Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

The internet is aflame over a leaked draft of Wizards of the Coast new licensing agreement for Dungeons and Dragons. But, should they be? Our resident legal expert Andrew says no and calls the Gizmodo piece that started all of this "irresponsible fear mongering." Listen in to find out why! For full links and show notes, click here!

Files

Comments

Ben Smith

A bit of a note about Pathfinder outselling D&D: this happened during 4th edition, which did not fail under the Opening Gaming License, but a more restrictive Gaming System License. And now, Paizo is creating a Linux-like foundation for an Open RPG license independent of WotC to counter the onerous licensing of your content to WotC. Most of the online creators I follow have focused on that line you pointed out, rather than the Gizmodo article.

Someday Sera

So…what about like…all video games? It’s not hyperbole to say the entire rpg genre, both jrpgs and wrpgs, are HEAVILY based on dnd. Some hide it better than others, but it’s there pretty much across the board, something like the original knights of the old republic follows dnd rules to a t, using the same terminology and mechanics in every aspect of the game. Even going back to dragon quest/warrior 1, released in 1986, one of the first jrpgs ever made, the influence of dnd on the game’s combat mechanics is very clear. Likewise dnd protected elements like mind flayers and beholders appear in nearly every final fantasy game, every souls game….pretty much every fantasy rpg out there, Tiamat? A major character/boss creature in EVERY final fantasy game. Dnd spells like magic missile exist in hundreds of non dnd fantasy games, And this is to say nothing of the crpg genre Unless I’m missing some nuance here dnd feels like it very much falls under “not defending your trademark territory” If the ogl only applies to tabletop games that’s one thing, but when it’s the entire structural basis for a genre of media, it feels like that ship has sailed. *seriously though, go load up kotr, and look at the character sheets, skill lists etc it’s straight up, just Star Wars dnd, full stop.

Someday Sera

In wotc’s defense…I absolutely thought pathfinder was part of official wotc dnd

Michael Grossman

The new OGL requires that all OGL content develop on the SRD v5.1 to be compatible with Dungeons and Dragons 5th edition, and explicitly says that developing on early versions of Dungeons and Dragons is "Unusable Content" Pathfinder and the like are all developed using the SRD 3.5. (Though they are not allowed to advertise themselves as compatible with 3.5) This seems to be a huge change. If people can no longer develop third party content for Dungeons and Dragons, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons second edition, Dungeons and Dragons Third Edition, and Dungeons and Dragons 3.5, I don't know how that isn't a significant restriction on the kind of content allowed. Wizards of the Coast is requiring that all content be compatible with the newest edition of Dungeons and Dragons. I would also like to state that, while Pathfinder's rules are based on the OGL, all of content developed using the OGL is available online for free. If I want to create a pathfinder character, I can go to either the Archive of Nethys (https://www.aonprd.com/) or pathfinder srd (https://www.d20pfsrd.com/) and find everything I need to create a character and stat blocks for monsters. What is not available for free is characters, story arcs, modules, stat blocks for specialty monsters developed for the modules. If you want to play pathfinder without paying for it, you can. All the resources are openly available. This is true of all third party content developed under the OGL. I feel that the characterization of "Stealing their rules" is unfair, and yes, Thomas, Paizo is in fact "Just giving away" large portions of their product. From the description of the Non-Commercial OGL ": Non-Commercial only allows for creation of role playing games and supplements in printed media and static electronic file formats." and the Commercial OGL " Commercial only allows for creation of role playing games and supplements in printed media and static electronic file formats." it sounds as though these online archives are no longer permitted by the OGL? Your summation of what Paizo would need to do is wrong. They have some modules they develop for Dungeons and Dragon 5th edition, and for that, they'd need to fill out a form, but Pathfinder Second Edition was developed under the original OGL and is not compatible with 5th edition. By the OGL 1.1 "You agree not to use Unlicensed Content unless Your use is specifically authorized by a separate agreement with Us." they would need to come to a separate agreement, not just fill out a form.

Michael Rops

I believe that there is a separate specific agreement between WoTC and Disney/Lucasfilms

Michael Grossman

Tiamat is a Mesopotamian goddess. Not copyrightable as a name. Tiamat as a goddess of dragons with five heads of different colours is a different situation. Knights of the Old Republic was developed on Wizards of the Coast's Star Wars Roleplaying game. Bioware also developed Neverwinter Nights and Balder's Gate. D&D 5th edition makes extensive use of Balder's Gate properties. They really try to play up their recognizable characters.

Michael Grossman

Yeah, most of the stuff I've seen complaints about is about that what Wizards of the Coast can do with intellectual property, though I do know one creator who was developing resources for characters with disabilities (neither Paizo nor Wizards of the Coast offer a lot of resources if you want to play a blind, deaf, or movement impaired character) who is concerned that the new OGL might prohibit the material. While I don't see anything that explicitly prohibits disabilities, it might be something that Wizards of the Coast considers "outside the spirit of the game"

Shaudius

Point of clarification. The OGL didn't exist until d&d 3rd edition, so products based on 2nd edition and before aren't covered.

Michael Grossman

Oh, okay. That makes sense. I had assumed that the original OGL had opened up the earlier versions because I'd seen some first edition clones. But when I was looking for a second edition SRD I couldn't find anything.

Katie Stienmetz

So... when is Andrew going to guest on D&D minus with Normo?

A Plethora of El Jefes

A friend of mine brought up an interesting question for Andrew: When preparing for this episode, did he use OGL 1.0, the original document, or OGL 1.0a, the current authorized document, and just drop the ‘a’ for ease of speech? There are apparently some significant differences between 1.0 and 1.0a

Tyler Larson

I don't think this is broadly true though. I follow tons of TTRPG community folks on Twitter and without exception it has been simple RTs of the article with calls to cancel your DnD Beyond accounts. Even, for example, Cory Doctorow 's long thread on the article focused largely on the scope of the license, including an argument that users surrender rights they should have in *DnD properties* , but nothing in your own IP. I have actually seen exactly zero instances of the argument around your own IP. Doctorow thread: https://mobile.twitter.com/doctorow/status/1613200657476976641

Mothringer

Note that the comparison of the 25% royalty to progressive income taxes isn't quite right, as it's based on revenue, not profit, in an industry where typical profit margins are nowhere near 25%, so it really can set up a situation where the more you make the less you keep. Also worth noting that it's actually the decision to abandon the OGL for DnD4e that lead to Paizo becoming a direct competitor. They were originally a publisher of adventures for DnD as well as a subcontractor WotC hired to run all their DnD related magazine lines and were forced to create their competing product to avoid being driven out of business when WotC changed the intervening version of DnD to a less open license then.

Garry Myers

So... Why aren't bonus episodes of D&D Minus behind the paywall a problem?

New Cat Just Dropped

I think you gloss over the "you can only make physical books/static PDFs" bit a little too quickly. VTT usage has become massive in the past few years, and Wizards banning any ability to make anything that hooks into a VTT at the same time that they are coming out with their own VTT is a major issue. https://arkenforge.com/what-does-ogl-v1-1-mean-for-vtts/

Michael Blank

I feel that Andrew's analysis of being able to copyright mechanics is inaccurate. I don't have the resources to search for it, but I think that this is the equivalent of attempting to copyright a recipe. The actual wording of spells or descriptions of rules can have copyright attached but something like a mechanic of a dwarf having +2 to constitution couldn't.

Tyler Larson

I don't think you are correct. The standard is a "modicum of creativity". And while you can't copyright a literal data set, the SRD clearly has had organization and editorial work sufficient to meet that standard (in my not quite yet an IP lawyer opinion)

NR

I'm a long time listener and patron and I think this episode is a bit of a miss. At the end of the episode, I still agree with the position of the Gizmodo article, and I don't think that anything they wrote is "bad faith" or even wrong. You spent a lot of time on the first paragraph of the article and reading the original and updated OGL, but I think you are misinterpreting what the Gizmodo author is saying. It says the new OGL "significantly restricts the kind of content allowed" which you took to mean the author saying it restricts the DnD rules/content allowed to be used (Blue Dragons shoot lightning), but I interpreted it to be about the third party content created under the OGL, which is in fact being restricted, and I think 'significant' is a fair modifier to use in that sentence. I really think calling this an "out and out falsehood" is not correct at all. Many of the lines of the article you highlight do not have the negative connotation you read into them. For example, you spent a lot of time on the line about the size of the OGL increasing from 900 to 9000 lines, but it doesn't say that is a bad thing, and I absolutely don't think it is 'misleading' like you called it. It's just an introductory sentence that provides some context about the scale of the change. Thomas literally says "if you want to talk about the evil of these added words..." but where does the article say the increased size is evil? Andrew inserted his own intonation when reading them aloud (dramatically emphasizing '9000'), but there are no words in that sentence in the article that indicate the increased size is 'evil', and my reading of the article is not that the author is saying the increased size is evil. You brought that yourself. Saying they put "unauthorized" in "scare quotes" is another thing that stood out to me. Maybe they put it in quotes because it is a quote from the new OGL? That seems like a completely reasonable good faith interpretation and I don't know why you attacked them for using punctuation that is completely accurate (its a quote, they put it in quotation marks). Outside of stuff like that, maybe I just missed it, but I didn't see anything really wrong with the Gizmodo article. Maybe I'm just not seeing the point you are trying to make, but I felt like the criticism you brought were not anywhere near as strong as the long intro about how this article is written in 'bad faith' and possibly intentionally misleading. Sure, some of the legal analysis in the article may not be perfect, but its not intended to be that kind of article. I feel like calling someone else's work "bad faith", when they don't have any previous reputation, should have a high bar, and it wasn't met here in my opinion. I love you guys and only post this because this felt like such a departure from the usual high level analysis I come to this podcast for :)

Mothringer

The retroclones are based on the 3e/3.5e SRDs and just attempting to replicate the experience of earlier editions without using any actual older edition content.

Pascal

Also, wouldn't ads on the free ones make it commercial?

Michael Blank

You can no more copyright +2 to constitution or roll d20+modifiers over a target number than you can the order, amounts, times and processes for making a cake. All of the stories and phrasing can be protected but not the mechanics. If I am wrong about that, then the entire TTRPG industry is about to be destroyed because that is the foundation it is based on.

Syngen

Andrew nailed the shit out of his analysis on this one. Wizards of the coast just basically put out a press release that says all of the same things

Michael Blank

They still felt the need to be snarky about some people feeling they won. WotC really needs a team to read stuff first.

Tyler Larson

Sure but you're now engaging in an exploration of the idea/expression dichotomy which is....complex to say the least. You could cherry pick out individual elements that might not be protectable, but I don't think you would win that argument on the SRD itself ETA: the reason a recipe isnt (generally) copyrightable in my understanding is because a recipe is a combination of functional directions (no reasonable different expression) and ingredients (pure facts or data)

Syngen

Oh I'm not saying that they don't need better PR teams and things like that. Don't get me wrong. They're still a corporation and corporations are evil in general. Just because I don't think we should be as freaked out about this leak draft as everyone is making it doesn't mean I agree with a lot of things are doing money-wise.

Syngen

I also think that they're definitely needs to be discussions around the OGL and things like that and people saying hey, we're concerned because we still want to be able to do the content creation we're doing also isn't a bad thing. I just feel like this has been blown way out of proportion.

Mothringer

It's also contradicted by WotCs decades long position on what the OGL allows, the claims that the OGL was never intended to allow those other things is a bald-faced lie on WotC's part. From their own FAQ that has been live since 2004, and was removed shortly before the leaks began: https://web.archive.org/web/20060106175610/http://www.wizards.com:80/default.asp?x=d20/oglfaq/20040123f "42. I want to distribute computer software using the OGL. Is that possible? Yes, it's certainly possible. The most significant thing that will impact your effort is that you have to give all the recipients the right to extract and use any Open Game Content you've included in your application, and you have to clearly identify what part of the software is Open Game Content." Note that a lot of other pro-WotC claims are also contradicted by their own public statements of the intent of the contract's meaning from that same FAQ.

Veki

I wanted to say that regardless of how much or little I agree with your analysis, using a Gizmodo article as the basis of your analysis was my least favorite part of the episode. I think I would have much rather had an OA deep dive into the OGL and history without talking about how right or wrong a Gizmodo article was.

A Plethora of El Jefes

Tiamat is also an ancient middle eastern deity. I think with Tiamat they are specifically protecting the 6 headed multi color dragon concept. The name should be copyrightable Baldurs gate and neverwinter (and ice wind dale) and set specifically within d&d’s forgotten realms campaign setting, they are using explicit tsr/WotC ip not the ogl.

TMoney2007

I saw a trailer for this one and it seemed like it had the potential to be okay... I'm not into the lore so I may not be qualified to judge it, but the movie doesn't seem to take itself too seriously which I think is a less bad decision than trying to turn it into a super serious drama.

Alex Drake

Paizo actually does just give away Pathfinder. Every bit of new mechanics gets added to the official Pathfinder SRD at https://www.aonprd.com… which may actually bring Paizo under the Fan Content Policy. My College Group actually ran for six years without buying a book, using the Pathinder SRD materials. The only bits that don’t go on the SRD is the Golarion Setting information.

Mike Lilley

Sex dungeons and bad dragons

Mothringer

The current edition of Pathfinder doesn't even use any content from any of the WotC SRDs anymore, it's just available under OGL because of the lower friction involved with not forcing 3PP to spend extra resources understanding a second open license to support pathfinder. They've already announced it's going to be relicensed once the new open license initiative they are working on with the 3PP is ready, to remove any WotC related risk.

Alex Drake

This is why Paizo made new Dragon Gods for Golarion, actually. Original OGL didn’t let them at that iconic element, so they brewed up their own thing. There’s actually very little non-mechanical material in Pathfinder that is attributable to Wizards of the Coast. The Tolkien Estate might have a gripe with them, tho… but that’s the story everywhere in Fantasy.

A Plethora of El Jefes

I think we read different press releases. The one I read said basically “we’re sorry you caught us” and now that they are caught they need to delay their plans so they can completely rewrite the document. They say they always intended to have community input on a document that was only sent to industry insiders and was originally intended to be signed and in effect by the end of today. Oh and I think a lot of people not be aware, but the reference to “other companies accusing us of stealing” refers to the fact that their announcement materials for their new online vtt contained images copied uncredited directly from pathfinder books (not redrawn in a similar style, actual artwork copy pasted directly)

Mothringer

It's not even the second or third D&D movie. The 2000 movie had two direct to video sequels.

Pascal

Agreed, I think the lack of background knowledge on the history really hurt them here. Knowing the context of the 4e debacle leading to the creation of Pathfinder, the fact that WoTC's own website said they could not revoke the prior license up until a month ago, the fact that the creator of the license said it was his intent for the license to be irrevocable, the fact that the new license excluded VTTs, while WoTC is developing one, etc. would all have lent some more context to the situation.

Mothringer

Fourth D&D movie actually. There were direct to video D&D movies in 2005 and 2012 also.

Mothringer

Not the first time, either. They had copy pasted art from one of the Pathfinder 2e bestiaries in at least one of the posters for the D&D movie as well.

Syngen

All right. Let me maybe change how I'm saying things. I'm not saying that wizards of the coast hasn't done shady things like what you're describing, but in the case of their update to the OGL I kind of have to go with Andrew on this one. Again, corporations aren't great and are going to do shady shit for profit. I understand that but in this very small instance I think it was a little bit overblown.

Unlikable Internet Goblin

Yeesh. I may go down that rabbit hole later. Sounds like a really fun waste of time.

Lexy

Props for the "Critical Hit (Piece)" title, that's clever

Cal

Edit: This post was originally responding to a coment name-calling and telling people to "get a grip" and saying this isn't important which has since been deleted. This is NOT criticism directed at Andrew or Thomas. ~~Please get a grip on your patronizing tone. This is entertainment law, same as any of the segments Andrew does on Baseball law or the segments that Morgan did on the Johnny Depp trial. It's a billion dollar entertainment industry - calling people who enjoy this as a hobby "adults who refuse to grow up" is gross.~~

Haha I Made You Say Butts

The community seems to be very interested in this topic if the Facebook responses are anything to go by. Can we get a follow up segment about the response WotC just put out and maybe a segment with the lawyer who wrote the original OGL? He is currently the lawyer for Paizo and Kobold press and is helping them create a new open gaming license system and it would be interesting to hear his take. Plus, I think he’s been on some YouTube shows so he seems down with interviews.

Junk Bonds and Junk Law

From the speech restriction side of things: it does raise some questions about whether relying on OGL to make content is viable long term. Of course there isn’t strong objections to revoking the license for those categories, but this is allowing future OGL updates (or just WotC C&D maybe) to retroactively disallow certain content. WotC is perfectly justified to include that. The community is perfectly justified to want to have a free and open community without the sword of WotC always hanging over their head. Think of iOS app developers who at any time could have their app banned from the store, removed from existing customers’ devices, and revenue confiscated. This might be just because they posted something negative about Apple on their blog, had something “objectionable” (and here I’m talking about as little as a naked breast), or even just performed some function that Apple’s own apps can perform. You can appreciate why creators and users would prefer to have a community not reliant on that, as the previous license was pretty close to promising. The new license is explicitly stating “this isn’t what you’re looking for” but now 23 years of network effects make changing platforms very difficult. Today WotC believes one thing. Tomorrow they could be owned by Disney and operate under a very different philosophy.

Mothringer

You're probably thinking of Ryan Dancey. He's the business guy inside Wizards that spearheaded the OGL drafting originally, not the Lawyer who drafted the final wording.

Someday Sera

Final Fantasy's Timat is generally a goddess of dragons with multiple heads so, their's is definitely from dnd. Though as I recall, later incarnations tend to have a single head, but are still typically a blue-ish colored dragon goddess, so maybe that was done to make her somewhat more legally distinct? https://finalfantasy.fandom.com/wiki/Tiamat_(Final_Fantasy) *this link shows the FF1 version which is the most copyright infringy, but she's appeared in most if not all entries since. Didn't know that about kotr though, explains why it's so overt about it. Most early rpgs have very obvious roots in tabletop gaming, but kotr was so much more blatant about it. Makes sense that it's a direct adaptation. I did know about the various forgotten realms games, but didn't know bioware made those too, that explains a lot.

Someday Sera

and when is the wooldasher mizzle going to show up in the monster manual? you know wotc wants him, he's a goldmine

Someday Sera

it's absolutely inaccurate, unless his definition of mechanics is different from what I understand. Video games famously steal mechanics from each other constantly. I'm less familiar with tabletop so maybe the laws are different there.

Someday Sera

I kept thinking of uwe bolle's fantasy movie too, but looks like that was dungeon siege...he made SO many bad sequels to it too now that I look. God...we need to get gam to do a bunch of his stuff for bonus episodes, that man is almost single-handedly responsible for the (mostly accurate) stereotype about video game adaptations being awful.

Someday Sera

There is no way that erotic dnd doesn't already exist somewhere....

Kevin (Nevu)

The bonus dnd minus episode doesn't use Dnd. It uses feelings and lasers iirc.

Jacob Vardy

Disclaimer: i get paid to run tabletop role playing games. To answer a question that i don't think was answered in other comments, the reason WotC only reserves the rights to a few creatures and places is that very little of it was created by WotC or TSR* employees. A huge chunk of the content, like creatures and settings, were created either by fans, taken from mythology, or plagerised from other authors (early D&D had a very messy history of legal battles with authors and their estates). The vast majority of D&D content is still produced by third parties. TSR tried to do everything in-house but couldn't meet demand while keeping high quality. After WotC took over, they eventually issued the Open Game License so there would be stuff for people to play. There are tens of thousands of authors who sell their stuff online as a side hustle. And WotC very much benefits from their under-paid labour. Which i think is where much of the anger is coming from. Oh, and the sex D&D book was published years ago. 'The Book of Unlawful Carnal Knowledge'. *TSR was the original publisher of D&D.

Jacob Vardy

Ingestion... its 'the Book of Unlawful Carnal Knowldege'. Published in Third Edition. To very mixed reviews.

Jinx Greymoon

The most humorous thing to me is that the whole “oh and by the way we own your shit to do with whatever we want” /is/ the part my friends have mostly been making the various angry grumbles about. Apparently we’re ahead of the curve

Godless Goth

That's the part all of my friends are the angriest about, too. Multiple DDB subs got cancelled because this was the final straw after so many other missteps in the past.

six

I found the framing confusing -- I heard about this story directly via the TTRPG community being upset, then reading WOTC's documents and statements. Having to hear those critiqued through the lens of a bit of shoddy reporting from Gizmodo made it harder to understand. After listening, I'm still mad about that asymmetric "we own your stuff" bit that Andrew calls out. But also worried about the impact on large-scale creators who make actual-play content (Critical Role, D20, podcasts with paywalls). Their freedom to do so has arguably given D&D its current renaissance. You can dismiss them as millionaires: but I like listening to them so I care about them. Are they going to change, in your estimation? I see that it's reasonable for WOTC to force these successful entities to renegotiate and pay royalties going forward. Disney would extract their money, sure. But I do hate it. And I wonder to what extent legal questions will be argued in the future about the difference between, say, an actual-play game using a licensed game rule-set and a play production using a licensed script.

I don’t want thanks

I think it’s worth noting that Paizo does in fact give away all of their content for free digitally.

What's her face

I hate that I'm doing this, but I'm going to comment before I've even finished listening. I'm in the communities that are up in arms about this. I've been part of the discussions about what the leaked draft might mean. I read the Gizmodo article the day it came out. I've read the relevant bits of the OGLs. I have not heard a single person make the argument that Andrew spends the first half of the podcast arguing against. It's a half sentence at the beginning of the article that may be wrong and overdramatic, but it's not what the actual contentious issue is. One thing I've always appreciated about this podcast is your desire to "steel-bot" the other side, but here it feels like you're spending an inordinate amount of time arguing against a strawman of the community. There are actual, real legal issues to be discussed here and this isn't it. What we actually find objectionable is the clause that lets them steal the work of anyone using the license. It sounds like you may get to this later in the podcast, but I've just spent half an hour listening to you attack an argument I haven't heard anyone make and do not care about while unnecessarily singing the praises of the company in question. I do generally respect what you have to say, so I will probably sit down and finish this eventually to see if you have anything actually thoughtful and relevant to say about this, but for now this episode has exhausted my patience. I wish you had spent less time on what doesn't matter and spent more time on what does. ETA: I made it a grand total of 40 minutes into the episode, at which point I'm feeling as though your reading of the article is as bad faith as you claim the article itself is. You seem to be misunderstanding or omitting a lot of important context, including that the OGL covers a lot more than just the 5e SRD and by de-authorizing it, they are causing a lot of confusion as to what the status of, say, 3.5 is. Do new modules for 3.5 fall under this new OGL? What about works published based on PF2e, which uses the OGL but isn't D&D based? There is a thriving ecosystem that is being thrown into chaos here that includes at least a dozen game systems that have nothing to do with WotC other than that they used the OGL. They could have said that One D&D was being covered by a new license, but they chose to do this instead. I'm unlikely at this point to make it to the part where you talk about the royalties, so I'm just going to echo what other commenters here have said and point out that the royalties were on gross revenue, not profits, so a kickstarter that brings in $750k but spends all of it on paying staff and artists would end up losing money due to these royalties. My understanding is that it's not uncommon for these projects to make less than 25% profit. Sorry, guys, but I feel like this episode was a fail.

MeggyLee

I became a patron to specifically mention this point: The royalties are on gross income, unlike taxes. Lots of these kickstarter modules aren't going to make tons and tons of profit. So I can see a huge stifling effect on the creativity of people in this space - the creativity that made DnD what it is.

I'm a man now but cute nb frog icon can stay

I think it's been said before but it bears repeating: Pazo actually *is* just "giving away their stuff for free". All the Pathfinder rules are available, for free and completely legitimately online through a website they control. You never have to give a dollar to pazo to play their games; thats why people like them so much. When the PHB costs a ton, and dice are expensive, and the dm guide is even more, and actually you need the monster manual, and you probably should start with the starter set, and really the good class options are in Xanathars guide well. Dnd is a fairly expensive game to get into. Pathfinder tho. If you want the official modules you can buy them, but you don't need to. And thats a HUGE deal to people just starting out ttrpgs. Sure they do sell a lot. But it's because people chose to support them. Not because a good game is behind a paywall

Chris Conley

@Mothringer which were, of course, as bad or worse.

Mothringer

It would've been much more useful too. There's a lot of publicly available evidence of the original intent of various parts of the OGL that disagree with Andrew's assumptions f what was likely meant, and that alternate approach would likely have lead him to encounter some of them. See for example any of the recent interviews Ryan Dancey has given about the creation of the OGL, which he spearheaded as the WotC executive in charge of turning D&D around immediately after their purchase of TSR. D&D at that time, despite being a property big enough to have video game licensing agreements, was hemorrhaging money with only a single digit employee count. The OGL was an apparently successful bet that the network effects of going fully open would far outweigh the lost revenue that would come from any new competitors it enabled. And note that Paizo was strictly involved in making content that made WotC's D&D products more valuable and only launched a competing product at an edition change where WotC tried to make a license change that would've undermined their ability to stay in business unless they diversified. Most of this debacle is a case of MBA types at WotC who didn't bother to figure out why their company both originally created the OGL, and then also came crawling back to it after a previous attempt to make similar changes. It won't shock me to see this show up in future business school case studies on corporate self-harm.

TheEthicalJerk

They want people to take it to their private Facebook group which is run by some of the worst moderators on the internet. A bit sad that they want to control the conversation like that.

Someday Sera

oh really? Andrew had mentioned he was getting spammed with nonsense over it, i figured it was just us being uh...annoying, maybe it's broader than that. I hope not, he doesn't deserve that.

Someday Sera

I was wondering if I'd misheard that, royalties on gross rather than net seems really unusual.

TheEthicalJerk

If one is getting 'spammed', why invite people to the conversation where they can be subject to shitty moderators?

JimBob Duggar's Liberal Conjoined Twin

I just signed up as a Patreon after this episode. The blowback I’ve received after sharing this episode on social media is amazing. Everyone seems to right to crapping all over WotC immediately.

Blaseking

I shared this episode with my nephew and one of our DM’s. As the messenger, I got your thank you for the clarification. So here, have your thank you, Thank You! As for the blowback I’ve seen and heard, people have already ignored the facts and been operating on pure emotion, and we all know how hard it is to break down that wall. How dare you educate me out of my self righteous anger.

Seth Swanson

Kinda the same, honestly. Andrews breakdown did explain a few issues and dim some of the near religious zeal but I felt like he missed the point about what has people up in arms, specifically the language around WotC having forever license to everything. He mentioned it at the end, but it got very little time, as opposed to lambasting Gizmodo's article on it. While I will admit to getting pretty caught up, I still feel like the community is justified in it's outrage. Not mentioned in the episode is that this isn't a draft. The new OGL was sent out to creators who were given an NDA and a week to sign. WotC further spent nigh on two weeks in complete radio silence while the community burned. More leaks came out, and are still coming out about WotC's leadership. Maybe it's true that WotC didn't have a single intent to harm the community and to simply update the language so it fit the times better...but they also handled it in just about the worst way possible. I'm a little disappointed that Andrew, and Thomas, seem to have just taken Hasbro and WotC at their word, trusting the "billion dollar corporation" without much in the way of scrutiny going that way. So, I got a lot out of the episode. It cleared up some things and reminded me about others (in WotC's favor) and generally helped me get a clear head back...but that's not to say that I think Andrew and Thomas did their best on this one.

Seth Swanson

Andrew did actually educate me out of my righteous anger, on a couple of the points of the OGL at least. That being said, I've kinda lived this whole issue for the last couple of weeks and if there's pushback, I think it's pushback that he's more responding to the Gizmodo article than the issues the community has with the OGL. And you're right. There are a lot of emotions involved and its hard to separate those from cold logic...and sometimes you maybe shouldn't. Anger gets stuff done sometimes, like getting WotC to backtrack. It's not great though if people like Andrew and Thomas are getting caught up in the tsunami for only wanting to help. Andrew was largely responding to the article, instead of the communities issues and he seemed pretty pro-WotC, while chastising people for defending "million dollar companies", and ignoring, or not being aware of, other things that had happened. So, I learned more than I had about the OGL and the new one, but also feel like Andrew and Thomas could have done a much better job on this one.

James Heath

Wow! That dungeon siege movie actually had real actors. Jason Statham, Leelee Sobieski, John Rhys-Davies (Gimli), Ray Liotta, Ron Perlman!