Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

VR37 - Ben Shapiro and Matt Walsh both wrote furious, error-riddled columns attacking the Supreme Court's birthright citizenship ruling in Trump v. Barbara. And so Thomas, attorney Matt Cameron, and producer Lydia ran the columns through an AI detector and their BS detectors to see just how fake and how BS they were. Spoiler: it's a lot.

Files

Comments

Gmork

The birthright citizenship opponents argument genuinely rests on the premise that the drifters of the 14A were unable to write coherently. They argue that the drifters intended only to add that formerly-enslaved people were now citizens but were unable to come up with wording that was clearer than "persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof."

General Contact Unit Problem Child

Hay Matt the other day the Majority report really annoyed me because they had a guest on who was like “oh they’re not going to wait for anyone to retire, they’re going to tweak the law just a bit and they’ll get a different ruling from SCOTUS” which makes no sense given the ruling was on constitutional grounds so aside from Kavanaugh, changing the law won’t make a difference I think the idea the US is potentially one justice death or retirement away from losing birth right citizenship is alarming enough, but apparently some people think need to add little bit of nonsense to make it worse.

David in Brooklyn

(with apologies) When I look at The Drifters' discography I remember "Up on the Roof", "Under the Boardwalk", "There Goes My Baby", "Saturday Night at the Movies" and "Save the Last Dance for Me" with fondness from my early teenage years. I agree with you, though--it takes real arrogance to say, "Here, let me fix that for you" to the framers of the Constitution, and then change the entire meaning of what was originally written.

Gmork

Not even just to change the meaning. To suggest that they couldn't come up with the phrase "former slave" and just stupidly used language that sounds exactly like it means that -- with rare exceptions -- you're a citizen if you're born here. *And* never thought to change it when we executed it that way for the rest of their lives.

William Evan Barnes

I feel like I'm going to end up writing this same comment on every post, but it's worth it. Stop using Google! You all know it's absolute dog shit as a search engine, it has been for at least a decade. There are truly great alternatives out there. Personally I use Kagi. It's the best search engine I've ever used. It is a subscription service, but what that means is there are no ads. It's very privacy focused, and while they do have AI answers, you have to explicitly ask for it by ending your search with a question mark. Otherwise you just get plain search results that are really good. Seriously y'all, we don't have to keep using Google.

David in Brooklyn

The wording that's actually in the amendment required more thought and more work than "former slave" would have taken, too. Its intentionality should count for something, one would think.

Gmork

Exactly right! It's such an absurdly deliberate and overly-inclusive way to say "former slave" that it should be rejected out of hand that it meant nothing more than that.

Ryan

The reference to a suicide pact comes from Justice Robert Jackson’s dissent in Terminello v. Chicago. I would highly recommend a deep dive on that case.

Kenny and Kyle’s App Company

I was interested in a control case on checking for AI analysis. I grabbed one of the blog posts that I wrote years ago, and tested it with, I think, the same checker. The results it gave me matched the language that Thomas read for the two they tested in the episode. My text, that was definitely human-written, was given an 18% Human, 82% AI score. "Your text shows several issues, an AI-like tone, repetitive phrasing, uneven rhythm, potential plagiarism, and low readability. These inconsistencies affect its style, flow, and credibility." It was just a simple post, written similarly to the way I speak, so it's not great literature or anything. But it definitely calls into question the reliability of that checker. Here is the text for reference: Let's do away with this phrase: "Sunlight is the best disinfectant." It's a great disinfectant, but you know what else does a great job even faster? Caustic chemicals. But what if you aren't combating bacteria? What if the thing you're trying to disinfect is actually Poison Oak. Then sunlight is exactly what it wants. I bring this up because throughout all of this bullshit with Milo, people keep saying that he should be given a platform to spew his hateful bullshit because once people see his horrible ideas then he'll be destroyed... i.e. put him in the sunlight and he'll die. But he didn't. Putting him in the sunlight gave him the energy he needed to grow. What killed him (or at least is killing him) was removing his platform and directly combating him... i.e. removing him the sunlight and pouring caustic chemicals on him. If you understand that his hateful rhetoric is a weed and not a bacteria, then you'll suddenly understand why giving it sunlight works against you. If we encounter someone supporting hate speech by saying "Sunlight is the best disinfectant" we should respond with "Sunlight is also fuel to poisonous plants."

YourJelly

I was going to suggest similarly check these people's writings from before AI and see how they rate, I don't think this is a reliable tool. Additionally these checker tools are motivated to over report AI score because that's what people looking for these tools are expecting to see

William Evan Barnes

That's a bit of an overstatement. Kagi at that time used Yandex for about 2% of their search traffic and had a revenue sharing agreement with them. Yandex itself split when one of its founders left Russia and started another Yandex outside Russia, so it's not entirely clear which Yandex that was. But you're right, a small portion of Kagi's revenue has gone to and might still go to Yandex, a potentially Russian (or Dutch) business. But Kagi isn't a $4+ trillion company, which Google is. Kagi has like 30 employees and maybe $10 million in revenue. And for a long time Google had a Russian subsidiary (bankrupt after the Kremlin seized hundreds of millions of dollars from their accounts), and a lot of Google ad revenue has gone to Russian companies. And beyond the direct connections to Russia, I just think Google has done an immense amount of harm to the world. I think this is genuinely a case where you shouldn't let the unobtainable perfect be the enemy of the good, and I do think that even if 2% of Kagi's revenue went straight to Putin, it would still be the lesser of two evils and cause less harm. That would be like $200k. But yeah, I think "Kagi funds Russia" is misleading, it makes it sound like they set themselves up as a business in order to bankroll Russian drones or something, instead of the reality where they shared a small portion of their revenue with a Russian search engine to pay for their use of that engine. I agree that there's no perfectly ethical consumption under capitalism, but there's no perfectly ethical action anywhere. You just have to do the better things when you can. And I think having a search engine that doesn't shove AI hallucinations and ads disguised as results down people's throats is the more ethical option. Oh that's fun too, Google has put an immense amount of technical and financial infrastructure into place to support the Israeli government and military. Check out Project Nimbus for a start. Oh, and Google removed a voter information app from their app store on Russian devices ahead of the 2021 Russian election. The voting app had been made by associates of Alexei Navalny, the opposition leader. They're an evil company.

Paul Collier

It’s bizarre to me that the otherwise fairly worldly and outward looking hosts of this show could have a conversation about Folarin Balogun without even noting the corruption and collusion of Trump and FIFA in having his red card removed so he could play against Belgium. It was enormous international news and yet another example of how FIFA is essentially an organised crime operation masquerading as a sporting body. It was also another piece of evidence of Trump’s corruption, on a show that often dis a great job taking about exactly that. Yet the discussion here barely went any further than basically saying America gets the “best” because of birthright citizenship. Weirdly nationalistic take from a show that is otherwise pretty skeptical of overt patriotism.

Chris Conley

I don't think "we have a nation" and "birthright citizenship makes us better" are particularly nationalist or overtly patriotic takes

Matt Cameron

I have a lot to say about that whole situation, but we had so many other things lined up to talk about in this episode that I didn't want too take much time on it. I just couldn't resist highlighting the irony of birthright citizenship being in the news in such different ways within the same week. I'd actually meant to lean more into the irony of Trump intervening to (corruptly) defend someone who would never have been on the US team if the rule Trump were pushing for had been in effect. Given the thrust of the Walsh and Shapiro pieces about how it is an unequicoval negative for the US I just wanted to start with this for some balance. And I guess celebrating immigrant contributions to the US team and wanting to see the team advance is inherently nationalistic, but here we are

Paul Collier

I get that, and I get that it was a short segment about the situation. But it was odd not to mention it at all, even if you didn’t have the time to spend on it in detail. Anyway- I love the show. This was a rare miss in my view

Opening Arguments

yeah I found that after. I checked them on a more reliable tool and the Ben Shapiro one still came up 100% AI. The other one did not. So, that's actually more consistent with what we were thinking