Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Can't wait to kick this off with you all on Sunday, June 28th, at 1:30pm Pacific/4:30pm Eastern. Peter Canellos will join us for the first half, and we'll discuss his book, Revenge for the Sixties: Sam Alito and the Triumph of the Conservative Legal Movement.

CLICK HERE FOR THE ZOOM: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85307729993?pwd=WnERzpZzjJ7xz0YSrfRRazg7BrW4GH.1

If you can't make it but would still like to chime in, drop your questions and thoughts below in the comments!

Comments

Susan

Here’s some of my questions. I understand you might not get to them all especially because not everyone will have these questions.

Susan

1. Did Trump do this to appease Alito because Alito liked Columbus? Excerpts from this article: Trump has installed a 13-foot statue of Christopher Columbus on White House grounds without submitting a plan to any panel. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/08/us/politics/reflecting-pool-trump-contract.html?unlocked_article_code=1.r1A.wBnd.3cpVYaNxNbi8&smid=nytcore-ios-share From the book: Page XV For Italian Americans, Columbus was central to their sense of belonging. Page XVII destruction of the Columbus statue rankled him.

Susan

2. Did he lie? Did Alito have an agenda of overturning Roe? Chapter 10 especially made me think that Alito was maliciously deceitful in his efforts to get on the Supreme Court and over turn Roe. Page 249 “obviously my Sam Alito at the time was holding back, or he’s evolved, or some of both” said a [former?] friend of Alito’s. Page XX “A judge can’t have any agenda,” Alito avowed at his 2006 confirmation hearing, Page xxxiv “Roe was on a collision course with the Constitution from the day it was decided.” Dobbs v. Jackson Page 136-He further vowed to be “open-minded,” and never to allow his personal opinions to influence his decision-making. Page 192–Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s references to “the rule of law” and “principles of stare decisis” were almost direct quotes from Roberts’s and Alito’s confirmation hearings of the previous year. Her implication seemed obvious: the two new justices were talking a different game on the court than they had before the Senate.

Susan

3. Why does Alito downplay the 9th amendment when it comes to women and other people who aren’t cis heterosexual white men? Page xxxiii and other places talks about the 9th Amendment Page 170– Chafee thought: This is a cold person.

Susan

4. Chapter 3 How does Alito explain what looks like bribery compared to his admiration for his parents? Page 224–Alito chose not to disclose a lavish fishing journey to Alaska arranged by Leonard Leo. Page 36—Alito said he couldn’t help making a contrast between some of the worst of what he saw on the campus and “the good sense and decency of the people back in my own community,” at his confirmation hearing, Page 168-highlighting his neglect to recuse himself in cases involving Smith Barney and Vanguard, two giant brokerages that happened to hold his stock accounts. Excerpts from article: In the years after the undisclosed trip to Alaska, Republican megadonor Paul Singer’s hedge fund has repeatedly had business before the Supreme Court. Alito has never recused himself. … https://www.propublica.org/article/samuel-alito-luxury-fishing-trip-paul-singer-scotus-supreme-court

Susan

5. Please discuss why Ginsburg thought equal protection clause was better than right to privacy to protect reproductive rights. Page 78–Ruth Bader Ginsburg, hoped that the justices would base their decision on the Constitution’s equal protection clause. Page 79 …constitutional roots for the right to privacy—the Ninth Amendment. Page 81– But the plain fact was the court had recognized the rights of women to control their bodies, Page 169 Alito would acknowledge a right to privacy in his Dobbs opinion but reject its application to abortion.

Susan

6. Could you talk a little about CLS and why people disliked it? Page 131 Derrick Bell, a pioneering Black professor, used the tenets of CLS to help develop critical race theory, … Feminist scholar Mary Joe Frug, the wife of Harvard law professor and CLS pioneer Gerald Frug, dedicated herself to showing how the law served to sexualize and marginalize women

Susan

7. Compare Borg to Alito to explain why Alito was confirmed to the Supreme Court. Page 137 The role of a federal circuit court judge is to apply precedents handed down by the Supreme Court. But at many junctures, Alito sought to stretch those precedents to cover conservative priorities, from abortion restrictions to gun rights to public displays of religious symbols to fewer constraints on police tactics. … he was part of a three-judge panel reviewing a Pennsylvania law requiring women seeking abortions to notify their husbands, he alone thought the law did not impose an “undue burden” on the right to abortion. … page 138 The court’s majority upheld the machine-gun ban, but Alito disagreed. …. Page 166-Chuck Schumer said it was all in the record for people to see: “Many of the opinions that he has written over the past 15 years cast real doubt on whether he can be a fair, mainstream, albeit conservative, judge.” Page 176 Bloggers speculated as to whether Martha-Ann had faked the tears to get her husband off the hook,

Susan

8. The author mentions Marbury v. Madison. I didn’t understand it. I googled and found this, but I still don’t understand it. I understand its significance BUT I don’t understand why the Judiciary Act of 1789 was declared unconstitutional. Excerpts from Britannica: Parts of the Judiciary Act of 1789 was declared unconstitutional. Section 13 of the act, Marshall argued, was inconsistent with Article III, Section 2 of the Constitution, which states in part that “the supreme Court shall have original Jurisdiction” in “all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, and those in which a State shall be Party,” and that “in all the other Cases before mentioned, the supreme Court shall have appellate Jurisdiction.” In thus surrendering the power derived from the 1789 statute (and giving Jefferson a technical victory in the case), https://www.britannica.com/event/Marbury-v-Madison

Susan

9. I prefer this interpretation. Encouraging people to take up arms (like Charlie Kirk did) against the tyranny of the government seems a bad idea. Look at the 100 year sentence of the guy who took a weapon to an ICE detention center. Page 193 The Supreme Court’s initial interpretation of this convoluted language was that it protected militias and not individuals, except in the military context. Page 195 “The term ‘bear arms’ is a familiar idiom; when used unadorned by any additional words, its meaning is ‘to serve as a soldier, do military service, fight,’ ” Stevens wrote,

Susan

10. Do you think Alito’s originalism ideology is BS? Page 195 ALITO’S SURPRISING BELIEF THAT originalism wasn’t the answer in every case started popping up more frequently in his fourth year on the Supreme Court.

Susan

11. What could Obama have done to force McConnell to let the Senate vote on his Supreme Court nominee? Page 209 No longer subject to the filibuster, Kavanaugh won confirmation by a wafer-thin 50–48 margin.

Susan

12. Alito seems to have no compassion except for Italian-Americans Chapter 2 page 18 the Warren Court was bending over backward to show its compassion for minorities of all stripes. Chapter 8 Alito offended by the Sopranos because it portrays Italians in a bad light. Why doesn’t it bother him Trump denigrates minorities? Page 255 But it also reflected his conviction that diversity was a zero-sum game. One group’s claim of discrimination necessitated another’s:

Susan

It feels to me that the subversive extremist justices like Alito and Thomas don’t believe in the fundamental values expressed in our Declaration of Independence. I wonder how Alito interpretes this part of the Declaration of Independence: We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.