Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

The rumors are true: they made another Super Mario movie. And, as licensed podcasters, we're legally obligated to see it and report back. On this installment of Retronauts, join Bob Mackey, Henry Gilbert, Stuart Gipp, Drew Mackie (from Thrilling Tales of Old Video Games), and Jess O'Brien (AKA Voidburger) as the crew uses their most powerful analytical skills to fully deconstruct a movie made for preverbal audiences. Will Illumination survive?

Files

Comments

Kormakur Gardarsson

Re: Drew’s point at the beginning of the episode about the standards to which we hold children’s entertainment: Bravo! Couldn’t agree more. Also, guess I need to see the Mario Galaxy movie now…

TheLupineOne

For a film titled "The Super Mario Galaxy Movie" it sure did not have much Rosalina. She was done dirty! She pretty much filled in the role of Luigi in the first one, spending far too much time imprisoned. Overall, the film felt like a rollercoaster which came to a sudden end. It ended far too soon and suddenly! I think I preferred the climax of the first movie, and the battle to save Brooklyn. My friend who I saw this movie with said it moved too fast. Characters are introduced, get barely any screen time, and are forgotten about as the cast move on to the next location. It's just a bunch of stuff that happened. I worry this film might be catering to the youth of the day, the tiktok generation, the kids with attention spans shorter than those we had when we were growing up. He said GOAT (the anthro basketball movie co-produced by Stephen Curry) was also too fast for his liking. I will have to see how Hoppers compares when I go see that.

Jeff Fanning

I had a surprisingly fun time at my local theater taking this in - as perhaps many others felt, I was a bit apprehensive based on the negative buzz around the movie. But- critics be damned; this was a hoot. And thank you all for the cracking good podcast; I'll take as many of these fine folk in my Retronauts feed as you can schedule.

Komsomol General

The sonic movies are better because they are real movies. They ain't great, ot even good, but at least they feel like they are trying.

Nessie

I agree that the movie does not follow the three act structure but it's also so tiring to see the same beats over and over in films. I liked the visual nature of the whole thing but Mario and Luigi don't have to have a falling out in the 2nd act for me to feel like we're at a movie. That being said, it would be great if they did something surprising with character development.

littleterr0r

My review: I fell asleep during the first movie and I didn't fall asleep during the second.

James Krusling

I haven’t seen either Illumination movie since I remain scarred by seeing the 1993 movie, which I rewatched with the Rifftrax and even with that I find it to be super duper frustrating (WHY IS YOSHI A REAL DINO? WHY?) However…this pod is making me reconsider seeing this one, which amazes me since I remember when you guys (rather enjoyably by the way) razzed the first one! It was a blast to listen to this one and weirdly enough, I watched the anime one a couple years ago on a whim and by default, it’s my number one Mario film as well!

Phillip

I have to say I was extremely shocked listening to the beginning of the episode and hearing the complete opposite reaction everyone had to the first movie. The first movie at least had a plot and resolved it and did it in quite a good way for a children's movie, even compared to other Illumination movies. This one just throws a bunch of characters and references one after another with barely anything to string them together, while I found the first one to be perfectly fine for a kids movie and enjoyed a lot of the easter eggs and references peppered throughout, this one didn't do that at all and just made it one painfully obvious reference after another. But thinking about it more I guess I'm not too surprised when two of the hosts on this episode do a monthly podcast about a Mike Judge TV show and refer to the baffling things that happen on that show as "jokes", so clearly perceptions of how to construct a cohesive narrative and what the definition of a "joke" is can vastly differ.

Dave Dalrymple

"Galaxy never made me ANGRY in the way that the first movie often did" sums up my feelings perfectly.

MENDOZABLE

How was Mario an A-hole in the first movie?

PurpleComet

Huh, I thought you guys were too harsh towards the first movie but now it seems the roles are reversed. I didn't think the first movie was good but enjoyed the easter eggs and other nostalgic elements. This time nostalgia couldn't overcome my annoyance at basically everything else. I didn't like the Illumination-style humor and how flat the characters were. Honestly you guys pointed out all the problems with it, you just landed on still liking it while I did the opposite. Like I said, roles reversed. Also, I noticed during the Mario Maker sequence Bowser Jr had a message block there, which is from Super Mario World, but he was making a level in the style of the original SMB. I hope someone got fired for that blunder /sarcasm

Jason J

Galaxy looks and sounds gorgeous and by all objective measures should be the better movie but I left the theatre feeling nothing. The first movie at least tried to have a heart but Galaxy didn’t even bother. To its credit the craft art during the credits was unique and legit cool.

Joe Hodgson

I finally saw this movie over the weekend. It was my son's birthday so we all had hamburgers and milkshakes before sitting down to take this one in. I didn't fall asleep, so I guess it exceeded my expectations. It's just "Mario References: The Movie" and it's fine. My kids seemed to like it and I have no plans to ever watch it again. While it would be nice to see a Super Mario movie that makes more of an attempt to make me think of these characters as actual characters, it's not as if any game in the series has succeeded in doing that so perhaps I shouldn't expect that of a movie.

PosiVibez4evr

I like Drew’s point in the beginning a lot. Kids movies can be incredible we don’t need to patronize them and not apply critical scrutiny to them.

Nuno Amaral

The anime section of the galaxy movie is my 4th favorite Star Fox game.