Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi all,

I wanted to wish everyone a happy new year! I also wanted to welcome and thank all the new Patreon members.

Lastly, I wanted to ask for suggestions on what more you'd like to see as a patron of Tasting History in 2022? Wether it be early access to videos, more general updates, or anything really. I'd love to create a community here and am open to any suggestions on how to do so. 

Feel free to respond here or shoot me a message here on Patreon.

Thank you all again!

Max 

Comments

Rachel G

Maybe you can do a series on "Royal Recipies." Like, what was Queen Victoria's favorite dish and then see if you can make it.

Pamela Goloskie

Any chance of getting the actual recipes, at least for things that will not be in cookbooks? Or is that not allowed because of contracts?

Palmtop Shisa

Happy New Year Max! I know at times you have to redo dishes to fix issues you have in recreating a recipe and wouldn't mind you going more into this in your videos or on the discord. : )

Kyla and Miguel de Villa

Happy New Year! We adore all of your recipes but the majority are eurocentric, so it would be very cool to see recipes from a broader variety of cultures. I also love hearing about what lengths you've gone to, to find these recipes and piece together the relevant history.

Evie

Not Patreon-specific, but maybe recreate fan-favorite historical dishes... using historical methods and implements (where possible)?

Chibi

Happy new year! Behind the scenes content such as mixing, cutting, folding, whatever the steps in between are. The real ugly work of cooking and baking😂Or the failures from the recipes testing. It would be great to be able to vote on the following recipes or the get the recipe via patreon.

Jared Estes

I love this idea as well!

Alexandra Marie

Happy New Year! Early access would be amazing.

Riz

Some more updates and maybe more behind the scenes stuff?

Karen Gaylin

Happy New Year Max and Jose (Jaime and Cerce too!). Marci Gras is typically associated with New Orleans but Fat Tuesday has its foundations in pagan festivals Celebrating spring and fertility like the Roman Saturnalia. Binging on fatty foods was part of it in preparation for the austerity of Lent. On the website www.followinghadrian.com they published some typical Saturnalia menu items like Apicus’ chicken in hazelnut sauce that could be interesting.

Thomas Collins

I'd love to see more behind the scenes stuff as well but PARTICULARLY maybe a vid where you go shopping for some rather hard to find ingredients.

Chris Illes

More on hand pies or other "all in one" hand food

Xhavier

seconded, I'd really love to see more recipes and history from the global south!

Gao Rowan

I think itd be fun to have little tidbits on historic foods/recipes that are interesting but don’t have enough material (either scholarly or in terms of being interesting to make) to warrant a full length video of their own. Another fun thing to do could be little posts that highlight local historic food culture suggested by patrons from their area or hometown (highly regional foods, food-related businesses that have been existence for a hundred or more years, etc).

Simona Righini

I second anybody asking for "behind the scenes", and I'd be curious to see - even in very raw form - information and details that you found interesting but did not make it to the final cut.

Sean Fiandaca

I'd like to see you make pemmican or other similar provisions which were used in the pioneer days (and be honest about some of that history).

Sean Fiandaca

Nothing the Donner party ate though :D

Sam Palahnuk

My passion for ancient foods began with a recipe for what was basically a Roman hamburger. How about you have the history of "burgers" and maybe make one too!

Dan Adler

I'd love behind the scenes stuff. The shopping, the research, the making Jose's life insane. All of that would be, I think, a lot of fun. Beyond that, I'd love to see you branch out. Food from Africa, or southeast Asia. Areas that haven't really been touched on yet. (and, on top of that, I Really want to see you eat haggis...)

Bob Mallen

I'd love to see you attempt for historic native dishes. Doesn't have to be limited to North American native groups either, but I think seeing the foods people ate prior to colonialism would be extremely interesting!

Jason Youngberg

I liked how you have a guest on the newest episode. Maybe, during the summer, you can go outside and use a grill. Are there any living history farms or ren faires in your area? Take a visit and talk to some of the people of how cooking was done back then.

Sheena Christina

I concur with those who want to see a behind the scenes of shopping…I would also love to see you hook up with a SCAdian group during a feasting or camping event to show you historical archeology and not just tasting the history, but living it too…once the world opens up a little bit more, and it is safe to do so, of course.

SKELETOR UP IN THIS MUTHA

I'd like to see any one of these: * a collaboration with Michael Twitty (Townsend can hook you up (https://townsend.tv/tag/michael-twitty/) * your take on the origins of Mulligatawny (I got to pepper water, dessert-spoonfuls, and chattys; oh my) * Appalachian/Foxfire foodways (leatherbritches, dried apple pie, etc.) * Dealers choice from some of my favorite Medieval Stuff (bonus points for forgotten ingredients like orris root): * All Manner of Cookery - https://archive.org/details/truegentlewomans00kent * Drunk Stuff - https://archive.org/details/vinetumbritanni00worl/page/n9/mode/2up * Kenelm Digby - https://archive.org/details/closetofsirkenel00digb

William Wood

I playtested a game on that once. My comment became a byline - "What it lacks in taste, it makes up for with flavor."

Pete Fitchett

Happy New Year to you and Jose, early access to videos is something a lot of creators do and seems to work well. I’d also say like others outtakes are fun. I also think I recall you mentioning you were thinking of doing dishes from other types of literature or something like that which could be fun.

Christine Houser

Just thinking out loud but how about looking in to historical foods from Native American tribes. Maybe contact some of the tribal offices and see how that goes? Might be a bit harder as it's not written but could make for interesting behind the scenes of interviews.

Adrian Slider

Yeah, Patreon-exclusive outtakes/blooper reels would be fun!

Theresa Givan

Would you be willing to do a video with one of us (in our own kitchens, you know yours) teaching us how to make a recipe, answering questions, and watching our reaction as we try a dish? You are always so great at describing dishes you’ve made and what they taste like. I would be curious if people would react to things the same way as you. Also you are an EXCELLENT teacher.

Tara

I think it would be cool to see some content one day of using historical cooking materials and methods. I don’t know if that’s possible right now, but one day would be so cool :)

Spookz

To sum up some things listed so far, that I think could be helpful: 1. Public-facing work, i.e. going to areas relevant to food/cooking history. 2. Collaborations with other creators, historians, chefs, etc. 3. Branching out your work to new cuisines. 4. Behind-the-scenes stuff. Overall, you have a very strong core content lineup. Your videos are fun, rewatchable, pleasant, and educational. Absolutely nobody will complain about you continuing to make strong content, and there's practically unlimited material out there. However, you could have some neat opportunities trying out new things, whatever those may be. If you got this far by doing things you want to do and enjoy, then I hope you just keep doing that. I can just feel the enjoyment and passion you've put into this all, and that's the part that makes rewatching your videos part of my morning ritual.

Jessica Kratovil

Happy New Year to you Jose and the kitties!!! Definitely interested in any "behind the scenes" type things lots have mentioned. Even just little snippets would be a nice treat!

Doug Hoover

For Patrons: Early access is always a welcome perk. How about posting the recipe and ingredient list here as a patron perk?

Bob Dowling

For the main videos, I don’t want to see too much change in style. I like how they are; that’s why I patr[e]onize the channel. Behind the scenes are fun, but not as a replacement for the normal. In terms of content I would quite like to see “sets” of videos that go together, perhaps one on a main course and a second (not necessarily the next video produced) that would be a corresponding dessert, so that we could see how a whole meal would come together at a particular point in history. For the historical element, what I would love to see are more “the rise and fall of [ingredient]” tales: rosewater, rue, sylphium (I loved that episode!) etc. Or perhaps some “first” recipes: what was the first tomato dish in Italy, the first potato recipe in Britain, and so on with the histories of ingredients that were introduced from the New World but have become staples in the Old World.

Redditování

Happy New year! I would love to see some shorter videos if possible, maybe some really short recipes or fun facts along with your usual content. :)

Michael Paulmeno

Happy New Year! I think it would be great to see a video about vegetarianism (not sure what dish would go along with this). Maybe some kind of medieval salad too since there is so much variety here. A video about chicken tikka masala might be interesting too.

Erin G.

Hi, Max. Reflecting on your request, I was pondering what it is that I love so much about The Great British Bakeoff. It occurred to me that a big part of it is the fact that I could see the failures of the bakers, as well as their successes. It makes them so relatable, and being there through their ups and downs, the triumphs and tragedies that go into making a baker, helps to draw you into their lives and their world.Drawing a parrell to Tasting History, I realize now that some of my favorite tidbits are the trail and errors that you go through, and especially when youo fail. Don't be afraid to show us your m istakes! Wheather in the form of outtakes or simply when something goes awry in the kitchen, don't mask it; exploit it!. You have a special gift for turning lemons into hilarious Emmy-worthy lemonade.

Jeri Spence

Would love to see something interactive. I live the happy hours. Maybe some sort of Patron bake-off?

Cindy

I think bloopers or "failure" videos would be great for patrons to see. I'll continue to support you whether recipes work out or not! When things don't work out, we all learn something new =)

John Manchester

Considering Sohla made a video last month Max may want to wait a bit longer before making a video. Plus with pemmican I believe it is regional so Max would need to pick a specific region as different tribes had their own variations as well as the Europeans in those areas too.

Leonardo

More depth into the recipes?

The Whitrock Family

You could do a series on "Last Meals"... For instance, the morning of his resignation, rumor has it that Nixon had a breakfast of cottage cheese and pineapple, a popular diet food at the time. If you wanted to do a President's Day thing, you could get some interesting stories from Presidential plates (JFKs love of Beef Wellington, for instance). You could do a deconstruction series, too, based on the spread of agricultural technology in the Columbian Exchange; pick a dish from a country around the world and trace how it got all its ingredients. Then, of course, there's lots of options for the potato/tomato line in Europe...

Lucio Gama

Happy New Year! I like the idea of presenting your bloopers, mistakes, or dislikes. Maybe incorporated at the end of each video, after credits. In terms of types of food, I'd love to see more non-European dishes (the Middle East - halva!!, India, Caribbean).

Erin G.

I would also like to see an episode on marzipan!

It goes down in the PM (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-11 11:00 I would love to see more candy through history
2022-01-16 17:29

juleen walker

Maybe also more lesser known indigenous foods from other countries like the kakanin of the Philippines

Erin G.

Yes, I would especially like to see an episode on barley sugar!

Erin G.

You seem to have a vast repertoire of Biblical references. Could you perhaps do an episode on Biblical foods? I know that this is a very expansive topic, so it could even become a series.

Juti A Winchester

Honestly, I don't need special anythings for being a patron. I'm just happy to help you keep making videos!

Larissa S.

I found an interesting cookbook - What Mrs. Fisher Knows About Old Southern Cooking. It was authored in 1881 by a formerly enslaved woman, Abby Fisher, who lived in San Francisco. She made pickles that were very popular among SF's elite at the time, and this book contains a few recipes for pickles. But most interestingly, the whole book is a transcription of Mrs. Fisher's instructions - she couldn't read or write. Which is also to say, the whole book's contents were just stored in her memory for decades! This was a pretty jarring reality for a lot of formerly enslaved people in America. But this book also is one of the first well-known and widely-published cookbooks by an African-American. You can read the book here: https://www.loc.gov/resource/rbc0001.2018gen23680/?sp=1&st=slideshow#slide-13 The most unusual recipes - I can't even guess how they might taste or look - are: #74 - Sweet Cucumber Mangoes (it seems to be a pickle stuffed with cabbage?) #81 - Pepper Mangoes (again, not seeing any mango, but it seems to be a whole pickled stuffed bell pepper?), and #86 - Sweet Watermelon Rind Pickles (this is a trendy recipe now, but back in the day it required putting watermelon rind in salt for a week????)

Larissa S.

A crossover with a foraging expert would be interesting - you do a lot of interesting recipes from the fancier kitchens at the time, but I know that poor people disproportionately relied on foraged food, pretty weird food, and simple food. I remember eating poke salad and (unsprayed!) dandelion salad in the 00s as a kid, as my grandmother lived through the Depression. I know a lot of these recipes are probably harder to find, as widespread literacy among poor people is a <200-year-old phenomenon, and people didn't think to write down the peasant food recipes.