Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Help me pick a sci-fi show!

  • Andor (Season 1) 686
  • Star Trek: The Original Series (Season 1) 97
  • The Expanse (Season 1) 303
  • Star Wars: The Clone Wars (Season 1) 181
  • 2025-05-27
  • 1267 votes
{'title': 'Help me pick a sci-fi show! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Andor (Season 1)', 'votes': 686}, {'text': 'Star Trek: The Original Series (Season 1)', 'votes': 97}, {'text': 'The Expanse (Season 1)', 'votes': 303}, {'text': 'Star Wars: The Clone Wars (Season 1)', 'votes': 181}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 5, 27, 15, 12, 11, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1267}

Content

Hey folks! It's time to start a new show! For this poll, I'm sticking to sci-fi shows only. Once I wrap up Severance, I'll post another series poll that covers other genres. So if sci-fi's not your thing, that poll will be coming soon.

Decided to throw 2 Star Wars shows in here haha. I guess I'm just in the mood for it! Also, only listing Season 1 for each series to start. If I enjoy the show, I'll likely continue with it, but don't want to commit to something too early as some of these shows are longggg (cough CLONE WARS cough, cough).

Looking forward to seeing what wins!

Comments

Joshua King

THE EXPANSE IS FINALLY IN A POLL!!!

Thomas Wetherell

How dare anyone dare pick something other than The Expanse.

Ridley

Oh my god Clone Wars made it to a natalie poll!! 😲

KeithJ

Praying for The Expanse. 🚀

Elias Deuss

Andor and The Expanse on the same list 😭, what to choose

Joshua King

Nat if you see this The Expanse is literally the best sci fi show of all time I BEG

Andy

Please please please let Andor win people! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Geoffrey T. Blackwell

I love Andor but *everyone* is reacting to it right now. I get that the algorithm gods must be appeased but please please please do The Expanse!

Ian

Oh my andor and clone wars this is a hard choice….

Essero Eson

I like how this poll pulls from the Matrix and gives an illusion of choice.

Ridley

Clone Wars would be the best era of Natalie golds reactions 😭 ✨️

Steven Hok

Damn, I love Star Wars and Andor is definitely amazing. But gonna have to go with The Expanse

—thoughtstorms—keith—

I agree with my namesake! It actually took me three tries to get started on the Expanse. But it has become a show i've really come to love intensely!

Danishprince

Tried so many times to get through Clone Wars but man is it sluggish with abysmal animation. Just can't bring myself to spend so much time on it

David Weinstein

Just gonna chime in once again with Babylon 5. If you want to meet the granddaddy of modern sci fi storytelling, that's it.

Andy

My 2 cents: Clone Wars is a bad choice unless you're committed to getting through all 7 seasons/ 133 episodes. Season 1 is fine, but not great. It really picks up only after season 3.

Jo

Andor was perfection but The Expanse is one of my favorite shows. Either way can't really go wrong.

Nightowl

I just want to take the opportunity to remind people that Babylon 5 exists, arguably one of the best sci-fi shows ever produced and my personal number one.

next_gen17

It was over when Andor was one of the shows

RustafanX

Voted for The Expanse, since I have not seen it myself, and have heard so much good about it! But I am not mad about rewatching Andor :)

Daniel Green

Andor may be a good show in technical sense, but it will bore the shit out of Natalie. Don’t force her to watch something she won’t enjoy.

Razor Bikini

Why on earth would you think this??

Razor Bikini

Very funny how everyone is like “oh of course Andor is winning” as if it hasn’t lost 57 polls on this channel at this point.

Danny Steele

I know the Clone Wars is a great commitment, and some of it is mediocre. It adds so much and is so loved by the fans that it has basically a much see if you want to understand Star Wars. Many of members of the Lucasfilm Story Group( the group that ACTUALLY makes story decisions for Star Wars) first came together to work on the Clone Wars series under George Lucas himself. From Clone Wars, you get both The Bad Batch and Rebels, both series that you should check out

Edward Rahardjo

Tough choice. Andor is peak Star Wars. But The Expanse is peak sci-fi. Hope both make it

KeithJ

The Expanse was the best hard sci-fi series on TV in years. If you liked Ron Moore's Battlestar Galactica, you'll enjoy The Expanse. It's the spiritual heir to BSG.

Michael MacDonagh

The Orville is great, if you wanted a mix of sci fi and comedy

Gregg

I voted for The Expanse. Best Sci-fi show I have seen

Slick447

Is Andor not seen as one of the best Star Wars projects of the modern era? You think she's put off by good television?

eemersonm

Andor or Expanse please!!!!

Sam Kimpton

Indeed. Babylon 5 paved the way for modern American television. It was the first show to have a planned 5-year story arc. Prior to this show, no American TV show featured a continuing story that evolved from episode to episode because the networks didn't think people would consistently tune in every week. Babylon 5 proved them wrong.

Jimathai

Would have voted for Clone Wars, but I just finished a rewatch, plus thats a huge commitment. And if you are up to that level of commitment I would rather you do The 100. The best worst show ever.

Max

The Expanse is an exceptionally good show. It gets my vote. I've heard good things about Andor, but I haven't seen it.

Jenny Chalek

Andor is by far the best Star Wars there is apart from the movie Rogue One. Clone Wars is EXCELLENT, but I doubt you'd do all the seasons, so what's the point?

wb

Would have voted clone wars but s1 was kinda weak and the best way to watch is in chronological episode ordering not release ordering

Powers209

I needed a break from disney after Boba Fatt. That show killed the fan in me. I canceled Dplus after Boba Fatt episode 3. I think the Expense is great TV. Maybe I'll get lucky and Nat will throw me a bone by watching Kelly's Heroes or Fun with Dick and Jane with Jane Fonda to break up so much disney.

mojo shivers

The rest of the shows are good and great television, but Andor is like a masterpiece of writing, direction, and performance especially when viewed as a whole. Season 2 really brought home how the whole show was put together as one vision instead of separate episodes.

Arthur Bridges

There is some backstory in Clone Wars and Rebels for Andor, but that won't make a difference in the viewing.

Mastervodo

I am happy Andor is getting a chance to shine, and all those Nattie fans who have been disappointed with Andor losing for literally YEARS now will have their opportunity! I think if you read a lot of the comments for people who have seen the Expanse and Andor both, the consensus is that Andor is good Star Wars, but The Expanse is better Sci-Fi. I concur! Not sad Andor is winning, but I do hope Natalie gets a chance to do the Expanse.

Mike Hell

Man, I am pulling for Expanse but I think this might finally be Andor's time to shine. I haven't seen it, but heard great things so I won't be too upset if it beats out the Rocinante crew.

Adam McCabe

I love The Expanse so much but Andor is just so good

Bobby B

Damn having to pick between Andor and Clone Wars. Though I’ve got to admit I’d be voting for Clone wars to hope for the progression to the really cool stuff later on including eventual covering Rebels.

Bobby B

I hope Nat eventually gets on to the Star Wars animated stuff since it does have legitimately great stuff

FW27

Clone Wars is awesome, but definitely way too long and has some blemishes that could be frustrating. Idk if it’s worth starting.

Nick Freer

The Expense do it for da Belt !!!

Joel

Andor is incredible! You may want to revisit your Rogue One reaction before Andor just to refresh your memory, I had only seen it once in theatres and kind of forgot Andor’s whole character when I started the show

Berry

Andor is fantastic, second season (after a shaky start) continued the winning streak too. The Expanse is also good, I thought season 4 was a little weak, but the rest is great. And even though at heart I'm a Trekkie, I can't recommend Star Trek the OG series. It's just too slow, dated and long. Maybe watch the old (or the newish) movies, you don't really need all the expanded backstory from the series, its not that hard. I've never seen Clone Wars and I don't think I ever will.

Berry

It helps that the second season is also good, that made more people pay attention. We forget sometimes, but even the objectively great first season of Game of Thrones was only moderately well watched. It only gained momentum by the second season and then ofc it went ballistic.

Berry

Ooh, good call! Murderbot is hilarious and the episodes are only 30 minutes. I even started reading the books because I'm impatient like that :D

Josh G

Star Trek TOS would be fun if just watching the good episodes. Same thing with Clone Wars, just watch the good, canon episodes and cut out the filler.

Daniel Green

Because, whilst it’s a good show as a political/espionage drama, non Star Wars fans will be bored to death by it. It’s slow and, at times, tedious. Unless you’re a Star Wars fan you’ll be bored with it.

Albiezushi

True but Star Trek should be prerequisite to fully get the humor though kinda like with Galaxy Quest

Darryl Low

Happy Wednesday Nat. Wasn't a big fan of Andor so going to vote for some classic Trek this time around. Have an awesome day 💛

Daniel McGuinness

AFTER SO MUCH GIVING I FINALLY GET TO RECIEVEEEE!! CLONE WARS ON A POLL! Third place BUT it’s progress! Funny thing to remember about Clone Wars is that the first few season aired out of order, kind of like an anthology, and only around season 3 did it start to get more linear. But they all connect if you jumble the order around a little lol Nat, I’d be happy to send you some watchlists for the show that A) Put the episodes in chronological order, and B) cut out some filler to make it an easier watch. Episodes are only around 30 mins so we could even squeeze in 2 a day like Avatar if you wanted :) Andor is good, but Clone Wars kept Star Wars alive! Some of the arcs on that show are genuinely amazing. Probably the most important show to watch if you wanna jump into Star Wars and actually ENJOY it again 🥹 next poll, i believe

Albiezushi

If she doesn't do Andor now, she never will🤞

Daniel McGuinness

Season 1 animation is definitely noticeable on the budget, but it gets better. And honestly Clone Wars is probably my favourite animation style ever - and I think a clear inspiration for the Arcane art style

OldschoolDOS

Farscape would be a good time

Brian Leonard

I went Star Trek. However, the correct answer for me is For All Mankind. I also would be interested in Babylon 5 or Battlestar Galactica.

Zeke390

The Expanse & then later And or vice versa. I'd love to watch both of them with you 😀

Brian Leonard

Is Star Wars science-fiction? I always saw it as a medieval fantasy masquerading as science fiction. I think it is more like Lord of the Rings than Star Trek.

Gavinmc

There are two scenes in Andor season 1 that I wish I could see again for the first time: I will envy you at those times

Kelvin

It’s a sci-fi/fantasy blend I think, like warhammer

Crispy

Black Mirror!

Giancarlo Ubaldino

Really torn between Andor and The Expanse, both are phenomenal shows, but ended up voting for Andor. Please continue putting The Expanse in polls, though.

Giancarlo Ubaldino

IMO hold off on rewatching Rogue One until after watching Andor.

Giancarlo Ubaldino

Agreed, The Expanse is the best sci-fi show since Battlestar Galactica.

George Roybal

Andore is not only the best Star Wars shows ever, but just an outstanding show. The story, the acting, the cinematography are peak in every way. Season 2 was top 5 in viewership throught the show. Also, 23 Emmy nominations on the way.

Cameron

Why does no one ever watch The Expanse? Top tier sci-fi.

Jacob Rodriguez

I really love Star Wars the Clone Wars but it is definitely a commitment and has a bit more of a complicated watch order for new people to get hooked on it, because there are definitely some episodes in season one that aren’t very good. The Clone Wars does have some really good Arcs and introduces and builds upon so many cool characters.

Thomas Richter

The Expanse is so good. Star Wars I don't really consider sci-fi because its really fantasy. It starts with a long time ago in a kingdom far away.

Thomas Richter

Andor is good, just not the right category is all.

kevin dale

She will appreciate Andor the most, so let her watch it! It’s the highest quality show on the list that connects the most emotionally as well.

kevin dale

I mean, Star Wars the movie was made for children too lol. What a weird comment. Some Clone Wars episodes are simpler than others but many talk about politics and military strategy and go to dark places that a lot of kids just tune out of. Clone Wars is a show that definitely gets better and grows as the episode count does.

kevin dale

I have a feeling this list was made because of Andor, since everyone is talking about it and reacting to it now. And she needed to at least make it seem like a choice by putting a few other series that take place in space too lol. I think it’s fine though. Andor is the pure definition of what Science Fiction is, in the literary sense.

Thomas Richter

There is no science in Star Wars. Its all magic mumbo jumbo (the force) science and technology are not really important to the story. So in the literally sense I don't consider Anything Star Wars Science Fiction. Even though I really like Star Wars.

Nick Luce

The expanse is so much better

Nick Luce

Bruh Star Wars slop over the Expanse is crazy

Andy

I’m so glad Andor is locked in for a win. Might I suggest doing it in batches of 3 episodes. They are narratively structured that way, you get the most bang for your buck reacting that way. Plus you can finish it quicker that way too, and then give the expanse a try.

Razor Bikini

Could not disagree with you more. It’s the only Star Wars show that is worth watching if you’re not a fan.

jamie jones

Andor is way better than the expanse

jamie jones

I dont think you understand what science fiction is Thomas. Star wars is 100% science fiction.

jamie jones

Break up so much disney? What disney? She’s been doing severance and the last of us.

Delaney Novo

Yellowjackets is a great show for future polls!

jamie jones

Daniel, natalie does like star wars. And maybe YOU find it boring but i watched the show with many non star wars fans and everyone seems to like it. You could not be more wrong

Thomas Richter

Its right there in the name, science. There is absolutely no science in star wars. Its pure fantasy. There is no shame in that, I'm not trying to make star wars feel bad but it's just not science fiction at all. Star Wars lacks one of the staples of science fiction, which is the science element. Star Wars is heavily based in spiritual and religious concepts, for example the Force and the Jedi, as well as the Sith, with a mythical twist. There are more of these elements as opposed to what can be understood as real-world, science-based ones. This isn't to say that a series like Star Trek is more accurate in its physics, mechanics etc., but rather that these sci-fi properties do not go the same direction as Star Wars when crafting their universes. Fantasy take up the spotlight and acts as the main narrative thread of the saga, not necessarily the politics or war that takes a backseat

Mike Hell

Them's fightin' words, buddy. I'm going to give Andor a shot since I've heard it's good even for SW, but don't come at The Expanse unprovoked like that, because I Am That Guy.

Ulrich Unterbrunner

You are comparing science fantasy with actual science fiction. They both fly in their own classes, that aren't even competing with each other.

Eric Janssen

Star Trek: TOS. The Bible of Starfleet. To quote Movie 1’s tagline, There Is No Comparison. 😎

Rey

2nd this!

Rey

Shouts "black mirror" into the void!

nitind

It's such a slow deliberate burn, I can't see it working otherwise.

Chris Lane

Andor is one of the best shows in TV history, Star Wars or not

Rod Reavern

Sophie's Choice... but with 4 children. I voted for "Andor: Season 1" because it's the most recent and "topical" since Season 2 (NO SPOILERS) wrapped up a couple of weeks ago. The only issue with "Andor" is that it's a slow burn, but with incredibly satisfying payoffs. It elevates Star Wars from the sci-fi/fantasy space opera popcorn flick category (which I love) to a top-tier sci-fi/drama. I'm confident Natalie will enjoy it... although she needs to watch it Season 2-style in 3-episode arcs. I suppose her reaction videos can be released as single episodes, but it's best to watch each arc in one sitting. (TBH, it was a struggle watching the first season week-to-week.) "The Expanse" is an incredible series. Objectively, the most realistic sci-fi series I've ever watched, but with tense action, genuine drama and intrigue too. "Star Wars: The Clone Wars" is excellent OVERALL, but there are numerous episodes that can and should be skipped (all the Jar-Jar episodes, the Droids eps, arguably most of the Padme eps, plenty of others). The best part of the CG animated series is the character arc of Ahsoka Tano, who was justifiably HATED in The Clone Wars movie because David Filoni deliberately wrote her with character flaws, which were masterfully resolved over the course of the series. Ahsoka is the antithesis of all the insufferable girlbosses Disney and Kathleen Kennedy have created since they bought Star Wars. Ahsoka's character started as youthful, sassy, and reckless, but at a reasonable power and skill level; she wasn't flawless and OP. Specific episodes addressed each of her character flaws, and there was continuity to her character development. By the time of the trial arc and the series finale, Ahsoka had EARNED her place as a fan favourite, and you believed she could and would do everything she did. The final two episodes were the most tense and emotional of the entire series, and I'm certain that Natalie will appreciate the long journey to reach the pinnacle of "The Clone Wars." The only issue is that I don't think there's any way to avoid watching the terrible Clone Wars CG animated film, as it introduced Ahsoka. Maybe there's an abridged cut on YouTube that covers her introduction, and that'll be enough. "Star Trek TOS" is Star Trek. I grew up with TNG; I couldn't stand TOS at the time, but gave it another chance more recently and grew to appreciate it, mostly. TOS is really old school with 3 seasons that range from 24 to 29 episodes long. IF Natalie eventually watches TOS, I suggest she do it similar to how Cassie from Popcorn In Bed did: Let Patreon members vote on the best 4-6 episodes per season, which best represent the series and are relevant to the films -- which I assume she'd watch next.

Matt

You should watch Andor 3 episodes at a time, each set of 3 is like a chapter

Matt

The Expanse is way better than every other Star Wars show except Andor

Wild_Lee_Coyote

Surprised Babylon 5 isn’t in this list. It may be old but its storytelling is exceptionally good. It made Sci-fi what it is today. It also has some of the best character arcs in cinema.

Jacob King

Voted for The Expanse. I’m not a Trek/Wars kind of person. I’d recommend DEVS or Orphan Black as fitting follow-ups to Severance but The Expanse has some good mysteries and space stuff going on.

Stack Pack

Hey Nat I don’t know if you’ve seen Battlestar (2004) but that would be my choice. Out of the four I’d pick the Expanse but I’d suggest watching BSG before that

jamie jones

Science fiction doesnt mean lets have science class, its futuristic/unrealistic/fictional technology changing they way society functions, such as space ships, blasters, aliens, hyperspace travel and so on. Star wars is science fiction.

Daniel Green

What do you want me to do? Change my opinion to be the same as yours so your opinion feels more validated? It’s a good political/espionage show, but as a Star Wars show it’s not in the spirit or the tone of what a Star Wars show should be. Nat will find it boring. And I’m not “wrong”… it’s called an opinion. If you like it, good luck to you. I don’t.

Noctis

I think she put it on a poll once, unfortunately it lost. I agree BSG is a must see.

Thomas Richter

Science fiction is exactly that, a future or present alternative timeline base on the reality where some fictional thing occoured that change the reality socioeconomic or technologically in some way. All other sci-fi are like that except Star Wars which is in no way shape or form based on any reality where the earth exists in any way shape or form. Is pure fantasy. With a chosen one warrior that has to travel through the realm to save the princess from pure evil. Shape or form

Daniel McGuinness

I know people are gonna be tired of Star Wars after Andor, but I hope to see Clone Wars on another animated/longform show poll soon 🙏🏻 There really is some fantastic stories there, and the characterisation of the clones is so good 😭 sure we gotta wade through some of the guff like the animated movie, but it introduces Ahsoka - maybe the most beloved new Star Wars characters ever

Tesh

i also HIGHLY recommend Foundation, its based of the book series by Isaac Asimov and its so good, much grander scale than most scifi, manages a good balance of personal issues with grand scale issues, it also has some incredibly unique concepts i think you would really enjoy.

Joel

I guess where I’m coming from is that the final season has arcs and moments that directly reference Rogue One and the creator made the show with the assumption that the viewer knows what’s coming, hence the choices he makes in the writing. I’m not saying she should do a full rewatch yet, just refamiliarize herself with the characters that appear in Rogue One.

Daniel Vezina

Ok, so a story about space ship and space travel is not sci-fy, it's fantasy, ok. Thanks for the definition.

Thomas Richter

Exactly. The same way that Reign of Fire is a (2002) Post-Apocalyptic Science Fiction Action film with dragons and no spaceships. But its based on a reality where dragons are scientifically viable and they dominate the earth. The venue does not make the type of movie, but the story and content. Wall-e is science fiction. Because its earth and humanity in the future. Star wars have no humans, no earth not our future or passed in any way

Snacky Munchies

This is tough, as I like all four! My vote would go to The Expanse Season 1. It had such a strong start and built a fantastic world. I can see why Andor Season 1 is leading though. it was truly excellent. A bit sad to see Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 1 at the bottom, but honestly, any of these are great sci-fi picks!"

MrStelmacki

The Expanse and Andor are both really good shows. I hope to see you react to both soon enough.

Lukas Weimar

The first season though is not as arc-structured as the second season: 1-3 Ferrix Arc, 4-6 Aldhani Arc, 7-10 Prison Arc, 11-12 2. Ferrix Arc

Boomcity

Can people stop crying about Andor now?

Boomcity

Yes. Yellowjackets is pretty great.

Boomcity

I couldn't get past episode 3 of the Expanse.

Jenny Chalek

How many rewatches do you think she'll do? if she's already seen it, then she has that background. Once she watches Andor, THAT's the time for a rewatch. Because that's an entirely new experience.

Joel

If you read my last comment you’ll see I’m not suggesting a full rewatch. My suggestion was merely that refreshing her memory about what happened and who appeared in that film (she watched Rogue One once over four years ago) could be beneficial to the Andor experience, especially Season 2. That’s just my two cents.

Jason Dolan

I have not watched the new ANDOR so that could be fun

David Sumner

Yeah, but the first season is kind a rough. It doesn't really start to get good until the second season. Also, a lot more episodes than most to the other choices.

David Sumner

Andorians are from Star Trek!

David Sumner

You really should put the option for just the top 5-10 Star Trek Episodes since a lot of the episodes are super dated and can be rough to get through.

DirectorInc

Finally FUCK. Andor is way too long overdue.

Tesh

ooohhh i second this, its been approved for a second and third season (filming at the same time i believe) and its a phenomenal show

David

It'd be nice to get Resident Alien in the mix. Alan Tudyk is brilliant.

E

YOOOOO LETS GOOOOO ANDOOOOOOOOOOOOR

Luis Enrique

I like Andor i just think the pace is a bit slow at times. Great grounded show though.