Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

It's been 11 years since the last proper Monkey Island entry, and more than three decades since series creator Ron Gilbert left Guybrush and company in the hands of others. So it goes without saying fans were more than delighted when mid-2022 saw the announcement of Return to Monkey Island, a proper sequel to 1991's Monkey Island 2—and one that somehow doesn't discount all the installments made in between. And now it's here! On this episode of Retronauts, join Bob Mackey and Nina Matsumoto as they set sail for yet another Monkey Island journey; but this time, it's to formerly uncharted waters.

Files

Comments

Mark D Myers

I'm glad monkey Island fans got a new game.

Paul

I finished it last weekend so I'll give my impressions of the ending: So obviously, SPOILERS past this point: I hate the ending. Firstly, the last puzzle in the game was the worst puzzle in the game. It didn't really make sense, a bunch of stuff about turning wheels left and right but what is left and right on a circle? And the years thing didn't seem to make sense either. There was nothing like this puzzle in the rest of the game and it seemed like you basically had to just experiment and guess. The actual ending part, I disliked a lot. The last two acts seemed like they were leading up to something and had the interesting theme of Guybrush really being kind of a villain, harming people with no regard in a reckless quest for his obsession. It showed his trail of destruction and the consequences, and people telling him he was going too far. He was basically becoming no different than lechuck. So I honestly thought the resolution would be that Guybrush needed to chill out and give up his obsession with monkey Island, and Lechuck would have his downfall from getting what he wanted. Instead the ending we got seemed both random and derivative of the second game, and made little narrative sense.

Jefklak

Yeah, the last chapter sucks, those puzzles felt arbitrary and that was the first time during the game that I lost my patience. A bummer! The ending itself takes a while to get used to, I was disappointed at first, but the more I kept thinking about it off-screen after I finished it, the more I appreciated the possibilities it creates in the player's mind.

Retronauts

Can't remember if I mentioned it on the podcast, but I thought the puzzle wheel at the end was the only not-good puzzle in the game, and I had to brute force the "date" part of the equation (which didn't take long). I liked all the puzzles with the statues, though. - Bob

Mike Mariano

I have been stuck for two weeks now endlessly wandering the Terror Island maze so I will unfortunately never hear the end of your podcast. Otherwise it’s a good game! Nina made good points regarding the close-ups and I find it very distracting to go from a conversation to Guybrush’s hand flying into a void from offscreen with some inventory item with no context. One moment where the camera worked was Guybrush in the SCUMM Bar talking to a new patron. When Guybrush began speaking the camera slowly zoomed into a two-shot instead of a full bar view. It feels weird to say Monkey Island needs a cinematographer but I think it would help!

Guybrush

I played this after playing another modern point and click game, and Return controls like a dream compared to the previous game, in terms of traversal, inventory, and interface. However the storytelling was unsatisfying and the ending felt like the creators working through their mixed feelings about the legacy of their work, leaving the fans as hapless bystanders.

Griffin

We've had a bunch of podcasts now about the Monkey Island series, but what exactly is a monkey island? Something I've learned recently when I was sent offshore: "The term “monkey island” refers to a place on the ship which is located at the top most accessible height. Technically, it is a deck located directly above the navigating bridge of the ship. It is also referred to as the flying bridge on top of a pilothouse or chart house, and also as the ship’s upper bridge. Sailors would use this place to perform solar and stellar observations. During the ancient time, when ship used to have masts and sails, the monkey island was also supposed to be located about 3/4th way up the main mast on few ships. There is no solid evidence or proof to back the origin of the term “monkey island”; however, there are a few theories that believed to be the reason behind the usage."