Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Help me pick the first NATMARES movie!

  • It Follows 82
  • Talk to Me 31
  • Barbarian 92
  • Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) 55
  • No One Will Save You 13
  • 2026-09-22
  • 273 votes
{'title': 'Help me pick the first NATMARES movie! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'It Follows', 'votes': 82}, {'text': 'Talk to Me', 'votes': 31}, {'text': 'Barbarian', 'votes': 92}, {'text': 'Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974)', 'votes': 55}, {'text': 'No One Will Save You', 'votes': 13}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 22, 20, 20, 21, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 273}

Content

It's that time of year again! 👻🎃🕸️🦇🐈‍⬛

God, this poll makes me nervous 😅

Comments

mojo shivers

It Follows would be amazing to kick off Natmares. I haven’t seen an amazing reaction to that in sometimes and it’s timely because They Follow is on its way next year i believe.

Lingussp

Talk to me is so good

Jay Robert

I drive by the house from It Follows all the time.

Leon Mabonga

You gotta watch obessionnnnnnnnn

Frank Lewis

Lights Out. (For future poll)

Leon Mabonga

Where can I find brother 🙏🏾

Danishprince

Surprised to see It Follows being that much further ahead than Talk to Me

Bobby B

The lighthouse by Robert Eggers with Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe. Perfect film for spooky time.

Lobos625

She posted it back in July i think

Lobos625

I have been wanting you to react to it follows for some time! Hopefully this will be the year

Ben Wheeler

I think the score for It Follows is an absolute love letter to Halloween’s score

Berry

Barbarian is a good movie, nice to see it ahead in the polls. Cregger also made Weapons (which I love) and the new Resident Evil movie which I'm very excited about.

Nick Freer

Please put Sinister on a poll at some point Nat

Max Rinaldi

The two most voted films had their directors see their latest films released in the last two months.

Collinson

Talk to Me is very good but not very well known but It Follows and Barbarian are also very good.

Kaden P

Nat strangely didn't like Weapons, but I would love to see her reaction to Barbarian

Collinson

It really is but doesn't seem well known unfortunately.

Danishprince

Well Weapons sucked so that might be why she didn't like it

PureGonzo

Not according to virtually all audience reviews and virtually all critic reviews – not to mention all the awards it won (including an Oscar). But you’re free to be wrong, as it is your right 😉

Jaanus_.

Gotta start with the classics. Out of the listed Texas Chain Saw. 🙂 Other than that Jacob's Ladder (1990), Mandy (2018), Suspiria (1977), The Thing (1982).

Rey

Honestly all of the above haha

Justin Hormann

Oh man, that would be FUN! Every October, since... I duuno, like 2019 when I got all the blu-rays, I've watched the whole run of Ash vs Evil Dead. It's STILL just a great time for me, and I was HOPING I'd get a chance to convince Nat to watch it (I just get the feeling she'd LOVE IT). It's 3 seasons long, so it may be a little much, though. Well, I'm still looking forward to watching it next month, lol. edit: as for the poll. I'm sorry Nat, I've just not had any experience with ANY of those films, lol. "No One Will Save You" is a title that interests me, at least

Albiezushi

LOVE It Follows, a movie so creepy its even 'following' Barbarian right now 😂

Jazz

Welcome to Derry is also a great precuel to the It Series, and it also stars Bill Skarsgard

Jedi Lounger

Malignant (2021) would also be fun. Also The End of Oak Street (2026) just came up on streaming.

ccc

You still need to do 28 years later bone temple while it's fresh on your mind! it goes 0-100 in the first 15 seconds and keeps going fr.

David Sumner

That was a fun one. Works well if you don't want to go too intense

David Sumner

I vote for Event Horizon, in honor of Sam Neil.

Frank Lewis

That's what I was thinking.

Marcus

Annihilation in a poll for the Natmares season, please. & Bone Temple.

Crispy

I haven't seen it follows in a while and I think barbarian is over rated so I know my vote lol

Brent giesbrecht

Honestly, the poll isnt that far off. Barbarian and It follows are excellent choices to do if you did both!

Kaden P

Petition for Nat to react to Lights Out, but with her lights out as well! Maybe just a ring light so we can see her face. But darkness otherwise

Dillon Sylvester

I like all these movies but Talk To Me is easily the best one

Frank Lewis

Haha. She'd hate us for sure.

Xavier Reynoso

there’s a movie that came out recently called Buddy. I went into it not knowing much and that shit was unhinged but kinda hilarious.

Kyle Turning Robe

Halloweentown please its suck a good Halloween movie.

jamie jones

Lets do the girl with all the gifts

Marvin

Talk to me is elite, one of my favorites from recent years

Rey

It had some serious adult swim vibes going on

Johnny

No autumn referencis, but some ides 1. Constantine (Keanu), 2. The Rundown (The Rock), and 3. Bill Murray's the Spy who knew too little.

Brandon

For a wacky horror with comedy sprinkled in Halloween movie, Trick or treat is a good pick 🤔

Mayhem Theater

How is Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Talk To Me have less votes? They're the better ones out of the rest

Bjorn Chircop

Smile 2 please :) and death becomes her