Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

A viral meme claims that a fake Eli Lilly tweet declaring insulin to be free tanked the stock to the tune of billions and billions. Ignoring for a moment the fact that it seems incredibly unlikely that an easily debunkable fake tweet on fake tweet day would send a bunch of investors into a frenzy, could Eli Lilly sue the tweeter? Or the Twitter? It's another Section 230 deep dive!

Links: 47 U.S.C. § 230, Malwarebytes, Inc. v. Enigma Software Group, Gonzalez v. Google LLC - SCOTUSblog, Trump 9th Cir. brief

Files

Comments

John of the bankruptcy pirates

Goody an episode dedicated to one of my email questions. Ok ok, I understand that they definitely got more than one, but I'm still excited. Ps. Can I encourage opening Args to explore mastodon as a Twitter replacement as Twitter implodes?

I'm pretty New Hampshire, but I'm not Libertarian Walks Into a Bear New Hampshire

Regarding the YouTube algorithm -- I keep pretty insulated on YouTube within the specific channels and topics I want, but for a while I was getting far-left (like, actually literally communist) content recommendations, and when I told it to stop recommending those, *then* they started recommending far-right content, which I'm also now trying to suppress with the "not interested" button. It's as if YouTube has decided that only nutjob politics should be promoted. (Given that algorithms that prioritize "engagement" with no regard for quality are a well-known problem with the social internet, I suspect that's *exactly* what the algorithm has decided.) PS: I regularly report PragerU and The Epoch Times as fraud. I'll try reporting them as hate speech and see if that works.

Kevin (Nevu)

Piat crew is already doing it so I suspect that OA will follow suit.

John of the bankruptcy pirates

I report them as fraud whenever they come up. Also Jim baker and prosperity gospel nut jobs. Seriously I do not understand how it is that our society is so broken that if you paint your extremely clear and unambiguous fraud in a thin layer of something that vaguely rhymes with Christianity, suddenly it's not a crime How?

Sidewinder

I'm an Army vet who occasionally targets shoots, and OCCASIONALLY watch YouTube reviews on things related to firearms, intermixed with cooking stuff, gaming videos, old music videos & live concerts, etc. To Thomas' point, the algorithm is so f*cked that literally *every* ad I get or recommendations are videos with titles like "🚨 Biden to sign bill authorizing door-to-door political identity checks🚨" or "The left declares civil war on REAL patriotic Americans 🇺🇸🦅✝️"... Its unreal the stuff that not only is allowed to exist on YouTube, but that you get funneled into by the algorithm. It's to the point where if I look up a crock pot recipe, I'm getting ads on for pseudo-military coffee companies & the Next Video recommendation will autoplay videos from a Creationist fake university.

Sidewinder

I've heard a lot of not great things about Mastodon and a lot of positive things about Post, but Post currently has a 100k wait list which is a terrible sign.

John of the bankruptcy pirates

Hmm the thing I like about mastodon is that it is decentralized. What is the negative? Any articles or anything I can review. I gave a digital security background so if there is a tech doc I can evaluate fairly accurately the risk. Haven't heard of post. Will give it a look

Jacob Vardy

But communists are right.

DigitalSecurity

I think Andrew and Thomas were thinking too narrowly about how the tweet could have affected Elli Lilly's stock price. It could have indirectly affected the trading of Elli Lilly stock by: - Creating more negative news about Elli Lilly and therefore affecting algorithmic trading for a short period, which leads to a very small cascade of sell-offs - putting their name in the news and affecting how people think about the company (eg. Bernie got out right after this and started shaming them for insulin pricing again.) To be fair, I didn't know THEY were the ones keeping insulin costs high until this event happened, and if I had any ETFs or index funds I held any substantial amount of money in, I'd have checked to see if I was invested in them and sell my shares.

Chris

I use Mastodon and like it. Basically all of tech Twitter has migrated there. The whole decentralization thing is a little confusing when you are setting up your account. But after that it is pretty smooth sailing.

Insert clever name here

Thanks for an interesting episode! I tend to agree with Andrew's conclusion on the fundamental question of whether Section 230 immunizes Twitter here. But I did feel like the episode didn't do as much as many do to give the best version of the counter argument. Some cases have jettisoned the distinction between the platform speaking and the third party, but the 9th Circuit has found no 230 immunity for text on posts that's created or developed by the platform itself (Fair Housing Council v. Roommates, 521 F.3d at 1162; see also Lemmon v. Snap, 995 F.3d at 1093). I agree that a suit against Twitter looks more like an attempt to hold it liable for third party speech, but I think a fraud claim arguing that the blue check caused harm--not the Eli Lilly stock issue, given causation issues, but maybe someone who was scammed by an account they thought was verified--would be interesting/non-frivolous under current section 230 case law.

The Travelers' Warden

YES. SOMEONE ELSE NOTICING HOW BAD YOUTUBE SEARCH IS. It is AWFUL now.

John of the bankruptcy pirates

I'm curious about how the positive act of reinstating banned accounts could play into liability. This is no longer just a bookstore. It is a bookstore that specifically selects the books it sells because it knows the contents of those books and has reason to know that content to be harmful

Insert clever name here

I don't practice in this area, but reinstating banned accounts does appear to be squarely within the protection of Section 230. In reinstating those accounts, Twitter is clearly acting as a publisher, which “involve[s] reviewing, editing, and deciding whether to publish or to withdraw from publication third-party content.” (HomeAway v. City of Santa Monica, 918 F.3d at 681). As such, it is immune from suit for that. The more interesting question on my view is whether the checkmark is taken to be editing third-party content or Twitter's own speech, which could fall outside Section 230 under Roommates.

Matthew Wojtaszek

Andrew saying "little Johnie seeing boobies" made me LOL so hard....

Missy

For any other movie nerds, if Stratton Oakmont (from the case vs Prodigy), that is the firm created by Jordan Belfort featured in the film The Wolf of Wall Street.

Lethal Wheat Gluten

When is the runoff for Warnock going to begin? Let's make sure.

Dan

I second this. Is the show doing another fundraising event?