Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

OA1278 - On its face, the decision in Watson is a pretty narrow ruling. Some states allow ballots postmarked on or before election day, but arriving after election day, to be counted. The court decided they can continue to do so.

But at stake was so much more. Bubbling under the surface, election deniers were trying to open a door to far more aggressive limitations on voting rights. With this decision, that door is quite firmly shut… by Barrett? Come hear Jenessa try to survive the cognitive dissonance of finding an ACB opinion extremely well-written, thorough, and appropriately critical of out-of-context half-assed attempts at historical analysis in the dissent.

Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!

Files

Comments

Duff Dyer

I am ADHD. I have spent my life reading the first paragraph 17 times and thinking, I can't do this. ;) Edit: I posted this prior to both of you saying basically the same thing, lol.

SpunRightRound

Just want to push back gently on the "Election Day should be a holiday" thing. Not everyone works a job where they get federal holidays off, let alone receive pay for taking those days off, and those who DON'T get holidays are disproportionately underrepresented electorally. This isn't to say that a holiday couldn't be a part of the solution, but it only really works if it's coupled with expansions to early voting and universal mail-in voting. The idea that making election day a holiday will solve access to voting issues is a super privileged position, and I challenge you to think beyond the experiences of privileged workers in society when we're talking about solutions to making sure every American that wants to participate in the electoral process has reasonable access to participate. Thanks for stopping by my TED talk.

General Contact Unit Problem Child

I wonder if where they fucked up a little bit on picking Barrett is they picked her primarily for the right wing identity politics reasons, rather than her ideological commitment all right wing goals. Like they picked she’s a white Christian woman with a shit ton of kids who is super pro life. It doesn’t seem to have occurred to them a person could be like that but then not be lock step with the far right on every other issue.

Gmork

Gorsuch was seriously citing to Air Bud? "Where in the rules does it say a dog can't recall their ballot?"

General Contact Unit Problem Child

Yes but not having as a holiday is even worse in that regard since underprivileged people also have less ability to take time off work

SpunRightRound

Right, which is why I said that it's part of a solution that also includes expansions to early voting and universal mail-in voting.

SpunRightRound

Adding in here that those same underprivileged people that have limited ability to take time off of work probably aren't getting federal holidays off, either. I work in a service industry job. I get Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Years Day off. I've worked jobs where having even those holidays off was not guaranteed. I also live in a state with universal mail-in voting, so it's unlikely that my employers would close for an "election day" holiday, as most normal federal holidays tend to be busy for us (a distillery, and I imagine we would be QUITE busy on election day, lol).

Jenessa Seymour

In case anyone has missed my larger body of work on this podcast: Election Day should be holiday. Early voting should be widely available and accessible. No-excuse mail-in voting should be widely available and accessible. Any mail-in forms should not require postage. You should be able to do that stuff all online for free anyway, including all accessibility features. A felony conviction should never affect the right to vote. Voter registration should be automatic. I could keep rattling off my beliefs about voting that probably put me in the 99th percentile of Americans in terms of wanting to make voting as open and accessible as possible. It’s literally my job.

Jenessa Seymour

Literally yes, and of course acting so smug about it, like he’d just pointed out the worst loophole. If any state made recall legal, as stated by the attorney for Mississippi, that would probably violate many federal election laws. That’s probably why NO STATE ALLOWS THAT. But apparently the fact that hypothetically one could commit that fraud without getting caught, and Gorsuch can imagine a multiverse where so many people did it that an election result illegally changed, that means we have to strike down any law that could hypothetically leave that loophole open… the can of worms that opens, to say if the law doesn’t physically foreclose the possibility of the law being broken then the law can’t stand… like how would any legal system function under that principle?! Maddening

Gmork

I hate to give her too much credit, but they may have stepped in it by picking someone who believes in their principles (which I disagree with) versus someone like Vance who sees faith as a tool to justify his desired outcome.

Jenessa Seymour

THIS. I think Thomas also nailed it that like, the abortion stuff isn’t typically hypocritical or incongruent, at least from a legal perspective. If you genuinely believe that a fetus should have the same rights as a full grown adult, to the point that it can override bodily autonomy of the pregnant person, then yeah what they’re doing makes sense. Like if they think autonomy matters at all (which it should; even if you think a zygote has rights, the pregnant person doesn’t suddenly have none), then it’s not hypocritical to turn it back to the states for weighing instead of a full-on ban. It’s not like incomprehensible to say that freedom of religion is impinged by taking benefits you’d give to any other org and not giving them to a religious org purely because they’re religious… it’s just weighed against the belief that my tax dollars going to a religious org is the far less acceptable option. That playground repaving case was basically designed to prey on that “oh come on” feeling that we are holding too strict a line on freedom FROM religion. It is completely imaginable that she just actually believes that stuff, probably plus some unconscious bias that it gets to conservative conclusions that support her worldview, whereas for Alito and Thomas it’s more consciously a means to an end (obviously everyone is eventually lying to themselves enough that they think they believe it on a level).

SpunRightRound

I appreciate your work, Janessa, and I think we all realize your fierce advocacy for removing restrictions that reduce election participation. I'm merely pointing out that often (as happened in this episode) the conversation is "let's make election day a holiday" without also acknowledging that there's more to it than that. Yes, 100% all of the things you said in your comment above and then some, and I'm sorry if my comment makes it seem like I'm attacking your work. I do not have a doctorate or a law degree, but did spend the entirety of my elective BA education in public policy surrounding election accessibility and systems, so this is a conversation near and dear to my heart as well. I just think leaving the conversation at "elections should be a federal holiday" without addressing the rest messages a solution coming from a very privileged position, and I think it's ok to acknowledge that. I like to believe this is a safe space to have in depth discussions about the nuances of topics presented. Happy election season to all, please go door knock for a candidate you support and help your neighbors make a plan to vote this primary season.

ctk

here's all i need to know about the "election day is THIS day and no other day" from republicans: if all ballots MUST be counted on Tuesday night, doesn't it make sense to allocate federal funds to count ballots faster?