Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I often I end up making dishes multiple times before getting them right, as old recipes love leaving out important bits of information (I think the authors enjoyed picturing people centuries down the road struggling with ingredient names and measurements and wasting money on ruined dishes), but rarely have I had something completely fail as spectacularly as my first go with a boiled Christmas pudding in a cloth. 

Luckily, I got a few tips from Twitter that might help me on my next go around (I watched tons of videos on how to do it, but clearly not enough). Good news is, I realized that I may want to try a different recipe any how. There were 3 Christmas Pudding recipes in Eliza Acton's Modern Cookery and this one seems a bit currant heavy after all is said and done. 

Take 2 begins this afternoon. Wish me luck! And if you have suggestions on keeping liquid out, other than boiling and flouring the cloth beforehand, I'm all ears.  

Files

Comments

Julie Lujano

Haha! Oh no! Good luck on round two! First the worst, second the best?

Aileen Hao

GOOOOD LUCK MAX!!!! Sending good vibes ✨✨ Hopefully Jose didn’t have to taste test this one :D

EnglishElf

I bought a pudding basin and lid. Then I wrap the whole thing in foil and parchment as per Alton Browns method. May not be historically accurate though :)

Matthew Wien

Good luck Max! I'm sure you'll crush it in round two. Looking forward to the success :)

Skye Acker

Maybe steaming instead? I dunno lol

Jean Buckley

I don’t have personal experience, but I’ve watched a lot of Townsend boiled pudding videos. Are you using a tightly woven fabric like linen, and boiling it long enough? Apparently, even if the pudding ingredients are cooked, the pudding may not hold together if it doesn’t boil long enough. So I hear.

Allisha Harvey

I think the boiling and flour method is the only way to use cloth, so your personal experience with it certainly trumps any knowledge I might have. Good luck on the next attempt! I'm sure you'll figure it out.

Simona Righini

<< I think the authors enjoyed picturing people centuries down the road struggling with ingredient names and measurements and wasting money on ruined dishes) >> "Ohi, Eliza, how's things with your new cooking book?" "Well, it's almost done, I'm just thinking about inserting some prank-ish recipes. You know, to see if people actually try them" "What about a pudding boiled in a cloth?" "Boiled in a cloth, you say? Oh, that's a great idea! Imagine the pulped mess... I'll definitely add it, thanks!"

Marc Kealhofer

Try a bit of butter on the cloth before adding flour and try a thicker cloth. If you used muslin, move to calico. If the calico didn't work for you, try a dense flat weave dish/tea towel (NOT terry cloth). Might be hard to find in LA, but they do make bags specifically for clootie dumplings.

Edie Alderette-Sellers

According to Mr Francatelli, Queen Vicky’s chef de cuisine, “a well- greased floured cloth,” “taking care that the water boils before the pudding is put into the pot to boil” is the thing. You’ll be making a oil-cloth raincoat, as it were.

GameHounds Podcast (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 11:00 I’d send you a photo of my copy of Mr. Francatelli’s book but Patreon doesn’t do photos. Let me know if you want me to send pages for cross reference with Mrs. Acton’s instructions.
2020-10-26 17:35

Tasting History with Max Miller

The problem was that a bit of liquid got in. Making a cloth waterproof is harder than it seems. Actually, it seems hard.

Patrick Duncan

Damn, if you were making (essentially) Clootie Dumpling, should have said so. Use a flour sack cloth, and a heavy dusting of flour. Some people cheat & use buttered parchment inside the cloth, but I've never tried that.

Lil

Lol...I know your pain! Although not Christmas pudding, I've made many a clootie dumpling in the past Max, and they're fairly similar. Firstly, you don't need a fancy cloth at all...even a clean cotton pillow case is good enough. Make sure your cloth is thoroughly scalded in the boiling water, but don't wring it out *too* much. And when flouring your cloth, you need to *liberally* dust it, as in once you think you've got it floured enough, go over it all again. And make sure to put an upturned plate underneath the pudding once it's in the pot - it shouldn't ever sit directly on the base of the pot. I've a recipe for a foolproof modern (80s) take on Eliza Acton's Christmas pudding recipe if you want me to send it on.

Amy O'Hala

That looks like my first attempt too...

Saffy

Probably advice you already have, but from when I used to help my Nana with puddings, you need a tight weave on your fabric - we used calico, which I think is what you guys call muslin? Then you have to make sure it’s damp before you use it. Not soaking wet, but like, ham-bag damp. I think she used to soak the cloth while we were making the pudding mix and then wring it out once we were ready to use it. And then, more flour than you think! We used to use a sifter to get a super even layer all the way to the edges (this was always my job), a little less than a millimetre thick, and then she would rub the flour into the cloth so that it caught in all the gaps in the weave. The water in the cloth turns the flour into a glue-y layer to protect your pudding.

ClaireIsClear

This may be a little late, but we still make clootie dumpling here (literally a fruity dumpling boiled in a cloot, or cloth), so you may find better ideas on how to boil a pudding without sogging it on searches for that - certainly you DON'T want to completely submerse the pudding or it will disintegrate. See https://catherinebrownfoodwriter.com/wee-clootie-dumpling/

Zoë

I've never made a boiled Christmas pudding, only steamed (yummy)! I know boiling things in cloth was a thing - they used to do it on board ship, so possibly your ancestors who went on a boat to America would have had their food wrapped in cloth and then boiled in a great big cauldron.

GameHounds Podcast (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 11:00 Soooooo.... did it come out? Don't ask why I've been on pins and needles about the end of the saga. That's the 2020 need for distraction talking.
2020-10-28 18:30

Tasting History with Max Miller

The second try was much more successful. But now, I have to wait quite a while before tasting it. Has to age for a few weeks. : )

Mark Dorfman

Ha at first glance, looks remotely like a diaper 😜.

Sherry C

It's the failures that prove that your figuring things out and not just relying on more modern recipes and faking us out. Be proud of those fails... They're full of learning!!!

Mike

that looks like tumor, after they cut it out :-(

Katherine Bruce

It might be worth watching Victorian Farm Christmas where one of the hosts, Ruth Goodman, talks to Ivan Day, a well-known British Food historian (what a great job!). The beginning of part 3 goes into it in detail. They do cook it in a pudding bowl and not just in the bag (if you watch the Christmas part of The Victorian Farm, you can see Ruth make it just in the bag and it looks rather like the above). It ends up as the perfect cannonball. (Alternatively you could go the really old route and do it in a sheep's stomach if you can get one, but butches are so often fresh out!)

Gizmodrake

Every setback is a temper to success. Dont be afraid to face failures :)