Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Help me pick a show!

  • Squid Game - Season 3 200
  • Star Trek: The Original Series - Season 1 257
  • The Bear - Season 1 486
  • Better Call Saul - Season 1 322
  • 2025-07-09
  • 1265 votes
{'title': 'Help me pick a show! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Squid Game - Season 3', 'votes': 200}, {'text': 'Star Trek: The Original Series - Season 1', 'votes': 257}, {'text': 'The Bear - Season 1', 'votes': 486}, {'text': 'Better Call Saul - Season 1', 'votes': 322}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 9, 0, 55, 4, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1265}

Content

Help me pick a season of a show to watch alongside Andor! (I will still be prioritizing Andor as the main show, just want something else to start too)

Comments

Kelvin

The Pitt isn’t on here, but I think it’s a good pick for a future poll.

CHRISXGAMESALOT

I waited six months to conclude Squid Game with Nat guess I'll have to wait longer. 😒

Ron Fatica

The Bear. I'll gladly watch it again!

Rogier Oude Heuvel

Personally I would suggest Star Trek Enterprise as a first show for Star Trek. (Only Season 3 is a bit rough)

Boomcity

We need The Bear, chef!!

Eric Wallace

Really hoped for stargate sg-1

Dimi

oh absolutely!!!!!!

Danishprince

Not really any of these that appeals to me so skipping this one - Happy voting everyone and may the odds be ever in your favor ❤️

Jerry Gonzalez

Really wanna see you finish squid game, but I absolutely love the bear.

mrhalfbit

PLEASE BETTER CALL SAUL

Dean

Ooooooo! That show is fantastic!!

Michael Bergeron

Huge Star Trek fan, and it’s been said before, but Star Trek will not win a poll if the whole first season is the option. And honestly it probably shouldn’t if it’s the whole season. It’s 29 episodes just for season 1. And there may not even be 29 episodes total you’d need to watch if you were just watching the good ones from the original 3 seasons. It’s not really like current shows where you will miss much context if you miss episodes, you can skip around and watch the good ones. It’s a far better introduction to Star Trek.

nitind

Those are some dark pairings. Someone's going to rediscover Eureka one day.

Brian Leonard

I went with Star Trek, but that won't entice me to resubscribe and I am completely out on all the other shows.

Darryl Low

Happy Wednesday Nat. Hope you are doing okay. Going Where No Nat Has Been Before and vote Star Trek. I can see already though that its headed off into the Final Frontier. Maybe one day, and then we can get to watch the movies with you. Have a great day Nat 💛

Brian Leonard

And it is so good for reaction videos.

Mastervodo

If it were ST:TNG, I might vote that - but it's waaaaaay too big. ST:TOS is just bad. And that's from a Star Trek fan. Haven't watched the Squid Games to get into it, but I've heard good things about The Bear, so the Bear it is!

Eduardo

Probably late for suggestions, but for the future you should consider watching Succession

Lawson

we need Loki Season 2 and Succession on the next show poll!

PopeyeNelson

Highly recommend watch ALL 4 seasons of "The Bear", then go and finish watching the final 5 seasons of "Peaky Blinders" and once those are done go and watch all 6 Seasons of "Better Call Saul". My OCD can't handle not watching all seasons of a good series, though if it's a bad series my ADHD will override my OCD and I'll oh look it's a 🐿️... and oh yeah, forget all about it!

Alex Le

Glad we're finally getting Master & Commander, have been wanting this react since Gladiator.

Mike Hell

I'm shocked Squid Games isn't killing this poll, but I'll happily go in on either The Bear or BCS because both shows are great, though S3 of Bear faltered a little bit (yes only Season 1 is promised but C'mon). BCS just gets better every season, surpassing Breaking Bad in the end, in my opinion, anyway.

Jason Gillman

Really wish it was Next Generation or even Strange New Worlds for Trek. As it is I’m voting for BCS

N K

BCS has some of the best camerawork of a show in the last decade and the writing is also superb

Baggie Mark

This is a great choice, I'm happy with whatever wins this poll

K.N.

FYI Nat it is the final season of Squid Game and it's only 6 eps, if that makes it more enticing to just finish the series.

Ben

TOS? A bad place to start? The irony.....

Ben

I love Trek and TOS too and I agree...there are definitely episodes that don't need to be watched

Laszlo Varga

Squid Game - Season 3 is only 6 episodes and that is it so you could start with this and continue with possibly the The Bear

kevin dale

Better Call Saul is by far and away the best tv series on that list. It’s unfortunate it’s losing to a show that’s good, but will be nothing but depression and anxiety reactions to every few days lol. What a mistake!

Edward Rahardjo

I work in a kitchen, so I can relate most to the Bear. Not saying it's the best show on the list, but it's short, packs a punch, and for me very confrontational, hitting both highs and lows. The show does inspire me to always do or be better next time

Choux D Bruxelles

The only one I know from this list is Star Trek and was not a fan. My brothers loved the show, but I never did. As for the other shows, I don't know enough about them to pick one. So I will leave that choice to more educated audience members. As for my part, I think ought to watch 'A Discovery of Witches,' starring Matthew Goode and Teresa Palmer. It is a well written short three season show. It's based on the "All Souls Trilogy books" by Deborah Harkness. Great story, great writing, great cast, great filmography, great production, and great directing.

Bobby B

Awwww Saul is never gonna win one of these is it.

Ty H.

I really hope "Better Call Saul" makes a comeback and wins because it is superb. I don't know if you ever saw the best show in the history of television, "Breaking Bad", but it's a sequel to that show.

YodatheHobbit

I have no interest in watching any of those series' at this point in my life, but I know the first season of the OG Star Trek is good. Watched most of it while I was camping in a sleeping bag on my phone and was having trouble being without video media for the first time in quite a while. Also, I was using the Netflix app for the very first time.

ShadowStunts

The Bear starts out great but falls off very fast. Season 1 and 2 are good but the last 2 seasons have been horrid. Definitely watch Better Call Saul since it's the greatest show ever made. Even if it comes second I hope you watch it after the winning show is done. :D

jamie jones

Should watch the suicide squad, then peacemaker

Casual Nerd Reactions

I’d have been thrilled, but I’d also be surprised to see her tackle such a long series.

José Amador

ST: TOS isn't bad, as someone opined earlier, it's just dated, its effects very much of its time. The dialog is campy, etc etc. All things that can be accepted and overlooked if you let yourself be swept along. It's just that... Look, I just don't know how much I'm willing to watch Nat laugh, roll her eyes at, and dismiss what is, in essence, historic and decent TV (that I also happen to enjoy).

Gilbert

Better Call Saul not winning? i dont understand the world anymore, one of the best shows produced in the last 10 years.

Eric Wallace

She mentioned putting it in a poll for the 1st season

Nightowl

TOS is an interesting pick, far from the best Star Trek show (obviously it’s from the ’60s) but I’d actually be down to rewatch it since it’s been ages since I’ve seen it.

Max

I'll try a different argument this time. Take a look at the total runtime of each option: 6.13 hours (Squid Game – S3) 24.17 hours (Star Trek: TOS – S1) 3.93 hours (The Bear – S1) 7.83 hours (Better Call Saul – S1) As you can see, TOS S1 is longer than all of the other options combined. It's a much bigger time commitment, and that hurts the chances of this option in the poll. Not to mention that it's very old content. If you were instead to take the 9 best-rated TOS episodes from all seasons (there are websites that can help you with that or ChatGPT), it would run you about 8 hours, so approximately the equivalent of season 1 of BCS. If the only Star Trek content you're willing to start with is TOS, a "best-of" approach would have much better chances in future polls. It's a well-accepted approach for content like that.

Çlôud

Thts what I'm saying better call Saul is clear winner

Zach Cloud

You had Cyberpunk Edge Runners up once, I wish that was an option again

Darryl Low

A better option would be to select the 10 best episodes from the season to give the flavour of the show. This would at least open up the movies for Nat to watch, should be interested in doing so 🙂

mrhalfbit

Excited for season 2!

—thoughtstorms—keith—

BeCaSaul is coming in second place, maybe it can be weighted a little in the next poll? Ranked Choice Voting is what we need, and we need it 2,000+ years ago! Oh, and also on Natalie's polls! ⭓ ⭔

Daniel McGuinness

I don’t feel comfy voting for Better Call Saul before Breaking Bad

David Sumner

I keep saying it: we don't want you to react through the ENTIRE original series, just 5-10 episodes is enough. The entire series is super rough to get through, you just need to watch a few classic episodes.

rayman

has she not seen BB before?

Daniel McGuinness

I’m not sure but it definitely hasn’t been a reaction

rayman

brother Better Call Saul is an incredible show, peak quality. But based off your comment I assume you never saw Breaking Bad either, and you’d need to watch that first anyway (which is also an incredible show)

rayman

if she never saw BB she should absolutely not watch BCS now. she needs to watch BB first

Daniel McGuinness

Is there really a point to that though? Just a YouTube vid with “10 best Star Trek TOS episodes” with no prior knowledge or investment in the plot? 😅 I get it’s a classic but if we’re not doing all of it, we shouldn’t do any

rayman

can I get a confirmation that she’s seen all of Break Bad before I vote BCS because if she hasn’t I can’t in good faith vote for it.

Darryl Low

Nat has watched Breaking Bad before.

Darryl Low

Watching the 10 best episodes of the season would work. Other reactors have done that and then went on to enjoy the movies with the original cast.

Darryl Low

Nat watched BB back in her pre-reaction days 😊

Daniel Vezina

LOL, you got short memory, it ended really strong. But the first 2 season of BCS are such a drag.

Rey

Man i would love to see you watch BCS and the bear both tbh haha they are just some top tier shows

Rey

Shes def see breaking bad shes mentioned it on streams before

Erik Stevenson

Voted for BCS here, mostly because The Bear has been on a downward slope in quality since season 1 IMO. I'm a sci-fi fan at heart, but have no interest in slogging through the older Star Trek series. Would love to see The Expanse back on a poll one day as the sci-fi option even though I'm pretty sure we'd never make it all the way through the show voting on single seasons haha.

Eric Mueller

Maybe in the near future, the tv show From?🙏

Kraackin

havent reacted to a show i want to watch in like 2 months lol. I think this is were we part ways

John Liebling

Why no consideration for the great writing on the Twilight Zone, from the 1960s?

Rochard Scott

You can't go wrong with The Bear or (ESPECIALLY) Better Call Saul.

Mike Hell

Dang, Squid Game in last place? Even against the typically-poorly-received-in-polls Star Trek TOS!? That is surprising. I was sure it’d win against any challenger in this poll. Not complaining, though. Let it rip!

simon.shoots

The bear is good, but this last season was sooo boring - so maybe just season one only 😂

xander

squid game losing :(

Tiger Chu

What We Do In The Shadows

xander

the bear is rlly good tho

PureGonzo

No, what he has is an opinion, and it’s an opinion that I and the rest of the world seem to share if you look at any reviews, rankings, or ratings for TV shows from literally any website or publication.

PureGonzo

She has seen BB, don’t worry :)

Daniel Vezina

Again, I'm putting Orphan black out there.

Max

Good suggestion. At least the first one or two seasons were pretty good.

Bryan Bryan

The Bear gonna be horrible on your back carrying all that stress

Siti Dee

Yesss the bear! I need an excuse to rewatch season 1 for awhile so this is perfect!

Eric Janssen

I’m guessing we have those self-focused voters who say “But I’ve already SEEN it!”, to explain the lack of interest in seeing one more student educated in the basics of Star Trek: TOS. Starfleet is Fundamental.

mrhalfbit

Honestly I can enjoy an episode of any season of Star Trek, but overall Star Trek is extremely slow and not very emotional, which in my opinion makes not so good reacting. I think this is doubly true for TOS. I would much rather have a reaction to season 1 or TNG.

Eric Janssen

Yes, but the comfort-food of TOS, and TNG, is that we get attached to the running character-quirks, in short episode-length bites. If there’s one thing that engages a female reactor on a series, it’s her addiction to Hang With Her Homies. We’ll leave the addictive plot arcs to DS9.

Tanner

Peaky Blinders S2, need to connect the story to the episode she accidentally saw in S3

Sean

The Bear is a good show. Too much yelling though.

Sam Winkler

I'm literally almost done with the Original Star Trek Series for the first time so I'll be voting for that if it's on the polls!!

P. Paul Castiglione

TOS is so morality driven. So much of our current genre TVs trends toward social justice by way of analogy is thanks to Star Trek:tOS. (Even with its glaring sexism to modern eyes, you can’t win them all) It is slow for us but when it hits it hits hard. But it is unlikely to draw out the tears or squirms Nat is prone to.

Daywalker

Nobody does the Orville and its great!

Luis Enrique

Squid games 3 would have had her in her feels though. I tried the bear a few times maybe I’ll give it another go

Chun

How has Kpop Demon Hunters NOT been on a poll yet?!?

Autumn

Nat... where is Squid Game S3??? 😭

Devon Guthrie

I feel like you'd enjoy Blue Eye Samurai

Mono

Should really watch The Amazing Digital Circus, it is so so good

Autumn

Hey Nat, noticed you never did Squid Game season 3

Logan Kerlee

I really would love to see Nat's take on Trek!