Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Once upon a time, there was a company that sold incredibly overpriced cables... When that well went dry, they moved onto patent trolling. This is the story of when they attempted to patent troll the wrong guy...

Links: Monster Cable - Wikipedia, Monster Cables, Monster Ripoff: 80% Markups – Consumerist, Do Coat Hangers Sound As Good Monster Cables? – Consumerist, HDMI cable scam used to fool in-store customers? | Engadget, Monster "HDMI Difference" scam still kickin' in Fry's Electronics | Engadget, Monster patent C&D, exhibits, Blue Jeans Cable response, Blue Jeans Cable Strikes Back - Response to Monster Cable | Audioholics

Files

Comments

David in Brooklyn

Oh, this will be interesting. The cable nonsense in the hi-fi business has been way, way out of control for many years. Monster was by no means the worst of it, but they seem to have capitalized on the trend the most widely.

Mother pheasant plucker

Thomas nails the analog analysis. I studied EE in college. A twisted pair cable will eliminate a large amount of environmental noise that you'd see on a cable. A shielded twisted pair cable will have near zero noise. The only other thing that matters is ensuring the impedance matches. An impedance mismatch will cause a reflection of the cable (the signal will "bounce"). For longer runs, it's a more pronounced problem. It'll ultimately mute the signal. Monster (afaik) was selling the idea that gold plated terminals did anything at all (it doesn't). It's about as useful as adding gold flakes to food.

Viktor Arthuis

The copyright story reminds me of a Tumblr thread I saw the other say. Shady websites will scrape Twitter for any comment mentioning tshirts in replies to images (think "This looks so cool, it should be on a tshirt"), take the image and then put it on a tshirt on their website automatically. A shitty thing to do to small creators. The internet then did what it does best and decided to troll them. Someone drew Mickey Mouse with text around him saying something along the lines of "This is not fair use, this is copyright infringement", a reply was made about tshirts and it naturally ended up on the website. Fingers crossed that Disney now do what they do best and sue those websites.

Michael Rops

Monster Cables lost the James Randi million dollar challenge back in the day. They did the coat hangar challenge too.

Zircon Productions

This is a good article. That whole debacle was a lot of fun, but Randi was livid…

David in Brooklyn

Yes, but analog consumer audio connections are unbalanced, and with two exceptions, the signal sources are at low impedance, while the loads that they drive are at impedances 50 to 100 times greater or more. (In EE terms it's a "bridging" rather than a "matching" load.) So any ordinary length of ordinary cable won't -- can't -- have any influence on the sound quality of the system. This is borne out by the "blind" comparative listening tests that the program refers to. The coat-hanger incident is no surprise if you understand Ohm's Law. The two exceptions in consumer, analog connections are phono cartridge -> preamp and power amp -> loudspeaker. These are a bit special; speakers, for example, may be nominally 8 Ohms but in fact, their impedance varies widely across the frequency range, so a speaker cable that has just a few Ohms of resistance can audibly affect the frequency response of the system. 16-gauge speaker wire, which costs a few cents more per meter and has lower resistance per unit length, might really be preferable to common 18-gauge "zip cord". And a phono cartridge/turntable ought to be placed close to its preamp so that cables any longer than a meter or so don't have to be run at all. Digital audio connections operate at radio frequencies, so in that case we're talking about transmission lines. Impedance matching does become important then, past a certain minimal length of cable. But Monster got its foothold back before the CD even existed. BTW, Thomas, "balanced" connections, typically used in professional audio, aren't any better at delivering signals as such--but balanced inputs (if driven by balanced signal sources over balanced cables) can reject various types of interference far better than unbalanced inputs can do, as Thomas May describes. Also, balanced lines were in use far earlier than the 1950s that you guessed; links from radio studios to transmitters and antennas used them in the 1920s and 30s, as did telephone lines, and I'm fairly sure that they were originally developed for telegraphy in the 19th century. -- best regards

Salt Prairie Photography

One big advantage that digital has over analog is the ability to correct errors in the transmission. With some math (and some redundancy overhead in the transmission), a receiver can determine if it missed a bit or got an incorrect bit, it can correct it. Also, yes, it's usually "bits" when talking about transfer speeds but "bytes" when talking about storage.

Erin Worrell

By about page three I was almost, but not really, starting to feel bad for Monster's lawyer. But since he was willing to send this nastygram in the first place, I doubt my sympathy is warranted.

Erin Worrell

I tried writing a nastygram on behalf of a friend who had this happen to her stuff. The address ended up being an empty field in Iowa, so it obviously came back undeliverable. Only cost me a stamp and a few minutes, but I figured it was worth a shot.

Andrew Katzenberger

Andrew was wrong. Those model numbers for Monster products that cost more than $500 were amps, not cables.

Nick Stack

Just wanted to add that balanced connections can help to reduce ground loops and other issues. They are now frequently available on prosumer equipment for reasonable prices comparable to regular consumer gear, as long as one is willing to look. (I use a pair of PreSonus speakers and a Sub in my office. Everything is connected over a balanced cable to my DAC. The speakers, sub, and cables cost less than $500.)

Galaar

I really enjoyed this, years of tech support calls explaining that gold-plated "high-end" Monster HDMI cables were a scam and now I have court filings to cite to as well. Fantastic.