Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Tim sat in the garage a little longer than he needed to. The engine was off, the keys were still in his hand as he stared past the windshield. 

He had told her to go. He had meant it when he said it. But that was not the part that sat wrong in his chest. The part sitting wrong was walking into his own house and not knowing what the first words to Natalie would be.

Asking if it went well sounded stupid. Asking about Bill sounded worse. Tim rubbed his face once and let out a heavy sigh. He tried to remember that whatever had happened in the bedroom stayed there as they promised. Knowing the details would only make things even weirder. He finally got out of the car and went inside with unsure steps. 

The house smelled like garlic and butter, and he could hear Natalie’s familiar soft humming from one of those songs she always lost the words halfway through, coming from the kitchen. 

Natalie stood at the stove in one of his old shirts and a pair of sleeping shorts. Her blonde hair was damp from the shower, darker at the ends and still clinging in place around her neck. No glasses yet. Steam fogged the window over the sink as she tapped a wooden spoon over the edge of the pan. She looked like she did any other night, as if their unorthodox arrangement never happened. 

She glanced over her shoulder when she heard the garage door shut.

“Hey, you. Perfect timing.”

Tim set his bag down by the wall and took off his shoes. “Hey.”

She turned the burner off and crossed the kitchen barefoot. Her arms wrapped around his neck first. He caught her by the waist, like he always did. Her shirt was warm from the stove. She smelled like her vanilla-scented soap. Clean. Warm. He couldn't detect anything from what had happened earlier. When she kissed him, it was the same kiss she always gave him after work. Soft and familiar. Maybe it lasted a second longer than usual. 

He kissed her back, melting into her loving embrace.

When they pulled apart, she tipped her head and looked at his face the way she did when she read him without making a speech out of it. 

“You okay?” she asked with a calm smile.

“Er, yeah.” He cleared his throat. “Yeah… long day. That’s all.”

“Mm.” She didn’t want to push. She squeezed his sides once and went back to the pan. “Sit. It’s almost done. I made the pasta you like.”

Tim pulled out a chair at the island and sat. He watched her stir. He watched the damp hair stick to the back of her neck. He watched her shift her weight from one foot to the other as she tasted the sauce off the spoon. He watched her hum again like the afternoon had not happened. 

He wanted to ask. But he also wanted to leave it alone. 

Natalie plated the food and set his bowl in front of him, then sat across from him with hers. She reached for her glasses on the counter and slid them on, pushing them up with her thumb the way she always did, a few loose strands of her hair falling around the frames.

They ate quietly for a bit, simply enjoying each other's company. The sounds of forks against bowls and the fridge kicking on filled the quiet between them. Natalie seemed as calm and unbothered as ever, but not Tim. He kept sneaking glances at her as if trying to spot any evidence of what she did earlier that day.

“You’re staring again,” she finally said, mid-bite. 

Tim quickly blinked to focus and let out a short breath that was almost a laugh. “Oh, uh. Sorry. I’m not trying to.”

“Don’t be sorry.” She twirled pasta around her fork and took another bite. “I figured you’d be thinking about it all day.”

He poked at his food. “I don’t even know what I’m supposed to say. I know I agreed to this, but I never really thought about what happens after. Well, at least how to approach it with you afterward.”

Natalie watched him carefully over her glasses before setting her fork down. 

“Do you want to know?” she said simply, her voice calm and mindful. 

Tim caught her gaze. His mouth opened, then closed. He shook his head.

“What? No,” he replied immediately. It came out firmer than he meant. He took a quick bite and swallowed before trying again, a bit quieter. “I don’t. I told you I didn’t need to know the details. That’s your business, not mine.”

Her mouth twitched into a small grin. That little spark he knew too well. “Not even a little?” Natalie teased, leaning forward and resting her chin on her hand. 

“Nat, please,” Tim groaned, but it lacked any real edge. 

“What? I’m just asking.” She picked her fork back up, looking all innocent, except she was not. “You keep looking at me like the answer is sitting on my face.”

Tim rolled his eyes and stabbed his pasta. “Zip it. Let’s just enjoy this nice dinner you made for us. Let a man unwind from working all day.”

Natalie hummed, pleased with herself, and took another bite. “Okay, okay. Dinner first.”

He shook his head once, fighting the smile that wanted to show up anyway when Natalie was up to her ribbing antics, and they ate. 

Later that night, the house had gone quiet as they settled into bed together. The bedroom was dark except for a thin strip of moonlight peering from the curtains. Tim lay on his back while Natalie tucked herself against his side, one leg hooked over his, her hair loose on his shoulder. 

He stared at the ceiling blankly, his mind still trying to process everything that had happened. 

Natalie shifted beside him, lazily tracing her fingers on his shirt. 

“You’re still awake,” she murmured, tipping her face toward him in the dark. 

“Hm? Oh, uh, yeah,” Tim said, glancing over to her. 

“You’re thinking pretty loud.” She tapped his chest once with two fingers and kept her hand there. “Do you… want to know?”

The same question from dinner again. Closer now and nowhere to hide. He was quiet enough that she probably thought he would shut it down again. Then he swallowed hard and took a deep, composing breath. 

“I uh… A little?” he finally answered, eyes turning back to the ceiling. “But not everything. No details. I mean it.”

Natalie hummed warmly and slid up until her chin rested on his chest. Her hair spilled softly over his shirt, and she smiled. “Okay. Go for it.”

Tim’s hand found her back and stayed there. “Again, I don’t want the details. None of that stuff. I don’t want to sound like a perv or anything… I just…” He took another deep breath. “Did… Did it go well?”

She thought about it for a moment, then simply nodded against him. 

“Yeah,” she answered smoothly. Then that little spark crept in, and she patted his chest again. “Well enough that I still made you dinner after. You’re welcome.”

Tim groaned and rested his head back into the pillow. “Jesus, Nat. I’m not sure that’s any better.”

She giggled, not mean, just pleased with herself. “What? You asked. I kept it clean as you requested, my good dear sir.”

“That definitely didn’t sound clean at all,” he replied dryly. 

He shook his head, though he fought a smile he didn’t want to admit was there. His arm tightened around her anyway. “Okay. That was all I needed to know.”

Natalie went still against him. Her fingers had stopped moving as she continued to search his face in the dark. “Tim,” she began, her voice losing its teasing edge and softening. 

“Yeah?”

“Do you regret this?” she continued quietly. She kept going before he could fumble it. “Because I will end it. Right now. I’ll tell Bill it’s done, and we never talk about this again if that’s what you want.” Her hand flattened over his shirt. “I mean it. Just say the word.”

Tim stared at the ceiling a little longer. His hand found the back of her head, then slid over her shoulder before finally speaking his mind. “No… I don’t regret it.” 

Natalie didn’t move. She just waited for the rest of his answer. 

“This is just for you,” he said, his voice careful but sure. “That’s the whole point of this arrangement we agreed upon. I can’t give you what you get from him in the arrangement. I know I can’t. So if this is what you need, then no. I don’t want to stop you just because I’m sitting here overthinking myself to death. I’ll get used to it eventually. So don’t feel guilty about it. This is all for you.”

She let out a small, assured breath, feeling a weight lift from her shoulders. “Okay.” Her arm tightened around him. “I just needed to hear you say it. That’s all. Thank you, Tim. Thank you for letting me have this. Love you.”

“Yeah,” he hummed as he kissed her hair. “I love you too.”

They stayed like that for a while. The house was quiet. Her familiar weight was warm against him. The question was answered, even if his mind still hadn’t fully caught up. But he could sleep a little easier knowing that his wife was happy. 

Almost a week had gone by since Natalie’s first time with Bill. 

Nothing major had happened beyond that. No second planned visit. No late texts while they were on the couch together. On the surface, things settled into their normal rhythm. Work. Dishes. The same shows and cute little dates to enjoy each other’s company. Natalie still stole his shirts, and Tim still kissed her cheek every morning before they got out of bed. 

She seemed better. Not in an obvious way. Just looser in her shoulders and very easy to please. She laughed and hummed more often than not; that tight little edge she didn’t know she was used to carrying around after a long stretch of quiet nights wasn’t sitting on her as heavily. Tim noticed, of course. He would be lying if he didn’t. ‘

He almost forgot it had even happened too. 

Not completely. It still crossed his mind now and then when she came out of the shower or when her phone lit up. But the thought didn’t twist his stomach the way it had that first evening. She was home and happy. That made it easier to leave the rest behind. 

One Friday night, they ended up on the couch like usual to wind down. Some rerun neither of them was really watching played in the background. Natalie’s feet were in his lap, her glasses on and her hair tied in a loose bun that was already falling apart. Tim rubbed his thumb along her ankle without thinking as he dozed.

“The garden’s actually starting to look decent,” she said casually, eyes on the TV. “For once. We got the last of those planter boxes replaced today. I thought we’d never get that done.”

“Yeah?” Tim responded while keeping his eyes on the screen. “The ones that were rotting?”

“Mhm. Took forever.” She shifted, getting more comfortable on the couch. “Bill stayed after to help me finish. He’s good with that woodwork stuff. He’s stronger than he looks, too. I had him hauling those boxes for almost an hour.”

Tim’s thumb paused on her ankle. The mere mention of Bill’s name brought back the whole arrangement to mind. 

“Right… Bill,” he trailed off, then tried again, sneaking a glance at Natalie. “Is he… Has he, well…”

Natalie looked over her glasses at him, that teasing spark already flaring. “Hm? No,” she quickly answered, certain. “He hasn’t. Not yet, at least.”

Tim glanced at her again, a bit unsure how to react. 

She shrugged nonchalantly, poking his stomach with her toes. “I can tell he wants to again. I’m pretty sure he’s still a bit conscious about the whole fucking another man’s wife thing. That’s the sign of a good guy. I chose well.”

Tim let out a long groan and tipped his head back against the couch. “God, Nat. Why do you always have to put it like that?”

“What?” She grinned, all innocent except she was not. “You asked.”

“I did not ask you to say it like that. I never do, but you do it anyway.”

“Hey, you started it,” she chuckled, wiggling her toes against his hand. “Relax, babe. I told you. Nothing’s happened since. Oh, and he asked how you were, by the way. I told him you were good.”

Tim huffed, shaking his head, and squeezed her ankle. “You’re impossible.”

“You knew that, and yet, here you are,” Natalie playfully shot back and let her head rest against the couch. “Anyway… the tomatoes might actually survive this year. Miracle. I was almost about to give up on those.”

He looked at her and relaxed a bit more. Talking about dirt, tomatoes, and Billi like it was just part of the week felt strange given what he knew. His body reflected that he was still unsure how to react. The knot in his stomach kept tightening and then easing off. 

“Good,” Tim replied. “I’m looking forward to trying some of those tomatoes one day.”

She grinned and turned the volume up a little. “Watch the show.”

He did. Or at least he tried to. Her feet stayed in his lap, warm and familiar, and for the rest of the episode, he almost forgot again. 

One day, the storage room at the community center was a particular mess. 

Natalie stood on her toes to shove a bin of craft supplies onto a high shelf, glasses slipping down her nose. Bill handled the heavier stuff. Folding chairs. A crate of donated balls. He kept glancing at Natalie like he was taking inventory of her instead of the room. 

“You’re staring, Bill,” she said, glancing at him out of the corner of her eye as she pushed a bin into place. 

Bill caught himself and huffed, setting the crate down. “I’m making sure you don’t fall on your face,” he replied, chuckling.

“Uh-huh. Sure you are.” She pushed her glasses up with her thumb and turned, leaning her hip against the shelf. “That’s very professional of you.”

“I can be professional,” he muttered.

“You can try. But those eyes are definitely giving off something else,” she shot back with a teasing smile. 

The air between them had a charge that had been lingering there ever since the first time they had sex. It wasn’t loud. Just there. The gym door was half open—voices far off, and nobody close enough to listen in on their conversation. Natalie felt the charge in her stomach. There was a warm little pull she had been pretending was just left over from last week. 

Bill wiped his hands on his jeans and nodded at the stack of mats behind her. “Those next?”

“Yeah. Please,” she said, stepping aside so he could grab them. She watched the way his arms took the weight. Stronger than he looked. She had already told Tim that. The thought of Tim flickered through her mind, but didn’t stay. 

They worked for a little longer, bantering again, but the tension remained.

“Are you always this bossy after lunch?” Bill asked, sliding a mat into place.

Natalie smirked. “Only with people who listen.”

“Hm, a dangerous combination,” he murmured back. 

“Don’t give me that. You like it.”

He looked at her then. Really looked. He held his amused grin, but his voice dropped. “Yeah,” he said, eyes locking with hers. “I do.”

Natalie felt her ears go warm as she busied herself with a box of jump ropes that didn’t really need organizing. Her heart fluttered with a thrill that made her aroused. She had been wondering when he’d try to make the next move.

Bill cleared his throat and continued, “I’ve been thinking about us… If we’re going to keep doing this.”

Natalie glanced over her glasses, that playful spark already showing. “Keep doing it?” she repeated with an amused chuckle. “We did it once, hotshot, and it was fun. Don’t get ahead of yourself.”

Bill let out a laughing exhale, rubbing the back of his neck. “Once. Right. That’s what I mean… I was wondering if there’s ever a next time… Are you open to that, or was it just the one time?”

She let the box rest against her hip. “Go on.”

“This is a first for me,” he said a bit quieter now. “But I’d like to keep seeing you. Something like an affair, I guess…” He paused, running his hands down his face as he realized what he said. “Wow, that sounds worse now that I said it out loud. Augh, I haven’t done anything like this before, sorry.”

Natalie tilted her head to the side, watching him with clear intrigue. “An affair,” she said, as if testing the word out. “That’s the word you’re going with?”

“Well, what else would you call it?” he asked.

She shrugged, smiling a little. “I don’t know. That’s why I’m asking. You mean sneaking around? Secret meetings behind my husband’s back? You want me coming over when nobody’s looking?”

Bill swallowed anxiously. “I mean… yeah. That’s what we would be doing if we were to continue this.”

“And you think you can handle that?” she asked, poking at it now. “You’re standing here looking like you might pass out just saying it.”

Bill let out a rough breath and rubbed the back of his neck again. “I can handle it,” he answered. “I’m just not trying to pretend this is something smaller than it is.”

Natalie kept her eyes on him, her heart racing. “Okay,” she said. “So say it.”

He looked at her, eyes wide as he composed himself. The gym noise stayed far away on the other side of the half-open door.

“Alright. Do you want this?” he inquired firmly, officially proposing his offer to her. “An affair. You and me. And are you okay with cheating on your husband? Because I need to hear that from you, Nat. Not the joke version.”

The word sat between them. Cheating. She felt it land lower than she expected. Not in her chest first. Lower. A warm, traitorous pulse that made her press her thighs together behind the box. Even with Tim in on it all, letting her have this relationship with Bill, the thrilling fantasy was more than enticing.

Natalie set the box down on the shelf. “Tim’s good to me,” she said softly. “He’s the best thing I have. That doesn’t change.”

Bill’s mouth tightened. “That’s not what I asked.”

“I know what you asked.” She pushed her glasses up with her thumb, then let her hand fall to her side. “I’m okay. I wouldn’t be standing here if I wasn’t.” She paused, smiling as she leaned further into this little fantasy. “I’m willing to keep doing it if that’s the answer you were looking for.”

He searched her face like he was waiting for her to get cold feet and take it back. She didn’t.

Natalie nodded once. “So… now that we’re going to have an affair, I suppose we should set up another meeting soon, shall we? What about after my shift tomorrow? Sound good?”

Bill’s shoulders dropped a little. Relieved but still nervous. It was almost surprising how willing she was, knowing how well she spoke of her husband. Perhaps something was clearly lacking in her marriage that she sought elsewhere. It stroked his ego to theorize what that reason could be. But that didn’t really matter to him. He got the answer he desired.

“Okay then. Sounds good. Tomorrow then,” he murmured, his voice lifting with satisfaction. “Of course, I’ll be careful. No one here finds out. I mean that.”

“Hm, I know you do,” she replied cheerfully. “Wouldn’t want to ruin what we have going on, would we?”

The wet heat between her legs had not gone anywhere. If anything, hearing him make his intentions with her clear made it worse. She shifted her weight and reached for another bin she did not need, just to have something in her hands. 

“Help me finish this,” Natalie added, glancing toward the door. “Before somebody walks in and wonders why you look like you just committed a crime.”

Bill shook his head and let out a weak laugh as he moved in beside her, close enough that she could smell the outside air on his shirt. Close enough that the tension made it almost impossible to ignore.

“Yes, ma’am,” he answered dutifully. 

Natalie smirked at the shelf, her cheeks slightly flushed, and did not look at him when she answered. “You’ll have me all to yourself tomorrow, hotshot. Try not to act up before then.”

Comments

No comments found for this post.