Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Help me pick a movie!

  • Oldboy (never seen) 280
  • Das Boot (never seen) 99
  • Apocalypse Now (have seen once, don't remember a ton) 76
  • Fight Club (have seen once, remember the twist but not much else) 132
  • The Hateful 8 (never seen) 466
  • 2025-06-24
  • 1053 votes
{'title': 'Help me pick a movie! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Oldboy (never seen)', 'votes': 280}, {'text': 'Das Boot (never seen) ', 'votes': 99}, {'text': "Apocalypse Now (have seen once, don't remember a ton)", 'votes': 76}, {'text': 'Fight Club (have seen once, remember the twist but not much else)', 'votes': 132}, {'text': 'The Hateful 8 (never seen) ', 'votes': 466}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 6, 24, 14, 35, 9, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1053}

Content

A bunch of random choices today...looking forward to seeing what wins!

Comments

Jack Dellanotte (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 12:00 I'm glad Oldboy is winning, because it's a great movie! That said, sorry in advance.
2025-06-25 13:03

mrhalfbit

GREAT LIST, MORE LIKE THIS PLEASE

James Bartley

Only one film i recognise and she's watched it before. Thankfully in the middle of re watching the ATLA reaction series a comfort show for sure.

Declan Molloy

Never seen Oldboy either so let’s give it a go. Also you can tell Nats been dying to watch it poor girl puts it in every poll😭

Teemu Laitinen

Das Boot is a fantastic film. Easily the best submarine movie ever. Definitely deserves a reaction at some point along with Downfall (2004) about the last days of Hitler in his Berlin bunker. Bruno Ganz gives a spellbinding performance as Hitler.

Lanny Stanfield

I fel like if you know the twist of Fight Club it'll be hard to react well to.

Eric Trinidad

I hope this opens up a path down doing the rest of the trilogy, sympathy for Mr. Vengeance/Lady Vengeance. Or even just the other Choi Min-shik classics I enjoyed, I Saw the Devil.

Boomcity

Hell yeah Hateful 8. Maybe it will inspire Nat to jump back into Red Dead Redemption 2 some day.

Edward Rahardjo

These are all cinematic classics. Of which the Hateful Eight is the least of the list, and that is saying something, cause it's also a good movie. My vote goes to Oldboy, would be great revisiting this classic

Jacob King

Voted for Hateful 8 - not my favourite Tarantino but my appreciation has grown with every watch.

Daniel McGuinness

Not the Tarantino glazing when we have REAL FILMSSSS on this list!

Nick Freer

Gotta try and get Natalie to watch Bone Tomahawk

Troymk1

I have seen all of these and most votes are going to the worst of them by a measurable gap. Oiy vey

JayF

Nobody - Natalie - I'm going to put at least two movies I've already seen on every poll. Love ya, Natalie, but there are a shit ton of amazing movies you're not watching because you don't want to leave your comfort zone. Want a few suggestions? Here ya go - The Name of the Rose (1986) The Sting (1973) Papillion (1973) Superman (1978) Smokey and the Bandit (1977) Cry Freedom (1987) The Killing Fields (1984) Stand by Me (1986) Glory (1989)

Mastervodo

Time for some Tarantino!

dedknedy

I especially like the Netflix Extended Version where they break it up into 4 separate episodes.

Mike Hell

I like The Hateful 8. it's a decent movie and imo one of Tarantino's best, but I really thought, going up against films Nat's already seen, that we'd finally get Oldboy. LOL the poll-only voters must be 25 or younger...

Mastervodo

I mean, Das Boot is Das boring for the most part. And if Nat's seen Apoc Now and Fight Club and knows the twist, it's definitely between Oldboy and Hateful 8. And I'm confused about the hate for the Hateful 8! Maybe Nat's people have just seen H8 more than Oldboy and want to see what Nat thinks of it?

Mike Hell

I agree, I'm cool with H8, it's good, but I think Oldboy is a better film. I'm also a little confused why Nat keeps putting Fight Club and Apocalypse Now or other films she's already seen when there are so many she hasn't seen, but maybe she just wants to see those films again.

Bobby B

I just rewatched Hatful 8 a few weeks ago and wouldn’t mind an excuse to do so again

Erik Stevenson

I think the issue you're struggling with is that Nat generally needs to pick movies that will get views, not movies that nobody on YouTube will watch a reaction to.

JayF

Cassie over at PiB reacted to The Sting and it's got over 130k views. Her reaction to Superman has over 350k views. Smokey and the Bandit? Over 200k views. Stand By Me? Over 200k. Glory? Over 250k.

Darryl Low

Happy Wednesday Nat. Voted for Fight Club as I have yet to see it, but it's certainly not putting up much of a fight in this poll! 😅 Maybe next time. Take care Nat 💛

Mike Hell

I agree that I'd like to see Nat expand her film viewing beyond what's popular in the last 20 years, but her viewers are clearly a different demographic than PiB's viewers. People sub to PiB specifically to watch those types of movies, and I don't think Cassie watches a lot of series, either.

Erik Stevenson

Happy to hand it to you on Superman, but the majority of the movies you listed have been up on her channel for 3-4 years. Reactions in general were bigger during the pandemic and immediately after, and also it's weird to look at 3+ year view counts when talking about stuff that needs to perform now. PiB is also almost exclusively a Movie reaction channel, so the audience is more plugged in on deeper cut movies from longer ago, it's what they're there to see. You also pulled out the most well-known movies from your original list, so just list those next time if you don't want people side-eying your requested movies.

JayF

Well sorry guys but I'm a paid subscriber on Patreon so if you don't mind I'll ask for Natalie to react to movies that I'd like to see her react to, not just the ones that you approve of.

jamie jones

The Hateful eight is great

kevin dale

Ah yes, nothing screams YOUTUBE VIEWS like Das Boot and Land Before Time lol. I agree with the other list. She should just watch great movies. People will be drawn to that more than “decent” content. (Das Boot is legitimately a great film, but it’s certainly not Natalie putting it on the list to juice views lol. Half the list the other guy gave would do better for that)

jamie jones

Should throw 28 weeks later on a poll.

Essero Eson

We're trying not to traumatize Nat with Oldboy.

Darryl Low

Great selection of movies, and you've done the right thing. You've suggested movies you'd like Nat to watch. If enough people agree with you, then Nat will probably stick them into a future poll 😊 She's said on many occasions that huge YT views aren't the be all and end all of her channel. Nat tries to balance movies that people have mentioned a lot with movies that she is genuinely curious about and wants to watch. That's why quite a few movies pop up regularly - Das Boot, Close Encounters, Oldboy etc, and movies that she has enjoyed in the past but doesn't remember a lot about them and would love to re-visit them. Sure, Nat could sit and watch them herself, but seeing as she has a reaction channel, she wants to watch them and share her reactions and thoughts on them, as there will always be avid fans for everything she watches 😊

nitind

It's always a good time for "Dave (1993)"

J G

Time to get hateful

Analytical Guy

My vote is for Hateful Eight for sure. I can't get into "seen once" movies. Even though the reactor doesn't remember specific details, they still have a sense of the overall plot and what could and couldn't reasonably happen. Still, I appreciate a reactor being honest about it, rather than trying to "pull a fast one" (claiming they haven't seen the movie) because the latter leaves the situation where one watches the reaction and gets the vibe that something is not quite right.

Boris Kopp

All in for Hateful Eight. Great visuals and a stacked cast as usual. Also super widescreen. I remember the best way to watch it was on 21:9 screens.

baxterzeppo

Hateful 8 is great but Oldboy is my vote

Daniel McGuinness

I wouldn’t say no to some 90s thrillers on a poll. Like: Copycat (‘95) Kiss the girls (‘97) The Bone Collector (‘99) etc, etc

Monnad

Even if it never wins I love voting for oldboy evey poll :D

Jinxter ジンクスたー

I will always vote for Oldboy until it gets seen, Hateful 8 is a good movie, but no where at the level that the original Oldboy is at

Essero Eson

Hateful Eight is a great murder mystery film. Like Clue in the old west.

SEAN ƴü KAY

Nat has been so laid back recently, so maybe we should vote for a laid back film like 'Oldboy' , right?

ccc

I have a letter signed by the president that says we gone watch hateful 8

iQueue211

How does Oldboy end up on virtually every poll and continue to get beat out?

Nicholas Sulikowski

Since it looks like The Hateful Eight may win the poll, I'd like to point out that there are two very different ways to watch it. One is the Theatrical Cut that runs at just under 3 hours. The other is the Extended Version, which is not only longer at 3.5 hours, but is also divided into four 50-ish minute parts like a miniseries. (Both are on Netflix.) I haven't seen either, so I don't know which is better. I don't know if the super long version is worth it or if it's just overindulgent, but I thought I'd share.

Jonas

The longer version is just as good. There's nothing wasteful in it. It's just more flavor and backstory/character stuff. That doesn't mean it's the version she has to watch. Both are good. She could break it up episodically if she wanted or watch the theatrical in one go. Typically, I'd tell people to watch the theatrical and if they like it, go back and watch the extended, but I don't know what's best for a reaction channel.

StarsANDnight

You have to watch k-pop demon hunters !!!

Mr. Redd

Could you consider watching Speed Racer? You’d be one of the first big reaction channels to cover it and it deserves more love than it gets. I think you’d really enjoy it

gilgath

Speed racer????? Why not just ask her to watch Bevis and Butthead if you're trying to destroy brain cells. The Green Mile, catch me if you can, so many great movies and you guys want us to set through some nitch cult movie... Come on guys

mrhalfbit

I seriously can’t wait for H8FL8 reaction. My favorite Tarantino!

YodatheHobbit

Man, so basic. So you ONLY watch oscarbait reactions, or just the 50 movies every react always reacts to, endlessly boringly rewatching the same films 10 times a year? "Want us"? There's not an us in reactions. People watch other people watch the stuff they like, that they're a fan of. And how in the fuck are you even calling Speed Racer is a niche cult movie??? WHAT?? 😂 It's an extremely Hollywood cast, that had a very large budget, based on a very popular 60s cartoon. Besides that point, here's no requirement to watch everything a reactor puts out. There's entire series reactions from reactors I subscribe to here on Patreon regularly that I'll never watch. Why would I need to? Watch and pay for what you like, not what's popular. When long enough goes by and content you aren't a fan of stops, stop paying. it's so simple. What an idiotic and film snobbishly rude comment.

Omar Sanchez

I swear to god one day it’s gonna be Oldboy all by itself in the poll and it still gonna end up losing 🥹