Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • 653 Episode 653 patron.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

What happens when Thomas preps a music law episode but Andrew also preps a music law episode? You get basically 2 episodes in 1! Given that we just moved to our more frequent schedule, we definitely did not intend to create such a behemoth, but there was just too much to cover! In the first half, Andrew sketches out the legal landscape in music copyright law and it's pretty severe limitations. We analyze the Blurred Lines/Got To Give It Up lawsuit, and the Sam Smith/Tom Petty case, complete with clips! Then in the second half, we FINALLY get to the actual case at hand, which is Grigson v Lopez. Thomas takes Andrew on a bit of a musical tour discussing different elements of the songs with even more clips!

-Subscribe to the YouTube Channel and share our videos!

-Follow us on Twitter:  @Openargs

-Facebook:  https://www.facebook.com/openargs/, and don’t forget the OA Facebook Community!

-For show-related questions, check out the Opening Arguments Wiki, which now has its own Twitter feed!  @oawiki

-And finally, remember that you can email us at openarguments@gmail.com!

Files

Comments

Michael

Keep the music law coming!

Scams Hacks and Frauds

I can’t say I’ve listened to every episode, and I don’t have a lot of interest in music. But at 3/4 the way in I’m going to go on a limb and say this is the best OA ever.

Big Lib

Andrew's musical taste is tragic.

Salt Prairie Photography

What if the completely isolated "bubble boy" had no exposure to Tale of Two Cities but did have exposure to something that was derived from it? Not perfect example, but suppose he had no exposure to media other than the Simpsons "It was the best of times it was the blurst of times?" Like he's seen some fair-use parody of the original but not the original itself. Then independently(?) comes up with the original

Tim

Am I seeing this right? Nearly 2 hours of OA content?!? I think I'm really going to enjoy this new format!

Sidewinder

Andrew & Thomas arguing about whether or not the "WOOOH" in Robin Thicke's song constitutes "party noises" killed me 🤣

Random Nonsense, No Tomfoolery

Joining Thomas on his musical recollection of things made my day in ways I cannot properly describe. I also was not expecting to feel so called out on my lack of melody ability on a legal podcast this fine day. That explains why I stick to doing weird rhythm stuff and find others to make melodies for me. I know my lane. #AlsoSufferedFromTheBluesTravelerSongConflationForAnEmbarassinglyLongTime

Stormy Decisis

It's harder for rhythms to be unique than melodies because there are, definitionally, fewer rhythms than melodies, but I would argue that it is possible for the rhythm alone to be unique. Take 'My Shot' in Hamilton. The little pauses in the refrain are very unusual and remarkable. I am not throwing away my (pause) shot. I am not throwing away my (pause) shot. I'm just like my country. I'm young, scrappy, and hungry And I'm not throwing away my (pause) shot. If someone else added a melody and different words, that rhythm alone would be recognizable.

I Don't Have A Clever Patreon Name...

Of all the copyright argument samples in the episode, Grigson's has to be the least convincing. It sounds like every late 90s coffee shop acoustic set I've ever heard. It wouldn't be impossible for the next guy up on open mike night to steal it, but, I'd have a hard time believing Lopez would need to...

Garry Myers

Pinch me by Barenaked Ladies Also, The Office theme

Michael

It is fascinating that copyright law for writings is basically works (not saying it is perfect but it workable) while with music it in many ways doesn't. The discussion of intrinsic vs extrinsic reminded me of an interview I heard with the great banjo player Bela Fleck. Fleck was talking about how the mandolin player Bill Monroe essentially invented bluegrass music. (It got its name from Monroe's band, the Blue Grass Boys.) The late great bluegrass banjo player, Earl Scruggs, played with Monroe for a bit before starting his own band, and of course, many other musicians started playing this new style of music. According to Fleck, Monroe did not appreciate until late in his life that he started a new genre of music - instead, he spend a lot of time being upset with other musicians and bands for ripping off his sound! Good thing, for those of us who like blugrass music, that Monroe did not have a good copyright lawyer at his disposal.

Chris Wiswell

This is great! Wondering about the lay person test here, what if they did a usual suspects style lineup? Plaintiff provides a song, defendant provides four more, and the jury asks whether it is clear which song was supposed to be ripped off?

The Future is not looking bright

Over the closing Credits I hear Andrew and Thomas still discussing music. Someone about the Red Hot Chili Peppers. Feels like two anchors talking at the camera pans awa *edit* oh. It's in there over the credits and again after them.

bella ciao

I love love the role reversal in this one, and love music law!! I also have a music background so this was especially enjoyable. Thank you!

Paul

Thomas steals the show! How amazing.

JustAGuy

Oh boy is this a frustrating episode as a moron who doesn't understand anything about music. It's kind of bringing me back to my mandatory high school music class where my teacher just threw words and sheet paper at me without explaining anything. Not that I would expect that much detail from Thomas that would be deeply unreasonable, it's just a same feeling of 'thrown in the deep end' It does make me wonder though; at what point are similarities necessary in music? I mean like, at what point will we or did we run out of novel musical formation?

Amanda Horne

I might have the hottest take on this one: That Disney song sucks, but the 90s song I actually enjoyed I mean, it's not great, but I would be happy to hear it come on the radio. It fits with the 90s alt rock sound I like I don't know what that says about me, other than that I like moody rock, and that female vocalist sounds like nails on a chalkboard, but obviously Thomas and the multiple EGOTs tell me I'm clearly the minority opinion holder 😂

C’mon

Ok. This is my all-time favorite episode 😁

Zircon Productions

It was, however, the band Spirit, and the song Taurus

Unlikable Internet Goblin

I think there are a couple components in play. One is that the western musical system breaks the audible spectrum down into 12 notes, so there's a fairly sizable restriction baked into it. The other is that not every conceivable pattern "makes sense" musically. That kind of complex, academic music is usually relegated to the realm of jazz or "progressive" genres. As it concerns popular music, your musical options are much more restrained. And once you start to recognize these patterns, you see them everywhere. The I V VI IV chord progression is notorious for its pervasiveness, for example. I believe it's the case that you can't copyright a chord progression (IANAL) for exactly this reason - similarities in music are to a pretty great extent necessary.

Unlikable Internet Goblin

Thomas, you're not at all wrong about a C/D chord *not* being a derivative of a D chord. The term "C/D" specifically means "a C major chord rooted with a D note". So C/D would be composed of a C, D (at the bottom), E, and G. If we were talking about a D-based chord, I would expect to see a variant of of D, F♯, and A. The overlap is one note, and it only overlaps because that note is forced into the C chord where it doesn't ordinarily belong.

Tim Fisher

First deep-dive episode of the new format was a huge win! I love this, guys! And Thomas, as a self-taught, absolutely abysmal but love doing it anyway guitar player, I could listen to you talk about music theory forever!

WhatGoesHere

5 words about the acoustic intro: Eagle Eye Cherry - Save Tonight

Frozen Cusser

The Lopezes are friends of the Court of Fake Internet Justice run by Judge John Hodgman. They are delightful and have appeared as expert witnesses for the court.

Billy

I was trying to think of a way to frame a question around this video for the past QnA, but ran out of time to get a good question around it, but Adam Neely’s most recent video seems extremely appropriate here: https://youtu.be/MAFUdIZnI5o He also has some other videos around this topic like his video about the Katy Perry and Flame lawsuit: https://youtu.be/0ytoUuO-qvg Adam essentially suggests that a system of citation could be a more accurate way to track influences through music. As Thomas gets to, I think this issue is that music is a very different art form than written works and things that current copyright rules work for.

justin clark

The Douglas Adams/Carl Sagan conversation got me thinking about where Kurt Vonnegut fits in, especially God Bless You, Mr. Rosewater (1965). I don’t think this is infringement, because they’re very different stories, but a couple quotes from Rosewater popped in my head when Andrew was reading the Hitchhiker’s Guide quote:

justin clark

“Hello, babies. Welcome to Earth. It’s hot in the summer and cold in the winter. It’s round and wet and crowded. At the outside, babies, you’ve got about a hundred years here. There’s only one rule that I know of, babies — ‘God damn it, you’ve got to be kind.’”

justin clark

“A sum of money is a leading character in this tale about people, just as a sum of honey might properly be a leading character in a tale about bees.”

cthulhuplush

I spent a bunch of the episode trying to recognize what Sublime song both sound like and it's the hook from "I've Seen Better Days"

cthulhuplush

... or Everlast, or Stained or any white guy with an acoustic guitar song from around 2000...

BlackEyedGhost

Here's a good rule for copyright law: just don't. Copyright laws strengthen monopoly, stifles creativity, and prevents the free exchange of information. People steal other people's ideas all the time, it's called "learning", and it's how you're able to read and speak these words. Copyright law is at odds with the freedom of speech, and being anti-censorship, I very much side with freedom of speech. Be it parody, fanfic, song covers, piracy, or tech innovation, the harm of copyright infringement is usually negligible and the benefits are generally expansive. But, if you want a rule that won't go over like a lead balloon, then copyright liability should be limited to an amount which can be reasonably estimated to be harm caused by the infringement and should be weighed against legitimate losses due to legitimate competition by the person/org being sued. If your song does extremely well and I remix it and the remix does really well, it's pretty likely no harm was done, and if harm was done, a good portion of it is likely because I created a better product so people preferred my version to yours. The particular numerical estimates for monetary loss and percentage that's legitimate competition would obviously have to be either agreed upon in settlement or decided independently by the court.

SadPanda

Kristen Bell sounds much better in her other song in Frozen 2 (Do the Next Right Thing) and any song from the first movie. I really think this was the weakest song in the movie. She's clearly outclassed by Idina Menzel and Jonathan Groff, though.

Sean Zipperer

Listening to this episode now and came to patreon to post exactly this.

Renee Z

We always call it the Taco Bell Cannon

Renee Z

Thomas--Every time I hear the intro song to Dear Old Dads, I think of Thomas and the Bible. If you hadn't written the T&TB intro song, could the composer of that song sue you over the Dear Old Dads song? Maybe you have to consult Andrew.

Corey Helwig

Man, that Frozen song also has the same chord progression as “Yours Completely” by The Poolboys. That and a bazillion other Christian alternative rock songs.

Nathan

Yeah. I heard the Grigson song and just immediately had this weird sense I'd heard somethings that were very similar before, and kinda settled on it being like a Barenaked Ladies song that didn't make the cut. Or a similarity to Train's Meet Virginia. There's probably a dozen or so late 90s early 2000s songs that sound way more similar than that Frozen 2 song.

capitalthree

I agree with BlackEyedGhost. But even working within the bounds of people's expectations about copyright, I think the way lawsuits are ruled with respect to music is a complete farce. There is a lot of freakin' music out there, and the birthday paradox clearly favors the coincidence hunters. Even the ice ice baby lawsuit is nonsense. If you can seriously copyright 7 bass notes, and claim that it substantially makes the song what it is, then the only reason music isn't completely dead as a human endeavor is because most musicians just have enough basic respect for the craft to appreciate it when they get the glimmer of an inkling that some other artist might have taken inspiration from their work, since that's the fucking point of art, instead of just getting dollar signs in their eyes. I would actually love it if artists had to cite their inspirations... like, if they want to lift some section of some voice of some song, to make a substantially different song, they should simply have to make a mention, which would help music fans discover more music. This impossible environment where musicians are expected to get permission, aka give money to every possible thing they may have knowingly (or possibly even unknowingly) used as too direct an inspiration for any part of a greater work, directly encourages them *not* to credit any of their inspirations, at risk of being sued by them. Anyone who wants to be able to sue anyone else over this crap should first use original notes and stop stealing the chromatic scale.

The Canonical Debate

It seems to me that missing to copyright analysis for songs is some kind of theory of the "criminal" mind here. Sort of the mens rea of the one accused of doing the copying. While I understand that's the kind of thing that's nearly impossible to prove, it does seem to be missing as a useful exercise for contextualizing the analysis. In this specific case, for example, it makes no sense to lay the songs down one on top of the other and see if they match beat for beat. What is the scenario being alleged here that would make it useful to compare them like that? I mean, there are different ways to "steal" a song: * Lay down a sample of the actual recording * Make a reference to the other song in yours (the Beethoven thing, or jazz riff callbacks) * Do a cover of the song * Do a cover of the song, but change the words (parody, "I'd like to give the world a Coke") * Crassly rip off an unknown tune you heard somewhere and pass it off as your own (the Led Zeppelin case, Do You Think I'm Sexy vs. Taj Mahal) * Get inspired by something you heard, knowingly or unknowingly, and riff of it The proof required and the way you analyze it should be different in each case, and the only scenario that makes any sense to me here would be the latter. And in that instance, expecting the two songs match beat for beat just makes no sense. Lopez and Anderson-Lopez are so out of Grigson's league, I'm reminded of the scene in Amadeus when Salieri presents his carefully-crafted piece to Mozart https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C1czzbk9ITk I mean, you'd expect some changes (for the better). Although you guys mocked the idea that the words were stolen, I think the coincidence in the lyrics is actually a pretty convincing piece of evidence. Given this specific scenario, someone needing to write a song about "things never changing", and hearing (or remembering) a chorus that goes something like that is a pretty convincing explanation. You would OF COURSE expect the lyrics to match the action happening in the movie, not what the original author intended. That reminds me of the Tangled (another Disney film!) adaptation of the song Something That I Want, which kept the original song, the original artist (under proper license, of course) and changed the lyrics to match the story. So why isn't scenario analysis/context an important part of the discussion?

Ghost of Jerry Thomas

Just like there are special guests for areas of the law, I would really love if you invited Pat Finnerty on for one of the music law podcasts. He definitely is politically aligned and could really help bring the musical chops.

Knight in DC

100% BNL was the first thing I thought of

Knight in DC

Adam is great. I know nothing about music, but still enjoy his videos.

Knight in DC

finally listened. stopping by to note that lopez and andersen-lopez likely do all of their composing with cameras running for exactly this reason. remember the tort is actual copying. all of the similarity and comparison nonsense is to *infer* copying. but if you have proof of original creation, then all of that other stuff is moot. this case will be tossed out because there will be documentary evidence of them writing the song.

Billy

He really is a fantastic communicator. That sandwich analogy just nails it.