because I have a feeling it will be calling me out.

sw

tht was sick as hell.. would love to hear any other insights you have around different evolutions/expressions of desire and attraction for non hetero relationships<3

Grady Wiehe

“We can have a little objectification - as a treat” I truly think you’re one of the best comedians working today. Especially in your recent work, you’ve really mastered the one-liner.

Lani Geiger

To understand the female gaze one must simply listen to Taylor Swift

Feid

As an nb butch lesbian I think your segment about lesbian gazing rings really true. I’ve been so thoroughly traumatized and treated horribly by men that I don’t want to put that same feeling onto the women I’m into. Especially as I’ve become more masculine through transition I feel closed off from romantically or sexually pursuing women, and as a result I’ve stifled my own sexuality. My best solution so far has been to treat women with a very “gentleman” like quality, holding doors, defending, whatever kind of thing like that, but even then I don’t know if that’s what women want and if I’m infantilizing or objectifying them by doing that, even though it’s not like I’m trying to get something out of it. Anyways. Great video!

Lani Geiger

*persephone herself is but a voice*

viruviruviru

My 10 year old brain trying not to laugh every time you say "gaze" and "yearn" cause it sounds like "gays" and "urine"

Darren DM

Absolute banger of a tangent. Bravo. 👏

Frostfalls

Re: the two components of the male gaze, it's interesting how at least for gay male relationships the subject of objectification and identification are often the same--many guys lusting after big, sweaty, muscular guys want to be big, sweaty, muscular guys themselves. I've found a nice circle of gay men that I regularly interact with on social media, many into kink, and to me it feels like I'm witnessing uninhibited attraction to male bodies where there is no limiting or shameful factor. I often feel bad for straight people because I don't know if many of them can experience this degree of sexual freedom and mutual looking.

CrystalJade

Great Tangent! This was beautifully done. I like how you covered psychoanalytic concepts by example rather than the fine detail. I just loved listening to how you’ve explored this! Part of this feels related to differences in the importance and ways of establishing trust and truthfulness in light of the power dynamic. Some see that men default to display (perceived ideals of inter-masculine competition), and women to masquerade (to evaluate recognition of subjectivity). That does feel reductive, particularly given how popular media seems to invert these positions when it comes to the question of desire. Next on my reading list is ‘What is sex?’ by Alenka Zupancic. You’ve inspired me to pick this up soon!

Random person

This was a very interesting video and I look forward to checking out the citations. It might be beyond the scope of this video, but I think men of color don't slot right into this dynamic (at least not in the Western society, which I'm part of). I think men of color are often dehumanized in a way that white man are not (the most obvious example being the stereotypes about black men and their genitalia, and that's just the tip of the iceberg).

Austin F

as a bit of a swiftie myself, this is insanely accurate, even more than i realized. 'love story' and 'you belong with me' are definitely the teenage female gaze, while 'cruel summer' is a more adult version

Austin F

straight people will never experience the bonding moment of a group of gay men sending each other pictures of various large men and saying "daddy" like a bunch of parrots

零 Rei

As someone who is nonbinary and increasingly tending towards agender (but not aromantic or asexual) and who has big desires but does not particularly want to be perceived / seen by anyone, including myself, this gave me a lot to think about. It feels like so much of my gender identity is tangled up in the warring factions within myself that on the one hand are very driven by visual / physical erotic stimuli but on the other are driven by a need to join with others' subjectivity (how I would describe what you call "identification"), a strong wish to understand and be understood by others, and a terror of rejection. (Don't worry, I have a pretty good therapist.) I think in a very real sense this is the core of my non-binaryness and bisexuality – a feeling that I belong in both and neither camp coupled with a discomfort with heteropatriarchal socialization and how it manifests inside me. If you were going to expand on this tangent to move it onto the main channel, I think it would be interesting to explore the ways in which wlw / femslash and mlm / slash fandoms differ. I'm an avid fan of yuri media and struggle with a lot of BL / yaoi stuff for reasons that have a lot less to do with aesthetics and a lot more to do with the different ways that power relations and psychic hierarchy are enacted in the different styles of non-cishet erotica. And also I find the ways in which cis het male yuri fandom and cis het female yaoi / BL fandom are similar and different pretty revealing of the dynamics you discuss in this video.

零 Rei

Also this was great and something I really needed at this particular time and place in my life. Thank you.

Ju Hana

I need needed this so bad. I come from a very patriarchal country, where women have no education or power, no boundaries. I have been struggling so much with my internalized misogyny which as a woman is really ruining my life. I have been objectified since I was a child, and since a child learned that I am just an object to consume. Thank you for explaining this so deeply ❤️

Frostfalls

Yes to that, and especially sending selfies and going "fuuuccckkk bro 🥵" to each other 😆

Studioroom

OMG u completely nailed this. This is MFA shit baby

ell

Any other fujoshis feeling seen right about now?

Nicholas Coffin

Really into seeing more psychoanalysis being included in your videos. And have been really happy with the tangents. Looking forward to next month's!

Ale Kenward

Cis-het woman here. I can chip in about the female gaze. I thoroughly identify with the woman who wanted to see Thor nude. I did not watch the entirety of Aquaman because of the plot. No, I saw that piece of garbage because of Jason Momoa (and Patrick Wilson). I think it's there, but we have been shamed so much that we do not dare to just enjoy looking at men. I also think Anglosaxon women are less willing to engage in that behaviour, but Latin-american women do like to look at men. There is a reason why so many women follow soccer, because of the likes of Cristiano Ronaldo.

J Jones

I haven't finished the video entirely yet, but I just have one quibble. Early in the video you mention that women reading erotic content generate a visual image in their mind and therefore isn't that the same thing as being aroused visually. I don't think it is the same. With an imagined visualization, you have complete freedom to imagine it with whatever personal nuances are needed for it to "do it" for you. Whereas with an image, everything is explicit, predefined, unambiguous. These really are not the same at all.

highclass_lady

(Oversharing for the sake of research) I recently had my 1st ahem experience with a lesbian (as a baby bi) at a club & she kept telling me that I kept "acting like a porn star performing for straight men" & that I "didn't have to be like that" to be sexy for her. She expected some kind of maybe not "performance" per say (cause I feel like that's a tricky word) but like a sexual role or performance from me that was completely divorced from the male gaze. A sort of more "correct" lesbianism that has never been shaped by the male gaze. I was unable to fulfill that to her satisfaction because perfectly embodying a completely unfamiliar approach to sexuality instantly was too unrealistic of an expectation to place on me on the spot in 1 evening. I grew up surrounded by hetero normative male-gaze portrayals of sexiness, & what I perceive as sexy has been shaped by the society I live in. For me I wasn't trying to play a role with her or "perform" I wasn't even trying to "be sexy" until she said anything, than how to be sexy, but in a "correct" way was all I could think about. I guess my ideas of what it means to "be sexy" have always been shaped by the influences of being desired by men. (Sorry this is so long, you said you wanted different perspectives so I hope this might be helpful) In Ways of Seeing, Berger discusses the observer & the observed. I've never not been somewhat objectified or observed. As a very young child, my parents wanted me to be in beauty pageants when I grew up. I remember being a little girl in a hotel swimming pool & this man just wouldn't stop staring at me, leering, following me, asking where I was going, I was 8 or maybe younger. I remember getting catcalled by guys in cars when I was 9 or 10 at the mall with my friends. My parents' expectations, to be a beauty queen someday, to be talented, (along with abuse I won't mention) took such a toll on me that I developed anorexia starting at age 10. It was so bad for 3 years that I lost my period for a year, permanently stunted my growth & never got any taller (disappointing my parents even further by not being tall enough for beauty pageants something they'd started wanting since I was 2 or 3). In high school, I had friends who were every man's dream & I got treated as a 2nd class citizen by comparison by guys who didn't find me attractive in contrast to how my hotter friends got treated. For me being seen as "dateable" for the 1st time was a monumental experience; partly because it was by somebody I admired. I knew what it was like to be seen as an object or to be sexualized, but to be seen as desirable, not just sexually, but as a dateable person by someone I admired was eye-opening. I think I craved that. I think the desire to be desired, to feel genuinely wanted as a person, to be seen as relationship-worthy, was something I somewhat conflated with, or at least tried to recreate or substitute with, the attention & the simulation of being desired /admired offered by social media. I wanted to be wanted, I may have been invisible to most of the guys at my school, but secretly on Instagram I became this micro influencer, dozens, sometimes hundreds of comments from guys saying they thought I was beautiful. I was 15 when my Instagram started taking off, & (due to some abusive family stuff) if I couldn't be loved back home, & I was invisible in school, then the allure of secretly being "somebody" online (that was the opposite of my everyday life) felt like it was filling a void somehwere when I didn't feel loved & I desperately needed something. I would later retire from being an "instagrammer" because I didn't like feeling so objectified anymore, or as in the tangent, dehumanized. What once had been "for me" felt like it wasn't anymore. When I was 19, during a student trip in Hong Kong I had a fling with this popular guy who was a total chad, my social status changed overnight, girls were telling me how envious they were that he had chosen me, & the way he looked at me felt intoxicatingly amazing. At ages 20-21 when I was living in Paris, the sexual harassment, & the incredibly racist versions of sexual harassment, were so intense & invasive that I decided I would never want to live in Paris long term or raise any hypothetical future daughters there. There's a difference between Hong Kong & Paris, between how I felt in those situations. I think a lot of men fail to see how women simultaneously want to feel desired, while not wanting to be harassed, objectified (dehumanized) or leered at which feels invasive. I've seen perspectives from men that felt like they were conflating the two, wanting to be desired, especially by someone you esteem, with "well you want to be desired, yet you call everything sexual harassment" etc etc; but those male gaze-y viewpoints completely fail to consider the woman's consent, & therefore fail to sympathize with her & see her as human. You can want to be desired by someone you admire AND want to not be treated as public property by men. My years of trying to be sexy on Instagram have undoubtedly shaped how I both consciously & unintentionally enact & embody sexiness, it's lead to the realization that I don't know how to see or understand my body as sexy or sexual outside of the male gaze; maybe part of that is my core insecurity issues of not feeling desirable, of never feeling pretty enough or beautiful, or sexy in the 1st place. Maybe part of it is still feeling like the undesired girl next to my much hotter friends & the shitty way that guys treat girls they're not attracted to. I think 1 of the problems with the male gaze is that, by assuming men are the main characters, they fail to see the impact the male gaze & it's implications & repercussions can have on women & how this affects our lives. This was probably way too much for a comment section, but whatever the case, I hope this is useful for your research. What you do is wonderful Natalie, I learn so much from you every time, you're amazing.

Lani Geiger

Such yearning! It seems to me that the point of relatability for a Taylor Swift song is the yearning itself; many love songs written by men are about the object of desire, and many pop-girl songs are about *being* the object of desire, but Taylor Swift songs are about the feeling of desire itself, or the narrative aspect. I’m reminded of this bit from Rilke’s First Duino Elegy: “But if you are yearning, then sing the lovers: for long their notorious feelings have not been immortal enough. Those, you almost envied them, the forsaken, that you found as loving as those who were satisfied. ” (love is the journey as much as it is the destination)

Capra_a_hircus

One thing about slashfic/BL/gay erotica written by women that I rarely see discussed is the way that it, for many participants, functions a lot like the way drag functions for gay men. (Drag kings of course also exist, as does yuri. But I think there are compelling parallels among all of these.) Sure, there is some element of adopting a male perspective to sidestep the contradictions of seeing and being seen, that Natalie talks about. A way of avoiding heterosexist expectations in fantasy. But, a lot of slash is deeply, deeply interested in exploring the experience of being a woman, being an object of desire, being penetrated, being submissive, being dominant, being objectified, even desiring women, all kinds of topics that aren't inherent to womanhood but which intersect with womanhood in interesting ways. It's just that many people find it easier to discuss (and eroticise) topics relating to their own experience if they do so from a lateral rather than literal perspective. It's not dissimilar to the preference many queer people have for allegorical vs literal representations.

Wissa

Wow look at all these super in depth comments! Natalie you hit it out of the park! I’m reminded of my own mess of a video sort of about “femboys” and fetishism, which I am too scared to rewatch because cringe. All I can say is, as embarrassing as it is, when I was a teenager the main number one reason I was thankful to be born a woman was because I believed if I wasn’t, I would somehow not have been able to enjoy BL as much as I did. I’m a weird type of asexual so that was really my only desired sexual outlet of any kind. I felt totally fulfilled by it and didn’t want anything else, ha. It’s like crack, that’s why so many fandom wars are fought over it. The truth is that this caused me to be a big believer in differences between (generalized) sexuality of men and women. I was so happy to be a woman because it represented like a secret, underground, hidden sexual perspective that they could never find or enjoy in the way I did. The point about the androgynous nature of mlm romance interests me especially because I’ve tried and tried to deconstruct how I actually viewed my make believe characters, were they really men? There was one point in my early life when I had this traumatizing realization that men were very different in real life than I had imagined them to be, my characters were in fact androgynous and that I had no real access to the true (more mundane) male experience. So what is going on? What version of men do I have in my head that produced these fantasies? I don’t even know if I can answer that.

Lauren Danielle

Fantastic as usual. 💜 The objectification conversation is super interesting—I would have to agree that there is a distinction between objectification and dehumanization. I’ve recently been thinking of my sexuality (and female sexuality in general) like a kind of essence that demands a sturdy container. I am the one that fills—you are the container for me. Human sexuality feels like a mutual filling-being filled kind of phenomenon (Literally and not literally.) We are both filling and containing. One thing I think is important to add to the conversation, especially in considering how objectification operates in gay male spaces is how race comes into play. (This is obv true in het/other queer relationships too.) I do think it’s true that men, at least at surface level, have less issues on the whole with objectification because of the intersection power, idealism and desirability, but for those same reasons it gets pretty hairy when race is thrown in the mix. The sexual objectification that many black men (and other BIPOC) feel in queer spaces is definitely a function of racism, which I imagine works pretty similarly to how women experience the dehumanizing aspects of objectification. I think that a culture of unnuanced, causal objectification in gay men’s spaces is also a reason why predatory racist sexual abuse is so prevalent. The amount of horror stories I have heard personally from friends and seen online is disturbing and horrifyingly mundane.

Frostfalls

Great point on how it's different in Latino culture, now that you mention it discussion on this tends to have a very ameri/eurocentric bend to it

Yesyesyesohyes

Cis vers gay man with a triple-digit body count here. People who aren’t gay men sometimes express envy when I share stories of my sexploits. Straight men usually envious of how easy sex can be for me, and women usually envious of the disposability/detachment I’m usually able to treat sexual partners with. it’s always made me feel low key lucky. The different dualities of a person’s sexuality that you lay out here—male/female, subject/object, gay/hetero—are such an interesting way to understand the different reactions people have to my slut stories. Anyways, thanks for churning out thoughtful, thought-provoking videos on the reg for us! We are so lucky! 👀💚

Jonathan Lum

If this got the full main channel Contrapoints treatment, this would easily be one of your best videos. Excellent work Natalie, your b tier content is still some of the best on Youtube.

John Giacobello

Thank you for this balanced approach (“we can have a little objectification, as a treat”💕). As one of the male gays I’ve always been put off by this topic - partly because it made me feel invisible (assumed heterosexuality) and, as you pointed out, the frequent lack of precise language and nuance it tends to be thrown around with. It does in some cases come off as an attack on visual pleasure, something I would not could not live without. Your Opulence video brought me such joy. At the same time I do wonder… when I’m worshipping at the altar of GaGa or Kylie, in their bespangled glory, am I objectifying or identifying? I think it’s somewhere in between. “I started to cry, cause I wanted to be dressed just the same”

Liz Mednick

My best example of the female gaze is Amélie. I know it was written by two men but I think they got it right. Y'know, there are some things the French just do better. The plot involves a lot of yearning, but the initial spark is absolutely visual and scoptophilic. And the porn shop scenes are hilarious. Anyway, loved the Tangent. Can't wait for the main channel version.

Narcissa Deville

So as a trans lesbian who writes m/m erotic fanfic I did kind of want to talk about this since I felt personally called out by that section. lol I'm fascinated by the idea of like it's an idea of guiltlessly enjoying sexuality because I would definitely say I do understand that. And I know for a lot of fanfic writers like me you do identify more with one character who you maybe imbue with your own kind of desires and fears and aspirations. I have written both f/f erotic fanfic and m/m and I think the reason I've gone back to m/m erotic fanfic is also a lot to do with like (at least for me) it's easier to have a distance in writing about these two male characters because I'm not a man whereas when you write about two women it's like *yearning intensifies*--hmm maybe this isn't helping my case. Amazing content as always!

Frostfalls

100% to all of this, exactly, I also tend to avoid this discussion because it induces some level of shame for being drawn to visual pleasure. But because it's usually a heterosexual-focused discussion it's hard to see what parts even apply to us. A common theme of the problem seems to be consent, but there is a level of mutual consent to objectifying each other, as we regularly do in gay spaces, and the power dynamic is inherently different as all parties are men. As for pop stars that's a mystery to me. What is it about them that has us drawn like moths to a flame while straight men appear to be uninterested? Is it identification with the themes of their music? I don't know if I buy that. Is it just that we have less to "lose" socially by admitting we like them, while straight men may listen in secret? I don't know about that either.

Warble42069

I think in my subjective experience, as a gay man, I do experience sexuality visually. But I wonder how much of that is shaped by media. I remember seeing gay porn for the first time and seeing other men's muscular bodies and dicks and thinking "this is what I'm attracted to? This? Ok guess that's it". While I have the body-dysmorphic-yearning to look like the hypermasculine muscle bro, I find myself experiencing attraction to all sorts of male bodies as well. I also long to experience the stereotypical "female" sexuality of emotional intimacy. One thing I would like to say is that as a gay man, I do feel very uncomfortable being leered at and objectified by other men. It makes me feel self-conscious and gross and I sometimes find myself avoiding queer men's spaces because I don't want to be objectified or have a million dudes try to get me to come to the bathroom/darkroom with them. Sometimes it feels like my personhood is negated by their desire to fuck me. I also worry that I do that to other men. Definitely have some shit work out there.

John Giacobello

A “diva worship tangent” would be enlightening 😊

Aristana Scourtas

I loved this tangent. The lesbian bed death thing really struck me — I’ve always resented that trope but perhaps I’ve just been afraid that it might be true. I think that also as queer women (and non-binary people etc) we bring so much trauma to the bedroom. Like, so so much. Your joke line about young women being traumatized to the point of neurosis before they even come of age really hit home. Unfortunately. And in sapphic relationships, you have not only one person carrying that trauma but TWO. Not exactly good for consistent spicy sexy time.

Aristana Scourtas

Also your m/m fic section made me thing of the book A Strange and Stubborn Endurance by Foz Meadows. Foz is (afaik) a sapphic non-binary person. The book is fantasy m/m where one character experiences sexual violence and then most of the story is about healing and embracing love and sexuality post trauma. As an SA survivor, it really struck me how much more approachable the story was when it was m/m vs if it were m/f or f/f. If a women or highly feminine character was the one who experienced violence I don’t think I could’ve read the story. But because it was men, it felt less close to my own traumas and I was able to not only enjoy it but learn from it greatly. ❤️

Aristana Scourtas

Also it’s a kickass book, would highly recommend

Luiza Lodder

Contra, you are one of the grandest thinkers of our generation. Thank you for these vids

Lucy Peck

In love with this woman. Period.

Emily

I think the thing in this video I am most willing to attribute to being 100% socialization is the female sexual narcissism thing. Am I to believe that, in a world where men are equally taught to groom obsessively and take pride in their appearance, there wouldn’t be a male culture of wearing cute outfits to the gym? Don’t men spend time flexing in mirrors already, sans the lingerie?

Emily

Thought #2 is that I really vibe with your point that “male sexuality is visual” could very well be just because visual media is made by men. IMO the most powerful counterpoint to this is k-pop, which is all visuals. (Boy bands in general. Plus the recent popularity of semi-canonically gay c-dramas like The Untamed.) Sure, the fans will still invest themselves in the elaborate lore, but I don’t see that as separate from the visual aspect.

O Bow

Part of what made me realize i was trans was how i interacted with men sexually. I would unconsciously act out what i thought they wanted from me as a female partner. Submissive, making noise but not too much noise. It was all so curated and usually left me disgusted and ashamed. dating a trans woman and taking on a traditionally masculine role in bed was the first time sex didn't make me dysphoric, and i could finally focus on a partner's pleasure instead of performing my own.

roxyamused

I think the lack of objectification by women is because society doesn't cosign women and femmes as sexual beings, while the male gaze is cosigned and even praised to the point that, even to perform masculinity correctly, a masculine person must objectify their object of desire- which that term "object of desire" is dehumanising and kinda cosigns it. I think the way society treats sexual minorities like us shows us this. Lesbians are either considered hyper sexual for the male gaze, or sort of asexual and chaste; while gay men are just super sluts going to glory holes on their lunch break and have very active Grindr profiles. These are the extremes that I think are slowly being balanced out from the self determination, openness, and communal discussion we currently have the ability to actualise. Victorian (and the millennia prior) sexual ideals are still being shaken off since our self determination/feminist/sexually realising/less strict class divides (though that seems to be changing for the worse)/etc society is really very new, so in a lot of ways it's difficult to theorise the inherence of any particular gaze with the historic societal sexual baggage that is being lugged around with any of these discussions. I don't know or think that any form of gaze, male or female in simple terms, is inherent. I just think society hands us glasses that are often not really our prescription but being told they are just our prescription and we have to accept it, despite the spectacles warping our subjective reality, making us nauseous and giving us headaches. How close the glasses are to our prescription makes it easier or harder. I actually think we're figuring out how to get better glasses, it's just we keep getting kinda shit optometrists. Each generation it seems the optometrists slowly get better.

FredShoey

Thanks for the video link. Mozilla has not been liking most embedded video from content creators I follow.

Tom Burke

Email to my friend about the above video, from one Baltimorean to another Baltimorean: Tom here, I hope you're recovering from your cold. I just watched a video by Contrapoints, available only on her Patreon, entitled "The Male Gaze," which provided me much food for thought. The video is in part a summary of the concept, both popular and academic, of "the male gaze," as such (intended specifically, as indubitably you know, to describe heterosexual male cinematography, and which you've discussed with me r.e. the Wachowski sisters' tremendously lesbian movie, Bound ?). Admittedly I don't spend much time thinking about straight male desire, probably because it strikes me as ubiquitous and therefore uninteresting, for obvious reasons. As our culture has historically been one of male heterosexuality, that sexuality is so deeply encoded in society as to be conventional, "uncomplicated." As Natalie points out, this is hardly the case, but with respect to mass media and pornography, it very much is uninteresting, at least to me. Indeed, Natalie's "Tangent" on the male gaze is, like so much of her work, refreshing insofar as it complicates major discourses occurring across various social media platforms, most especially Twitter, Tumblr, Tiktok, and Reddit, but even so in academic, or "academic," circles. Heterosexual male sexuality (loathe as I am to admit that any man, especially any man attractive to me, might indeed be heterosexual) is not the same thing as "the male gaze," for example. For my part, Natalie's video made me think about my own relationship to women. As a fiction writer, I do, perhaps foolishly, feel I can write a convincing woman. I've attached my latest short story, which was just discussed in workshop and of which a substantial portion is made of a woman's perspective, to receive your blessing on this front (ha-ha, I'd just like you to read it). At least, none of the women in workshop criticized my treatment of Agnes in this story. But, well, does she "feel" like a woman? I can't say. As you know, I'm a great believer in the imaginative and empathic capacities of the human mind, and as such do not believe any person's representational capacity to be confined by his race/ sex/ gender/ sexuality/ nationality. I do not believe that any such ethnographic (Are not even "man" or "woman" ethnographic categories?) designation runs "all the way down," that is, these categories are purely superficially phenomenological, never metaphysical, nor even deeply phenomenological. No, they are superficially phenomenological. Is my philoso-babble here meaningless? Apologies. I do, lately, at any rate believe that even ever-"skeptical" leftists in fact operate within a Christian moral framework that goes so far as to inform their phenomenologies, their epistemologies. Never mind the colonial impact of Christianity! Never mind the hypocrisy of a leftist Christian, an academic Christian, an anti-colonialist Christian, an anti-Christian Christian! No, they shall re-impose their moral system upon the world in contradistinction to the capitalist liberal system, and by sheer dint of its tepid "kindness" it shall overtake the world! Never mind, of all things, what wins or what loses, bloodshed or war, finance or trade, no, never mind, indeed, the great horrid teeming swath of reality cross which we walk, the pipes, the sewage, the cables, the internet, in short the infrastructure, let it all rot and whither, for we have socialism, and Marx is our Jesus, and He is perpetually reincarnate! Never mind the horrors of revolution, for they shall never come to pass. Thus we pass elegantly across the moral high ground, trailing our moral pessimism like a bridal shroud, they won't let us win, ha! At any rate, apologies for that little rant, back to my relationship to that nebulous category: women. My father, as you know, had eight sisters and a mother (Agnes, the eldest, having died three or so years ago.). He therefore grew up within a matriarchy. Among my aunties, men are regarded, more or less, as breeding stallions of two varieties. They exist to make money and to help to produce children, but beyond that they aren't good for much. Indeed my aunts regard me, much as I've earned a modicum of respect by being my father's son and by being gay, in the same way. "How," one asked, "will you support yourself?" "Aunt Hilarie," I wanted to say, "I am nineteen and have no family and no dependents, I needn't bother with supporting anyone for the time being!" At any rate, in the manner that many women grow up in an atmosphere within which they are "daddy's favorite" yet fundamentally not quite respected as people, so did my father: his mother's favorite by virtue of his sex, and yet among the most explicitly powerful members of his family his sisters regarded as an exceptional member of the second sex. Granted, he has the massive advantage of having grown up in a patriarchal society, so his upbringing was an ideal blend of both. Thus he is a maternal father, a womanly man. My mother, while perhaps a female chauvinist, is nevertheless a woman, and a second wave feminist (Perhaps?). She has an undeniable conservative streak, but she has enormous self-respect and respect for the vast majority of women: why, she asks, don't they respect themselves the way that she does? Men, meanwhile, have the freedom, by virtue of their sociopolitical dominance, to be "sluts" in a way women mayn't: meaning that they may dress revealingly, and my mother will bite her finger appreciatively in response. (So many hot joggers!) Men may be objectified like objects; women must be appreciated like art. Now, I hunger for men. I understand cannibalism as a metaphor for sexual desire: I watch a jogger's muscular legs and lower ass pump along, and I feel a lust not unlike hunger. I sit across my room from poor Flynn, my cohort mate, and all I can think about is blowing him, swallowing his flesh and ingesting its excretion. My gaze, the homosexual male gaze, lingers along his bulging fatty-muscular thighs, towards his short-shorts and his outward-puffing crotch, the crotch, the groin, seeming swollen in those shorts. This is manifestly gay. I've recently decided my celebrity crush is Ross Lynch, specifically in Troye Sivan's music video for "One of Your Girls." How gay! The flesh, the expression, the painted nails, the unbuttoned jeans, seductive in a manner I've rarely known, make me hungry. That hunger is so essential, so, indeed, "primal," I have trouble believing it is located solely within the male sex. Indeed, I do not. But how are we to reconcile these things? I've never understood why men struggle to write women, but probably that's my own ignorance of women. Still, in my paradoxical narcissism, I believe I might write anyone, I might depict the sexuality of anyone. Did not del Toro depict some crucial female sexual impulse in The Shape of Water? Natalie, in her video, says there's discourse over women's "appropriation" of gay men's sexuality for m/m fanfic and yaoi and BL and so on. Bullshit, I say! Let them write what they want! I've fruitfully ingested such content. Who are these people policing (often gay) women's depiction of mlm romance? Women, I presume. I don't think gay men give a shit. We're too busy debating the ethics of straight men performing in porn targeted at gay men (once more, I could give a shit). I struggle, perhaps because of my own privilege, to understand the difficulty so many, particularly men, seem to face in writing women. I do recall once saying to Caroline and Kyle, formerly Kylie, "My sister's friends have been asking me for advice on the SAT IIs, and I don't get it. Just take the test in whatever classes you're best in, and you'll get a 700 or higher." They both looked at me with a blankness intended to indicate something. Eventually Kyle said it, "But you're smart, Tom." So maybe I take my own basic human fucking empathy for granted? Or the requisite intelligence to substitute for empathy? I guess "as a gay man" it's easier for me to empathize with women? But Tolstoy, who was manifestly straight, wrote manifestly wonderful women of various kinds. The Bechdel test has nothing on War and Peace or Anna Karenina. So I don't know what's going on here. I have the following massive, gaping blindspot: I am a man. Yet sexualities are various: to treat men's sexualities, women's sexualities, as monoliths is profoundly misguided. So where do we go from here, in terms of gender politics? Dunno. Dunno, Tom

Annabelle_Thann

Some of your best content yet! I would love to see this turned into a main channel video someday. As a genderfluid person who was raised a girl and only somewhat recently began going by another name and other pronouns, part 8 really hit home. When I identified as cis het and then cis bi while dating my boyfriend of seven years, I felt guilty about enjoying m/m content, but it scratched an itch nothing else did. It's honestly part of what forced me to contend with my gender identity and non-cis-ness. Seeing in this video that others who very firmly identify as women, and other sapphic women too, experience a kind of gender fluidity when consuming erotic m/m media, makes me feel less alone... but also once again reeling over my own identity. I know that my masculinity is not only present in a sexual context, but I admittedly do struggle to define what it is. Sometimes I'll feel like a man, or close to it, for days on end, and reach for a testosterone consult, but then something will happen--whether it be a reaffirmation of sisterhood or, unfortunately often, experiencing or witnessing misogyny--that reminds me of my ties to womanhood and girlhood. As you said, I think this association of trauma, harmful objectification, etc of femininity and by extension feminine sexuality is what leads to guilt and distancing from sexual desire. I'm with a woman now, and feel far more hangups and guilt over my sexual urges with her, ESPECIALLY when in masc mode. I am so terrified of hurting her the way men so often hurt women, and while I dealt with sexual shame with my boyfriend, it was a different flavor. The shame of "letting someone take me" that faded with time and as I grew up and rejected purity culture, vs. the shame of potentially enacting harmful desire upon the woman I love, are entirely different beasts. All of this is further complicated by body-brain disconnects, but I don't want to get too into things that personal. Anyway, all of this to say that I found this video deeply intriguing and engaging in a way that was both academic and personal to me, and really appreciate all the research that clearly went into it.

Eric Kaplan

honestly learning to identify with women is tough but also super interesting -- the hardest job you'll ever love.

Rebecca C

Half way through this tangent. I feel so far there is one obvious bit missing when we talk about female sexuality and gaze: we live in a society where it is not supposed to be public, and where it is also not meant to be public. Also: female sexuality is - as mentioned - supposed to bolster the male ego, not diminish it. Hence leering women undressing the self-conscious man with their gaze are evil or a joke. Whereas the male hero helping the woman gain confidence through his lust for her, is a thing which again boisters the male ego, while telling women to yearn for male approval. Also what I am missing so far is the bit, where male gaze is the shot of a male slowly taking in a woman, bit by bit. And it is perfectly fine. The same scene with reversed gender roles would have a very different effect and is usually kept out of male sight in "chick flicks" and romance novels.

Nele B

this is such a masterpiece and could easily be a main channel vid! the part about female narcissism was so spot on and relevant, natalie WHEN are u writing a book!!!

Kirsty

As a straight cis woman who reads and writes male monster x female human fics…well, we are more a minority compared to m/m human fanfic writers. I do see us getting way more shaming then people who like m/m fics, which are probably considered pretty normal at this point. (Like weird example - slashers - when it came out that some fans like pennywise in the recent IT films, there were so many articles freaking out, asking “wait!!!they just like the actor under the makeup right?! Not the child eating monster no way😭 - people were so anxious over the idea that some people might fantasize about a monster clown - even though all other slashers also have a minority of female fans thirsting in erotica - so there’s probably more who felt shamed out of their feelings) I bring this up because you talked about women not having as many heterosexual fantasies but I think it’s an interesting thing - the Edward cullens and other monster men kinda show a female sexuality interested in male monstrosity. Some of these characters aren’t human at all (like your tumblr post part) but a subsection of women love this stuff, both consensual and non con fantasies. No one’s ever attacked my writings (and they are pretty wacky lmao) but I’ve seen the twitter dramas. The way people throw around abuse/p word because they think your fantasy reflects on real life is so ridiculous. I think liking predator/prey dynamics in erotica is completely normal, and perhaps liking monsters in erotica is a way for women to also shed the “stigma” that comes with a human man as love interest etc… Thanks for this video, loved and definitely gonna rewatch many times :))

Lani Geiger

Ok, so random thought: I think there’s a serious neglect of the “I can fix him” element of female romantic desire that comes from (IMO) a woman identifying with someone’s pain and wanting to provide relief to herself by providing relief to them, transmuting both of their pain into love and connection. I do think there’s something about the stereotypical female romantic/sexual fantasy that is very much about the connectivity with the other, whereas the quintessential male fantasy is about (not really sure how to phrase this, since I’m not a dude but I’ll give it my best shot) the conquering and assimilation of the other into their own ego (while simultaneously losing themselves in the other? idk).

🕸️Eli

Straight porn isn't gross because of objectification (consensual objectification is hot), it's gross because of its non-consensual subtext; it's violent, not in a hot kinky way, but in a rapey, woman-hating way, in a world where women get silenced, subjugated, harassed, raped, and murdered daily. I don't know how it is over there in the first world, but over here it's as clear as the light of the day that the sexual violence pictured in straight porn is not fun BDSM roleplay where men play as doms and women as subs (c'mon that's way too nuanced for a man who doesn't wash his own ass 'cause he thinks it's gay), but just traditional gender roles in the bedroom broadcasted for the average man to enjoy, the same man with misogynistic opinions and ideas, religious or otherwise, who votes against women's rights.

Jussi Eskelinen

This is one of the things that makes me feel like a bad homosexual – I have no interest in divas whatsoever. I can appreciate the music and the art when it's good, but I don't see them as relatable. Instead, I wish it was those bearded sweaty beefcakes singing industrial metal songs about their experiences of gay love. I don't mean this in a bad way, but I wonder if diva worship is mostly just a 1900s mass media phenomenon that's easy to latch on to, because historically a woman could publicly express the things a gay man never could – desire for men, oppression, heartbreak, etc.

Austin F

definitely. i think a lot of songs by female pop stars attempt to bridge the gap and appeal to both male and female sexuality, each one a bit more to one side than the other. that's not an attack on them, it's just how mass marketing works. what i've noticed is that the music that is clearly for women tends to be more like "ruminations". it's more poetic, more about yearning and desire, things are often stated a bit less plainly. i think the biggest recent examples of this are taylor and adele. it's no coincidence that these two have sold an absolutely ridiculous amount of albums, either, way more than any other artist in the past couple decades. (in the past few years, it's seemed like olivia rodrigo and billie eilish are also taking on this title, and they are ALSO huge album sellers)

Sarrasinae

This tangent feels very relevant today as I delete my Grindr account. Too many chasers. I felt so many reduced me down to a fetish object with a dick rather than an actualised subject. Gross.

Julia

This is my favourite video of yours so far. Since SRS I'm rather struggling with my own sexuality: Being attracted to women while being a women but simultaneously being primarily turned on by a male-female sexual dynamic. How do you reconcile those? Was SRS or even my whole transition a mistake, even though I'm happy about the changes in other areas of live? It's relieving to hear that I am not the only women with a complex relation to sexuality and gender. I think the video is helping me understand my own sexuality as well as the sexuality of others.

Austin F

(fellow gay man here) when i was younger, i found i hated being sexualized after i had first met more creepy men. once i had bad experiences with gross men, it started being hard to separate any kind of sexualization from someone being predatory. that faded a bit once i had more positive mutual experiences, but the apprehension has never completely left. i wonder if that's how a lot of women feel in general

Ads

This vid has made me want to hear more about your perhaps (or perhaps not) overstated turn towards the Freudian.

Julia

I think maybe the most important part of nen learning to identify with women is to reduce social gender segregation from a young age. Boys need to be friends with girls. I think many men have never been in a mixed friend group (or the one girl was „not like the other girls“) and as a result don't understand women at all. I guess consuming media with good portrail of women could be an alternative to having actual women as friends but I don't think it would be quite as effective.

highclass_lady

I feel like a lot of what another Patron, 🕸️Eli, commented can also be said regarding the fetishization of Asian women & a version of racist sexualization which I think is worth mentioning. Eli wrote: "Straight porn isn't gross because of objectification (consensual objectification is hot), it's gross because of its non-consensual subtext; it's violent, not in a hot kinky way, but in a rapey, woman-hating way, in a world where women get silenced, subjugated, harassed, raped, and murdered daily. I don't know how it is over there in the first world, but over here it's as clear as the light of the day that the sexual violence pictured in straight porn is not fun BDSM roleplay where men play as doms and women as subs (c'mon that's way too nuanced for a man who doesn't wash his own ass 'cause he thinks it's gay), but just traditional gender roles in the bedroom broadcasted for the average man to enjoy, the same man with misogynistic opinions and ideas, religious or otherwise, who votes against women's rights." (End quote) Personally, I don't think I've ever watched any porn featuring Asian women, because the thumbnails alone suggest something that would be an incredibly degrading & painful experience that I may find triggering. I have, however, experienced what it was like being an Asian woman on dating apps, & an Asian woman on social media, & to walk down the street in different countries wearing different levels of modesty as an Asian woman. A lot of people wouldn't believe the stuff that gets said to me, I've basically sworn off dating apps forever at this point. By fetishization & objectification (in this context) we mean something that overshadows your humanity, effectively erasing your personhood in the eyes of the beholder. When being an Asian is what people see as a justification to reduce you to a fantasy or a disposable or abusable piece of meat, as less than human compared to some of your white women peers that they are less overtly degrading to, there's little to no chance to ever be comfortable with someone being attracted to you because of your race. In a way Asian fetish "submission" is too often seen as an automatic reduction of the need to ask for consent, a reduction in the agency, humanity, & dignity that makes a human being seen as someone who needs to be asked in the 1st place. Too often, just being Asian is presumed as, or seen as "permission" or an invitation. Being Asian is not inherently sexual. I imagine this is similar to how some people, well, conservatives, often see being trans as implicitly sexual even though trans people are literally just existing, being. Being an Asian woman does not grant permission for someone to sexualize me or make assumptions about my sexual preferences or invite inappropriate comments, much like being trans does not automatically make someone available to being approached with sexually suggestive comments. Being Asian does not give men permission to follow me down the street yelling racist things or in some cases racist sexualized things. It's also why I won't dress in traditional Chinese clothing or Japanese schoolgirl uniform stuff for someone in the bedroom, it's a trust issue, after a lifetime of objectification (dehumanization) I have to be sure this wasn't the reason they wanted me all along. It probably doesn't help that I'm 4ft 10, have a babyface which adds to looking really young, have naturally giant breasts & fit into like 5 significant fetish categories. I never want to submit to someone because they've chosen me because they see me as someone who will submit to them & fulfill an "Asian girl" fantasy. I want to submit to someone (in bed only) because I love them & trust them completely, & enjoy feeling desired, enjoyed, & "taken" by the person I desire & want to be chosen by. For context, I'm Asian-American (adopted, not culturally Asian) & have lived in the US, France, & England

Elina K

natalie casually dropping these videos as she isn't changing my life and giving voice experiences i've never been able to🙇‍♀️

highclass_lady

Eli I hope this is okay but I wrote kind of a derivative comment further down in the comments section, you stated this comment so well that I just wanted to cite what you said & I added onto it in my own comment. I hope that's okay in this discourse comments section setting, please let me know if you'd rather I remove your quote from my comment

Austin F

i don't know if this sounds dismissive towards men here, but i feel like a lot of the reason so many men don't understand the gap between being desired (what people want) vs being dehumanized (what feels terrible) is because they don't have much experience with it. as a gay, once i started being sexualized by other men without my consent (ugh tumblr was so bad about this), it really sunk in for me how bad it feels. you don't feel desired, you feel demeaned. 'feel like a piece of meat' is a common metaphor people use, and while that's accurate, it also made me feel like a doll that they were projecting anything they wanted onto. these men didn't know me, they just looked at me and decided what i am because that was what they wanted me to be. it feels intrusive and wrong. i think a lot of men don't get it. they see it as "well, i want someone to be attracted to me". but a creepy man isn't really attracted to you; he's attracted to the version of you he has in his head. he has decided what you are, without your consent or input. he's decided you are "innocent" or "sweet" or "cool", and it doesn't matter if you really are those things or not, because he isn't interested in you as a person, just as a doll. and because men are powerful (especially in groups), his decision feels like it has more impact than yours ever will. idk. i guess that's more my personal experience, but from what i've read, i think it's a similar feeling to how most people feel when they get objectified by men

Vanessa Formato

Wonderful as always! I was interested to hear your take on Magic Mike, and I really hoped you'd also specifically bring up Magic Mike XXL, which I think does a much better job of actually embodying the female gaze. I've seen both movies, and they're night and day in terms of how they frame both the men and the idea of women's pleasure. Laura Crone on YouTube has an excellent video on the topic!

highclass_lady

I think what you wrote here is incredibly insightful, & as I currently understand it, I think I totally agree with it. I have an additional, less directly on-topic thought that your comment led me towards: Honestly, this might be why, as a grown woman, I so often have gotten girlish crushes on very effeminate gay men after they've become close friends: they don't desire me, so it feels safe. I am reassured that they aren't objectifying me in such a way, because they aren't sexually attracted to me at all, therefore I trust their platonic affection because there's not a chance that underneath it's somehow sexually perverse. He's without a doubt not attracted to a doll version of me & in my miserable mind, that assurance gives me "permission" to have a middle-school tier crush on him. A man who's probably older than me, likely shares some interests in fashion, art & culture, & can love me (as a friend) but without the sexual dynamic, my dream come true right?

🕸️Eli

Don't worry, quote me to your heart's content

🕸️Eli

What I meant by "objectification" was fixation on a body part, including the dehumanization that comes with it. I think this is fine as long as you have consent. If you don't then it is gross and not okay. Isn't all sex like that? Though I can see how easily it could turn racist when objectifying Asian features as signalers of sexual submission and availability.

Laura G

I'm an older (nearly twice your age, I think) trans woman who has been at this a while and who passes well. On a vacation recently I was swimming in a rooftop hotel pool with a bar. I wasn't really thinking about much of anything except how nice the warm sun and the pool water felt when I noticed there was a man about my age at the bar definitely watching me and grinning. He kept it up. At exactly the same time it was kind of creepy ( I am dammit NOT a piece of meat and was he going to follow me and try something?) and my vanity/narcissism giggled because he apparently found me attractive and I was reminded that I was trans and felt very affirmed. The gaze is like lasagna. Layers of all sorts of things cooked in a sauce.

Deconstruction Interactive

Love the video as per uzh! I thought it was challenging but ultimately very satisfying how you set up an interaction between the male gaze rooted in objectification through repressing guilt and shame and being seen and the female gaze sublimating the shame and guilt associated with being the object of seeing. It made me reflect on the meaning of the word "to see" a lot, which is always fun. On the genderfluid gaze and the eternal gender war: I see where you're coming from, though also I can say I don't think the "war" will be quite as intense if men follow your demand number 1, to identify more with women. I have an unusual perspective on this I admit, as someone who identified as a guy most of my life and now identify as non-binary. In the process, I have begun to identify with women more, and a lot of the guilt / shame / opposition is reduced. I do *not* mean to imply that there should be or will be more non-binary people as time goes on, but just that straight cis men can also go on this journey and it will reduce, but not erase, some of their internalized feelings of guilt and shame, and reduce the need for objectification of women.

Ale Kenward

I think that many women like bad-boys masculine men, but there's a difference between who teen girls like and who adult women like. As a teen it is true that overt masculinity is off-putting, but I know few women past 30 who like a smooth-chinned guy. They do exist, many women past 30 like BTS guys, but many others like soccer players and rappers.

Ella Miss

I literally do this. I began producing music and entertainment media that I can relate to and feel like represents myself. I hope to empower other women to do the same. Thank you for this. I dance burlesque, produce 80s inspired synth and perform with a gay acrobatic but not overly muscular person.

Sam Fletcher

Great video, all the quotations felt relevant and insightful. Really interesting topic, and this is the most coherent explanation of the whole picture I've heard.

highclass_lady

I think there's different types & intensities of objectification, it's really more of an umbrella term. There's Freud's definition, & I think a lot of more broad associations & societal understandings of objectification also get clumped together. I think the type I was describing here is where objectifying an attribute, or a combination of physical attributes is done so in a way that flattens a person into an idea, a collection of characteristics, thus stripping her of her humanity & , at least mentally "relieving" the observer of some of the self-consciousness hang-ups that would arise if he saw her humanity as his equal. There's a long-ingrained history of racism & inequality; I think that many instances of partialism objectification & fixations on particular body parts are less complex than racism dynamics. I have a thing for collarbones, but I personally don't find that attraction supersedes or overtakes the rest; I have to be attracted to the person who has the prominent collarbones, & I'm not going to be attracted to someone just for the sake of their collarbones if I don't already like the rest. So maybe my attraction isn't as strong what is typically considered fetishes, because I can't just isolate & build a fantasy on that alone, but if it is still a fetish, I think my attraction to collar bones is fine as long as, like you said, consent, don't be weird, etc. I also don't think there's anything inherently wrong with being attracted to someone who is Asian (gosh it's also degrading to be seen as inherently undesirable) it's more like when someone's attracted to an idea of an Asian woman for those other fairly disturbing reasons that Asian fetishes become harmful in ways & to extents that other body part objectification might not always be.

Ale Kenward

I'm into fashion history youtube and a creator made a video once on how hot Regency men were, and showed a bunch of portraits. There was even a reddit thread about how inappropriate it was that she "objectified" all those men, which happened to have lived 300 years ago. But she not only admired their fine form, also identified them by name and even told stories about their lives. How is that objectification?. I think women police their desire (and others) way too much, hence the "wrong" idea that female sexuality is "tamer". Only white feminists think that in Latin America, even when there are evidences to the contrary, but it helps to construct a narrative of women as passive victims.

Vilu

I don't agree with your conclusion, simply for the fact that maybe the byass it's considering man and women like they are two different worlds. I'm a cis straight woman and I live my sexuality like you describe the male sexuality, and I've been with men that live their sexuality like you describe women sexuality. I think that all the wiews about sex are singular and peculiar and it depends on culture, how you grew up, what you've read, what you've watched, what you've been tought. Basing on my personal experience, I don't think there is a male and a female wiew of sexuality, the people I meet heve different desires and ways of enjoying sex. Also, all the male gaze thing it's purely cultural and it's just the consequence of how men are tought, direcly or inderectly, to behave or to just be.

John Giacobello

Maybe… the music industry has become incredibly savvy about marketing to gay men, and it’s more profitable overall to sell a Madonna or a Britney than a Rob Halford. I do enjoy watching Rob Halford and Freddie Mercury do their sweaty man things. And I experience a different kind of visual pleasure when viewing the spectacle of a pop diva performance than say, a visually stunning Laurie Anderson show. But with our pop stars I feel there’s something deeper going on than latching on to a media phenomenon. Worship of female idols can be spiritual and predates Judy Garland. Maybe being raised Christian with just the one male God to worship has left me seeking some kind of symmetry.

Ann C

I'm in awe of people who can write thoughtful and intelligent comments so soon after viewing the video. I have to let the content simmer in my brain for a while, so I'll comment about lingerie instead. I enjoy lingerie for its sensuous aspects—silk or satin on skin, pretty colors, soft lace. When my husband gives me lingerie as a gift (who is it really for?), it is far sexier, less comfortable, and more visually appealing for him. Still, I appreciate that, even after a long marriage, he still enjoys how I look in sexy things. 
 p.s. Natalie, did you see the comment on Twitter indicating the this video was open to non-patrons?

Andrew Hanson

Section 6 was interesting. My wife and I have talked about this a lot over the years of this weird conflict between being socialised, growing up in the 90’s, to somehow satisfy and cultivate male attention, with the deep unease and disgust it causes. There was a particularly weird period when we lived in Japan where she felt the attention disappear and also then with it the need to satisfy it that she was oddly uneasy and disassociated by.

Jussi Eskelinen

The Twitter comment about wearing sexy lingerie reminded me of the phenomenon in the (gay) kink world that is known as “stealth leather/rubber/PVC/thonging/etc”, where you wear kinky underwear, or sometimes an entire outfit, under your normal day-to-day clothes, just to feel sexy on your own during the day. Can’t help but think that this is just a version of it. I think there’s probably very little space for (straight) men to engage in this kind of behavior in heteronormative masculinity, because patriarchy judges this to be “gay”.

Abigail

When it comes to lingerie and dressing sexy, part of the thrill of it, form me is crossing the line from Madonna to Whore. Good girls don't wear those things. Rose disrobing in front of Jack and asking him to treat her like he treated the French whores, and to leave a record of her sensuality, something she was supposed to hide and save for her husband, its an absolutely thrilling idea.

Abigail

But I don't dress sexy everyday, not just because of work rules, but because of male retaliation. I want attention, but I don't want to be honked at by strangers in passing cars. I want to be seen as beautiful when I sit at the bar, but I don't want to put at the end of the night. So I'm left with contradictory female narcissism.

no

sometimes we need a moment to lingerie on the impact that the video left within us first (so sorry!!)

Ren

As an ace person who finds everything about this baffling, I really appreciate Natalie’s care to say things like “most” or “generally.” I don’t mind being reminded that I’m an outlier but I hate being erased, and Natalie doesn’t erase me. 🥰

Anna the Smiling Cat

40-something years old trans lesbian who started transitioning fairly recently, don't pass, still married to the woman I met before I started questioning and possibly sort-of-asexual but not sure about that. Can't make any sense of it when it comes to myself. Interesting topic though.

Paige Cirtwill

Exactly! The implications this discussion has on romantic relationships and intimacy in general are huge. I think a lot of the myth that women and men have inherently different sexual drives is related to the idea that romance and intimacy are things women desire, but men should not. I truly think The Culture so thoroughly associates intimacy with femininity that a lot of insecure men can’t accept their own desire for intimacy, so the desire is sublimated into something purely sexual.

Haemophilus

It definitely was interesting when I went to my first play party (which happened to be t4t tho I know generally queer BDSM play parties are also like this) just how different the portrayal of BDSM in porn was different than the BDSM in queer spaces. BDSM in queer spaces is very much play, it's all theater. I think cis heterosexuality and the visual demands of porn can warp people's imaginations of what BDSM is actually like.

Studioroom

Such a great video. I lived in San Francisco for 15 years. When I traveled other cities like Seattle or LA men would LOOK at me and it was pretty easy to meat men. But in SF strait men have learned not to make eye contact with strangers. I guess it was something about that gaze.

Lani Geiger

I honestly sometimes feel like men are so out of touch with their own emotions and corporeal existence that for a lot of them sex is one of the only ways they can really feel embodied (by literally using someone else’s body lmao). I have no idea if this is accurate but dudes need to be like practicing mindfulness or something and realizing themselves as complex beings with internal states rather than floating cameras that go smash when angy. (Obviously this is a massive oversimplification and everyone is different etc etc)

Amy Forest

I think if you want to try to define a female gaze, it helps by starting with the it helps to start with the most female dominant science of biology. Let

Maayan Dahan

Heyyyy whats the music at 16:40?

no

female sexual narcissism... well it certainly is made to sound pathetic but i think basically all the inhibitions and unfreedoms cultivate in women feeling ugly & undesirable, not feeling entitled to pleasure, alienation from own body etc, and when those things ease somewhat, especially if at the same time, the sensory pleasure of being a corporeal lifeform kinda hits. i shake ass in front of mirror now. i'd shake ass in mens presence no problem but that would be an expression of bodily freedom thats severely inhibited by the threat of sexual violence and humiliation. and honestly ifl i've resexualized myself through my attraction to women in a sense. i know men find me attractive and it's fine and doesnt ease a single insecurity about my body, but i look at myself and know that there are women who find my ass impressive and my breasts sexually attractive and so on. now thats relatable... doesnt improve my 'body image', but makes it irrelevant to a degree which is more, practically speaking, liberating

🕸️Eli

I don't entirely agree in that it's all theater. I'm gonna be honest and real specific about my sexuality for a moment here, so if that makes you uncomfortable, stop reading. I'm female, ok? And I don't feel sexual attraction in a dainty innocent cutesy way. I feel it as necessity deeper than hunger. It's aggressive and dominant, it's highly visual and totally unrelated to emotions. I'm into androgynous women, men, and enbies, but I particularly like femboys. I like girl-shaped people you could say. I found this out accidentally when a girly twink sat on my thighs and made me feel things I had never felt before. It was not my brain, it was not my heart, it was an overwhelming feeling coming from right between my legs taking control of me, making me think wrong, making me breathe wrong, making me crave wrong things. Wrong as in nonsensical, wrong as in forbidden. It felt not psychological but physiological. It felt as if my body wanted me to impregnate him even though it can't be done. I had never even considered being a top before that day, but it was not something that I had a say on. It's just a truth about myself that was revealed to me on that day. It's just how my body works. So, when I do BDSM or am sexual in general, it's not that I'm taking part in a play similar to theater, more so that I'm given consent to be my true self.

no

it's like: THIS is what i was made to feel bad and conscious about. my body? like, most of me? terrible

Adrianna F

lol I flipped out at that!!

no

also i was surprised to hear that rcrumb's comics were appealing to men and appalling to women. idk. i get it. he's horny and has little interest in performing dignity for the sake of other men. a man's version of shaking of the male gaze auxiliary evil eye thats turned on men themselves

Amy Forest

I think if you want to try to define a female gaze, it helps to start with the most female dominant of sciences; biology. Let's take the trans body as a starting place. It is neither male nor female, since it has traits of both, and when searching for mates, trans people aren't doing the typical showboating assigned to them by their sex. Their approach to life is more soulful, it's a drama, all the world's a stage and the men and women are simply actors. Alright compare this with cis/straight people. Since their bodies already align with their expected behaviour, we might characterize their behaviour as mate searching. A girl puts on makeup in the morning? She's doing to to find a mate. At least this is the position a sociobiologist might take. When men take apart women's bodies and focus on sexualized body parts via the male gaze, that's just biology training for male reproduction. So, what is the corollary, what is the female gaze? Let's say you're at a football game, and you are taking a female perspective to evaluate men. Well you might look to other animals and conclude that males tend to throw extravagant pageants for the chance at having their genetic code passed on. Indeed, under the existentialist frame of mind, there can be no greater honour as existence is otherwise meaningless. Men don't have the biological infrastructure to nurture children on their own, being /selected/ is a necessity for legacy. Otherwise, you live, you die, the end. Side note, it's interesting that women have a lot more freedom in this regard. Once you get pregnant, that baby is yours. Your body is much more poised for child rearing. So being predestined as the offspring sex, while certainly limiting in the historical sense, is much more freeing in its modern incarnation. You never have to worry about your purpose in life, you have the capacity for offspring built right in. You just have to decide for yourself on what terms you accept it. Silly side note <3 Anyway, back to football. So being selected is an important goal for the straight male. Whenever he wins at the game elements of football, he showboats. He is essentially saying "I am male, I am strong, pick me!". I was gonna finish writing this argument and proof read it to make concrete and indisputable or whatever, but fuck that. You can't make a perfect essay, only an incomplete one (and for that matter you can't stop bad faith actors picking apart your work either). I don't really know if this adds anything to the conversation, but i feel i want to be part of the conversation and that's what matters to me

Noah Rouse

straight men need some more sexual narcissism. I had this experience of having sex with a sex therapist (highly recommend), and she talked about this concept of needing to be attracted to yourself. She even talked about masturbating to yourself in the mirror. After I tried that, my perspective on sex really started to change for the better. Like a lot better. I don’t think men will ever be on cardi b and Megan thee stallions level, but if we could get some of that, that’d be great. (Also, this concept was in a book, but don’t remember it.) (Also for context, I’m a man who is very bi-curious, but I’m pretty firmly in the women loving camp.)

M

I always joke with my friends that the male gaze convinced me everyone was looking at and fantasizing about women including me. Everyone looks at women from a place of attraction because all the media I consumed said that. I was SHOCKED when I was told Charlie’s angels 2000s were made for the male gaze and not my bisexual youngling eyes

Noah Rouse

I agree with you, but it is a tricky problem. I work in early childcare and boys and girls naturally just gravitate towards playing with their gender more often. But I think a big reason for this is the simple in group out group that we put them in both using our words and also signifiers (think: we gender them, girls wear their hair long more often and are put in pink, boys wear their hair short and wear anything but pink). It seems so silly, but I think that stuff has a profound effect because it creates a divide so early. The problem is: how are you gonna get parents to change that. I’m not too worried about it, but that’s just what I think about

Noah Rouse

Somehow this seems highly relevant. As a man, I kind of have to think of myself as a scary monster sometimes and just be fine with it.

Frostfalls

Full disclosure, I actually feel very similar to you Jussi. I'm only really interested in popstars when they make art that I genuinely enjoy, but beyond the art I tend not to care much about the divaness of it. I'd be several times more interested if they were a guy I'm attracted to writing gay songs that sound good. But those seem to be few and far between... the closest example I've seen is the Chinese idol group Produce Pandas: a pop idol group of bulkier guys in their late 20s and early 30s, very unusual for the genre. They never explicitly mention the gay community or gay experiences but their fans are almost all gay, particularly gay bears. And funnily coverage by non-gay outlets seems to remain completely oblivious, just going "this idol group promotes body positivity!"

Noah Rouse

I wish I could double like this.

Sev

Great video, I have no smart opinions except I hope the NUDE THOR woman is thriving

Kirsty

You feel you “have” to think of yourself that way? Why’s that?

Turki

I think the concept of the male gaze or objectification of the body has biological component more than social. Look at gay porn for example or gay erotica, there is no fear of identification with the same sex.

Emerson Whittaker

I feel like the way I balance objectification and subjectification is in sort of objectifying/admiring the things a person is confident about, like trying to figure out what they think is hot about themselves and then to see them that way. Maybe that's why I find it hard to be attracted to people who seem unattracted or ambivalent to themselves because it gives me nothing to latch onto. I'm sure this isn't a one size fits all, but whatever, it's kind of fun. Also hard agree that the genderfluid/verse gaze is superior, lol.

Folks,,

Love the video, but I think more consideration can also be given to the AMOUNT that men and women are viewed n society. In your incels video from years ago, you being up the fact that a lot of (heterosexual) men live in an absolute vacuum of attention from the opposite sex (e.g sending messages on dating apps). Why would a young man, who perhaps has never been proactively approached by a woman, be able to imagine being courted; having MANY opportunities, over and over again, where they’re presented with a situation that can tip over into sex? When I was younger, I remember feeling like every time I talked to a girl it was a miracle and this was like, one of my precious few chances to experience sexual pleasure with another human being.

Folks,,

Additionally, there’s a trope (and it might just be a trope) of older women being more forthrightly sexually predatory. Does it have something to do with how women get less male attention (for better and for worse) as they age? Might be correlation not causation but I wonder

Amy Forest

Yeah I'd agree, Britney does look out of place. But I actually think that's a good thing, and she might be enjoying herself more than we think. Brittney of course was persecuted for her sexuality. I imagine she has a complicated relationship to that entire side of herself. By now, post crisis, Brittney has a lot of rebuilding to do, and at an age we have historically shunned from sexuality. So the fact that she tries to reclaim it, is really more inspiring to me. Like yeah, she probably missed a real opportunity to develop herself organically, it's awesome that she's picking up where she left off rather than just banishing herself to "no longer fuckable" world of geriatric women. It's beautiful to see her reclaim that. Very human. Very wow

Mikel

In Spanish (here in Spain at least, don't know about Hispanic America) we do have the word "objeto", but we don't really use the term "objetificación". Instead we say "cosificación", which comes from the word "cosa", that is, "thing" in English, so "cosificación" would be something like "thingification". I've always felt like the Spanish term "cosificación" has much more degrading & dehumanizing connotations (especially when used by feminists, which most often is the context in which it's used) than the English term "objectification", despite being each other's most straightforward translations to the other language & both being used in each language to refer to what is essentially the exact same concept.

Miriam Gold

The topic of women who like m/m erotica was really interesting to me because I am a lesbian woman who enjoys reading m/m w/m and w/w pretty much equally because I don't self insert ever when I'm reading erotica, but I have more of a voyeuristic enjoyment of it. So like if I read straight erotica I don't envision myself as the woman or the man, but rather it is just hot to me that they are into *each other*. I wonder if this is part of the appeal of m/m for women is that it can simply be consumed and enjoyed without identification, you don't need to consider where you fit in the story, you can just enjoy a window into someone else's story. Also I'm curious for other's insight on the relation of this video to the topic of kink. While men seem much more likely to have sexual fetishes, women on average seem much kinkier, with both more women seeming to be kinky, and with a way deeper scope of creative depravity in their fantasies. I wonder how this fits in with the idea that there is something less sexual about women

Miriam Gold

I feel like this has maybe more to do with sexual confidence (which younger women tend to lack for reasons of socialization)

WaitforRain

Find it curious that Natalie didn't take an explicit stance on pornography in this tangent, just a couple mentions and maybe some allusions. And I don't think she ever has? Anything she's ever said about that subject has always been rather ambiguous afaik. (Worth noting that I increasingly find the term itself not useful for discourse, but seeing that the idea of pornography still looms so large in modern discussions about human sexuality, it does stick out to me)

Miriam Gold

I'm a lesbian woman who reads all pairings in erotica and for me the reason this is so easy is because I just don't self-insert, even in lesbian pairings, but rather voyeuristically enjoy the fact that the participants in the story are attracted to each other. I wonder if part of the reason many women like m/m erotica is that it removes the barrier of having to figure out how to fit yourself into the story and just allows you to consume and enjoy without having to want everything happening in the story to be happening to you. Also its a great point about feeling shame about more masc sexual urges. As a very subby kinky bitch, I don't have this fear because I know if something went wrong it would happen *to* me, but I do have a similar fear of being the cause of this sort of shame for my partner. I fear making my partner feel like a bad person for engaging with my submission/masochism and that i could accidentally lead them to engage in activities that would make them feel serious guilt for "hurting" or "degrading" me. I feel this especially with my current partner, who though rlly enjoys it is pretty new to exploring her domme-ness, and sometimes i feel like i'm like corrupting her with my degenerate sexual tastes lol like some adam and eve type shit

ContraPoints

I talked about Lacan in the "subjectification" section that I ended up cutting oops

ContraPoints

by "introverted" I'm trying to describe sexuality that's in its own world, fixating on objects without reference to social interaction or other people's minds. maybe not the best term just the one that came into my head.

deez nuts

The glasses metaphor is fantastic

Don Pepis

we have that in latin america :), i totally agree with you

Mikel

I think there's another type of gay male gaze which is directed at women instead of at men. Us (male) gays struggle to identify with that idealized image of (straight) manhood that other men often narcissistically identify with, so instead we direct that narcissistic gaze to this idealized image of a woman who is extremely successful, fabulous & desired by men. Superficially this image might seem pretty similar to the straight male gaze's image of women, given that it's often extremely sexualized as well, but I think it's actually quite different: the gay male gaze's image of idealized womanhood is a woman who is the object of men's desire, yes, but who above all is not an object nor passive, she's independent, in control, a girlboss ("yaass queen slay!") & driven by her own desire & ambition, not by her desire to satisfy men's desire; she's basically a gay man who happens to not be a man but a super woman. There're some popstars, actresses... who people see as pandering to the male gaze that I'm like... yeah, she's pandering to the male gaze, but not in the way you think: she's pandering to the gay male gaze, not to the straight one (which is completely logical, at this point I think it's far more profitable for most female popstars to cater to gay men than to cater to straight men honestly). I actually think straight men feel threatened by the kind of exaggerated & voracious female sexuality & almost-drag queen-level bimbo ultra-femininity portrayed by the popstars who actually cater to the gay male gaze & not to the straight one, and I think it's kinda funny that people who don't really get the phenomenon think that that extremely sexualized image is for the gratification of straight men's desires & that the whole thing is pretty sexist & backward. A perfect example would be Slayyyter's two most recent music videos https://youtu.be/NxnTxDWbGpg?si=Qnwnfrw4CD1MC_C4 https://youtu.be/U8gtVljq4cg?si=KH3Is5-Q2f8L0Dlv a straight man could perfectly jack off to her watching these videos, but that's not the point nor the intended audience, there's no doubt to me that this is for gay men & for herself.

Shane Cadden

Great video, some interesting ideas that I have found myself questioning a lot recently, however I don't think it is fair to say we should send Andrew Tate to the moon. The moon did nothing to deserve that.

Øyvind Rønningstad

Thanks, is that mostly the same as how you describe "desubjectification"? Or maybe the problematic combination of objectification and desubjectification?

Me Myself I

@Contra regarding the suggested reading for men, how about you suggest some specific books and women to follow? I always try to seek diverse perspectives. But finding high quality people to follow / books to read isn't easy (aka time consuming). I bet you'd have some great suggestions...

Will Donahue

Nothing to add other than I agree with this wholeheartedly... I feel no sexual attraction to women but Slayyyter is appealing to me in an entirely different way. She's like the embodiment of drag queen femininity.

Annabelle_Thann

yes! I'm bisexual but find myself attracted to cis men the least often, and honestly I think it has a lot to do with the lack of sexual narcissism. That seems counterintuitive to all the things I find annoying about typical cis men, ie being unable to empathize with others and believing their experiences are universal, overly centering themselves, their inability to relate with women, inability to anticipate others' needs, etc. But these forms of selfishness are harmful. The one place a form of "selfishness," or rather, self-centeredness or self-confidence, *isn't* harmful, is the sexual narcissism Natalie talks about. When a man is feeling himself--and *truly* feelings himself, not acting or behaving in a way that's meant to be domineering, but just confident and happy with himself, maybe even a little playfully sassy--that shit's hot!!!

leavesarefalling

This topic is so fascinating to me and one that I think about all the time. As a mostly-straight cis woman, I do believe that there is, to some degree, an inherent biological difference in the way most men and most women experience attraction - I do think that men are aroused more by visuals, and women more by concepts. Your theory on the oppressive guilt that women feel about gazing is one that I had never considered, and there may be a lot of truth to it, but without any evidence to back up this statement, it just doesn't FEEL true to me. Or at least, it doesn't feel like the whole story. You're definitely on to something with the "yearning" theory, BUT, I think the truth is more along the lines of what I said before, visuals vs. concepts. For some women, maybe the concept is the chaste, slow-burn Darcy hand flex (which feels very safe and far from male violence), but if you look at the endless streams of fic that involve BDSM or straight up non-con, you'll see that for lots of women, the concept involves submission, ownership, etc. - actually, in line with male-gaze pornography, and the kind of male sexuality that you proposed may just be incompatible with female sexuality. In my mind, they're completely compatible, it's just that when we look for representations of the act rather than engaging in the act itself, men want to see it, and women want to conceptualize/think about it. I also have to say, "the female gaze is not magic mike, but harry and draco" absolutely took me the fuck out. It's SO TRUE. I've been trying to tell people this for years, lol. Your whole section on women who like m/m content was extremely validating - referring to it as stigmatized, rather than fetishizing. Maybe it is fetishizing, who am I to make that judgment, but it was refreshing to hear from someone who thinks maybe it's just an okay space for women to experience sexual fantasy without a traditional inherent power dynamic. Also also, as it was so eloquently put, bitches really do like twinks. I am bitches. Speaking generally, a man's ideal man is a god-to-the-incels bodybuilder, and a woman's ideal man is much closer to Prince Caspian; he's got some sort of feminine energy. I think there is a female equivalent - a woman's ideal woman (skinny, decorated for the sake of the rhinestones being pretty), versus a man's ideal woman (curvy, breasting boobily). Sometimes I am performing for the voyeuristic man inside my gaze, and perhaps just as often it is for the part of me that loves my favorite color.

Gee

Well done! Another great piece of work. Your insight is, as always, enlightening. Thanks.

Austin F

i disagree about getting more shaming; i think people who like gay romance of any kind are mocked/insulted for it anytime their content is actually exposed to mainstream audiences, and the only reason you don't see them getting mocked more often is because those audiences completely avoid their stories. as a guy, if i ever bring up any kind of gay romance around other guys - whether something as serious as brokeback mountain or something as fanciful as slash fanfic - i'm almost certain to get a negative response. i can't tell you how many stupid and annoying 'jokes' i heard when we'd have any reading in my college courses that had gay romance, which always just amounted to "omG tHOsE GuYs diD IT iN thE BuTt sO WEirD aND grOSS XD"

Austin F

i totally agree about shame. i was treated pretty horribly by straight men growing up, and one of my biggest fantasies now is to have a man that's both masculine/strong and also wants to protect me. i always felt afraid of men, and all i ever wanted was for someone strong to stand up for me and save me because i couldn't do it myself. there's also an element of me wanting validation from the same type of man that rejected me so brutally. yeesh, i should unpack that one in therapy.

Austin F

with regards to m/m shipping being fetishizing - as a gay man, i think a lot of it is fetishizing, but i also don't think it really matters. the art we indulge in doesn't need to be 100% PC, and fanfic is very easy to avoid if it puts you off. as long as they're not acting weird towards gay men in real life, it's not that important. the only time it genuinely annoys me is when fans of it try to portray it as some kind of progressive statement lol

Kirsty

I wasn’t talking about mainstream audiences- I was talking about fandom - where gay romance is considered normal by comparison - I’ve seen the harassment creators get for making darker content involving monsters etc… Also it sounds like you need better guy friends who respect your likes!

Mikel

She just gets it, what a queen!

Amanda Miranda

What an amazing video essay! Curious to see the upcoming tangent on identity. Thanks. + I really wish you and Annie from girls guts and giallo would get together someday and talk about fetishism, lesbianism and horror movies.

Roisin Isner

I do think the sexual narcissism thing is true, and I think men do it too. Like, the guy that tried to create a story for women that ended up mostly appealing to men, I think those sorts of fantasies of working class TESTOSTERONE are masculine sexual narcissism. Cis-men are more obsessed with penises than anyone else. Gay cis-men, straight cis-men. Obsessed. Think of cis-men obsessing over women's penises too. They are so obsessed with penises. I've noticed that straight women are mostly whatever about specifics like penis size, and sexologist research suggests this is true. It's not that women don't care about penises, just not in the same Size Queen obsessive way. We don't treat penises the way straight men treat boobs. And this makes sense, because people who have sex with cis-women aren't obsessed with the specifics of vulvas. Labia Queen is not a thing. Any focus on vulvas begins and ends with preferences about the amount of pupic hair. And certainly, in the queer femme community I am in which includes a lot of transfem people, there is zero preoccupation with penises. I have sympathy with this cis-masculine penis obsession -- it's right in front of the body, hanging out, dangling around, becoming erect. It's an interesting thing. Something to measure, and something to easily symbolize as a part of the whole -- the penis is a partial representation for one's entire sexuality. For the experience of sex itself. In my experience, women don't like straight porn designed for cis-men, because it's all about centering the penis. Everything is about seeing what the penis is doing, so it's difficult to self-insert and fantasize that we are the woman on screen in a way that is pleasurable. I also think, with certain music videos especially, or Britney's instagram, there is an immediate AVERSION that some straight men have -- because it is SO not for them -- that they start trying to use a combination of warped feminism and weird Victorian prudishness to argue against it. I think it's threatening because they feel like feminine exhibitionism should be *for them*, and then sometimes it isn't. And that's confusing and scary and feels wrong. And whenever I ask non-toxic men about this, they answer something like, "that is very cool, and not for my benefit." But even the non-toxic men feel a little threatened by it -- and they don't want to Gaze at it. It doesn't invite their Gaze. Basically, it's repellent. Anyway. I always end up watching these tangents with my partner (a cis-ish guy) just because we love them. We always have lots of conversations about them after. And this time, it opened up a way for us to articulate deeply important perspectives about our sexualities that was really productive and great! I don't think I've ever had a convo with a partner before that had such clarity and specificity about my experience as subject and object as a woman. I really liked the point that objectification can be kinda hot -- because both of us ofc derive pleasure from sometimes feeling like the object for the other, and enjoying the sexual narcissism we give each other. In bed, I feel like I flit between identifying as myself and identifying as my partner. That's the fun of sex. So many straight men are incapable of having sexually gratifying experiences because they're terrified of identifying with women, which also consequently makes them bad in bed. So yeah, this video rules. I've read and watched so much about the Male Gaze and never seen something as nuanced and resonant as this. Yeah, a lot of the discourse de-sexes women in a way that just feels so Victorian. Like sure I AM soft and diffuse and interested and emotions and yearning and whatever, but I'm not ONLY that. I don't want to be told that that's all I am or the totality of what I am limited to. Maybe sometimes I can also get off on objectifying my twinky boyfriend, and I get off on it because he's getting off on it because I'm getting off on it etc.

Austin F

sadly, guy friends that are respectful towards men that like "gay" things are not easy to find irl outside of specifically LGBT groups. honestly, many men tend to be really mean when they're only around other guys. while a lot of straight men won't directly say "i hate gays" to your face, they'll make a lot of 'jokes' that they think are so funny. and when you're gay, you have to be "chill" about it, or else you're one of Those Gays that 'gets offended by everything'. honestly, there's a lot to be said about having to be the "chill gay". it's kind of like the concept of the "cool girl" in gone girl, lmao

h

I think as well with your example of Cara Delevingne just like abjectly leering at meaghan thee is that, not only are there some women who don’t feel shame in being the one who looks or holding the gaze but also, in this specific example, it’s a White woman objectifying a Black woman, which is obviously a whole other later that could be woven into a discussion of The Gaze. The ‘Eating the Other’ and all that

ContraPoints

Yeah I remember an interview with Jinkx Monsoon, who said (on the topic of Jessica Rabbit) that straight men and gay men have the same fantasies. I do think Jessica Rabbit is “male gaze” but in a way that’s more gay than not, more about wanting to be her.

ContraPoints

Honestly I’m inhibited by the YouTube terms of service. Maybe someday I’ll do a pornography analysis video and host it on a different website lol

ContraPoints

Wow yes “cosificación” is much better than “objectification.” I might try to use “thingify” in the future as an English substitute

ContraPoints

I do think that straight men wanting to experience more desire-objectification from women is widely unrecognized and unsatisfied. I think women are often reluctant to be “too forward” with men, out of fear of “inciting” a dangerous/out-of-control sexual response, or just of being unfeminine. But it’s something that should probably get talked about more in straight circles

Folks,,

Great points; like many straight men I totally didn’t even consider that a woman being the approacher doesn’t equate to continued agency in the situation and the fear of “inciting” or otherwise losing control of the situation makes total sense. Thanks for the response, and yeah — another mark in favor of this kind of thing being talked about, in all of its nuance, among straights

Folks,,

Definitely makes sense

Magali

Oh thanks for that comment, i find that I agree. I want to add, I remember years ago I started seriously wondering and wondering why it was so very rare that straight men would have a sense of fashion or dressed purposefully or had their own style.

Ellen Owens

I actually don’t think Natalie would disagree with you here, or rather she is more interested in the conversation to be had with the world *before* we can have the conversation you’re outlining above. Of course women want to pursue their desires like men, but they don’t as easily due to shame of doing the gazing. Men would like to participate in sexual narcissism but they don’t as easily because they fell shame about being the desired/gazed upon one. But most conversations reinforce these seemingly neo-Victorian beliefs about sexually. I felt that Natalie’s argument was “so let’s talk about the shame so we can let everyone just pursue the desires that they want to pursue.” Like you, my wife (cis) felt this perspective on many womens shame was all new. She very much doesn’t feel shame about gazing or pursuing. On the other hand I totally do and felt like I 100% hit the shame Natalie was outlining. She does lean into the binary a bit at the end which I appreciate her tackling, don’t know if I agree with her. But on the whole I think she’s acknowledging the fluidity you’re describing, it’s just under our own surfaces.

Tanner Gore

Okay but this kinda ate….

Magali

Thank you so much for this great tangent! I really am curious of what would come with (a lot) more women/queer lenses in media! (I actually think it’s not true that it wouldn’t sell, I’m sure It would) When I spot some i almost always feel something special. I think it simply has to do with the absence of traditional cis het guy gazes, a bit like going to a queer club or space and the feeling of freedom and ease that goes with it, but in a movie (yay portrait de la jeune fille en feu:)) and I really like your recommendations at the end and also yes to the fluid gaze!

Molly McCormick

As a late blooming lesbian in the midst of mucking through decades of sexual repression and internalized homophobia, I really appreciate the content and timing of this tangent. A huge part of coming out to myself was repeatedly confronting and accepting that I am allowed to enjoy looking at women, that this isn't inherently creepy or forbidden. It really messed with my head to repress my entire sexuality without realizing that's what I was doing, and it's a huge struggle to get that part of my brain to relax. Like rationally I understand that I am out as gay, trying to look gay, but there's part of me that's like "okay but if tell a woman she's hot then she might think I'm gay??" Anyway I'm exhausted, love your content, deeply appreciative of any and all lesbian theorizing, and would love to see a subjectivity tangent or mini tangent or w/e at some point.

Andrew May

My wife and I watched this together and enjoyed many moments of pausing to discuss. Thanks for such excellent content! Tangents are premium shit at this point. We’re ending with the wondering if desire itself is so generally stigmatized in our puritanical, “persecuting society” (to quote Bronski), and we have internalized so much shame about even desiring another, that “male gaze” is being over applied in discourse about desire itself. That desiring is such a sin, and, in academic discourse, “male gaze” is as well, that we’ve substituted the former for the latter. All desire is male gaze, is objectifying, is dehumanizing. Oh dear. How ashamed we are.

Ren

Your first demand reminds me a lot of Jane Ward’s argument in The Tragedy of Heterosexuality (intentionally provocative title, excellent book) that straight men need to learn from lesbians how to actually like women.

Arica Schuett

Loved this. I don't have any profound comment to make besides saying this is one of my favorite you've ever done. Perhaps my favorite since Envy. Your evolution is always relevant, never dull. Can't wait to rewatch and share with others.

e_staff

If I have to be in the forever gender war, I’m glad I’m equipped with your Tangents.

shai

loved loved loved this one. Definitely deserves to be a main channel video bc imo this is a sorely needed contribution to the convo around this topic

Ema Agafitei

The female narcisism theory at least, in part, is real. I find myself dessireble when I desire myself, there is a egocentrism to it. And shame following the egocentrism. And I do think that the clasical conceptions of female gaze and female seggsuality are very behind. There are women that do most of the things that men do, we just do not talk about it or just achnoledge it to ourselves. Corporality is not a sin in the XXIth century, or, at least, I hope that. On the female perspective, I would consider also Helene Cixous's essay, The Laugh of the Medusa, it is deffinetely a tad more avant garde than psychoanalytical +/ feminist theory. Corporality is not a sin, again. And women, from the empirical data I gathered as a women are attracted by the dinamics between male gay lovers. And as You Yourself mentioned. Most gay erotical novels written by women and I would argue have a voyoristic aspect to it, to add to your argument. And also a control incentive to it, women strife for control. Women do have a desire to control and dominate, how dare we, so maybe that we partly compensate for the instances they felt weak and exposed. Or under the Male gaze. The prospective of the male gaze is also a great instrumet of surveillance, a man might not watch at every point of your day or general existence, but it feels like it, especially for victoms of seggsual violence. I came to the conclusion there is a biopolitic of the male gaze, and in the extreme opressive cases it becomes necropower, in instances where women are considered possesions, sub human, souless. So the female gaze should exist as a reactinary element, it is in our interest as a feminist movement for the female gaze or at least the angroginous, non male gaze to exist and treaten the status quo. It leads me to the next point, there is a facette to the female perspective that wants to inspire fear and visceral rejection to other people, not only the male gaze. And there is another point to the women being attracted by the feeling or the longing, women are in fact attracted by the means of Language. Might be due to the historical burden of having to interpret every small cue that we became better at Language, so that reflects upon us by finding ourselves disireing either very subtle and fragile type of sexual experiences or the more edgy/violent ones. I do personally wager that the mistery of what attracts women is in the Language. Language as in code, means of communication that include the non-verbal, the fleathing microexpressions and the CONTEXT. Men are about the text, women are about the context. And I would say that the gender non conforming people are about the intertext. I would wish to add, even if probably no one would read this, that to me the ambiguous nature of female desire seems as a deffense mecanism, an adaptation to the harsh existence throughout history. Or I am just halucinating at 2AM. Either way, it was a great video.

Rahneian Madsgs

But this is a relatively recent phenomenon, which might have ties to the Atwood quote about being your own voyeur. Women's view of their sexuality as fluid can be argued to be a byproduct of male desires codified in our patriarchal culture that women consume both consciously and subconsciously. In the ancient world (to varying degrees), men's sexuality was understood as fluid and women's sexuality was all but rendered invisible and lacking of true sexual lust. But the men these men would find appealing tended to be more effete. I think viewing your sexuality as fluid doesn't explain desiring people of the opposite sex whom you can identify with using a masculine-feminine dichotomy.

Beth S

I have no idea what to do with this thought, but like probably everyone else, I always try to map on my own experiences when thinking through these discussions, and I do think there's something to the perspective of, well, "ugly" women. People who have not experienced real-world visceral examples of feeling their bodies be objectified, because men (or others) seem to be wholly uninterested in their bodies. Because at least for me, despite never having felt that literal objectification, all these same concepts around what it is to be "seen by men" still feel very real and applicable to parts of my life. I suppose one could argue that this is because at the end of the day men will still just view all women as a hole, but I dunno. Dissatisfying explanation. I also have this notion that there's a media trope of "ugly" women being more horny or pervy than "normal" women, and while I'm sure that's usually not much deeper than the joke of how horrible it would be to be pursued by such a creature, it strikes me that there's also a sense that such women are more free to be that way. I also don't know what to make of that, one of many reasons why I pay Natalie for her thoughts and not the reverse.

Lauren Greenspan

I realized I was queer in my 30s. Burst into tears the other day when my therapist said to me: "Your desire for women does not make you a predator."

Hannah Lazarte

The way you articulate your point is so satisfying

Lana Robert

This is such a good video I almost think it should be free to the public. It's not just good, it's important.

Chrombus

“Might have to keep that one simpler!” Promises promises. But great video! Is there a place to see all the sources you cite? I always want to get the books you mention in your videos, but then I don’t write them down and you know.

Opinionated Online

I'm glad to see someone critique how "The Male Gaze" and "The Female Gaze" have been used online a lot recently. Thank you especially for critiquing the ways "The Male/Female Gaze" discourse online promotes "Neo-Victorian" gender stereotypes about male sexuality and especially female sexuality. It's something I've been bothered by so I generally just ignore that online discourse. But, it's nice to see you respectfully critiquing it. It's strange when otherwise progressive people are promoting and encouraging ideas about gender (e.g. that men are more "visual" and women aren't "visual") that I most associate with Evangelicalism. It's something that as a woman I've always felt alienated by. I've also found some (not all) examples of "The Female Gaze" kind of baffling. Things that seem neutral at best. I do not feel at all represented by much of "The Female Gaze" discourse. I do think "The Male Gaze" has some validity when talking about films and media, but it is used incorrectly the vast majority of the time in online discourse (e.g. when it's applied to individual men's (or women's) experiences with visual attraction). "The Female Gaze" discourse, as it currently stands, I feel is less useful. At best, it feels like women projecting what they personally like onto other women and calling it "The Female Gaze." And, at worst, it feels like a traditionalist "Neo-Victorian" effort to downplay women's visual attraction and libido. Even if that's not the intention, and it's coming from generally progressive people. I don't have an issue with the sort of stuff "The Female Gaze" is generally about or people who do feel represented by it, but I wish it had a different name since there will be men who relate to it and women who don't relate to it.

Matthew Mendenhall

I am still processing this content, Natalie, and I appreciate allll of the new intellectual directions for study I could go from here. I just wanted to put this out in the ether and I don’t care if it’s judgy or wrong or disjointed: in my experience, the gay male gaze is going too far. Gay men segregate our social community by body-type likeness and kink. It’s always been this way but maybe it needs to change someday. In Portland Oregon, there is no more exclusive community, besides perhaps the rich, than gay male “bears.” Bears seemly highly idolized and visible in Portland. They orient themselves around Bearracuda which is exactly what it sounds like. It’s a huge gay night club/event serving Bear body types. What am I supposed to do with this information? Clubs catering to a specific type of body? Personally, I’m not a Bear. Nor am I a twink. I’m just… a man. Honestly, my body is a bit curvy on the hips and huge in the chest, my body reads feminine to me. This gives me a lot of trouble as a gay man. Where do I fit in? Where does my friend fit in who is Asian (and feels like he could never be a bear, hello racism in gaze) and, like me, does not have gay male friends anymore because of the idolizing of male form types? I have a close friend who I would like to see again, but he keeps going to Bearracuda events and really Bear/kinky/diva venues. That’s not my cup of tea because I just don’t orient my social life around people I’d want to fuck all the time - I’m a lot more basic than that when it comes to what makes me happy, what bodies I gaze at, and what sounds fun. Did I really just exchange all of the judgy gatekeeping in heteronormativity for a gay male culture that is built and segregated on the gay male gaze? Is anyone else really struggling in similar ways to me?

Matthew Mendenhall

Your knowledge of Freud’s work is really tactile. I don’t know if I’ve ever encountered someone who talks Freudian concepts as effortlessly. Like when you’re able to help us understand what Freud is really getting at within the theory of castration anxiety. What books are you reading about Freudian psychology? If not Freud’s work itself.

Tyler Ray

I think Natalie went way too easy on gay men. She made everything about the male gaze unacceptable with heterosexual while giving gay men a free pass or gave some illogical reason. It comes off as if she’s walking on eggshells not wanting to offend a minority group.

Rose

Thank you for this video and yes the subject definitely deserves its own space. To put my point into context: I’m talking from a French perspective, I am straight woman and I was born in the eighties. Coming back to your question: How different are straight women desires from gay men? I would argue: In an egalitarian world, I think these desires could merge. In today's world, which is still marked by strong inequalities inherited from centuries of patriarchal domination, the desires of straight women and gay men still differ. Because yes, I think that a key to understanding these differences lies notably in the violence of the relationship of domination (real and symbolic violence). I'll make a distinction between women who submit (consciously or unconsciously) to men's desires (1) and those who emancipate themselves from them (2) 1) The Male Gaze or the Dominant Gaze? To understand and move beyond objectification, it may be necessary to look at it in even more detail. To cut it into pieces (ahah). What exactly are we looking at? Personally, I can't think about objectification without thinking about the dominant/dominated, active/passive dichotomy. And this leads me to thinking about violence and fear. For a long time I was subjected to my sexuality because most of my partners were not educated about consent. The images we received from most of the cultural content were also very clear: the man desires, the man submits others to his desire, therefore the woman have to submit. She's being coerced (more or less consciously, depending on the case). For me, this would also explain the taste for non-threatening Twinks, which promise a different kind of sexuality, non-threatening, non-violent. It seems to me that gay men are not in this dynamic. They're (mostly) not afraid of men because they know they can say no, they are much more outspoken than women. Consent is at the heart of their sexuality, whereas traditionally, in heterosexual relationships, consent does not exist. And often nowadays it is still absent. From what I’ve experienced and what I hear around me consent is still very often dreaded by straight people. Yes you read this well, normal people who have not been educated on the topic of consent still cringe at it and even less know how to put it into practice. And that, unfortunately, is how we contribute to reproduce old destructive patterns. An unfortunate aspect of the dominant/dominated dichotomy is that the dominated seek to associate with the dominant in order to survive. What is desirable in this case is no longer pure looks but the attributes that signal membership of the dominant group (in the context of our society: wealth). Because yes, the 50 Shades of Gray scenario would probably work less well with an S&M enthusiast who wasn't wealthy. 2) Pleasure at looking, giving and receiving: pleasure everywhere So now for the desire of women who have overcome this (often unconscious) desire to be dominated. Here I think we need to introduce the concept of the giver and receiver of pleasure, a concept at the heart of consensual sexuality. And what happens when we introduce these notions? You introduce dialogue! And that opens the door to an infinite number of possibilities. In this case, the visual pleasure is still there, but it may play a lesser role. From this perspective, there is no longer any male nor female gaze, because there is no longer a dominant gaze that dictates to all the other gazes what they should see and appreciate. Sexuality returns to the realm of the intimate, the imaginary reclaims its place and the prefabricated morbid desires of consumer society are rejected. Each person does not seek their desire in another person, but rather gaze at their desire within themselves. They begin an exploration that will continue throughout their lives, because sexual desires are not fixed but changeable. A reference that might be interesting to consider for this analysis is the movie Don Jon. For me, this film shows in a way the distinction between the taste of seeing and what may be beyond the pleasure of seeing in sexuality (including losing control over your desire).

Anaïs

Love this tangent so much! Such important topics and well-articulated points that very much resonate with me as much more realistic explanations of how sexuality and gender work in practice than the sort of essentialist, supposedly "progressive" (but really not) theories you critique. Especially love the section on the genderfluid gaze (clearly the superior gaze!) because I do agree there's something liberating about m/m erotica for people who have been socialized as women in a very ambivalent way regarding sexuality. Like yes it has its own shameful element because "objectification of gay men," but in a way I think no one writing m/m erotica believes they are depicting realistic gay relationships... it's attractive because "equalized" power dynamics make it more ok to enjoy (often wildly graphic) sex scenes without the shame and yucky feeling you get with female protagonists. And I think that's why so called "reversi" couples (even more equalized dynamics) are a common trope authors love to at least hint at. Another response (Rose) talks about an "emancipated" desire for women who have overcome conforming (only) to the submissive sexual role, and I think this is what can (sometimes) make queer sex truly liberating (when not reproducing heteronormative dynamics). In my experience (as a bisexual woman), it has allowed me to discover parts of myself that can enjoy gazing and being a subject (more active/ dominant) without shame because the dynamics feel more equal (partners can both be subject and object). Anyways this is all fascinating to me, thank you Natalie !

Anaïs

I agree and can relate with a lot of what you say, and I think what you refer to as emancipated desire ("pleasure at looking, giving and receiving") is related to what Natalie is talking about in the "genderfluid gaze" section

Sunbeam

Wow, this was good, and really thought-provoking. I'm an oblivious, mostly gay guy with some straight sexual attraction, and I'm surprised at how much of my behaviour is a mix between stereotypically female and stereotypically male habits. Also a little glad, because I thought I was just weird. Like, on the one hand, I pretty much never watch pornographic videos, it's mostly a mix of online stories and artworks, I need some kind of emotional or intimate connection in them (which is why the videos are often a turn-off), and I'm a sucker for romantic or even just interpersonal narratives enmeshed with the erotic aspects (although my reaction to the Notebook is similar to that of horror movies, in that I mostly feel hurt and confused by the pain and sadness in their stories, per https://xkcd.com/2076/). On the other hand, while I'm uninterested in Speckle's cheesy, passionless porn video, I wouldn't consider Bertie's chaste romance to be erotic either. I can't speak for anyone else, but my feelings for romance and sexuality are linked but pretty distinct, and in terms of direct eroticism, I'm a pretty stereotypical gay man. Also a furry, naturally :). I'd agree as well that my... tastes (?) are pretty shaped by the sociological aspects. Like, I'm fine with and can even like some themes of dubious consent (like hypnosis, saying-no-but-meaning-yes, more committed BDSM) in gay erotica, but it's much more uncomfortable and "too-real" in straight stuff. The straight presentations also feel more, well, "rapey" to me than the gay ones (or often flat and excessively cruel whenever there's a dominatrix involved). Honestly, I think the distinction Contrapoints made between objectification and de-subjectification is even more explicit in the contrast between straight and gay erotica. Like, men are very much objects in gay erotica, but (generally) every character has their own feelings and urges, and they can all be identified with. Whereas, in the little straight erotica I've seen that's not made by a woman or gay guy, it's not just that women aren't the focus, which is to be expected in erotica for straight men, but women are almost always just conduits for the men's fears and desires, which feels boring/uncomfortable if you don't lean into it, and I don't. On a separate note, learning that a lot of M/M erotica is written by women... well, it's not offensive to me, not in the way lesbian erotica being written for men is offensive for lesbians (and, like, in general), but it is surprising and a bit confronting, although in hindsight there are a few tells. I'd also say that, to me, the "gay male gaze" seems a lot broader than the "straight gaze" of either gender. Like, standards for beauty and attractiveness seem a lot more personal and contextual, and there seem to be more niches people can fill. This might also apply to lesbians, but I'm 100% oblivious on that topic. There's a bit of a caveat for sexual desire. If the straight male gaze is generally sexually aggressive, it feels to me like the gay male gaze is more sexually... needy? Not in a bad way, just that it feels like gay male sexual desire in queer media, fiction and online has a more pointedly erotic undertone, whereas straight men's gaze is stereotypically focused on "scoring" and "getting off", but with the details left pretty nebulous. Anyway, sorry for all that. I'm still living for the young adult joy of anonymously sharing vague but personal details of my life online, and this video really shed a new light on myself. I'd love seeing this topic as a main channel video, especially to see the bonus chapter, but I imagine Contrapoints has a lot of topics already, so I imagine that might be on the backburner. The only critique I'd make is that starting the dialogue in the chapter slides felt a bit off-putting to me, but that might just be a personal preference. Awesome video, thanks!

Mariana C

keen to hear about this too

Mariana C

So much to think about! I do wonder if a lot of this sexual narcissism is not deeply connected to our experience of gender identity and how it is contingent upon how other genders view us. As a woman, I've struggled with prioritising my own subjective, experiential desires over the desire to be desired (mostly by men or the very masculine). When I discovered my very obvious physical attraction to women, I had this deep intuition that a woman could never hurt me like a man could. I thought this was likely a positive thing, but I've come to understand that this is connected to the fact that men are able to affirm or deny my womanhood and attractiveness in ways a woman cannot. In the end, they are the holders of this panopticon-like gaze. Growing up I was ignored or bullied by men more so than abused and desired, but I still observed how others were objectified (and seemed to revel in that). There is thereby a part of me that relished being objectified - in the short term - but I am unable to deliver myself to that part of me due to my understanding that that satisfaction never lasts. I don't have many answers, mostly only additional questions, as I am keen to continue exploring whether I will ever be able to centre my sensorial and physical experience over my desire to feel affirmed or seen in some way. Perhaps it could be useful to broadly apply the two types of viewing pleasure described by Mulvey - one more ego related and another more sensual / carnal - in a less gendered way to explore why we connect sexually.

Gabriella

"Women aren't supposed to desire men, they're supposed to desire men's desire." As a bisexual woman, the thing that originally prevented me from fully knowing that I was bi is that I didn't feel attracted to women the way men seem to be attracted to women. For me and my sexuality, I really need to feel desired by someone else in order to feel desire myself - and for me, the gender of the person can vary and I absolutely identify as bi, but I don't exactly ~~desire~~ women - in a similar way to how I don't exactly ~~desire~~ men, I desire to be desired. Desire doesn't sound like a word anymore. The points you made about how female sexuality is driven by female narcissism sometimes, and that women want to be desired by men, but learning the specifics of that desire is creepy, and often women prefer to read about or invent a fantasy man who sees and desires them in exactly the way they want to be seen... so well articulated, so real. I do feel that a lot of my sexuality stems from wanting to be seen and desired in a very specific way. And maybe that is as much a fantasy as a man's anime titty gf fantasy, but it's a no less real and physical feeling. This video is so brilliant. It's really unlocking some mysteries for me in terms of my own sexuality and gender. For real, this video made me feel less alone. Well done as always!

Ao

I found the discussion on the genderfluid gaze and m/m media to be really interesting and relevant to me. It's something I've been thinking about A LOT lately. I recently got really into danmei (Chinese m/m literature). Getting into danmei made me feel guilty and ashamed because soon after I got into it I noticed all the discourse about ‘danmei being a way for straight women to fetishize gay men’ (I’m AFAB). Honestly, all the guilt and shame has come solely from those people on the internet who are making that argument and shaming women; I don’t inherently feel like I’m doing anything wrong when I read a book about a m/m relationship or write a fanfic about it. I know this isn’t indicative of everyone’s experience, but getting into danmei has actually helped me with figuring out my own sexuality and gender identity. I already identified as asexual before becoming a danmei fan, but becoming a danmei fan just cemented my ace identity further and helped me figure out I’m aegosexual. Also, reading a bunch of danmei made me start to question my gender identity. It was interesting when you talked in your video about women seeing themselves “as men sexually”; I feel like that describes me, sort of. I feel like one of the reasons I enjoy danmei is because I identity with the characters in the sense that I want to BE a beautiful, feminine man. Or maybe just an androgynous person. I don’t know. I’ve recently started identifying as nonbinary, but I’m still not quite sure what is going on with my gender. Either way, I’m not sure I would have figured all this out without danmei. I also find the m/m fetishization argument to be strange in the sense that it assumes that all m/m authors and fans are straight, cis women. That’s just another example of assuming everyone is straight and cis. Are they? I know that many m/m authors and fans ARE straight, cis women, but I also know that a lot of fans are not straight, cis women. I know this is anecdotal, but I’m very involved in the online danmei community and I can say for sure that the fans in this community cover a wide variety of sexualities and gender identities. (At least in the English-speaking community; I realize things may be different amongst Chinese fans and other communities outside English-speakers.) So I don’t know, the whole “fetishization” argument just seems like a lazy way of shaming (supposed) women without digging into what’s actually going on in this community.

Jo Weldon: Sex Worker Style

While working as a Cis-female queer dominatrix I was (am) particularly fascinated, frustrated, and inspired by watching men struggle with their own desires under the predominant structure of "the male gaze" -- a term I perpetually want to put in quotes, since it for me it's shorthand for a set of conditions that frame sexual desirability as defined by what's appealing to men. One of my clients would do some incredible gender-identification contortion, imagining himself as the passive woman and me as the subjugating male, at the same time that he needed to perceive himself as male and me as female in order for the stimulating taboo to take place. I was left with a sense that while it's all worth examining, and efforts worth making to improve communications and relations between all genders in all orientations, there's no answer that "fixes it" with regard to the male gaze, which is why I felt a sense of recognition at the conclusion of your video! Words are failing me right now, but as a politicized sex worker, I think about this quite a bit.

cheesecurl

you should do a podcast with anita sarkeesian <3

Anna Peckinpah

If the voyeur in my own head gazes both at myself with narcissistic desire to embody an idealized fantasy, that same voyeur is also one that shames me and sometimes makes it too painful to look at the image staring back at myself because it never can and never will measure up to a feminine ideal vision. The voyeur often points out the very inadequacies and shortcomings that when I as a bisexual woman look at another woman who embodies the beauty and fantasy that I both simultaneously desire but often cannot bring myself to express explicit desire for, because of both my own deep insecurities and also not wanting in any remote way to contribute to the pressure of that woman feeling as if she doesn’t live up to the epitome of the fantasy either. With channeling desire though through narratives of m/m romance (Last of Us strawberry episode being the most recent example), there is some deep catharsis that I think goes even deeper than just pure physical lust and attraction. It’s this radical acceptance and seeing in the m/m a complete, raw, uninhibited desire to let the other know they are desirable not just as they are, flaws and all, but also BECAUSE of how they are, flaws and all. It’s that acceptance, and I feel it towards both male and female romantic partners where I desperately want to either drown out the voice of the voyeur by embodying a fantasy either to a male partner that they don’t have to feel inadequate because I am providing them the assurance they are enough and can have a fantasy without the prerequisites of living up to a “Chad” ideal, and for female partners, making them feel as if they are the ultimate fantasy, that their own voyeur cannot even perceive how perfectly they embody my desires in the most intimate, vulnerable of moments. I feel like not just pleasure but an aversion to pain, to feeling unworthy, to feeling inadequate is also deeply rooted in how female desire manifests oftentimes.

Kiki

Great video! Very thought provoking. I wonder also about how the legal regime has played into all of this, especially with regards to the criminalization of adultery, sex work, abortion, and gay sex. Something institutionalizing and pathologizing those feelings of guilt and shame? Foucault hi how are you lol. Also as other commenters brought up I would be interested in you further interrogating the gay male gaze, specifically with regards to the way gay men interact (or refuse to interact) with specific races and/or body types. But also how the power dynamics of racism perpetrate and create exceptions and complications of the male gaze generally (ie the white woman desiring the enslaved black man)

Cade Fire

As a switch/vers enby, can I say..... Yes

Andrew Holt

This is a great video, but one thing I think it missed was the asexual and aromantic gaze. How does the male/female gaze change when sexual desire is removed, how does it change when romantic desire is removed. I think that would have yielded interesting results. My hypothesis is that, statistically speaking, women are more likely to be asexual and that men are more likely to be aromantic. This results in the male gaze having a tendency towards aromanticism and the female gaze having a tendency towards asexuality. Am I on to something here or am I off the mark?

Colton Royle

Yea, this is difficult. The more I'm reading about sexuality, of course the more I think that, no matter how you were going to approach this, there would be some remainder left out. Somebody out there is going to feel like something wasn't addressed. For what it's worth, after your video, we watched a trailer for "The Buccaneers" on Apple TV Plus, and felt your points right away. Maybe this is what Lacan meant with there being "no sexual relation." I've been reading a lot of Darian Leader, and I think I've realized that sexuality is so individualized, even when we have been inscribed so deeply into culture. I AM thankful for your hard work on this though. Psychoanalysis is pretty much all I want to read now, and I think you helped with that.

L. Loparco

I'm a trans man. The effect testosterone has is CRAZY. Why wasn't this brought up?

Jordan S

Wow this is so fascinating. Great tangent pick!

Justin O'Brien

lol theres no female jeff dahmer cuz shes smart enough to not get caught

Hannah Lazarte

I haven't stopped thinking about this since I watched. the idea that every romantic relationship I've been in has on some level been about me an the the other person objectifying each other, has shaken me to my core. It makes a lot of sense to me why things start to get rocky bc of this. this somehow has lessened the pain of being single for me. I've been trying to accept being single for so long and this legit helped me. I freed me I can't explain how.

towerofmadel

As a lesbian, sometimes I wonder if I overcompensate the “uwu gay” within me by enjoying “male gaze” content—pinups for example are fun and sexy and maybe gratuitous. But it’s fun! And sexy! I like boobs!! I do get nervous being too…objectifying with guy friends who like women too. Like I want us both to be comfortable about our attractions, but how far can we go before you start saying weird shit ((and how much of that is weird and how much of it is just my anxiety around hearing men express sexual desire?!)) I wish women were more feral about pussy and dick and whatever turns them on. I think it’s especially frustrating when I look at my gay male counterparts who are “allowed” to be so openly horny and perverted for one another This is just a random post-viewing stream of consciousness blurb so please excuse its wackiness

Miriam L

Natalie, please keep doing these Tangents. They are superb work, seriously. I am so happy every time one pops up in my Inbox. Thank you!

Taron Fredenburg

i id so hard with the "genderfuck gaze" section. thanks for putting this together! it's really interesting.

Taron Fredenburg

i think that those generalizations have the "neo-victorian" problem natalie talks about in the video, i.e. while it's true men are often socialized to care less (or pretend to care less) about romance than women and woman are given a lot of ambivalence about sex, those aren't the same as genuinely experiencing aromantic and asexual orientations. there may be an overlap, but imo trying to figure out why people are aro and/or ace is like trying to figure out why people are gay or transgender.

Taron Fredenburg

that said, i think this is interesting because you could be like, "well what is the male gaze apart from sexuality?" and you could get into the way men often think the women they end up in relationships with should be the sole person responsible for managing the man's emotional needs. but asking "what is the female gaze apart from sexuality?" sends us into that whole uwu chaste stuff that many people use to define "female gaze" in the first place. and that's not even getting into the way that a lot of ace people still engage in sexual fantasy or masturbation, but don't want to do the thing with other people. the memoir "gender queer" covers this in an interesting way because the author (iirc an aroace person) experiences something like the genderfluid gaze natalie mentions.

van

Please relieve the second part of The Hunger saga 😭🙏 it's been a year and a half

Alesha Montgomery

My thoughts on the male gaze are more the portrayal of the world in media with the expectation that the viewer is straight male. The portrayal is not restricted and doesn't force the lens to look away, feel guilt or have to empathize. Damn right women like enjoy being desired, but not all desire is equal. I want some one to notice me, find me attractive and special. That doesn't mean I enjoy when a guy on a bus stares at me and starts jacking off. Being an object isn't special, it strips you of what can make you special. Last part of this long rant (you asked what I think) When I think of male gaze what comes to mind is comic books. The best example in this is Harley Quinn. That is a character that has been approached heavily by both the male gaze and non male gaze. I hesitate to call it female gaze, I am not sure what that is.. But depending on the artist and writer she has been portrayed as a ditzy, impossibly curved, dressed to be viewed and nothing more than a submissive fuck toy. Other times her chest has shrank to normal human size, she is not a genius, but she earned a degree as a psychologist and knows her shit. She does empowering things, breaks free from an abusive boyfriend. I have a one shot comic of her that on the cover she is displayed with massive boobs that are just barley covered and held back from bursting out with a little fabric and string. On the inside is a origin story that showed her trying to survive as a med student in the slums, wearing normal clothes with normal human proportions. I actually love this issue and its one of my favorite comics. At the time I had a little display area for some of my favorite comics and I didn't put it on display because the cover made me uncomfortable. I thought I was cis straight male at the time, but it felt gross to me. Its not that I hate seeing boobs, I am a fan. Its was that there was this interesting story and character and on display it would be just the gaze, the over sexualized representation with out the context or character. I am not sure if I am explaining it well, but to me that fits my concept of the male gaze. It reduces what it sees because it doesn't have to look deeper and its so damn unnerving as a woman because you are reminded that in the perfect world for many straight guys is your silence, submission and sexualization. Okay, Ted talk over.

Lou Lou Sainsbury

This was so excellent and had never noticed the line about transvestism in Visual Pleasure when I read it at uni. For a while now i've been thinking alot about what a trans gaze could mean or look like, i think this also relates to your video on liminal spaces - It reminds me of the film Rebecca (1940) where the lead character is haunted by the rooms and the preserved objects of her husband's ex-wife (a more idealised dead femme). I feel so much of these films which became staples for the 'male gaze' can be spun in such interesting ways when it's transed. I'm curious what you would think a trans gaze might feel like, or the conditions of spaces that could allow trans gazes to exist and be meaningful...

Emily Knox

This was amazing. Thank you.

Hannah Peterson

I think the opposite of the tension that heterosexual men feel between desire and shame (of attraction to someone/something vulnerable) is the tension that heterosexual women feel between desire and fear (of attraction to someone/something dangerous). I think that a lot of the things that heterosexual women often describe as attractive are ways that we try to deal with that tension. For example, the yearning and sexual repression of a period film like Pride & Prejudice is a demonstration of a man who is capable of controlling his desire and the expression of it, but revealing just enough to be compelling. This makes him both safe, which is paramount, and desirable. Another example of this is the trope of a formerly tough/intimidating man becoming "weak" with desire. And while women don't seem to display the kinds of "part" fetishes that you mentions, the kinks that are common (BDSM, rape fantasies, etc.) are ways of acknowledging and exploring power dynamics. I sometimes wonder how much of the guilt and shame that women feel around sex is actually about fear. I also wonder if this is truly as gendered as it might seem at first glance. It seems as though gay men are not afraid of other men in the way that women are as a whole, but perhaps physically smaller men who have sex with larger/stronger men feel some similar way? I'd be interested to know.

some kind of gay cryptid

As an ace-spec lesbian who primarily consumes male/male erotica, I feel very seen by this. (In a good way.)

Jesse

I think an interesting thing to consider is the ways that trans gay men interact with these ways of looking objectification/subjectification. As I’ve transitioned and had to interact with men in different ways it’s made me realise that I’ve always had a very different relationship with objectification than cis women, but also not one that is like cis men. Feels like I sit in an interesting liminal space between the two experiences. As such I’ve always felt very external to the Discourse surrounding the idea of the Male Gaze … there’s probably a video essay that could be done about this if I ever get time to make one 🤔

marie garnier

About straight women not desiring the types of bodies men think we do (i.e. muscular bodies), I think we also need to factor in the fact that women probably censor their desires, taking into account what they can *realistically* desire, as well as *safely* desire. I enjoy muscular male bodies and derive great pleasure from looking at them (and not just their forearms), either in media or in person, and I know a lot of my straight women friends do as well. But the men who have and/or cultivate those types of bodies are not typically the ones that treat women the best, IRL or in the "discourse". This is of course another generalization, but in the venn diagram of very fit men and men who are respectful sexual partners and worthwhile romantic prospects (especially if you're a feminist woman), the overlap is pretty slim. Also, and this is perhaps a more personal comment, I am a little scared at the thought of being physically vulnerable with a person who is a great deal stronger than me. So desire for those muscular bodies seems to be something better left undisturbed while we develop a taste for the Chalamets...

Noah Rouse

“If I could wear your clothes . . . I’d pretend I was you . . . and lose control” - En Vogue - Don’t Let Go (Love) I feel this is applicable somehow. Idk

Blu X

I relate to the lady that wanted naked Thor. This is a really interesting tangent.

andrew konoff

At 7:00, when you talk about "being gazed at forcing the experience of self awareness on us, which is maybe inherently an experience of shame" – psychoanalysis has a lot to say about this. Basically, this isn't inherently shameful – but it can be. Being seen by a "good object" – a supportive, accepting presence – is profoundly therapeutic, and the thing at the core of secure attachment. A good-enough parent sees you, and you feel seen, but also accepted. You feel a base level of comfort, after a while, with the idea that you both exist, and so can be perceived, and that, because there's no shame being communicated in that gaze (for the most part) by your good-enough parent or analyst (either by refusal or punishment or just them looking at you with the stink eye), you're acceptable, okay, just as you are. However! If you didn't internalize a good object, you instead internalize the shame of someone who could not accept you. Shame isn't an inherent emotion we feel. It's transmitted, communicated by someone else whose shame we're taking on – at their insistence. I mean even if a not-great parent just ignores their kid, we learn to take on the shame that they feel that prevents them from engaging with our feelings, thoughts, etc. So yeah. We can definitely feel what's going on with someone's gaze. And feeling the accepting nice gaze of a good object is so profoundly therapeutic that it's the whole way that, I think, psychoanalysis helps people. Eventually, you can internalize a good object, and refuse the shame you internalized in its place. Then, to feel your self (even through another's gaze) isn't so inherently shame-filled and disorienting. You can just *be*.

Mar de Silencio

I've thinking about this topic a lot lately, and I really appreciate this tangent just now. All the part about the gay women gaze is, I think, even more complicated for bi/pan women. Because usually out gaze and desire is different towards men and women (and to NB people) . And very often out desire to women is more... Joyful? (I'm not sure about how to express it in English 😅). Like, very often,we are even reluctant about our desire towards men (there are a million of tiktok memes about it), but when we desire women,we feel guilty of objectify them and we panic or go back. I don't know, I don't have any certainties. But this video has come just on the right moment for me. Thank you very much💚

highclass_lady

Happy Birthday Natalie! 🎉 Also, we sent you a Birthday e-Card to your email via GroupGreeting cards! Over 200 of your fans from all around the world signed it! Have a wonderful birthday weekend! 🥳

Veronica Barratt

Happy birthday Natalie 🥳🎂🎈 - I loved this tangent, you are beyond amazing

Quizoid

My gosh these are all so good and fascinating to watch. Somewhat related, I’d love a tangent on Snow White. The sheer number of conservabros coming out as hard core Snow White fans 🤣 is shockingly fascinating. And the Brett Cooper reveal… it’s all so fascinating and I really would love to see this analyzed. Maybe just one on right-wing cancel culture in general… So much of it seems to be centered around women.

José Ángel Sánchez Gómez

Thank you for sharing this comment. I am finding this video to be very healing, and the comments to be a place to learn.

Lex Kuzma

I'm curious how that works for things where there is obvious distance and safety, like watching Magic Mike or any other film where well-built male bodies are featured. Are you able to use the safety of the screen separating you from them to enjoy the male body, or are you still stuck grappling with the threat that accompanies that strength even in the context of fictional media and fantasy?

Lex Kuzma

As a man with a strong attraction to women as whole people, your description of the motives for objectification are completely foreign to me. I've never felt like my attraction to a woman is a threat to them and I can't recall ever feeling like I needed distance from women that I was attracted to, only more intimacy. I love women's bodies, but I also love everything else about women and I've never felt conflict in that. I've also never really understood the whole idea of objectification. This whole video was great and thought provoking. Definitely worth a few watches to digest.

Maíra Macário

This video was a whole healing experience to me. As a pan woman who has been through some trauma, you made me reflect on things I had only scratched the surface of. This video will be one of those I'll rewatch a bunch of times. Thank you so much and happy birthday!❤️

IamBrix

This might be my new favorite video of yours. It's really interesting to me, and I'm not sure if it would be as fascinating to me if I weren't a straight dude. Especially the women who read the gay m/m erotica stuff. It's stumbled upon something I intuitively maybe noticed when I was younger and first started dating. Despite what media/society tells you, I think women have a hunger for a completely different kind of man, rather than the traditional predatory masculine archetype we know of. I'm a lot closer to a "softboy" (lol) than the other, and I guess because of insecurity/social norms, I was completely flabbergasted when my first girlfriend took interest in me. She was gorgeous, and I unironically asked "why?" when she made her feelings known. I assumed I wasn't the archetype of man someone like her would've taken interest in. If men stopped trying to embody that toxic ideal of manhood, I think they'd be surprised by the connections they'd get. And both men and women can have healthy connections where we both see each other on our own terms. I don't know just some random babble but I'm definitely gonna read some of the books you recommended.

Glen O'Carolan

Your silence on the troye Sivan one of your girls music video is deafening

no

just had some additional thoughts after encountering a post by a terf lesbian with ideas abt lesbian bar that theoretically would use some facial rec ai to sort out trans women. i believe sexuality to be very social and that shit to me seems like an instance of social inhibition of sexuality, enclosure of means of semi public sexuality behind a check point. 'papers please' and inspections dries that pussy in seconds init. nasty power grab

no

yeah all the studies conclude that womens libido is just. not that high. because of nature. i bet if i actually look at papers meta studies etc, much of it going to be fairly easy to dismiss and then we come back to what's the point of trying to quantify unquantifiable other than imposition of power relations

Alec

She does mention hormones at 9:40, but dismisses them as less significant than societal norms in forming male vs female sexuality. I'd agree testosterone has a mush larger influence than she gives credit. Video still kicks ass tho.

Conner Rohwer

Always makes me think of the 30 Rock scene with Hazel and Liz: “Ah, the male gaze.” “They’re all a bunch of gays.”

Guilherme Tamaki

Hello Natalie, hope it's not to late to wish you a happy birthday! thank you, as always, for the insigthful video, it gave me food for thoughts in a subject that I'm not familiar with

Rose

Thanks for your feedback. What you wrote got me thinking further and I watched again the section about the "genderfluid gaze". (sorry my answer is going to be quite long again, this topic is just so rich :) I think this is only one possibility for the emancipated desire of women for men. I think that there is a multiplicity of ways to desire men. I personally found that it might be related to my menstrual cycle but I would say that it has to do generally with where you are at in your life and how you feel etc. Two female artists came to mind to illustrate my point. I particularly like this video clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sx0r8QeaswU (translation of the lyrics: https://lyricstranslate.com/en/manque-damour-lack-love.html) and this song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_RXITcgyy4o these two examples touch on mental erogenous zones that are particularly important for the women I know: humor (not taking oneself too seriously) and the state of vulnerability in which women find themselves during the sexual act (not least because it has long been associated, and still is for most of humanity, with the possibility of pregnancy).

bailey bayer

I just discovered the Kathleen Stock rabbit hole and I would really like to propose it as a future tangent topic. Is there a place to submit a request for tangents? I am relatively new to the Patreon. Thank youuuu <3

Mian Emily

This video is EVERYTHING, you said so many things I’ve been thinking but couldn’t put words to

bugtime

this might be dumb or too broad/straightforward and im sure you have a million video ideas but i’d be really interested in a video on family (how the notion has changed, cultural significance, how its used as a weapon, biology vs society, outdated visions that overtake peoples entire political ideology, sexism, tradwives, what a utopian form of family would look like, some incest jokes, etc). i can see the 50s housewife costume/set already. but id watch a video of you talking about anything

Pauline Drillet

I found out about the male gaze when I was eleven : I went with my mom to the movies to see Starsky and Hutch, I was befuddled by the scene where Hutch asks the two women to kiss each other, I asked my mom « why did he do that for ??Why didn’t he kiss them himself ? » « Because he enjoys watching them » she answered…

Graham

I recently wrote in my journal wondering if my attraction to women, under the right diagnostics, would be considered a kind of psychosis. Describing it as enslavement is an adroit observation.

Pdlp

I thought that the topic of 'The gaze' was pretty limited, and repetitive, but you definitely proved me wrong. It's one of my favorite videos now, and I'm surprirsed to have been convinced that the fluid gaze is the bestest of all gazes.

Lani Geiger

As a corollary, the stereotypical female-narcissism-experiencer needs to realize herself as a floating camera in her own right so she doesn’t need to use someone else’s eyeballs to see herself. I’m trying to be fair here

James Lopez

Great tangent! I fully endorse all recommendations at the end. I think through a combination of factors I ended up with the right amount of identification with women so that I'm at least cognizant that my peeping is a kind of trespass, but I don't really feel guilt or shame about it. One thing I wish came up in the video was trans men, because I have found myself relating to them after they start T and the amount of sexual thoughts and desires they have goes through the roof. I think T probably plays a big role in how often men think of sex and probably even the intensity of their desire and thoughts. They're feelings that need to be wielded responsibly.

James Lopez

Oh! And everybody should watch "But I'm a Cheerleader" and "Deadloch" because they're good media by lesbians that I think will be easy for most people to relate to.

sunlit_music

Thanks very much for making this video Natalie, it was very eye opening and thoughtful. I really appreciated you mentioning the male gaze, female gaze and the genderfluid gaze.

Christopher Price

Throughout the video I kept on thinking about Will Arnett's character on 30 Rock saying, "You’re the gay one. Wanting to be with a women, how gay is that? You win sex against a man, that’s as straight as it gets." There's also this meme on twitter about women complaining about how their husbands can't satisfy them, but it's only because they won't tell them what they want. There definitely seems to be an element of repression in the air whether it comes from a variety of angles. As a cis-straight-dude coming from an evangelical background it's been a trip getting my basic straightness. Like, I'm very visual but also give me those narratives of longing and tension. Apologies for the rambling but thanks this was very good, with lots to think about.

Alice

An analog for the “genderfluid” gaze might be drag shows. The performer is choosing to adopt a persona distinct from their “real” one, and they objectify themself in a way that hetero society never imposed on them. So performers can have fun and feel safe dancing for dollars like cis girls a hetero strip club, and it’s guilt-free for patrons to enjoy.

Anna Huber

Excellent video! It's added a lot to my own thoughts about the futility of modesty cultures. Having grown up in a "complementarian" community, we were so trained to sense male gaze and try to control it, but our struggle was always undermined by (many other things, but also) the conflicts you've covered here. I appreciate you so much.

Anna Huber

Also, I think my archetypical pairing of supposed-to-be-desired-manly-man vs. surprise-straight-woman-obsession is Star Trek's Kirk and Spock. (Hot take: Spock is basically Edward Cullen but in male centered media.)

Nathaniel Trent

Sometimes I just want Contrapoints to do a Hasan Piker-esque commentary on the Youtube Jubilee trans debates

James Lopez

I for sure see it but a lot of people forget Spock's struggles to follow Vulcan philosophy. It seems like there's something there like "it's hot that he can get violent but hopefully not against me" which is basically my feeling about Harley Quinn. And Spock.

lantu

It's just a small point but when you say objectification comes from the guilt of desiring women, and that in turn comes from viewing women as fragile, I wonder if that's begging the question a little bit. Idk though

Adah Goulet

Omg I've been thinking the same thought recently hahah I love imagining people's reactions to things I react to and I like imagining that we all react the same way about this Mother Sivan in this video which is a MAJOR feeling of simpness followed by a bunch of bottom facial expression emojis (can't find the right words for it but you know exactly the ones I'm sure, we've all seen them)

Chrombus

Okay, I did it. I made a list of all the media mentioned in thie video aside from memes. I did get drunk half way through, so good luck. Ways of Seeing by John Berger Psychopathia Sexualis, by Krafft-Ebing The Notebook by Nicholas Sparks Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, by Sigmund Freud Anchorman Race and Representation, by Bell Hooks Blue Velvet, dir David Lynch Existentialism, by Jean-Paul Sartre Barbie Movie How Anita Sarkeesian spent 1 Million Dollars, by Thunderf00t Silence of the Lambs Tippy and Birdu Evangelion Twilight 1(?) The Female Eunuch and The Beautiful Boy by Germaine Greer Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema Laura Mulvey Lacan Jerkin’ It (Don’t!), by Kant Freud, Partialism Newyourscience You mom’s pubes May (2002) Can The Female Gaze Truly Exist? by Zoi Agaputou Anita Sarkeesian Again Magic Mike (2012) The Village People Failed to Write a Chick Flick by Anon Mr Darcy 50 Shades of Gray Everybody Loves Dahmer The Robber Bride by Margaret Atwood The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir Titanic (the movie) "black female movie fan" to bell hooks The Oppositional Gaze: Black Female Spectators Hannibal SNL skit about gay reality TV Harry and Draco. Hey, she did a Greer! Girls Who Like Boys Who Like Boys by Lucy Neville Demands: Men must identify with women! -Kick Tate -Consume Women Women need to overcome their conditioning and love more actively -society should shame women less, shame predators more Feminists need to stop talking about the death of male gaze and sexualisation of women.

Chrombus

So, Natalie? Was Greer right? Since everyone got on board with Harry/Draco, the beautiful gay boys?

meomeotalks

the bi panic i feel watching this video is so complicated because 1, Natalie you look absolutely ravishing in this video; and 2, i’m all of a sudden confronted with the question of whether or not i feel attraction to girls due to my own narcissistic tendencies 🫠🫠

hag fag

This was an incredible watch and genuinely changed my life a bit, thank you. I'm a genderfluid gay trans guy and often feel like the way I desire and am desired is very fraught, with people not knowing at all what to make of me if I don't stick to certain scripts. My androgyny feels like a big unknown for people. I have felt heavily desired by men in secret and yet stigmatized for gazing back, and mocked for it. It has taken a long time to mentally exit the crushing amounts of shame all around and just simply be. Thank you for the clarity this video gave.

Sappho's Friend

Im a lesbian (fem4fem) and im gonna be honest, i cannot affectively comprehend being a lesbian but also enjoying harry and draco style erotica, because to me they are just two people who are the opposite sex from me, and whom i thus dont find sexually or romantically attractive. I understand cognitively what you said in the video about that, but i just dont understand the rest of the mechanics. For me a female-female couple are most aligned w my tastes, male-female couple are second, but i simply could not enjoy erotica that centers two male characters

Rentaror

Love that you had to specifically include that you aren't attracted to masculine women. Very relevant.

Sappho's Friend

yes, it is relevant, to seeing trends among different subpopulations, and i included it given that contra is also fem4fem yet differs in this aspect it, so i dont think its down to being attracted to masculinity. But that aside, why is that a problem in the first place? just saying lesbian says as much about my orientation as just saying fem4fem does, that two member term is my actual sexual/romantic identity, neither one in isolation is, and this is a convo specifically about attraction. You just had to take it personally I assume. With that mindset, if you were logically consistent, youd see an openly straight woman as a misogynist, since shes not into the same sex and just has to openly say it (so haughty! so very relevant /s)

Celine

I can enjoy it if it's fiction. I read a lot of erotic manga with muscular men, and I also enjoyed Magic Mike.

giomam

Hey Natalie! long-time fan, new patron. just watched this incredible vid, and it really reminded me of the conversations around the movie poster for Cordelia (2019), which went viral on Twitter before anyone even knew what the film was about, because the *poster* was so 'female gaze' in way we're not used to seeing. But then everyone was quickly disappointed because it turned out the film was a horror movie, and the poster was supposed to be more disturbing than sexy. It really made me realise how untapped female sexuality is in film, that this poster came out and so many women got excited about it, like a familiar fantasy was finally a movie worth making - but no, the gap in the market still kind of gapes.

Philip Carter

I think a lot about gaze — have you ever heard a distinction made between a ‘particularized’ gaze versus a general one? Like…. I look at myself in the mirror, do I register a single holistic image of my entire reflection or does my gaze find a ‘spot?’ Or… I’m cross stitching a picture and I can look at each individual stitch, but what about when my eye zooms out a layer and I focus on the big picture instead? I have wondered if evolutionarily speaking the ‘gaze latching to particulars’ is an expression of vigilance (spotting an invader on the horizon, looking for food, etc). Anyway I associate the male gaze with this particularizing tendency… it’s making distinctions, dividing, penetrating. It’s different than the ‘passive’ (grounded, integrated) gaze which just takes in information and makes a complete sensory picture, without focusing consciousness on the completion or prevention of some action. There is gaze as a witness and gaze as an actor. Idk

Matoya's Hat

It's a minor sub-tangent, but I also think it's important to reject the idea that Delicate Emotional Yearning and the desire to bang someone nasty style are necessarily contradictory to one another. Those things absolutely can and do intertwine. The erotica I read is mainly aimed towards women (primarily straight women, because most of the lesbian romances I've come across do seem to have the Delicate Victorian Woman Purity uwu thing going on), and tends to be *very* explicit when sex scenes actually happen. Especially if you're reading fanfiction. It's also full of heartfelt yearning. The yearning doesn't have to detract from the physicality of desire - in the hands of a decent writer, it should enhance that physicality. I think it's probably because any desire can be enhanced by the inability to fulfil it immediately. Food always tastes better when you're hungry, getting into bed is heavenly when you're exhausted, and sex is most satisfying when you've been driven half-mad with lust. I definitely think female oriented erotica has much more of a focus on that sense of delayed gratification, for whatever reason. I'm actually kind of surprised this doesn't show up more in male-oriented pornography, because it's not exactly rare for men to enjoy edging, which is basically an expression of the same principle.

Ben Singer

How To Be Gay by David M Halperin is a great attempt to explain this (and other parts of gay culture)

Quickpawmaud

Can you make a tangent playlist?

Rhiannon

Natalie if you see this its okay to take a mental health break if you need to. I noticed you didn't schedule any vacation time in your original plans for video releases which doesn't sound sustainable. Don't fall into a rabbit-hole of self-loathing please! Just communicate with your fans that you need to take a break. Its fine!!!

highclass_lady

Natalie, I agree with a previous comment, please give yourself permission to take breaks & to take the time you need! Especially in the final weeks before a new video, please try your best to take care of yourself -I know that’s easier said than done but you deserve to be treated well & looking after your wellbeing isn’t an indulgence it’s a NEED. Sometimes we set unrealistic or unsustainable expectations for ourselves because everybody’s a bit imperfect, but you’re not any less worthy or capable if that happens! Even though everybody can change, & we as an audience want to encourage your progress in being healthier & kinder to yourself, we don’t know you orthosocially & nobody should expect you to change or completely “fix” stuff, also progress isn’t always linear or visible to us! We’re so incredibly proud of you & you’re amazing exactly as you are. Girl, you’ve got this! & if you take more breaks - girl, you’ve still got this! & on that note please allow yourself paid vacation time! We believe in you (not like in a projecting expectations type of way) but like as said in Cinderella: Have courage & be kind (including to yourself, especially to yourself!) 🦋✨

Aderyn Albarelli

Winter is a mean. 😞 I hope ya got some peeps to play chess and be spooky with, and if you feel you can afford to work less, I think your audience is the kind that would appreciate you taking care of yourself.

Aderyn Albarelli

Ah! 😣 I missed this. Happy late birthday, Natalie! Also, thank!

Aderyn Albarelli

After I first watched video I had no thought. The idea that portrayals of sex say something about the social world we're making for ourselves isn't something that seems to come up often. I wonder if sex ed can have a role in correcting this (how do brainstorm ways to guide a discussion that would be helpful, not just another way for students to harass each other? this is difficult.), instead of leaving it as a liminal space for Andrew Tate types to fill by convincing anxious kids that "sex IS inherently about domination, and that's good actually". Hearing people my age say adjacent shit, a few years back, was wild. Maybe porn -shniff- is ideology -shniff-. When you mentioned that guys identifying with women will be helpful, I wondered, is the difficulty identifying with themselves a barrier to this? Like "the first violence a man is taught to do is against himself" sorta thing? At long last, I both had time to swing by, and remembered thoughts.

Declan Maguire

But that's still visual. You're not talking about visual vs. non-visual, you're talking about a fixed image vs a customised imagined one. Both are still visual, which was the entire point of the point.

Declan Maguire

I find it curious as a man that I, and all men I've known, have zero interest in "I can fix her" erotica in principle, and I have NEVER seen it in practice. It's just so completely unrelated to our desires as I've witnessed them, a non-sequitur. I can't actually imagine any sort of media where the woman embodies aspects of my pain and I'd gain erotic gratification from projecting myself into the place of a man who "fixes" her. Like, even as you describe it, it makes no sense to me. I don't want to fix my partner's pain - I want it to BE FIXED, resolved and gone away. Fixing it is just a means to an end, and the resolution of that pain has no erotic force, it's merely the clearing away of a problem for someone that matters to me. It's an entirely functional matter that just happens to consist of someone's subjectivity. It has all the frisson of repairing a broken toilet that started back-flowing when you were making out.

Declan Maguire

@Eli, you've described parts of the male experience that a lot of women seem to struggle with, and even men seem to struggle explaining without leaning on cliches. It's this possessive forceful sense of just "MINE" that takes and possesses, not in a way that's totally indifferent to the subjectivity of the other person, but is still deeply invested in their interrelationship to yours as its manifesting in that moment. A sort of primal entitlement prior to judgement, the way a toddler might spontaneously feel entitled to whatever toy is in front of them that they decide without deciding, is theirs. An entitlement that expects and needs the other person to melt into it, helpless not just against you, but themselves as they blissfully melt into you. I think that a lot of the talk around kink has had a sinister undertone where it's actually a form of neo-victorian compartmentalisation. Kink is just a fun meaningless activity (don't question why it's always about power and domination)(don't question it)(you're a bad person for questioning it)(don't ask why it's not something else). I think the label "kink" has become, for a lot of people, a coping mechanism for deeper and broader desires about how they want to be treated in the bedroom or more broadly in the household. To allow them to celebrate and negate it at once, to indulge while denying the capacity for meaning with a little phrase; "It's just a kink/fantasy". Half truths that shut down uncomfortable thoughts, with clever tricks that redirect inner scrutiny while pretending to address it.

Lani Geiger

As a woman, the visual element is typically more of a supplement/useful insofar as it contextualizes the narrative; honestly; my eyes glaze over if there’s a specific image the author is clearly trying to convey. I don’t have aphantasia, and I do enjoy attractive people, but it’s almost like—ok, if I go to a nice restaurant and the food is plated nicely and tastes really good but the people I’m with suck, it’s not going to be a good experience. But if I go to Denny’s and the food is awful slop but the people I’m with are fun, it’s gonna be a good experience. Like don’t get me wrong I’d rather have a nice meal with cool people, but the actual experience is mediated far more by the dynamics of what is happening rather than what *is*

Chris Fox

As a gay male, I've always felt that my sexuality was less problematic for the same reasons you described lesbians feeling empowered to enjoy gay male erotica/slash fic. It makes sense to me. I wonder how much of putting oneself in the aggressive or passive role is equal to putting oneself in the traditionally masculine/feminine role (weather or not I'm swapping out body parts in my fantasy... I don't tend to fantasize about women either as objects or being the women. My bi ex however loved to watch straight porn and imagine himself as the woman... much to the chagrin of the gay men in the room (while simultaneously being very repressed in what he would allow to happen in man on man sex... or what he would allow his girlfriend to do to him for that matter... he grew over time, but even 5 years in he was still very restrictive in how much control or power he was willing to cede to me (him on top, not me on top even though he almost exclusively bottomed) :P The tangled webs we weave.

ExMachina14

29:28 "So far as I am aware, no lesbian in recorded history has ever had a refrigerator full of severed women's heads." Elizabeth Bathory is a potential candidate here, although both her sexuality and her guilt as a serial killer are debated to various degrees. There are intersecting problems here with the historical erasure of lesbians combined with the historical infantilization of women. A lesbian version of Jeffrey Dahmer would have a much easier time escaping notice as a lesbian and as a serial killer in a society that sees women as sexless and powerless.

Johanna

After watching this, I saw the tangent on Parasocial Relationships. This may be the reason why 1950s housewives loved so much the attractive, talented, gentle, and friendly Liberace... their daytime husband.

Chazie

Rewatching this I want to give my perspective on the "fujoshi" part of the video, I'm very intrigued by the statistic that says it's mostly straight women consuming M/M content, because in my experience for the past maybe 15 years in fandom, most of the M/M consumers I know are either gay/bi trans men, and lesbian/bi women. Trans men can easily "justify" it because they discovered themselves through identifying with fictional men, but there's a looot of discourse about women fetishizing gay men. I think you're right that it's a way for wlw to escape the shame and guilt of sexualizing women (and I think as you mentioned women can more easily identify with male characters), but I agree that it's tragic that a lot of women think that way. As a bi woman I say I consume less F/F because I simply haven't found a ship that gets me going, it's less prevalent and the ones I see are simply too cute and wholesome for my personal taste, but I know there's toxic yuri out there and I just have to look for it. I have a cis straight male friend who draws big titty anime girl porn and is a normal decent guy who treats women like humans, and very interestingly, most of the people who bought his art in person we lesbians (men would point and laugh at it). I find the feminist "stop sexualizing women" discourse very tiring because it's not that we shouldn't sexualize women, it's that we should also treat them like human beings. I've had a hard time explaining this to twitter leftists who are kind of falling into puritanical talking points lol.

Opinionated Online

That's exactly who I was thinking of during that part of the video (along with, "That's not necessarily true"), but I thought it would be too complicated to bring up in a comment.

ExMachina14

I think this statement about drag performers objectifying themselves fails to understand the enormous number of drag performers that are trans. Lots of drag performers (perhaps even most of them) genuinely see the gender in which they are performing as an authentic and true expression of themselves.

ExMachina14

Ironically, I think the "facial recognition" would backfire and exclude a bunch of cis lesbians instead. Trans women are far, far, far more likely to surgically feminize their masculine features whereas cis lesbians are far, far, far more likely to disregard gender norms in their own expression.

ExMachina14

And society believes that female versions of Jeffrey Dahmer can't exist, so nobody suspects them.

Alice

I’m a genderfluid trans woman, and I’m a drag performer myself. My impression is that most of us see our drag persona as expressing a “real” aspect of our gender/sexuality while still being artificial, exaggerated, and camp. It wouldn’t be as fun or as freeing to just look and act the way you do if you’re not on stage. And you don’t need to objectify yourself, but most of us enjoy that when we have a good crowd.

Yoon Choi

This was the video I didn't know I needed! 🤩🤩🤩

Ellie Chapman

this is utterly perfect. watched this with my 50 yo ex christian parents (they were christians when i was growing up). grateful for you because you are incredibly good at critiquing all sides, a trait which my parents deeply respect. they really listen to what you have to say and it bridges our gap pretty wonderfully. we couldn’t help pausing every 5 minutes to discuss. so many intersections with purity culture. also must say i am so grateful time and time again that you are a lesbian. so lucky that my fave can speak to my experiences so well!! very relevant and one of my top 5 favorites from you!!

Sappho's Friend

14:40 the phallocentric view is actually how the term vagina was invented. vagina literally means "sheath" (for the benis, right)

Erk

I'm so glad I signed up to the Patreon, this alone makes it worth it. This might be one of my favourite of your essays in a long time, Natalie. You rock, love hearing your insights.

Erin Laura

I had to stop this video like 7 times to look at myself in the mirror and marvel at how stunning I am

Anna O.

I'm a bi woman, and I definitely end up reading M/M fanfiction. I've found F/F and M/F fic that's really good, but I think some of the prevalence of M/M fanfiction is because so much of media features men as the best-written, most dynamic characters, and people tend to focus on them when writing fic. We need more female and nonbinary characters who are written as whole people, rather than as objects.

Erk

Me too, but that's pretty normal for me.

K

You’re a hardcore badass. Thanks for this.

F Youtube

Same but it was only because I have this gnarly tooth infection

ctina

I wonder what would happen to the gaze if we would question the nature of the relationship between subject-object; the "-", or the distance between subject and object, so to speak, rather than only addressing the qualities attributed to subjects and objects

Michael Scarbrough

This was such a fascinating watch! Really enjoyed this tangent.

Vítor Medeiros

I just got here and haven't watched the Tangent yet but I'd just like to say that a main channel video on "Identity" would probably be my favorite thing ever and this is only a slight exaggeration. The concept of identity (and, yeah, the oft-maligned idea of 'identity politics') is one of my main academic concerns right now (yeah, I know, boooo) and you're a big inspiration to what I'm trying to do in My Political Science Journey (boooo again, but we're all nerds here, I reckon? So I think it's at least a little bit fine lmao)

Paola Nicoll Alzuru Castillo

gosh, I felt so seen on the genderfluid gaze, it gave me the chills, i was so astonished that is a thing, it makes so much sense now. Love that!

Kevin

this was sooo thoughtful, im obsessed and nourished truly

AnkhKeeper

I must thank you because I have so much difficulty accepting my sexual feelings towards women as I feel like a creep. I am reconciling that slowly and this video has been very helpful!

Laura Torlaschi

This video means a lot to me as a sex work activist/bisexual enjoyer of porn. It's helping me clarifying and argue with the SWERF in my head about certain things.

Honoria Valemon

I think a really good example of the male gaze towards men in movies is the way Arnold Schwarzenegger is framed in 1980s movies. Clearly Arnold as a person is very sexy, is sexual, and doesn’t object to being objectified (as proven by his bodybuilding career) but he’s never framed in a sexy way in films like Predator or Terminator. His muscles are aspirational, not sexy. We rarely see his bare legs, his costumes frequently don’t fit very well (looking at you, Running Man), and his body is usually seen in connection with guns or cigars or other phallic standins. It’s a pretty big difference to MCU movies which are filmed in a way that lingers on the actors bodies in a way that showcases their sexual attractiveness.

Xina Shimek

Thanks this gives me more structure to the thoughts I had after watching Saltburn. The female gaze/sexuality enacted by a male avatar. It was really interesting to see visually enacted in a film.

mossy

i actually enjoy this style of video. i feel like sometimes i’m unable to share your more theatrical videos with people who are a bit more close-minded and dismissive. they get distracted by the fluff, and stop listening, i’ve noticed. even though i love and appreciate all the effort, aesthetic and all. i’m excited for your next video!<3

Cara

Thank you so much for this! Is there enough of a talking point for a tangent on the narcissism portion of the male gaze, and how the “type” of male character in movies has changed? Over the last decade, I’ve been weirded out by certain male friends of mine who claim to relate to and obsessively idolise characters like the Joker, Dexter, the serial killer in Saw. But when I ask them why, they get really paranoid or offended. When this was highlighted in the video, I instantly wondered why/how/what does this end up doing more widely to the real world these guys interact with?

Sofia

(0-6:30 min.): could the act of gazing upon a superior be interpreted as a privelege that the powerless do not have rather than something to do with the guilt of being gazed at? After all, in many instances, such as slavery and rape, the perpetrators do not believe their actions are morally wrong.

Bronwyn Bacon

when it comes to the “yearning“ I think the reason it’s attractive to me is that it’s symbolizes a man who is both sexual and is capable of exercising restraint. I want a man who is both attractive, and that I can feel safe with. A man who acts impulsively on his desire and takes what they want with raw power feels threatening, not sexy.

Cara

Polite request for a ContraPoints Must Read/Must Watch list for books and movies 🤓

Caitlin Adkins

This is beyond masterful! Thank you so much for making this video.

Bryce

This was incredible. So many points hit home

Paulina Rosa

You just explained my own sex life to me.

Hanié

As a bisexual everything is x10 more confusing tbh. And about the last part, I don’t think we have any (or enough) beautifully made or attractive lesbian or bisexual representation in the media, that’s one of the reasons we’re all drawn to the gays. There are so many gay couples that you could obsess over but there are just two shows about lesbians and they are not even that good.

Morhzov

Fellow bisexual and I completely agree

Annelies

Lot of late bloomer lesbians say they experienced comp-het because they mistook desiring men with the ego boost that comes with being desired

Jordan C.

I second this!! Super curious about this trend and what it says about us today IRL.

Cara

Yes! What examples have you seen? (Obviously, our own sample sizes are not representative of the whole, but still so, so curious!) :)

g.c0r7

I LOVE the fact that you included the "genderfluid" gaze in this video, which I very much identify with. I struggled a bit to untangle the internalized comp-het narrative from my relationship with my boyfriend, since neither of us is straight. Watching this video helped me make sense of why certain things about the sexuality we share as a couple feels complementary in a way that feels very natural but still sometimes triggers some feelings of guilt/"shouldn't be like that" that I have to intentionally uproot. Thank you!

Lauren Kawulicz

The Twilight video and now this one that I just gained access to are so helpful to me in unraveling poorly understood conceptualizations of feminist ideas that have made me feel very scared of men and like my sexuality is very wrong, i.e. that I have been brainwashed by the patriarchy to enjoy feeling small and I have to sacrifice my gender expression and sexuality to be a good feminist or even to be safe. So thank you for that! This content is extremely interesting and extremely healing!

Leigh Hile

Natalie, I've been a fan for a while now but just joined your Patreon and am blown away by the fact that even your tangents are head and shoulders above many (very respectable!) creators' main content. Also, I think between this and the Twilight video, you are my sex therapist now? That is a joke, of course, but in seriousness, I currently identify as asexual because that seems to make the most sense with my personal experiences, but it still leaves me with a lot of questions. You've given me a lot of new perspectives to think about over the past couple weeks, and I'm grateful. Anyway, off to read a whole bunch of M/M erotic fan fiction before bed and think about what that means. Thank you for being amazing!

cai willis

I just subscribed, and I am struck by the quality of your tangent videos! I would be happy with just you talking at the camera about whatever for an hour, this is such a treat!

Sappho's Friend

Im a fem cis lesbian, and in practice, when ovulating, feelings wise im often the googly eyed lust cartoon, while when not ovulating, the hand grazing neovictorian stuff kicks in lol. the intensity of romantic attraction doesnt really vary much with the menstrual cycle for me, but the more explicitly sexual side of things (horniness) does strongly. Hypomanic episodes will also ramp up the sexual side of things, even more so than ovulation.

ijbar

Wait! Is contrapoints using an AI that immitates the voice of Werner Herzog? Haha, that's so fun!

Kęstas

Sorry for being exceptionally off topic, but maybe does anyone has ever made transcripts to tangents? YouTube does it fairly well, but it's not translated properly of course and I may have wanted to translate a couple of those to involve some friends into some conversations lol Thank you whoever you are seeing this and thank you Natalie for bringing up some interesting povs on topics I do care about and make my works about as an artist. Also love not exactly the twist, but the look towards metaphysics æsthetics and art in general. I adore this perspective so much.

Benjamin

Henry Rollins

Jasper Rose

I've gone on and off testosterone several times due to ADHD and access barriers, so I've gone around the hormonal merry-go-round a few times, and each time noticed a shift in my sexuality. When on estrogen, I tend to prefer reading and imagining, like I have to be taken by "the story" of the moment. Sexual urges are dormant until "activated" by an external force, but can be pushed aside to be brought up later. It builds, but I can just put it away. When on testosterone, it's more like a constant and slowly increasing feeling of need, and visual stimulation works a lot better. LOOKING turns me on a lot more. Then there's the uncanny valley of hell, which lays somewhere between. When I stop taking T, there's a week or so of dead sexuality and I can't climax even if I try really hard. I crave affection and attention, but can't work up the appetite to actually engage. I think these differences cause a lot of tension in heterosexual couples... especially cis heterosexuals, since they can't relate at all.

DJ Jaylex (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 I am sure I'm not the only one who, as a heterosexual male, find himself in your descriptions of the lesbian gaze at women a lot. I've been having many of those same ambivalent feelings about my attraction to women, and there's a good reason I usually write stories from a female perspective, also getting a kind of enjoyment and emotional identification out of f/f stories (like yuri) that I don't really find elsewhere. I feel myself much closer to many of the stereotypes of female sexuality presented in the first half of the tangent than most perceptions of male sexuality.
2024-04-28 09:53 I am sure I'm not the only one who, as a heterosexual male, find himself in your descriptions of the lesbian gaze at women a lot. I've been having many of those same ambivalent feelings about my attraction to women, and there's a good reason I usually write stories from a female perspective, also getting a kind of enjoyment and emotional identification out of f/f stories (like yuri) that I don't really find elsewhere. I feel much closer to many of the stereotypes of female sexuality presented in the first half of the tangent than most perceptions of male sexuality.

I am sure I'm not the only one who, as a heterosexual male, find himself in your descriptions of the lesbian gaze at women a lot. I've been having many of those same ambivalent feelings about my attraction to women, and there's a good reason I usually write stories from a female perspective, also getting a kind of enjoyment and emotional identification out of f/f stories (like yuri) that I don't really find elsewhere. I feel much closer to many of the stereotypes of female sexuality presented in the first half of the tangent than most perceptions of male sexuality.

Evan Deo

I've also had very similar experiences re: reading vs seeing for sexual stimulation and the insistence of sexual urges on T. Another thing I wasn't prepared for (and I have no idea if it's a common reaction) was that my eyes started feeling like magnets drawn to chests. I never before had to try to look at someone's face instead of their boobs while having a conversation. Young, old, big tits, little tits, it doesn't even matter if I find them attractive. At least a few times a week, I have to consciously fight my gaze from drifting down. It's frankly mortifying and I can't imagine how I'd view women if that had been present since puberty.

Kodak

I need you to know that I now think about that woman who wants to see Thor nude like once a week at least. I love her, I want to be her friend. I cannot get over the way she is just obviously not second guessing her sexuality or her desires. I'm here for it. 💖

Martel

I heard someone posit once that fetishes form out of a misfired phobia of some sort. I think this was just forum philosophy without any real academic backing but if I'm remembering their argument right they were essentially making the case that a lot of fetish content centered around things that people without that fetish would find viscerally upsetting. Death, dismemberment, the more horrific kinds of monster fucking, transformation into inanimate objects, mind break, having something lay eggs in you, etc. Their theory was that they had at one point been so terrified of that concept that the brain coated it in a protective layer of sexual arousal to try and cope. A sexual stack overflow error. Certainly one of the more compelling hot takes I've ever heard on the subject but it still wouldn't account for the masculine propensity towards foot fetishes unless they meant to imply that men are uniquely likely to be terrified of feet.

L

I told a friend once, “yes, I like boobs and have def fantasized about women, but I never interpreted that as being bi bc I assumed I’ve been programmed to be turned on by that thru the male gaze.” And my friend said, “maybe it’s not that complicated. Maybe you can just like boobs? Is it possible to just like boobs for any reason, and just accept that liking boobs = bisexual?” I have since admitted I am bisexual but have only gone on a handful of dates w women and find them so disorienting!

Tasha

I am a bizarrely fast typist. I’ve never transcribed anything but this seems like it could almost be fun to transcribe? Anyways if I do I’ll come back to this comment and let you know lol

Sappho's Friend

"I heard someone posit once that fetishes form out of a misfired phobia of some sort." I can confirm it's true for my case that that plays a role, however i also remember it was present since i was a wee baby (i remember very early due to asd), so i think theres also some kind of inherent inborn neurological variability that leads to it even without any post-birth environmental factors. To clarify none of the things you named are my kink, but it applies regardless I think both of these contribute I also think theres different kinds of kinks, like leather, hand or foot fetishes are not analogous and that these different kinds behavioural kinks or fetishes that center around dangerous/vulnerable parts

Sappho's Friend

yeah, contra herself describes that ego boost/social desirability aspect.

molly

I feel this in kind of the reverse way. I've always had an aversion to scenarios where I am submissive/dominated and I can't tell if it's innate or comes from awareness of objectification and feminism from a young age

Cynthia Sonier

People are upset about objectification...like we don't live in a world that treats objects better than people! We worship objects all the time! We go into debt for having the "right" car, the "right" shoes, the "right" phone. We throw all human right principles out the door to get the ressources to make those objects. A particular class of objects, addictive substances, seem to have a lot more agency than the humans who buy them! Now, think about how many love songs that describe men's romantic feelings as an addiction. Are we sure that a little girl who grows up in a society like this would NOT prefer to be an object with the power of peeling people away from their money rather than the crying, vulnerable, heartbroken subject?

inhabitmoss

It's the old "being a sapphic teenager in the locker room at school but you don't know you're sapphic yet but you do know you feel deep burning shame at seeing everyone changing around you so out of respect to everyone else you pick a tile on the floor and Stare at it" conundrum

Anna Drew

Really could relate to part 6. One of the most priceless gifts I ever received is the full-length mirror and jewelry cabinet at my Dad gave me for Christmas 3 years ago. Aside from it being a true symbol of his support and affirmation, I spend an hour or so altogether per day standing in front of it, making sure my broach is correctly positioned, my hair is just right. Broach, necklace, earrings matches or compliments dress colors, how much clearance there is between my skirt and the floor and how much shoe is showing, etc. And when everything is perfect, I will then just stand there in front of the mirror for a good 15 minutes or so. I have to build this "vanity time" into my preparations to go out socially. And when I'm out it's the idea that I look good to myself that cancels any thought of what others think. But the compliments do come and that's just a bonus.

jean

i love your work so much natalie, especially from the perspective of an artist whose main interest is the perception and depiction of women! i literally took notes on this video for academic use and for my upcoming independent studio practice for university!

verter_osot

It was a really good video, thank you!

Hiroshi McBride

i can't believe you got Werner Herzog to narrate on this video

Mighty Yam

Watching this video was a fun exercise in realising how much a male-gazey dominated society has wrecked my sexuality beyond repair. It's a particularly disturbing reminder of how much of my self-image and self-worth comes from a sense of self-voyeurism, as though in order to self-actualize (self self self self) I must be able to view myself favourably from another person's (read: a man's) point of view. You know, I only really got into m/m after experiencing sexual assault and years of sexual coercion. I always assumed that some part of that interest must come from an unconscious desire to distance myself from sexual acts in order to find pleasure in them and to distance myself from a het dynamic that seems inextricably tied to gender-based violence and thus feels unsafe -even in fantasy. So I felt very seen listening to you talk about m/m in the context of women's sexuality.

Albertyna Varga

Everytime I watch something made by Contra (especially if it's about gender/womanhood) something in my head just clicks and I realize that I've had the exact thoughts she describes but couldn't put them into words. Contra really proves to me how important humanities/philosophy are, it's unfortunate that these days it tends not to be very respected.

Liam F

I'll definitely have to give this another viewing, but this just spoke to me so much.

Liam F

Honestly, as a bi guy who took a long time to fully accept his attraction to men, the big barrier for me beyond internalized homophobia was fear. I think I'm deeply intimidated by the idea of domineering masculine hypersexuality. I almost feel demisexual when it comes to men, and yet my attraction to them is undeniable when it kicks in. I actually identify a lot with yearning when it comes to men because it feels safe, it feels secure, and it allows me to trust. I don't know what this says about me, lol.

Mikayla Holland

This is so interesting to me because I’ve definitely heard this from trans folks before, and I (cis woman) relate more to the on T descriptors. It’s less true now that I’m in my 30s (or maybe it’s something else, who knows) but for a solid 10 years there my sex drive would not be ignored 😅 It makes me wonder about my own hormone levels, and what else might be at play, and it’s a bummer that science definitely cannot currently solve this mystery for me. Although I believe it was Natalie in another video that called philosophy inherently erotic because the big questions cannot be resolved, so I should probably just revel in the uncertainty ;)

Elizabeth

Is that Werner Herzog AI as Sigmund Freud? Because it’s what it sounds like and I’m living for it.

Cynthia Sonier

Some feminists say "the male gaze" the way the church said concupiscence! Reminds me of something I read somewhere online, I quote from memory: "Repeat after me: Attention from men is not a compliment" Um, yeah. That sounds like someone who would unironically taze herselfs every time she thinks of a man! The gays called, they say the 1950s have called them and want their conversion therapy back!

Anna

From personal experience, anecdotal, non-scientific: the more emotionally repressed and avoidant of true intimacy a woman is, the more her sexuality and gaze is similar to a man's. I believe therein lies the bulk of the difference + I guess MAYBE some hormonal stuff.

durnsidh `

That honestly might be the placebo effect. You associate T with masculinity, you associate masculinity with a certain kind of sexual expression, so you anticipate and create that sexual expression.

Jasper Rose

@durnsidh, I don't doubt that's a factor, but it's certainly not the whole story. I didn't expect it to change this much. It's come with a lot of physiological changes too. I can go into that a bit, maybe TMI... ((but there's definitely a shift in arousal in the primary sex organs. I used to have fluids through the entire interaction and only become engorged towards the very end, now it's the opposite, the first stage of arousal is now an erection, and I have to be extremely aroused to have enough lubrication to tolerate penetration. This begins to reverse after about a week off of T. My two transfem partners are the opposite, they now both leak a bit the entire time, and need to be extremely aroused to have an erection)) Changes in sex hormones, even small ones, have pretty dramatic effects on physiology regardless of sex or gender. Fat redistribution, (including hundreds of small, very subtle changes across the whole body that aren't just more/less hips and breasts) primary and secondary sexual characteristics, skin texture, muscle definition, smell, taste, hair texture, and a million other things you wouldn't really expect. Even cis people have changes in their mood and sexual behavior patterns when taking HRT. That's a huge reason people take it in the first place. Would you also suggest that trans women grow breasts because they associate femininity with more breast tissue? The brain is technically the organ that initiates that change. Maybe there's some influence there, but it's kind of a chicken and egg situation, isn't it? The idea that the shifts in sexual experiences of trans people during HRT are 100% socially constructed reads very "John Money" to me. All the evidence we have shows that there are biological factors to gender identity. Why is it hard for you to believe that it would cause changes in the brain? There is no real distinction between the body and mind, "physical" and "mental". It's all a single interconnected system of chemical reactions. It affects every other aspect of bio sex, and the brain is as much of a sex organ as a phallus.

Jasper Rose

Does a pregnant woman become more or less easily aroused and have strange cravings because of her cultural associations with pregnancy? Or because her body is genetically primed to react a certain way to progesterone? Probably more the latter than the former.

Elliot Theodor

Loved it, enlightening 💜 through as a trans man and former lesbian I kinda have to say - I never really noticed the male gaze on myself because I never cared whether men were attracted to me. I only realized that me looking at other women was potentially offensive after I transitioned, when it hit me that with my passing, as far as they are concerned I'm just another dude leering, and I toned that shit down VERY fast. Caveat: although as lesbian my existence was blissfully unaware of men on a concious level, I suppose its inevitable that some sneaky bits of toxic masculinity shaped my interactions and relationships to women in many ways, because yknow, I still live in the same world.

Olive Nicole

I'm sooo late to the party but I don't care, I need to talk about R. Crumb. I'm an indie comics artist who's pretty deep in the scene, so I hear his name a lot. I kinda like some of his art, and I appreciate that his subjects are "strong women"- at least they're preferable to the meek, submissive sex objects I'm used to- and he's clearly very skilled. I'm not angered by ugliness, or by erotic drawings of hot girls (obvious if you see my work). That said, I hate everything he's about. There's a specific ugliness to his (and many of his contemporaries') work that I can't come to terms with- manically vapid bug-eyes that clearly feel something but communicate nothing, showy crosshatched shading that often masks careless imprecise outlines, and pointlessly ugly and pathetic self portraits. R. Crumb's work is at odds with itself- where's the love for his subjects? His resentment blasts itself all over everything he tries to depict, and, in my opinion (many of my friends disagree), ruins the art! His hatred is obvious and obsessive, but incomplete and unexamined, and it even seeps into intimate portrayals of people he loves. Crumb's perspective is reactionary, confused rebellion against something he can't make sense of. Classic suburban male angst- the suburbs dream of violence, after all. You called his work "honest," but I don't think such a confused artist is capable of honesty. I think his art makes people worse, at least a little bit- it's not a coincidence that most of his fans that I've met are miserable (though maybe that's just what people who make comics are like). He clearly hates himself, so he'd agree with me

Belle

i am a woman and i love feet.

Lisa D

The section on fetishism was inspired, I loved your take.

Olive Nicole

Just found out that my parents and I had dinner with R Crumb when I was a baby. Couldn't make this up if I tried

Rose Dombegh

I wonder if the Netflix show "Young Royals" is an example of the "female gaze." Women were central to its production, the romance is (yes) soft, tender, built around desire and yearning more than gratuitous sex, and as a result I (a woman) find it way more erotically compelling than anything like Magic Mike.

Asocksual

Ooh, the part about men feeling like their desire for women is inherently predatory and that's why they objectify (which leads them to be actually predatory!) was extremely eye opening! Also, thank you so much for pointing out that women are into guys with a feminine streak, I'm aromantic and asexual (which makes hearing stuff like this utterly fascinating and honestly kind of hilarious, like damn you live like this? wild) so I wouldn't know, but I see a lot of stuff online which makes it pretty clear to me that women love cute femboys and men do not understand that at all. The world would be a better place if more men did, I think. Oh and I forgot to mention, the part about eye contact hits different for me as an autistic person who finds making eye contact to be an act that doesn't come naturally and something that requires conscious and discomforting effort.

Mirabai D

Hi Natalie! I’ve loved this video since it came out a year and a half ago, but I can’t help but think about how R. Crumb, the comic writer you used as an example of male sexual gazing, wrote and published a comic documenting the time he drugged and raped a woman. It’s unequivocally rape in the comic, he even draws her screaming and crying “NO! NO!” while it happens. I can’t help but feel that this massively complicates the notion that male sexual desire is “just like that” and we should accept it. Crumb was a confessed rapist, not just a vague misogynist. I don’t think his depictions of women should be held up as innocent horniness when he himself was a violent person who assaulted the women he was so obsessed with.

Kelly Chartier

I am no expert. Connection is a language a great deal of people do not understand. It's also something that is not easily visually depicted. But is desirable, particularly for those only fluent on a language of physicality; as that can be unfulfilling in its loneliness. There's been a lot of dried up language about the dread of seeing the object as a subject, and to be seen, that medicalizes the act of building the bridge to connect. And, in futility towards building that bridge, says objectification is fine. It's what we've got to work with. Which is odd to me, because if you change the environment of any object, you'll see that object differently, even spiritually. What is enshrined as sacred in your home? Forgive my frustration. I think I'm not fully getting this. But it seems to me a giant paradox to speak to us using dry language about putting together this sexual emotion with our meat parts, and yet say it in a fluid, musical way as though you're trying to connect at a deeper level. It perplexes me this contradiction. Is it an act you only put on for the camera? Do you not try to connect in this way with the people you know? Have you not felt that connection? 😮‍💨

Seiya

I am not a woman. I am NB femme but I used to indentify as a woman and I was socialized as one so I still relate heavily to the experiences of women. I'm also bisexual and will tell anyone who will listen that as a bi person I feel much more secure in my attraction to men than most hetero women seem to be. Unlike most het women, I have interrogated my sexual desires and faced the fact that, yes, mens bodies really do "do it" for me. They aren't the only bodies that do it for me. But I would never imply that mens bodies or sex with men is unpleasant and something to be endured by women in exchange for emotional closeness with men the way I hear a lot of straight woman AND men implying. I love chest hair. I love the soft rippling musculature of a man who is physically capable and strong but also soft and pliable and warm. I like dicks and beards and the masculine "musk". And all of that does it for me visually and physically. However, I find that even if all those elements of attraction are there for me with a particular man, I will not be able to maintain attraction to that man unless I also respect him and find him emotionally attractive. In a way my attraction to men's bodies as objects is Contingent on my attraction to them as subjects that I to identify with. Even a man I have previously enjoyed the physical act of sex with and found myself very physically attracted to in the past, if subsequently I find that that he is self centered; inconsiderate of others; lacks integrity; is emotionally immature: then I will no longer be able to maintain my physical attraction to him. Or not to the same degree. Even if my body still responds with some attraction to that man, it will no longer be as intense and my enjoyment of the physical act of sex with him will be much diminished. Like it goes from great sex with chemistry that keeps me in the moment to mediocre less than fully satisfying mechanics. It's as though the fullness of my erotic enjoyment of someone requires and element of seeing them, identifying with them and feeling seen and identified with by them. And I don't know how common my particular experience is in other femme or afab people. I feel like when I speak to women who sleep with men, they share some element of this experience. And when I speak with men who sleep with men, I find they don't tend to report similar stipulations for their sexual partners. I feel like I hear from gay men about experiences of grinder as anonymous mechanical sexual encounters and hear that referred to as satisfactory for them in a way I don't think it could ever be for me. Perhaps this is because gay mens perception of the danger men might pose to them is very different from an afab persons perception of the danger men might pose to them? Maybe I need to respect and identify with my male sexual partners in order to fully embody my attraction to them because as an afab person I have been told and seen the statistics my entire life that the person I am most likely to be murdered by is a male intimate partner. And maybe that creates psychological environment in which I can only enjoy a mans body if I feel safe with him, and I can only feel safe with him of I feel like he sees me as a person. (Not to say that gay men cannot also be victims of intimate partner violence and assault, only that the threat of sexual violence has maybe not permeated every single conversation about how they're supposed to interact with the world and with other men the same way it does for afab people, so maybe it isn't such a defining feature of their mental conceptions of the world and their safety in it.)

Seiya

My teenage interests in slash fic was a fantasy about being desired by a man without being socially degraded by his desire or having my identity as an individual subsumed by the ways society sees a woman or afab person who is a man's sexual partner as his property.

Lauren Shear

Was about to say this! I'd totally listen to Freud's work if I knew Herzog read the audiobook!

A

not to be parasocial like that...but i think you are probably the smartest person ever alive

Soobshoob

man i wanna watch Hannibal with you

mati johnston

This was amazing. I don’t understand how I can watch a video like this and feel I understand a topic better yet still not be able to concisely articulate what I’ve learnt, but I know for sure it’s the case. Makes my little physicist brain explode. Also, this was amazing couples therapy for me. My partner and I have amazing. communication but i understand things he’s been telling me since I started transition way better now. Ironically it was when you were taking about lesbians I got it. Irony! People need to see a reflection of their own style of objectification to understand it as objectification. I get it, I’ve got it 😂 Haha, passive, but… hungry.

Nick Austin

Rewatching cause I miss mother

Rose Dombegh

I so want a revision of this given the advent of Heated Rivalry. Here's my take: I feel like Heated Rivalry epitomizes female gaze, and it includes quite a lot of visual gazing/visual sexuality. But it provides visual sexuality in an emotional/sociological context that seems far more appealing to women than a hard masculine strip-tease demonstration. Limited personal experience leads me to think that this shouldn't be completely attributed just to internalized shame. Yes, the narrative structure of heated rivalry might provide a fantasy for women to lose themself in and, through identifying with a male subject, negate the shame of gazing at and desiring a male object (essentially giving women permission to experience men's sexuality) ... but I think there are more straightforward ways to explain it. Personally, I think it's largely that the narrative structure creates a sense of emotional intimacy that awakens the desire for gazing and makes the gazing feel safer, more intimate, and thus more enjoyable. At least in my experience & from talking with female friends, some level of emotional intimacy seems important to sexual desire in a way that goes beyond "needing permission to look." If anything, it's often the other way around; emotional intimacy & the building of emotional tension can usher in the desire to gaze, to see the person as a potential beloved. So maybe it's not that the female gaze is about "emotions" (good) while the male gaze is about "bodies" (ew), but rather that different emotional/social circumstances lead women to desire visual stimuli, to spark an interest in bodies. These circumstances aren't provided by Magic Mike or Playgirl magazine or whatever, which leads people to interpret female desire as not being physical or lustful.

xx-

The question of "why don't women like superhero movies?" came up, "even though they have female superheros like black widow and captain marval?" And i started thinking about how the thing in the entire marvel franchise that appealed most to female audiances was captain america's angsty relationship with bucky barns, his friend turned enemy. And how women love lord of the rings. and i think what girls want to see are men having intense, dramatic, complicated feelings. like they're strong in body but their heart is vulnerable. they care about something.

XYA|6782

As someone born as a male, I only grew up on female YouTubers like unjaded jade, Ruby granger, Jen smith vlogs from prank vs prank after her break and a anewhopeee/catie wayne or boxxy how some people may know her and other forms of female/feminist media with some male YouTubers that didn't focus much on the male gaze as the primary form of content. I've found that in my adult life; like the lesbian that gazes at her partners body sexuality and feels a lot of shame. That I also do feel a lot of shame and it doesn't help that I have a high sex drive, I won't say it comes from feminist media but I feel wrong to feel incredibly attracted to a women and I feel as though i'm a bad person. I won't go much into it because I also commented something about this on gamergate tangent and AMA streams before as this tends to be a recurring theme or a point of contention in your videos. I just feel that if there is more shame around male sexuality or just any sort of sexuality like the one you mentioned about a lesbian staring at her partner lustfully can cause shame. This could cause boys that are born in recent years to feel a lot of sexual shame that may even cause them, to stop and shame their own sexuality. which could further cause sexual inhibition when in a sexual setting your girlfriend might want that sense of erotic validation from you but can't get that which can then in return cause resentment. I feel that young boys and girls need to learn how to express sexuality in a healthy way that also encourages us to open up sexually in a consensual relationship without shaming any one.

Chrombus

Gross. I should never write anything down.

Ian Patrick

I imagine some folks here have seen Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, Jane Schoenbrunn's 80's slasher homage. It has a lot to say about women and queer folk "borrowing" the male gaze to better enjoy sex. As Natalie describes, straight couples, particularly egalitarian straight couples, can *absolutely* struggle with the object/subject problem in the bedroom: that while respecting your partner's subjectivity may be indispensable to a happy relationship, but it's not always smoking' hot. I assume that's why kink, even a self-consciously silly version of it, is often prevalent in egalitarian hetero circles.

Saxifrage

Can't believe you got Werner Herzog to voice Sigmun Freud in this tangent