Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hooo boy! Lots of very energetic feedback on our DnD episode. Spoiler: many, many people think Andrew totally biffed the analysis. So, he's gone through a ton of it and has some fresh analysis for you. Is this an Andrew was wrong? Find out!

Here's the fb thread where you can insult Andrew. Here are the original show notes!

Files

Comments

Viktor Arthuis

I am fully expecting this episode to be Thomas reading comments and Andrew calling them dumb, wrong and embarrassing for 76 minutes straight.

TheEthicalJerk

Disingenuous to claim the OA Facebook group is unmoderated. It is full of awful moderators and this kind of statement really damages the show's credibility.

Tavernaut

Without further comment on the OGL stuff: as someone who doesn't use Facebook, I have to say that I'm a little sad that the discussion about this episode is entirely relegated to a Facebook group I won't be able to access. I completely understand not opening it to the floodgates of Twitter or the like, but inviting discussion on Patreon alongside Facebook would have been nice.

TheEthicalJerk

You've saved yourself the hassle of being insulted by their moderators.

Nick Ward

As a long time OA listener, Patron, and D&D player and GM, thank you for both of these episodes. I feel the D&D community gets very upset when Wizards does something remotely profit-motivated, so I deeply appreciated your perspective on the legal and business side of the OGL.

Christian Walters

Obviously, you have to know an entire company's history with their competition, their customer base, and the public before you can comment on a specific legal document from that company. Silly Andrew -- don't make the Internet re-evaluate things they are already confident they know! I've been told a bunch lately that Hasbro/WotC has a long history of abuse of their player base. Now I'm learning a new OGL will anger a thriving, enthusiastic player base. I'm starting to suspect the Internet by and large doesn't know what it's talking about... Keep up the good work, guys :)

Tavernaut

My intent with my comment wasn't to be negative about the moderation team. My problem with Facebook is with Facebook, not how OA organizes its community groups. Please don't make it about your disagreement with their mods.

TheEthicalJerk

No, that was the intent of my comment.

TheEthicalJerk

Making Wordle into a board game is pretty abusive.

Knitting To Old Time Radio

I actually saw some of the twitter garbage. It was aggressive and abusive. I've no respect for comments whining about having this argument on patreon or Facebook and moderators. It's a podcast and a podcast topic. It's work for Andrew and I really have no time for people making accusations about the integrity of the podcast over this. No accusations were made by Andrew. No insults were thrown at anyone. But the abuse and absolute snottiness of people who can consume this podcast for free but feel entitled to attack hosts is very dissapointing. Thanks guys.

TheEthicalJerk

Great, so criticism of this or any episode, should only be directed in a forum where they have awful moderation and claim to not even run the group? I don't have respect for people who don't bother to learn the issues either.

Knitting To Old Time Radio

Yes. Because that's exactly what I said. I'm talking about abuse. Muddying that distinction is not constructive.

Sidewinder

At EthicalJerk, you'd think you'd prefer your criticism to be on Patreon where they actually read and engage with the responses, not some random group where someone(s) unaffiliated with the show give people a hard time... its not Andrew/Thomas' job to police up every Facebook group in existence... the criticism seems unnecessarily harsh

Sidewinder

Are they affiliated with Thomas/Andrew or is it a random fan group?... Facebook is a cesspool

TheEthicalJerk

So the Facebook group where they direct people to have this conversation is now a random group? Patreon would be a far-better alternative than that horribly mismanaged group. However, I imagine it may not be the best to say criticism should only come via paying channels. He also said that he would not be responding to things outside the Facebook group.

TheEthicalJerk

It's where Andrew is directing people to have this conversation.

TheEthicalJerk

So your response to abuse and aggressivity is to say you don't respect people who complain about the complaint process?

Knitting To Old Time Radio

You're on your own tangent and writing your own novella here. It's nothing to do with me. But best of luck with it.

Lord Shaxx's inside voice

Any complaints/criticism should be sent to openarguments@gmail.com. Your gripes with any elements of the show is none of our concern and should be addressed to the hosts directly. They are straightforward people and will honestly discuss the matter with you in private.

Sidewinder

They also seemed to be engaging heavily on Twitter from the official OA page, not just the Facebook group. Andrew saying he isn't responding to comments saying "how much is Hasbro paying you guys?" like was on Twitter doesn't bother me that much, every vitriolic reply on Twitter was from someone whose entire feed was covered in D&D material or related to this lawsuit, so I don't blame them for not engaging with a sizable amount of the feedback that didn't seem to be in good faith.

TheEthicalJerk

And yet they said they will not be responding to e-mails or private messages about it. People should not be directed to put their criticism in a Facebook group that is poorly moderator and is claimed to not be affiliated with the show whenever the moderators do something stupid.

TheEthicalJerk

That's fine, they need not engage with every bad-faith comment or even respond to every good-faith criticism. The point is that they should not direct people to a private Facebook group that is poorly moderated where their 'fans' can defame and ban you should have the audacity to criticize them. The show talks a lot about how to speak to the Uncle Franks of the world but the moderators of their 'unofficial when it chooses to be' Facebook group are even worse than the Uncle Franks.

Lord Shaxx's inside voice

I am not talking about DM. This conversation does not belong here, period. I couldn't care less about your self appointed crusade against a Facebook page, and you will find no sympathy here.

TheEthicalJerk

Got it. Patrons shouldn't be allowed to complain about the show on Patreon. Perhaps a little less gatekeeping next time might be good for everyone.

Kalle

I know that the discussion is supposed to be in the FB group, but I tried it and it is too far left for me as a leftist Finn :) I think Andrew is confusing a particular license (GNU General Public License) with Open Source licensing in general. There is no hard and fast rule that an Open Source license must be "viral" in the sense that GPL is, or that you can use choose the license version you want to use. See eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apache_License for details on an open source license which is very different from GPL.

Sidewinder

He said in passing that he won't engage with further hair-splitting on the topic in the first 2 minutes of the episode and somehow this constitutes Thomas and Andrew personally endorsing the moderation of an unofficial Facebook group... please give it a rest. The Gizmodo article was bad and they addressed why from a legal standpoint. They then released a whole extra episode to address the concerns and clarify their positions. Sooo many topics get covered on this show and this is the only one I've seen in years where some listeners die on the hill of "you didn't cover this specific angle in the exact manner I wanted and since you won't have an extended dialogue with me to address my concerns, your credibility is shot with me." That's absurd... so glad to be done with this topic because gamers are the most sensitive, thin-skinned people on the planet.

TheEthicalJerk

It's unofficial but yet they link to it here and on their public OA Facebook page. Why not simply tell people to take the conversation to Patreon if they want to engage in better faith discussions? Good thing I'm not a gamer - however, the OA Facebook mods are surely the thinnest skins in the known universe.

Lord Shaxx's inside voice

Don't put words I haven't said in my mouth. Facebook, Patreon and twitter are terrible conversation platforms, and you know that. Considering the amount of vitriol that this subject generate, you also know that it is next to impossible to have a public conversation without having it devolve into a toxic mess. If a creator publish content that displease you, voice your criticism to them, then move along

TheEthicalJerk

They invited criticism of the episode on their private Facebook group. I take issue with the way that group is moderated. In my eyes, it's a way for them to control the conversation and have the mods ban anyone that is too critical. You just told me I shouldn't complain on here. For someone who couldn't care less, you seem to care a lot.

Chris Conley

I haven't found the FB group too leftist at all? By which I mean the one Thomas and Andrew post in, not whatever people here are complaining about.

No-One of Consequence

I get why they feel they have to make episodes like these, but they are always among my least favorite episodes they do. Invariably they come off as defensive and/or ranty, and focused largely on themselves rather than an interesting legal topic.

TheEthicalJerk

Parol is Norman/French for verbal. Get those Saxons out of there.

Kalle

I think it is more of a question of a very different discussion style from what I'm used to.

Lord Shaxx's inside voice

Do not mistake my interactions with any kind of concern for your overarching opinion. I've also told you where to direct your criticism. Voice your opinion in a polite manner and I'm sure they will at least read it. There is nothing else for me to add to this conversation, so I am ending it.

TheEthicalJerk

You sound like one on their FB mods. Criticism shall only be accepted in the form and manner prescribed by Shaxx!

Daisy W.

Strong agreement, what I listened to came across as defensive to the point of feeling kinda uncanny. Lots of what they are responding to is obviously bad faith, but it seemed like the ellided over substantive criticism. They call out people engaging in moving goalposts, but defended factual inaccuracies regarding Paizo by focusing on an, also incorrect, comparison of the size of WOTC and Paizo. Disappointed that they didn't use the opportunity to tell a more complete story.

Sidewinder

Probably because the OA Twitter account was being brigaded and Quote-tweeted by folks saying things like "How much did Hasbro pay you guys?" and the like. The genuine criticisms that I saw previously (like interpreting the word "use" from the Gizmodo as meaning re-sell commercially etc) were addressed. Without being a subject matter-expert on abstract D&D lore and background info, I'm not sure what part of the story they aren't telling... these sort of comments implying that Andrew/Thomas are misleading listeners or somehow siding with big corporations seem so bizarre and unnecessarily harsh.

Rawls’s OG Position

I like the discussion opened up towards the end exploring legal decisions in regards to games, copyright, trademark, and licensing. Seemed to move towards an interesting issue in protecting games. For instance, they mentioned Tetris, but what about other games or sports? I also enjoyed learning that Pac-Man’s knock-off had a first and last name. Either way, no idea what the controversy was about. We might need another episode to explore the controversy in full (kidding).

Christian Walters

That's the thing about modern OA -- don't like an episode? Just wait 36 hours, you'll have a new one! As a gamer who doesn't pay attention to game companies AND a cynic who thinks most of the internet is a monument to Godwin's Law, episodes like this warm my cold, black heart. (Thomas, if you found the right group, I think you would enjoy D&D. Assuming you had the time. Which you obviously don't.)

and I are in the 2nd 3rd it's objectively the best

Small nit on *this* episode in regards to open source software, so I'm putting this here instead of the FB thread. I believe Andrew is confusing forwards-compatibility with backwards-compatibility in his reading of the GNU GPL (and yes, it is pronounced "guh-new" in software land). I'm looking at https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-3.0.html 14, which says: "The Free Software Foundation may publish revised and/or new versions of the GNU General Public License from time to time. Such new versions will be similar in spirit to the present version, but may differ in detail to address new problems or concerns. Each version is given a distinguishing version number. If the Program specifies that a certain numbered version of the GNU General Public License “or any later version” applies to it, you have the option of following the terms and conditions either of that numbered version or of any later version published by the Free Software Foundation. If the Program does not specify a version number of the GNU General Public License, you may choose any version ever published by the Free Software Foundation." Andrew says around 44:30 of the Patreon episode: "So what that says basically is 'we may make future changes, but you can pick previous versions and continue to publish under those previous versions." Which yes, would apply if the last sentence of the GPL applies: that the program did not specify the version number of the GPL. However, if a program like GNU releases version 5 that says it is licensed under GPLv3.0, I *don't* think you can choose to use that GNU version under GPLv2.0 (an earlier version). If GPLv4.0 came out, you *could* choose to use that GNU version under GPLv4.0 because it's a later version. Also, as I understand it as an open source software author and contributor (and I do think there is lots of misunderstanding by software people about the legal interpretations of the licenses we use), future software versions could choose a different license (probably not in the particular case of the GPL because it's specifically designed to be viral, but under other open source institute licenses), but you *can't* go back and rescind/modify what license a previous version was licensed under because it's already out there. So I could release software program Snorgledorf version 1 under the MIT license, but choose to release Snorgledorf version 2 as closed source, and that doesn't change that Snorgledorf version 1 is licensed MIT. There has been plenty of relicensing drama in the open source software world. Finally, if this Gizmodo article leads to my favorite podcast discussing alleged toejam eater (and worse) Richard Stallman, I will pee myself.

and I are in the 2nd 3rd it's objectively the best

YES EXACTLY this is getting way far into open source software land, which is already a tangent, but GPL style licenses are actually not preferred in many open source software circles because of their virality, and that's a whole separate topic. Did the person saying the D&D license was supposed to be open source specifically say GPL?

Daisy W.

Again, bad faith criticism is bad, obviously, and the pretense that OA is in the bag for WOTC is stupid. However, 1. when a lack of subject matter expertise leads to make multiple factually incorrect statements, treating that criticism as expecting knowledge of "abstract lore" or as part of the larger bad-faith backlash is inappropriate and condescending, 2. Parts of this that would be very interesting to hear from a legal podcast would be, as an example, engagement with the interactions between legal frameworks and community norms and the history of this kind of conflict in D&D.

Nate

I can’t tell you how happy I am that Andrew is one of 17 people (along with me and my sister) who remember The Great Space Coaster and Gary Gnu. “No Gnews is good Gnews!”

No-One of Consequence

I think part of the problem is that this controversy goes deeper than the legal analysis. Many of WOTC's recent moves have been perceived as striking against the community and culture that has thrived around their various IPs. Discussion about this aspect of the controversy obviously falls outside the ken of a legal analysis/news podcast, so you can't fault them for not addressing it. But at the same time, focusing exclusively on the legal analysis can be seen by many as deliberately eliding over large parts of what's at stake.

Daisy W.

I think that's my view as well. This is a topic that has a lot of law in it , but it isn't a legal issue, it an issue of conflicts between profit motives and a community with a strong open- source ethos. This just isn't really a good topic for the structure and approach of this podcast, and focusing on the Gizmodo article amplified that issue by relying on that article as the cypher for the reaction as a whole.

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

Hi all, professional software tamer here. Just want to comment on a reoccurring semantics issue I am seeing in these discussions. When I hear people saying "open source" they are using it less as an actual specific thing and more of a "vibe", and this is leading to a LOT of confusion. First of all I need to mention that in the development community we generally don't call something "open source" when doing formal license checks. Instead we refer to their specific license, since honestly there are a LOT of gotchas. See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_free_and_open-source_software_licenses Andrew mentioned that in the GNU license he was reading, it required all derived work to be licensed the same. We generally call those "share-alike" licenses, and they are totally a very real thing in the software community, but they tend to be quite rare. Also, and I can't emphasize this enough, open source is being applied here as an analogy to the open source software community, but that analogy breaks down in some really important ways. Let me know if you want a full explanation, but honestly a lot of the conceptual basis of open source software relies on the fact that binary executables can't be easily decompiled, coupled with the fact that access to the real source code allows for a competent developer to circumvent any and all possible laws related to intellectual property. This is probably why source-available software (that is not open source) never really caught on. Honestly, in a very real way, the idea of open source comes down to the fact that a lot of these rights are just not protectable by any self consistent and well written law when the source code is available, and that is simply not the case with more abstract things like table top games!

I'm pretty New Hampshire, but I'm not Libertarian Walks Into a Bear New Hampshire

Huh. The Magic patent quote seems incredibly broad to me as someone who used to play the Pokémon TCG (back when it was still distributed by WOTC) and had friends who played its competitor Yu-Gi-Oh (not distributed by WOTC). I wonder whether non-WOTC games actually had to pay royalties for concepts like "using cards that represent energy" and "reducing your opponent's life points", and whether the part about the mechanic of buying cards to build your own decks (which a quick trip to Wikipedia says had existed since the 1950s) was enforceable at all.

Knitting To Old Time Radio

I don't remember this bit I remember nearly getting kicked out of a web forum around 2009 for recommending soneone try GIMP. I definitely meant GNU Image Manipulation Program! I swear I wasn't telling "Bad Idea Bear" to just get themself a sex slave. Although I know how that must have looked.

Catrenya

I think—legal cases entirely aside— a lot of the angst around this issue comes from D&D’s history and development being messy, involving extensive derivation from (and occasional wholesale copying of) game mechanics/characters/tropes originating in other games. TSR sold D&D to Wizards, but generally they’re viewed by the community as not deserving credit for creating it, but rather as caretakers of it, the way FIFA is the caretaker of professional football. When they go out and make license changes like they did, it feels gauche and counter to the spirit of a caretaker, and people recoil.

Some Guy Some Where

I still think Andrew is wrong in his first criticism of the Gizmodo article. The article says that the new OGL “significantly restricts the kind of content allowed,” and Andrew said that’s false because 1.1 and 1.0 have pretty much the same restrictions on the use of WotC IP, like mindflayers and such. I think that’s a misread of what the article was saying - as it went into later on, it was talking about OGL 1.1 being restricted to books and static digital files. That is a significant restriction on the *kind* of content allowed - I’m sure going to be sad if this means we won’t get further Pathfinder video games, for example. Andrew seemed to take WotC at their word that the OGL was never intended to cover anything like that, but that’s simply not true. For example, they specifically covered the issue in their FAQ for it and said that you could develop software under the OGL 1.0a. I thought Thomas was about to address this on this episode, but then he said the argument was that restricting nazi stuff was the content restriction the article was talking about. That sucked to hear. It’s a shame that that’s the argument that he saw, because it’s pretty weak and I still think this was serious flaw in their criticism of the article.

Chris Conley

I believe it's a sum of the parts argument, like with Andrew's Tetris example; if your game has just one or a small subset of those core features that make a Tetris game or a CCG, then it's definitely not a ripoff; if your game consists of all of them, it may well be.