Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks, this time you DON'T know the drill. This week's Friday episode is going to be Matt's ultimate guide to the NY Trump trial. And so, this week, if you have any questions whatsoever about the trial, post them here so Matt can answer them on the show!

Also, if you do still want to post episode ideas, that's never a bad idea and we'll always take a look at them!

Also also, we're covering some SCOTUS cases soon, probably the immunity and the homelessness one, so any questions on those are welcome!

Thanks!

Comments

Ruairi Hipkin

Something I’ve seen in a lot of US criminal trials, counsel will refer to “exhibit number [whatever]”, show the item to the witness, then formally adduce (move) it into evidence. Why does something have an exhibit number before it’s been admitted into evidence? Don’t items get exhibit numbers once admitted?

Cameron Kushwara

Devin Nunes crying about unregulated capitalism happening on trump media and asking Jordan, Comer and the rest of Clown College to fix it. But mostly just because I want Matt to explain the difference between "shorting" and "naked shorting" and for Thomas to make jokes about it being cold.

Unlikable Internet Goblin

I saw something (sorry, I don't have a source but I wanna say it was the Times [I know, I know]) about one of the jurors saying in the questionnaire that they got their news from Truth Social. If that's true... How does this not invalidate their claims to impartiality? If we have a jury with a die-hard Trumper in it, what are the odds we get something like a hung jury? Can an obstinate but insensible juror lead to a mistrial?

If it weren't for this economy, I'd subscribe

I'm so sure I learned this here - that numbering is so the judge, rest of the court, etc knows what you're referring to... You number your own exhibits... But I don't actually know, I'm just trying to be helpful with vague memories

If it weren't for this economy, I'd subscribe

Serious question - I know it might sound frivolous - but what about a front page NYTimes article (or similar publications) titled "TRUMP TOO AFRAID OF [? anything or anyone... e.g. prosecution lawyer] TO TESTIFY" ... every single thing I've heard about the orange guy makes me think it's the sort of thing that would make him demand to testify? Or has this sort of thing fallen flat when attempted before?

Ruairi Hipkin

Episode suggestion - which will be right in Matt’s back yard, as it comes from Massachusetts - the case of Karen Read - it seems to have a protracted procedural history and it seems a bit complicated

Cats are NOT trash!

In addition to hearing your (collective) takes on it, I mostly want to know where I can go to read the transcripts, as well as who the best reporters are who are "live-tweeting" to get the best sound bites from (summary at the end of the day is fine, doesn't have to be LIVE-live). That's probably a better question for this thread than for RRF, though. Anyone able to point me to any good places, though?

We have moral luck at home

I'm curious about the legality of actually banning TikTok. Are there legal ways to actually do it or is it all political posturing?

Cats are NOT trash!

IANAL, but I've watched quite a few trials. It seems that they often pre-number the exhibits they know or have a strong suspicion they'll use during the trial, and I believe even submit the list with the numbers to the court and opposing side. But they can introduce other stuff, and usually just number them sequentially after the end of the list. But the jury may not end up seeing all of the exhibits on the list, so you can end up with the actual ADMITTED exhibits being something like 1, 2, 5, 6, 10... And it seems some places use numbers for both sides, but just a different starting sequence (like 101 for plaintiff/state and 501 for defense), or numbers for one side and letters for the other (but the trial I saw that did that, after Z, they went to AA then BB instead of AA then AB then AC like Excel columns, so ended up in triple letters for the 53rd exhibit and so on, which then results in fun ones like KKK and XXX, so that's fun).

Kathryn Dittamore

Can you cover the Supreme Court case Idaho vs United States and the impact to the EMTALA? I don't think people realize how bad it could be if that's overturned.

James Hamblin

No suggestion here, just appreciation for all the great info Thomas and Matt are providing!

Lawrence Frank

There was an opinion piece in NYT or WAPO saying NY v Trump is an embarrassment to Alvin Bragg, there is no case or second crime blah blah. I have not read the indictment. I think it is clear that the scheme violated election campaign contribution laws, but I think the author was saying that’s federal law. Does it still count? Why do apparently informed people make this kind of argument.

Gmork

The Truth Social thing was wildly misleading. The juror said thar they got their news from a variety of sources, and in addition to seeing Trumps truths, they listened to the Mueller She Wrote, a podcast that makes OA seem right wing in comparison.

Maria Kladaki

I was thinking along the lines of the nyt article too. It just does not seem to be basis for election interference. Suppose Trump paid put of his own pocket. No records, no nothing, just a bank transaction from his own personal account to Daniels. Where is the crime?

Matt Cameron

Absolutely have to do this--it may have to wait until the decision though. I really wish this one in particular hadn't been the same week that the ny trial was starting *and* immunity arguments were being heard. Plus grant's pass! Just drowning in the news bucket over here

Xavier Branch

This is a question about strategy. Could Blanche and Co. do a strategy of "yes he falsified business records, but the felony enhancement is bogus"? Or can he maintain innocence on the charges while still challenging the felony enhancement?

Kevin Duff

I hear a lot of discussion online about this being the weakest case against Trump and on the face of it it is the easiest to portray as politically motivated (the feds declining to charge, the upgrade from misdemeanor, etc). What's the Uncle Frank angle on this case?

M. D. Nova

Would really like a future deep dive on Project 2025. I’ve dived myself and actually read a slice of it and there are more and more sites breaking it down, and more and more media coverage. But not enough people really understand how horrible it is. This site is doing a good job of getting across the horrors of it - linking one of their topical pages - https://www.stopthecoup2025.org/immigration

The DinosaurDave

If you had a client that kept falling asleep, what kind of air freshener do you use to cover up the fart smell?

Sean

What happens if Trump's legal fees exceed his resources? (Say after he loses the election.) Can the lawyers on his criminal cases back out? Does the last one have to remain?

VMLs still seething at Patreon but fine cause VML

Regular Rapid Response topic proposal: An early take on the FTC decision to essentially ban non-competes and Chamber of Commerce's constitutionality arguments against. The rule, the political environment, and the composition of the Supreme Court have me concerned we are ripe for a return to Lochner era jurisprudence.

Only ninety eight percent Neanderthal

The criminal case requires a unanimous jury for a guilty verdict right? Was the civil trial (E Jean Carroll) jury verdict a simple majority/do we know how large the majority was?

Opening Arguments

Just for the record, I strongly disagree that Mueller She Wrote makes us seem right wing, let alone even being to the left of us. Allison Gill is pretty solidly just... a Democrat, right?

Michael Rops

Please cover the BS questions from Gorsuch and from Alito. ‘Say the president lead a peaceful protest that delayed a congressional votes. Could he be prosecuted for that?’ What the fuck? If I could be prosecuted for it or Thomas could be prosecuted for it, why the hell is the President any different?