Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

First, let's bring Thomas's score up to date: he got #311 correct, picking (D), and is now 166-for-311 (53.4%).  He's smoking the chatbot, which is a sad 0-for-2.

Files

Comments

Ben Smith

Examination-in-chief means this isn't cross-examination. This is one of the plaintiff's own lawyer and witness, so hopefully they're not hostile nor dodging questions. The texts sent an hour after a hurricane sound like contemporaneous notes, which can be used to refresh your memory during trial. Final answer: B

Mike Koeppen

I have no idea what "Examination in Chief" is without cheating and looking it up so I am only guessing and going with C.

Timothy Thayer

Yea, I'm going with B because nothing in the fact pattern jumps out at me as the witness being evasive or hostile. Idk what examination in chief is but can you be cross-examining your own witness? Maybe the plaintiff's lawyer senses the witness could be stressed out due to court proceedings after a friggin hurricane, idk. B seems like it fits the best.

Amanda Horne

But what in the fact pattern leads us to believe that the witness can't remember what they wrote?

Carl Earl

My guess is that EiC is the civil equivalent of a Prosecutor's Case in Chief, so while they are introducing evidence. I think it uses the term here to show that it the Plaintiff's witness and not a cross examination.

Codsternation

I think this is one of those trick questions that Andrew mentions the bar likes to do. It cannot be C as it is not during cross. It cannot be A or D as the fact pattern doesn’t back them up. You wouldn’t expect your own witness to dodge questions and you have to ask to treat them as hostile. That leaves just B as the only viable answer remaining.

Simon Crowley

B - They are not being entered into evidence, they are just being shown to the witness to refresh their memory

Ilan Woll

B is the only one that makes sense

Rchaw

A and B assume facts not in the pattern. Witness is from same side and no other facts to support treating them as hostile so no facts to support D. Left with the sherlockian answer of C, when all other possibilities fail... I'm with Chat GPT on this one.

Mary R

C. The texts must be relevant to something in the case. Also there is nothing here that shows the witness dodging, forgetting stuff, or being hostile.

Chris

A. Not B because you need a hearsay exception. Not C because this isn't cross examination. And not D because it text messages are not a leading question.

Cakemeister

It's my understanding that a "hostile witness" means that you can treat them (at least somewhat?) like you are cross-examining them, mostly I just hear it as "you can ask them leading questions"

Quark Twain

The answer doesn't need to be present in the fact pattern. They're really asking, which of these answers states the most plausible reason for the texts to be allowed? Think of it like this. "Is the dog wet?" A. Yes, because it's Tuesday B. Yes, because he jumped in the lake C. Yes, because he's taking a nap D. Yes, because he's a good boy