Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello loves.


Happy Sunday. That hole picture is not mine. I took it from the internet.

I’ll read all these comments.

I would like to ask for some feedback about the Althing itself, since the opportunity presented itself so magically. If you’re new, don’t worry if this is confusing…just follow along. The Althing is a monthly newsletter and roundup I’ve been posting (and charging for) since near the dawn of the patreon. It was my hack to make sure I had at least once piece of content every month. I have to post it by 12pm PST on the last day of every month or I lose out on that dough.

Last night my draft got mangled by a patron bug and I didn’t make the deadline….and I posted a frustrated message. We will work on fixing and posting it Tuesday when everyone is back at work. I crawled into bed with my partner, who’d been entertaining Ash and waiting patiently in bed for me for an hour while I’d tried to fix it - and I grumbled about how on-brand it was for the season. And how hard it was to write something so satisfying and not be able to release it to the world. I thought about my parasocial heart. And about how much I work on the fucking weekends.

(You’ll be happy to know we are all taking the day off today and going to the beach with the boys.)

So. I woke up today to all your wonderful and understanding comments and I figured….

I’ll ask YOU - my family of patrons for many years: is there anything I can or should change about the Althing?

Do you like enjoy or even watch the little video message I include? Is it too long? Too hard to read? Too repetitive? Is there anything you would rather see, or hear about, or read? Given that we are possible switching to a monthly model, should we do it quarterly instead of monthly? Listen: I make it for YOU. It often helps me (and the team) to sort of take stock and survey my work. It goves me a nice place to put all the stuff that doesn’t fit anywhere else.

But.


Evelina said:




And then Superball and Laura said:




This is something to consider at the moment.

What really caught me was Evelina saying about the “liberating power” of giving up digging and starting anew.

So I’m going to look at this tech disaster as a little bit of a gift, an opening, for the moment.

Someone was recently talking about a loved one with me and used this same metaphor: the hole, the digging. They said: “once you’ve dug a hole that deep, the only way to dig is down.”

It was such an apt metaphor and stuck in my head for days. It’s so true, and reminds me a lot of my addict friends’ stories about Rock Bottom (notice the similarity? You’re….”down” there.)

You can climb out of a shallow hole, with your hands, with your feet, with your grit, on your own….when you’ve made a mild mistake or two. But once you’ve doubled and tripled and quadrupled down on the darkness - whether it’s lies, denial, addiction, or whatever - and you’re in a 179-foot deep hole….you cannot dig up.

If we wanna take this metaphor further, there’s two ways to get out of a hole that deep: leave this reality completely (I’ll let you interpret that one - one path leads to clicking glittery shoes and reaervaing time and one leads to….well), or start shouting for help so someone lowers a rope. That’s the way out.

And here we are, back on The Art of Asking.

It’s never too late to ask your world to throw you a rope. You may think you’re too far down there for someone to hear you…but I promise you, someone knows you’re down there, and help exists. Sometimes it’s time to stop digging and start yelling.

I have been considering a lot of my own bad habits lately, and often not liking what I have to face. The last-minuteness, the entitlement, the self-centeredness, the distractability, the ever-justified carelessness, and most of all: the blind trust I have in people, in which I used to take such pride (I will sleep on any couch) and by which I used to define myself by….but that I now see as a kind of painful and dangerous naivety (sometimes that couch has a trap cushion door into a 179-foot deep hole).

Maybe it happens for a reason.

Tell me.

Maybe it’s time to change the Althing.

Why not now?

Note: the draft of the August one is done, and it’s good. These changes would be for the coming season.

May you all find a way to get out of whatever hole you’re in.

I’m gonna make some coffee and some pancakes and go to the beach with my son and my friends.

I love the shit out of all of you.

X



A


Files

Previews only

Comments

emptybliss007

I’m pro all thing, however, I’m also pro- whatever. Probably not helpful insight, apologies. I like this community we have together. I like the connection and general connected-ness. All thing or no, I think you’re all stuck with me 😂

Marley Kendrick

I tend to never read all of the althing if I'm honest. If there's a brief summary at the top I tend to scroll to the bits I want to read most/updates from the team especially. I keep up with the individual posts throughout the month so I guess there can be some repeating parts but for someone else who doesn't read every post I can see how a summary could be useful. I rarely watch the video because by the time I've scrolled, my adhd brain forgets its there 🙃 but if it was a shorter post I'd probably prefer to watch the video (having the video as the main content appeals to me)

Dan Nero

My two cents. I have invested in you. No, you don't pay dividends in cash to my account but what you do give back is so much greater. My investment in you also allows others to experience what I already know is wonderful. I can't say I watch every althing or even every live cast but knowing what I contribute allows you to keep sharing, creating and inspiring, you do you! I won't be going anywhere anytime soon and love how connected you have remained through the years.

Sam Huish

Not helpful probably but I happily ingest anything you choose to post. I like being kept informed, I like your little nuggets of wisdom. I like it all 🤷🏻‍♀️

Russ Grazier

I did a monthly recap on my Substack for the first 6-8 month and then one month I forgot. I apologized to my followers when I realized what I’d done, and they wrote back saying “no big deal - do what works for you - we read because we want to and we can scroll back to see past posts at anytime.” I know the allthing is a bit different, but I think most of us have a handle on what you have put out to the universe. Maybe just occasionally highlight a thing or two that you want to make sure we didn’t miss. I am among those who always thinks, “Amanda put an awful lot of work into that Allthing post - I hope it’s worthy of her valuable time.” I’m ok with what works best for you. Just along for the ride, to support you and your art. Cheers from NH. ❤️

Lynnise

I'm pro whatever doesn't add to AFP's mental load. I sense it would be cathartic to end it and rebirth it when you know.. you'll know.

Moxie McMurder

There's a scene in The West Wing and a character tells this story, seems apt. This guy’s walking down a street when he falls in a hole. The walls are so steep, he can’t get out. A doctor passes by, and the guy shouts up, “Hey you, can you help me out?” The doctor writes a prescription, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a priest comes along, and the guy shouts up “Father, I’m down in this hole, can you help me out?” The priest writes out a prayer, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a friend walks by. “Hey Joe, it’s me, can you help me out?” And the friend jumps in the hole. Our guy says, “Are you stupid? Now we’re both down here.” The friend says, “Yeah, but I’ve been down here before, and I know the way out.”

Maggie's Yarm

I'm new here but I personally love the Althing. Gives me a moment to digest my own month along with you. Purely selfish but I would love to see an action item monthly. It's a little cliche but what about a journal or art prompt? One of my favorite things about this space is the nostalgia of art school it gives me. It would be lovely to have some simple and communal art or writing projects to create together. Not that I need anymore reason to patronize your Patreon but some guided art is totally the kind of thing I have, do, and will continue to pay for. Enjoy the beach friend. Soak up that end of summer love.

Nancy

Overall, I like the Althing and I get why having an income baseline matters as a self employed person. My favourite parts are the video and poetry choices. I probably skim some of the content. My thoughts would be keep but maybe make shorter? If that’s helpful 🤷‍♀️

Teresa Toro

I think if you're starting to look at the Althing like a monthly "gotta make the donuts" task, maybe it's time for a revamp. To what, I don't know (so that's not so helpful.) But all that said, I love it: my life is so hectic, I don't always get to read all your social media posts, so having a monthly roundup here is great for me, personally speaking. Because I often read on my phone (hectic!) I don't always watch the videos or listen to the voice rambles which causes a pang and total FOMO. Something I'll sit at my desktop and catch up on those in one big meal; sometimes they just all get away from me. But I still love that they're here for me, intimate, waiting. The Althing could evolve, though. The format could be different each time. No month is exactly the same for you so the Althing doesn't need to be, either. Ugh I am not sure this is helpful. This is what you get on Sunday morning at 7:30 on half a cup of coffee 🙃😘

Yana

From The Land of Feelings, I propose quarterly, the 'quieting hush', if you will. Anyway, there are still the web chats/casts etc, which are always splendid. You'll get it right, for you 🤜💚🤛.

Dea

Hmm. My head just hit the pillow (it's after 9.30pm here and I rise with the birds) so I’m not in my most creative mode. But...Althings... - I love monthly. Along with all the other gorgeous Patreon rreats and surprises. Quarterly feels too long between drinks - ? - I think we your Patreon Patrons love the intimacy and immediacy of your videos. Your Amandaramblers. Please consider keeping them - ? - li'l sneak peeks at what you're working on is always thrilling. A bar of a tune, a flash of a lyric; you decide. Not much is required to keep us in thrall -? - tidbits of rehearsals - ? - tiny puzzle pieces of anything else you feel like sharing, in whichever format you choose - ? I don't know about everyone else, but I so look forward to your Althings. Just as they are. Or however you wish to Thing them. There's definitely something particularly generous about your videos though, I must say:)

amandapalmer

Never seen the West Wing, but this is a great story. It’s also made me realize there are so many “up” and “down” metaphors when it comes to this kind of shit. Hell. Heaven. Being down in the dumps. Being down. Keeping your spirits up. I wonder if there’s something to be said about these metaphors and the toxic positivity of the idea that was always have to be up and out of the ground and the dark. Only the seedling in the black earth grows into a tree in the sun.

Jana

If it gives you more freedom and less stress I'd be happy to switch to a monthly model. I know my contribution is only quite small right now but nonetheless I wouldn't mind to pay for "nothing" for a month if life happens. I see the Patreon more as a solidarity funding. And there still would be the possibility to do the all thing without payments and deadlines attached.

Dea

Oops treats* sorry sleepy-typos...

Zoltanina

Honestly, I usually just skim the Althing for the bits I'm interested in and hardly ever watch the video. I'm the most basic a-dollar-a-month-patron anyway and if a bunch of artists need to go from dollar a thing with caps to 3-4 bucks a month, I'll need to decide where that money goes. So I don't feel like your decision should be based on lurkers like me, but on the other hand there are probably a whole bunch of us and most might not answer to queries like this. So I did.

Wendy S. Katz

That one photo is so poetically perfect.

Wendy S. Katz

I hardly ever feel like I have time to read the entire Althing. I usually scroll to view the pictures. A pithy nugget - or a few - would be fine with me. A haiku...a koan... enjoy the beach

Lynnise

Ironically althing also spells halting.. slow and steady..

Lynnise

This. I've been and gone a few times as a member due to relocation and cutting back costs etc but it's always my priority to return.. I don't contribute much but I'm here to support AFP.

Alexis Mai

I like to believe you could dig sideways, slowly filling the hole with the dirt you break loose, but it’d be a painfully slow process, and I’m only just (once again) realising the lengths I’ll go to before I ask for help. I think the Althing is a great safeguard for months when I don’t follow the Patreon religiously. I usually don’t read it right away, but keep it in my inbox for an unexpected reprieve. That being said, it is the bit of content that feels least necessary. And if it adds stress, I’d rather you allow yourself to focus your attention elsewhere. I like the idea of a quarterly reminder of what’s been happening, but it could even be much shorter than the Althing. More like a friendly index? Obviously, I loved—and have a personal interest in 😅—the bulletin board. But perhaps that could reincarnate one way or the other, too. 🤷‍♀️

EmVT

Thank you for this question, actually several questions! My post turned into a long ramble, the TLDR is sometimes you win by cutting the knot instead of trying to untangle it. Have a wonderful wonderful weekend at the beach, I hope for you that you drink all the coffee and eat all the snacks!! I just did a cold plunge at Split Rock yesterday is was life changing for unexpected reasons. About the Althing, I love it but all good things must come to an end and this is not the first time you have wondered aloud about changing it. I would say put it in a drawer for a while and see how it feels. Letting go of something doesn't always mean burning the shit out of it forever :) It seems like this is about more than the Althing tho? You feel like you're in a hole or a rut maybe and it doesn't feel good, you feel trapped maybe because the Althing is strategic. You can pay your staff, get them healthcare, and pay your collaborators and your office rent and I'm sure I don't know what else. You maybe feel trapped because previously it has seemed clear that monthly is not your jam, you talked about this before. Does it feel unalive and maybe take away some of the meaning and imperative of creating art. Maybe this will be a new phase to try where the external pressure is not there and see what kind of art you finish/start? Then there is the Patreon question, it's not the first time the platform has sucked. You probably feel loyal to it which is understandable. To bring it back to the Althing, this recent loss of work suggests you could somehow change your process, or change your platform if it's not flexible enough, but it sounds like you want to try a new era and start from scratch. STARTING FROM SCRATCH IS SOMETIMES THE ONLY WAY FORWARD. Sending love to everyone, may you all be well! 💛

Katie Player

My preference would be an Allthing-ish round up of the month by voicenote, with accompanying short message with hyperlinks to individual things. I mostly use the Allthing to catch up when life has been too busy to follow along. I don’t need to read lots, you talking briefly about your work with the odd reflection would be perfect for me.

Deniz Bevan

I love the allthing, especially the dives into other creators and the books you've been reading. I don't watch the videos (love when we get Alex transcripts!), but that's just me–I always feel pulled in a hundred directions and am so busy trying to carve time for my own writing, that videos are one of the lines I draw. I'll happily read a 10k-word essay any day, though! One thing I really appreciate is your ongoing sharing, it's such a wonderful way to have a patreon! (I was going to say "run" a patreon, but I resented using business-speak!)

Emma Brown

I like the althing but really don't want it to be a chore for you. Maybe a little shorter so it's not so much like homework.

Elizabeth

I very rarely read the althing. I skim it and get the general idea. Life is often too crazy (as it is for many of us-including you). I contribute to the Patreon so that I can help you create art while not having to worry about how your family's needs are going to be met. You do what is best for you and your family.

Isabel Vogt

Same here. A lot of scrolling. Looking for dispatches from the team. Completely ignoring the art section. Most of the times, I do watch the video, though.

Clair Rook

There are no accidents, only opportunities ❤️ And there are no deep holes, only unfathomed limiting depths of our own creation…so if we created them, we can create something different. Something inspiring. Something new. What would bring you joy to share with us, Amanda? Be as creative as you want to be, blank slate or retain and add whatever you wish, what excites and enthuses you. We’re all here for the journey, for the ride…love you everything ❤️🙏🏻xx

Madison

I have always enjoyed the Althing, and the videos you make for them. But if you do decide to switch to a monthly model, I'd have no problem with you switching to more of a quarterly Althing installment, just so you'd have more time for other things each month ❤️

Felicitas & David Lahner

I remember a time where the all-thing was posted as the first thing in the month, so that you would not have so much stress at the end of each month. Maybe that is an option to go back to in general? Or was the lack of stress hindering the all-thing from being completed at all? I don't remember when and why it switched back to the end of the month.

Christina C.

I just got fired from my job as the Executive Director of the only LGBTQ+ center in my red county. I had technically started my work in June of 23 but my contract for hire wasn't signed until February. There was a disastrous start to my contract period with a mass exodus of people. It was sort of good because of the bad reputation of place and people I was inheriting (the bad seeds seem to be the ones leaving.) But one of those who left was my mentor and the outgoing ED who was supposed to stay on for 6 more months to consult us/me in the areas I was green in so I could focus on the areas I'm pro at (fundraising project startups/managments/ and grants) to ensure financial stability and grow us into the future. After the exodus it went from a staff/board vacuum, to a new and promising board half filled with newbies, to yet another exodus with most of the newbies leaving almost as soon as they started. That left a huge vacancy at the board level and those who did remain were very detached from the actual LGBTQ community at large and the day to day operations of our place. (Despite the many reports and requests I sent to deaf ears.) This detachment is ultimately why I was fired. When I tried to stimulate the new board into a state of professionalism they didn't appreciate my urgency (for lack of a better explanation.) Despite the awful working conditions I was under, the low pay, the lack of direction from a half assed inattentive board (who loved to remind me they were the bosses and I was an employee) in 6 months I secured 3 grants, pulled off one major and two smaller Drag Show fundraisers, and overhauled and led the biggest Pride Festival in our city's history. In the middle of all that I was in the trenches with marginalized members of our community, high ranking LGBTQ folks fed up with our organizations failures, sketched out business leaders who crossed the line into being allies with us despite their fears of being blacklisted by the conservative majority, government leaders wanting to serve our population better, elected political leaders wanting to learn, former high level city officials, beloved philanthropists. Everyone basically. I had meeting after meeting with. I had to do this because I was new. But this is also how I do everything. I need to know all the stories to serve well. In doing so I was helping to create a new era in LGBTQ/Ally unity in my city. I will go to my grave with this being of the greatest works of my life. But I was only allowed to do it for 6 months before the flames came. It was all cut short abruptly before I was really even getting started. My board ebded it all with a termination letter that included (falsely) the words "Failure to do essential job functions." I've been through a lot. I've lost a lot of papers and edited photographs and artworks to computer Hades. I've lost friends to death, whole lives cut short mid battle, both literal and metaphorical. But never have I had such a great labor of love cut so short amd harshley from such major corruption. Even so, after the initial trauma anger and frustration, something washed over me that is still unexplained. Something freeing. Once again the universe is telling me the same message I learn with every fire: There was never an end game to any of that work despite my desire to find the finish line as a professional. It was always...always....about the individual lives I was changed by and that I got to help. The work itself is always just a scaffolding to the better thing: community. Never will a day come that it doesnt suck major balls to lose the work itself, but with each burning I have a greater and more profound love for the people the work leads me to. And I know I'm preaching to the preacher here cause you have been one of my defacto mentors on this for double decades now. Much love to you in your current Phoenix era and many blessings as the rain comes to wash away the ashes. We love anything you share with us in whatever form and we also know what a true pro you are no matter what epic work gets lost to computer Hades or takes on a new form. ❤️

Sarah Grace

What I'm always getting the most out of within the Allthing are the parts about other folx, as I have given attention to your output as it arrives during the month. It's fantastic to hear from your team. Some of the recommendations and shoutouts to other artists you've featured have lead me places I love - books, art, music by others that I keep coming back to. I wouldn't want to see that go away, but if it had other formats or timing it wouldn't change things for me. The roundup list is something I scroll. I hardly ever take the time to watch the video, I think that's just my own preference for reading and that the format of video is so gracious of you to take the time to do as there are many people I know that it makes the thing more accessible for. Thank you for your time and patience and work and worry!

Moxie McMurder

We,as humans, are literally created in the dark, in the womb. And that dark womb is the safest place to be. The dark is underrated, it doesn't have to be bleak, it can just be dark and peaceful.

Sara Blue

Same Here… Mostly I just manage To Look the videos (which I love!) and the Basic Life and Death updates. Thus I understand Its nice To have a monthly overview, To have something like this once or twice a year would totally do it for me (but I am Generally More for Spending Time creating than documenting creating). So - do what s best for you 💚

amandapalmer

Yes!! Yes!! Yes!! It’s all about the individual impact that bleeds on. The seeds of life. 🌱

Karen Jarboe

Sometimes it is a little too long for me to get through with a kiddo and a full time job. But I love all the updates and including both text and video :)

Edith Solarski

I like the Althing. Although I usually just read the beginning, your thinking part. I really like reading about the state of your life/mind. I relate a lot to that. Makes me feel connected to you. I guess quarterly would be fine. But i guess it would change the feeling for me. I like the personal (onesided) conversation.

Kathryn

I enjoy it as it is. I am hearing impaired, so I particularly like when there is a video and transcript. However, I would be fine with a change up, or if it needed to change each time as life changes. I do appreciate the round up with links to things I may have missed.

Erica

I would definitely be up for an Althing rebirth. I often find it too long, and repetitive if I've been keeping up with things as they happen. The missives from staff are sweet but seldom add anything new or different (they're just talking about the same things you just talked about), and it feels like a slog sometimes to get through the recommendations of other artists at the end. Maybe I just need to reexamine why I feel obligated to read it cover to cover every month.

amandapalmer

Just a note here as I read the first 50 comments or so: it looks like people are often skipping it because it’s long. Video = good. Other people and projects and notes from the staff = good. Brevity = good.

Parker

Our society has that habit of labelling some emotions as negative/dark too, which doesn’t help, along with the toxic positivity that we’re socialised into conforming to - it’s so bloody hard to untangle yourself from it all. My therapist has been nudging me into acknowledging that my brain is AuDHD and it’s blindsided me (I’m 58) I’m being forced to view my whole personality and life experiences through a different lens and So. Many. Things are…pulling the rug out from under me. To the point that I no longer really know who I am. At a friend’s solstice burning party in June when I took my turn to burn what I made, I said that I no longer know what it is that I want any more. So many of the life goals that shape my past weren’t actually my own. The mask of who I thought I had to be has been ripped away. First by becoming chronically ill and now by realising the root cause of why that happened. I’m currently at the bottom of that hole. But deep down I think (hope) I know that I’ll be able to slowly navigate my way through the dark tunnels that lead to a way out - if I keep my eyes, ears and heart open, and take it slow. Yeah, The West Wing 🫶 - splendid stuff. Much like ‘Yes Minister’ i doubt either will ever cease to be relevant.

Jenny C.

I absolutely read your round up and skim through the rest - I agree with what feels like a theme of shortening it up. One of the other patreon's I support sends out a "look who I'm following" any time they add someone - it looks like maybe a stock patreon format? Splitting out certain sections of the althing, like the recommendations, or the staff round ups, would shorten it but then I wouldn't want to see sections other people might enjoy go away, so really you're just splitting the long thing into multiple shorter things. Maybe some of those become less frequent? While I don't read it in detail, I love the transparency of wrapping up the numbers. I also think we're here regardless of how much you're making, so is that needed? Maybe you chunk out the sections and have people vote on what they think you should keep - whether in this or another format? (I'm a data geek)

Amanda Junay

Wow I fully agree with what others have said that, yes this was part of the purge and the burn! Yes it's beyond frustrating when you spend so much time with tech trying to use it. But now you get a day off! Now you don't even have to think about it

Kimja Cobsen

I like the hole. Some of the most interesting places I have been (in retrospect) were down in the ditches. Crawling out of these holes is how we grow. That said: the Althing is often a bit long - but I’m sure there are patreons who like the long read. I read diagonally and in depth when I want to know more about something and or have time. I also think you have to do what works for you. If it helps you to regroup and be more productive for your other projects than that’s good. But if it costs you too much time away from more loved projects or people, than make it shorter. We love you and your work either way ❤️

SField

Love the Althing. It's a technical hitch, nothing more - not a message. I think deep down you know if you want to shorten it. It's your time - use it for good.

Jen G

I like the Althing, but I'm cool with making it less work. Honestly, I love the voice/video from you and the deeper dives into the artists you worked with as I later check out their wider bodies of work. I'd be happy with a bullet list of stuff from the month before with links to the original posts. Just the titles; no need to recreate the wheel. I'm here because I want to be, so if I missed something I'll click without extra prompting. Maybe rotate the support team to one person per Althing, unless something special needs some early light. I like the numbers on the state of your patreon. Much Love!

Maggie's Yarm

Amanda ... Real talk... The first few seasons especially are a beautiful Capra-esque civics lesson. It might be something good to watch with Ash if he has election questions.

Nick Tepe

I support you because I admire your work as an artist, whatever form that takes. My life is better because of what you put out into the world, whether it’s your music, performances, videos, writing, rambling, whatever. I also appreciate (as an occasional artist myself) that it’s useful to have some sort of built in accountability or deadline, and I’ve always assumed that’s what the Althing did for you. But for me as a patron, I don’t care whether it’s the Althing that you use to fill that need for accountability/deadline, or something else, or nothing. As long as you keep making your art, I’ll be along for the ride.

jessica conley

I like the videos. Often too busy to read everything, sorry to say. The videos I can play while working or walking my pup.

Lizz Lee

You do whatever your little heart desires.

Katie Player

Also - don’t care when. Doesn’t have to be at a certain time of the month or monthly. Kinda regularly is good so I can reorientate myself with what you’re creating. Definitely not missing a better offer to stay up and wrestle with it 😉

SewTara

I love the AllThing. I’m usually pumped when it arrives but as I start to scroll I realise I don’t have time to digest it all right then and I mark it read in my mail box and there it sits. I get to it eventually. We’re here to support you. I agree if it’s helping the team go ahead and keep at it, if it’s for us I’m pretty sure we’re here anyway and if technology gobbles it up late at night while people are waiting for your snuggles take the hint/gift and go snuggle your loved ones. 💜

Nancy Chandler

Maybe a mini one every month and then a longer one quarterly?

August M.

Speaking of getting things done… is there a place where patrons here gather and chat for social or personal connection? Was thinking about reaching out to see if there are others who might want to do some virtual co-working?

Rebecca Starodub

Bad habits or coping mechanisms? Our survival requires us to find ways through, and it sounds like you are moving out of survival mode. This is a great time to take stock and decide what you want things to look like moving forward. You should decide what work/life balance would look like for you, figure out the boundaries for that, and then decide on how to move forward. If you don't want to work weekends anymore (and as someone who worked in hotels for years, I feel this) then the Althing would need to be posted on the last Friday of the month, not the last day of the month. You have lots of long form writing in you that you've been saying you want to share with us. Keep the Althing administrative: notes from staff, Patreon numbers, and artist recommendations. Take the time savings to do more voice rambles for us or one of the long form essays that's been on the back burner. Anyway, that is my two sense. Fully support moving to monthly model if that is the answer. As others have said we are here to support you and your art, and your art enriches our lives. Learn from Chappell and figure out what your boundaries are, and start there.

SpaceCrumbs

I enjoy the Allthing, especially the video. I agree with shortening the copy. I’ve been frustrated lately with the repetitiveness from socials and patreon. I feel the patreon should be more special, intimate posts. It’s a bummer when I get an exciting patreon notification and realize I’d already read it on FB. Not everyone has socials, and not everyone has patreon - so I understand the strategic overlap to reach more audience. I guess what I’m saying is that it makes me happiest to get special tidbits here that are just for us. Love you, Amanda.

Zomino

What does putting together the Althing provide to you? Keep that and let the rest go.

Joanne Sprott

Being that it’s Virgo season and a New Moon in Virgo on Monday (tidy up, clear out, pay attention to details), I’d reassess the value of the Althing. This busy old lady likes the summary of things, but I tend to skim through it because it’s a lot. I can absorb images easiest, and I usually don’t take time for video. I like hearing from the team. You could do a poll on frequency; I’m torn about going quarterly. Monthly still feels like a good schedule. As always, of course, you be you! 💛❤️🤗

Laura Wellner

I do love receiving the Althing; the video is always a delight! Yes, the Althing can be long, but I understand the reason for the length, and I do save it for another read later with a cup of tea. It's a good thing to have a review of all the things made; links back to a thing's original post could minimize some of it, but additional content about a thing that was not included is always of interest. Occasionally, I discover that I missed a thing from reading the Althing. The housekeeping section does have its purpose, especially for new patrons; this could be shortened and have a link to a page where the information lives. There is always room for improvement in everything we do.

Sparo Arika Vigil

Sending you some **hugs** and lots of gratitude for you being you 💜 I've been part of the patreon nearly since the beginning and I just wanted to share that I continue to be here because I believe in you. You inspire me. Now, regarding the Allthing, I've read a few of them & love the photos (maybe once or twice a year) & I don't think I've watched any videos from the Allthings yet. I'd love to read more, but honestly I just don't have the energy for it, most months. Still, I'm grateful for the opportunity to directly support your creativity, however you express yourself. 🤩🫂💜

Michael Murphy

Maybe it's time to go in a whole new direction, like get a new stage name and suddenly go all prog rock or something? Stranger things have happened to musicians' careers.

erica munhoz

I think if you feel the need to change anything abt it, follow your heart. On my part, I LOVE the vídeos. Sometimes I have little time to read but I enjoy watching and I scroll down to get a feel and see if I can catch something esse abt what's up. I love the Althing.

Simon Hoerder

To be honest, I prefer the written word over videos. I rarely watch videos unless they contain cute cats or good music. Also, I usually skim the Allthing but I like that it's long and that I can go back and read it if I'm having the mood for a long Allthing read. But you know better than us where your inspiration leads you and if it's leading away from the Allthing then it's better to put your effort elsewhere.

Gabby

I think of the Althing as something you do to summarize your month, an exercise you enjoy and find valuable for yourself, kind of like the way you like taking selfies, more than something you do for the readership. It is your thing, your process, and I read some of it and skip some of it when it is only repetitive.

Andromeda

I like the Allthing. I don’t read everything but I appreciate the wrap up, I don’t read every post in a month. I don’t watch the video.

Jann

While I appreciate the effort put into the Allthing and it is lovely to see all that has happened in the past month in summary, tbh I frequently run into a tl;dr issue. So many things to read and my current novel is always calling me. I like to know what is on your mind, what odd thoughts and feelings have sprung/are springing. How about a little Amanda essay on the Thought for This Month? I do trust your artistic intuition so whatever feels right and best for you will always work for me. Enjoy your day away! <3

Alexis

I've been a patron for a pretty long time and I must confess I don't often read the Althing. Partly because they are so long and partly because for my adhd self the large paragraphs sometimes feel very overwhelming. I know it's more prose than easily scannable blog post because that's your writing style. But if youre considering changing the format something with some smaller text blocks, bolded font, more paragraph breaks, even bullet points would make it feel a little more manageable. And I'm afraid to say I didn't even realize there were videos, but if you keep doing them I'll look out for them!

bluefoxx

I really enjoy your videos and your voice rambles. They are my favorite parts of every post you, um, post! It's fun for me. You're in your kitchen, or a Hamptons kitchen, I might be in my kitchen...I like the reality of it. It's like we're hanging out. As far as the writings of the Althing, I like your updates. They may be long, but life is intricate and you are extremely busy so there is much to update! When I have my coffee and my own life is calm for the moment, I like reading your Althing vs scrolling on X. I say keep 'em going, and sprinkle in your videos. If you have a video speaking the Althing to me, then I am so satisfied ❤️ Love, love, LOVE YOU!

Christopher Werner

I think that just because something goes wrong that doesn't necessarily mean the universe/God/gods/pixies want you to drop it. Maybe it wants to see how badly you really want it. Of course there are myriad shades between yes/no/maybe so, but only you can discern what's right for you at this point in time and space. And it can of course change again which is also ok. That said, specifically the Althing is a lot work, and changing it up due to schedule, circumstances, to simplify it (less is more) needs to be what fits for you. I like Nancy's idea of a quarterly letter with monthly minis. These could be a good transition. I look forward to them and will carve out some time to read through them and watch the videos.

calliope

I guess I’m in the minority, but I like the ramble of the Allthing. (And I was a copy editor!) Both the video and the post. The video is long, sure, but it’s cathartic—at least it seems that way to you. It is for me; I’ll listen after work or walking home or after dinner or early in the morning. They’re deeply relatable and we get a window into a brain that, let’s be honest, just isn’t abbreviate-able. The raw strokes tell the truest stories. As for the post, I like the non-linearity of it— the pictures, the poems, the featured art (y’all are so talented!!🖤). Sure it’s a little long. But I read it. I read the catharsis. The raw strokes tell the truest stories.

Coila

I read the Althing and enjoy the video. But the Althing *is* longer than I'd prefer. 😅 I love your update at the top and the part about what you've been doing the best. I don't always read all of the rest of it, but it doesn't bother me that it's long. I like that it's got sections and I can just read what I'm interested in when I don't want to read all of it.

Carly

I love the videos! ♥️

Gina Rivera

I love that you put your everything into the Allthing, but I must also confess that I do not usually read the entire thing. I have executive functional disorder and reading is really difficult for me, so I normally watch your videos, listen to your voice rambles and skim through anything that's longer.

Melinda M Kearney

I especially love your videos and voice rambles.

Andrew Tabori

I love the stuff you put out, no matter what. But it strikes me that this is a chance for a new thing. If Augusts is ready, then the new thing would break with a change of season, heading into autumn. Instead of everything drifting off for the winters slumber, the roots of something new can take hold. Something unknown. Something we might not know we need until it reveals itself.

Anthea Peck

Ok, first of all I love that shirt!! So much. Second, I love the Althing, but I also trust you and your team to make changes if you see fit! Your videos aren’t too long. I always look forward to reading the whole thing with my coffee. It allows me a few precious minutes to myself in the midst of family chaos 😱

Anthea Peck

I don’t get a lot of time to myself (mom here) and I love the length because I get a break/time to myself when I get to read it! But I’m also an avid reader and it doesn’t take me very long to get through 🙃

Tamara

You can always dig to the side? The Althing is usually the thing I read because I can focus. I think you have a variety of readers -- some of us need the monthly digest from which to launch.

Michelle Turner

I like the Althing as it is, but if you need to change it or let it go, please don't feel obligated to keep it. Give more of your weekends to Ash. My son just turned nine last weekend; I'm realizing how fast it goes and how much harder the questions get.

Francine Hibiscus

I enjoy the Althing. I don't consider it an essential document in its current form. Videos...are not a thing I engage with ALL HAIL ALEX OF THE WORDS. This is my brain's fault, I used to love voice rambles! Give a list of bullet points? Some random whatever? Don't be constrained by boundaries! Dig sideways!

DrWex

Honestly? It's too long for me. I usually watch the video. Skim a few paragraphs, read a few paragraphs and by the time there are team updates at the bottom I'm skipping. (Sorry, team. Not that I don't love you; I just don't have that many hours in my day and so many things I want to put in those hours.) Some of this is due to the necessarily repetitive nature of the Allthing - it's repeating things I've read or seen or heard earlier in the month. I have a hard time separating out new content from repeated content. And yes, I'm a Short Attention Span Theater human. Maybe that means this is not for me. Which is fine - lots of content in the world is not for me. But you did ask.

Mō

I think the althing is a nice monthly ritual and a good way to have an overview of what happened / what's planned. Now I usually listen to the video but don't necessarily watch it, I just listen and I only skim through the text but don't really read it ... Maybe it doesn't need to be every month ?

James G Watt

The wee video is alwaya a Joy. I love the regular longer written pieces too but i don't like the idea of you doing them if they are a burden. I liked the picture poem a few weeks ago and the poetry and music is why I'm here. I'd like it if you felt free to mix it up and give us what you feel the urge to share, what ever form it takes. I'm not wedded to a strict format.

Rebecca Edwards

I love the Althing. I like words. I like length. If I can’t read it all in one go, I come back it to eventually. Here I was more struck by your re-evaluation of the blind trust of your younger days. Maybe because it’s turning to fall. But it always gets me thinking about learning to make room for new ideas and making peace with past ones fading. But it is not all high mindedness here. I should add that as an Aquarius, I am sleeping on no one’s couch as that is simply crazy talk. Hard pass.

Wendy E Rowe

I generally skip the video. I read the entire Althing, but honestly it's hard to find a chunk of time long enough and I'd rather get short emails every so often about whatever you want to tell us (I usually save time by just reading in email instead of on Patreon). I'd happily pay even in a month when you don't give us a Thing; it's not like you cease having value in a month without a Product. I figure we support you doing you.

Michela M.

Sorry to hear about the technical mishap. I always skip the videos (appreciate the transcripts for the important bits, when you add them). I would appreciate it if it was shorter. I don't mind the repetitiveness, I skip the parts I already know. Making it quarterly could be a good idea too. I'm definitely NOT caught up with all Patreon posts and activities anyway.

Aleta

I like the Althing. I don’t often get through it on one sitting. But I sort of think that would be true whatever the length. I kind of like to read one part and sit with it for a while. That said I would be just as happy with a reinvention. You are a creative person with a wonderful brain that puts things together in unique ways. I’d be really interested in seeing what some new way of telling us what’s up would look like.

Valentin Shauger

Hey Amanda. Its Val yet again, wishing you hugs and peace. I just love you. So much. Post away please. Whatever you feel. A long post, a short post, a music post, a silent post, I dont care. Your voice means so much. Ill watch and read it all. I hope the beach is so much fun for Ash and you all! Always here for you Amanda Palmer. Love you so hard. 🫂♥️

Taylor Zartman

1) That shirt fuckin rules. 2) I myself am going through a moment of practicing letting go and moving forward. I wish I had more insight into your Althing, but I think if it feels good and ready to move past it, there's no harm in trying something else. You can come back to it if you need to. And for the data - I read, but almost never watch the video (this is true of most content for me unless the video is documenting a performance). And I enjoy your recommendations of other art and what you're reading. And I enjoy hearing from the rest of the staff.

Suzanne

I have no notes. The althing gets long. I don't always read it right away. But I get to it eventually. And I often go back and watch the videos. I appreciate the work you put into it. And I can't think of a month you haven't done another thing. So... Do whatever you like. I'm here for it.

Molly McEnerney

That is a really good point. After all you (and the world) have been through, allowing yourself to rest deep in the Earth sounds healing and magical and life-affirming. There are some seeds, including the seeds of giant redwoods, which only germinate after a fire has come through and burned away what was growing on the surface. Maybe there are seeds hidden deep within you which have been protected by a hard shell, and now that the fire has come through, clearing away everything that had seemed reliable or predictable, the cooling waters are percolating down to them and nourishing them with what they need to germinate. When a seed germinates and sprouts, it becomes something entirely new and different (which is why sprouted grains have more available nutrients). The tender green shoot that sprouts up is so small and vulnerable, but it also has the power to break through a concrete sidewalk. This tender but unstoppable green aliveness is one of my favorite words, Viriditas!

Molly McEnerney

Maybe we can throw you a rope, or maybe we can find a ladder long enough, which would be easier to climb up. Maybe we can even fly over in a helicopter and lower down one of those harnesses for airlifting someone to safety. Maybe it's time for things to get easier instead of harder, or just differently difficult.

angela b

I am also time strapped and tired and lacking a clever suggestion or witty words to contribute to this discussion. Mom dying in June has sapped in a way I never expected and made me re-evaulate my life choices. 2 jobs, a marriage a couple of teenagers and me starting school again and general self-care has left me little extra time. Admittedly, I have been neglectful of the Althing for months. Our opinions differ on certain topics and sometimes your posts even piss me off! But like a family member who I love anyway and want to support, I keep up with my patreon-izing. So I trust you and the team and your brilliant patreon supporters to come up with a creative solution. Love to all, everywhere and all at once. 🥰

Jannis

This is about you and your art. If the Allthing doesn't feel like art but more like a job you have to do, then don't do it. If it doesn't bring you joy then change it to something that does! 💗

Christina

I generally don't watch the althing video, and if I don't have a lot of brain space, often I glaze over before getting to the end. I do scroll down and heart it, but I don't generally read it all in detail. Sometimes it feels like work to read it all in detail and I just can't around the massive amounts of detail reading I have to do for actual work. I like the summary of things released (especially if there were a few), the things being planned/coming, and the summary of the state of the Patreon. As long as they tend to be, your suggestion of it being a quarterly thing makes more sense to me.

Phil Parkman

I don't think it would be Amanda if it wasn't wordy

Art Popp

As illustrated by the comments above your current style fits two different modes of Patreon interaction: Some like the ~weekly tidbits raining a bit of serendipity into their lives, others like to set the time aside and make sure they didn't miss anything tasty in one of the "many posts" months. If I were to guess at patterns of sharing that might work better: Steal from John Oliver and "Last Week Tonight" Make the 2nd of the month the all thing time. We can wait 3 days. Making the end of every month "crunch time or I don't get paid" is just bound to have random life-events create needless BradyBunch drama. It should never be the other way around: Your site should fit your life.

Anne Morgyn

I almost always listen to your videos and rarely read the whole allthing as that's what works best for my brain. I do scroll it though and generally take note of it like bullet points to see if there's anything I didn't catch that I might want to circle back on. But I always watch videos with you in it because I find your physical presence always gives the connection to your presence, your authenticity and creativity that keeps me here.

Joni

Ok, so as a person with Anxiety... I confess that always worry about you/the team around "All Thing" time.... I feel like it's bigger each time and as much as I'd like to read it all (or to be more honest, feel like a should), I admit, I don't think I ever have... I scan it every month.... It's feels like a checkmark more than a creation (if that makes any sense) You do what works for you, your team and everyone's capacity... And I'll support it 100%... Moreover, I never want you working when you don't need to in order to meet a Patron deadline... We're here to support your well being, so that your music and words can support us when we need it... I would never want the admin of it all to get in the way of the true purpose of this relationship, which in my mind is to create authentic connections between people and between people and Art. And that my darling Amanda... You do seemingly naturally. Do you. I for one have your back regardless.

Sara Nelson

I often find the Althings overwhelming which is probably a me thing and not a you thing. Life has been overwhelming and a huge wall of text is sometimes too much for me to digest. I admit I almost always watch videos you do and hit as many livestreams as I can. I don't personally need you/the team stressing out over the Althings. A more abridged version, bullet points, even a video version would be just fine with me.

Emma Rose Stecheson

I have to admit, I never watch the videos. I skim some or all of the Althing, I don't usually sit and read every word. I'm sure all of it is important to some! But it's very very long. If there's been a Thing that month I am very interested in, I read about that for sure. I like seeing people's Amanda inspired art, too! That's always fun.

Mollie Isaacks

I’m a long-time supporter and honestly can’t always read a full allthing. Sometimes I miss stuff during the month and the recap is helpful. But honestly, I prefer your authenticity above almost everything else. I’m a huge supporter of not reinventing the wheel. Lots of people here have already made great suggestions about making bullet point lists with links, moving to a quarterly version, etc. I would support any of those. What resonated with me most was the feeling that you use this as a chance to reflect on what you like best about the allthing and drop the rest. I’m here for you, whatever you decide on. ❤️❤️❤️

IRIDYSCENZIA

Bravo! Your dedication is inspiring 🏆

Annmarie Sloane

Thank you for asking us all… I think if you sit in quiet contemplation for a moment… be water… you know the answer… we can feel it… you can too …. All part of the rebirth…. With love 💜

Adrienne Danielle

I personally love the videos. I have been around when I can be since the start of the Patreon and have always dipped in and out of reading the full Althing, though it’s nice to have a big update there for when I can’t be very engaged with the monthly happenings, like a nice little jumping off point. At the same time, maybe there’s a way to use this opportunity to ease up on the pressure? Could you make timed-by-midnight post just the video, and then give yourself a lengthier deadline for the long bit, within a week out from the first? Just a thought! Honestly fine with anything you decide feels right 🤍✨

Dea

Interesting. I love reading the long posts, personally. Feels like time allocated to just me. Am a person who reads a lot in general though - just happen to find it meditative. It's not an either/or, for many of us, by looks: we can love the long written posts while loving the videos; we can love the images, voice recordings, cryptic little mini-posts. Can understand how meeting all of those preferences would take a lot of out of you though, sure.

EmVT

hi August, a lot of people hang out on the shadowbox, once you set up a profile it's a great way to connect with the AFP community on any topic under the sun. It is moderated on a volunteer basis by Mr. Len Tower and a few others "https://forum.theshadowbox.net/latest" There is also a chat under the Patreon community tab which tends to be more twitter-like / stream of consciousness

Skyeanna Malito

The videos are my favorite part. I also really love the art begetting art section, and what's coming down the pike. I skim the part about money. I also usually only skim the recaps because I read all of the other posts, but I still think they're great for people who don't read everything else. I also LOVE all the photos.

Scott Meekins

Just be yourself, Amanda. Ultimately, that's good enough for everyone.

Laura Damone

I absolutely love the videos I love watching and listening to you. I read what you write also. Amanda you need to do what feels right to you. Love you too ❤️🌹Have a great Monday off.

Andrew Sullivan

Keep it, just post what you would like to!

Esteban Montemayor

Thank You for how much you ask for and carefully consider feedback from all of us. Ultimately, we all exist as one big PATRON of your amazing Art and Self, Amanda. We. Fucking. Love. You! I love the Althing! I don't always tune in to the post-by-post happenings, so the Althing keeps me in the now-know. Also, and I know I've written this before, but I'll say it again: the Althing Videos, especially, are incredibly cathartic. Oh, my. I often cry (in the best way) while watching. Despite the fact that I've never been to a DD or Solo AFP concert (one lovely day this will Change), I feel powerfully connected to you when you make the Althing Videos. You feel authentic and truly grateful for the platform, and for life in general, even when it's hard. All this being said, Change happens. I accept that. It's kinda funny to say 'I accept Change.' because Change and Chance don't give a fuck what I accept or don't accept, lol. Sometimes it's Change for the better, though! If it makes more sense for you/us to run the Patreon monthly, and therefore the Althing quarterly, I support that. I support You. Live your best life, you only get one. ❤️❤️❤️

Marie

The one thing I’d like for you to change about the Althing is the deadline. I think you should send it out on day 1-3 of a new month. This is solely because I know it's important for you to Thing it within a certain month, and so this way, delays and bugs wouldn't affect the business side of it all.

Avery Maltz

I’m a new patron so I’ve only seen like one Althing, but I really liked it!!! I watched the video while doing some random tasks and then took a break to sit down and read the text. The multiple ways to convey information felt good and accessible to people with different ways of processing information. As someone who just got here (but who has loved your music for about half my life), I would feel like I was missing out if the Althing tradition changes drastically! But ultimately, change happens and we will all love you through it because we trust you to steer this ship. 💗 Also, I recently sent you a Patreon message offering to make you some botanical drawing ink, I remember you mentioning you were feeling drawn to explore some visual creative outlets. I’m sure you get lots of messages, so I figured I’d mention it in case it was lost in the pile. Thanks! 😊💗

Kathryn Drew

i really like the Althing as it is and usually watch the videos x

elia bassin

I think of my tiny donation as like the employers contribution to your 401k retirement plan, but your an artist who never got that so as a payback for all the energy you shared in various ways over a couple decades. I feel guilty if I think you are getting paid for future obligations. I'd like you to share whenever it feels right in your soul. And as a second thought to your life as a parent and inspiring artist.

Emily

Life is busy. I always enjoy the option of a brief TLDR

Bob Wait

I have no idea what you should do with the Althing, but after 15 years I just realized today that the title of the song "Oasis" doesn't actually refer to the band, and I'm thinking that you're a very clever human.

Jason Compton

More Hanoi Rocks!!! tee hee...sorry....had to do it....I am persistant if nothing else.....

Becky Ellen-Johnson

I enjoy the contact however it comes. This is your show, I just like getting to be a tiny little part of things and floating along in the wake.

Shiranne

I read it sometimes. I virtually never watch the video (sorry? 😬). It’s a lot for me with everything else going on but I figure it works for other fans even if that specific thing is not for me. If it’s tiring for you I would revisit for sure.

Marc Jeray

I try to read the Althing and usually fail because of work or life, etc. But I love seeing it in my Inbox because it reminds me that AFP is out there making art. And that cheers me up. I’ve been really struggling these past few months. Really getting frustrated with my wife and trying to figure out if it’s me, her, or both. A lot of my social outlets shutdown, and being very high anxiety, I know it’s important but it’s also hard. Going to try to get out today and enjoy the weather and my day off!

Melissa Mykal

The althing is a lot. I do read them. But it's long. Use this moment to figure out what makes sense for you to spend time on. Make it highlights... make it photos... make it easy for you. AND most of all, just change the timing - send it at the start of the month. I know we all need a deadline sometimes, but flip your timing so you don't have a hard deadline that tech can roadblock.

Aimsel Ponti

Rarely have time to watch video. Not for lack of love just life. Sometimes I read every word of the text, other times a power skim. But I always appreciate them. always ❤️‼️

Ryan Stuck

Your thought process on how to escape the hole sounds about right. The other option is digging stairs, moving slowly up and out. Now the question is, who taught us this and why? As a gen x man I don't recall anyone specifically teaching me these lessons, the lessons of not asking for help, dealing with your own shit and stoicism. However, they're just as ingrained as any habit or philosophy. I can only guess we lived in different times and these were still looked at as the typical masculine traits and we, or I, just emulated what we/I had seen throughout life. Maybe they still are, I couldn't say. I still have significant difficulty asking for help. It feels like weakness. And that's one thing a man never shows, or so I believe. I mean, I'll ask for help with stupid shit, but anything of substance is left for me to handle, alone. Even seeing a therapist I still don't let it all out, but luckily she's patient and finds little nuggets I let slip once in a while. What saddens me is many times, that hole slowly turns into your grave. From an addiction standpoint, only a few are able to claw their way out; most just climb out to go and dig another hole right next door. I've drifted off-topic.

Ryan Stuck

Interesting call. I'd think more prog metal, or maybe noise rock. And switch to "Amanda and That Other Guy." If you get the reference then you watched Adult Swim when it first came out, and I'm aging us both.

Matt Castanier

I tend to follow everything you do and usually just skim the Althing. So I’m on the fence regarding continuing. But if you do continue, please post it at the start of the following month or quarter. That way you won’t have such a hard deadline. And it leaves open the possibility of doing something Althing-worthy until the last day of the month or quarter! 😎

Michelle

Yeah I'm with the folks who find it overwhelming. Like I want to skim, but often I see it in the inbox and it just feels stressful, like one more thing I "need" to read. So it's like 65% I'll skim, 20% it gets skipped and 15% I'll read the whole thing. And I don't know if I realized there was always a video. :/

Jen

Love you ❤️❤️❤️ if change feels good change it. If it is a ball of stress change it. I read the all thing and listen to the video but truly you could simply say this is the all thing to keep the lights on and I would be good with that as well. As usual I am saying fuck it do what feels good, do what feeds your soul and not what strains you. Love the people in your life and take days off. Do what you need. Much love and light to you❤️❤️❤️

Coriander Wolfgang Rainbeaux

I read, watch and listen to every single thing. (I’m also neurodivergent haha.) If you find it cathartic and joyful to share, I’ll keep reading, watching & listening. If you change the format and/or think something is too time consuming and don’t wanna do it, I’m good with that too. I enjoy seeing all facets of you and the people around you, not just music. I appreciate you being 3 dimensional.

Tara Timmsy

Your call on this one! I‘lol support whatever.

Dragan Gill

While I think it's nice to have a round-up, I have sometimes found the All-Thing a little repetitive of your other posts and sharing, so it's long and hard to parse out the new things, but not so much so that it stops me from going through it anyway!

🎭Orpheus Wren🐦🏳️‍⚧️♂️Zaunking of Words

I missed this post because I have been in agony for two days. I'm crawling my way out of a difficult section of the grave I nearly landed in last year: regrowing all my muscles. It's going well and WOW do I hurt Amanda, my love, I have had no energy to read the Allthing for over a year. I've been skimming them. I'm exhausted, in pain, and I've been abused I am sorry, for I know you have all put much time, work, and thought into it, but exhaustion is exhaustion and I don't even know how exhausted I am. I'm still learning that one I save them, though, and someday I will have the energy to read what I've missed Someday

Moriah Martel

Hi! As an artist and community builder I look forward to the Allthing because I love how it teaches me about the innerworkings of how you are running your business and your life along with your art. It allows me to see HOW IT ALL WORKS, which is awesome.

Deeslee

I Love what you do, but the Althing doesn’t need to justify itself with long proof of work. It could just be a photo of a sunset. Love the video but miss voice notes. The part I read is how you are doing and skip the rest.

amanda pallay

I love the AllThing in it's current form. I like that you can choose to skim it, like some here do, or you can read it in chunks ....or you can sit down and carve out time to savor the words you thoughtfully chose to share. I do all three every time, I give it a skim, go back and read chunks then finally sit down to read it all. I look forward to it every month. I know change can be good, liberating, blah blah. I hate change...which is why, I guess, I need to experience it more. Maybe? Either way, I'm sure whatever you decide to do with the AllThing, it will be done with great care, and that's all that matters. We'll be here for it.

Olenka Fawkes

I do tend to skim, I like the all thing summary at the beginning. I like that it goes in depth. See violet blue's pandemic and cybersecurity roundups for an example.

christine lloyd

what a lovely post and lovely comments. Years ago, I lost my manuscript (ironically called Doing Time on Planet Earth) - when someone came through the windows of my apartment at night, while I was sleeping in said apartment, and stole the laptop which housed the manuscript. It also contained my recently completed tax documentation. I raced about like a madwoman changing bank account numbers, credit card numbers, and placing myself on credit tracking services. Also worked hard to recapture the manuscript - which I was able to do - a portion was written. Social media friends offered to take up a collection to buy me a new a laptop, but I decided to do this on my own. And I ended up writing the robbery, the police's handling of it (poorly), the fingerprint expert's dialogue on how one cannot lift a fingerprint from a windowpane, etc into my manuscript, then four years later self-published it. The MS was better for it. But when I hunted a new apartment - I found one that wasn't easily accessible from the roof and looked out on trees and crickets. I also realized the apart had black mold - affecting my physical and mental health - so eventually leaving the apartment ten years later, was long overdue. I think sometimes life hits us upside the head with a sledgehammer to get us to try a different direction. And I do adore your posts.

Julie Sweetin

Don't get me wrong - I've always loved the Althing. It's always full of beautiful stories, and lovely human updates of those who work with you. And even if its sad news or happy news it has always been worth the read and worth the watch of the video you post. Especially the meat of the post, which is usually a new song or a new piece of art/writing or something fantastic that I always enjoy immensely. HOWEVER, the Althing is A LOT. This isn't a complaint but a simple statement of fact. It takes hours out of my day to read through it all, contemplate it, look at the pictures, watching the videos. It takes me hours, not just because I am disabled, but also I am also the type of person who needs to invest my whole being into reading something to really absorb it. To take time and think about what you've said/shown. So while I have read and absorbed many Althings, being someone who has been there since day one of your Patreon, there have been Althings that I didn't even open or read at all...because they were just too much for me to handle at that point in time. I don't always have the time and energy for it unfortunately. And I often think, wow Amanda....how can a person (or, a few people, I'm not forgetting Alex and the other people you feature in your Althings!) hold all of this in their brain all at once and be able to recall it all for this one Althing? How can so much emotional and physical and metaphysical effort be placed in one thing at one time without some kind of collapse? It feels like if it's a lot for me to read, it must be a lot more to put together. I'm so appreciative of all the hard work you and your team put into it, but it doesn't have to be something that makes you feel like you're digging a deep hole you can't get out of. It might be time to consider turning your Althing into multiple, easier to manage, easier to digest Onethings throughout the month. I'm not experienced in business practices so I can't say how this will effect your financial aspect of this, so I hope whatever you decide works out for you and everyone <3

Chantelle B

I always read the Althing, but I would also read it if it was 10 sentences long. I just love reading your stuff.

Haley Forrester

I love your music, I love your brain, and I love your passion for community-building and creativity! I have had so much fun at your concerts, and had my heart and mind delightfully stirred from reading your book and some of your online postings. I know, logically, that the Allthing has many of these things I love held within. And so, so rarely do I even open that email, because it is too overwhelming. Sometimes I open and skim and then close it for later, but more often than not those emails pile up until there are hundreds in my inbox, and the stress of seeing all the unread emails bogs me down and I just have to delete them all to... well... start fresh. Perhaps the Allthing could get a fresh start as well. Become more manageable, both for us, and for you and your team! Just a little breath of fresh air, instead of a gust of effort for everyone? I love being a patron because I believe in what you are doing. You do you! <3