Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends,

Here is the longest video of my career. It’s about Twilight. For a long time people have been asking me to make a video about love/lust/limerence. I consider this to be that video.

I began work on this in summer 2022, and things got out of hand from there.

Originally I'd planned to make a video called “Top/Bottom” or something like that, about feminist debates around sex and power. But I worried that wouldn’t be a suitable topic for YouTube, increasingly a “family friendly” platform.

So I turned instead to a more PG-13 version of these same issues, namely discourse around Twilight, which was having a pop culture renaissance at the time.

Research on Twilight sent me spiraling down rabbit hole after rabbit hole of adjacent topics, from the psychology of fantasy to the philosophy of desire to the history of the romance novel. I also cannibalized many of the notes for what would have been "The Hunger (Part 2)."

The result is a video that’s kind of about Twilight, and kind of a defense of psychoanalysis against the sexual ethos of my generation.

I’ve been living with this project for so long now I genuinely have no idea whether it’s crazy good or crazy bad, but fortunately that’s for you to decide, not me—let me know what you think!

I’m going to take a week off to recover, and then let’s talk Tangents.

Thanks as always for your patience and support.

Ilysm,

Natalie

Files

Twilight | ContraPoints

Join me on the path to Twilightenment. Support this channel: https://www.patreon.com/contrapoints •Donate: https://paypal.me/contrapoints •Twitter: https://twitter.com/ContraPoints •Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/contrapoints/ •https://www.tumblr.com/blog/nataliewynn •Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ContraPoints/ •Website: https://www.contrapoints.com/ •Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPoints •ContraPoints Live: https://www.youtube.com/c/ContraPointsLive Check out my other videos: The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/EmT0i0xG6zg The Hunger: https://youtu.be/RTRT794IQBg Envy: https://youtu.be/aPhrTOg1RUk J.K. Rowling: https://youtu.be/7gDKbT_l2us Voting: https://youtu.be/t3Vah8sUFgI Justice (Part 1): https://youtu.be/smQsfNw_7V4 Cringe: https://youtu.be/vRBsaJPkt2Q Shame: https://youtu.be/K7WvHTl_Q7I Canceling: https://youtu.be/OjMPJVmXxV8 Opulence: https://youtu.be/jD-PbF3ywGo ▬ Contents▬ 00:00 Part 0: Twilight 05:00 Part 1: Fiction 18:30 Part 2: Desire 44:21 Part 3: Fantasy 1:22:54 Part 4: Power 1:51:28 Part 5: Death 2:22:12 Part 6: Identity

Comments

Lizzy

FHDJSJDBDHSH

DansuIkari

Yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyes. Love you mummy.

Ryann Johnson

Words cannot describe my excitement for this

Jules

well there go my plans for the day! ❤️ YAY

Usurp

What a birthday present, thank you!

Sadie Rae

YEEEAAH BABYYY OHHH YEAHHH WOOOO!!!

beefo

love you mother.... happy friday......

DansuIkari

Ohh my god. I'm so hyped. Really looking forward to watch it :D

Damien

THANK YOU MOTHER <333

Daughters of Ferrix

Well done getting it up after your premiere crash yesterday! I hope you feel really rejuvenated from your week off, thanks for your hard work 💛

sam

YESSSSSSSS

vasilis

The only Oppenheimer-length film I need to watch

Raye

🚨🚨🚨MEGASLAY ALERT🚨🚨🚨

Sophia Z.

I NEED that top/bottom video😭😭😭

val

could not have guessed this video topic at all. however i am SO ready for this

Eric J

Yay I’m so excited to watch it! Thanks for your hard work Natalie 💜💜

Tommy

this was made for meeeeeeeeeeee

Cmoney

I trusted the process. It’s time bitchez!

RJ Blue

Friday night plans just dropped 😍

Lejasserie

Noice a great start to March. We appreciate your work! 🌟

Ashton

Three hours we are EATING TONIGHT

Veislogia

been waiting for that new video for what feels like years but i dont mind, the wait will be worth it no doubt!!!! 💙

Robin

Fuck yeah, I can’t wait to watch this

KnoXX Vicious

I'll be a twilight nb until I die. I'm foaming at the mouth for mother to educate me about my most beloved hyperfixation

Viktor KH

Enjoy your week off to the fullest extent! I can't wait to watch this first thing tomorrow morning 🖤

Simon

I waited how long for a Video about Twilight? This is not a joke is it, ok time to learn about Twilight I guess😷⚕️😤

Garrett on LSD

Eyyyyyyy!!!! I know what i’m doing tonight with my family after a healthy dinner of shawarma and bong rips lets go!

anna

well damn. your videos and the entire twilight series are the two things i rewatch the most. target audience reached.

DansuIkari

Now using the chance to be one of the first in your comments and get your attention. Thanks for your amazing work and I hope you are fine. Thanks for the patreon pause. It shows that you do it for the cause and not for the moneyz, but I wish you all the wealth and happiness in the world. Please stay like you are and share your amazing thought with us. Maybe cut down on your own perfectionism for you own happiness sake. And a wish for last. Maybe Israel Palestine conflict next time? Would love to hear your Perspektive on it. But you know what's best for yourself. Just throwing in ideas. XOXO<3

edaV

❤️

Jessica Cheeri

Aw yeah! I know I'm going to have more thoughts about this one when I'm done watching, especially about the psychology of fantasy section. I know you've been working on this one for a while, so a big congratulations for you! Edit: Yes yes yes! I loved it, it's exactly what I needed and I loved how long it was. This, especially the whole segment on disavowal (which I've always referred to as permission-seeking behavior) is a particular special interest of mine as someone who enjoys kinky things and had a path to trans discovery a long while back that had more than a little forced feminization fiction in it. So, thank you so much for making this, it's one of my favorites, and I hope you can take a rest for a bit

Allison Otting

GOD BLESS, this is just what I needed for my 10 hour flight tomorrow.

saltkettle

I’m so excited! I wrote a paper on twilight in college referencing the work of Susan Griffin on pornography. Thrilled to see your take!!

lily c

this gives me a reason to marathon the twilight series (which i’ve never seen). i would LOVE to see the top/bottom feminist video you mentioned though, perhaps in the future

Leahbunny

Yessssssssss! The synchronicity is sweet (was literally thinking about you when I got the notification). Thank you so much. I just came out as trans to my parents. I feel so light and I don't care when I hear the insults 🥰

Leanora

It is 10:30 at night here - looks like it's gonna be another late night for me

Seb Jones

The absolute BEST Friday night surprise!

leo over monroeville

i was JUST in the process of making contrapoints themed bracelets to distract myself from waiting for the video to drop AND i have my twilight bedsheets on......maybe manifesting works after all I'M SO EXCITED

Zeif

I'm very excited for this. Consider taking a month off, to Really rest and reset?

Liam Gregory

congrats on finishing the video! must be exciting to get it off your desk!

jada

ohhhhhh i'm exactly the target audience for this. dropping everything including my midterm papers

Karen Larkin

Natalie I am SO excited for this. Thank you so much, I appreciate your work

e ponce

I can't stand how excited I am to watch this Bollywood length masterpiece (I'm sure). *screamsinearly2000snostalgia

Jaololpes

I missed this. I'm gonna save it for the weekend. Thank you so much Natalie ❤️ Take care

Ariel

3 hour video, goddamn you spoil us! Please rest as much as you need, I can’t even imagine the amount of work that was required to work on something like this. Girl, take a vacation.

Tyler Ray

My body is ready to watch your video on repeat for the next 6 months every night

Patryk Zep

Hey Nat, i was thinking about asking you about this: what do you think about a series of videos about the process of making these videos? Maybe split into script making, montage, a biological woman's venture to create a cohesive color story and issues along the way. I think this would be very cool and interesing, not sure if only for me :) no pressure tho, I appreciate your hard work and thank you for this vid, I will be watching it soon 💗

Augusten Ladd

Finally something worth fucking watching in this fucking hell hole ass fucking disgusting garbage world.

Lizzie

The contacts are brilliant 10/10

Jordan00

SO excited, thank you!

Spencer Hubbard

was your harpsicord built by William Dowd?

Elias Tsirides

ok.. seems I am going to go to bed at 3 in the morning..

1x9nta

Indeed the fruit is sweet!

Merry Iris

I'm so excited can't wait to watch!!!!!

Ali Erdaty

No. Freaking. Way. I love Twilight. So worth the wait!!!

Regina Cuddeback

I gasped when I got the email and saw "Twilight" edit: amazing as always. Some parts reminded me a lot of Big Joel's "A Surprisingly Passionate Defense of Twilight", I wonder if you watched it! Also, after taking a hit, I will argue that christianity has BDSM influences and more so than the reverse.

Jesanthepus

The GOAT is back ❤️ I am so thoroughly excited for this, thank you for all the hard work mom. (Also: having never really had anything to do with twilight, my excitement shows me how indiscriminately I love your content and how I trust anything you put work into to yield something insightful.)

starwen

BEST NEWS IN THE WORLD!

Sam G

YAAAAAAAY

Asche Helling

YEEEEESSSSSS HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO MEEEE!!

Annabelle_Thann

WAKE UP BABE NEW THREE HOUR CONTRAPOINTS VIDEO JUST DROPPED

Daria Marchenko

I thought this day couldn’t possibly get any better 🥹 Thank you so much Natalie, I can’t wait 🍎

Joshua White

Forget Dune, THIS is the 3 hour event my friends and I will be viewing this weekend.

Made of Stardust

"I chose Twilight to be PG-13" "What's you're favorite type of heroine? Comment below" I love you Natalie. Thank you.

Amalia

I'm seven minutes in and the editing is killing me, it's so perfect! I can't believe you dedicated 18 months of your life to Twilight, amazing

Bill Rutherford

Cancel all my meetings! Looking forward to this

ANDREA

thank youuuu ❤️❤️

ChutneyBear

I saw that my usual full amount had been debited on Patreon this month and I was like 🤞🤞🤞🤞does this mean a new Contrapoints video?!?!? YOU DID NOT DISAPPOINT! Eeee just about to tuck in, thank you!

Rick Griffin

I wasn't sure if this one was gonna be for me, but then you got to the first chapter and this is SO in my wheelhouse Still watching (obviously) but fear and transgression are definitely an inextricable part of eroticism. Like any fantasy, it's not an acceptance of threat and peril, it's a re-imagining of them into something until the control of the author, imparted to the reader. Danger and imbalance and problematicnessism adds thrill.

CrystalJade

Yaaay!! I can’t wait. The power of metaphor in the right hands cannot be underestimated. It’s the force that underpins meaning, and transcends desire and repetition into the space of jouissance. It’s too late to begin this, but I now have a beautiful Sunday on my hands!! Thank you!! ❤️

MindFlayerInABathrobe

3-hour Twilight Deep Dive is not what I was expecting, but honestly I'm here for it

Davide

I'm going through a shit time, capitalism is making me work myself to death. but a 3 hour Twilight video at midnight on a Friday night (local time) is just what I needed. bread for the soul. Thanks Natalie!

Stephen Brealey

Too late for me to start tonight, but this is a chunk of my next day off sorted.

LC

Yayyyy 🥳

Knobiknows

aww yiss, motherfucking breadcrumbs!

Coolsoy

Congratulations Natalie. Hope you enjoy some R&R, you've definitely earned it.

michael mcgrath

Natalie, I hope you know how I (and many, many others) would be willing to wait for decades for a single video. An absolute slay. Categorically fucking brilliant. Love you.

Nate

Actually gagged beyond belief to hear you talking about Anne Carson

valentina

Does this mean The Hunger Part 2 is never releasing?

B

I hate the wait, but it is always worth it in the end. The fact that it’s almost 3 hours long is iconic. I am so fucking excited to watch this. THANKS FOR FEEDING US MOTHERRR 🧛🏻❤️

Richard Earley

I walked out of watching Dune and this was the first notification I got!!

AnkhKeeper

This is perfect timing considering that I have a limerence now…

☀️ Ben H☀️

The main channel videos for the past while have all seemed to link up with whatever stuff is a current issue in my personal life, and based off the description this is the same. Im very excited to watch!! And 3 hours! Make sure to rest up.

☀️ Ben H☀️

I think an AMA for the new video would be pretty good, seeing as there are a few tangents to catch up on

Grace Griffin

Watching this as a reward for finally securing a job! Excellent work, as always

ROMAN!!!

you look so hot!

Erk

So, one of my best friends wrote her master's thesis on twilight a few years back. A little while later she passed away, and I *really fucking wish* she was here to watch this with me, but thank you Natalie for being the closest I've felt in a long time to talking to her about Kylo Ren and Twilight and women's fiction and how people see it. It's cheesy as hell, but I kinda feel like I'm having lunch and chatting with her as I watch this and I'm choking up a bit.

Elli Seiff

im crossfaded and in my own lesbian desire cycle right now and this video is making me cry

Peter Rozing

Thank you Natalie! As always,this makes my day!

highclass_lady

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Veronica Barratt

As someone named Veronica, who has been recently engaging in limerence. The "suppose hypothetically, someone named Veronica, is an unrequited love" - I felt personally called out 😂

faith

i loved this a tonne. i texted my friends about this (because we’d watched twilight and fifty shades together during a drunk sesh at my house) and i expect them to watch it soon

Aqua Burton

The fact that the final line in your last video was foreshadowing this one is amazing. I can’t wait to watch it!!

OnlyUkeThatMatters

okay, now i know what i want for my birthday: one used copy of "penile imperialism"

David

Thunderous applause! Honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if you get an honorary doctorate some day. Or a regular one. Gloria Anzaldúa never got her PhD, but it was only because she refused to accept a non-traditional dissertation exception for her works on Borderlands.

Parafox

We got a new Contrapoints video before GTA6 🎉

Jaime Oni

I've been wrecked by the end of a three year relationship and this video was such a comforting three hours <3 brilliant and funny as always

Ash Gabrielle

Haven't watched it yet so no verdict whether it's good or bad (though as a Patreon patron I am of course biased so I'm sure I'll love it), but can't wait to watch this with my spouse this weekend :) every time there's a new Contrapoints video we curl up and watch it on the TV together.

Joe Johnston

Where did you even find that crazy choker in part 5? Genius.

sw

Godel Escher Bach Meyer Mozart Augustine

DatePitLeftovers

I’m basically just going to share this video to anybody who discusses romance/erotica with me, either in a positive or negative manner. I read a ton of it, and it’s exhausting to defend something that I like, like pumpkin spice latte, but also I’m energized by talking about the sexual politics in the media I consume.

Tomás Arriagada

Wow Ive just watched the whole video, I don't know how you managed to put all my anxieties together and give them a nuanced answer and """"resolution """ I will ponder this video for months to come. It just gave me a lot of food for thought and I feel so humbled after this. [I have never read twilight but the video felt deeply personal]

Asha Busova

Really amazing video! Take your time resting up doll : )

breausephina

I just finished the whole video and will likely watch it many more times. The first Rowling video in 2021 was what prompted me to come out as a trans man while married to a cis man; for me Twilight feels like it answers, or at least starts to answer, a lot of the questions that have risen out of my transition with regard to gender, power, and fantasy and what they've meant for me on the feminine and masculine sides of my transition. I'm so excited to share this. FWIW I vote crazy good.

V

This video was fantastic! The tangent from last year on objectification definitely felt like prerequisite viewing

Kyra Styner

Waking up to this post was like waking up on Christmas morning. I am giddy.

Honoria Valemon

Just putting it into the world, if you ever decide to make your scripts into a book of essays, I would buy it SO FAST. And buy tickets for the inevitable book tour.

Amalia

Okay, I finished the video, and bravo. Had me constantly reflecting on my own feelings about sexuality and desire in a really profound and enlightening way. Amazing, amazing work. So proud to be a patron and send you a few dollars to support this kind of thoughtful, empathetic philosophy.

Andy Pfau

Amongst your best. Great job!

John Giacobello

WOW. Looks and sounds amazing, gorgeous. I can’t believe how much is pulled together here, and resolved with such grace. I’ve never seen Twilight; need to watch it then take this all in again. My head and heart are spinning.

MindFlayerInABathrobe

Dang, this is some amazing work! I'd honestly never understood the appeal of books like Twilight before, but now I think I get it. Also making me rethink the way I relate to my gender and sexuality, and I am loving it.

Lee S.

We love you and love this!

Gwen Stearns

Not to encourage your worst impulses or anything, but this would've been worth the wait if it had taken twice as long to come out.

Gart Kundalini

thank you! hope the recovery goes well. take care of yourself~

estella

him: you'd better not be the world's most dangerous predator when i get there me embodying the yin in his yang in his yin in my yang: also side note but i really liked your playing in the credits of this one. you can really feel the emotion in it. clair de lune is great

King Scene

are you really sure you want a family friendly best heroin discussion in the comments - because while I could weigh in as an expert quitter I've found it's not really the best way to get past an addiction

Aristana Scourtas

Halfway through and DAMN it’s so good! My friends and I canned boardgame night so we could watch this together ❤️ I love the tie ins to all of your recent tangents from the last several months!

Craig Ruis Fisher

Thank you for creating. You’re a beautiful human. We love you!

Ethan Oswell

This is honestly such a banger. And, not to be superficial, but the outfits are just - Mwah - Perfect.

Elli Seiff

also, i relate a lot to the chapter about death because i went through some violent medical trauma that has given me ptsd. thus, i have a lot of subconscious fears of penetration in that general way you described. really helped my thinking on the matter!

Chloë Joan López

The phrase “advanced Lacanian astropsychology” will sustain me on my next extended sojourn across our vast discursive wasteland.

Munchy Lunchco

Worth the wait. I feel like this video has given me so much to think about and has lead me to realize some things about myself (like reframing my sexual preferences, for example.) Going to be reflecting on this for quite some time. Can't wait to rewatch this after some time has passed. Thank you for your hard work, Natalie!

Audrey M

so good as always! a lot to think about with this one, and a lot to read aka the entire twilight series. sending you a big nap after this one 💖

katxwithwings

I love this video so much. As someone who has been reading and writing fanfics since middle school, this video felt like you took some of my own thoughts and reflections of my kinks and beloved romance tropes and gave it the context and research that I could never do. I also love that you used Twilight as a vehicle for examining love and desire, because Twilight and other romance books like it are truly an unfiltered look at a certain type of female fantasy, including the good the bad and the ugly.

Chloë Joan López

And I guess we really are in the middle of Sex Wars II, aren’t we? Revisiting all those rebuttals to the ilk of Jefferies (jesus christ, Janice Raymond is still alive and blurbing??) is fun for me, because it’s nostalgic, but the fact that it’s necessary also makes me sad for the young people that we couldn’t radical queer a better world for them. I blame 9/11.

Marlene

This video is soooo good 😍 thank you

holdorz

THANK YOU

super evil sam

Natalie, I’m not exaggerating when I say this is not only the best video you’ve ever made, but literally just the best thing ever made in general. The long wait was well worth it for this absolute masterpiece. Love you queen mother <3

Jenavive!

I love that she so perfectly demonstrated the relationship between desire and lack by delaying the release. Still reeling, cannot wait to rewatch, 287364876234 out of 10, holy shit, screaming, bus, club, another club, linda evangelista, thank you, missed you, thank you, gnight.

super evil sam

Anyways, I will probably listen to this every night to go to sleep

Sappho's Friend

ayy its like an expansion of the male gaze

Wadeofhonor

Just finished. Wonderful job. Coherent and thoughtful all the way through.

Ollie

crazy good

Mel Vitta

This is probably the hardest ContraPoints video I've ever watched because I could not stop pausing the video to reflect on my own Twilight history and constant desire to post comments about every little thing. Twilight is such a weird series for me. I have so much weird personal baggage tied up in these books, from the fact that they are tied up with an ex that I have not nor will I ever fully get over, to how I found Twilight in Barnes and Noble when it was still a relatively new book and there was just a small online fandom (yes, I am saying I'm a Twilight hipster). I will always like Twilight. It will always be one of my franchises of all time.

Andrei D.

Man, I'd kill for a list of all those book behind her

Surna

Collaboration with Andrea Long Chu when?

Alice

Great video! Congrats on finishing it!

Ren ☆

You AND my spider essayist posted at the same time…. I will be feasting for days. Do not call upon me, I’m busy

CodeTako

This was the very thought provoking and brought together a lot of ideas in a satisfying way. Great job on the whole production, and enjoy your rest!

Pendleton

Spider essayist?

Grigorios

The necklace at part 5: Death is incredible. Production design is always brilliant but that particular detail stood out to me.

Hellvetika

Can anyone tell me the name of the song she's playing during the end credits?

Kata Kéri

It’s clair de lune by debussy

Hellvetika

thank you!! I knew I knew it but couldnt put for the life of me remember the name. on a related note, the name "debussy" has aged really unfortunately

Zindagigi

This was amazing! can't wait to re-watch it in a month or so

Cat Cannon

I went to a viewing of Twilight last year at a small soviet-era movie theater in Budapest. It ended up being me (a 30-year-old woman in the "twilight" of her life) and about 50 Hungarian teenagers. I was struck by the way they interacted with the movie, enjoying it ironically and sincerely at the same time. Within seconds everyone was howling with laughter. They laughed en masse at the absurd elements of the movie (Edward's constant glowering for example,) even saying the cringiest lines along with the characters ("This is the skin of a killer, Bella," in perfect unison, in a Hungarian accent, very delightful,) but they also wholeheartedly engaged with the fantasy. They squealed when the male vampires were introduced (Jasper got the least love, Carlisle the most) and genuinely enjoyed the romance. This felt to me like a very healthy and lighthearted way to engage with this piece of media and I laughed along with them the whole time. My favorite ever movie-viewing experience. On an unrelated note I'm a lesbian and am staunchly Team Charlie. I can't explain it but he's the lesbianest character in that whole series Wonderful work, Nat! Your best one yet, and that's saying something <3

Neil

Haven’t watched yet. Just seen the email. Shrieked with delight. Saturday plans on hold. Nothing quite like that moment when a new Contraptions video drops! 🍿 🥰

Neil

Enjoy your very, very well earned rest, Nat. You’re the best! X

Matthew Mendenhall

This is your most challenging video ever. Your breakdown of DHSM tagged at the end of a 3 hour video is a gag. We organize our self-concept using those DHSM dyads. For example, I know at this stage of my life I am attracted to men and male bodies, however, there is a point at which I do find myself to be homosexual because of my submissive tendencies. That through-line is unethical as you argue. You’ve reached real knowledge here in the discourse community and that’s really exciting to be a part of as a fan and supporter of you. (Btw, I’m also so proud of you for not doom scrolling horrible people on X for content to make this video. You’re our self-care icon. 😇)

Daniel Loizos

Hi Prof, Congratulations on your next magnum opus. Rest well x

insu

maybe the tangents could go to another platform that is less strict than YT? I think some thoughts are great to be explored, as not-family-friendly they might be. Then you could elaborate on the top/bottom aspects more specifically. Thanks for the video and the inspiring thoughts.

terrestrial trash

You've managed to make something even better than Envy. No notes. It's perfect. I assure you, it was fully worth the wait.

Pudžma

I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR MONTHS. and the first few mins of this is already crazy good. you’re my fav youtuber for sure. thank you for all of you work — have a great recovery;)

Ewen McNeill

Having watched all 3 hours (!!) of this, straight, it's amazing. Already easily in the top two of my favourite pieces of yours (I'm *extremely* fond of the one with the butterfiles... because butterflies 🦋). I especially liked the DHSM terminology, and the break down of the associated assumptions of gender roles. But the whole exploration of the place of romance fiction in society was also inspiring. I admit I wasn't sure of Twilight as the framing for this piece at the beginning, but having seen the whole piece I feel like the Twilight framing worked. And possibly even now makes it topical enough for more people to watch. The final 15 seconds, I have to say, was the pièce de résistance that had me applauding out loud. But all of it is stunning, and has depth I feel would reward a second watching. Possibly, though, the next epic video essay could be an hour and a half long? As a treat? 💚 (Or at least have a planned interimssion... I had to make my own :-) ) Ewen

Cinabeeeeee

This was worth the wait. Thank you for so eloquently exploring the connection between these topics in such a compassionate and comprehensive manner.

Gee

This is great! Thanks for the effort you put into your work. You have an amazing mind.

Megara

This was amazing. I think this is probably going to join Envy as one of my favourite videos (that I rewatch an insane amount). Also, your looks in this vid *mwah*

Alecxy

There is a porn category called “sensual” where woman is the main receiver of pleasure and man takes pleasure from giving pleasure to her. It still ends with penetration but that is still part of her receiving pleasure, because the position, frequency, intensity are all at what she wants. I wonder where would you put this category in power dynamics between heterosexual couples? I wasn’t aware of that I would find it more egalitarian until I experienced it.

Daniela

Incredible! Worth the wait. Apologies if you've posted this somewhere and I missed it, but is there anyway to access a reading list/ bibliography for the video? I too would like to spend 18 months in a Freudian spiral.

Wissa

This is my favorite video of yours thus far! I’ve never thought of it this way before—The way fantasy lets us escape from the burden of choosing, not just mundane things, but the act of choosing a partner is relegated to fate, “the universe forced us together” in many fictional scenarios.

White Punk On Dope

Now I understand the last line of your previous video.

Sndrccc

WOW. just finished it. wow

Nathaniel Solyn

I often rewatch Folding Ideas' trilogy video essay on 50 shades and was part of the high and mighty crowd regarding the book's "problematic implications"... Your video has thrown everything into fresh light, and I love it for the added nuance and remaining criticism you manage to bring. All well worth the wait.

Isaac_Enver

Great video! Worth waiting for, and I think Twilight was a good pull into the topics of literature and sexuality.

ikram hammi

Thank u for the video!!! It was a real delight

YogaDadBod

I think I died at the “post-cadence clarity” subtitle. You still got it, girl.

Viktor KH

Video was amazing! Fantastic argumentation. Love how deeply you went in on this. Well worth the wait. I'm also gonna go ahead and second everyone else in the comment section here asking for the bibliography

Samuel Victor

This video is absolutely fantastic, as expected. Not to make this all about me, but I found it very helpful. Natalie made another fantastic video and continues to be my favourite creator on the platform and one of the few I can genuinely say improves my life with every upload, and what it teaches me about myself and others. For those who want to skip a personal story, stop reading now. Job done. I'm a producer, writer, director and occasional actor in the film industry. (Several of my friends worked on the Twilight movies and I was somewhat on the perifery of the first 50 Shades film, so, um, sorry slash you're welcome depending on your opinions. I've also been quite heavily Potter adjacent so these fanfic parts made me giggle). I'm ostensibly a cis het male, though others, predominantly conservatives who are more rigid in people sticking to normative values may see me as otherwise. When I was a young child, I was always the star of school plays, very theatrical, and being in Britain in the 80s, and going to an all boys school in my teens, often crossdressed and played with gender norms for theatrical effect and creative expression. As a child, my favourite colour was pink and I loved "girls" toys, like My Little Ponies and Barbie.... as well as "boys" toys like He Man and Transformers. I just never understood rigid gender roles that seemed arbitrary. My parents and some teachers assumed that I would be gay as adult, and were fine with that. I'm in no way offended by people who assume this of me, I've just never been attracted to a man in that way. Anyway, as a teen in the 90s, I became a somewhat successful standup comedian touring holiday camps and the like, somewhat following the mold of Eddie Izzard, until one day (TW) I was a victim of an extremely homophobic near death attack from an audience member, offended with how I dressed and what they percieved as my slighty camp/effeminate demeanor on stage. I continued to have fairly steadily growing success in the entertainment industry, winning a song writing competition then transfering to mostly ghost writing lyrics for (and traveling and performing with) many multiplatinum American rappers and RnB stars, and then slowly moved into working on movies, starting with low budget British hooligan and Cockney gangster movies, then slowly getting success in Hollywood, working with brands like Star Wars and Marvel, and since 2014 I've been developing a new superhero franchise that was delayed by Covid and the strikes but now is being annouced at Comic Con later this year. What does any of this have to do with Natalie's video? Well, when I originally wrote the script in 2014, it was first inspired by me seeing the rise of Jordan Peterson becoming somewhat of a mentor and fatherfigure for young men the age of my own kids, who found his (sometimes admittedly valuable) psychological and self improvement advice helpful, but how that was leading to many of them becoming very toxic, enforcing conservative and right leaning values, also the rise of the incel movements and backlashes against the pop-feminism of the 2010s Tumblr memes etc. I came up with the idea of a male and female superhero, the man who was on the right, the female who was on the left, and both of whom had very different ideas of what it means to be a "hero" - the film also strongly explored the pressures on males and females to confirm to stereotypes and the media's role in pushing the propaganda since childhood. In the 5 years between writing the original draft and it being greenlit in 2019, several of my close friends, and a very close family member came out as either trans or non-binary. My want to educated myself to be as supportive as possible to them lead to me deep diving even more into these subjects, and adjusting the female superhero to be non-binary and A-sexual, and removing any possibility of romance between the two heroes, and added a more diverse and inclusive city for them to protect. I worked on the Star Wars film, Rogue One, where I suggested a re-write which included me writing (and saying in the movie) the line "Just Let the Girl Speak!" which became somewhat of a feminist rallying cry during the #MeToo movement and accidentally lead to me travelling the world since then talking about the importance of giving a voice to marginalised voices in the film industry, and raising money for Women's and LGBTQI+ causes. Again, all of this lead to me doubling down on these themes in the film, even when it meant having to turn down several major studio offers who wanted me to sanitise the script for foreign markets. Now, it has become more than a film, to me, its a chance to make the world a better place by encouraging these kinds of discussions via a major blockbuster title that will hopefully have a very wide audience. The thing is, I have become extremely introspective and soul searching of my own deep rooted subconscious biases, internalised fears that have manifested in toxic attitudes or behaviours in my youth that I work every day to try and course correct from and appease. I am now 42 years old and I have only recently made the connection that this extremely traumatic homophobic attack on me in my teens, for not conforming to gender norms, lead to my career in my 20s subconsciously only persuing ultra "masculine" and often toxic portrayals in the media - me being a "macho" (sexist!) rapper, playing skinhead football hooligans, cockney gangsters making homophobic or racially charged jokes etc in films. This behaviour mellowed over time, strongly encouraged by my longterm partner and children giving me more nuance and making me want to work for self improvement, but it was only really once accidentally becoming a voice for females and LGBTQI+ people in the industry (and having seen some truly appalling behaviour towards them) that I started reappraising my old behaviour and attitudes fully, disecting where I got those ideas from in the first place, and deciding to use my platform to be an ally. But still, I never did standup again, nor did I feel fully comfortable being personally seen as anything less than straight and 100% cis, despite seeing myself as an ally & supporting equality and fighting against homophobia. More recently I certainly don't care how others see me, and I've worked on any internal fear related to my own gender or sexuality that I'd evidently unconsciously internalised. After a Reddit AMA of mine about my career went viral, I was recently offered to do a standup / storytime special talking about my experiences in the industry... this lead to me thinking about how much transpobia is in current major Netflix specials, and wouldn't it be great to do a special that speaks out against this? It got me thinking of Eddie Izzard again, and how I used to idolise her. I am not sure how this will manifest in the special yet, but watch this space, I guess, I'm definitely comfortable with being more like my old self. I liked me as a kid. I was different and creative, and it was cool. Somewhere, I lost that, trying to be "a real man". Fuck that. Sadly during this process, my relationship of over 20 years reached its natural conclusion. I've had several opportunities at new relationships but many of the conflicts mentioned in Natalie's videos about power and gender dynamics in relationships, love and sex are now at the forefront of my mind, and I constantly worry about being a good partner, not wanting to give into deep seated emotional and sexual desires that perhaps I now realise could be unhealthy or harmful to myself and my partner, and even if my sexual and romantic preferences were ever truly mine in the first place, or just trying to conform and prove things to myself and others. It feels safer to be single until I work this stuff out. But also as someone in the entertainment industry for over 25 years, and who it on the cusp of moving into "true" mainstream (if that even exists nowadays) I am more and more aware of the responsibility to not push harmful stereotypes, and to set a good example, whilst also remembering that most audiences want an escapist fantasy, and not to be preached to, and most media shouldn't be taken literally. So yeah, TL:DR this video was very helpful to me from a professional curiosity perspective in how I portray relationships, sex, love, friendship and gender roles on screen, as well as from a more personal perspective trying to unravel my own sexual and romantic inclinations. Thank you, as always Natalie. (and if you ever want to be in a weird arty leftist movie masquerading as a blockbuster to trick Hollywood types, HMU. lol UWU)

Kapelski

I think you maybe should get the video runtimes a bit tighter in my opinion. 3 hours is honestly getting a bit out of hand.

Ezra Weissman

Potential patreon benefit - uploading an uncensored version of the video here!

Sunbeam

Congratulations! Even though the video is three hours long, it's so funny and well-written it flies by. While I'm still looking forward to the sequel to The Hunger, I'm glad to have watched this. My condolences with YouTube's shenanigans, and well done.

RJ Blue

I’m a very, very literal person — unfortunately, because I feel like it always ruined my ability to enjoy certain kinds of fiction — and this was such an interesting look at why people enjoy things I’ve never been able to get my head around. I’m embarrassed to say I was definitely one of the people who made fun of Twilight and 50SoG, and somehow did it while harbouring my own, very Zoomer lesbian-coded version of that power fantasy (wanting a MILF to step on me, and maybe also give me access to the power she has/validate me and my worth through her interest in me). As always, it gave me a ton to think about and maybe even a couple things to talk about in therapy. It’s always been there to some extent, but I love the amount of psychoanalysis you’re weaving into your videos lately. It’s what I’ve always admired most about your work, when it comes down to it — that ability to empathize with other people and give your viewers access to that empathic understanding. I’m proud to be a patron of yours, and I look forward to watching this at least a couple more times. ❤️

Lily

literally so good, tysm

Samuel Victor

My mother was been a professional writer of romantic fiction (non-explicit, for BBC radio & women's magazines) in the 80s and 90s. I am currently staying with her as she is ill, and decided to watch this video with her as I knew she'd be interested in the themes. That joke made me laugh, and I had to pause and explain to my 70+ year old mother what "post-nut clarity" was. Thanks Nat.

Chloë Joan López

Also while we’re on the topic of 1990s psychoanalytic ultrapretentious queer vampire film discourse, I feel the community needs to know about Nadja (1994), the recipient of my all-time favorite MPAA rating, rated R for “bizarre vampire sexuality” since it actually thinks through what lesbian vampire sex would entail.

Kristian Gendron

It’s funny because I’ve been thinking about the topic of desire and lover/beloved a lot recently, so the timing of this video was perfect (almost spooky). A buddy of mine who I introduced to your work a year or so ago made a joke today: “are you sure it’s spooky timing, or is it that contrapoints has just mind controlled you?” My response to that is that I don’t understand the question; fate or mind control— there is only one thing!! Also, whatever. I always do what mother says. (Thank you, I enjoyed this immensely. Definitely worth the wait)

Simone Aurora Simmons

I'm just sad that sunshine, a gorgeous vampire novel by Robin McKinley, written before twilight, never got the respect it deserved. It had all these themes but in a much more adult way and in a far superior writing style.

Marianne

As someone entering the third month of their depression chair, I appreciate a lot how you acknowledge the agony of heartbreak.

Jarod Karls

Truly incredible. Thank you for this

Kharina Sterner

Just finished watching and was thoroughly educated and entertained! Brava! 👏🏻

I identify as a Stuka!

Ah; the Church of Jesus H Christ of Faller-Day Saints, LLC - a division of Hyperdyne Defense Systems (Patent pending, copyright applied for, your results may vary, no warranty expressed or implied). Better known as the Moron Church...

Annie Fischer

Having a GREAT time watching! My sister and I have already said that it’s going to be rewatched multiple times

fae

😭 a twilight essay from natalie!!! it feels like my birthday and christmas and my christening all at once, thanks mom

Ari

Was the perfect end to my day. Thank you

Emil

Oh, man, this was a banger! I realize it's kind of asinine to comment on the Twilight part, because it's mostly just the framing device around the philosophy, but I'm gonna anyway, because I feel like I need to defend Stephenie Meyer's honor a bit. Your interpretation of why the Renesmée imprinting happened is probably the most lucid explanation I've ever heard, but I think it can't be true if you look at the order Meyer wrote the books. The bulk of Breaking Dawn was actually written during the editing of Twilight as a gift to Meyer's sister called "Forever Dawn," before Meyer knew she was going to have sequels, and, because the love triangle was something she came up with while writing New Moon, before Jacob Black was a main character or a love interest. And in Forever Dawn, where Jacob is just some dude Bella talked to a couple of times when she first moved to Forks, *he still imprinted on Renesmèe*, just when she was a couple weeks old and he came up to visit Bella instead of him being present at and it occurring at her birth. Renesmée/Jacob, as an official ship, actually predates Bella/Jacob. Honestly, I think the reason it happens is less deep than Meyer wanting to have her Edward and eat her Jacob too, and it was just that since Forever Dawn was originally written as a really long HP-style epilogue set a couple years in the future, Meyer wanted to make sure that everyone had a confirmed love interest, and there were Jacob and Renesmée, still single and needing a pairing.

Carol Foley

This was amazing and I am so glad to be a patron!

Sean

This explains so much about why my music theory professors always came off as horny, thank you so much, Natalie

Amy Morrison

Should have subbed ages ago but this three-hour opus made me want to start throwing dollar bills at the television so i came straight to Patreon. Highlight of the weekend.

deana bug

casually dropping THE most decadent synth version of the twilight melody-- mixed in with Natalie's performance, UGH !!!!! i cannot believe this

LSDFR2

I saw the title this morning and thought, oooh twilight, that will be a fun video! But now I've watched it I think this is my favourite video yet, exceeded my expectations in every way. It was amazing to see discussion of these books taken so far beyond them being unfeminist etc, Natalie's dissection of the complicated nature of human sexuality feels almost life-changing tbh. Thank you Natalie!

LSDFR2

Oh also, regarding your mitosis/genesis comparison: I've heard that the word "rib" is actually something of a mistranslation and it could equally be translated as either "side" or even "half". Not 100% sure this is true, but if it is it would make the comparison even more apt!

James Witzeman

Really amazing video Natalie, there’s no world where anyone could dislike this

Cassie Dee

After watching this one, I went for a run. I have a mix of high energy music to work out to, and Get Low by Lil John and the Eastside Boys came on. And I had a realization. Despite the fact that I am a cis woman, when I listen to this song, I am the one who skeet skeets. Till the sweat runs down MY balls May all you bitches crawl.

Ren ☆

Confirmed crazy good!

Pete Murney

Can only say bravo and that this was entirely worth waiting for! As a Twilight tangent the impact the books had and still have on Forks and La Push is also both interesting and entertaining. I've been out to that area regularly since the mid-80s and Forks in the 80s was at the center of the conflict over trying to preserve the last of the old growth forests outside of those preserved Olympic National Park. Forks was a bastion of anti-environmentalist pro-logging sentiment, the quintessential red neck logging town. Long after that battle was over - the trees cut, the logging jobs gone, etc - to see Forks become the center of teen vampire romance tourism was and is just very funny. It has also been heartening to see the Quileute Tribe able to expand and make more money off their resort thanks to increased tourism. There is, needless to say, a long history of racism against the tribal members in the area and their reservation is pathetically small given the area they originally occupied. It is wild what the real world impacts have been of Meyer randomly picking a spot on the map to set the books.

lorelei

CONGRATS QUEEN <3 we're so proud of you, enjoy your well-earned rest

Ernie Tremper

I did an involuntary squeak of delight when you shifted gears to start talking about power. This video synthesizes so much that is right up my alley and feels so vital. And still I couldn't believe how much the ideas in the final section bowled me over. A fucking triumph, your best video yet, so glad I subscribed, now rest and come back stronger than ever 💪 💙

Oetta Geraghty

Natalie, Eros The Bittersweet has been one of my favourite texts for years. The amount of times I have watched and rewatched your essays and thought about how deeply I hoped you had read, or would read, Carson's spectacular and fascinating essay is almost uncountable. Your mention of absence had me jumping up and down in my chair, telling a friend, who knows how much I love EtB, so when you listed the book on screen I honestly could not believe it, and had to stop watching for sheer excitement. I don't know anyone better suited to discussing these themes than you, and I cannot wait to properly sit down and take it all in once I can have a good chunk of time to do so. All my love..

Hanié

Loved it. This video is amazing. The only thing I can mention is that the editing pace felt like it was too fast, and needed more pauses and the audience needed a little time to catch a breath and even let the info sink. Although, understandably, you had to edit it this way because it’s almost 3h long; I personally can sit and listen to you and your ideas for 6h straight tbh. Side note: there is a Christina Yang (yeah from GA) quote that perfectly aligns with the last part, she says that she’s not with powerful men because they’re powerful, but because they resemble the power she has within herself. Also, you’re so inspiring ✨ Also: I think that the Parks and Rec episode about the time capsule and whether the Twilight books should be put in it or not would’ve been funny to throw in the mix. Especially the debate in the town meeting scene where they discuss whether it’s anti-Christian or too Christian.

Jordan C.

Incredible video that might even knock your Envy video from its number one spot for me! As a writer and consumer of romance fiction I thoroughly enjoyed the analysis of the genre and discussion of power dynamics. I love how your videos always make me think deeply and want to have conversations with other people about these topics to explore them more. Also, personally I love the long form videos! There are some topics that merit the extra time and breathing room, and I don’t think the time stamp should discourage a thorough analysis. I almost wish there was more!

Mandora

What a stunning cover film still, reminds me of fashion icons from the sixties.

Helena Martin

Natalie, this video made me rethink how I feel about my own relationship with sexuality and what I think about kink. Thanks again for a marvelous video, I have lots of things to journal about and/or chat to my therapist to lol 💖🌸❤️

Thais Laursen Munk

I love this video! I had not heard of Jack Halberstam before, but that quote of "If Sheila Jeffrey didn't exists, Camile Paglia would have had to invent her" truly made me laugh :D

Sean

Thank you for sharing this!!

LynnieBeep

Absolutely fantastic. I had to watch in chunks and I've just finished. You put words to a lot of feelings that I've had. Gonna spend some time thinking and mulling on this one. Also that Simpsons clip caught me, had such a big laugh.

kaitlin_equilibrates

I was feeling really amazed at how gracefully this video tied together so many of the themes that have come up in your work in the last five or six years right before you made the comment about doing this instead of a doctoral dissertation and ijbol. I loved everything about this. Congratulations!

Jack M.J.

I love this so much. It's fantastic. I do have a question on the theology in the video. Did you choose a Biblical lens in lieu of the Book of Mormon, Doctrine & Covenants, etc. because of audience or your familiarity with one over the other? I'm ExMo and just found it interesting. Not a critique by any means, just interested in your writing and research process.

Tomme

Incredible. Incredible. Incredible. There’s no one like you Natalie. Thank you!

Vivek Patel

If you've never moaned at a chord progression or a lush modulation or a beautifully sung vocal harmony, have you even lived? For me, the vocals before the bridge of I bet on Losing Dogs by mitski s e n d me. Also all of Symphonie Fantastique. Music definitely hits the same part of my brain that romance does. Thanks Natalie, this was well worth the wait

Lizzy

Thank you so much for this amazing work!!

Vivek Patel

'and you did it at my birthday dinner' always cracks me and my friend up. Your humour was spot on - Sheila Jefferies would've been tough to read about, but highlighting the absurdity with humour balances it nicely. In terms of problematic ships being a healthy exploration, I agree completely. Trying to draw a line around 'bad' ships is impossible and it gets silly fast. I know people who love Hannibal but draw the line at fanfic with an age gap (17 y.o/immortal god, which would still be coercive even without the age gap cos of the whole god thing). But yeah, thoughts about masc/femme duality and power in sex have been swirling a lot for me as a young gay guy and I definitely have a better understanding having watched this. I'd already kinda come to the conclusion that giving and receiving in equal measure seems like the best, most romantic options for me, but now I understand the *why*. My head is also now filled with the twilight trio as a poly throuple so thanks for that (might have a look on ao3 later lol)

Vivek Patel

Probably not; this video has seemingly eaten half of the notes for it. But I think it's an honorary hunger part 2, and male gaze tangent part 2

Abigail

I am really loving watching the red candles burn while smart pretty lady talks about Twilight for the runtime of at least one Lord of the Rings film

Vivek Patel

If the male gaze tangent is the hobbit, then this video is LOTR Or maybe it's The Male Gaze (Deluxe expanded edition) (Natalie's Version)

Riley

Before and during sex, I'm mostly worried that I might shit myself if I bottom. Not as worried about losing my identity. But something to consider! Thanks for another thought-provoking video.

Vivek Patel

'have her Edward and eat her Jacob too' ABSOLUTELY CACKLING

Beth S

Fascinating as always. I'm deeply curious about other people's personal takes on the "cuck tent" fantasy, because I think it might be a common one? I was thinking on how I've indulged in similar fantasy myself ("it is the apocalypse... guess we have to cuddle to survive...") I think Natalie is spot-on with the analysis that the silly, contrived artifice of these scenarios is necessary for the fantasy, because it removes the realistic elements that act as barriers in real life, which often involve agency. The unrealistic ludicrousness is not a problem, it's a requirement. But I do think the particulars of what those barriers are & why as analyzed in the video are specific to the emotional needs of Stephanie Meyer/fans of Twilight who relate. Avoiding the shame of asking for intimacy was never a part of my own cuck tent fantasy. Instead, I would have gladly asked, but in my case I didn't find it plausible that a man would say yes. The Twilight version of the fantasy removes the agency of the woman/subject, but my version removes the agency of the man/object. And some versions surely remove the agency of both (think of the popular sworn-enemies-become-ships fanfiction.) Talking with a friend, he said his version of the fantasy is that removing the necessity to ask also removes the risk of the pain of rejection, and I also realized that this safety from pain overlaps with both my formulation of the fantasy and Meyer's. Mine stems from my own insecurity about being undesirable and unwanted, while perhaps Meyer's stems from her insecurity about being the "bad girl" and the shame of wanting intimacy as Natalie argued. Her Mormon upbringing seems relevant here compared to my thoroughly nonreligious, liberal one, where I wasn't exposed to those same sexual judgments. And conversely, her likely "typical" body maturation and development are different than mine, where I have mental illnesses affect my appearance (BFRB) in ways to make me "not conventionally attractive" and have never felt or been treated like an object of desire to men in my real life. As a third example, it occurs to me that it might also apply to, say, a closeted person where the contrivances of the scenario remove the need to make a same-sex advance. The need for that could likewise be to remove the risk of rejection, or of social stigma & shame, but not necessarily. It could be removing the necessity of changing your conception of your "identity." It doesn't count as being gay since outside forces caused it to happen etc. But that one showcases that such fantasy is not necessarily healthy -  I mean very few things are necessarily anything. But it does make an interesting return to the critics who say it can reinforce negative internalized beliefs, and how they have a reasonable point too. Anyway I guess I just find it fascinating that thinking about this through the lens Natalie presented, the idea of "frivolous fantasy" does actually demonstrate the depths of people's complex humanity rather than their vapidity. If anyone has written "Draco and Hermione are forced to spend the night in the Forbidden Forest" fanfiction, maybe they can shed light on what insecurity is being assuaged there, lol. My friend suggested that it might be to overcome the feeling that you suck as a person caused by people being mean to you (Dracos), since their loving behavior toward you in the cuck tent shows that their meanness is circumstantial, not a result of your innate suckiness. But neither of us have this fantasy so we're not sure. And I'm also curious if there any other versions of the fantasy where "agency" isn't the important barrier that is being removed by the powers of the narrative circumstance. 

viruviruviru

contra, gorge, listen to me.... love love LOVE you work, super duper respect your process, but if you leave us for multiple months again I WILL go insane

Nikee Star

I think this is a very good video overall. However the part about yin and yang is probably useful to someone who is Cisgender and trying to understand gender complexity for the first time. But ultimately that's too simple a analogy since it only contains two elements. As someone who has lives outside of the binary, I perceive that gender isn't a one dimensional spectrum...but a multi-dimensional space. Most Non-Binary folks would tend to agree with that. Most of us do support you Natalie. Keep doing what you do!

Commendable Freeloader

The Kiwi in me would have YIPPED if you used Perse from Lore Olympus but instead I YOPPED at the John Waters refs. 🥹 my humble beg that you are in his new film

Andrew May

Holy crackers, Natalie! the first half walloped me yesterday, had to pause midway and sleep on all that. Second half today! This is a massive project and it is so so thoughtful, funny, and engaging. Twilight was always this spectacle happening on my periphery. I knew a tiny bit of the discourse. My wife is way into fanfic and the many, many, many genres of romance. This has been really fun for us to watch together and talk about. She keeps saying, “I hope she’s gonna talk about vampires” and “I hope she does an analysis of Buffy!”. Still crossing our fingers. Congratulations on another triumph! I know this was a massive project for you. I hope you can feel some relief and rest a bit. Thank you!

Darren DM

I think it is crazy good. As with much of your work, I genuinely feel cleverer for watching it. At least for a while anyway. Thank you!

Many Lesions

Amazing. I love how each video builds upon the previous vids. I feel like theres some epic masterwork in the future that you are paying the groundwork for.

Grady Wiehe

Love it. Honestly I’m dying for your Saltburn hot takes. Since I first saw it I’ve thought “A very Contrapoints film if there ever was one.” Opulence, envy, degeneracy, and let us not forget…the mouthfeel

Vic

Awesome video. I wish there was a related books list for further reading on this and related topics. Bataille, Bader etc all sound like authors I’d love

Julia

Recently read Sexed Up by Julia Serano, which is all about the predator-prey cultural sexual script. This video seems a bit like Natalie did too, but then went „maybe predator-prey is just kinda human and like fine-ish“. I really like Sexed Up and obviously the various problems resulting from predator-prey need to be controlled, but I also think that to some degree my own sexuality is just inherently predator-prey shaped or similar and it's more productive to just accept that, than to worry that I'm a bad feminist or something.

Abigail

If you guys liked this video, definitely read The Locked Tomb series. "One Flesh One End..."

Ruth Sangree

Natalie....this was outstanding also, as someone who has loved all the tangents in 2023 it was so fascinating see the threads tie together, especially with "the male gaze" and "liminal spaces" videos. nothing repetitive, but it absolutely rhymed and I got so much more out of it. thank you! and congrats on being done with this beast.

Seán

Honestly, this is the best thing you've ever made and shared, and it feels like such a culmination of everything I've seen from you thus far. There's so much to take from this, so many directions to explore (grief is erotic desire for a possibility lost, for example, intersecting readings from death doula work with this). DHSM in particular describes some of the single most painful parts of not fitting into these categories and losing friends and loves in my life when ultimately I didn't consolidate into this system. More and more, what you discuss resonates in ways I can grow. Also, absolutely getting the book quoting Sappho translations. Seriously, profound thanks for everything you have and keep doing. You are a safe and trustworthy nexus to so many concepts that help me and others find our place and how to see more in our worlds.

Colton Royle

I'm so glad I read "Eros, the Bittersweet" on your recommendation. Thanks for your hard work! My partner and I loved watching this.

Aristana Scourtas

Playing Debussy at the end fucking killed me, thanks for always combining sophistication with silly lil jokes, it makes me happy

nat

I seriously think this might be your best work ever. I know I’m going to sound silly saying this but I genuinely feel like your mind is so gifted 😭 the way you synthesize all of your theories and thoughts and weave them together into something engaging, extremely informative, coherent, and hilarious is beyond me. I feel like you’re having discussions about things that I’ve always thought about but have never heard anyone truly speak to altogether at once (this goes for your other videos as well!!) and it’s just such a pleasure to be able to watch it…it’s late and I’m not making sense but congratulations on finishing this video and thank you!!!!

Lauren Ivory

thank you for your work!! Your insight really does make a meaningful difference to how I see the world.

Rose

Q&A stream to talk about the video?

Laura Lin

The conclusion on Yin and Yang is really wonderful gender metaphysics. Imo, it’s the answer to the question from The Hunger (Part 1), “What makes gender desire different from other desires for drugs or God?” It’s not a yearning or a craving, borne out of lack, but something already present, “within,” waiting to express itself. It’s not desperate, but euphoric — not chasing a lover, but being at peace in the company of a long-time friend.

BaSe

Awesome! 3h, and never get’s uninteresting. Team duality 😁

Patryk Zep

Video viewed. I am not able to put together any question or conclusion yet because it was an overload of information, so I will be coming back to it many times. But one thing I do know for sure: the way you choose your sources, play with the threads, know when to tie in a topic raised in tangents, even have a great feel for the amount of repetitions - never too much, never just for word count, never for lack of arguments or solely for aesthetics. It screams flexibility and awareness of what you're doing it for, every word has a purpose. And that's probably the main reason why you are number one on beauty youtube for many. Love your mind 🧛🏻‍♂️

Eddie

Fantastic work as always❤️

CrystalJade

Wow! I’m feeling so overwhelmed right now. These concepts are just so fundamental. It feels like my gaze has been directed towards themes we don’t notice we all orbit around (albeit with differing degrees of eccentricity). All accessed through a deconstruction of Twilight. Such a lot to take in. Beautiful yet also quite daunting. So much detail and texture that feels so familiar, yet also difficult to place in the everyday. I’m left with so many contrasting emotions and questions. Like why do I feel these themes are reduced or disavowed in everyday life. They don’t seem to be collectivised very well at all I guess. Well worth the wait Natalie. I’m going to have to rewatch again and again!

Darren DM

I found your reference to Daoism compelling. There's a youtuber called Hans-Georg Moeller who has the channel Carefree Wandering. He co-wrote a book on identity called Genuine Pretending which explores, within a Daoist framework, the paradoxes inherent in identity.

marco

It is gorgeous. This and your video (feels weird to call your essays just "videos") on Envy are the best things on YouTube. When watching your essays, I feel like I should have studied philosophy, it makes me want to TEACH philosophy! XD (also then I could just show my students your videos when I don't want to talk much) ;) It was well worth the wait. Keep up the great work.

Ann C

I already commented on the video on Twitter. Still, I wanted to add that I loved the brief harpsichord and piano performances and particularly enjoyed the music that played over the end credits.

Philip Carter

Natalie, you have raised a series of issues so sensitive and important and achieve it with such a degree of dignity and self awareness! I am in awe. I adore your musical analogue with the trilling on the dominant chord to express desire. I’m a musician and I think deeply about love and music, often. For one thing, Natalie, your ‘epicycles of yearning’ makes me think of the circle of fifths. BIG YEARNING is my violin playing in G major (its favorite key for its parameters of resonance) and every other key, every other scale I play in, forms it’s logic of anticipation and relief with reference to what happens in the resonance of that original key. When I look at the unfoldment of the overtone series and look at the scale patterns of western music, this makes good sense as well. The ‘tonic’ chord is closest to the heart of the vibrating string (its ‘home’ note), and the notes for the dominant chord show up in the series soon thereafter. And around the circle we go, recreating these patterns of desire from every conceivable reference point. I think it may be silly, but this damn circle just defines a center point that nature would have us always try to return to equilibrium with. Like a vibrating violin string trying to get back to stillness again. Like developing in utero and experiencing the shift into outer experience as an original experience or ‘disunity’ that needs correction. Union w mother (‘mother’ a mercurial stand in for any face or life form we entrain with and mirror) is the tonic chord and our separation is, most archetypically, the dominant chord with its trembling melody. Something that I do think, though, from this musical perspective, is that the concepts of desire and relief (or the yin yang of love itself) represent the oscillating character of vibration itself. To look closely at it is to freeze time itself. It’s like looking at an algebra equation. The ‘void’ of yearning is 0. Everything dynamic on both sides of the equation express 0. We play music, we dance with it, we entrain with it, and create these same patterns in the macro, and the music doesn’t have to stop. I think that even in death our identity must merge into grander rhythms of the cosmos and perhaps our consciousness takes on a different temporal perspective on this world of forms. Anyway I talk abt this stuff a lot on my podcast Taropedia. Check it out! I think that the sublimation of desire is the name of the game in the 21st century. Woof! So many thoughts. So much love for you, Natalie!

Dana Migdal

You made some incredibly good points about the female fantasy driving this story, but I think in some ways - and you did discuss this in the larger sense, of course - Twilight was also kind of a Conduct Novel for me as a 12-year-old tween. It taught me how I should act and react around a man very capable of (and possibly interested in) literally killing me. I recently watched this clip with a male podcaster saying he can't be attracted to a woman if he doesn't feel like he could kill her with his bare hands, and a lot of the comments were from women saying they also couldn't be attracted to a man who couldn't kill them, in the sense that they're only attracted to men much larger than they are. It's such a constant threat of heterosexual relationships, just knowing he could kill you at any minute when he feels like it - this sadly literally happened to a friend of mine's sister, whose 21 year-old-boyfriend (allegedly - the trial's still in progress) choked her to death. And this doesn't even require the insertion of vampires into the situation, a regular man can kill you with just a bit of effort. This horror is such a real option for women who date men, and I feel like so much of our media at an early age fills a kind of Beauty and the Beast functionality ,of preparing us for these complex power dynamics and trying to train us into being sweet, enthusiastic and irrationally trusting - otherwise many of us would be too terrified to ever go out there.

Dawn Dreams Circus

OMG 3 hours! Natilie! Alright. I am going in everyone. Wish me luck.

RmhWork.

why Edward has a Volvo?

Miriam L

Great work as always! Woah I loved this. So so so interesting and well explained. I kept pausing and thinking out loud YES THIS IS SO RIGHT. I was so happy when I saw it is three hours hahaha thanks Natalie!

Kat

I would recommend CJ the X's interpretation of imprinting for consideration too. They give a very plausible rationale before tearing it away, it's quite fun if you enjoy their frenetic style. The whole video is gloriously horny too; "do that to me" still resonates in my head anytime I see anything even a little bit hot.

Kat

Fantastic video, love it, love the going back and forth arguing the entire dialectic in good faith. The only thing I am incandescent with rage about is justifying goddamn Pamela. Especially being dismissive of my girl Eliza Haywood, who wrote my absolute favourite 18th c. romance novel: Fantomina. Like, even if Pamela is telling the truth about her sexual virtue, which, that constant device of fainting as holding off Squire B - what he's okay to r~pe her, but r~ping her while unconscious is too far? - she's still lying about being virtuous because where is she getting all the paper, ink, and candles to write her novel length letters home? Pamela is a thief. Where Fantomina takes agency of her ravishment, seducing her seducer multiple times in multiple costumes until finally getting bored with a man who can't recognize the woman he's been f~cking for months when she does her hair differently. Eliza Haywood wanted a fantasy where she could do what she wanted, Richardson wanted a fantasy where virtue would get rewarded, and I would argue that where Richardson's legacy gives us the "erotica" of Fifty Shades, Haywood's legacy gives us L'Histoire d'O and Venus in Furs. The biggest problem with Fifty Shades, the root of the dubious consent, the poor presentation of fantasy as fantasy and not actual aspiration, is that the author doesn't even seem to like sex, much like Richardson. But O presents dubious consent (does O actually consent to her death at the end? Can she really consent to her death if her master ordered her to consent to it?) as pure fantasy, and while it's not something you'd want in your real life it is sexy because Pauline Réage seems to genuinely find the situations she's writing about erotic. As a side note I love the argument that Pauline Réage must have been a woman because of her intimate knowledge of women's clothing. It's true that some of the most tactile moments in the novel are the feel of the various types of clothing, the crisp, starched linens, slipping on a pair of mules. If Pauline Réage was a man he was definitely a man who wore women's clothing. But to return to the point, if I can be said to have one, I think there is a perfectly valid critique of both Pamela and Fifty Shades in that they are presented as terrible behaviour that the reader is prescribed to follow for ultimate happiness, the most extreme and popular examples of their time of terrible "I can fix him" mentality where Fantomina and O, while more extreme, are forays into pure fantasy and fit your premise of how we should read fiction better.

Kat

Also, we should read more Aphra Behn. That woman wrote some great revenge stories. Check out History of the Nun.

Kate Kater

A milli! A milli! A milli! And it was very enjoyable too. Welcome back!

Clara

thank you natalie for your hard work 🥹🥹🥹🫶🫶 you can allow yourself to take more than a week of rest top/bottom content could be a tangent vid content ! i’m really curious about your take on sex and power dynamics

william simmons

Crap I didn't get the notice until after 11pm, I needed sooooo much caffeine at work. Old age sucks.

Ben Anthes

Give her a bloody PhD for this, will you, psychologists? Please?

Alex Higgins

I’m at Pelagius and Saint Augustine and my verdict is ‘crazy good’

Ads

I'm sure I'm not alone in thinking it would be super exciting to get a video on your turn towards the psychoanalytic.

Martyś

Fantastic video! Hope you get some good rest 💖💖

a. j. archer

me in 2006: wow, bella is stupid. as an empowered young feminist, i would never get so upset over a smelly boy me in 2024, having experienced the agonies of Lesbian Divorce: 👁👄👁

Ethan Good

A sublime addition to your videography. Please enjoy your much deserved time off. I will rewatch many times and return here when I have something intelligent to say.

Ethan Good

Well Saltburn just got bumped up my watchlist by a few slots!

Tyla Stark

I was quite hungry for The Hunger part two, one might say I was yearning for it lmao. So I'm glad to see it used for this. Lovely work as always. Fire outfits too. Those gold contacts were dope.

Zany Fennec

It's a wonderful video! I'm one of the fans of yours who leans more on the sex negative radical feminist side, and I felt like the criticism of the way fantasy is treated by radfem theory was very poignant and accurate. I do find that upon a superficial examination the latter part leaned somewhat too strongly into an essentialist reading of femininity and masculinity, but I wonder if that was really intentional or there's something more to it. You've treated the topics brilliantly as always, and usually I find myself being able to sign off on every word (inc. the male gaze tangent), but this one is peculiar because it feels like I should be disagreeing with you, but at the same time I'm not? Psychoanalysis is dense as a subject, and you find people ranging from Irigaray to Lacan to Juliet Mitchell within it, and it's certainly very interesting to explore. I'm happy you gave radical feminism a fair overview (although not spotlessly so -- I feel like MacKinnon and Dworkin are certainly more agreeable and defensible than Sheila Jeffreys), and it was as well-researched and stimulating as ever. I'm going to be rewatching this one a lot <3

Nicole Song

How sweet it is just wanting

Lauren Alyson

Absolutely loved this and will definitely re-watch!!! I too was yearning for The Hunger Part 2 and this was glorious. Thank you ❤️

Iceskatin

Thank you Natalie for this video. The subjects in this video are some of the ones I couldn't wait for you to tackle and I'm not disappointed. It's feeding my braincells. Would be amazing to have a ContraPlays video of you playing the full Clair de Lune !

Sharna

loved it

Patricia GC

not lying this video was so good that I decided to finally join patreon, it feels like you presented ideas about myself that I thought only I was having not to mention debunked fallacies that are deep in societies psyche. Thank you for being so thoughtful in your research and analysis, your original ideas are so insightful that I think decades from now we are going to consider you side by side with all this theorist you are quoting. Thank you for doing what you do.

frogsmore

Natalie, here is yet more evidence why I was mortified by you apologizing for not hitting some self-imposed deadline. Your content is sooo dense with insight I am breathless, always, tying to keep up. I often spend hours, days, weeks, thinking about what you say in minutes (now I sound like Star Trek II lol)

frogsmore

"The good old days are good and gone now That's why they are good,because they are gone But our conversation turns the cow tow We kiss the pasts ass all night long." Old Friend, Loudon Wainwright III

catmuffin

As a dirty European, let me tell you what’s going on over here in Pervoslavia: We yearn for the profane, uncut, titties-and-dickies-on-display version of this MASTERPIECE. Ugh, fuck YouTube and stupid family-friendly censoring. You’ve truly outdone yourself with this video essay. Thank you so much on continuing to demystify the human condition: You’ve helped me more than any therapist I ever had in understanding myself! I hope you are doing well and I hope you feel proud of what you’ve done. As a fellow perfectionist - I know that’s hard, but your work is truly incredible and helps so many people understand wtf is life. Thank you 💜

Turki

Hello Natalie, I was wondering if you can provide Arabic caption for your videos? I understand English but some of the English words in this video is difficult to translate. Thanks.

Elesge

I cannot believe I've been edged for three hours because I thought Tristan und Isolde's opening would be addressed

Kristian Gendron

Natalie do you like Chopin’s Nocturne in e flat maj, op 9 no 2? Or are my erotic tastes very basic and vanilla.

Kevin Hengehold

When is Sheila Jefferys joining Adam Corolla and Dennis Prager on the "Trigger Warning" tour?

Guilherme Tamaki

There is a Manga called BeastStars in which the protagonist is a wolf who is in love with a bunny but the power dynamic is switched, and there is a reccurent theme about predation/meat eating literally and metaphorically. Thank you for the great video Natalie, wish you the best.

MXTXC

Oooh, this video made me very happy. The music is fantastic... and the bloody pearl necklace! Nom nom nom.

Alien6981

Great video. Can't really condense all my thoughts in a comment of reasonable length, and even if I could my thoughts are still scattered, but once again it's very helpful, useful work. Thank you. One thing: I understand the argument that the fantasy of these romantic novels is aspirational, for the oppressed and a disenfranchised party to get power by joining a more, perhaps inherently powerful party, but isn't an important aspect of the fantasy also that the love of the weaker party redeems and transforms the aggressive nature of power itself, at least as it's embodied by the powerful object of affection? This change happens not just in how the stronger lover treats the weaker one, but also how the stronger person behaves with others outside of the relationship, in their community and potentially in society, either by sharing their privilege or at least admitting to the pride and prejudice of power (I think both Elizabeth and Darcy are "guilty" of both, which is possibly the point)? Isn't there at least in the most successful fantasies a desire for the domineering power to become if not meeker at least "tolerant" of the less powerful in general? If so, how would that fit into the theories of will to power and the morality of resentment? Is topping from the bottom a morality of resentment, or is there another morality at play, maybe a fantasy of transcending the "base" aggressive nature of power into a potency born from love? And is that even possible? Of course I don't expect actual answers from you or anyone here, I'm expressing the thoughts your work inspired, but replies are obviously welcome. My pronouns are cis/male btw, so I am always suspect of my own perspective of things. Also, thank you for making this video, because I could never get my cis/female wife to watch these movies with me. There's a camp pleasure to them, but they are also a solid romance saga, and even if she won't watch them, at least now I can say they have the ContraPoints seal of approval.

Erin Kraus

Thanks for all you do.. really enjoyed the video

Erin Kraus

Yes, exactly… she’s absolutely special

christof

i regret to inform you that emily dickinson and taylor swift are sixth cousins, three times removed

eon

Thanks for the video, enjoyed it a lot. Watched it in one go and finished 3 in the morning.

satb90

There is something about the video that really parallels themes from "Irreversible" by Gaspar Noe. Particularly the exchange between characters that stresses the importance of "sexual selfishness" as an integral part of a fulfilling sexual experience for both partners. Monica Belucci's character explains to a friend that part of the reason why sex with him might actually be tedious is precisely because he's singularly obsessed with the pleasure of his partner and never takes time to consider himself. He therefore robs the said partner of any pleasure she might derive from having sex with him precisely because she feels the pressure and desperation emanating from him. Ultimately this pressure stops her from truly surrendering to the experience and actually enjoying it. Subsequently this is perverted by the rape scene that occurs in the movie which acts an immoral, abhorrent variation of this idea being taken to an extreme. Amazing video, really enjoyed the analysis.

Holly

Finished watching this, and just wanted to say I audibly gasped on a call watching it together at the line of "femininity and masculinity belong to all humankind". I feel like I've just unlocked a little nugget of freedom, so thank you for that. <3

peter annear

OMG Natalie!!! No wonder this took so long. How on earth you turned a discourse on Twilight into The Theory of Everything as it pertains to Sexuality and Gender, This is why I am totally calm to contribute to this Patreon to see one film every year or so. This crystalised so much in such an entertaining and poetic way. I've watched this end to end 3 times and taken notes. I will watch many more times. This is superb work. Thankyou.

Amanda Halbrock

I watched most of this high (weed) so I'll have to rewatch this for sure. But with how much the topic feels like it's up my alley I really wanted to love it on my first watch but I got more out of some sections then others. I liked the general twilight analysis. The stuff on romance was interesting to me and made me think of some friends of mine. With the stuff on sexuality I really wish there had been some writing by leatherqueers in there as well. To me it feels like it's missing that perspective on power, sex and gender.

Temerity Lore

Wow there is a LOT going on here...So I'm just going to leave this link here...in addition to my undying admiration! (if the link is un-clickable because I'm tech illiterate lulz...the song is Nightcore-Bad Apple metal version. I believe the video really compliments the duality expressed through this entire presentation) https://youtu.be/mGHkK5aVfMM?si=AN-oOgsobtR_GHi-

castor

i thought this was brilliant from start to finish <3

Chiara

I have been ranting to friends for ages about my frustration with even queer people so frequently conflating the top/bottom, dom/sub dynamics, among others. Plus I also had a recent Twilight binge (which may have involved writing some of my own smutty fanfic) that left me reflecting a lot about how society's perceptions of sexuality are reflected in Twilight. So overall I parasocially appreciate you making this video for me specifically. Well worth the wait.

Nel Meyrink

This is your best work, Natalie. It's fucking phenomenal.

Julschi

As a fellow Twilight-stan I seriously love this video. And as a person I appreciate the criticism of DHSM the most. Oh, and the music is just so good. Thank you! 🙏💕

Nikee Star

Firstly there's no need to be rude. I'm not personally attacking you or Natalie. Not everything she says is automatically gospel truth because she said it. She'd be the first to admit she doesn't get everything right. Just because Natalie's explanation of gender fits your own personal conception, it doesn't mean that it's accurate for everyone.

highclass_lady

As someone else mentioned, I would love to see a full video of you playing Clair de Lune! 🎹

Electro_Static

I’ve never felt more abnormal for having a vanilla sex life that consists of two people who love each other doing nice things for each other in bed on a consistent basis.

Matteo Manino

Finished the first rewatch, Mommy's milk is sooooo good. I'm shaking, again; you are phenomenal. Thank you so, so much.

luv2riri

Crazy that this works so well as a three hour sit down watch but also every sentence can (should) be standing and studied on its own (your cuck tent is racist)

Ruthie Kelly 📚

I would like to also add that there is something about this video compared to some of the more recent ones that had this tint of sadness and despair that made me want to hug you when they posted. Twilight and sparklepires as a jumping off point to the theory of everything of gender and romance and love…you seem so delighted and it’s infectious. You seem so much happier and more joyful, and that fills ME with joy to see you doing so well. Love that for you and many happy returns!!!

vctls

« Twilight » yeah, right 💖 I have to say, I felt really stupid hearing some of these ideas. About fantasy in particular. Now I'm wondering if it's because I was afraid to think too much about the subject, fearing that I wouldn't like the conclusions. I'm still not sure if these interpretations are closer from some truth or if I just want them to be, but in any case they're very refreshing. Also, I had a few good laughs. Thank you. I was just a bit frustrated by the Taoist bit at the end. Not sure where to talk about this so I'll just leave it here. There's something that bothers me with this symbolism. Although it accounts for interconnection and fluctuation of opposite or complementary concepts, it still draws clear lines between them. Might not sound as sexy (if not wildly irrelevant), but I found more intellectual satisfaction when approaching these concepts through linguistics with stuff like prototype theory.

Gabriella

I have to pause literally every ten seconds to process how smart and funny everything you just said is. All hits no misses she does it again folks

Gabriella

"A fantasy is a fictional scenario in which you are in control" THISSSS

Stef

This was absolutely incredible Natalie. Truly fantastic fucking work honestly it's beyond impressive that your every work surpasses the previous. I'm going to need like a year to process all of your points.God tier galaxy brain work, now please get some rest!

Gabriella

If you ever published your essays as a book I'd buy it right away

Hanna Lisowska

These are always worth the wait. Fantastic work

DontTouchMe

Love this video essay, as usual! Thank you for the time and care you and your team(?) take putting these together. Long form content for the win! As a former Twilight lover turned Twilight hater I enjoyed hearing your insights.

Sara

Natalie needs to release this as a book.

Elizabeth

But what will she be cradling in her hands on the cover?

Sara

🤔 A fruit tart?

georgia harding

Little brown (the publisher) produced twilight AND infinite jest

JoyOfResistance

I love the art, the humor and Contrapoints in general. But as a non-prudish European and a fervent reader of (European) historical erotica, I'm afraid I must disagree with so many points made in this video. (Really, come to Europe, there's a long tradition of sex that has nothing to do with power or violence or the black hole! :D )

JoyOfResistance

And it pains me that the quote of my boy Leopold von Sacher-Masoch is unfinished and out of context, he explicitly talks about equality in sex and the need for women's rights in that bit (and ends his whole book on that thought, boom!)

Lissi

Crazy good! And even longer than dune2 🙆

Gabriella

I love how with these videos it feels like you are really able to peel back layers of abstraction and get to the core truths. The idea that "sexuality is not a pure innocent thing that has simply been corrupted by society" - this is so profound, I absolutely love this analysis. It is so much easier to apply the "there are social hierarchies" framework to explain everything but it's not a satisfying explanation. Your mind is amazing!

Tom Martell

Considering “I watched a 3 hour long video about Twilight” is a statement I would have sworn I could never make up until the moment the video came out…. I’d say “crazy good”

Ryan Relativity

is that not why she spoke of eroticism as inherently perverted? these things exist innately within the act, try as you might to create truly egalitarian erotica, it won't be as interesting as twilight

mouse

LOVEE this video!!! I've been thinking about it for days now. and I gotta say, it was the perfect perfect thing to watch before seeing Lisa Frankenstein lol. thank you for your art!!

mouse

LOVEE this video!! I've been thinking about all of it for days! also, a perfect perfect video to watch before seeing Lisa Frankenstein lol so excellent. thank you for your art!!

Corinne Stein

When I watched your recent-ish tangent on the Male Gaze I was left with the thought "damn, this is an incredible line of thought, I wish she would consider making this a main channel video." I literally jumped up from my desk to go explain certain bits to my roommate (also a fan of yours) as they hit, because the insights were kinda blowing my mind. Especially the one about the female equivalent to the "male gaze" not existing, or rather being a combination of female and male perspective. This video was all of that and more, maybe my favorite thing you've ever made in that it's extremely relevant to my interests. I'm 28 and came up in internet fan-spaces from Lj and DA to tumblr and have always been super fascinated by the politics of sexual expression through fiction, esp. as someone who has a hard time making sense of my feelings around relationships and "love" in real life and for whom fiction has been essential at forming an understanding of those- for these same reasons i've long been fascinated with the concepts of love/limerence. The 3 hours i spent watching this were some of the most riveting of my life. Discussions around these topics have become more and more frustratingly restricted and people in some fan-spaces more and more intolerant of them in just the past 5 or so years in ways that I find alarmingly incurious, and I find the way you approached them here to be thoughtful, fascinating and refreshing. On a much more basic level, the line "this is a fujoshi safe space" did make me hoot. I appreciate your sense of humor immensely.

Blaire Frei

I don't have any carefully thought out response to this video. Just wanted to say that it was thought-provoking, expertly crafted, and concluded on a beautiful note. It's also about the sharpest your humor has been yet. I love how it weaves so many of the last few Tangents into a philosophical theory both simple and all-encompassing. Can't wait for the AMA <3

Jenny Rodriguez

I loved the video, truly in awe of your ability for connecting seemingly random topics together, however, I must disagree about your views regarding long term relationships, I get you used it as a segue, but it's quite narrow to dicern that there's only conformity or re infatuation in long term relationships, hopefully you'll review this topic in depth in your 40s and see it's all a matter of perspective, I found the Death segment slightly contrived with all those bible quotes, but I definitely loved your analysis.

Madsey H

Thank you Natalie. This video was spectacular watch that enriched the three days I took to watch and absorb it. I can't imagine how rich your inner world is, if it produces thought and art on this level. Thank you so much for sharing with us x

The Existential Shrew

This was absolutely brilliant. Have you seen the opulent version of "Cellophane" by FKA Twigs? (Live at the Wallace Collection on YouTube.) I thought of you immediately when I saw it. Anyway, I found out recently that the song is about Robert Pattinson and his bat shit insane fangirls. That was a rabbit hole boy howdy. Ilysm ❤️❤️❤️

Andrea

Congratulations on this accomplishment! It ties together so many of the themes from your videos from the past into a grand unified theory of gender and sexuality. I think what I appreciate most is how satisfying the conclusion is at the end which I won't attempt to restate, but it made me feel a calmness and a peace about myself and the world in way that I have not felt often before. Thank you!

PurpleTurtle

Living for those red beads. Seriously though this is a work of art. Peering right into the heart of humanity and making it look easy. 😲

JoyOfResistance

But that's the great thing about BDSM; in the end it IS equal, because you play the roles, you don't live them (because then you end up as Leopold von Sacher-Masoch says, in a world where we are doomed to be unhappy as the anvil and the hammer and he doesn't believe it's healthy for anyone). That's also one of the things that I love about kink (and that I disagree with in this video); yes, for some people it's a way to deal with shame. But as a dominatrix I find that more often than not, it is a form of storytelling. And that's what makes it sexy, the story you choose to tell. (And it can be about power or pain or whatever, but it DOESN'T have to be and so often, even during play, you return to this point of equality. It's play, not power, that is sexy).

Erk

Commented earlier about how this reminds me of my friend, commenting now after some very strong emotions making the first half hard to get through to say this is *phenomenal*. Natalie, thanks. I hope you're not mixed on your feelings anymore, this is such an excellent and inspiring essay. Gonna watch it a lot of times.

polyval

When I saw your video I jokingly said to my friends, before watching it, that it would be roughly the same as my PhD dissertation project on end-of-19th-century french literature and sexuality & gender, only better. Having now watched the video, I can 100% say your video is a way better dissertation than the one I planned to do ; but also that it gave me insights I never thought of, so well... thank you for this <3 this is truly interesting to see lots of texts that I have read and your interpretation of them !!!!

Amber Bennett-Groves

Thinking of characters like Edward Rochester and Maxim de Winter as representations of my animus is really very useful advice. Previously I just thought of the difference in my taste between fictional men and men irl as being like the difference in houses that make for good home improvement shows compared to a house you'd actually want to live in. (If they can't directly affect your life then they just need to be interesting to be attractive, and it's more interesting when they're kind of broken or dangerous.)

Torval Pecker

I couldn't help but think of your new video Natalie while watching the new movie "Poor Things". The similarities between it and Twilight and bold and undeniable lmao. Would love to hear your thoughts on the movie ☺️

Ojaswi Sharma

I think "Sherlock" (the BBC series with Cumberbatch) makes obvious the certain homoeroticism between Sherlock and Watson but also explores this desire for chaos that's erotic. I think it is a subversive example of male desire, per your definition.

Beth Jerky

im not even finished but i think this is my favorite. upset you didn't bring up our uncle Barthe's essay on the strip tease. love you

Rose

Thank you so much for your work! It was really enlightening and fun, as always :) and here comes another long comment: The paucity of love stories centred around a heterosexual relationship... How repetitive! How boring! But it suits the commodification of culture because it's standardisable and above all predictable. What bothers me most about all this is that all the space and attention given to THE relationship of the central lovers doesn't allow us to envisage and subsequently desire other types of relationship that take us out of this circle towards destruction. Basically, for me, feminists haven't gone far enough with the male gaze, what obstructs us in our evolution is beyond the gaze, it's the average male drama (that also gave birth to many subsequent female drama such as Twilight ). The fact that we end up wallowing in the self-fulfilling prophecy dictated by certain men. What else is there? Have you ever seen Rivette's Céline and Julie go Boating? Have you seen Woolf's Orlando? And more recently, Borleteau's A mon seul désir? Let's look for new narratives that lift us up and get us out of the vampiric grip of repetition.

OldGuardBard

It took me watching this twice to realize that Bella can be thought of as the """for women""" version of Kirito from Sword Art Online

Prosinco

long time follower, first time patreon hi! i would say “amazing as always, Natalie”, but i feel like this might be one of your best works yet, or at least a clear, eloquent, and systematised culmination of the concepts you have been exploring in previous videos. so i wanted you to know that i see what you did, and think you did an incredible job! over the past year or so i have been reading a lot of books and watching essays on topics you touched upon here: Bataille, the myth of Aristophanes, the Death Drive, Paglia, the similarities between the spiritual and the erotic in mystics such as St. Theresa (btw if you haven’t already I highly recommend Revolutionary Demonology, which touches on this in a way i find positively divine), etc… one unexpected benefit of these long pauses is that i learn so much over a year, and hearing you cover so many topics i encountered between releases makes it feel so much more poignant and satisfying, in addition to it being so well researched and of high quality. i know ytubers are under a lot of pressure to release videos frequently, so i wanted to share this appreciation to counter that a little bit. a few notes on the content itself: on the matter of non-consent, i see two additional possible reasons why noncon is a popular fantasy: 1. i find that imagination works a bit like a circuit in that nothing is gradual. if you try to imagine going from point A to point B, you have already reached point B. so in order to stall resolution, imagination NEEDS obstacles. non-consent becomes a kind of “logic obstacle”, where the opposition of intents has to take place first, allowing sexual buildup before the obstacle is resolved in the climax. this may be why so many noncon fantasies actually have the victim later be willing. 2. in an indirect way, it may stem from a desire to have MORE consent. in intimacy we often desire to be understood wordlessly. we wish to be understood on a level so profound that communication becomes unnecessary. in other words: we wish to be a single mind and a single organism. but this is impossible. one thing that comes close to that ideal is the homoerotic relationship between the gangster boss and his goon: he doesn’t have to ask, he can make his desire clear with even the subtlest of gestures. oh, to be so well understood! naturally the next level is when both parties can PRETEND not to want something while being perfectly aware of each other’s desires. what greater proof of trust than when one says “no” and the other understands it means “yes”? lastly, i noticed that the part talking about the potential dangers of fantasy felt somewhat bare-bones compared to the rest. i was curious if you intentionally left it ambiguous to let the audience form their own opinion, or if you yourself don’t really have a definitive answer as to where one should draw a line? or do you think this is something for a future video? sorry if this comes off as overly verbose, im a little stonedbut thank you so much for all you do💖 EDIT: i forgot to say happy woman's day!

Marvelous_Smokey

This video showed up on my YT recs just as I was having a very hard and emotional time with a loved one. Thank you so much Natalie, this was interesting, aesthetically pleasing as well as a very comforting watch of a video essay essentially taking my teenage self's hyper fixation seriously and dissecting why it worked. Totally worth the wait.

Amanda Qualls

I have been methodically making my way through this video, trying to take it all in, and it made me wonder: have you ever thought of doing limited print runs of your scripts? I would love to be able to read and annotate and maybe even ruminate on your words.

Drew Anderson

This video is really fantastic. It's been great to see how some of the lines of thoughts from the tangents get developed into more "official" form in the longer videos. On that note, I am really glad to see you go up to bat for psychoanalysis, especially regarding its utility in thinking about gender, sex, and identity. I'm a PhD student in philosophy and am working to specialize in psychoanalysis, and it is always difficult to teach Freud to students for the first time because of years of ingrained skepticism they've picked up from the internet and high school psych courses; but having someone as influential as you show firsthand how important and useful it is for articulating these perspectives is huge, not to mention that your analysis here is really interesting in its own right. I particularly liked your use of Spielrein! Definitely didn't expect to see her name come up in this video. I also wanted to add that some of arguments about the masculine-feminine duality within people reminds me a bit of some things that Otto Rank (see: "A Dream that Interprets Itself") and Alfred Adler (in "Psychological Hermaphroditism in Life and in the Neurosis". This paper has some serious problems but is nonetheless of some value). Both talk about how masculine and feminine traits come to achieve a certain balance within each individual. From that Adler paper, he says: "uncertainty about one's own abilities creates doubts causing a vacillation that is influenced at times more by "female" tendencies (fear and related signs), and at other times by those of the "male" ( aggression, compulsive-obsessiveness). The structure of neurosis (neurasthenia, hysteria, phobia, obsessive-compulsive neurosis, paranoia, etc.) shows us, and is manifested best of all by obsessive-compulsive neurosis, the variedly intertwined "female" lines, carefully covered up and built upon by hypertrophic "male" desires and striving." This masculine protest develops compulsively as over-compensation because the "female" tendency, seen from the perspective of a child's value system, is regarded contemptuously as a childhood disorder and is held on to only in a subliminal form and only because it offers outward advantages (love of family, affords freedom from punishment, gains praise for obedience and subjugation, etc.). All forms of internal compulsion in the normal person as well as in neurotics can be derived from this attempt at a masculine protest." Sorry for the lengthy comment! Loved the video, and looking forward to the next.

Zuzanna Maria Tadeusz Amadeusz Mochniej

I watched it in 3 sittings, to make it last longer. Although I do miss the socratic dialogue, I also like those of your more theory heavy materials. I loved this one! It felt so close to my heart, since I love Twilight, I ADORE Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles, and love-lust, vampiric, carnal desire, life and death have always been subjects I've been quite obsessively passionate about. The work and dedication you put into this video really shines through and I wanted to thank you for everything you do ❤︎ Remember to be kind to yourself! Love from Poland

Deconstruction Interactive

Happy belated International Women's Day! This is an amazing video, and totally deserves to be your dissertation. A dissertation with literally millions more views than most dissertations will ever get. Absolutely incredible work, Natalie :) I spent a lot of time watching this video and thinking of Neon Genesis Evangelion, which deals with many of the same themes though centering a male perspective, that of Shinji. Also the idea of topping from the bottom made me think of the Bene Gesserit, as I had just watched Dune 2 yesterday. It's fascinating how much these themes pop up everywhere in our culture, and yet if it weren't for works like yours, people would not get exposure to why they are so prevalent, and what is behind them. I love that you made it marxist in the end with a dialectic of sexuality :) And I loved the very last part, about non-binary perspectives and oneness and the Dao. Being non-binary myself, I really appreciated the idea of sexuality as a mountain, and if anything, I would love to see you explore this more in a future video. Congratulations on this incredible, monumental project!

Julia Ottenberg

I’ve watched this 2.5 times already, every time it’s better than the last

Samuel Victor

So I get a notifcation that Natalie liked my post, and I assumed it was my somewhat oversharing post below and got nervous! Only to then see that it was my silly "post nut clarity" comment where I seemingly made a stupid typo... that I'm now scared to edit incase the "like" disappears. Funny how these things parasocially matter. Anyway, glad my silly comment made you laugh!

Elen Lebet

Great video, enjoyed it immensely despite disagreeing with it. I thought it was somewhat unfair to touch upon sex negativity without exploring the "traditional" male fantasy. Drawing conclusions on heterosexual norms on the basis of female sexuality/fantasy doesn't draw a full picture. The anxieties of sex negative feminists come mostly from the dehumanising aspects of the male fantasy. Female fantasy doesn't hurt anyone, because they are (mostly) bottoms, and bottoms are gonna bottom. Are we ready to say that violent male fantasies are just as safe and harmless as Twilight? Deeply suspicious of the framing of power as a necessary element in sexyness and infatuation. Vanilla sex based on equality is being marginalised right now, but I don't think it is something unreachable, many people practice it happily. Great content anyways!

ibi

haven't finished this but I think this is my fav video since Envy - and there were some darn good videos in between them!

ibi

your connection of blood to life and death reminded me a lot of the video game Hades! the main idea is the protagonist (Hades's initially stillborn son) trying to escape the Underworld to find his mother. there's a point later in the game where someone speculates that the protagonist is the god of blood, as he represents life/family, but also has a bond with Thanatos (god of death) and represents the union of the god who rules the Underworld and the goddess who rules vitality and nature. people also talk about his blood and his (sole) inherent ability to fling "bloodstones", which his dad refers to as "your blood". interesting to see different interpretations of blood.

ibi

also some more random thoughts: 1. timely for this to come out not long after kristen stewart saying twilight is gay 2. a lot of analysis of modern sexual dynamics omits femdom as a thing so I'm glad it was mentioned! 3. there's a psychosexual aspect to a lot of conservative rhetoric that I think is so intriguing - political cartoons about women stepping on men, etc. i wish people talked about this more.

Christopher Riley

Worth the wait! Thank you for doing what you do!

ContraPoints

Sadism is definitely not given a full treatment in this video. I sort of note the incompatibility of masochistic fantasy with actual sadism, and then move on. Possible future topic, though it would be difficult to cover without analyzing male pornography (so, very difficult to do on YouTube).

Katsognathus

Loved the video! I'll be revisiting this one in the future as it's packed with so much info.

Elena Kayanyan

Long-time fan and insufferable debater here - first off the outfits + mise en scene for this video were INCREDIBLE. I think I agree with the conclusions that “we all contain masculine and feminine potential within us and it’s more satisfying to express both”, “sadomasichistic fantasy has psychological origins that cannot be fully explained by leftist analysis of social hierarchy, nor abolished […] Sexuality is not a pure innocent thing that gets ‘perverted’ by corrupt society”, and twilight being good actually But hmmm…I take issue with some of the points // framing of the points you made. Some questions that came up: 1. DHSM (”this division of sexuality into bipolar roles”) is framed as largely / purely sociological, even if this isn’t explicit - But isn’t a discussion on desire / sexuality incomplete without addressing biological predisposition // how this behaviour was selected for in more detail? - The reason that DHSM exists *is* both biological and environmental - It’s why you see similarities in the way masculinity and femininity are portrayed globally + throughout history, with some fluctuation - of course though, as you said, biological “disposition is not destiny” (1:33:44) - I assume you didn't address this a) bc your videos analyse media through a sociological rather than biological lens, b) imagining DHSM as a *purely biological* construct is quite common already so it probably seems redundant, c) video was already quite long... 2. Is DHSM negative, or just the result of pattern-recognition? - A lot of the words that you list out as being conflated in DHSM are *genuinely* correlated - Plus, correlated words correlate with even more words, to create a kind of lexical field - People maladaptively clinging onto these correlations to make poor decisions (whether or not the correlations themselves are correct) should go, sure - But the concept of DHSM itself (unless i’m misunderstanding it) seems inevitable - I think you addressed this in part 5 (as quoted above), but when you say ”DHSM has got to go” - 2:44:02 // it’s “an ideal we can strive for” - 2:44:39 etc…is it even possible to get people to decouple the tangled up concepts that make up DHSM? Is it even rly desirable to do so? Has anyone been able to do so, sustainably? Need to revisit the video some more times. Also happy belated international women's day yippee

Kayt Colburn

I’ve already watched it twice and I have sent it to so many. This video brought me great comfort in a time when love feels confusing and validated my escape into smutty romance novels and fan fiction. Thank you for once again producing the absolute perfect video essay we needed. You are a gem ❤️

Manon

I second this! Especially for these longer videos with such complex and interwoven concepts, I would definitely be in the market for a printed version

Pamela Healy

was the P in ContraPoints always capitalized? I feel like this is a mandela effect thing

Robin McDonald

This is my new favourite video of yours. I have often debated with myself about my own tendencies with kink and romance about how much of it is biological or behavioural, and this was such a good exploration of the history of women's sexuality that really enlightened me. Thank you for all your hard work, and being the most entertaining creator. On a somewhat unrelated note, my relationship with your videos has lasted for about 5 years now, and of all the partners I've had over that time, my boyfriend of nearly a year is the first I've managed to actually get in to your videos with, which I find to be very gratifying.

VenomdP

Welcome back! Loved the video. I would also love to hear a tangent on the "Gaylor" community and hear your thoughts on it since you mentioned. I, for one, think it's definitely possible there's something there... her "Lover" era and the You Need to Calm Down music video was SO strange if she's not hinting at her sexuality...

jessamyn

This was your best yet, Natalie! I was reading Thoughts Without a Thinker by Dr. Mark Epstein at the time I watched this and there were so many parallels! Thank you for all you put into this. It’s epic!

Zacry Spears

9999999/10. this really helped me work through some shit. TY<3

MagicMadMan

This sounds like a random tangent, and it kind of is, but this did help give context and understanding to Neon Genesis Evengelion. Specifically to a fairly important theme "The Hedgehogs' Dilemma."

Zhenya Oliinyk

I watched a part or two every night during this week and it made it good

Tree

I think this was the most perfect thing Ive ever watched

purpleforest

literally have put off finishing the last 30 min of this MASTERPIECE for weeks now I LITERALLY can’t bear for it to endddd!!

Paparazzi

Can we get the non PG 13 version as a Tangent? I'm sure you have many more thoughts?

Eric Kaplan

is that Ed Asner in the Cartland Collins debate? If it isn't, who is it? IF it is, why is it?

Mary

This is my favorite video of yours! I watched it with a friend and we loved the thorough defense of women's sexuality and sexual fantasies. Also, my friend said she wants you to do an analysis on the Jujutsu Kaisen anime and how that show has unleashed a wave of shameless female horniness onto the internet lmao.

Gabriella

Disavowal + CNC fantasy discussion is also relevant to the scene where Jacob kisses Bella against her will. She gets to be kissed by Jacob without it being her fault at all. I remember when I was 12 or 13 and read the books, my mom read them too, and she had a little sit down with me to explain why Jacob doing that was wrong and a violation. Which was good parenting and all, but part of the effect was that I felt shame that I had really enjoyed reading that scene in the book. If I have a daughter who reads twilight one day, I’d want to talk to her about consent but also about not feeling shame for enjoying these kinds of disavowal fantasies!

viruviruviru

just finished rewatching the witch trials of jk rowling and at the end you say "harry potter is dead to me, im switching to twilight" i'm screaming

Ryan Wright

Anne Carson is so important to me and I’m really glad Eros the Bittersweet is featured in this video! If you haven’t read Autobiography of Red I can’t recommend it enough. It’s v trans imo, and gut-wrenchigly beautiful

Edward Steele

I recognised half the background music in this one! Interesting how much of it was from a specific Chopin book I got when I was younger and finally decided to learn all the pieces in recently - "Chopin: An Introductory Album". A great set of Etude's, Preludes and Mazurkas!

The Staff of Harmony & Strife

Fantastic video! Brava, brava! Thank you so much for making me re-examine my internal misogyny through Twilight of all damn things. Bravissimo!

Kapelski

Upon second viewing this really clicked for me. Maybe your best video. Not sure yet though.

Pete Murney

Don't know if it's time to talk tangents yet, but I think an exploration of the Pandrogeny project might be relevant. It is to the best of my knowledge the furthest anyone has ever taken the idea of the partner as other half of the self. Genesis P-Orridge and Lady Jaye Breyer modified themselves to look as identical as possible and then came to identify themselves as one pandrogynous being named Breyer P-Orridge. They were so far ahead of their time (or out of time) that no one else has caught up!

Angie B

I've not stopped thinking about this video since I first watched it. It has helped me gain so much clarity on our collective understanding of sexuality, gender, and desire, and to make sense of my own personal experience too. And the ending!! You're so brilliant!!! Probably a thousand times more useful for the world than another PHD dissertation...

Laura G

I have watched this three times now. I did my undergraduate in psychology, and this is the most idea rich, moost interesting lecture on sexuality and gender I have ever seen.

Vishal Cain

I need to hear your thoughts on this.. Camille Paglia.. a tangent maybe?

bins

watched this video 8 times and did 3mg of psilocybin extract and now I'm dating one of my best friends. thanks contrapoints!

Joelle Killian

Oh my god. Psychologist here (with lots of analytic training), and I wish they had just shown THIS in our Human Sexuality seminars instead :) Coincidentally, I was also listening to a podcast about Lacan (nerd, I know, shut up) the same week as watching this, so I basically SCREAMED when I saw that HOLE omg. Love. 10/10, no notes.

eva henderson

Anne Carson, George Bataille, and Angela of Foligno in the same video? And it's not even my birthday? Seriously, this is absolute perfection. I always rewatch your videos, but this is the first one that I've watched multiple times in the span of a week. I feel like I've been waiting my whole life for such a comprehensive and poignant analysis of desire, sexuality, and fantasy. The intrinsic violence of these things has always disturbed me, which has made it painful and complicated to engage in any sort of intimacy, but I can honestly say that this video has helped me make my peace with that. In summary: I laughed, I cried, I changed my brain chemistry, 20 out of 10

Uri Baruchin

Finally carved out time to watch it in one go. Absolutely delightful and the intellectual tonic I didn't know my limerence-ridden broken heart needed. Thank you.

Trejon Dunkley

This is definitely one of your best videos, probably an all time great video essay. Is a bibliography (partial even!) available? I have a lot I want to add to my reading list now.

chobani-flip

you know, I came on here to ask the same thing 🤣 I've looked all over and I can't find anything, so I've resorted to running my cursor over the played bar and pausing on the covers of the books. Currently listening to an audiobook of *Savage Appetites* by Rachel Monroe, and it's SO GOOD. I also found Lucy Neville's *Girls Who Like Boys Who Like Boys*

Tommy

Every video deserves a 2nd, 3rd, 4th listen! So much to appreciate/ think about from the topics you discuss. Suggestion - watch all seasons of The Sopranos next! We need a contrapoints philosophical analysis/ deconstruction of the most celebrated TV series of all time!

Liz

Such good work. Thank you. And I have never watched or read a minute of Twilight. Even the madeleines looked good and I don't like madeleines.

Aud

It's been almost a month and this has turned out to be one of those special bits of media that has actually changed the way I think about and interact with the world in the day-to-day.

Lily Yousefi

Hi Natalie, is there a way to have access to the list of resources/books you used for this video essay? I don't mean a numbered exact citation list, just a rough list.

mossy

crazy good 10/10

mossy

feels like nourishment

purpleforest

seen it four times through now and I feel my molecules realigning into place in my brain each time,,, it's sosoos good!!!!:DDDD <333

Felix

Love you

Annabelle_Thann

It took me three sittings to watch this with my gf and they were all worth it. Really helped me understand my own desires and my hang ups around those desires

Sabrina Penna

Weeks after watching this almost as soon as you released it, I'm writing that I loved this and that I've watched it multiple times and that I probably will again. Not very thoughtful, I know, but that's it before I go to bed. Also, I'm SO happy you're back. Watched and commented on the Generations video earlier today. Looking forward to the coming tangents. More, please.

Grace Carroll

Like a lot of people commenting here, I've watched this about five times, and it is honestly mind-blowing, thank you. It's difficult to remember that there is a lot of value in psychological approaches to sex and gender when all you have been bombarded with since you first started to understand these concepts was political rhetoric. Not to say there's no value in that, just that it's important and reassuring to remember that our minds are not always in control of themselves. It's given me a lot to chew on - and made me come back as a patron actually. I only left for financial reasons but when this came out I was like nah dude gotta catch up on those tangents lol

Grace Carroll

Sidenote I remember reading Anne Carson as a classics undergrad and not understanding it at all so you will have made my supervisor very happy for finally helping it click

Lily Stein

need you to know this is in fact CRAZY good, could never be crazy bad

Georgia

As a sapphic romance author who occupies a unique-ish niche in the market ("dark but consensual"), I never thought I'd find another person on this planet who thinks about this stuff as much as me. Duh, of course, the person is you. This made me feel sane, in fact, I've forced this on every author or friend around me who is even remotely interested in the genre

Bearsly

<3 thank you, such a nourishing video. you do excellent work!

Tasha3D (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-14 12:00 would be interested to hear your thoughts on The Love Witch if you've seen it. The director is working on her next film a take on Bluebeard, she talks about "bluebeard films" in which the protagonist is unsure of her/their lover wants to kill them. Twilight is a bluebeard film, beauty and the beast is a bluebeard film
2024-04-11 20:12

TheLovingAvoidant

Watched this over three days and understand myself and life so much better now. Going to need to rewatch it probably a few times in the coming months to absorb and synthesize into my own articulation of the most resonant aspects as they connect to other beloved ideas.

Ash Gabrielle

I really love The Love Witch. It's an interesting movie!

pjkc

Amazing video! Third time watching this now, and it's still *so* dense and beautiful... my fave aesthetic touch was probably the Tristan and Isolde bit in the soundtrack, super clever to Dracula-fy the yearning, pretty much sums it up. The core thread I take away from the video as a whole is that, as a basic fact of the human condition, we define ourselves and sustain our yearning through various fantasies, which require varied impediments or constructs to maintain their own internal logic. We block, we rule out, and we constrain, with DHSM and other illusions, in a doomed attempt to give form to our yearning. I'm reminded of Either/Or, of the choice of whether or not to try and impose rules on our condition, to propagate and regulate our drives by a ritual we call ethics, or to simply embrace things as they are, and find them beautiful. Idk though, I feel like I'm gonna be trying to understand this video at least as long as it's taken you to write it. Some real astral plane Lacanian astrodynamics going on in this one Natalie. Well done, I feel like I've been hit by a truck of books.

Squash fei

As an aroace-spectrum person, many parts of this video did not speak to me personally, or "make something click" per se, and that's ok. I tried very hard to relate the ideas in the video to my own experience, and while it worked for some ideas, others were just completely foreign to me. I felt kind of like I was taking a curious but respectful foray into another culture. I learned a lot of interesting insights into the way most people (presumably) experience and conceptualize love.

Mark Nugent

Been catching up with your work, I'm an ASD completionist, and I have to say , so far, all killer, no filler. I appreciate your smart, funny, confrontational, artistic content. Who knew there was so much mine in Twilight? Thank you Natalie.

Collin Estes

This video essay made me so happy; thank you so much for your thoughtful and deep analysis! So, Stephenie Meyer and I actually became friends because we both joined a writing forum around the same time in the early '00s, and I helped proofread the manuscript of Twilight (book 1). Despite the fact that Steph was (at the time, anyway) more on the conservative side--you know, Arizona Mormon, etc--it always really bothered me how critics accused her of being both anti-feminist and also somehow dangerous to conventional morality. Plus, they totally overlooked her great sense of humor! This video essay made me feel proud and honored to play a very small part in the Twilight phenomenon

Charlotte

I definitely noticed a lot of the themes in hunger pt1 in here in this video. I think there is still a lot of room for a hunger part 2 though and that is in what the role addiction plays amongst cravings, yearnings, how the subbing in of addiction for spirituality is so common.... there are deep themes of desire and yearning in there that don't necessarily touch in the same way as it does with love/limerence. That is what i am hoping for a hunger part 2 of some sorts but obviously trust and appreciate any direction your art takes you!!! this video is huge for me, it's soooo affirming to my own personal sexuality, it's a lot of questions i think about a lot too.

Morhzov

You definitely had a hidden tangent about Christianity in here and it was quite beautiful. I think a lot about what you mentioned here about the profane/sacred really speaks to why Christians have become so crazed about abortion. It even symbolically plays with this ctrl+z (undo) of the sacredness that you've outlined here that happens as part of sex and sacrifice. At least now I understand my parents a little better than I did before. All thanks to you, mother.

Gaia Moisan

This video is everything to me and my friends! Thank you for your work. I have gotten all these suggested videos about limerence because I watch the twilight video over and over again lol. Most of these psychologists talk about limerence like it is inherently pathological and distinct from “real love”. Would love to know what you think about this!

Alisha

Love every single thing you've ever done. Thank you for your work!! ✨️💐🩷

Lina7

Thank you for such beautiful work in both content and shape. A burning question: did you - do you still - like to read Twilight? They say art should entertain and teach. You taught us Twilight has a lot to teach. Does it bring you pleasure too?

story

this is easily my favourite video you have ever produced, and it is what triggered me to sign up as a patron and to give you my money. THANK YOU!

Amanda Tori Meeting

There’s something so comforting about having such a strong, trans-affirming argument about how one of the most fundamental drives in human behavior functions. In a world on fire I can’t help coming back to Natalie’s reassurance that it sucks but it all kinda makes sense and, who knows, maybe we can make better choices.

Andrew May

I know it’s a bit frivolous, but “He still don’t know if I can control himself” keeps me coming back again and again 🤣

Matias Blanch

Question: do you share your video scripts with bibliography for members?

Daria Costea

Im curious what do you think about the couple morticia and gomez in light of all this

Lina7

Hello Nathalie. You probably won't see this message, but just in case, I'd like to propose helping with making the French subtitles (the automatic translation can do in a pinch but some sentences missed the mark in way that is a bit funny but also cringey. Usually I put on the English subtitles but I showed your video to a friend a few days ago and had to often correct the French subtitles). As a fan of your work, I don't mind doing it for free, pour l'amour du langage, le défi de trouver le bon mot (I'm an editor in real life - who is about to get their holidays time) afin de traduire au plus proche des expressions difficiles ("gaslight, gatekeep, girlboss" for instance) et afin de participer même de loin à ton entreprise philosophique et artistique. If interested, let me know !

csinclair

Is it possible to get something along the lines of “works citied” for this? I’m in a Queer Theory course and I would love to incorporate your work. Thank you always.

Julia Goyer

it’s crazy good. seriously

Hugo M B

This is my favorite video of yours. And itt says a lot because I love your content.

M

Rewatching this after the Surreal Videos tangent is even more enjoyable than before, because now I recognize the Lasagna Cat structure.

Lina7

Hello Natalie. I've been working on the French subtitles for your Twilight video. I'm happy to say that they're now available for downloading on Captionfy : https://www.captionfy.com/video/youtube/bqloPw5wp48?caption=fr-6Rr I've sent a mail at info@contrapoints.com a few weeks ago but I think it was probably swept up in your fan mail 😁. Here's to hoping I can do another one with Envy next. Wish you the best !

Seiya

I've watched this video like 5 times since it came out because it's just that mega crazy good. Also you look gorgeous in all the looks. Thank you for serving them!

Noah Gallant

I’m not sure where else to post this but the Twilight video has been removed in Canada due to copyright! I haven’t seen Natalie address this anywhere and wanted to make sure she’s aware. i really wanted to rewatch it 😭

Albertyna Varga

this video being removed is kinda devastating

Steffi

It’s also gone in Germany and Austria WILL IT COME BACK??this video is what’s keeping me going 😩😭

Ariel L

It's been over a year since this video came out and I still come back to re-watch it regularly. I generally prefer not to post at all, including comments on videos, but I wanted to leave a comment on this just to say that it is one of my favorite videos of all time. I recommend it to friends regularly. It's funny, insightful, and interesting, and I am very happy that you brought it into the world.

Connor G

He still don't know if I can control himself

Connor G

I'm curious if anyone has a full bibliography/reading list for this video?

flyx

Rewatching this video reminded me of this very old SMBC comic, which matches quite well with the masculine/feminine fantasy, but back in the day I didn't have the words to describe it: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2010-05-21

MJayBee

I'm rewatching this again, and the way this spirals into different aspects of sexuality is brilliant... but of course, it's just about Twilight

Rose Dombegh

I feel like the rewatching of this video is itsself erotic ... built on the tension and release of a really really good argument being artistically laid out then brought altogether.

Heather

Circling back to this as required reading for my Twilight Forever festival stream watch party… Ms Points please can we book club the new Renesmee/Jacob book 😩

Imogen

I've just watched this for the 3rd or 4th time and each viewing makes me feel worse. Like, how could I have missed all of this when I read Twilight? Clearly I'm not the person I thought I was.

A

Mother, I’m watching your twilight video essay again… except I can’t because copyright 😢