Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Good morning, Diamond Feit here. We're fast approaching the 30th anniversary of DOOM, id Software's infinitely replayable & reshapable first-person shooter. And as much as I'd love to spend two hours of my life talking to fellow DOOM-heads about why that game absolutely rules, the truth is Retronauts already has an episode dedicated to that topic.

What I did instead was invite Stuart Gipp and David L. Craddock onto the show for a conversation about DOOM clones, the catchall term we once used to describe the first-person shooter genre before that new identifier took over. Together we attempt to define what makes an original game a DOOM clone, highlight our favorite examples from the 1990s, and speculate as to when and why the term died. But first, we open the show by gushing about DOOM and why that game absolutely rules because of course we did.

Be sure to watch David's documentary about this perpetually popular genre called simply First Person Shooter.

Episode art from John Pading, edits by Greg Leahy. Music credits:

11:20 - Doom (PSX): Credits & Demo

20:33 - Doom (PC): Intermission from Doom

32:54 - Heretic (PC): The Graveyard

47:36 - Doom II (PC): Evil Incarnate | Duke Nukem 3D (PC): Grabbag

54:39 - Redneck Rampage (PC-CD): UFOs, Big Rigs, and BBQ

1:04:55 - Alien Trilogy (PC-CD): Derelict

1:16:58 - Blood (PC): Shipwrecked

1:29:07 - PowerSlave Exhumed: Set Arena

Closing - Doom 64: Finale

Files

Comments

Patrick McClafferty

Think the first FPS I played were the first person segments of Jurassic Park SNES...didn't have a PC til the following year and played shareware of Wolfenstein and Doom around that time.

Michael Castleberry

I played Wolfenstein and Spear of Destiny before Doom, but man that changed the game. I had a demo for Blood that was in some magazine i bought back in the day and played that a lot.

Matthew Donnelley

Great episode as always. HOWEVER!!! How do you all talk for so long about DOOM clones and no one mentions Serious Sam even once?! Oof. L.

Jefklak

Was hoping to hear some DUSK love

Nat

One Doom clone that I remember fondly was Chex Quest. My parents didn’t let me get video games with any sort of violence, so most Doom clones were a no go. Chex Quest allowed me to get a similar experience without the blood and guts. Plus, it was part of a balanced breakfast!

Michael Castleberry

Surprised Dark Forces didn't come up since the first one was basically "Star Wars Doom". Also loved Outlaws, also from LucasArts for that old west setting that was rare at the time.

WARIODROME

Late to the game but I really loved this one... Stuart+Diamond is always the best combo

Philip Renshaw

If you start off at freezing point and you keep adding degrees when does 'cold' turn into 'mild' which then turns into 'hot'? That's how I feel about Doom Clones. Heretic, Hexen, Quake, Dark Forces, Marathon, Duke Nukem all added their own little spin on the formula but by the time Half-Life comes around that's when all these changes added together into something that was almost unrecognizable from Doom IMO. Ultimately while many of these games are great in their own right, I don't think any of them really did Doom as well as 'Doom' did. At high levels of play its almost like a choreographed dance with the sense of speed you have and the wide variety of enemy types that force you to prioritize which you need to go after first and with what weapon. I don't think any game till this day has really captured that feeling for me. For anyone who wants to pay Doom in 2023 GZDoom is a great choice if you want a more modern experience. If you want to experience Doom as it felt like in 1993 I would suggest tracking down the source port of Crispy Doom. Its a great way to play the game as you remember it from your child hood with a few QOL updates to make it playable for 2023 standards.

Cajun Baz

I can't believe there was no mention of Redneck Rampage, which is definitely a Doom clone. The developers later made Return to Castle Wolfenstein and COD: United Offense. I'm hoping Microsoft will do something with this dormant IP.

Cajun Baz

My bad. I was probably doused in moonshine by the 50 minute mark.