Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Next 4 Chapters

Hey Everyone, I'm going to be working on Chapter 72 a little more later this evening, but I still have a few things to figure out with it. Didn't want you all waiting around for me, so I said I'd upload them and get your thoughts. How it leads into Chapter 73 was a problem and I feel like there's something missing, but I just need to think on it a bit more. Thanks again for the understanding with the delay on chapters last week. Hopefully you'll enjoy this one. You'll be relieved to know we have an Appraisal in this batch. :P Hope everyone had a great weekend! :) All the best, Brian

Comments

Kurby

You evil evil man. I literally just layed down in bed to go to sleep. Now I gotta read these chapters first!

Karen Shelton

Whoa!! Got those out super quick. 🥳 can’t wait to read more of Coach. Thanks Brian. 😍

Nate

Thanks for the chapters, just in time to jump into bed and read. Don't know what I'm going to do at work tomorrow now though 😅

Nate

Wahoo take that Doc Ameye, Sal snagged ATHENA 🥳

Raymond Mouton

Btw, I thought chapter 72 ended just fine with that joke. Interested to see what follows though… next Monday… sigh…

Thomas Todd

Just woke up, it's a holiday here in the UK and this drops early. It's a good day

Thomas Todd

I really want to post the meme "He said it! he said the thing!"

UMCDaEMON pp

Love it. Never enough however :)

Pickled Rick

A great set of chapters and with the Prime skill definitely opens up a whole host of possibilities and getting all the Argento's into the pod to fix their damage will be great. Instead of terrifying first years with a teacher morphing into a Prowler combining Barry's ability with Prime would make an excellent simulation room for students to practice without losing limbs. Also like the idea of having tracker that give more traditional LitRPG stat guidance. I would consider maybe writing a connecting sentence between the last 3 chapters. Going from Coach to Fabi and Upgrade to Quest was slightly jarring so maybe add lines like "we need to show this to Quest this changes everything" or "I hope Upgrade or Fabi don't kill me when I show them this." It would just prep the reader for a passage of time between chapters. Also you are currently towing the line with how much Crafting Sal is doing with no immediate pay off and I don't want to see a repeat of Book 4. This is just my opinion but maybe limit crafting to improvements to the Elixer machine or Athena for the remainder of Book 5 (couple paragraphs) and stick with Dungeon Delving or Shade bashing for the remainder of this book. TL;DR: • Love Athena think it opens up a lot of changes to future growth for Sal and his guild. • Last 3 chapters need a better transition • IMO remainder of book needs to focus on action and the Shade climax.

Max

Question for chapter 70 Why would Sal need to check with Upgrade and Fabi and not only with Upgrade.  Upgrade is his teacher and mentor and this build does not use any essence programming.

42

it feels a bit like you learned a new word and just had to use it a bunch...

Nate

We have the book name meaning!!!!! Fits perfectly too

Andrew Tobin

Book one comments: “Sal seems so OP…” look at him now!

Lisa Johnson

I like the last chapter. It not super exciting but it’s a great transition. I’m imaging or hoping next week will be all about dungeons, Shade and maybe a positive Guinea pig from Athena. Anthony?

R. Skye

Thanks for the chapters! I thought 72 read well. It covered Sal working through his imposter syndrome and covered why he needs to still take classes to better understand what he is doing. There is tension starting about his skill capability outpacing what they are ready to handle. I like the brainstorming session about solves. I think it will be interesting to see how many trackers the one iteration of Athena could viably support though Protocal does do city management if I remeber correctly. The difference would be power consumption... Protocal is tied into Ameye's infrastructure... Athena is not. I like the tracker concept as a way for people to remotely access their progression but I feel there needs to be a solve for their initial scans otherwise the bottleneck of needing everyone to go into the pod at least once could be rough given how in demand it will be.

Manpolar

Which word. I didn't notice much repetition

A.J. Polanowski

Woohoo thanks for the chapters! We will all be your legion 😎

Max

Feedback for Chapter 71 At least from my perspective, I don't think you hit the mood/feeling you were going for in this chapter.  Upgrade and Fabi are not funny at the start of the chapter - they are mean. Sal is afraid in this chapter and needs reassurance, but all he gets is feeling guilty. I really liked the third last sentence Upgrade said ("This is by far the best thing you've ever made, and a beautiful use of the Mythcrafter ability."). That is much more fitting for the character for me. I didn't know that I longed for a wholesome interaction between Sal and Upgrade, but after reading that paragraph, I knew it was something I needed. Upgrade was always teasing Sal, but she knew when it was appropriate. But what is much more memorable about Upgrade is that she has Sal's back and supports him when he is afraid. She always took her time to watch over him and make sure his build was safe. I miss this interaction, and I think this chapter could be a way to return to it.   I think you could have a chapter with a strong emotional impact if you changed some things about it. I would remove Fabi from this chapter because her dynamic is not helping. She also has nothing relevant to say in this chapter and the next. Also Sal needs to keep this invention secret. It makes no sense yet to involve Fabi, she's not part of the guildand she is no teacher. Instead, I would focus on the relationship of Sal and Upgrade. Sal needs his mentor and someone who can relieve his fears. Upgrade should take this situation seriously and her first reaction should not be mean and making Sal feel guilty. She could reassure him and tell him he build something beautiful but they need to discuss with Quest how they can implement that safely.   I think that could make the chapter memorable. Like it is right now I don't see myself coming back to this chapter to read it again.

Book Wyrm

Can I suggest ending the chapter with Legion and moving taking the piss outa sal to the beginning of the next chapter.😉 Think that slightly works better as this chapter is a bit of a climax for the book. The only thing you might be missing, is hype I think. Your writing style tends towards amping up the hype and then ending the chapter on a cliffhanger. I'd say this chapter ends in satisfaction. Making this chapter a bit an exception. I normally would n't post suggestions like this, just trying to help out.

Sam

Isn't Sal still 18? I don't remember him having a birthday?

joey sorrentino

Its weird, i really love the crafting but in the back of my mind i just keep thinking is he ever going back to school or actually get these projects working to progress the guild. I was kinda hoping for a scavenger run where his bot just flies around and finds all the dope shit.

Pickled Rick

Slight correction but Fabi is 100% a part of the guild as she is basically 2nd in command on the hierarchy with Upgrade in the role of advisor like a Captain who will take the support members under her wing.

joey sorrentino

The book 1 vibe is so different lol. Remember it started with him just flirting and banging chicks. Now hes like 100 years old and is too busy tinkering. Like im sure part of it is to show hes maturing and understanding the big picture but hes still a teen and teens who have sex are unlikely to stop especially when so many women are interested in him.

Dawn Zeleznik

I thought the trackers were to eliminate the need for people getting in the pod. Have I misunderstood that.

Pickled Rick

Needing people to enter the pod for certain things will actually help keep the invention more controlled. If Bastion supporters can just buy trackers then they can help strengthen the enemy with little oversight but if the trackers only have limited functionality then having only 1 pod at the heart of Sal's guild headquarters will act as a good deterrent or at least slow the spread of who knows about the brains behind the Legion system.

Dawn Zeleznik

I enjoyed the chapters. I reread 72 and something about Fabi being so quiet and not meeting Sal’s eyes seemed off to me. She’s always been a very direct character, maybe it’s that for you as well? It kind of pulled my attention from Quest’s comments because I was thinking, “what’s up with her ?” That’s really the only thing that stood out to me. I hope that helps. Normally I don’t like to comment on stuff like that because I realize you have continuity editors and just plain old editors looking for errors or deviations. Since you asked for our ideas about it I thought I would try to help this time.

Max

But she didn't join officially. What do you think about the rest of my feedback?

Pickled Rick

It was actually part of my suggestion that Sal stop crafting for the remainder of the book. He has a machine that will build him gear, a machine that will make him potions to strengthen his essence gates and a machine that can show him how to improve his stats and hopefully his Silverson arts. Book 6 he could make a full size simulator with Barry's skill but for now Sal needs to actually use these new machines for all they are worth to get the Myth guild up and running.

Pickled Rick

I have a vague recollection of him having a party during the semester break (Book 4) but would need to reread the book to remember if it was a birthday or just a Saviours or Guild celebration.

Zwil

Really fun chapters, thank you!

Pickled Rick

Fabi's family business are one of the key backers for the Guild Headquarters so her membership is fairly official even if there is not enough slots to bring her on as an official member yet. I am very British with my reading so I don't see mean in the interaction between Sal and the girls because playful teasing is kind of how I would support my friends and vice versa in a normal situation that was not life threatening when someone is overanalysing something. The trackers will also very likely need Fabi (and the Fabricate skill) and maybe the Arkright exclusively in order to make different grade trackers so having her in this scene shortcuts the requirement of Upgrade passing the info on. With Essence programming failsafes built into each grade, again very much a Fabi thing, the user would gain more comprehensive information/access as the tracker's grade increases. Going into story ideas now maybe common up to rare trackers help you improve your weave exclusively up to set grades (higher rarity = higher grades) while epic and above trackers start to give weave combinations to evolve the person's weave further. Also helps with costs for Quest as he could buy a lot of common to rare trackers for the students to add more incentives to work hard while 5 or 6 legendary trackers would probably bankrupt him. They would make an excellent signing bonus for the Myth guild members though.

Max

Chapter 72 I don't get why they should split the System from the machine. You wrote that it should be fine if it is associated with Coach. Why go the extra mile. Also it is kind of weird that they talk about Shade and Sal is all mysterious but nobody really cares. I would assume you couldn’t change the subject so quickly if Quest thinks his students could be in danger because the .5% chance hit because Sal changed the future on purpose. If Sal tells you “Don’t worry I have it under control “ I wouldn’t believe it. Major red flag. The only reason Quest and Upgrade are in the room is because Sal can not estimate consequences.

Sam

The only party I remember was the post Gala party, which had nothing to do with his birthday.

Sam

Think that Fabi is just a bit overwhelmed and feeling a little outclassed by Sal. This is, what, the 4th major item he has made since she met him? She is used to be considering one of the best and now could be wondering if she can even keep up with him.

Max

Thx for sharing your thoughts. Maybe the understanding of the teasing is a cultural thing. I think there is nothing playful about it in this instance. And about involving Fabi at the start we come from different directions in this discussion. You think about what happens in chapter 71 and 72 and already know what is discussed. Therefore it makes sense to have her there. I wrote it from the perspective of the end of chapter 70.

M

These chapters are some of the most engaging of the book with key characters being more... in character. For Chapter 72, I personally do not understand the Athena => Legion distinction.

R. Skye

Agreed. Might also be an opportunity to create smaller quick scanners for updates that are located away from the guild/pod location.

Pickled Rick

If Athena is your PC then Legion is the OS (Windows or Linux). Basically Legion is the rebranding of Quest's system while Athena is the machine that will house that system.

R. Skye

My comment about the bottleneck was more along the lines of the same way Sgt Head quantified how many people could be helped. Assuming 1 person per hour between setup, scan, tracker/legion tutorial, and cleanup... there is a bottleneck on how many people can be processed by the main pod. Limiting it to the guild members only at first is great, but scaling will need to be addressed.

Ali Sha

Thanks for the chapters! I’m curious about how Athena actually works. Do people actually have to get in and be assessed first and then the trackers roll out and update the training plan? Or can people just skip getting in and it will work just off the trackers? If so it doesn’t make sense to me to make it a fancy tanning bed. Might be better as just a computer of some sort. Just my thought.

R. Skye

Does the world have an equivalent of a hacker for EssPro stuff? One of the concerns around the pod is access. The trackers, if integrated with the pod in a way that data is sent and received between the devices, could create an exploit. Would that be a concern Fabi or Upgrade would bring up or address if it is a viable concern? While Bastion may not be able to do this with their lack of essance related attunement/mutations... Locke with his private army...err... Sentinels... may pose a unique problem. Is that something the sheer processing power of Athena would be able to mitigate on its own? Could Ameye's infrastructure forceably network with Athena?

M

But if I have no PC (or visibility to it), then what is the point of Linux/Windows? To strain the metaphor further, if I can access Linux/Windows remotely, then why does my PC need a stormsteel seat? Why does Athena need to be beautiful? How does a visor read the abilities?

nin10do

I think that the book is great so far in the many relisterning of it one thing I would note is that the friends interactions are missing until elixir machines onwards and although Sal is annoying him with predicting his future book one they aren’t talking it’s like he out grown them and they going to be in the guild

Sherry Walles

I'm not sure chapter 72 is missing anything, but it seems the flow is just a bit choppy in the last two pages. That's a personal feeling, so with that and $4 you can get a cup of coffee, yeah?

Kerradeph

Yeah, this was my immediate thought too. Like, is there a way to lock down the esspro to prevent people from modifying it after they have their hands on it? What could be done if they were able to modify the esspro to remove the blockers from communicating with Athena? Could Nexus permission limitations prevent that kind of abuse? Could the esspro that handles access permission be done on Athena's side to prevent privilege escalation on the end user side?

Pickled Rick

A PC is more that just an OS, you have RAM, CPU, GPU etc. If a PC had Windows with Intergrated graphics but no GPU it won't play games very well because you need something dedicated to process the game assets faster and at a higher level. For the machine, Athena is the thing with all the necessary skills(PC components) to read you weaves and develops the improvement plan (run the game). *Athena has 4 specific skills while the trackers would be similar to Sal's in that they can exchange data packets with Athena but his/Athena's skills still do the heavy lifting. Legion and the trackers in this instance would be like the cloud based gaming trend that never really took off. A better tracker might give you higher access, higher evolution paths or merge recommendations (like a higher tier subscription gives you higher resolution games). The person sitting in the chair is uploading their unique weave condition, skill progress and stats (like the cloud company uploading a new game onto the cloud for you to play). If you don't sit in the chair (upload the game) the tracker software has nothing to access(no new game in the game library) to give the skill improvement guidance or track your skill/stat improvements against (your games save file when you reopen the game between sessions). If you need any further explanation I will need to drop the metaphors because that got more complicated than I was hoping.

Pickled Rick

They need to get into Athena first as Athena can scan the person to see their skill, weave condition, skill mastery and their current stat distribution. The tracker will just download your profile from Athena and use Legion to give you your stat sheet and quest log. The tracker will have basic skills to monitor which quests you complete and send that info back to Athena. The Prime skill in Athena can then extrapolate what quests you need to do next to progress your skill. By keeping the trackers simple it should keep costs down as it will basically act as a sophisticated go pro that links back to Athena instead of needing an expensive tracker like the one Sal wears which has its own set of high level skills built in.

Frilas Gilneas

I agree somewhat; the banter felt off for me, especially from the part where Upgrade pushes Sal aside to get inside. Before that, they were just at the point where Sal showed he wouldn't touch anything above epic grade, so it felt more natural. But when they storm in to see the craft after basically confirming it's mythic, I would have expected Upgrade to do a full body check on Sal first, since that was a big part of the last 20-30 chapters. Instead, nobody seems to even consider checking his health there. Fabi being there made complete sense to me because it's about the evolution of Protocol, and Fabi has worked directly with Doc and probably has more experience with this specific ability than Upgrade. With the added concern about drones, Fabi currently has more in-depth knowledge about how Jackal works. As a small note, you are absolutely correct. Looking at it from the guild's perspective, Fabi has so far shown support for the guild but has no intention to join it at the moment, and her family's business has also not been involved in any way so far.

Andrew Tobin

Yes, but… the relationship fell apart pretty spectacularly, even if they’re becoming friends. Sal from book one was suave but didn’t have friends. And he’s in his head about Fabi. I can’t wait for Destiny’s reaction to the new build tho.

Andrew Tobin

Because he knew Prime could use rules, was all about rules, and he trusts Fabi as a senior on builds and she taught him so much through the store. She is almost another de facto teacher.

Andrew Tobin

It’d be interesting to see coach or Athena with the Argento parents, whose powers are too much for them.

Pickled Rick

It feels more like Brian wanted to have machines take over some of the more tedious parts of guild management and he needed the Elixer Machine, Arkright and Athena to do that. If Sal wanted to make a legendary weapon for Sakura he could either build it offscreen, spend 3-4 chapters making plans and building it or 1 chapter where he and Sakura discuss parameters for the weapon and let Arkright build it. I can really see the machines having a huge payoff story wise going forward. I agree they have gotten in the way of his relationships a bit, albeit less so than in Book 4 when he made the Arkright almost completely by himself over half the book. Should be back to normal from next week I think.

Andrew Tobin

I didn’t take the banter as mean, but it wasn’t meant to be friendly or teasing. It was meant to be concern, reminding Sal of limitations, that he severely hurt himself last time, and that he should be planning his build, having guidance from his teacher, having support in case things go bad, not overdoing himself alone when he only just got out of hospital.

Andrew Tobin

I kind of agree, but that’s exactly where these chapters were leading - Sal saying he has to get into dungeons, and the showdown (or maybe anti-climax, or subversion) with Shade. I’ll be interesting to see what Athena says in between, but I would imagine there will be action shortly.

Andrew Tobin

@sam also, having just gotten a massive power out of nowhere (I know her real power was friendship, it was in her all along), the promise of getting mythcrafter when you were looking at a near powerless future is overwhelming. Can she even get another implant? I know Sal can do anything with weaves, but originally implants sounded like a super important, one-time thing, and she had one.

Max

Okay, but than they could just say that. Why make him feel guilty? Why can’t there be a wholesome interaction with direct communication. E.g. “Hi Sal, we are very concerned about your health. Are you sure you didn't overdo it. Were you wearing you regeneration equipment we built for you?” “That is very kind of you. Yes, I did pay attention about my health. Also Coach was there to supervise that my weave would not damage me. Please come inside, I need your help with something potentially dangerous I built. I need your evaluation if it is safe to use.”

Andrew Tobin

They talked about using trackers to give students basic mobile recording of performance and stats in previous chapters. Having it tied onto Prime and Athena now just makes that more powerful a concept. Having a few other powers like tracking of enemies, teams, data, etc would also be good.

R. Skye

I could see Anthony eventually becoming a EssPro White Hat.

R. Maxwell Steele

I think the healing device Sal gave them were supposed to fix the body power disconnect. It never seemed to make sense with how Sal couldn't fix the same issues in his own body, like a device that heals eyes to counter damage from all-sight and adapt to it's future use should have worked on Sal as well.

R. Skye

I think it's because of Sal's endurance vs his fathers. Petro may not be at 18 or whatever is needed but he has demonstrated he his stat block outclasses Sal's at the moment.

R. Maxwell Steele

Yeah unfortunately there's way more moving parts but the books aren't getting any longer. So somethings are losing focus. Like having a mythic drone that gets used once for the whole book and only on vastly under leveled opponents that he already could defeat without mythic gear. Kind of undermines the whole thing. I kind of figured it would be running dungeons nonstop in the background on autopilot. Or even just doing patrol sweeps in rough areas and expanding safe zones. Not just arm candy. Another example, I thought Arkwright would have made a huge pile of evolutionary uniforms, though my preference would be that they go to the hunters on the front lines rather than the students. But either way would work. It was a big focus that fell off. Sal also seems to replicate weaves on himself much less, for example Divinity's weave used to be a staple and now he avoids it. Fighting stuff was a cool addition, not that he really needed it and it made me dislike his parents, still undeniably cool. The hospital drudgery stuff was my least favorite but we've been told it's essential for something coming? So can't really complain about necessary plot points. And obviously I'm too greedy and to hit all the loose threads it would have to be double the length. So I get it.

Andrew Tobin

Yes, but I think Coach just proved Sal doesn’t know everything about it, and how to prevent the damage his dad faced. They can repair it, but knowing more about preventing, and safely improving it would be great. I also can’t wait for Gallant’s mom to show back up. I almost wonder if all this work, which could lead to improve Gallant is about to be the backfire that triggers Gallant’s villain turn as he grows impatient seeing all these things Sal has made and hasn’t given him (having not tested it enough) and he powers up and goes mental.

Pickled Rick

Petro was only doing slow damage to himself because he has higher endurance and he was only using the appraisal part of the weave and underclocking the power requirement. Sal has a lower endurance and he is using the full power of all-sight to assess the grades of his equipment during the final part of the crafting. The damage seems much more intense which is going over the critical level faster than he would have been able to heal it.

DRA

I am looking forward most to the showdown with Slade,

R. Maxwell Steele

That's not how I read it, I got that Athena can do the scans.. but using the data form external scanners works too. In fact she will likely be able to use the scans already in the skill orb machine. Which is why Sal was like oh I just thought they would read it off the screen. Which is how they hide Athena, they plan to build a bunch of scanners/trackers that connect wirelessly. Enabling scans and output from far away. First Athena just has to digest all the data. And I imagine the test group will get scanned directly, since the trackers aren't built yet. If everyone who uses the system has to physically interact with Athena, that secret isn't a secret for long.

R. Maxwell Steele

The system that everyone is going to have telling them what to do, and giving them the *ding* you just increased strength by +1. That is going to be the Legion System teaching people how to achieve power ups and grading them on their improvement. And they interact with it via trackers. It will consist of a bunch of interconnected stuff like the internet: Quest's old System dumb AI, a bunch of databases on random servers for context, the trackers for interface, and the new Athena coaching tips for guidance and the Athena dumb AI which is suped up to process everything and connect all the dots like map (or like an indexed server). So I'm thinking Athena is like a server/processor in the background that you never see. And the System is like the internet, the sum of all the computers connected to the system. And the tracker is like smart glasses that you use to get online. Though if the Arkwright has a smarter AI (dungeon core piece makes it smarter, a brain of sorts) and eventually plays with Athena over the network, it can open the door for a super AI. Which would actually have a personality and capacity to choose.

42

'catastrophise' it was only used 3 or 4 times but it feels as if a more ordinary wording would fit better in most places.

R. Maxwell Steele

I think a great reason is that as the System becomes more important, giving away information on key parts of the system makes those failpoints targets for terrorism. Athena is already too awesome just on a one by one treatment creation. As the heart of a LitRPG godlike system, it's just too much of a target. But if no one knows, it's just a mythic scanner in the background that the system can already do. The camouflage of assumed irrelevance. Additional features would just be added to the tracker, but does increase the cost and I think the main goal is mass production of basic functions. That said, I think features like mini map and stuff would probably make the cut. Especially since Athena can do most of that from distance while communicating with all the trackers. As for Sal's fear, they think it's borderline impossible for anything to go wrong and they probably made a note to check on that probability. So it's a comment that comes off as more of a scared teen than a real threat. They don't know he's planning to agitate Slade on purpose like we know. So they don't perceived the greater threat. Luckily Sal is bringing many assets that can each handle Slade one on one.

Ira White

OK I just blitzed everything from chapter 1 of legacies to here and I NEED MORE. Love this series keep being awesome.

Frilas Gilneas

I’m enjoying the chapters and the direction the story is taking, but I’m struggling with some of the logic behind skill evolution. Awakener evolving makes sense since it’s the skill Sal injected, but I don’t understand how Skill Master could evolve after being injected. If it were a skill specifically for items—like the one Sal created for the elixir machine—that would make sense, but evolving a human skill after removing the weave by adding it to an item feels confusing. Similarly, the ravel method in Awakener doesn’t seem like it should trigger a skill evolution. It feels more like it enhances the existing skill to an ultimate version rather than evolving it. Evolution, as shown with Fabi’s skill or Predator, happens when something new is added, like additional teeth to the weave, not just when a skill is refined. The pacing of the story also feels scattered. Since Coach appeared, there’s been an overwhelming amount of information and discoveries, and after Sal’s three-week rest, we’re suddenly thrown into a rushed one-week prep for Shade. This reminds me of the start of Book 3, but in that case, the rushed week served as a buildup to the tower, allowing for more depth later. Here, the rapid sequence of events makes it harder to stay immersed. The progression also feels uneven. A third of the book focuses on Sal designing and building the elixir machine in three days, followed by a three-week break and a single dungeon run. Now, we’re in a one-week prep phase, and it seems unlikely we’ll see Shade in this book. With around 90 chapters, I suspect the book will end on the day of the dungeon with the Delvers. Another time skip would feel odd, especially since so much time has already passed, and it’s Sal’s first week of actually taking classes after missing weeks. If he skips classes for dungeons, it’s hard to see how he can become the top savior while missing such crucial time, since realistically he should be on the verge of failing his classes. Going by the more slice-of-life direction at the start, the skips should be between meetings instead of everything happening at once, then a week skip with nothing, and then everything at once again. That would also work better with the attempts at introducing POV changes. Lastly, I wish we had more clarity about Brophy. He’s mentioned repeatedly and used as an example by Coach, but Sal never asks what happened to him. This makes the topic feel unresolved and more like a distraction from the main narrative. Looking forward to seeing how these elements develop in the next chapters!

nin10do

I think he suffered from nightmares from what he was seeing though out the vision but although with legion it would upgrade divinity weave so she could see further and have wings using her upgraded weave when it considered safe to roll out I say that I probably say that it would be a year 2 rollout so everyone has maximum essence gates.

Jonathan Campbell

Sal is going to be confronting Deathstroke about something? I definitely missed that crossover being teased!

Ron Blondeau

Nothing wrong with these chapters, they are great. Nice to see Upgrade and Fabi advising Sal. The complexity of Sal's inventions is sometimes hard for me to follow but not for some obviously. Something else is bothering me about this story, not in a bad way but from another angle. Sal is 18 or 19 years old. This is the time in a male's life when testosterone peaks. Sal had "a bit of fun" with Hannah and it has been stated that he finds Upgrade, Vanessa, Divinity, and Fabi beautiful. Is it time for that aspect of the story to mature?

Sloth

The whole assisted suicide interaction feels very off-tone for the series

Justin

I think that would be like asking the healing machine to give you bonus strength or dexterity points.

Justin

I can't compliment these chapters enough, the crafting, the character interplay, the set-up for future schemes...Like I said in Discord, I just wanted to keep quoting everything I was reading! Well done again Brain, and please make every day a Monday lol.

Tanstaafl

After reading this set I am struck with the notion that folks would want to have something over the eyes - a tracker. This seems ovely complicated to get a report from Athena.Why not just deliver it to their Quest tablet [of non Quest device] from Prime? For Quest members, pay -sit - recieve summary on screen and recieve full report via tablet after 1 hour. This would help reduce the attention on Athena. For Guild acces they and the Guild would recieve the report after 1 hour, indiivduals would recieve the report after 1 hour. That timing could be reduced over time and for Coach to have the full results to consult with individuals

Nicolas

Thank you so much for these chapters!!!! Love the crafting and cant wait to see the results of legion!

Pickled Rick

Because the guilds don't have quest tablets and the tracker can record you completing the tasks as you do them and track your stats unlike a tablet as they grow

Dutch Palmer

What's missing before the next chapter is the appraisal!

R. Skye

The reread does make it seem off, but I think that is because it is the first signs of Fabi having PTSD from her experience at the Gala. This is her first time seeing a machine similar to what she got into. I can see her getting triggered a litte by it. After the incident happened she was swept up in excitement, brought to a party, worked on a mythical device with arguably her closest mentors... she hit the dungeons to try and master her ability and came to the conclusion to lock down her ability till she gets control. This could be seen as escapism to avoid processing the trauma. She has to completely reaclimate to how she does things now that she can literally handwave things into being. Then, when she is finally getting comfortable with her new powers the one person who was essentially her savior destroy his eyes on a project. A project she used her powers to make better. After the incident she escapes provessing the trauma again as she hit the dungeons hard. While it was stated it was to help get components and build something to help Sal... that behavior is destructive. The dark humor manifesting is just another sign somethings not right with Fabi. I may be mistaken though with my read on things.

Brian J. Nordon

The Appraisal of Athena is in there, what one are you talking about?

Tanstaafl

I would assume that the Guild members and population in general have phones / tablets.

Dutch Palmer

They talk about the appraisal, but I've read through the chapters twice and didn't see solid definitions for all the abilities talked about. Where is the table?

Brian J. Nordon

It's in the middle of Chapter 70. After "He already knew what it said."

Lizzie Dean Makes

I agree with others that we need less solo crafting and more social interactions for a bit - there are so many collaborative projects that they could create blueprints for and have the Arkwright auto-produce and Argento Auction distribute - like sets of those pocket dimension satchels he designed last semester for a commission for scavenger network or lower grade grappling hook coats for that medic guild, or scanners for hospitals, or the clothes that help people slowly evolve their abilities like the suit he made for his dad etc, all they need to do is send blueprints to the Arkwright right? So I would totally be designing starter kit type sets for each of the other guilds and major factions with the common grade evolutionary runes and equipping all the people who can’t afford high end commissions from a crafter directly - there is so much low hanging fruit, never mind armour and weapons. Sal already has trips lined up to see the refugee cruise ships and identify their equipment needs, as well as invitations from other big players like Ark guild and the medic guild etc. I want to see the stuff he has already made changing the world before he goes and builds another earth shattering thing that then isn’t being used - so far he built all this stuff and has the ability to unknot weaves etc but none of it is actually being utilised fully because everyone is super cautious.

Lizzie Dean Makes

And by satchel I mean the they asked to be a satchel he turned into a sort of toolbelt - I think it was for foraging but it struck me that’s the kind of thing the scav network needs - I had tons of craft ideas for the scavs - like if they could infuse metals and wood like Sal does and turn them into ingots they could get more than 10 runs out of a location before it was exhausted - maybe a portable device that can take in wood/metal/stone etc and produce regular sized infused composite base products that might not be the best epic crafting material but would be highly useful in quantity for mega projects like the reclamation guilds or Ark. the sheer amount of jobs for unskilled labour like the refugees without their own skills that could be produced by equipment that they could use to become useful to the powers that be on land without having to fight demons themselves.

Sloth

Ah. See, I didn’t connect any of that. I think, if the author has been going for this the whole book, that perhaps it needs to be made more clear in editing. But yes, this does make a lot more sense from that lens

Frilas Gilneas

That is an amazing idea. By creating harvesting gear like that to refine wood and other materials into even the lowest form, they would solve one of the biggest issues in the crafting section: not having enough materials to learn with. With Sal having created the fort that can grow, you could basically create a guide on how to do it and give the refugees a way to build themselves a place to live by growing houses. That way, you can use the number of people so that those with crafting skills can work together, while everyone else can provide essence for refining and accelerating the growth process.

Dutch Palmer

And I'm the idiot who stopped reading halfway through the chapter. Thanks for the pointer. Great chapter, btw.

Pickled Rick

I wonder if Divinity's weave can evolve. Presumably an evolved version of her ability would allow her to navigate possible futures with more control and efficiency and maybe even give more detail for far future readings.

nin10do

I believe she can with the discription of her when she shows Sal the ideal future she has more intense glow eyes and her hair blowing in a canteen talk about a storm moment like in x-men I think Sal accidentally changed her weave so much that in book one she had so much trouble in Lombardi class from when he accidentally interacted with her weave I like to think that she was the first even though I’m probably reading too much into it

R. Skye

They most likely do, but they are not synced to Athena and they do not have the right EssPro/skills/tech to actively scan/monitor/update the way a purpose built tracker would allow for.

M

I did the same thing. Table skewed the pagination so I, too, thought the chapter ended.

Ira White

Why not both? When you think about it. They could use the tablets for the students and the visors or eye patches for the guilds and rich students who want to spend Q cred to look cool or for convenience.

Pickled Rick

Sal improving people's weaves is the element from the early parts of the story I miss the most. It didn't take a lot of page space and the character immediately got a large boost to their capabilities.

R. Skye

Yea in book 3 he corrects Upgrade that he is only 18 when she thinks he is 19. There was never a mention birthdays, but we do not know how this rebuilt society handles them. I think Coach is mistaking Sal for being older because of everything that he accomplished to date. Sal never corrected Coach. Given how Coach is busy he may not have fully read Sal's profile or hust forgot in the moment given their entire interaction.

nin10do

On text is Legion copy right to the hand held or doesn’t that matter in text/name of os system well anthena

Gecko

interested to see the "Sovereign" drone(s) in action and the valkyrie suit to be done

Jonathan Robichaux

I've done that before where Adobe, like, sections off the appraisal to another page and makes it seem like the end

Sam

How do you think the drone would be running dungeons without him and still be kept a secret? You have to sign in to run a dungeon and I'm fairly sure someone would notice either a drone entering the dungeon or if not, then the next person to run the dungeon sees only dead, harvested corpses. The evolutionary armor is supposed to be the crafters' big project so if Arkwright does it, then it defeats the purpose for the crafters, making them again redundant. And he used Divinity's weave once on his own and then every other time he used it was for Quest and the Doom Society. He has not used other people's weaves for himself on a regular basis since starting school.

Sam

Yup, sounds like when Sal planned the build, he expected people to get scanned by Athena but now they are planning to use trackers instead. So he didn't need such a big build after all.

Sam

Was what she got considered an implant or an imprint? Cause I think it was hinted that you could get both (as long as you paid) whereas you could only get one implant.

Sam

You do realize that most people don't talk that way unless they have had extensive therapy?

Ty

Fantastic chapters I didn't think chapter 72 was missing anything. I can't wait to see Athena in action!

Brett 'Swantz' Swanson

I've been reading Quest Academy for a few months and I love the series! I've been editing along the way (30 years teaching, I can't help it!) but now maybe I can help my fellow readers before the books are published! Anyway, a mistake that I've seen several times in other books is the incorrect usage of "conscious," when it should be "conscience." The first is when you're aware/awake of something whereas the second is your moral viewpoint.