Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

It's the return of Mo's Poplaw Lawpod! Ace associate Morgan Stringer breaks down the tragic death of up-and-coming cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. Charges were filed against Alec Baldwin and armorer Hannah Gutierrez-Reed.

Files

Comments

Therese Chan

Excellent episode! I’ve been wondering about the details and legal breakdown on this, and Morgan did a fantastic job as usual.

patreon sucks

great breakdown! looking forward to following the outcome. next pop law request: the young thug RICO case in fulton county?

Big Lib

Being a gun guy I think what happened was 100% preventable and only caused by severe negligence. Everyone who was in the chain of custody of that gun is responible no matter age, gender, occupation, or level of fame.

TMoney2007

That doesn't mean it rises to the level of criminal charges. Actors aren't relied upon to be responsible for gun safety for a very specific reason... Their job sometimes requires them to violate typical gun safety rules. That's why the procedures were built around having strong controls on the custody of the weapons and multiple people verifying their safety. It would be less safe to create a situation where an actor had to keep typical gun safety rules in their head at the same time that they had to violate them. It's extremely easy to say something like you said and to an extent I don't disagree... It just doesn't actually translate into any actionable conclusions.

Big Lib

I didn't argue this legally. I am not a lawyer. I am speaking about the use of firearms. "Actors aren't responsible for gun safety for a very specific reason...Their jobs sometimes require them to violate gun safety rules in their head at the same time that they had to violate them." NO. You need to reread that and have a serouis think about why you believe that and think it's OK. If a director wants a shot that is unsafe then they shouldn't get that shot. Full stop. A movie is never more important than life. I can design a system that can guarantee safe use of a firearm on a set. I wouldn't have to though because over the decades people have developed procedures that have been amazingly effective. That person died on that day because a large amount of people didn't give a fuck.

Gmork

Although it didn't work in this instance, I think everyone on the set is safer if the actor can delegate gun safety to an expert solely focused on that issue rather than it be one of several issues they're juggling before the scene.

Billy Whitehouse

I agree with you in theory but in practice that means never seeing someone aim a gun at themselves or another person on screen or stage. That’s just not how things will ever work (especially in live productions).

Billy Whitehouse

I agree with TMoney if it was me personally as the actor I would’ve inspected the weapon out of habit (especially doing a rehearsal) but legally I think this on the armorer and maybe the AD.

Billy Whitehouse

The part about the armorer being “set up” is insane. Anyone with even a modicum of experience with arms and ammunition would be able to tell the difference between types of rounds. Most people familiar with guns who have half a brain can tell you roughly how full a magazine is and with what type of rounds just by holding it and feeling the weight. A professional armorer should have no problem picking up a round and telling you whether it’s live, blank, or dummy. In most cases they should be able to do it on sight but I don’t know how realistic Hollywood dummy rounds look.

Osmium

Something that I thought she was going to bring up is how the live ammunition got on set. This was something I heard shortly after the shooting and perhaps it's been disproven since then, but allegedly members of the crew brought ammunition to plink at tin cans during their break. This raises the question of how they were able to get access to the prop weapons and why nobody stopped them. Maybe they brought their own guns that used the same caliber as the one in the movie and a handful of live rounds got swept up and added to the pool of blanks and dummies. This should have been caught by the armorer, but it at least paints a picture of how this situation happened that doesn't need to resort to conspiracy theories that involve jealous coworkers incriminating the armorer or Trump going after Alec Baldwin.

Keishu Asada

Hold on, where is the download link?? Has Patreon removed them again? I can't really listen to the show without it.

FlaimingBanana

Keishu, I was confused too at first, before realizing that Patreon moved the download button to the 'three dot' menu.

Shrooom!

For anyone commenting based on their experience with/knowledge of guns, know that anyone who has spent even one day on a film set and anyone who has done stage combat is right there with you. This is not normal. More red flags than a Communist parade.

Big Lib

Nope. That can be done safely in many many ways which is why this should be a trial of many more people.

TMoney2007

I'm sorry, but you just aren't grounding your argument in reality. You can try to impose your values on the rest of the world, but that's just not how it works. No one is going to abide by your rules of "no gun can ever be pointed at a person on film"... Get real. You've basically predicated your argument on the concept that no one should ever take any risks for any purpose that you don't personally think justifies them... Again, that's not how the world works. You've literally just said "that shot shouldn't be done because I say it can't be done safely" and that's just ridiculous. Aside from the fact that you're not an arbiter of what is safe just because you're "a gun guy," no one is going to listen to you, so we best make plans based on you potentially being wrong and no one listening to you. This falls on the armorer. No live rounds should have been anywhere near that set. No gun with any active cartridges in it should have been handed to an actor when it wasn't absolutely necessary and absolutely controlled. Honestly, if Baldwin was just going to practice drawing, he should have been handed one of the inert replicas. It also falls on the producers for cheaping out on the most important part of a film involving guns. You DON'T rely on an actor to ensure the gun is safe. In his capacity as an actor, Baldwin had no appreciable amount of responsibility. Do you think the guy who pulled the trigger on the gun that killed Brandon Lee was responsible if he was an actor? Of course he wasn't. Mostly it was an accident, but it was an accident caused by negligence on the part of the armorer.

TMoney2007

I heard the same story and also noticed that it went away... No one should have had access to the prop guns without the armorer knowing. It seems like no outside ammunition should have ever been allowed near the set... If someone is shooting during breaks, the armorer should be on top of that making sure commingling doesn't happen. There are like 20 places that proper procedures would have headed off this tragedy. The biggest thing is that it sounds like the decisions around who would be armorer and what their responsibilities would be were motivated by money. Someone died because the producers didn't want to spend the extra money to staff properly.

Big Lib

WOW! You sure made up a whole lot of shit there. I never claimed to be any kind of expert or hold any power. As a matter of fact I made a point of how few deaths and injuries happen BECAUSE a lot of people over the years have developed excellent safety protocols. The fact that such a stupid mistake was made in an industry with lots of smart people who keep people safe says nothing good about these movie makers. As far as shots that are impossible to do safely shouldn't be done, yes! You should never do something that causes death to just shoot a scene. I don't believe in oh well accidents with guns. When someone is harmed by a gun it's because bad decisions where made. Gun accidents don't just happen.