Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Today's episode begins with a brief mention of the breaking news about Mike Pence that we will be covering in depth as soon as we know more!

Then, we look at a couple of lawsuits and learn why Liz isn't always a fan of the OA "read the complaint backwards" method. Does she convince Andrew? Listen and find out!

We break down the latest conspiracy counterclaims from One America Network News, while learning the difference between the conservative persecution complex worldview -- that Big Tech is censoring conservatism because reasons -- and the reality: that big companies are funding and propping up garbage conservative outlets like OANN.

After that, we move on to arguably the Worst People in the World: anti-vaxxers. Specifically, we look at a lawsuit by RFK, Jr. and a whole bunch of weirdos against All the Media for kicking them off YouTube and Twitter.  It's... something, all right. But! At least we learn a little something about the Trusted News Initiative anti-trust and the media along the way.

Notes

SOTU Fact-checkhttps://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/08/us/politics/fact-check-biden-state-of-the-union.html

Dominion complaint against OANhttps://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.234315/gov.uscourts.dcd.234315.1.0.pdf

OAN California Lawsuithttps://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/21410177/oann-lawsuit.pdf

RFK lawsuithttps://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txnd.371829/gov.uscourts.txnd.371829.1.0.pdf

Liz Backgrounder at Wonkettehttps://www.wonkette.com/antivaxx-loons-rfk-jr-jim-hoft-other-idiots-sue-news-outlets-for-booting-them-off-twitter

J.W. Howard Attorneys: We Have A Big Pirate Ship!https://jwhowardattorneys.com/

Trusted News Initiativehttps://www.bbc.co.uk/beyondfakenews/trusted-news-initiative/

Associated Press v. United States, 326 U.S. 1 (1945)https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=12116214944985887583

Files

Comments

William Evan Barnes

Andrew, cut the shit man. This isn't what taking stock, making changes, and making amends looks like. Lucky for you Patreon is being difficult when I try to cancel my patronage. I'll be pushing for refunds though. You're burning all possible bridges by carrying on like nothing happened.

el que es causa de la causa es causa del mal causado

Please Andrew, step back for a _significant_ while. Find someone else to pair with Liz for the time being if you must. This does not look good. Also, each quote in the intro are way too long. Maybe use the time to work on that as well. You can not rush this back to normal.

Gmork

Any chance you could do a deep dive on right of publicity? It could be relevant given that you're fundraising off "Opening Arguments with Thomas Smith . . ."

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

I feel like I have seen a lot of needlessly hateful comments here, and I need to just say three things. The first major point is that I don't have all the facts. Frankly I might NEVER have all the facts, and that is upsetting to me. With that said, the rest of this post should be kept with that in mind. The second thing I need to say is that the level of hatred and vitreol I have seen in some posts is disproportional to the apparent reality of the situation. Yes Andrew did inappropriate and gross things, but in a good workplace that would have lead to first a formal HR complaint, and then to termination if Andrew continued the behavior after being put on notice. It seems like there was never really a clear and obvious notice given to Andrew about how hurtful his behavior was. It feels like he was robbed of the chance to really improve his behavior, and that is unfair to him, and unfair to the community, and that has to be given serious consideration by all involved here on Patreon. The third thing I need to say is that I need to leave this community, and I think I need to stay clear of the atheist community entirely from now on. To be clear, this isn't just about the allegations, and it isn't just about the "bad vibes" I am feeling when I listen to Andrew. No... This is because I just don't see another way that Andrew could be held accountable here for his actions, and when you are the last person in the line that can hold someone accountable, I think there must be a far far harsher standard. I can't simultaneously expect republicans to stop gerrymandering, and also support Andrew on Patreon. I can't shame tobacco executives for not being accountable while also listening to OA. Yes, everyone was just acting within the system and within their rights, and yes the people involved were robbed of their fair chance to improve themselves in their own ways. The same could be argued for those Republicans and those tobacco executives. I can't demand people I hate to act against their best interest to make a better world while also allowing the people I like to not do the same. We all need to come together and break the unjust parts of our society... Even if we like them. We all need to stop asking how to play the game in the best way, and start asking which game we should be playing. We all need to acknowledge that the core philosophy of Opening Arguments relies on the critical analysis of the structures of power, and collective action to make a better world for the long term. I am sorry. I loved all of this while it was running, and I hate myself from saying this, but I think Opening Arguments needs to end.

Sidewinder

If nothing else, they have to understand that saying nothing for a week then coming back like nothing happened without half of the podcast & blasting out episodes, is a bad look that will rub many listeners the wrong way, right?

Chris B

This is really gross. Get help. Here til the end of the month. 🫡

Diane Fishburne

Holy cow! The original situation was disappointing; however I know the effects of alcohol. It is disinhibiting, can leave memory gaps, and impairs judgement. A loved one suffered for years as did everyone around him. At this point, I have to ask, are you drunk all the time? You are showing very poor judgement. One thing I learned in those years was that only the person imbibing has any power in the situation. I couldn't "fix" the situation for my family member and no one else can for you. I wanted to keep my OA Patreon open for a show of faith for future reconciliation but this is just draining energy from me that I need for other things.

Matt Kowal

Here's my (generous) speculation on what's going on: Andrew does horrible things. Horrible things become known to the public. Thomas ends up in a very bad mental state (understandably). Andrew sees that Thomas is in no state to make business decisions (and also considers Thomas's past mental health issues) and goes into lawyer mode. He has a business with contractual obligations with advertisers to produce a product and a business partner who is having a mental health crisis. He therefore takes steps to take control of the business and protect himself and Thomas from any rash statements. Thomas interprets these steps as a hostile takeover and hastily publishes several messages on the OA feed. Andrew removes the messages, because that's what any business partner or lawyer would do to protect everyone involved. Andrew realizes a statement must be made, but it's hastily put together in response to Thomas's statements and he makes several mistakes and misinterprets things Thomas says. He's not a PR guy, everything is happening fast, and he's dealing with his own family issues. (I will admit this is a generous interpretation; I suspect more went on behind the scenes than we know) Time is running out to meet their obligations to advertisers, so Andrew asks the only person he knows who may still be willing to help (Liz) to record a few episodes with him. He explains that the contract requires episodes be released, and if not they could get sued, and there will be no OA for good. Liz agrees (perhaps temporarily, we don't know). I think overall lots of stuff is happening behind the scenes, and we're only getting bits and pieces of info sometimes secondhand. Andrew is clearly the one who messed up and needs to take responsibility, but I also think he's in a tricky situation. He didn't technically say he was going to step away for a bit, but I think that would be a good idea. Also, Andrew, please explain what's going on at some point.

(You Gotta) Fight For Your Right (To Ex Parte)

Andrew's day job isn't this podcast, it's him being an attorney. You bending over backwards to give him every benefit of the doubt - even some of which Andrew has admitted he doesn't deserve - feels very MAGAish.

Fred Bremmer

Lawyers get disbarred for stealing from their clients, don’t they?

el que es causa de la causa es causa del mal causado

That's an interesting interpretation that would put him in a difficult position that was hard to explain. Depending on the contract though I would be looking to put that on pause and/or substitute a second person with Liz (maybe providing research and guidance/topics) and long term suspend the podcast depending on how it was received vs the duration of any obligation. I think it is also a stretch to justify a 50:50 partner locking out the other, but maybe there was some sort of notice given that he would be willing to stand behind should (other) lawyers get involved. The main logical inconsistency I see in it, that an advertiser obligation wouldn't explain posting these as Patreon paid episodes. It would definitely have been in his power to add a little announcement that patreons are not going to be charged for the foreseeable future or until he has a finalized cast.

Chip Parker

Being a moderate liberal, I'm not looking for Andrew to be burned at the stake. Knowing how far left his views are, I'm a bit surprised he hasn't walked naked through the town square as fellow ultra-liberals shout non-binary pronouns at him. As an attorney with decades of litigation experience, I find Andrew's insight accurate and compelling. I'm sure Andrew can walk and chew gum, and I'm sure he can work on being a better person while still providing analysis on current legal issues. People who are offended by his desire to continue to do the show can change the channel (or whatever is the podcast equivalent). As for Thomas, he seems to have blindsided Andrew with his strange posting of a text exchange recounting an awkward encounter with Andrew. It seems Thomas wants his #metoo moment. To Thomas, all I have to say is, "lots of luck in your senior year."

Alexander Thomas

Well if nothing else Andrew you sure have shown that you still have no intention of stopping when people ask you to because it makes them very uncomfortable.

Sidewinder

"I'm a moderate liberal" "Someone's looking for their 'Me Too' moment" Maybe read the room and the fact that this podcast's Patreon subscriber base has been cut in half in less than a week and still falling. Lots of us were willing to give the benefit of the doubt & potentially give Andrew a chance to redeem himself. He said he was stepping away and seeking help & DAYS later releases multiple episodes without his other co-host with zero explanation, as if all of us would just be like "oh, I guess it's the Andrew & Liz pod now 🤷🏻‍♂️". Andrew isn't doing himself any favors here.

The Show Goes On

I agree about Thomas. He saw sentiment turning against him for "enabling" and threw down the trump card. I'm a victim too, see! They are lining up to sympathize with him now, it worked well. I'm not about mob get your pitchforks culture. I enjoyed the legal analysis and that's why I'm sticking around.

Matt Kowal

I think Andrew is certainly working on unwinding or pausing that contract. Given how quickly these two episodes have dropped I suspect his back was to the wall, whatever deadline they had must have been close. I would hope he's also looking for a replacement host for himself, but time will tell. Regarding Patreon, from Andrew's perspective, there isn't a reason to deviate from business as usual. The patrons are still getting the ad-free episode they paid for, and they can set a limit or end their patronage anytime if they don't like the episodes. They've always had agreements with advertisers for the free feed, and a separate agreement with patrons on the paid feed that he's sticking with for now.

Alex The Apologetic (that his name is too long)

I think you and I are actually on the same page here. 100% Andrew's job was not to take social cues. That is my whole point. The job of tobacco executives was not to protect the health of their customers, and the job of Republican planners is not to ensure fair and equal distribution of power amongst the other political parties. Maybe I am delusional, and maybe this will sound absurd, but I always felt like Andrew's job was far more important and more meaningful than just reading legal documents. Heck, I could probably find hundreds of lawyers who can read legal documents and put in the work. The thing I really valued from Andrew, and the thing that I really could not find almost anywhere else is more nuanced than that: Andrew looked deep into the heart of our legal system. He analyzed the balance of power, and the rights and abilities of the different power players. He made factual statemens on the law, yes, but he was making them in the context of really teaching me about the reality of the situation. He was providing analysis that would take me years to come to otherwise. He was showing that sometimes, when everyone does their job well and everyone plays by the rules, sometimes there is still injustice. Sometimes the system is broken. Sometimes we need to step back and acknowledge that this game we are all playing against each other sucks, and it is time to change the rules together.

C’mon

Great analysis..Liz Dye is a natural!

C’mon

Also ..thanks for all the content attached, looking at the OAN lawsuit is fascinating!

CutePhoton

Sure, let's bring some unnecessary transphobia in to this while we are at it.

CutePhoton

Arsonist continues to work hard to burn podcast to ground.

Blank Blankman

I think one of the more baffling parts of this situation is that Andrew has pressed on without even remotely addressing the situation. Not even a noncommittal statement of “yes there are a lot of things going on right now, I am not going to comment for obviously potential legal reasons, but I am dedicated to bringing law news to our patrons and our advertising partners contractually expect us to keep bringing in revenue regardless of these ongoing issues. As such I will be carrying on with Liz Dye to meet my obligations to you put patrons and to our advertising partners.” Instead the parting statement of claiming to be stepping away, claiming preposterously that Thomas somehow outed Eli, thin apology and then pressing on as if nothing happened? Patron counts have tanked from over 5000 to less than 1800 as of today. Also incase you didn’t know you can become a patron then cancel in the same day for no charge! Just going to leave that here.

C’mon

Thomas, to me, seems sincere and was obviously struggling. But he didn't describe a Cosby or Epstein event. I don't see it as unsupportive of #me too to recognize that. There are no categories of "acceptable" sexual harassment, yet Al Frankiens thoughtless jokes at SNL are not identical to Trumps "grab them by the P" or Armie Hammers grooming to degredate women. I just don't get that vibe from what little we actually know. I'm here for the Law analysis, which to me is amazing. I've learned so much from OA, I'm glad it's still here.

Mike Lilley

So the part of the story where, yes courts expect people to break contracts when no longer in their interest, is somehow not self serving?

Pierre

Carter Was a GREAT president i dont understand why american dont see it. Do you imagine how faar ahead in greenhouse figth we would be. He would have save my children generation. REgant was shit

C’mon

I think it's fair to say that there is a lot going on behind the scenes we aren't privy to. What's the number one rule? Limit what you say in public. A lawyer being a lawyer shouldn't surprise anyone.

Timmaye

What would the sub then cancel do? I wouldn’t think it would impact metrics.

Em

I'm thrilled that OA is continuing, and I've doubled my pledge in support! One tiny note for Andrew and Liz: slow down your speech a bit. You're both speaking rapid fire lawyer style. Thomas used to naturally slow Andrew down, Liz speeds Andrew up. Remember you've got a huge non-lawyer and non-US lawyer audience. Slow down a touch so we can keep up with what you're saying.

Dr_Emil_Schaffhousen

It would have made so much difference to me if he'd done that.

Crazy Animal Lady

Andrew. The legal thing to do is not always the right thing to do. When you realize this and are ready to act on it, I for one will be here for you. For what it's worth. But right now you're still digging your hole deeper.

Eli Kravitz

This is how I read the facts too. I’ve been looking through social media for someone else who thought the same. Andrew’s actions (including being angry with Thomas) are consistent with someone trying to minimize damage from a partner reacting recklessly and emotionally. I guess we’ll need to find out all the facts at some point.

Spooky Luke

I was really expecting a statement like that. Just a "As you know, there are some things we can't comment on for legal reasons, but here's what's going to happen with the show going forward" or some statement about it. It's just bizarre to jump straight into it without acknowledgement and a new host.

Giant If

Holy shit, dude. Nobody is, or should be, allowed to claim that a business partner is having a "mental health crisis" and therefore shouldn't be allowed access to what they are contractually owed. Thomas is no more emotional than Andrew in this whole mess-- probably less so, actually-- but that's totally irrelevant to whether it's moral or even legal to lock Thomas out like this. You're speaking as if Thomas was involuntarily committed or something, when Andrew's the one who admits to alcohol causing him to make terrible decisions that hurt people. He's also the one (allegedly) continuing to profit from this show while Thomas gets nothing. Thomas who, you might now, just had a third child and has his own family to take care of.

Giant If

You're thrilled that Andrew is allegedly taking every dime of the profits from this show for himself, having (again, allegedly) seized total control of it away from Thomas, when they had a 50/50 agreement? I have to assume that you weren't aware of this. I can't imagine someone making this statement in good faith, if they were.

Spooky Luke

Here's what I would have liked to see. Thomas addresses the situation, even in a "I can't comment on some things for legal reasons" way that mentions the accusations against him. He says that there is some things that will mean Thomas won't be on the show anymore, he says why he's continuing the show at this time without Thomas, what that's going to look like, and how Liz ended up as the new co-host. I don't think that's a lot to ask, and much less awkward than just moving on and acting like nothing happened