Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Yolanda's egg round 1 vote

  • Sinnoh egg - GEN IV egg 145
  • Unova Egg - GEN V egg 179
  • Kalos Egg - GEN VI egg 252
  • Hoenn Egg - (GEN III) the kid lied! 26
  • Indigo Egg - (GEN II) the kid lied! 23
  • 2026-09-06
  • —2026-09-12
  • 625 votes
{'title': "Yolanda's egg round 1 vote", 'choices': [{'text': 'Sinnoh egg - GEN IV egg', 'votes': 145}, {'text': 'Unova Egg - GEN V egg', 'votes': 179}, {'text': 'Kalos Egg - GEN VI egg', 'votes': 252}, {'text': 'Hoenn Egg - (GEN III) the kid lied!', 'votes': 26}, {'text': 'Indigo Egg - (GEN II) the kid lied!', 'votes': 23}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 12, 19, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 6, 11, 7, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 625}

Content

For the first round of the egg selection, just to narrow down where the egg will have come from. Then I will look through the options for that GEN of pokemon that we can draw from and will put in something that I like for the second round of votes.from.

Comments

Rex

I feel that Gen 5 will have the most options to pull from.....I also Just love Gen V in general.

Shadow Fiend

Same, there's just so many things you can choose from in Unova.

David Green

Deino egg to piss off Lance

Forint

Just give her the froakie. I saw the poll before I read the chapter, went thru all the dark and rock types that show up for the 3 regions. And froakie, by far, is the best option. Narratively interesting too, cause her mom is a water type.

Brendan White

No Gen 8? Obstagoon or Toxtricity would be perfect for our Rocker Gal.

Rhett Faucheaux

Say it’s gen 6, so the kid may be right on the region but not on the rarity of the Pokemon. The starters of any regions will have their eggs secured as possible, all of them grow into pretty powerful Pokemon with decent trainers backing them so I doubt some kid comics into a brand new opened up region isn’t gonna have a starter egg gambled away.

Forint

Now, if we're not limiting ourselves to water/rock/dark. Then it comes down to aesthetics *cough*volcarona*cough*. That makes things more difficult, narratively speaking. But there is precedent.

ShinLupin

Sadly no routes or connections to Galar yet. So no imports

PlasmaticPi

I'm assuming the egg color at least matches Greninja's colors of mainly blue and/or black. Which probably means water or dark types. Looking through the pokedex app I use I'm voting for Gen 6 since those pools of pokemon are pretty small yet very interesting, giving us a good chance at giving her Binacle, Clauncher, Pancham, or Inkay, none of which have really been in any pokefics I've read but could be great for her. Personally I'm hoping for one of the latter 2.

Revan

Gen 4 (and subsuquent gens) has Riolu, which would be beneficial for Yolandas own growing aura. But I think she'd benefit from Gen 5 the most, Zoura, Sandile, and Pawniard. If you wanted her to one up her brother tho? Gen 6 has Carbink

john

What about Flabébé it’s fairy type

Mario Schade

Hmm. Yolanda's current team: Pupitar (Terra) Arcanine (Spot) Pidgeot (Flapper) Sneasel (Slash) Tyrunt (Queen) To cover the types a bit more, Drapion or Alolan Muk would be good options (pure Dark-type Pokémon are weak to Fighting, which would be negated with these two, leaving only Ground as a weakness). Otherwise, you could also add a Steel-type; in that case, Bisharp (Kingambit) looks interesting. But it shows up very often in stories. If it’s not Froakie, a Hisui Samurott would be a Dark-type option that could be incorporated into Brock’s knowledge of alternative evolutions. However, I find the idea of a starter Pokémon’s egg being given away… a bit tricky. Do we know which type Yolanda prefers? The team is mixed and i cannot remember if it was told. But i think it has not to be a Dark-type? Seismitoad is very rarely used—but its types would also be a bit odd for her team. Deino/Hydreigon for the joke with Lance. Otherwise, the options get pretty limited, especially if Generation 7+ is ruled out. If you follow the anime’s logic and assume the eggs’ appearance alone allows for conclusions, then it gets even harder. I’m not sure what the eggs have looked like in the story so far. In the chapter itself, however, the appearance isn’t mentioned at all—so you might not even need to think about Froakie’s colors and can consider similar Pokémon as the only options. That would raise the question, though, of whether the shopkeeper really couldn’t narrow it down and Froakie (and similiar colors) is therefore actually a possibility, or if that’s completely off the mark and we have a free for all. So... which Pokémon could fit the second theme? Music and potential for Yolanda in this regard. Kricketune, Ambipom, or Diggersby (drummer), Gothitelle (maybe… if it could sing), Chingling (with a new Mega form), Toxicroak (~), Clawitzer (if you used its cannon as beats) So… I’m spoiled for choice. I like Hisui Samurott—but a free egg doesn’t make sense, even for a kid from that region. So something more normalwould be better. I mean... we just got a reminder about trading Pokémon. Maybe it’s a Pokémon that doesn’t suit Yolanda at all, and she has to give it away (the extent of the problems between the Pokémon and Yolanda is a matter for the story), and only then does she find the target Pokémon that’s a better fit? It would be a longer route, but it’s an idea. Ahh... do whatever you like. :D

Pi

Might I suggest a Hisuian starter? Make it hatch as an Oshawott, but evolve into the Hisuian form.

Nova

The Answer, as always, is Goomy. Goomy is best. Goomy is round!

RudeCzar

A croagunk would be great for her team

Jeff Fischer

While starters are always popular, I'd like some of the underused mon to see some screen time. How about a Binacle for an eventual Rock/Water physical sweeper?

StoutlandForTheWin#1

Gerninja gives Yolanda 3 dark types out of 5. Do it. Yolanda was meant to be a dark specialist.

Brendan White

Yolanda got swindled! It's an egg from Hoenn! But wait!! It hatches an Absol!

Connor Behan

There are literally only 3 rock types in Kalos that Yolanda doesn't have. Binacle, Carbink, and Amaura. Pick literally any other region!

Deep sea enjoyer

diancie To make Brock envious with how in the early chapters he was looking for carbink to take care of his diamond mine

TorrhenWintry

Should be a binacle, dwebble or roggenrola

JAndy

But Goomy!

Hooli4ss

The froakie makes sense atleast . She has a lethal squad for engagements outside of battle, no psychic but a Weavile , TTar ,potential Greninja? Lean into that Dark Type , nothing wrong with it. If not Greninja , I highly recommend Malamar . Can cover that Psychic area while still being a Dark Type(I’ve seen Malamars do dangerous things in fics.) She’d also have Sabrina for advice if she did have a Malamar.

Ixta

I'm into the idea of Yolanda getting a Froakie, but there's some other Kalos pokemon that would be cool. Pancham, Carbink, and Goomy could all work as well. And if it was a Carbink and she wasn't into it, she could trade it to Brock for something else off the reserve, like one of the new Glimmet.

wannasniffyoear .

Have it be a Battle Bond Greninja as the surprise. Continue the tradition of Brock and fam showing up with surprise pokemon.

Ixta

I agree it should be a froakie. I just read chapter 333 again on Royal road and saw she was already thinking about needing a water type, so it fits. "Her shelves were packed with books about various pokemon management guides, along with a familiar journal that I’d used to read through. I nodded to it. “Reading up about water types?” I asked. Yolanda nodded.”Yeah, gonna need them, or a good flying type, but seeing as I have a good start on water types I thought I might go that direction. Not sure what I’ll catch though. Think I could get a Lapras, or a Squirtle?”

Addicted2Games

Give her a Goomy egg. Same region, wrong pokemon, and Lance can seethe as someone else gets a new baby dragon. Also, best slug.

john

My vote for Inkay