Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

OA1272 - We are excited to welcome veteran journalist Peter Canellos to discuss his new book Revenge for the Sixties: Sam Alito and the Triumph of the Conservative Legal Movement. In this first-ever biography of Samuel Alito, Canellos draws from extensive interviews and years of research to provide a complete portrait not only of Alito as a person and a jurist, but of the reactionary conservative legal revolution which helped get him to the Supreme Court. In this conversation we go beyond the basics of the book to discuss (among many other things) who Alito really is, how his early life shaped his view of the world, and why so many people who knew him before his nomination now say that they don't recognize who he became after it. 

SAVE THE DATE! Join us  this Sunday June 28th at 4:30 EDT for our first meeting of the OA Book Club--featuring a brief visit from this month’s author Peter Canellos! This new monthly bonus will be available to patrons at every level going forward,, so please subscribe anytime at patreon.com/law!

Revenge for the Sixties: Sam Alito and the Triumph of the Conservative Legal Movement, Peter Canellos (2026)

Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!

Files

Comments

Gmork

I hope Thomas' talk recognizes that there 100% is a MAGA conspiracy surrounding the assassinations attempts. It's not that MAGA pre-planned them or instigated the shooters. But after the events, the admin did engaged in a conspiracy to exagerate the danger/harm and to mislead the public about the shooters. That matters bc while they haven't faked the attempt, they still conspire to achieve the same ends as if they had.

Opening Arguments

These things aren't even in the same universe. Taking advantage of something politically vs. staging an assassination attempt? Yeah, obviously Trump tries to take advantage of everything that happens. Politicians all do that. If you have stronger claims about a conspiracy I'd be happy to look at them. When I researched it, I was actually really surprised to find that Trump's doctor didn't actually lie, and it was just a fake quote that went around. The dr was very reasonable about the ear injury in official statements. But again, I hate being wrong so please link anything I'm missing on that!

Peter Baird

Alito emerges from the book as someone who integrated the time and circumstances of his own particular childhood and adolescence into a fixed method of seeing the rest of the world. Canellos’ inclusion of a brief portrait of Algernon Ward Jr. growing up in nearly the same 50s-60s time frame as Alito a few miles away is a fascinating contrast. Both are in suburbs of Trenton, New Jersey, but while one grows up in the aspirational white enclave of Mercerville with perfect lawns and new schools, the other grows up in Battle Monument, an area close to downtown in the midst of white flight and gradual decay. One joins the Debate Team and edits the school newspaper, the other dodges white neighborhoods with merchants who lock their doors to Black residents. As Matt brings out in the interview, Alito seems to have become a touchstone for grievance rather than a brain engaged in forging beneficial outcomes. Despite this, there is no doubt he is possessed of a formidable intelligence and an unshakeable conviction of his own rightness. My own emerging opinion is that Alito is something of a small mind. He falls neither in the tradition of firebrand revolutionaries like Jefferson, Sam Adams, and Patrick Henry, or the stability-loving Framers like Hamilton, Madison, and Mason. He is rather a crusader for his own niche of culture to the exclusion of all others; more in line with Roger Taney’s outrage over Northern states agitating for the abolishment of slavery, or Stephen Field’s casual racism.

Gmork

With the WHPC, there was a very deliberate false narrative to convince people the shooter got much closer to the event as opposed to the truth that he was immediately stopped at the first line of security. And in both cases, they tried to mislead everyone that the shooter was an antifa liberal. I obviously agree that it's dumb to accept the false assumption that the admin planned the attacks. But they did engage in an after-the-fact conspiracy of misinformation to achieve the exact same goals that a faked assassination attempt would have been staged for. It's not There's No Conspiracy. It's No -- The Conspiracy Started After The Unplanned Shooting. By way of example, even if the Nazis hadn't staged the Reichstag Fire -- if they were merely lying about a fortuitous occurrence -- the conspiracy to falsely blame their enemies for it mattered a lot. We shouldn't deem it "no conspiracy" just because it wasn't pre-planned.

Gmork

I never thought of Harriet Meier's loss as a victory for FedSoc. That was really interesting.

Chris Conley

The Genoese "aren't even Italian"? I feel like the city might be surprised to hear that

Matt Cameron

Genoa had a long proud history as an independent entity. "Italy" wasn't a thing until the year that the US Civil War kicked off

Opening Arguments

oh I was referring to the Pennsylvania shooting. And I do think this is kind of just a bait and switch way to legitimize conspiracy thinking on the left. The word you're looking for is lying. They lie in coordination on everything. The only reason to try to link that to the obviously wrong conspiracy theories around the shootings is to attempt to launder those conspiracy theories in some way.

Chris Conley

Sure, Italy was politically fragmented for most of the medieval period, but very few states that exist today existed then, especially with anything even close to the same borders. Italy had not been united under a single political rule in nearly a thousand years, ever since Rome reconquered the region from the Ostrogoths...only to lose northern and then central Italy to another invasion of Germans, mainly the Lombards, just three years later, who created their own kingdom and eventually formed much of the northern population. (Hence the name of the region, Lombardy.) But Italy as a concept and name for the peninsula and broader geographic region obviously persisted that whole time. There's a reason we still use the Roman name for it, and it was the driving force behind the nationalist project of Garibaldi and the other supporters of Italian unification in the 1800s.

Gmork

I think what we're talking past each other on is the meaning of "conspiracy." You're using it to mean tin foil hat theories that everything that happens is part of some master plan. And I totally agree that the assassinations weren't staged and that it's detrimental to pretend otherwise. But I likewise think it's harmful to ignore the small-c conspiracies of lies that take place after the fact to try to give the admin license to do as they please. Those aren't as "sexy" as convincing oneself the lizard people are behind everything, but they're more harmful because they're real.

Matt Cameron

all good points but I guess in my mind it's like saying that 17th century Clan Cameron (of which I am a proud direct descendent) were "British" when of course they were no such thing until unification in 1707 (and had very little interest in being British even after that). Maybe that's not a great analogy though, I admittedly know a lot more about UK history than I do Italian

Chris Conley

OK, but there too the toponym is much older, and funny enough also tied up with and popularized by Roman administration. The word Britain/Brittany/Brython etc. existed over two thousand years prior, first attested by a Greek explorer in the area in the 300s BC as the local place name used by the native Celtic people, and eventually under Claudius it was adopted as the name of the new Roman province, Britannia, for nearly four centuries. The French peninsula (and former kingdom) of Brittany was itself named for Great Britain; the Breton people were closely related to the Britons, and reportedly originally colonized it from the island. Scottish clans may not have yet thought of themselves as "British", but they were certainly "Britons" and "Brittonic" (or "Brythonic") in that older sense.