Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

To be clear, Thomas absolutely nailed #296 and 297 and is now 156-for-297 (52.5%) headed into this one!

Files

Comments

Avi Physics

Is this a Civil Forfeiture question? I am going to guess B, because at the very least, that watch aided and abetted the theft.

Amanda Horne

I don't like the wording on this one. When I first read it I was thinking he was grabbing his wife or girlfriend's purse, and reading it again I thought maybe he just had a feminine bag. It doesn't mention him stealing anything, or taking it off a woman's possession, or if it was with or without her permission. After reading it through I think I'm supposed to assume that the purse was stolen, or at least have probable cause to think so, but they should have worded it differently if that's what they meant. I vote C, but only because I think this question is worded poorly (unless I'm correct, and it's supposed to be a trick question)

christine brean

B may not be the legal answer, but it is what I would do if I was a cop

Sam

I think by "woman's bag" they mean "being currently carried by a woman", not just "looks like the sort a woman would carry". The wording could be clearer.

Sam

This seems easy to narrow down to B or C. D is irrelevant and not established in the question in any case. A seems irrelevant, the circumstances seem to justify a search of the man's person. So it's a case law question: Is "it's expensive" enough to say the watch, whether or not it's an Apple Watch, is probably some sort of fruits? Given the apparent state of civil forfeiture law, I'd guess B.

Pterrorsaurus hex

Absolutely C. Whose to say the man and woman aren't together and he's running an errand that requires the purse? Hell whose to say it isn't HIS/HER purse? At most officer Jerry should make an inquiry. Then as far as the watch is concerned, it has nothing to do with the purse. The man may just own an expensive watch. Hell, the biggest thieves in America rightfully own extravagant things, but unless they've been proven to be gained illegally, those things shouldn't be confiscated. If you're going to take the watch, why stop there? Take the man's shoes, too. Take his glasses if he's wearing them. Hope he doesn't need insulin, that's now evidence. There's not enough reason given in the question to justify stealing some man's watch--- Whether it's common police practice or not.

Ilan Woll

B. But they missed the chance for a Tom and Jerry bit

TMoney2007

It said that he stopped and quickly followed him... Because of that, I think that the implication is that the alleged robber didn't have time to have robbed another person for the watch. I don't think he cop had probable cause to seize the watch because they didn't see it being taken and there was no chance for it to have been taken while the cop wasn't in pursuit.

Eric Brewer

C. The officer had reason to think the purse was stolen, but no reason to think anything else was.

Tom Joyce

I also vote C. There was no evidence that the watch was stolen. For the watch to be part of the crime, it needs to be proven that the watch was stolen. If the victim swore that the watch was her husband's (or son's) and she was just taking it to the jeweler for repair, then it would be in. Otherwise Officer Jerry and his cronies need to show that a second crime took place, and that the watch was part of the second crime. Just theoretically..... If Mark Zuckerberg steals my wallet, that isn't proof that he also stole the $12,000 leather jacket he was wearing at the time.