Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

You know the drill - post your questions here & upvote with the heart the ones you want answered!

Comments

Teresa Gomez

Who or what is your greatest enemy?

DontJudgeALawBookByItsCoverUp

We now know that the 118th Congress will start its session with 222 Republicans and 212 Democrats (and 1 vacant seat). I've got a few related "What if" questions about what are probably unlikely scenarios. What happens if 5 Republican seats become vacant? (217 Republicans seated) What happens if 10 or 11 Republican seats become vacant? (fewer Republicans seated than Democrats) What happens if after special elections for those vacant seats if Democrats win 5 or more of those elections? (and therefor control a majority of seats) Has it ever happened in history that control of the House changed parties in the space between midterm and general elections?

Kevin

How does one pass a super statute like RFRA compared to a normal statute? Also, what's to stop this supreme court from striking down any good super statute?

Help, I'm trapped in a podcast factory!

Andrew, suppose you had cases in front of Judge Cannon, FSW. Are there any steps you could take to try to safeguard your cases against a judge who is clearly not afraid to openly take sides?

Peter Coyne

Is Andrew at all familiar with Coroboration as an idea applied to criminal law? Not sure if it exists in other places.

YakkoWarner

Not law related, but can Andrew give any insight into why people from Maryland have an unhealthy obsession with their state flag?

Andrew Pane

How can attorney-client privilege be waived using the crime/fraud exception without first proving that a crime/fraud has taken place? Or put another way: if a jury is told that evidence is being introduced using the crime/fraud exception, doesn't that prejudice them that a competent expert has already determined that a crime has taken place?

Stormy Decisis

What are rights that an otherwise competent adult can't sign away? Could I sell you the right to determine my religion? Could I sign a contract giving opening arguments all of my income for the next five years in return for an on-air shout out? If every worker in a building agreed, could they sign away their right to a fire escape? What is the building was the US Libertarian party headquarters?

Stormy Decisis

Re Christmas: what was a present you always wanted but never got as a kid? Do you still want it?

General Contact Unit Problem Child

Andrew you said Judge Cannon refusing to obey the higher court's order would be like if judges just started ignoring supreme court precedent. If judges did just decide to do that what would happen if we couldn’t get the votes to impeach them? Like suppose by some miracle we took back the supreme court but all of the Trump hacks that are still on the bench just started ignoring any progressive rulings they made, what do we do? You kind of made it sound like the only remedy to that would be to impeach them and we know the GOP in the house and senate wouldn’t go for that

General Contact Unit Problem Child

So it’s my understanding that you can’t use diminished capacity as a defence for crimes committed while intoxicated because it’s assumed that if you were intoxicated it was you fault for choosing to get in that state. What if I was only intoxicated because someone else slipped me something without my knowledge? Like suppose I ran over someone while drunk but I was only drunk because someone put Vodka in my chocolate milk. Presuming I could prove that could I mount some sort of diminished capacity defence in court?

General Contact Unit Problem Child

Can Andrew just tell us what his plan to get around Mitch McConnell blocking judges was now we don’t need it? My theory was that it was getting the senate to pre-approve a bunch replacement SCOTUS judges during the lame Duck period, so you can just put them straight in if any judges retire or die in the next two years. I want to know if I guessed right?

Timothy Thayer

Didn't we preconfirm this last SCOTUS nominee, Ketanji Brown Jackson, as a condition put forth by Stephen Breyer? Am I wrong that he wouldn't retire until his replacement was confirmed? If that's really the case, what's stopping preconfirmation of a bunch of liberal justices in waiting to immediately take seats as soon as they're vacated? Can a confirmation be reversed?

Gmork

How long do you think Cannon and the other unqualified Trump judges will be on the bench? Am I just fooling myself in thinking that most will move back to the private sector after a few years bc they don't love the law enough to tolerate the hard work on mundane cases for comparatively little pay?

Gmork

That was pretty much the core of a case called Lockner, which was basically considered SCOTUS' low point, although the current court would enthusiastically agree that employees can force workers to sign all rights away.

Don't use good yarn on bad conspiracies

The right to a fire escape isn't just for the benefit of the people inside the building. It is also for the benefit of the fire fighters. That would complicate the issue.

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

If I demand/suggest that someone sign a contract that *I know* is unenforceable, either in my favor or in the other party's favor, have I done anything wrong? I was in a debate with my friends about my state's strong protections against NDAs regarding pay and workplace compensation, and I brought up the fact that I frequently see employers demand that their employees sign an NDA to not disclose pay with coworkers even though the law very clearly states such NDAs are unenforceable in California. Now I can clearly see why a company would want to push this kind of contract. After all, how many new hires at Tacos Del Cara (or whatever small company) would actually have the resources to really check if that NDA is unenforceable?The vast majority of employees would almost definitely comply with the NDA simply out of fear of enforcement. My friend said that was clearly illegal, as the contract itself is deceptively tricking someone else into thinking the law is different from what it is. My concern is standing. If an employee discovered this deceptive contract and tried to sue, how could they prove that the perceived inability to disclose pay caused them financial damages? I will be honest, this sounds like a massive problem with our justice system since I feel like the deception should be tortious, but I am not sure how you could prove it. What if that NDA came with consideration like a bonus or pay raise? Could the employer claw that back?

Matt

Say someone like Kari Lake ran out of lawyers unafraid of Rule 11 sanctions to file their nonsense petitions and they started to file stuff pro se. Is there any kind of sanctions recourse for that since Rule 11 seems to be about a lawyer’s professional conduct?

Glumli

I recently read an article covering a conference at Harvard law school on the topic of "Common Good Constitutionalism". It was described as a potential successor to Originalism for the conservative legal sphere, essentially raising "classic morality" as something even more fundamental to base decisions on. It sounded terrifying... Is this something to be worried about? Should we be working now to head this off?

YakkoWarner

Are there any new or evolving holiday traditions in the Smith and/or Torrez families now that children are getting older?

Richard Scott

Is there a case Andrew would have loved to have been involved in with the precedent as it existed back then? Would there be one he would love to be involved in with current precedent, no matter how far back it went?

Deanna T.

What are the chances that the next Republican POTUS will give a blanket pardon to all Jan 6th insurrectionists, The Trump Organization, and Trump himself if he's ever convicted of anything? I'm finding it hard to celebrate convictions because of this possibility.

Michael

Could conceivably be needed in 2025 though!

Timothy Thayer

I cant take credit for the idea. My best friend was talking about that and said he wished he could ask Andrew. When I heard they did Patron q&a, I decided to ask here.

Michael

I think there is an OLC opinion that says a successor can be nominated contingent on an announced intent to retire, but that such a nomination would expire before the President's term ended.

--Jonathan--

Similarly what about hypnosis If someone can be hypnotized to squawk like a chicken whenever they see someone dressed in yellow, presumably other things are possible. What if the reaction to unconcious triggers results in illegal activity? The standard line given by clinical hypnotherapy advocates is that you can't be hypnotized to do something you would not otherwise do. This seems like nonsense, as people who turn to hypnosis to (for example) give up smoking clearly can't otherwise do it, or they would have. Are you aware of any legal cases where the "the evil head doctor made me do it" is raised as a defence?

Keith Richards

Texas juries are not allowed to be told about the cap on punitive damages. In other words, it's against the law for jury to be told about the very law they are asked to decide on. Surely this Kafkaesque law violates some part of the constitution?

Probably a real person

Two part question: Why are some EPA violations criminal while others are civil? Why does the government settle cases against corporations rather than prosecute fully? For example: in 2021 it seems like Dupont and PMNA got off relatively lightly compared to what they could have faced at trial. Or in 2022 when the pharmaceutical companies got to pay without admitting culpability for the opioid crisis. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-epa-and-texas-settle-dupont-and-pmna-and-require-action-address-violations https://www.npr.org/2022/02/25/1082901958/opioid-settlement-johnson-26-billion

Looming Dementia

I don't think that "super statute" is a thing. It's all just legislation, unless it's added to the Constitution.

Probably a real person

Is Judge Cannon likely to be impeached or removed from the bench for her grievous misconduct?

Forgetting to change my Patreon name

A lot of states have or are trying to pass laws that restrict trans people's rights to enter gender-segregated spaces on the basis of their "sex as listed on their original birth certificate" while most states allow amendments to the sex listed on a birth certificate, albeit some more easily than others. If someone is fortunate enough to have an updated bc, can another state really just decide to go off the original document? And if so, where does that stop? Could they just decide to only honor names as listed on the original bc and screw over everyone with an amendment for a spelling error too? Is this a weird thing for this type of document or could they just ignore amendments/updates to other legal documents like wills and say "no, only the original matters"?

Looming Dementia

To add to the core comment here (not that it really matters legally), how about people who get a major yeast colony growing in their intestines, after a hard-hitting antibiotic or something? Their digestive tract ferments its own alcohol from eaten carbohydrates, and the person is perpetually a little drunk. Yes, this affects their ability to pass a breathalyzer and/or blood test.

Brian Brondel

If Twitter goes into bankruptcy, as Elon Musk has suggested might happen, will Elon's creditors take ownership of Twitter? Would they be able to fire him as CEO?

Tonei Glavinic

Re #2, I think part of it is that the govt can get the company to agree to do things (especially on an ongoing basis) in a settlement/consent decree that they couldn’t necessarily get at trial (especially a criminal one), and relatedly that it can obligate the company to behave better/do certain things for a period of time into the future at risk of having the entire previous hammer dropped on them if they don’t

Tonei Glavinic

Rule 11 specifies that sanctions can be applied to “any attorney, law firm, or party that violated the rule or is responsible for the violation.” Courts generally give a lot of grace and leeway to pro se litigants, but I would expect that to not be the case here

Tonei Glavinic

since fire escapes are presumably required by the city or county that the building is located in, I think the workers wouldn’t have standing to waive that requirement - the government would have to, and would have to have legal grounds for doing so

Tonei Glavinic

I think there’s an underlying existential question re: religion - what exactly is it? Assuming proper consideration etc. I don’t see why you couldn’t sign a contract to e.g. become a member of a church, attend on a regular basis, evangelize, refrain from making any statements contrary to its teachings, etc.

The pun is mightier than the sword

If Congress passes code of conduct standards for SCOTUS, would SCOTUS then be able to sue over the constitutionality of that bill? Who would then rule on that issue?

Tonei Glavinic

My guess is that the jury wouldn’t be told

The DinosaurDave

Has Andrew ever been threatened with sanctions, if so, for what?

Chris Wiswell

Could a republican house judiciary committee pin an investigation by just issuing subpoenas for investigators working on Trump cases over and over again? (Thinking of how Rand Paul seems to subpoena Tony Fauci monthly, or whatever)

Carl Earl

Looming dementia, yes your hypothetical could argue diminished capacity because the intoxication was not willful or voluntary (unless prosecutor could prove that the person KNEW they had the disease and intentionally ate a starch/sugar meal before the actions) Same goes for GCUPCs first hypothetical. The hypnotism hypothetical doesn't apply because hypnosis doesn't work that way. Stage hypnosis is a magic trick that uses people's desire for the spotlight and fear of public shaming against the volunteers to get them to do the chicken things. You can't get someone to do something they wouldn't do because they actually ARE chosing to do the things.

Carl Earl

Tonei's right about the religion one. Most religious organizations have a "statement of faith" that employees must sign when starting work. Most also are immune from religious discrimination laws due to carve outs.

Carl Earl

I assume you mean OTHER than asking/paying Trump to put a good word in with her? 😁😜

Carl Earl

I predict: Thomas - background noise he can neither filter out or identify and stop. Andrew - people who can't tell the difference between scotch and bourbon?

Carl Earl

As far as I can tell, the House has not had control change due to special elections since the civil war. I don't think it did before that, but my source was focused on the current 2 party system which didn't start until about 10 yrs before the Civil War. Regardless of how many Reps are removed from office, the principle remains the same, each district missing a rep must hold a special election for a replacement. The only thing that would change is how many districts are having special elections at once.

Baron Atomy

Coworker was extremely upset that his religious accommodation wasn't accepted when others' were, and alleged bias though AFAIK never made an official complaint. I pointed out to them that this is the sort of thing that will happen when we put people into positions of assessing 'sincerity' of believers and ideological positions, a position they'd advocated for and opined on regularly regarding accommodations for faiths other than theirs. I was trying to find case law and precedent setting decent tests for accommodation for free exercise beyond Lemon and Employment Division v. Smith to help them understand how complicated it can be, but only really ran into the pastafarian Driver's License photos and prisoner issues in Cutter v. Wilkinson. What level of scrutiny into a person's beliefs, practices, consistency, adherence, etc. Is questionable and assessable in terms of courts and officials getting to rule on the 'legitimacy' of their 'sincerely-held religious beliefs'? How much do a plaintiff's or defendant's orthodoxy/orthopraxy matter regarding how others assess an adherents' level of belief and commitment, when it comes to accommodation or protected class? The DoD has a process with the Chaplaincy and EEO to try to assess eligibility for most accommodations, which, yknow, squicks me quite a bit, but still seems like more than what's available in most places. (Granted, most other places of work don't have to struggle so much with beards and, sadly, certain vaccinations). How much of a person's private beliefs and practice and public history is fair game in making assessments of a mutable characteristic like level of belief and practice?

Matt Butera

What was your favorite class in law school?

TheEthicalJerk

When a law is struck down, where does it go? Can't the executive continue to enforce it since the judiciary has no way to enforce their rulings?

April Poff

If I need a lawyer in a particular specialty, but I don't know one personally and I don't have community contacts to ask, is there a good source to consult? Is there an Angie's List for lawyers?

Looming Dementia

@Carl Earl Could the police really go after such a person for eating too starchy or too sugary of a meal? 😄

Looming Dementia

I don't know. Does the SCotUS always lie or always tell the truth? 🤔 Besides Thomas and Alto, I mean. We know the answer on those two.

Sil

Re: the Trump PAC under investigation for fraudulent fundraising - would love to know why DOJ hasn't issued some kind of cease & desist order based on the fact the big lie they're basing their fundraising on has been disproven in 60 different court cases.

Gmork

Threatened by a crazy opposing party/counsel? Probably. Most lawyers have at some point. By a judge? I'd be very surprised if Andrew ever had, as it's pretty rare for ethical/diligent attorneys.

Amanda Horne

Due to the frequency and severity of peanut allergies, maybe a Payday?

Sparkle Donkey

What makes a "member of the press" a member of the press (that would give someone more access or more leeway in a legal case?) If someone just prints out a sign that says "PRESS" or just writes a blog or has a Youtube channel, can they be considered "press" under the law, or are there variable degrees, like the NYT would be given more acknowledgement as a valid member of the press under the law vs a "citizen journalist"?

Garry Myers

Is there any room for the possibility that Trump actually wants to go to jail to avoid being poisoned by Putin when he's no longer useful?

Brad Kalmanson

What if a juror just knows? Could this come up in voir dire? What if the attorney said something to the media before the trial even started?

Doug Hudson

I’ve been thinking about the “inversion” of the 1st Amd where platforms can’t moderate speech but governments can tell platforms what content should be shown. For example, if Texas passed an “Age Appropriate Design Code” like California or the UK, could it use it to try to block access to all LGBTQ+ information behind age-gating as a backend around (traditional) first amendment protections for speech on platforms? What are the options to stop them if they tried it?

Quark Twain

That would be enjoyable but don't get your hopes up. Musk loves telling employees at his various companies that bankruptcy is just around the corner. Another reason they should work "hardcore" 14 hour days and sleep in the office.

Quark Twain

Is there a possible conflict of interest when a judge is involved in two unrelated cases involving the same party? Do judges ever recuse themselves on this basis, or is there a way for a party to request a different judge? This seems especially relevant with Trump and his ilk involved in so many cases, and we know they hope to draw certain favorable judges.

Quark Twain

For a hypothetical, suppose a defendent is found guilty of fraud. A few months later, they're involved in an unrelated case that happens to go to the same judge. The judge is of the opinion they're a slime weasel, and knows all about their previous dirty dealings. Seems unfair.

DDashevsky

Many states enacting laws forcing trans athletes to compete in the wrong division contain a very small number of trans athletes. Does that open these laws to challenges as bills of attainder?

Matthew from Talking About the Big Stuff Podcast

"Ivana's grave is full of documents!!!" Okay, that sounds like a conspiracy theory . . . but it's Trump, so nothing is off the table, or is it? Where would each of you put your beans on a subpoena to exhume the casket and check if they can't turn up all expected documents in other places?

Matthew from Talking About the Big Stuff Podcast

I wonder if lawyers who specialize in such cases couldn't (or why they don't) put that in their commercials so they're not saying it during a live case. I mean, Andrew told us, so it can't be illegal to tell anyone outside of the live case, right? So "Hi, I'm Thomas Smith of Thomas Smith Second Chance Law Firm, if you've been harmed by a big corporation, I can help you get justice. Also, if you're on a jury for such a case, make sure you award the maximum damages possible because the punitive fines are based on damages!"

Wordorigins.org

Mercer County, New Jersey (and perhaps other jurisdictions) is conducting jury trials via Zoom, where the jurors Zoom into the trial. I can see all sorts of problems with this, including the digital divide skewing the jury pool. (Mercer county is home to inner city Trenton as well as fabulously wealthy Princeton.) Could Andrew comment on the implications of jurors sitting and deliberating via Zoom?

Fireball Old Fashioneds

If someone testifies in a civil proceeding and fully answers all questions, can they invoke the 5th Amendment to avoid answering the same questions in a criminal proceeding. Or, is that right waved when they allow the questions previously?

bella ciao

From a non-U.S. perspective, I might argue that the highest court in your land is very clearly illegitimate - bought and sold by dark money. Assuming global leaders who matter to the U.S. concur with my perspective (not some unimportant person like me), what, if anything, does that imply for the U.S.'s authority in the world? This is probably more a political type of hypothetical, but can you think of any legal implications at the global scale between U.S. relations and its allies?

bella ciao

This could be a quick one (or someone on this forum may know the answer): I'm hearing in various legal podcasts that Sinema's defection from the democratic party doesn't impact the power Democrats gained in the Senate (ie they still don't need to do some power sharing bullshit with GOP). I'm not sure I understand: Why is this the case?

bella ciao

Hypothetical, say I'm a *criminal* defense lawyer whose drug cartel client asks me to traverse a desert to collect $7M of illegally gained drug money to pay for his bail. 1) is there anything sanctionable about the role I played in collecting said drug money (assuming I never ask the question directly to my client to know where the origin of the money came from)? 2) if it's not technically illegal/sanctionable, is it right for my courtroom colleagues to shun me? (Shouldn't they realize I'm just being a strong advocate for my client?!?)

Mitch Gresko

Most states' bar associations have a referral service. Also, avvo.com is a place where people can rate lawyers.

Mitch Gresko

Does the discovery of more classified documents at Trump's storage unit create probable cause to issue search warrants for ALL of his other properties? It kind of seems like that would be the case, but I haven't heard anyone discussing it.

Mitch Gresko

Who would win in a fight, Andrew or Neal Katyal? Would you be willing to duel with him over the rights to the Opening Arguments brand?

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

So I recently read that Elmo Husk just fired the Twitter general council. That strikes me as perhaps unwise to say the least. My question is this: how dangerous is a lawyer scorned? I know that a lawyer could very easily abuse their previous position to harass and attack their previous client. I also know from your previous discussions that it would probably be pretty easy for a competent lawyer to get some revenge without ever seeing consequences. Assume for this question that our lawyer is motivated to get revenge, but would never ever do anything clearly unethical.

Lawless Yeti

Any update on Microsoft’s purchase of Blizzard Activision?

Ilan Woll

Given the multiple sanctions against Kraken lawyers, how did Kari Lake find two lawyers willing to put their name to her lawsuit given the high likelihood of being sanctioned

Mike Koeppen

Let's say a litigant through fault of his own can not find a lawyer to represent him because of past actions or weakness of the case. How would they proceed in a case brought against them if they cannot get council?

Mike Koeppen

I know Andrew has brought this up on the show. Is there any reason to have oral arguments before the supreme court, when for the most part the court has made up there minds before the case is even argued? Both parties have sent in their arguments on the case in writing. This just allows some dickish moves from the justices during oral arguments. Alito comes to mind in a recent case.

Glumli

Does special counsel Jack Smith know how to smile?

Ben

(Leaving aside for the sake of this question that the death penalty is a horrific anachronism which has no place in modern society) If Donald Trump were to eventually be indicted for a very serious crime and sentenced to death, would his secret service detail be obliged to try to stop that from happening? What would the limits of their role and duty to protect their assignee?

Tim

How common is it for a grand jury to issue public reports? Here in Loudoun county VA, a Governor-Youngkin-appointed grand jury published a public report alleging all sorts of shenanigans with the school board handling of a “sexual assault by a trans student”. And it’s hard to know how politically motivated this report is. Not asking you to comment on the details of the report itself… but if you heard of a grand jury releasing a 94 page public report, would you tend to give it credibility or not?

Ilan Woll

There has been talk that Republicans were urging Trump to impose Martial Law. What would have been the practical effect if he had done so on Jan 6 and thus refused to leave office under that standard "until order was restored"

Forgetting to change my Patreon name

It's because she will still be caucusing with the democrats like the other independent Senators (King and Sanders). Not sure how accurate this is but I think of it like many other countries where many small parties have to form a coalition. 3 independents, even if they were independents in the same way, for the same reasons, have no power structurally on their own. Thus they have to pick a major party to share power with.

I'm pretty New Hampshire, but I'm not Libertarian Walks Into a Bear New Hampshire

What the hell is this article (and/or Ron DeSantis) talking about? Just, in general? How can a court empanel a grand jury, and how can a grand jury be tasked to investigate something rather than decide whether to proceed with charges based on the evidence presented by prosecutors, and even if they can somehow investigate, how can they investigate a general topic rather than a specific claim of wrongdoing??? https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/13/desantis-seeks-grand-jury-investigation-of-covid-19-vaccines.html

Josh Kramer

Regarding the Independent State Legislature arguments before the Supreme Court this term: Would a state be allowed to rewrite their Constitution to not have 3 branches of government? Could a state decide not have a legislature? Could they elect to have a monarchy if they really wanted?

I'm pretty New Hampshire, but I'm not Libertarian Walks Into a Bear New Hampshire

Oh hey, I asked a very similar question to this a few years ago and it got answered on the show! Under the guarantee clause of the constitution, every state is required to be a republic, but the only mechanism for enforcing it is for Congress to refuse to seat members from states that they don't think count as republics. In our current political landscape, where to put it lightly the major parties disagree on what exactly a "threat to democracy" is, that seems like something to worry about...

Mike

Has Andrew ever heard of "The Perfect Crime", the Georgetown Law Journal article by Brian C. Kalt arguing that there is an area in Yellow Stone where you can't be prosecuted for committing crimes? Any comment on the theory? Also they made a mockumentary style horror movie about it called Population 0. I haven't seen it but it might be a good LAM subject.

Mike

I think this is likely to impact non-US courts more than non-US politics. For example, the SCC used to routinely canvass and refer to SCOTUS cases in reaching their opinions. I expect that practice is likely to stop now that SCOTUS is so obviously biased.

Mike

A similar thing happened in Ontario during the Paul Bernardo case. He told his lawyer where he hid videotaped evidence of the crimes he committed. His lawyer recovered the evidence and was subsequently prosecuted for not turning it over.

Jeff Nathan

Flyer's Rights has been engaged various lawsuits against the FAA over whether or not seat pitch (the distance between seats) must be considered in assessing whether passengers can safely exit an aircraft in an emergency. Flyer's Rights interprets a section of the 2018 FAA authorization act as directing the FAA to issue regulations that establish minimum dimensions for passenger seats, including pitch. The FAA interprets the text in the authorization differently and never issued such regulations. Flyer's Rights attorneys recently argued in front of the US court of appeals in DC seeking a writ of mandamus ordering the FAA to issue the prescribed (as per their interpretation) guidelines including seat pitch. How might Chevron come into play in this case? Does Andrew have a prediction on who is likely to prevail? More information here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/transportation/2022/10/06/airline-seat-size-faa-smaller/ And here https://www.aviationpros.com/airlines/news/21280719/flyers-rights-argues-minimum-seat-size-standards-case-in-federal-appeals-court-asserting-that-the-faa-must-follow-the-law

Rebecca

Copyright Question! Can you have a derivative of a derivative? The FB group was talking about 50 Shades of grey, which came from a Twilight fanfiction, which (obviously) came from Twilight. Because the Twilight author didn’t sue upon the fanfiction release, does that demonstrate failure to protect your copyright, and allow for 50 shades freedom to publish?

Niklas Starck Westerberg

Since American politics affect all of the world many comments are written about it also here in Norway. In a recent commentary in a major newspaper it was argued that the moderate right and left are making a comeback lately after being gone for 10 years. They offer the infrastructure bill, the gun control bill and most recently the bill protecting same sex marriage as evidence. Would you agree in the assessment that the centre has gained more momentum in the last year?

Another Minneapolitian

I am watching the rail workers strike and wondering what rights congress has to impose a deal on two private parties. What is the legal basis for this power?

Another Minneapolitian

Having recently bought a house. Is there any way to streamline the buying process so we don't risk carpal tunnel signing document after document? Would it be possible to write a law that bans non-fee simple sales of real property or something? Thoughts?

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

I am going to say: Thomas - the eternal struggle to live up to his own technical and professional expectations with regards to the projects he undertakes. Andrew - THAT GOD DAMN WALL BEHIND HIM!

Rick & Sara

Andrew, in a episode 661 where you broke down Monster Inc and defamation, you mentioned that they're very litigious. This reminded me that in previous episodes, especially where the Kraken legal team was concerned, you would remind listeners where you could be reached if anyone wanted to challenge statements on the show legally. Has this ever happened? Have any of OA's previous episodes generated a legal response from either those who were the subject of an episode or maybe Kraken-adjacent?

James Weingarten

Could you tell us audio nerds how you record the show? I heard you mention Audacity. Do you record each person separately and then mix them together? How long are your recording sessions? Do you record multiple shows at a single session? Thanks

No name

Is there anything that can be done to force companies to adhere to an agreed specification? I'm in the market for bone conduction headphones but everyone uses proprietary magnetic USB chargers instead of USB.

No name

Is there anything I can do as an AZ resident to get people involved in fake electors disbarred?

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

Honestly I am interested in general strategy with this kind of case. Do you try to force the judge to rule in a way that gives the most ammo to your side for the appeal? Before a higher court, the strategy should probably be to force the totally biased judges to write the most specific, most absurdly narrow decision to limit the damage to the rule of law, but what if you could get judgement on your side if you were a sycophant? Could arguments devolve into statements like "I know you want to rule against the black church your honor... But have you considered how much power you could hand to white Christians if you wrote a broad decision in my favor?"

We have moral luck at home

What's Andrew's recommendation on how to get involved in local politics? Should I just start attending local city council meetings? Or is there something else I should look to get involved in?

Mark Hogue

Surely there must be a path to prosecute the QAnon fraud. Also, surely the intelligence community and DOJ have a pretty good idea of who the perpetrators are. If these assumptions are correct, what is the hold-up?

Galaar

He's about a year late to the NFT party, but there's always time to laugh at the shameless grift.

ElChorizoTX

I believe I remember hearing Andrew talk about how the Twitter board had a fiduciary duty to hold Elon to his offer since it would be the best option for shareholders as far as making a profit goes. However, with the ensuing Elon fiasco scaring away advertisers and decimating the workforce, would a shareholder have any actionable case against Elon or the former Twitter board? I'm assuming the board would be safe under a "can't predict the future" defense, but someone could go after Elon in the same way there have been rumblings that Tesla shareholders want to (for him devaluing the stock).

Mark_

Thoughts on minor conspiracy theory? Elon is making such a spectacle banning accounts for frivolous reasons to distract from more meaningful bans being done more quietly, perhaps at the behest of a certain group of foreign co-investors.

Mark_

In some state courts you can challenge the judge for potential bias (not necessarily malicious or intentional bias). I am sure there is a federal analogue.

Mark_

Labor code 232 in California allows employees to speak freely about wages. In theory you could sue for recession of that unenforceable portion of the contract, but that wouldn’t be worth a whole lot. In reality you would just discuss your wages and Sue under the labor code for any retaliation. Labor Code has massive penalties and is very employee friendly to incentivize employees to enforce their rights.

Mark_

Trump org was a state court, so it would take a NY governor to do that.

Insert clever name here

It's explicitly prohibited under California Law, specifically Cal. Lab. Code 432.5: "No employer, or agent, manager, superintendent, or officer thereof, shall require any employee or applicant for employment to agree, in writing, to any term or condition which is known by such employer, or agent, manager, superintendent, or officer thereof to be prohibited by law." So in California, it wouldn't be a common law contract claim, but rather a statutory violation (for which there are penalties). Other jurisdictions will be different, though.

tony

How many patrons for the stretch goal of having a Liz segment every episode? She’s so fun to listen to

Kyle Bloom

With the increase in show content and all of the breaking new going on, when does Andrew lawyer?

Donna W (uk listener)

Can a lawyer charge a client upfront, in order to file a lawsuit which they know will be sanctionable? Ie Trump pays lawyer Z $1m now and the lawyer does it, knowing he'll be sanctioned but his payoff was worth it (even if it results in disbarring)?

Join Your Labor Union. Together we bargain. Alone we beg.

As a general rule, should Unions that represent Federal employees be for or against Chevron defference? On the one hand, these Unions frequently want to challenge Agency decisions, and having the courts automatically give the Agency the benefit of the doubt works counter to the Union case. On the other hand, the Federal Labor Relations Authority, itself an Agency, has decided administrative cases in favor of the Unions (and against them), and eliminating Chevron deference would make all these decision more vulnerable and this area of law less settled.

Justin Haines

If the rail workers were to wildcat strike over their government forced contract or were just to collectively call in sick for multiple days in a row what, if any, legal consequences could they face?

Steven NYC

How did Ace Associate Morgan Stringer end up working for a Maryland lawyer? What’s the story? I don’t recall hearing that history.

Fraud Fishy Hates Everything

Regarding the appeal from that one guy on "Obstructing an official proceeding", do you think there is any risk that the real intent is to get it before the Supreme Court so that they can get an opinion narrowing that charge to be toothless like they did with public corruption laws ala VA Gov Bob McDonnell and his Mc-Tobacco-Ferrari?

Fraud Fishy Hates Everything

From a business and legal standpoint, what exactly does it mean when you say "Opening Arguments is sponsored by the Law Offices of P. Andrew Torrez"...? Do you have a contract with yourself? Is there remuneration?

Justin Haines

Which Autobot would you pair up with which Decepticon in a star-crossed lovers tale of romance and tragedy?

Pain Strumpet

ChatGPT suggests: "How do you see AI potentially impacting the music industry in the future, and what legal issues do you think may arise as a result? For example, could AI be used to create music or assist with music production, and if so, how would this impact the rights and compensation of human musicians? Are there any legal frameworks in place to address these issues, or will new laws need to be developed to address the unique challenges posed by AI in the music industry?"

Teresa E.

Is it possible that some of the Republican members will be arrested before they can be seated? If enough, does party control change?

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

DISCLAIMER: I am not a lawyer! Reading a little bit into that law's interpretation, it seems there are still serious questions as to if the act of telling an employee to sign a deceptive contract is itself to "Require, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing the amount of his or her wages." of if if that law really just prevents retaliation against the employee after they do disclose their wages. (https://casetext.com/analysis/new-california-law-prohibits-choice-of-law-and-venue-in-employment-contracts) I have good news though, you are totally 100% right for a different reason! Like a doofus I never saw that California labor code Section 232 has a part B: No employer may "(b) Require an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose the amount of his or her wages."

Clayton Johnson

How many Trump NFT's did you manage to buy before they sold out? :D

campindan

Legally speaking, how do prisoner swaps work?

Travis E.

I was correctly arrested for a DUI several years ago. I completed everything that the court asked of me. Nine years later, I moved to another state, which imposed conditions on me because of that incident. How is that legal?

SJ Wood

Why tf do Alford pleas exist?!

Russian warship, Go clownhorn yourself

Is there any way the 11th Circuit can put their finger on the scale of judge choice, especially when it comes to Cannon and Trump? I understand how problematic this could be, but FSW Cannon's actions didn't put her in good standing among her colleagues.

Josh Kramer

Awesome, great response. Thanks!!