Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello loves.

A question and a few words about Chappell Roan, below...and QUICKLY, I'm announcing:

TWO ONLINE EVENTS next week, one livestream concert and one webchat/Q&A.

1. FOR ALL PATRONS:

This TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 10th, from 12-2pm EST live from THE BRIDGE SOUNDS AND STAGE in Cambridge, MA (with an all-patron studio audience!....we invited a handful of the guest-list tier patrons here). THIS EVENT WILL BE OPEN TO ALL PATRONS, EVEN THE FREE SUBSCRIBERS.

You can all RSVP and find the event link and archive HERE.....and I'll remind you on the day!!!!

https://www.crowdcast.io/c/livefromthebridge

...........then............

2.

FOR WEBCHAT TIER PATRONS {$10+}:

This THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 12th, from 11:11am-1:11pm EST - a casual catch-up and Ask me Anything from home.

You can RSVP and start asking questions and chatting here:

https://www.crowdcast.io/c/sept12thchattychat

....

Greetings from Boston, where I'm operating out of a zig-zag lunchbox at the moment.

There's a lot to share, but I'm mostly just buried and trying to breathe.

The music is keeping me alive. I spent the better part of the afternoon working on an arrangement of "Pink Pony Club" by Chappell Roan.

I'm gonna play it at you....probably on Tuesday, and I'm gonna make you all sing with me.

I need it.

As you can see above, I don't bother to put on outfits and make-up anymore and I even leave my fucking reading glasses on when I take photos because I can't be fucked to take them off.

But that is okay, because CHAPPELL ROAN IS ON THE JOB.

I love this artist.

I feel like she sprang from my home planet.

Speaking of Chappell....I posted this to socials the other day and wanted your feedback as well. Answer here, I am reading all the comments across the board.

I would love your thoughts on this. I have been steeping myself (and my kiddo) in Chappell Roan’s music for the past few months and it’s been both a balm, an inspiration, and a portal. 

I so rarely hear new music that truly touches me - the last new album that I deeply connected with was Phoebe Bridgers’ “Punisher”, which got me through the second harrowing year alone in New Zealand, especially as I drove around alone with the kid - and this one, OOF…it’s a tourniquet that my heart needed. Just go listen to the whole of “Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess” from start to finish and thank me later. (Key tracks: Pink Pony Club, My Kink is Karma, Casual....but honestly, they're all fucking grand...and I'm going to cover at least one of them a night on the upcoming solo mini--tour.)

If you’ve been following my songwriting for the last 25 years you’ll understand why I cherish this voice. Catchy, painfully and gruesomely honest, synthy, flippant, queer, unapologetic, vulnerable, risky; all the musical and lyrical things smooshed together in a package that soars. 

That being disclosed, I’ve been watching with fragility, deep curiosity, and mom-worry as Chappell deals with the cost of immediate and stratospheric fame, including a whole kerfuffle in the past few days regarding the canceling of some shows. 

Below, I’ve pasted the statement she made a few days ago. The press picked it up and the pundits (and Jewel) have weighed in. I’m going through a really hardcore transformation of my own as I re-tool and re-navigate my relationship with my own value, my own music, my own body and autonomy, my own naivety in the face of the world and the cultural kool-aid still flushing out of my patriarchy-molded, clogged, egotistical and attention-hungry veins. It’s been a lot. Younger artists whose work I love - Phoebe, Lorde, Billie, Chappell - they all provide a mirror for us olds as we gaze into the chasms of our own decisions. I don’t know if I’m going to be able to carve the time out, but I’m really inspired to write a piece about this for the substack if I can. So before I crack open the inkwell…talk to me about anything: Chappell, fame, parasocial pain, your own rethinking of what success means and what our culture does and doesn’t get right about it. 

Always curious to know what the crowd is thinking. 🤘🔥🌈♥️

….

From Chappell’s IG:

For the past 10 years l've been going nonstop to build my project and it's come to the point that I need to draw lines and set boundaries. I want to be an artist for a very very long time. I've been in too many nonconsensual physical and social interactions and I just need to lay it out and remind you, women don't owe you shit. I chose this career path because I love music and art and honoring my inner child, I do not accept harassment of any kind because I chose this path, nor do I deserve it.

When I'm on stage, when I'm performing, when I'm in drag, when I'm at a work event, when I'm doing press...I am at work. Any other circumstance, l am not in work mode. I am clocked out. I don't agree with the notion that l owe a mutual exchange of energy, time, or attention to people I do not know, do not trust, or who creep me out-just because they're expressing admiration.

Women do not owe you a reason why they don't want to be touched or talked to. This has nothing to do with the gratitude and love I feel for my community, for the people who respect my boundaries, and for the love I feel from every person who lifts me up and has stuck with me to help the project get to where it is now.

I am specifically talking about predatory behavior (disguised as "superfan" behavior) that has become normalized because of the way women who are well-known have been treated in the past. Please do not assume you know a lot about someone's life, personality, and boundaries because you are familiar with them or their work online.

If you're still asking, "Well, if you didn't want this to happen, then why did you choose a career where you knew you wouldn't be comfortable with the outcome of success?"

—understand this: I embrace the success of the project, the love I feel, and the gratitude I have. What I do not accept are creepy people, being touched, and being followed.

This situation is similar to the idea that if a woman wears a short skirt and gets harassed or catcalled, she shouldn't have worn the short skirt in the first place. It is not the woman's duty to suck it up and take it; it is the harasser's duty to be a decent person, leave her alone, and respect that she can wear whatever she wants and still deserve peace in this world.

I want to love my life, be outside, giggle with my friends, go to the movie theater, feel safe, and do all the things every single person deserves to do. Please stop touching. me. Please stop being weird to my family and friends. Please stop assuming things about me. There is always more to the story.

I am scared and tired. And please-don't call me Kayleigh. I feel more love than I ever have in my life. I feel the most unsafe I have ever felt in my life.

There is a part of myself that I save just for my project and all of you.

There is a part of myself that is just for me, and I don't want that taken away from me.

Thank you for reading this.

I appreciate your understanding and support.

###

Send thoughts.

I love you.

A lot.

xxxx

Amanda

.....

TOUR DATES:

Saturday, Sept 21st: NORTHAMPTON, MA - ACADEMY OF MUSIC
Thursday, October 17th: FAIRFIELD, CT - SACRED HEART COMMUNITY THEATRE
Saturday, October 19th: TARRYTOWN, NY - TARRYTOWN MUSIC HALL

Then….with The Dresden Dolls:

Saturday October 26 & Sunday Oct 27th: WOODSTOCK, NY -  BEARSVILLE THEATER
Friday November 1 & Saturday Nov 2: BOSTON, MA - ROADRUNNER, with Gogol Bordello 

On sale now at amandapalmer.net

.......

Files

Previews only

Comments

Kelly Shea

my baby girl is back in boston at BU, so it’s nice to know you are there as well ♥️

snek

Just jumping in to suggest checking out the album “this is how we get better” by TNC. It’s helping me grieve a lot.

Valentin Shauger

Im so happy you love her Afp. Her musics gettin me thru some shit. Fun fact: Chappell identifies as a drag artist! How fucking COOL! Queer pop forever. ♥️♥️🩷🩷

LT

So proud of Chappell. Love her. Love Jewel. LOVE YOU! 💕

Lizz Lee

I don't care for her music but I'm almost positive your voice will change some of that for me. Honestly, you could probably make me like GaGa or Taylor Swift and that's saying fucking looooads.

Jessi Moss

i've never understood the lack of humanity given to celebrities. i understand they're there to entertain. that's their job. but their job shouldn't be 24/7 just because the fans demand it. they should be allowed to have time to themselves regardless of where they are. they're human, not dancing monkeys. there's a difference between when an artist is working and when they're not. it's never okay to interrupt someone trying to eat, or grocery shopping, or spending time with they're friends/family, etc. why do people think they can do that to celebrities? i don't get it. just because they're famous doesn't mean you have access to them whenever you want. they deserve their time. and i don't understand the backlash Chappell is getting for pointing that out. i love her. i love her music. i'm glad i stumbled upon her youtube a couple years ago. i glad she's gotten the opportunities she's gotten. but she should be able to exist in peace without people demanding things from her every time they see her.

Alexandre Sobreiro

I'm so happy you and Ash were caught by the artistry of Chappell. I had ignore for years my best friend's suggestion to go listen her music... And finally when I surrender I was almost immediately in awe and singing along. Ever since I have been aware of her music and statements, I'm so happy and worried about her.

Amanda Junay

As I'm starting to navigate a very busy schedule as my little business and book club booms. I love the Chappell not only is establishing her own clear boundaries but how YOU and others are cheering her on. I am having my very first book club meeting at a local canna club on Sept 27th and, The Art of Asking is first up on the list. So prepare for an influx of sales!!! So even while you are resting and leaning into your own boundaries. I'll be cheering you on, helping you succeed, and helping you influence a more compassionate community.

Amanda Junay

Oh I forgot to add! So many people from across the country are interested in the book club it's now going to be offered virtually! Then I can reach even more people with your novel and message

Zomino

I only hope that parasocial relationships can calm down in the near future because of voices like Chappel, and Sia before her. Idolizing “celebrities” has only been terrible for our society in so many ways: actresses take the place of models, power dynamics are greater, scrutiny of individuals is more harmful, boundaries are broken leading to less safety, influencers take advantage of the system, abuse is more likely. We need to be able to separate the art from the artist to the level that the artist wants.

Moxie McMurder

Chappell has written some absolute bangers, My Kink is Karma is *chef's kiss. I absolutely respect her stance on fame and boundaries. Some artists thrive through those connections and other's don't and that's OK. It really is up to the fan to be a decent person and respect the fact she feels uncomfortable with, what would be considered inappropriate behaviour, from anyone.

Zomino

But I don’t live it, so I’ll be really interested in hearing your opinion, AFP

Joanna Lindblad

My thoughts? People are people, FFS!! We all have a lot on our plates, a lot on our minds, and shit we're going through. It doesn't matter if someone is an artist or not. Compassion, respect, and being appropriate are a must! (((❤️)))

Nicole DeNicolo

There is an older interview where Chappell talks about how the music industry is really good to people who don't take care of themselves. She has worked for most of her life to get to where she is today and it is all happening very fast. She has also spoken openly about how she will shut it all down if she or her family's safety is jeopardized. It is important to remember that no matter how famous a person is they still have the same rights to privacy as the rest of us. They also share the same vulnerabilities as any of us. I appreciate the way that she's setting clear boundaries and I just hope that the community will rise to the occasion and respect her boundaries.

Carrie Antinaro

Being from the U.S., I don’t know if this kind of thing goes on similarly in the rest of North America or the West. I suspect it’s rooted in capitalism. From my 25 years of customer service work, I saw many people who believed that, if they pay for products or services, then it’s acceptable for them to also receive almost anything else they believe they deserve from the company or representative/clerk delivering those goods or services. If they don’t receive it, then resorting to verbal or even physical subjugation is acceptable to them, even though it would violate common human decency in most other contexts. Many hold fast and dearly to this “law.” (Pssst…the only actual law is the basic common decency that also applies to people who aren’t serving you. Companies are just giving in to entitlement more these days for financial reasons.) If a person is successful in the way that our culture currently defines it, then a great many of their admirers and fans believe they have certain entitlements similar to those of a customer, but it’s blown up to outrageous proportions. “That’s the price,” they’ll say. I think it boils down to people experiencing strong, uncomfortable emotions due to certain inner narritives, and instead of feeling, observing, and exploring their emotions with compassion, they attempt to change the emotions by controlling the behavior of people outside of themselves. And it works…in a way that is really gross, and often damaging.

Maura M

To be perfectly honest when I think of Chappell Roan I keep coming back to this scene from the Taylor Swift documentary Miss Americana (available on Netflix): she’s talking with Brendon Urie of Panic at the Disco, and Urie is talking about how he’s having a hard time finding a place to live because fans keep showing up at his rental house and it’s scaring his wife, who is very private. Taylor Swift responds with sympathy, and with a story of her own - a guy was arrested for sleeping in her house.

Zenobia

I'm from Chappell Roan's "dying town" (for any of you who may not know the reference, listen to California). When you're a liberal/progressive in this 'buckle-of-the-bible-belt' part of the country, you form an instant bond with anyone else who thinks the same way you do. I lived in LA for 10 years, loved it, but still wanted to come back to my hometown because I knew I could make more of a difference here for those that may think like me, but can't leave, than I could for anyone in a more liberal city. I, and others here like me, are thrilled that Chappell Roan is doing this for us from afar. For this ultimate queer icon/feminist/brilliant artist to pop up from our same beginnings brings us joy and makes us proud. It is sad to hear that she and her family and friends may be getting harassed. I hope it's not from locals. I've often wondered what the more close-minded citizens here think of Chappell and how she's representing us. I love it, but others may not. But it cheers me to know that she is handling this with that kind of response - nicely articulating the strange experiences in her life while also reminding everyone that women deal with this kind of double standard on a daily basis. I'm a big believer of "be the change you wish to see in the world," and am so proud of Chappell Roan for living up to that every day.

Emily Harris

She really is my favorite artist's favorite artist. 😂 To me, the beauty of art is in its collective humanity. Parasocial relationships are making humans products, and it gives me the ick and feels so far removed from what art is. We aren't entitled to a person's whole being just because we are in awe of their talent, and we are so lucky to have these artists show us a glimpse of their experiences so we can connect with others. People aren't products, and to assume otherwise feels like a capitalist hellscape... but maybe that's where we are.

Emily Harris

Oh, and Chappell Roan is just so fantastic. Red Wine Supernova makes me reflect back on my 20s with amusement. The fact the line "I heard you like magic... I've got a wand and a rabbit" exists is *chef kiss*

Nat Torkington

Related but not the same, Scalzi on idolising people. https://whatever.scalzi.com/2024/08/15/please-dont-idolize-me-or-anyone-really/ Anyone who has an audience, is famous for any version of fame, knows that the "Amanda" we think we know and the "Amanda" you are ... are different people. Public presence is full of choices: what to wear, what photos to show, how often to appear, what topics to talk about, what topics to avoid, what discomfort to air and what to keep, whose boundaries you respect and in what ways .... As fans we buy art, and we buy the artist -- we fall for the persona. Even with manufactured personas like "Lady Gaga", fans learn about Stefani Germanotta and believe they know the real person. Nobody knows the real person they're married to or were born from, let alone someone they "know" through talk shows and biopics. Hell, I'd say we don't really know ourselves. It's an artificial intimacy, created by the audience in response to the actions of the public figure. And I'm not even talking about stalkers or pervs. I am fascinated by what you've built here, this wonderful precious community of vulnerability and intimacy. I do wonder about its limits of scaling: if some percentage of an audience are going to be weird and awful, then you'll get more of them as the audience grows. And when your therapeutic art is so much about trauma and pain, it feels like that skew the numbers too. I can only imagine the horrors at Chappell Roan scale. Thank you for coming to my TED Babble.

Joanna Lindblad

As far as what you wrote about customer service, people are assholes everywhere lol I've worked customer service for years, and people take "the customer is always right" too fucking seriously to the point of being very inappropriate. Not everything is free, and as a customer, you are not entitled to everything. That being said, I've worked with some wonderful people and glad I could help resolve their issues.

Pinky Pinky Pinky

As a counterpoint, I’m wondering how it is that Keanu Reeves (as huge a star as he is) gets left alone and respected riding local trains and wandering about living his life and other stars have lost the ability to move through the world safely and easily bc people are stalking/approaching/crowding etc. social media and paparazzi are a hellscape feeding off and into the insatiable public desire for more than an artist chooses to share. Sia probably got it right hiding her face all the time with wigs. I love that Chappell is so unapologetically expressing herself . But I don’t love that her success comes at such a high price . I wrote on yr Insta that my kids saw her last year do a small gig in Melbourne with local drag acts . She was amazingly inclusive and generous to the local queer scene . My kids are queer and it meant a lot to them . My 15 year old trans kid got to sit in on an interview on JoyFM ( the queer radio station here in Melbourne) and Chappell allowed them to ask her questions . It was generous and genuine interest in her community . I love her so much . As do my kids

Francine Hibiscus

I never heard CR until I heard your cover of Casual and I bought the album right away! What an amazing person!

EmVT

re. "rethinking of what success means and what our culture does and doesn’t get right about it" speaking as a non-performer, I consider my own definition of success to be personal, almost private. I can't relate at all to the social paradigm public people have to deal with as a "tax" on what y'all do in your chosen life's work. That said, in all the groups I've been part of the consistent theme has been the value of community, that's what people are hardwired to seek. Community is good. If "culture" refers to mostly social media, I think what we get wrong is not differentiating between different flavors of public figures. AFP is not an elected politician, and not a news outlet. I think the "blue checkmark" culture exacerbates the worst aspects of our ability to connect, it's literally a dumbing down of "culture" and reinforces an othering paradigm. The level of entitlement of a lot of people online is breathtaking. There are some performers whose work I love, who have decided to not be on social media at all--who can blame them? I say good for them, they owe me nothing. AFP, if you decided to duck out of socials, I would miss seeing you all the time, and, I would still love and support your music and writing! I'm pretty sure that will never happen because you kind of like them socials, but for me, it's a "nice to have" not a "need to have". The community you've built though, is deeply meaningful and my life wouldn't be the same without it. I would be fine, just a little poorer without it.

Eric Riddler

Fifty-something cis man here, who’s very glad that my demographic doesn’t have the power it once had to play gatekeeper over whether or not talented young women could reach the audience they deserved. I love Chappell Roan! Honestly, the moment I realised that I was no longer in the target demographic for popular/indie music was absolutely liberating. If I didn’t like a popular song, who cared? There was so much to listen to instead. Plus, this was before my time but there was a moment in Australian music history when Wendy Saddington, a talented emerging queer singer, argued with her record company about a rush-released live album. Immediately labelled “A Difficult Woman”, Saddington never released another record. This link to a clip by a young Peter Weir, filmed in the aftermath of the record company falling out, shows just how great a loss Saddington’s talent was to the music industry and I really hope that Chappell Roan can weather the storm and keep working her magic https://youtu.be/zO9R639mk34?si=gRrRiCOEEoa5Ox7o

Suzanne

Honestly, I don't think I'd heard of CR until she released the statement you shared. But I'm tits deep in house and family and medical shit and work and had to cancel on coming to see you perform because of all that, so... Yeah. I will probably listen while I'm in Chicagoland next week getting ready for our go-live. As for the sentiment... It's part of why I keep the perspective that famous people are still *people* they're still human beings with lives and feelings and souls. They aren't possessions of the public. Just like ANY person, if you are invited to chat and interact? You do. If not? You don't. You mind your damned business. That's all there is to it. I don't understand what makes it so complicated. Just because someone is able to share their art with you doesn't mean they are sharing every part of themselves. You accept what's offered graciously and gratefully and move along. I don't get people sometimes. But that's probably why I've been friends with more famous-types over the years. I see the PERSON first. That's the important part. The rest is a bonus.

StoryADay's Julie Duffy

Huzzah. It needed to be said. Sometimes behavior creeps and becomes gradually normal or acceptable and if we had just teleported through time to this moment how weird would it seem? I hope an army of famous women (and others) stand up and speak up about their right to be off the clock.

Joni

Ok... So funnily enough... I'm seeing these issues pop up in my profession (Event Management / Hospitality) and I think you really hit the nail on the head. It is generational to a certain extent and all I can say is bless the Gen Z'ers (or whatever ..) The issue that came up was posted as an industry question on LinkedIn (yes, I'm total square...). In essence, planner was at the end of a three day program, saw someone in uniform and approached them to ask a question. According to the post, the staffer responded "I'm clocked out" and walked away. Now the OP was a) horrified at the rudeness and lack of service and b) utterly blown away (in a good way) by their ability to set boundaries and speak up for them. As "olds" some of these acts can hit badly and cause us to misunderstand / not hear all the, often younger, person is saying (I frankly find it hard to believe that anyone in that position wouldn't have at least said "I'm sorry I can't help you, I'm clocked out"... But there you are). I also feel that one should set boundaries firmly but kindly (at least the first time) and I feel that it's possible to do so... In regard to Chappel Roan... She's leading a charge that is LONG overdue... We've been giving away our labour and time and swallowing the now mythical story of corporate loyalty. When in reality, HR has become another line on the P/L sheet, beside copier and supply costs, and sadly, just as disposable. I'm 48, born in '76, so child of the boomers, but not quite full on X (we're refered to as the cusp apparently), and I kind of feel like I see both sides. I grew up with the message that your work was the most important thing in your life. Your family, your friends, everything else, was there to support your work or a hobby that took second place to work. I'm also young enough to realize what an utter crock that is, and being scheduled for 30 hours of work over a 35 hour period (true story) is not something I'm willing to accept anymore. For that I was told I wasn't a team player (and bad at "staying in my lane", whatever the fuck that means) and was fired. This is not the working world I want my child (or yours) going into... Chappell's tapped into something we've been simmering on as professionals and new leadership (as us "olds" start filling those leadership seats at the table) for a while now without the words. I think artists like Chappel, and Jewel, and Paris Paloma are giving us those words. I feel that artists almost always reflect the unspoken elements of their time... Both good and bad. I'm seeing a lot of art about taking stock, really looking at the systems that create our society and the unspoken "rules" and calling bullshit on it all... And frankly I'm here for ALL OF IT!!

Joni

A little brevity to an excellent point if I may... Here's your cute for terrible CS days... https://notalwaysright.com/ It's just pages and pages of crazy customer service stories.... And most of them are really funny!!

Tamara

Having all kinds of meetings about boundaries this week! I loved "...as we gaze into the chasms of our own decisions." Whew, is that ever true. I have just discovered Chappell Roan and "Femininomenon" is in regular rotation!

VTRADDICT

I have to ask - do you feel like your fans ever go too far in terms of familiarity or make you feel unsafe or uncomfortable in your interactions? (Partly coming from a place of self doubt and wondering if I've ever done that - the familiarity thing that is, I'm pretty confident I've never made anyone feel unsafe in my life)

Clare Sanders

For my two cents...I think she is absolutely right. I really struggle to understand the alternative. I guess personally I would never go up to an artist I just saw out in the world and expect/start an interaction just because I admired their art. There are other times for that...meet and greets and so on. There's a reason those kinds of structured opportunities exist (and of course there are 100% still boundaries within those events too + artists should never be treated badly for not wanting to do those things). But if I saw Amanda or any artist I liked out in the world then my instinct would be to treat them with the same courtesy and respect as anyone I don't know. Because I don't know them and they are not on the clock! And if they wanted to know someone like me then they would create and invite an opportunity for that. And if they don't then no big! I can just continue to enjoy and support their art.

Janelle

I'm glad to see her pushing back on what fame means and what behavior famous people are expected to tolerate and allow from fans, and honestly, probably people who aren't fans, either. It's a long overdue conversation, and I hope it actually gets somewhere. As far as her cancelled shows, as an avid concertgoer, the backlash to that is baffling. I get that not everyone goes to concerts and that for some fans, especially young ones, she might be the first artist they love enough to pay to see, and that can mean not knowing what happens if and when a show is cancelled. But the fact that some of her fans seem to genuinely believe that she owes them money for hotel rooms and travel strikes me as incredibly entitled and out of touch. I get that some of them saved up for it, were looking forward to it, and can't afford to shell out money again if and when she reschedules, but they have to understand that's just the risk you take when you buy a ticket. I've had tickets for shows cancelled because of scheduling issues and I've had tickets for shows cancelled because of band illness, so I get the disappointment and I've traveled for my fair share of shows, but it's ridiculous to expect more than a refund. Traveling for a show is a choice. And I feel like some of the anger may be misplaced. I get that it was short notice, but I have to wonder if some of this airfare and travel was booked through third-party sites known for being non-refundable. Either way, why not be angry with the companies who actually have your money and won't refund it? They set those policies, not Chappell Roan. I also think they need to consider the possibility that her management might be making some of these decisions, but frankly, even if they're not, she has the right to decide to cancel. Most of all, though, the fact that her apology wasn't good enough for some of her fans is ridiculous. What more is she supposed to say? Her "fans" are gonna bully her out of the industry.

Gabby

How could this be controversial? No one has a right to touch or stalk another person. Isn't it an actual crime? Do the really big stars like Taylor Swift or Billie Eilish, or Adele go around with body guards?

Nichole Parker

If she's on the clock for a meet and greet, asking for selfies and to talk to her is a yes. If she's not on the clock leave her tf alone. Yes, she may make art that speaks to you deeply, no you are not besties, no she is not speaking to you directly, no you aren't sharing a psychic connection and you secretly know everything about each other.

Damaris the Goddess

I’m sincerely glad she said that. NO ONE OWES ANYONE THEIR BODY, TIME, WHATEVER, FOR ANY REASON. You may be in a room full of people and everyone talks about what a great guy that person is. And there’s something about that guy that just gives you a weird vibe or creeps you the fuck out. That’s your intuition. Listen to it on 11 & break the knob off. Don’t gaslight yourself & don’t let others gaslight you, either. It might not be today or tomorrow or the next year, but they will show who they really are & you won’t be surprised because you listened to your intuition. Standing up for yourself can be really hard. Standing up for yourself on a worldwide level is necessary to keep your soul.

Ingrid Bohnenkamp

I find it interesting that some people take more offense to Chappell’s firm but relatively polite boundaries than to other egregious celeb behavior. They’re acting like she assaulted someone or something !

Mandi Hood

I jotted a few words down after I read your post. They were: archetypes, myth, ancestor worship, capitalism, projection, psychosocial development. Not sure I’ll get to those in this comment, but here goes: Chappell is spot-on. I get that within the bell curve of humanity, there will always be a certain amount of predators, assholes, and people who are prone to destructive obsession. But the dominant culture on this planet, fueled by rabid capitalism and the narcissism that accompanies it, has produced far more of those people than if we were living in a different system. Currently, people seem to have carte blanche to project anything and everything onto artists and other public figures. There is a sense of ownership around this that really disturbs me, and I think it’s indicative of how unwell our culture is. Also, it’s bad news to put people on pedestals, whether they are in your every-day life or in the public eye. Projection, generally speaking, is bad news, because it’s not grounded in reality. We all deserve to make mistakes, to say things we later don't agree with, to be human and fallible and vulnerable. It's so ironic to me the way famous artists get treated. Like, what a recipe for stifling creativity and crushing the human spirit. But I do think projection is a natural part of being human. As infants, we only know our caregiver/s as Everything. It takes a while for baby humans to even figure out that we are not Mom, which makes sense because we started out living inside of Mom. Part of human psycho-social development is not only learning that we are separate, but also at some point, that our caregivers aren’t perfect. Even non-abusive parents are flawed and fallible, because they are human. Which means we are flawed and fallible. Ideally, we learn that being flawed and fallible is natural and part of the human condition. But these are hard and often painful lessons to learn. And so many of us didn’t get anywhere near the love and care we deserved. So it makes sense that so many of us long for that feeling of someone/something that will be All The Things for us. This is why archetypes and shared stories are so important to cultures and communities. Stories are where those archetypes are made. And stories are safe places in which we can project anything and everything we need to project. And we can do that without harming the archetypes in the stories. I dig that. But in our culture, we seem to project all that onto the storytellers, themselves. That’s fucked up. It makes me think about communities and cultures with a strong connection to ancestor worship, communities with shared stories that have been told for hundreds of years or more. For example, I wonder what life was like for the ancient and medieval Welsh bards. Did they have fans who obssessed over them? Did they have stalkers and people who made fucked-up threats to them? Did people project onto the bards? Or did they project onto the people in the bard’s stories? I don't know but I suspect that the projection went more onto the characters than the bards.

Amy Gleixner

Personally speaking, the stans kill my desire to put things out into the world. Not that I think I would get to pop star levels, but I watch how mega fans treat the artists when the artists do something new/different, how they get bullied, how every detail of their lives gets dissected and analyzed... And I just wither away. As with workplace sexual harassment keeping women out of certain areas they might have been passionate about, but for that lecherous person who poisoned it, I think of all the creative people who are terrified into not sharing what they make with the world. It makes me sad to know they're hiding or even stopped making things they're passionate about, and even more so that it was people who "love them" who caused it. Imagine what kinds of art we would have if people weren't assholes. To that end, I removed as much as I could of myself from the Internet - no social media, especially - and stopped posting what I make altogether. The reaction people get from fans was a factor, but also included the fact I was spending more time trying to make things marketable, that appealed to others instead of me, and it was making me hate the things I loved. I started a zine club and I run it almost entirely offline, but for an email reminder I send, and it has been so good for my mental and creative health. I can't make a living off this now, and probably never will, but people are kind and supportive and compassionate. Folks are often surprised when I answer "no" to "do you have an Instagram account". But as with when I deleted Facebook, I found out who the people are who actually care about me, because they find a way to stay in touch. That being said, this isn't a social media problem... People have consumed their idols for as long as fame has been a thing. I don't know how we stop it, but it seems like calling out the behavior, both by the artists and the peers of stans, and not rewarding it, might be a start? The last part is tricky, since a major part of what stans are rewarded by is the artists literally just doing their jobs and going dark is a shitty solution. It's cheaper to be a good person. In more ways that financial.

Coila

I don't like the way people feel entitled to celebrities. I understand that they *feel*, very deeply that they're friends with them. But even with friends, it isn't ok to demand time, physical affection, etc on the spot... There's usually some dance. Some negotiation. That doesn't mean the art isn't Real or didn't come from a Real Place. My relationship with this community and with you, Amanda, is all online with the exception of a few folks I had the pleasure of meeting in person before one of your concerts. And there have been times, recently, when I felt like you and/or this community cared when no one else did. Sometimes because it was true and sometimes because I *felt* seen and heard here even though there were others in my life who wanted to and were trying to show they cared. I'm grateful to you for making and keeping this community. But I do feel like it all being entirely online (for me, because I'm in the mid west) is lacking things I need and I'm so lucky to have found friends IRL too. And to still have some dear friends from other times in my life.

James from Wellington

Ok this time I let my calendar work out the time difference, so I will miss the concert sorry

Marley Kendrick

Your comment reminded me of a thought I had yesterday, a lot of the people I've seen in person behave like problematic fans....I've found that they do treat friends kind of the same and tend to have demanding personalities. Also, I live a lot of my life online due to health and definitely its made me feel more connected to chatting here or on videos of youtubers I follow. It can feel like people who don't know me are a big part of my life but at the same time I'm very aware they have no clue who I am/aren't my friends and don't owe me anything (no one does)

Len Tower Jr.

* I love to have an artist like Chappell (or you) that sprang from another planet. * It takes two to tango. Relationships need mutual respect. Assuming there is a relationship, or that you can abuse one that is established, tears at civilization. Love to all, Len

Moriah Martel

I've been re-reading your book, Amanda and am at a section where you are talking about your intimate relationship with fans, especially early on doing long signing sessions after shows. I also see "fanbase" building as really community building, and I'm so inspired by how you do that! I'm curious about what you've learned about boundaries while also being so intimate with us. Would love to hear you talk more about how you authentically connect, while also caring for yourself.

Len Tower Jr.

A travel insurance policy might cover these expenses. Not clear that a cancelled show, would be a reason for the insurance to pay out. Of course, the premium might be out of reach of some fans. Love to all, Len

Kristi Neely

Hope this livestream will be archived too! It’s the day of my surgery. I will save it as a little treat for my goo stage.

Jen Cowitz

Re: Chappell Roan: I've always dreamed of performing and creating as my lifeblood and career. By age 6, my body made a lot of choices for me that meant a really solid healthcare plan from my employer or union had to be the primary goal.... but putting my feelings out there and making people feel as a result.... what could be more human? But by pretty early on, I realized I'd rather be a voiceover artist or a performance artist that could wear a mask. Even in my deepest dreams, my most heartfelt wishes, I'd want my art known without my face. As a millennial, the internet was immediately and obviously toxic. I was 12 or so when the "Wynona Rider shoplifting" scandal played out. Then, everyone asked why people with so much money would do such a thing.... by then, I already knew it was a cry for help, to get caught, to be seen. I hadn't stolen (yet), but I could see the dare that it was. Self-destruction bleeds outside oneself. It's a secret you desperately want someone to see, but fear its revelation. Chapell is such a modern celebrity. There are opportunities I passed up because I was scared to be seen. Hell, at my local ren faire I was known for a few songs and was repeatedly recognized at the supermarket... it felt great, but I was terrified by what was in my cart, what it said about me. The fourth wall is weirdly sacred; I can let you in all the way (so I think in the moment), until I'm scared for you to see me eat cheetos (or whatever). Having met you at Graveside, I kinda of realized some things. Of course you are yourself, laid bare, but... you're maybe as laid bare as a bride/groom at a wedding. There's only so much any one person can possibly give of oneself, in any moment, over and over. Parasociality is very true for fandom, but it's still true for orbital friends. I'm grateful to hug you, to tell you your art helped psychopomp me through a hard moment, but that doesn't make us comrades. I'm so grateful to Chappell for setting boundaries, but like all boundaries, they are lines in the sand : "if you take this action, this is my response..." which means a few shitty people could take art from all of us. There's no resolution here. I'm grateful for the connection you give us all on patreon. I'm aware it's still part of the truth. I can't speak to the multitude of experiences artists face. It's hard; it's all hard. But I'm grateful for the art that has pulled me from my darkest places.

IRIDYSCENZIA

Awesome job! Keep it up! 👊💯❤️

christine lloyd

On Chappell Roan’s Music: Chappell Roan is fantastic, thank you for the rec. I downloaded her at work. Anyhow as to your question... In sum? I agree with Chappell, completely. The artist owes the audience no more than the art. That’s it. And that is intimate enough on its. Own. Art, I've always believed should stand on its own? I kind of agree with David Bowie's assessment (which I saw in the art exhibit at Brooklyn Museum of Art), where he stated that art changes as we interact with it. It is different things to different participants. It's not just the creators but all who come into contact with it. It's also a way of understanding another's point of view - to get a glimpse into their psyche, and in some respects to connect with them. Art can be shockingly intimate at times, the most effecting art - I think - often is or the most memorable - the bits that stay with me.

christine lloyd

Adding to my comment above? in regards to privacy - since art is often in of itself an act of intimacy in that the artist is sharing with us a piece of themselves, do we have the right to ask for more? I don't think we do. I think that's presumptuous and invasive, and the artist is right to push us away at that point. Art is magical when we are mutually sharing it. The artist shares their creation, and we share our reactions to it, either by playing with it ourselves, interacting with it, or analyzing it, however we need to interact with the art as long as our method is consensual and doesn't harm others (including and especially the artist). A difficult line to neatly navigate I know. Nothing is ever simple when it comes to humans, is it? At any rate, I don't think the artist necessarily needs to know of every interaction – just that the very act of interaction – gives their art life outside of them? I know as an artist myself - that what makes me shy away from sharing my art - is that fear of too much of intimacy, of those I'm sharing the art with - clamoring for more than I can give them, or rejecting it out of hand for not being what they expected, or worse thinking my very act of sharing the art - is in invitation to know everything about me or to judge me? Instead of greeting the art with curiosity and an open mind – too often it is greeted with judgement, moral or otherwise. And that’s painful for something so intimately and honestly shared. There's something to be said for the purity of anonymity or a pseudonym. I want my art to stand outside of me - to be seen on its own, as part of me, but also apart. I want those I share it with - to be free to play with it in their own sandboxes, without necessarily telling me. I like the idea of art as being like a child - that you send on its way, but like any nervous parent, with more than a little trepidation and fear, but the art, the creation takes on a life of its own, all the more powerful when we, the artist, are left out of it - watching it go off and succeed. Those we choose to share it with? Should see it as a gift, paid for or otherwise, and ask no more of us but to play with it, forever and a day.

Parker

Indeed. And…Imagine what kind of *world* we could have if people weren’t assholes 🤔😔

Scott Meekins

Super Fans are not Super Stalkers. As always, out of common logic, may we treat each other with respect and dignity. Nobody likes a weird creep. Good day to you all!

Ruby Rose

Thank you x Kia ora e hoa x I joined for free. When circumstances change I will subscribe 🖤🩶🖤

Douglas Roark

Hello. In general, I'll avoid commenting on much on the post. I doubt I'd have much to add anyway beyond teens and young adults just have to navigate the world as best they can. Nobody makes perfect decisions all the time, especially people who find themselves thrust into the spotlight all of a sudden. I certainly did some things that I don't regret and yet I wouldn't dare repeat, sometimes out of a desire to get closer to people who had zero desire to get closer to me. (D'oh!) Instead, maybe this long-ish story will interest you. I spent the weekend going to a few shows as a treat to myself for this godforsaken year finally turning around. The guy's music was comforting when I was feeling low as shit. He did the VIP thing. A few acoustic songs, meet-n-greet, etc. By the third and final time, he recognized me and called me out by name. It was a bit of a mindfuck. He's a smooth talker who learned how to hustle on the streets. So, he knows how to read people and put them at ease. That's good, and yet it puts me in my head, like I'm trying to figure out a magic trick that I'm witnessing. I started wondering if I had made a mistake. I know I didn't. I enjoyed the experience, and I got to have some breezy but fun conversations. I think he was also legit happy that I was trying to get to know the Rio Grande Valley better. (He's from there and got the key to his hometown over the weekend. He loves the RGV and talks up South Texas music all the time.) Still, I was praying I wasn't "that guy," even if I knew to just enjoy the VIP thing, enjoy the show, and go home. Despite this, by accident, I ended up near the bus after that third show. Standing there was a couple I had talked to earlier. The lady had told stories earlier about getting too close to artists and spooking them. Like, following them out the back door and such. I bailed almost immediately. If I wasn't "that guy," I knew that hanging around the bus would definitely make me "that guy." (Bonus points: Before going into my hotel, I checked out the statue of Selena that was across from the hotel. You know, since this post is about parasocial fans and such....)

Zenobia

Hello! So happy you are here making Springfield an even better place to be! :D