Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

Comments

Fieryone

Wouldn't it be D because it's hearsay?

Ilan Woll

A. Saying I will murder someone is not attempted murder. Otherwise Eli would be facing six charges of attempted murder. Granted this question is terribly written

MamaG

A. Horrible girl. I would think the former BF could consider a libel suit, though.

Quark Twain

I don't understand what D is supposed to mean even in theory. It's not proved that he will kill her in the future? It's not proved that he ever said the statement?

The pun is mightier than the sword

Seems like it has to be A. D doesn't make sense when there is no discussion of what evidence is being shown & where. B & C saying he's guilty based on using a common phrase with no steps taken to actually murder seems way too far.

Dr_Emil_Schaffhousen

This is the weirdest set of questions. The statement is potentially a verbal assault, so it can't be A. B makes no sense and C makes no sense because the crime is assault, not murder. They can't be true because if a murder takes place in the future, then it would have to be proven in court beyond a reasonable doubt that the statement is true - in other words, that he murdered someone. That, and not the statement, would be the focus of that trial. So my answer is D, but not because it's hearsay. Because it's the truest answer - in this fact pattern there's no murder, there's no trial, we can't prove that he will kill anyone.

James Weingarten

I think A is the answer. D is a rationale for whether or not to accept evidence.