Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Help me pick a new longer term series! (Patreon)

Published:
2023-05-17 16:00:08
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Poll

Help me pick a new longer term series!

  • Barry 502
  • Battlestar Galactica 342
  • Star Trek (just 1 season to start and would do a poll to decide which one is best) 168
  • Legend of Korra 719
  • Sherlock (idk, I've seen this mentioned a bunch on Discord haha) 627
  • 2023-05-14
  • 2358 votes
{'title': 'Help me pick a new longer term series! ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Barry', 'votes': 502}, {'text': 'Battlestar Galactica', 'votes': 342}, {'text': 'Star Trek (just 1 season to start and would do a poll to decide which one is best)', 'votes': 168}, {'text': 'Legend of Korra', 'votes': 719}, {'text': "Sherlock (idk, I've seen this mentioned a bunch on Discord haha)", 'votes': 627}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 5, 14, 16, 47, 8, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 2358}

Content

Help me pick a new show to dive into after wrapping THE BOYS. Tried to pick shows with a few seasons, but ones that aren't more than 4 or so. Star Trek would just be one season to start.

A lot of folks have been mentioning Ted Lasso Season 3 and I definitely plan to get into that soon! Right now, I'm thinking I will start that once I wrap up Season 2 of Daredevil and keep it on as the show to alternate with this one. 

Comments

Martin7777

You will relate hard-core to Barry

Darryl Low

Happy Wednesday Nat. Going to go with Legend of Korra as people are raving about it and would love to watch more animation with you. Looking forward to Ted too. Have a great day 💛

elmest

Legend of Korra hive stand up!!

RationallySassy

Dang, these are hard choices! I want to pick a few, haha

Corthos Entertainment

You might also want to consider Doctor Who. They’re about to move it all off HBO Max and onto Disney+, but I think you would enjoy it!

mrhalfbit

As actress and someone in the industry you would LOVE Barry

FullMetal B

So glad Barry is in the lead! As it should be.

Bret Moore

Barry, hands down, no contest.

KeithJ

I picked BSG but I'm not optimistic.

UngawdlyJish

Oh man. Sherlock is amazing. But I won't be sad if Berry wins.

Jason Dolan

Barry is great because the show is also ending so you’ll get to experience close to real time this summer and it is a show you can knock out fast because I think it will only have 32 total episodes for the series.

Jorgalorg

Definitely Barry Sherlock is such a waste of time

Boomcity

Totally down to finally start Barry. Have you watched any of Love and Death on HBO?

RationallySassy

Though Barry would be cool, I got to go with Korra just because I've seen a few other people watch The Last Airbender lately and just love going back to that world.

Rebecca Solomon

I could totally get into a rewatch of BSG!

fryke

Chuck or Halle?

Noctis

Beats, Bears, Battlestar Galactica.

Logan Kerlee

I saw BSG and my vote was decided. I think all of these shows are quality though.

Megatto

Can't believe you guys aren't voting for Star Trek

Nicholas Sulikowski

I second this. Don't worry about the classic show either. Just start with Series 1 from 2005 with Christopher Eccleston.

Dr_Dallas

Legend of Korra for sure! Barry is great too but after The Boys, maybe something a little more light hearted.

Aleks

One day Andor, one day

jamie jones

Barry. The others are all meh

Lawson

lowkey want Korra to win i miss our avatar time 😭

Erik Stevenson

Ahh good to see Sci Fi represented with Battlestar Galactica, but it has more episodes than The Expanse even with fewer seasons haha.

Andrew Aguecheek

I'd love you to do BSG, not only for your reaction, but for an excuse to rewatch it! Can't believe it's 20 years since it came out!

Jo

Andor or The Last Kingdom are great shows

George Baxter

Please not Legend of Korra. I appreciate people love this show but there are many reactions to this out there already…

Lisa Tosti

I love Barry and I think you will love it but I can't not vote for Sherlock. It's such an amazing show!

Christian Fierro

Estou em Portugal agora, vou a voltar em breve e continur assistindo. Adorei o trabalho continue assim. Obrigado!

Jeremy Gill

I'd go the 4 seasons of Black Sails. Story about long john silver, captain flint, Billy bones, all before treasure island...a mature prequel series that has historical pirates and locations throughout.

Śéáń

I really hope Barry gets it. Top tier show, short run, and very few people are covering it.

Jason Gillman

I’d prefer Battlestar or Trek or Sherlock but I’ll vote for Korra just in the hopes it beats Barry

Joshua Kon

Barry is alright but Sherlock would be great! I think korra would be fun too but BG and ST be too geeky for youtube now a days.

Logan Kerlee

Main reason why I'm not is because I'm wanting more dedication to it than just one season. I don't want to watch the one season, get super into the reactions and not have it win a poll again. That flat drives me bonkers and would make me unsub from the Patreon.

Tiger Chu

What We Do in The Shadows

John Piazza

Im REALLY hoping Korra wins. Rewatching Avatar The Last Airbender when she watched it was awesome.

Joey Johansen

Sherlock was a fun watch, I've not seen Barry yet and that could be great as well! :)

Giancarlo Ubaldino

I'm voting for Battlestar Galactica, but I'd also like to mention Luke Cage.

Lawson

any plans to watch she-hulk or are we skippin that one?

Alvin Baca

You need to get into the expanse

Danishprince

There are many reactions to the others shows as well lol

George Baxter

Not Barry! A show about an actor! How could. Nat not like that? And Korra is so many episodes

Danishprince

Really hoping Korra wins! It's not on the level of ATLA due to a lot of production issues causes by Nickelodeon but it's still an incredibly enjoyable experience on its own <3

Ab

Definitely Barry

Delford Chaffin

Battlestar Galactica and Sherlock are two of my favorite shows of all time.

Dan

Suggestion for a future poll - The Americans. Brilliant show all around and there’s a lot to dig into (and react to) with each episode.

Lee Gannon

I'd like to see her react to it also especially with the 60th anniversary being this year.

Jomero

I don't know if Sherlock is a long series. Each season only has like three episodes.

Corthos Entertainment

For sure!! And with Ncuti Gatwa coming in next year, it’s going to be a wild ride!

Ian

Really happy to hear you fully intend to get to ted lasso at some point as I'm resisting watching season 3 so I can watch along with yourself 👍 voted for battlestar Galactica even though it has no chance against all the avatar fans that will just vote for korra 🤷 shame cuz Sherlock would have been cool too

Tim Brown

Barry would 100% be the perfect show for a Natalie reaction! It's the perfect amount of humor and thriller elements, and it's about to wrap up its final season too

Ruler

Succession

Walter Lopez

Barry all the way, Nat! Keep keeping it on your polls if it doesn't work out. Must Watch, Nat! Must Watch!!!

Dante

Barry is literally the perfect show for her. I’m really keen on seeing someone who has experience in the acting/theatre/casting industry react to that show. It’s pretty much made for Nat.

Joe Blankenship

Miss Marvel and She-Hulk are pretty short. Hopefully Barry wins though. I bailed on Avatar, so not interested in Korra.

Richard Maurer

Sad to see Buffy the Vampire Slayer isn't on here. But considering what shows are winning the poll, it probably wouldn't win anyway, which is a shame, as it's easily better than anything on this poll - imo (which just so happens to be the correct opinion). Well at least I have The Normies, who are doing a killer job with Buffy.

Bruh iTs Klamydiuh

like many people have mentioned, Barry is a pretty fun show.

SpiderCreep

Barry is such well directed and written show so I really think you will enjoy it. Some fun characters for you to get attached to.

Josh McHugh

Battlestar Galactica (TV Series 2004–2009) Back when this came out, I considered it one of the best series ever made. Since then, there are several series that are better, but I think this remake of Battlestar will be very enjoyable to watch.

Logan Kerlee

Yeah, those are my feelings as well. I'm really not a fan of Korra.

THE LORE!!!

Man, I'd love to see Nat do some Trek but I feel like I'm nearly alone on it. Shit, nearly every poll she puts, the popular opinion is completely at odds with what I'd like to see.

Jeff K.

Dang, I was hoping The Wire might break into the mix. This does remind me, I really need to watch Barry though. Started it, and just kinda lost track of it.

Razor Bikini

Am I the only one who wishes Nat wouldn’t watch so much kids stuff? I’m sure Korra is fine but I think of how she reacted to No Country for Old Men and how rare it is to see her properly blown away by a masterpiece like that, compared to watching whatever the latest Disney thing is and just being like “well that was fun.” Not tryin to rain on anybody’s parade, and I know the kids stuff is generally just more popular on YouTube (which is a whole other issue) but I often get the sense Nat would like to watch more mature and intelligent stuff than she usually does. Also Korra fans don’t be mad at me this isn’t about Korra specifically just a general observation.

Logan Kerlee

I'll have to check their content out, appreciate the post.

Eric Janssen

Unfortunately, girls of all ages will glue themselves to a cable/streaming "kids stuff" cartoon if they're promised the characters will have a Relationship. In fact, I'd wager most of the fans nagging Natalie into watching Korra were hooked on the soft lez-toon aspect long before Disney's "Owl House" came along. They LITERALLY believe animation should serve no other purpose. (And every time, I dare one of those fans to quote a classic Chuck Jones line...Any quote.)

Endling_king

I vote Star Trek. But also which series? The original, the next generation, deep space 9, Voyager, enterprise? (I'm leaving out strange new worlds and discovery on purpose, fuck those ! )

SpiderCreep

Overturn the Poll Natalie. 😂 Barry has theater in it! THEATER!

Philip De Leon

So... Daredevil, The Boys, and John Wick aren't exactly Kids Stuff. I'd say she's already watching 80% mature non-kid-friendly stuff these days if you look at the lineup for the last year.

Razor Bikini

I’m sorry but please don’t associate me with your misogynistic opinions.

Razor Bikini

And if Daredevil and The Boys (both pretty good shows) are your bar for mature content then I’m sorry but we’re just not having the same conversation.

Patrick Egan

I've never seen Barry or Legend Of Korra, so I can't comment on those. Battlestar Galactica starts off great but the quality really drops as it goes on. Star Trek might be TOO much to deal with when it comes to the TV shows. Sherlock on the other hand is fantastic, and a good length.

Rev.J

What happened to Andor? BSG is quality! Watched everything last year, again, but it’s a long journey – Season 1 13eps, Season 2 20eps, Season 3 20eps, Season 4 21eps. Plus the Webisodes (The Face of the Enemy, The Resistance & Razor Flashbacks) and the two movies Razor and The Plan. Plus the viewing order of all the above. This will help: https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/sci-fi/how-to-watch-and-stream-battlestar-galactica-is-the-sci-fi-series-on-netflix/ I’d be happy with just the two part miniseries. So say we all!

Dustin

I think there’s just too much Star Trek out there. Maybe the new movies because they are approachable without watching so much and are a pretty fun watch in one sitting. Would lean Barry or Sherlock.

k8ie

BARRY is such a well done show and it’s about the industry but has a spin on it i think it’ll be right up your alley.

Brian Leonard

I went with Star Trek. I would have selected Battlestar, but that gets problematic on YouTube. I would have voted for Doctor Who if that was an option.

Gerald Corona

Travelers. Great acting. It only has 3 seasons and comes to a satisfying conclusion.

simon.shoots

Barry falls apart after season 2, won’t be good // Gotta go for Sherlock it’s amazing all the way through

Ben Wheeler

I’d vote for the movies with the OG cast than a show just b/c of the time commitment

Daniel McGuinness

Since it looks like Dave Filoni is gonna be heavily involved in Star Wars going forward, I would love to see you get around to The Clone Wars show at some point 😁 It does such a great job at expanding on the story of the prequels and developing the characters that you’re familiar with in kinda surprisingly nuanced ways, that it’s helped turn a lot of people who were kinda lukewarm on Star Wars to begin with into bigger fans! And gave us one of the best characters in SW history, Ahsoka 😭 I know it may seem intimidating at first, jumping into an animated show with 7 seasons, but the episodes are 30 mins max! And while episodes originally aired non-chronologically, there’s a popular episode guide out there that’s recommended by the official Star Wars page which tells you the order to watch them in chronologically 🫡😅 I’m not expecting it to be the next show on your radar or to even make into any polls soon since I haven’t seen much talk about it, but I think you’d actually really enjoy it, so I thought I’d just bring it up and cross my fingers 🤞🏻🤣 Love your content! (And I’m voting LoK 👀) 💛

adrianR31

Sherlock is hella fun but you gotta go Korra

Dustin

Black sails is one of the best shows. Starz just doesn’t get the traction of the other networks.

Rev.J

12eps over 4 seasons (plus 1 original Victorian era Xmas special) – perfect. Get to see what all the fuss over Cumberbatch’s (masterful) performance was all about.

Steve J

If we're gonna do a cartoon lets do Invincible or Vox Machina :)

Rev.J

62eps across 6 seasons! Though only 10 for season 1. Again, I’ve watched the entirety several times. Star Trek, erm which ST are we talking here – original 60s or StNG onwards?

Alvin Baca

The way they depict space battles and navigation is so brilliant is its simplicity and accuracy. More Sci fi writers need to start looking to this show for inspiration. I think I've watched this 4 or 5 times. Really hoping nat picks it up before I rewatch it.

Werlock Holmes

I didn't vote for Star Trek this time, but I think, overall, the franchise deserves attention. Maybe at some point, there could be a separate poll to decide what Star Trek stuff to watch first. Sherlock would be an interesting choice, I don't really see people reacting to the show these days. It's just that, in my opinion, the last season was a mess, but some people still liked it.

Brandon Corcoran

I will forever stand by Succession. 4 seasons only and it's just wrapping up.

Rev.J

OK, hear me out here. I did a compilation for the daughter of an American friend when I surprised her that Doctor Who was older (1963) than Star Trek (1969)! Do the first Hartnell ep, then all the Regeneration episodes (including the McGann TV movie) until Eccleston, who’s only one season, then Tennant. But again like ST & BSG, it’s a lot of viewing.

Mr BONDI

Barry is on another level, it will surprise you. Also the episodes are short so is a good show to mix between others

Erik Stevenson

The expanse has fewer episodes than the Sci Fi shows she included though lol.

Steve J

post says keep it around 4-ish seasons, but even then BSG=74 episodes, Expanse=62

Erik Stevenson

Yeah seems like she just didn't look up episode counts despite being concerned about the length of the shows. Bummer since The Expanse polled better than Battlestar Galactica the last time they were in a poll together a year ago in May 2022.

Corthos Entertainment

That’s not a bad idea … might I make one suggestion? Let them start with Eccleston as the mystery of who and what the show is drives that first season. Then after Tennant begins, they can go back and watch some specific and curated episodes from the old series to help fill in gaps that might exist from only seeing NuWho. This way we keep momentum without losing steam prior to hitting the 2005 season. But I like that you want to incorporate old episodes.

Texadan

I suggest Babylon 5.

Michael Rockenfelder

As much as I would love it to be Korra (and it seems like it will be) I *need* someone to do Battlestar!

LightsCameraJake

The only show on this list that I've seen is BSG so that's my vote. I've never seen Avatar the last airbender because it's a child's cartoon, just not into them, so I have no idea if I'd even like Korra or understand it.

Eivor

The Last Kingdom or Vikings

NareikAC

Barry is a must

Barry is incredible...ly dark at times. I'm not one to feel disturbed at things but even I have been disturbed by some of it. Still a great show though!

Michael

I'd recommend Rob and Trin reacts, very detail focused and intelligent people, they recently finished the whole show on patreon and fell in love with it

Xeph

Man this is actually a kind of hard poll. Voting Sherlock cause that's just a really good show and I wouldn't mind rewatching it. Korra is also good though.

Aaron Davies

Never heard of Barry , or legend of Kora , Sherlock is that the one with Benidict cucumber in . Battle star is amazing , solid each season

Xeph

ATLA is less of a child's cartoon than you might think, especially in season 2 and 3. Korra is straight up directed more towards teens than kids.

Camaro English

still no westworld ;( BUT KORRA LETS GOOO

MadIcelander

It’ll be a crime if Barry doesn’t win this

Danishprince

Always a shame to see people just cutting off shows like that just because "it's a kids show". You're missing out on so much great storytelling in general :)

MadIcelander

Barry is arguably the best show on TV right now.

MadIcelander

It’s dark humor. It’s more hilarious than anything.

Gomi

Not sure if this is on your radar but check out Dark on Netflix.

Erik Stevenson

Funnylilgalreacts is about to start BSG after she finishes Firefly (couple months out).

LightsCameraJake

Might go back and watch ATLA at some point maybe to see it but not sure thought

Alan Felicia

Chose Sherlock as I'm a fan of Benedict Cumberbatch and hoping for Nat to also watch one of the Sherlock movies with Downey Jr to compare performances

Rijona

I’m still waiting with my fingers crossed to see Band of Brothers win a poll 🙏🏼

Daniel Quezada

Barry is a masterpiece from Bill Hader. No matter the Poll, you’ve got to check it out. A show that can switch between very dark themes and comedy so smoothly is a rarity, and Barry does it easily.

Erik Stevenson

After she does Ted Lasso S3 she'll prob do a poll of shorter series since she'll be doing LOK for forever. My guess is Band of Brothers and Andor will be on that poll as they've both done pretty well in polls previously,

MacGuffinStuff

Battlestar Galactica was cool, seriously. And Star Trek: The Next Generation, I mean, the episode where we meet Q, that alone justifies some love in the poll.

Timminson

Korra would be so good!

Danishprince

Korra is 53 episodes lol and she'll most likely end up doing 2 episodes per upload just like ATLA

Erik Stevenson

Sure, so six months haha. Definitely longer than it will take to get through the third season of TL + probably another 1 or 2 shorter series.

Atreyu Auryn

Battlestar Galactica, or ANY show that isn't heavily watched by a lot of other channels lol, please.

Danishprince

How the hell are you getting 53 episodes to last 6 months dude.. 53 episode with 2 per upload = 26/27 upload slots. 2 uploads per week = 13ish weeks which is a bit over 3 months. That's really not that much for an entire series

Danishprince

Bit over the 4 seasons she's looking for xD

Erik Stevenson

Why are you assuming she'd do 4 episodes of LOK a week on top of other shows? Recently we've been getting 2 episodes of hour long shows a week. Personally I'd be happy for her to burn through LOK to get it out of the way, but just seems unlikely.

Thomas Richter

Barry is Super good and relatively short

Rime Pendragon

Barry is great. Sherlock is garbage. Watch hbomberguy's video "Sherlock Is Garbage, And Here's Why" to find out why.

Danishprince

Several reasons. She usually does 2 uploads of the same show per week (at least when she's not traveling) and I'm assuming she's gonna do 2 episodes per upload because that is what she did with ATLA since they're short episodes :)

Mastervodo

So say.... about less than 1/3 apparently.

Steve J

oh come on, it's only 320 episodes or so... :)

Kev Martin

Some great candidates I'd either like to see for the 1st time or have never seen. Or a cartoon show. Hope the poll turns around in any other direction.

Ron

Yes, +1 for Twin Peaks!

euclid

Barry for SURE

Berry

As much as I love Star Trek, it's probably not a good show to watch on the channel. The best classic seasons are all later seasons and the seasons are very, very long. Even at its best it's not really fun "reaction" material. The newer Chris Pine movies are standalone watchable and not terrible, but also nothing special. Sherlock starts strong but ends up being kinda meh. Battlestar Galactica is pretty cool, especially the first seasons. A bit like Firefly but much larger in scope. I haven't seen Legend of Korra. Barry seems like the best fit. It relentlessly mocks the LA scene, it's relatively short and has amazing (black) humor.

jamie jones

@eric- if you dont have respect for women why are you even subscribed to this channel?

Danishprince

I would 100% vote for just the first 5 seasons as those are what the show were originally meant to be and even has a nice wrap up

SilentBobFather

Sherlock is only 15 90 minute episodes. I hope you eventually watch it.

overdev

finally someone who is willing to watch a Star Trek show :)

Benjamin Muscanere

Oh please do Barry. Its one of the best shows ive ever seen. And its not that long!!

Eve

It probably won't ever be on a poll, but Sons of Anarchy is one of my all time favourite shows. Can recommend!

Steven

Legend of Vox Machina!

David

Battlestar Galactica would be WILD because of how dramatic that show is. I can't even imagine how many shocked-nat faces we'd get lol

Colter

Need some Doctor Who love in these polls

Chris Biebel

So you'd do a poll for which Star Trek, but not for which Battlestar Galactica? (j/k)

Baron

Thank you Nat for all the polls where you let us all choose content for you to react to. I may personally be disappointed with the results BUT I appreciate the fact that you make these polls for us to vote on content. There is so much content out there to watch and enjoy it must be tough to come up with polls because no matter what you do someone is probably gonna not appreciate what you choose. So all I can say is Thank You because what you do is AWESOME!

Daniel Vezina

Orphan black is a thousand times better then any of these. 5 seasons, 10 ep each. So underrated, had the mischance of airing at the same time as 2 other juggernaut. GoT and Breaking Bad. Tatiana Malsany deserved to win the Emmy for every years, instead she got a pity one for season 5.

Inhale Burrito

Is that Netflix Sherlock or Elementary?

Arronax06

I think it's neither, given the title it's BBC's Sherlock :) (I didn't even know Netflix had a Sherlock show too)

Arronax06

If it's not too much to ask, what channel watch those shows? None of those shows are watched on other channels I follow, so I'm interested in finding new ones :)

Arronax06

Legend of Korra is the continuation to "Avatar, the last airbender". All I know of Barry, is that people that watched it comment a lot, so I guess they liked it :D

Arronax06

@Erik Ah cool, I never went back to check the result of that poll :) . FLG is definitely one of my favorite reactor, that'll be a good watch :)

Steve

what version of star trek is on the poll? if it's the original series, i'd be down, but i'm a pretty niche crowd. if it's the new stuff, i really hope we can hold those off as long as possible. it's best to see what star trek is for fans of many iterations of the show. it's a completely different thing now, treated as an IP instead of a reflection of society.

Dolanator9

Marvel/FX’s Legion It’s 3 seasons and it’s different from any superhero show you’ve reacted to (except possibly Moon Knight… for… reasons) I highly recommend it and would say more but going in blind I think would be worth it.

Arronax06

We don't know yet, she said there would be a poll to decide which Star Trek to watch :)

Arronax06

What other reactor did you see do Legend of Korra, if you don't mind me asking :) ? I'm looking for a good one, if you have a favourite :)

Peter Jones

I think you should dive into the Expanse. I’d love to see you react to that. Season one is good. But there’s a lot of world building in the early episodes. Hold onto your seat for season two.

Richard Maurer

Yeah, I really doubt if Natalie is going to budge on this one. I don't know if you follow Addie Counts channel but she just started Ms. Marvel.

Matt Gwinn

You'll get through Sherlock faster than the others, because the seasons are really short, but it's pretty awesome. BSG is really good too, but it's a commitment. You really need to watch the whole series. Barry is also really good. Korra is alright. It's worth watching, but not rewatching

Summer

“instead of a reflection of society” lol in what world??? 😂

Summer

I love bsg and it’s a great watch (mostly) but I’m desperate for someone to watch modern star trek 🤞🏻🖖🏻

Richard Maurer

I wish more reactors would do this show. It wasn't even poorly rated, numbers-wise or review-wise. Don't know why it gets overlooked so much.

Richard Maurer

If the best shows were put in this poll, it would be a completely different poll. Battlestar Galactica is a pretty good show (I voted for it) but it doesn't really make for great reactions - as least judging by what I've seen so far.

Richard Maurer

Funny, of course she means the 78 series.

Richard Maurer

She said she's skipping both She-Hulk and Ms. Marvel.

Baron

Sherlock, the BBC show was on Netflix for a long time, it is not on Netflix anymore. Netflix does have Sherlock content like The Irregulars which I thought was laughable bad, using words that literally did not exist in a period tv show especially a Holmes one is bad. But they do not have a show called Sherlock, they have those two Enola movies....

Daniel Vezina

Orphan as plot twist every t3 episode, I think It would make great reaction, I also think it would do great on Youtube

Jenny Tolls

Oh wow I never thought she would return to Korra

Richard Maurer

Andor is a short series - this poll is for long series. For the record though I'd rather see Andor than anything in this poll.

Richard Maurer

I second Invincible, but for another poll. This poll is for longer series.

Caomhan84

Neither did I. I'm surprised to be honest. Although maybe she heard the stuff about the movie coming in 2025, and the leaked animation image showing the adult "Gaang"

Bryan Bryan

BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY

Richard Maurer

Rob and Trin is one of my favorite new channels. They did a wonderful job with Lord of the Rings.

Rey

God i would love to see you react to barry just for the reason youve worked in casting alone lol

Daniel Linan

Has there been any mention of shows like Breaking Bad or Ozark?

Lean

i think she saw breaking bad, not sure about ozark, do recommend

Richard Maurer

As if I needed another reason not vote for it.

Richard Maurer

Don't get me wrong, OB would be a great show, I'd vote for it in minute. Instead we get indeterminate Star Trek, dollar store Avatar, and Barry.

JD Shick

Man Barry is such a good freakin show. Even if it doesn't win the poll, definitely would love a reason to rewatch it here at some point.

Shawn E Mercado

Star trek is an enormous can of worms, and not all of it is good. The older shows that people care about (TNG, Voyager, and DS9) are alot of seasons, with the old 20+ episodes per season model, and mostly one-off episodes written on what are obviously very tight budget and time constraints. OG Trek is kind of the same except u think it was canceled pretty early on, but obviously you have like six movies. It's losing anyway so it's moot, but I'm just trying to say one season of, for instance, Voyager is about the same run time as 2 or 2.5 seasons of game of thrones. And there are 7 seasons. And that's just one of the shows. Honestly if you were going to do any of those older shows, I would seek out some sort of consensus fan recommendation on which episodes are must watch, which ones are "good", and which ones ultimately can be skipped.

Anonymous Groucho

"Star Trek would just be one season to start." I'm not sure Natalie knows what that sentence means and I know I don't.

Shawn E Mercado

I also want to say, The Wire. Pretty please lol

DaftBasterd

"LM Reactions" are two wonderfully fantastic reactors for Legend of Korra! Highly recommend!

DaftBasterd

@Rev.J Yet there are 76 episodes of Battlestar Galactica and she put that on the poll

Anonymous Groucho

Does she really mean season one of TOS? I've wanted her to go intro Trek because of my love of Trek, but I assumed it would be the movies.

Dean

Andor is only one season (of two total seasons) so far, just won a Peabody, and is fantastic. I’d be very interested in getting your reaction to it ESPECIALLY if you haven’t seen Rogue One (watch Andor before)

MertzRocks

Although Star Trek TOS is one of my favorite shows of all time, its episodes are somewhat disjointed and there is no over-arcing storyline (in those days soap operas had a bit of a monopoly on those lol). So I went with Battlestar Galactica 2004, since The Expanse is not on this list (hope you didn't forget about that one) and I wanted to pick a sci-fi show. Galactica is still a well-written, well-produced and well-acted human drama set in space and is very character-driven. Even when plotlines thin a bit, the show finds a way to bounce back strong again. I continue to highly recommend both it and The Expanse. Besides, I've not seen anyone react to Galactica yet (the Expanse yes). However, it doesn't look like any sci-fi is winning this poll anyway lol...

DaftBasterd

Personally super disappointed that BSG got in but Expanse didn't, considering almost every comment on the poll announcement the other day was about The Expanse and the fact that BSG has more episodes than The Expanse. Barry is my second choice but man, I thought The Expanse would for sure be included on the poll. Everyone should see the show! Next time maybe!

Shannon Turner

Sherlock is, hands down, the best TV show ever.

Anonymous Groucho

I'm learning from these comments is The Expanse is something I need to be watching.

Chris H

Incase anyone is on the fence; Sherlock is what, 12 episodes long for the entire series? 13 counting the special episode. Sure they are like small movies but we'd be able to get through it much faster than the other series. Plus it's been forever since I rewatched it and would love to atleast watch the first two seasons again!

KamikazeCDN

I have hope that one day Sons of Anarchy will appear on the radar

Mike Hell

Yeah I'm a little surprised with BSG being included and not The Expanse, but oh well. I voted for Barry because it's the best thing ever.

CJ

Sherlock is incredible and one of my favorite shows. Hope it wins!

Mike Hell

Agreed. Episode 6, The Sound of Her Wings, was phenomenal. Very few reactors watched it. I'm sure Nat would love it. And it's only what, 11 episodes?

Mike Hell

I'll just say that I'd have voted for The Expanse over any of these shows, but my vote is for Barry because Nat would absolutely love the theater atmosphere, and with the end of the series just a few weeks away, I'd love to watch the first seasons again.

Chris H

I enjoyed all 4 but those first two season were something special!

Jeff E

I think Nat chose BSG over The Expanse because she wasn't looking for shows with more than 4 seasons (The Expanse is 6 seasons).

Corthos Entertainment

Yes! I have an earlier comment for this, and some support on it too. If we all talk about it together maybe we can get her to try series 1 with Eccleston??

Corthos Entertainment

Sadly they removed Westworld from Max. It’s not available anymore. It’s a FANTASTIC show … just off the table for a little bit I bet

Corthos Entertainment

Doctor Who really needs some more love from the reactor community. Too few have experienced it’s awesomeness

MertzRocks

She has reacted to Rogue One.

Rasheed Asse

Legend of Korra would be great , I feel like you would love it

eemersonm

Agree with all of this

Caomhan84

She would. A lot of people here, and for over a year, have said that the show is worse than ATLA, but Korra has many things that Natalie was specifically looking and wishing for in ATLA, plus it has more of a "normal drama show" structure. So a lot of viewers here might not appreciate it but I think she herself would.

Arronax06

Ah ok, that makes sense, thanks :)

Arronax06

As far as I understand, she meant 1 season of any Star Trek series, the specific serie would be determined in a later poll :)

Jeff E

I hope "Sweet Tooth" on Netflix is included in a poll soon. I really wanted to find a show that Nat would personally enjoy, without being terrified or disgusted. "Sweet Tooth" is charming and fantastical, but also has serious, thought-provoking social commentary and I think Nat would absolutely ADORE it. It only has 2 seasons and both have been great. Unfortunately, I haven't seen it mentioned in the comments anywhere, so I might be the only "golden nugget" interested in it lol. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Travis

I really think you would love “Shrinking” a show on Apple by the creator of Ted Lasso. It is funnier than Ted Lasso and nearly as heartwarming. Aside from that I’d love to suggest Succession or The Wire

Adam Doyle

Sherlock would be great because many episodes/storylines are self-contained and therefore viewers don't need to commit to a whole series, and can just watch 1-offs and it still be enjoyable.

Troy

I like all of the suggestions. I voted for Battlestar Galactica. It's losing, but it's my favorite out of the listed suggestions. But, can't go wrong with any of these shows though.

David Sumner

Please stop saying Sherlock. That show is not good. Yes, Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman are good in it, but overall it's just not a well written show.

MertzRocks

Natalie, There are lots of questions to resolve with Star Trek (which won't win so this is all a bit moot but I love doing this (lol) so here goes): 1- Which series? Of course TOS to start. Kirk, Spock & McCoy (Scotty, Uhura & Sulu and later Chekhov). But... 1a- Release order or production order? The release order is so disjointed that continuity is near impossible. The production order is better imo but there is still some inconsistency that most real Trekkers ignore today. BUT ALSO... 1b- Watch ALL episodes or just the 'BEST' ones? I would say the 'BEST' ones but then that becomes another poll--and a huge one--or POLLS. Season 1 has the most 'BEST' episodes, S2 is about half good half average to dreck (imo but don't get me wrong I still love some of that dreck lol), and S3 is mostly dreck with a few really good eps thrown in. There are many of us Trekkers who could possibly draft suggestions for a poll or polls, citing which are "must-see" episodes, which are "really good too" and the ones that are "easily missed". S1 has 29 episodes! That could be whittled down to 20 'BEST' imo but only with some hard choices. Also imo, there are TWELVE "must see" episodes just in S1, just 4 or 5 in S2 and 3 at the most in S3. IMO you can't watch ANY Star Trek without beginning with the Original. Other opinions differ. Sure, some of it is cheesy or corny or BOTH lol but some of that can be weeded out with careful selection of episodes, and SOME of that is essential to the charm of the show! As for the TOS Movies, I would recommend skipping the first one altogether (sssoooooooo ssslloooooowwww aaaaannd ponnnderoouuuusss lol). The ST2-3-4 trilogy is a MUST, 5 is pretty crappy imo and 6 is good but not good like 2-4 were good. If all you watched were 2 thru 4 that would be enough. All I will say (for now) about the other series I have seen (Only seen them all thru Enterprise plus just a few eps of Discovery): The Next Generation starts slow and doesn't really start to get good until S3 or S4. There are some really deep episodes in TNG. Deep Space Nine is about the same but with a different aesthetic, being a stationary post instead of a starship. The later seasons are very good with longer story arcs. Voyager was imo the pinnacle of Star Trek achievement but the overall story arc does have a few holes I won't get into here. Enterprise is often considered the worst Trek but I disagree. S1 takes a minute to get going and throughout the series there are missteps but I loved the characters (except one who they didn't develop near enough) and the last two seasons are stellar imo (except that damned finale... lol) *whew!* GEEZ! That's more than enough! Hope you enjoyed reading! Stay Golden Natalie! You are my first love as far as reacting goes. I leave you with one important parting thought: PLEASE don't forget about THE EXPANSE!

DDK

Pleeeaasee do Barry, i juust finished Season 3 and I’m obsessed with it. Great writing, keeps you on your toes. I don’t think Sherlock holds up as well as some folks remember…😬

Brian Moore

Star Trek will always have my heart, but I have to admit it would be hard to get through the original series from the 60s. Maybe do some “best of” episodes then move on to the movies and The Next Generation.

DDK

I just realized that Star Trek was in this poll and now I’m torn lmao. I still think Barry is the best choice, BUT, I’m 1000% down for whenever you start Star Trek (and I would start with The Next Generation series from the 80s/90s) 🖖🏾🖖🏾🖖🏾

MertzRocks

My "moot" comment is much longer lol.

MertzRocks

Natalie has seen Breaking Bad, though I feel she would do well to revisit and react to it. Better Call Saul as well (not sure if she has seen that but she told me she saw BB) as they are, imo, two of the best TV series ever produced.

Newtro

Korra and Sherlock 🫨

Dante

Nat keeps talking about how busy her summer is and how she's feeling a little overwhelmed. I do think it would be nice for her to do a shorter runtime show alongside Ted Lasso since the S3 episodes have been longer than normal. Barry is my pick and I think she'd like it the most out of all the ones on here, but if it doesn't win I really hope Kora does. Sherlock episodes are 90 minutes long so we'd definitely only get one per week and maybe even fewer movies because of the time commitment. I mean she could watch 3 Barry episodes or 4 Kora episodes in the time it would take her to finish 1 Sherlock episode. With Barry or Kora, she'd have way more time for movies than she would with Sherlock

MertzRocks

By the end of ep3, anyone should be intrigued enough to continue and by ep4 or 5, HOOKED.

Arronax06

No offense, but your opinion that the show is not good is equally as valid as the opinion of people posting that they like the show ;)

MertzRocks

Agreed. I would suggest beginning with 2005 Series1 and at some point later, at least after starting Series 2, polling for "deep dive" older stories from the 60s-80s

Dean

Dang

Richard Maurer

Star Trek will never win a poll because its fans can't even come to a consensus as to what version to watch, unless it's "all of it", which is a time commitment no reactor or casual fan will make.

Arronax06

So I might be misunderstanding something, but I'm pretty sure this poll is not for any of the movies, so I guess, none get her to Wrath of Khan? As far as I understand, it would be either the first season of TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT or one of the recent ones DIS, PIC, SNW

Richard Maurer

Yes, every episode was great, but The Sound of Her Wings was one of the most beautiful things I've seen in a series, ever. Can't wait for season 2.

Juliana Montenegro

I’m shook Korra is in the lead. Really excited about that one

DaftBasterd

BSG has 76 episodes, Expanse has 62. The seasons in BSG have like 20+ episodes each, compared to Expanse's usual 10 each, both show's episodes about an hour each, so going by the season number is kind of an illusion.

Slick447

Barry and Sherlock are both GREAT. Legend of Korra is cool too. I think Natalie would enjoy Barry the most, but I don't think you can go wrong with any of these choices.

Atreyu Auryn

OZARK! OMG YES, it's so goood, it's perfect for a reaction series and is only a couple of seasons. Hope she atleast puts in a poll.

Fredrik Larsson

Legend of korra? Really!? I feel sorry for anyone that has to watch that.

Bryan Bryan

The acting class scenes alone would be worth the reactions. BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY BARRY

Berry

Like mentioned before, Hbomberguy has a video (11 million views btw) about _why_ it's not a good show. In short, it's flashy and has some decent acting but it mostly just implies cool things around the corner without actually delivering. It also goes out of its way to mostly not be a Sherlock Holmes crime mystery, which is bizarre. It was a very frustrating watch for me, because it could have been much better.

Art Tiangtham

My favorite videos are of Natalie cracking up and I think Barry would be right up her alley. A huge no to Battlestar Galaxtica…let her laugh!

khaliqtessi

If you want a blast from the past, try to find some of the 90's cartoons like X-Men, Batman, Gargoyles, things like that.

matthew h

It doesn't look like Sherlock is available on any regular streaming service except Amazon, where you have to purchase each season. I like the show but I'm surprised its getting so many votes.

Kev Martin

If the channel ends up being Ted Lasso and Legend Of Korra based for a few months, I guess that's a good opportunity to take a break from it. Zero interest in either.

Vince Ledezma

I agree I feel like there is not enough comedy

Daniel Vezina

Gargoyles is such a gem. X-Men is getting a new season, she should check it, it's probably gonna be the version of those character that's gonna transfer to the MCU.

Daniel Vezina

No matters, it's the best one of the polls.

Anonymous Groucho

Okay. I think it's safe to say we have two hard cord Star Trek fans here. And my first memory was a TAS spot about pollution. But let's talk realistically. How can one get her into Khan without having the history we have?

DarthChef

My write-in vote would be for Band of Brothers. In a few weeks we will be celebrating the 79th anniversary of D-Day. And if timed right she could have the first episode available on Patreon by then.

Anonymous Groucho

Legend of Korra is gonna win this and I have no idea what that is. Of the things I do know.... Sherlock is brilliantly written. As brilliant as the character.

Pristineus Hoc

Sherlock has english humor and personality quirks that make it so memorable.

Brian Flaherty

its the avatar last air bender sequel series

Jenny Tolls

I am quite surprised that Korra is winning. I didn’t think her audience would be into that, especially with the controversies that surround it.

Smoolio

Ima resub for Korra

Coolbreeze

Ive been hoping you would get around to Korra ever since you watched Avatar. I'm a big fan of the series. And while it has its lows with weird story routes, its still quite entertaining and still a very good show. I pray Korra wins, I subbed for The Boys, and you'll keep my sub if Korra wins the poll for sure

SilentBobFather

Correct if you voted for Sherlock you may want to change your vote.

Jacob King

Korra!! Sherlock series are made up of three movie length episodes which wouldn’t be the easiest to react to especially as there at least one dud in each series.

Martin7777

Those voting Korra: she will definitely watch it at some point. Please consider changing your vote to Barry if you haven't seen it. Then you will get both :D

Danishprince

Just wanted to say it's really nice seeing a rational comment from someone in regards to not having an interest in what's currently being reacted to and just deciding to take a break rather than getting super salty in the comments which unfortunately happens far too often <3

Wes

I would actually resubmit for BSG, such an awesome series and story.

Lee Gannon

I'd probably only vote for a Sherlock series of was the 1980's Jeremy Brett ITV series.

Caomhan84

I already do that myself when she watches nothing but marvel or the boys or something like that. I have zero interest in it. But I do watch the movies on occasion. So there's no problem with just taking a break.

Ryan Spangler

Oof, tough choice between Korra and Battlestar, as they're both essential viewing, but I'm going with Korra this time!

Caomhan84

The streaming options for Sherlock are thin. It's something that the majority of her viewers are probably going to have to buy. The only option I can see is crackle, but that's just for people in the US and it has commercials so it's going to throw off people who stream with her for the full reaction. So maybe that's not the best thing to watch right now. Until it lands somewhere easier to stream.

That’s Not Acting

I'm not super jazzed about any of these, really.. Even Star Trek (of which I am a fan) being the original series....it's just tough to get through a little sometimes. It's pretty, very dated. Legend of Korra looks interesting but I haven't seen it myself. So maybe I'll vote for that one?

Caomhan84

I feel the same whenever I see Star Trek pop up on these polls. I've been a Star Trek fan all my life but none of the shows are well suited to reaction channels. They are the old TV model of 26 episodes a year, with a lot of filler, TOS in particular is very dated, and they take awhile to get going.

Trent_88

I neeeeeeeeeed Korra, I know some TLA fans hate on it and it has some issues. But it's honestly a beautiful show and I love it on a very deep level and it gave me strength when I needed it most.

Juwan kee

IMO Korea gets a lot of flak, some of it deserved but, most of it not. It is a pretty solid series I’ve been wanting you to watch.

SmokeAndACoffee

I voted Battlestar because it's just one of my favs and I feel it doesn't get enough love, but definitely looking forward to Korra! Season 1 is spectacular, and then rest is good. Last Airbender is just so epic that no way Korra or anything they did next could really live up to it, but it definitely is good in it's own right

Josh G

Korra is extremely mediocre. Sherlock is great but not really a long term series; would be finished rather quickly with only 15 movie length episodes. Barry has a smaller audience; strong demand from those that watch it. BSG is solid sci-fi and consistently good thru the show. Star Trek would be great if the TOS/TNG filler was cut out and would open a lot of reaction opportunities with all the ST content there is.

Josh G

I'd vote for ST if the filler was cut out. Lots of amazing episodes but not worth a reactors time to sit thru the garbage ones also.

Caomhan84

But then the question becomes how you cut the filler out? You can't have polls for every series because then fans would argue over episodes. If you Google an episode guide of just essential storylines and limit yourself to those episodes, you're going to have people that are unhappy in the comments that you didn't watch such and such episode because it wasn't on that particular list. There's no way to win here. That's why I honestly think that Star Trek is best avoided on something like a reaction channel unless the person is an existing fan.

Gabriel Dehan

Battlestar Galactica is one of my favorite TV show of all time, it's such a solid show, and a staple of any sci-fi lover

kirt bang

if its the benedict cumberbatch sherlock , that is like my top 2 of tv shows i ever seen in my life. murder mystery. he’s probably the perfect casting of sherlock and dr strange all in one

LightsCameraJake

Both the classics and the newer remake show are great! If she ever does watch it, I hope its the remake however.

Chris Geyer

The problem with Star Trek is that almost every single one of the first seasons, was trash, except for strange new worlds, which only has one season

Chris Geyer

Have you thought about doing quantum Leap?

Chris Guerrero

Can someone tell me when she usually announces who won ?

Danishprince

Usually happens when she talks about it in an upcoming video or when the uploads for the series happens - She don't really do a post to announce the winner of a poll

Cuttlefish

Legend of Korra won. RIP.

Logan Kerlee

I don't believe she means ToS Star Trek. I think that there would be a poll to decide which series to watch.

Phillip Elbert

If anything in this poll beats Sherlock then I give up.

bread

KORRAAA!!!

Angel Sanchez

Noooooooooooooooooo lol jk Korra is probably great but I could really go for Sherlock...you know.

Vincent Valentin

idk how Sherlock is beating BSG . literally never heard anyone talk about it after it ended

Inhale Burrito

I remember bing watching a Sherlock show with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman I swore I watched it on Netflix but it's been years so maybe was somewhere else.

Logan Kerlee

Looks like I'll be taking a month off of here. Not a fan of Legends of Korra. I'll totes be back after that wraps up though! Good vibes, everybody! :)

Ernesto

Star Trek is an interesting choice as it is way too long. I think TNG is nearly double the time of watching Iron man to Avengers End Game. I love it, but that's a lot. BSG was a disappointment. I would actually recommend Farscape as a scifi show instead to watch as it is underrated and not often reacted to. Especially withe fact that Peacekeeper Wars is available digitally to watch (It was only available on dvd for a long time).

WWW

Would have loved to see: Peaky Blinders, Bridgerton, Ozark, Castlevania, Haunting of Bly Manor (loved your last Haunting series reaction) - anything but these to be honest! I hope you can react to one of these in the future!

Kevin Mowery

Farscape would also be a good choice because, unlike Star Trek most of the time, it's got ongoing plotlines to follow.

PureGonzo

I second this! All of those are excellent.

Atreyu Auryn

Ozark, definitely. Amazing series.

UngawdlyJish

Oh yeah, I forgot about the American one. I hope the BBC one is what she means.

LightsCameraJake

Ozark in my opinion is as stressful as breaking bad in a lot of parts. a great show I hope Nat sees someday.

Patrick Egan

Farscape was a lot of fun, if a bit uneven at times. But man, the big climax of the Peacekeeper Wars mini-series to finish off the story was EPIC AF. Some of Ben Browder's finest acting ever.

Michael Bergeron

I mean Korra will probably last about 3-4 months. It’s unfortunate since it’s the only option in this poll I wouldn’t be watching along with. But if it wins oh well. Hopefully she will power through it quicker since episodes are so short

REDR58

"The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" from 1984 with Jeremy Brett! :)

Dante

Ozark was an amazing series until they absolutely botched the second half of the last season. Such a forgettable and lackluster ending

Mike Hell

So I'm just gonna throw this out there: I'll bet Nat didn't know that Sherlock wasn't on any streaming services before making this list, so if Sherlock had won, which it ALMOST did, she'd have had to cancel it and do another poll. I suggest doing another poll, but with Barry, Korra, and something else, just to make sure everyone gets a chance to vote on something that she can actually stream (and that we can stream, too). BTW I suggest The Expanse ;)

John Piazza

Y’all are weird. It’s the best thing on this list.

John Piazza

Who hates on it? Korra is just as good as A:TLA

John Piazza

Umm, Korra is just as good as Avatar

John Piazza

What controversy? And also her entire audience loved Avatar. Korra was just as good. Why would her audience suddenly not want that?

John Piazza

Are you on crack? It’s the best thing on the list.

Josh G

I think that opinion is in the minority but ymmv.

SmokeAndACoffee

I wouldn't call it mediocre; I'd call it good for what it is. And it is a kids show aimed at the young to mid teen demo. It's still got excellent writing, good stories, and lots of fun moments and characters. But its story line isn't quite as wide ranging as ATLA's was. I've made this comment myself, and seen others who feel the same, but Avatar: The Last Airbender is among the great stories of our generation. NOT necessarily animation, or cartoon, or tv series. Just STORY, period. I mean that on more levels than just what the narrative was, but how the art and music and cinematography (does that term still apply in animation? lol) all just blended together perfectly to make a masterpiece. Korra is just a pretty good extra show to help expand the universe of that world which, from what it seems, they plan to expand the Last Airbender world quite a bit with upcoming series, movies, comics, etc (I'm sure there is already plenty of comics and books out there, but I don't keep up with it too much lol).

Danishprince

It's on Amazon Prime though..

Mike Hell

only option is to purchase, at an average of $15 per season

Danishprince

Must be a region thing cause I have full access to all the seasons at no extra cost

Ian

It must become all four seasons are free on BBC iPlayer here in the UK

Caomhan84

SNW is actually the easiest entry point into Star Trek, even though I didn't like the show that much. Well, I kinda did. It just has some "NuTrek" annoyances that I just can't get past, despite me liking the overall vibe and most of the characters. But anyway, I agree with you. It's mostly light, fun, fresh. Any other approach to Star Trek would be a mess. And I've said elsewhere that I just don't recommend Star Trek for YouTube reaction channels. Unless the person is a fan already, it's just not episodically set up for YouTube reactions. And if, say, she would Google "20 best TNG/DS9 episodes" and watch them in order to skip all of the filler, there would be endless arguing in the comments about why X or Y episode was skipped. And there would be someone who wants her to watch "Code of Honor" despite how bad it is just to see a funny reaction.... Yeah. A mess best avoided.

Martin7777

If Henry Ford had asked people what they wanted, they would have said "a faster horse". People don't know what they want.

Jenny Tolls

You should watch That 70s Show! Tons of good content to react to and it’s a show that I know you’ll love!

Danishprince

I know they aren't as popular amongst the long term Star Trek fans but for someone that only got into it through the "new" movie trilogy I actually thought that was a decent way to be introduced to the universe

Jose Munoz

Community! The first three seasons are brilliant!

Garth M. Cassidy

Miss Natalie, I recommend you watch Lucifer it has 6 seasons all on Netflix. Pretty good show.

LightsCameraJake

Hey Daft jake here! Do you have like a discord or anything to DM you on my man?

Jonathan Barrick

“Black Sails” (4 seasons, Starz) Aimed at a mature audience, a fair amount of nudity/sex scenes and naval combat in the first season or so then tapers off. It’s a 1700s period piece revolving around high seas piracy, a few legendary real-world characters/pirates make appearances, though it may not follow their lore. My wife and I have watched the entire series a couple of times “Vikings” (6 seasons, History Channel) Also a period piece aimed at a mature audience, for the same reasons and once again tapers off as the series goes. Follows a character from the Old Norse sagas, Ragnar Loðbrok/Lothbrok [in Old Norse the letter ð (eth) makes the same sound as th in the word “this” or “that” instead of a “D” sound as it’s sometimes incorrectly pronounced], though it definitely diverges from the sagas with ‘inaccuracies’ to the mythology. Very interesting and entertaining though

Michael Bergeron

I don’t think it’s weird to have a different opinion. It may be the best thing on this list to you, and I’m glad you enjoy it. But it’s not something I enjoy, so to me it’s not the best thing on this list. That’s not weird. That’s just people enjoying different things and having different opinions. What’s weird is judging people based on their opinions.

Andrew Smith

No its probably the worst one on that list.

Thorton

Black sails and The expanse are both top tier not so talked about shows, vikings are great for 4 seasons or so

Jonathan Barrick

Agreed! The last couple of seasons of Vikings seemed to drop the ball but was really good before that

ccc

Have you ever considered Supernatural? It may be out of your taste though

David Sumner

That show's 15 seasons and each season is around 22 episodes. Way too long of a project.

Steve J

I think Strange new Worlds first season was better than the average StarTrek since they had a whole season of set-up in Discovery. By the time they got around to their own show it was kind of the second season already. That, and the show is just better on a lot of levels. I've actually just started a TNG rewatch with my daughter about a week ago. I remembered the whole first season and a bit more just being really campy/bad, but is really only about the first 6-7 episodes that are rough.

Natalie Gold

I’ve seen it! Did love that show growing up

Natalie Gold

Oh I’ve seen the office believe you me! Haha

Xeph

Daredevil and The Boys are both TV-MA, aka they're rated mature. If that's not the bar for mature I'm not sure what is. Obviously there are things that are more mature, but in terms of a bar, TV-MA would probably be the bar.

Xeph

Gunna add a voice for Black Sails for a future poll, amazing show with one of the best final seasons I've ever seen, and it doesn't get reacted to a whole lot.

Razor Bikini

Admittedly I could have phrased that more clearly but I just mean we’re not using the word “mature” the same way. Those shows might be rated “for mature audiences” but they’re still pretty immature. Shows like The Wire, Mad Men, or The Leftovers are more what I had in mind. Shows with nuanced, adult themes, rather than superhero media for edgy teens (again to be clear, I like these shows, but they’re not particularly deep).

Fatal Spoon

Succession has Natalie Gold in it. Also it’s really really good.

DaftBasterd

Hey dude, my socials are the same everywhere, feel free to DM on twitter or whatever!

Iroh789

Expanse, how is this not higher on other people's lists.

Jonathan Giles

Hell yeah. Sherlock is great. Cant recommended Life on mars on enough

Tentomushi

Glad to see the right show is winning :) (Korra)

Jim

Wow this was close, too bad sherlock lost. I really love that show.

Connor Crout

Battlestar will likely never win sadly, but that series is honestly amazing!!!! putting it in a poll vs Korra and Sherlock is a rough challenge for it! Still recommend watching it though on your free time if you ever have the chance

Siti Dee

Oof Sherlock is 2% behind! Almost a tie :')

Adam Doyle

Definitely Buffy/Angel (for a future poll)

Amanda Speed

Buffy the Vampire Slayer! :D

Zach

DAMN was really hoping barry would win

Aythius

The first two seasons of Barry would've been so fun, especially the acting classes parts.