Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello loves.

Reading comments.

Quick and serious question because I have been cancelled for less.

If you’ve been following the plot, you’ll know what this is (the LONG DELAYED CHUCK-age of the THINGS from 2018).

(Screenshot from IG).

It reads -

Serious advice/question:

I’m thinking of throwing a bunch of wedding/engagement rings into the sea today (about 8 of them - I have been tasked…long story, I’ll tell it later). I was gonna film a clip. They are tiny and silver/diamond etc and the ocean is a vast maw, but…in theory, art and profound meaning aside, this is littering into the ocean. I don’t think anyone canceled titanic for that diamond necklace litter move. Talk to me here. What say you, crowd?

…..

I love you.

Everything changes.

Xx

A

Please advise.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Danielle O'Connor

As it’s not harmful to the environment I don’t see why not! I’m intrigued

Aimsel Ponti

Don’t do it. Sell them and donate the money to an abortion rights charity. if there’s a way to do that that doesn’t feel disrespectful to those who sent them I think that’s the right call. And have some kind of other ceremony for those people who sent those things. That could be figured out later.

Bruce Strong

I would say make sure you're out to deep water and give them a throw. The environmental impact is quite minimal.

Emma

I would have a jeweler break them down, melt them, sell the pieces, and give the money to a women’s refuge

Kim Fitch

They are natural elements you are only returning them to Mother Earth.

Steven Panzek

Cast away Amanda. The farther the better. The ocean floor is a treasure trove. Add to it my dear

Eve L

Jewelry artists love to get unwanted things to melt down and make new art!

Martin OHare

I think we need to be more bothered about micro plastics and plastics. I say I Ur good. They are small. chuck em in. X

Bruce Strong

But if you're worried about the tiniest possibility of something perhaps swimming into a ring, I would then embed them in a block of concrete. Wouldn't have to be very big. Maybe a 3-in cube. And then toss that. Basically a zero impact.

Susan Lazarus

Emma has the right idea- they should help other women

Tracie Winslow

Huh. I never thought about something like this. Like, yes, technically it's littering into the ocean. There's a LOT of litter in the ocean, and this would be a tiny thing in comparison, but that doesn't make it right. But I don't know if it's wrong. The metal and stones in the rings came from the earth and they would be returning to the earth. But...yeah, I don't know.

Jo Swift

In the grand scheme of things and with the amount of metal already in the sea, I don't think it will make any difference. Also it's a good way to let them go😁

Damian Masterson

Starting from a first principle of do no harm, I would say no to the ocean, and find a different way. Accepting that disposal is the correct action since that is what you were charged with doing, perhaps fire. Perhaps burial. But I would discourage from throwing into the ocean where something could get stuck in them, or hurt by swallowing them.

Augustine

I wouldn't do it... The message is cathartic but marine life doesn't understand which items are art and which items are litter. There's too many "just this once" incidents of people throwing solid objects in the water and animals being found with said items in their stomachs.

James from Wellington

Are we debating in terms of adding more of our discarded things to the ocean?

Alex Manion

No plastics, no weird alloys? I think the ocean would cope. I probably wouldn't do it on a remote unspoiled nature reserve, but off a pier/in a town, sure?

Emily

I mean are you trying to prevent the one ring from ever being used again or something else? If we're, we're going by the stories. Chucking a ring into water doesn't cause it to go away. It just means it ends up in some other person's hands. And then someone still has to track up the volcano to throw it in. Can you throw them into a volcano?

Dana Green

You could melt them down, like dramatic mt doom style

Mary Alice Fraughton

It depends how much bullshit you’re feeling up to facing. I would absolutely feed them to the ocean in your shoes, but I wouldn’t film it and I’m not famous. I think you’re likely to get a lot of push-back on this. Maybe you’re just the ring-bearer now? Any active volcanoes around that might stand in for Mount Doom?

Peace

Recycle ♻️ melt them down or give away to an artist for reuse.

Callie Michaels

I get the point of the “recycle” and “sell them” voices here, but my feelings are: Keep to the original intent do what the senders asked you to do. Send them to the sea with their old secrets, lies, and heartbreaks. Deep water burial.

nikos papageorgiou

I think these days if you film yourself doing anything and put it online, someone will find a way to get offended. I can only speak for myself in this instance, but I don't find that offensive, and I don't consider it littering. If you get on a boat to go to anywhere, the amount of pollution you're causing (indirectly), is immensely greater.

Andrew Davis

I wouldn't do it personally. Even if the environmental impact is tiny, I feel like there's still a decent chance it will result in "Amanda Palmer tries to kill endangered sea turtles" discourse or something.

Moxie McMurder

I'll be honest, my concern would be for animals that may swallow the rings even though I appreciate the artistic idea behind it. Perhaps there's a better metaphor out there that doesn't result in littering/death of sea creatures etc (Although the idea of one of those rings ending up in the belly of a whale...I mean...😉)

Francine Hibiscus

FLING THEM they are inert metals and perhaps will find new homes someday. (Me, I would sell them to a jeweler and donate the $. )

Deniz Bevan

Are they real gold/silver/etc.? I think that's fine, compared with plastic, because they'll dissolve or rust, unlike plastic!

Daniel Klein

Toss them in; collect 16 bits of trash from the beach; ignore the haters ♥

Maggie's Yarm

I love this idea and although littering is bad etcetera this seems to be minimal impact and is certainly better than plastic being thrown into the environment. Considering the the way there were sent to you I think recirculating them as rings is contradictory to the message. Smelting them down into something else would still be in line though.

Danielle Cavanaugh

I'm reposting my Facebook response: I say donate them. There are so many people that would love to give someone a ring, especially one that represents an engagement, but can't afford to. My engagement ring was originally my great uncle's that he pawned after his relationship ended. My great aunt bought it back and kept it, passed it to my mom who then passed it to me when my husband couldn't afford to propose to me. It meant nothing good to anyone else but I love it so much. The symbolism of giving them to the sea will end there. If you give them to another, they will most likely represent something else for someone else. It will feel better doing something that benefits another person in some way as opposed to sending the energy under water. ❤️

Ashleah

I think it could be really cool to find an artisan and ask them to melt down the metals, remove the stones, and make some kind of art piece with them instead. I think a transformation on that level would still let the individual pieces be free, and would release any feels they might be holding.

October Jones

They can’t strangle sea turtles. And anything that’s big enough to swallow one probably won’t die from it? It seems pretty harmless to me.

Caroline King

Melt them down and transmute them into something else x

Neil

Not sure what to add about marine littering, I'd be concerned if they were valuable and could be sold to benefit someone. The KLF should've spent that 1 mill on charity

SField

bury them?

Amy S

I would be worried about the animals who might ingest them. Idea, would there be a way to have a net to catch them all just below the surface or have the rings on strings so they can be reeled back in?

Lisa Claire

I think it’s fine (and deeply poetic) but I don’t know jf the act of doing it would cause any ecological harm. I’ll be reading the comments with great interest.

Sarah Grace

*I* won't lose any respect for you if you do it. What the rest of the world says...🤷‍♂️

Kayleigh Griffiths

Idk…I’m a big fan of not adding any more negative energy and general trash to nature, vast and powerful as it is. Any alternative would depend on what the motive is, I guess. Release of the old and toxic, art, or something else.

xannybee

Don’t do it. Littering in the ocean is a bad idea, it’s already a threatened ecosystem.

Kim Fitch

Although -My zoompha ( genz + gen alpha) says it’s littering and why not sell them for money where money is needed!

Douglas Neudeck

Why not reforge them into something better, just like those who survived what the rings represented originally?

Janet in Georgia

Part of me says do it. Another part of me says don’t. Fishies like to eat lil shiny fishies (hence the shiny fishing lures out there) and may mistake one for a snack. I don’t think that the patrons that sent the rings would want harm to come to any creatures from discarding their rings. Melt them down? Bury them somewhere? Smash em?

JessTCreate

If the materials all came from nature, they can return to nature imo

Lizzie Lovejoy

The impact will be minimal, people throw jewellery into the sea for many reasons. This should be okay, and probably more environmentally friendly than most BBQ's on the beach.

Philipp Windgassen

They are all made from. Precious Metals which are eternal. They came from the earth (or actually space) and go back to the earth. I like the idea...

Taylor

Imo? Best revenge? Lottery for lucky couples to win spite ring Edit: that way we’re all recycling and consenting to the energy it came from (: lol

Robin

Two options: Either outright sell them to a jeweler and show receipts verifying the funds were donated to a fitting charity (DV? Mental health? etc)… Or, request a jeweler allow you to video record them removing any precious gemstones, melting down the metals, and transforming it all into something new of your own AFP design. It could be auctioned off, also with funds going to a charitable organization.

Carole

If you would do it without filming it for the emotional catharsis then I would do it and film it for the art catharsis. You’ll be cancelled again and reinstated as the tides ebb and flow.

Rusky South

I love the idea, but worry someone will attack you for it.

Lynn Anderson

Definitely sell them to be melted down and donate to a refuge or abortion rights charity. That’s destroying them in the spirit of the asking, but also doing good from the casting away ♥️

Marcus

I would say: Don't over-think. If the original intention was to throw them into ocean, do it! 😉 (Environmental impact is negligible anyway.)

Amanda cozens

It could be a ceremonial melting, returning to elemental form.

Chris Jeske

I wouldn't. I'd be worried about somebody down there ingesting something indigestible. I like the concept, *I* just wouldn't do it.

Tara Timmsy

No ocean. Maybe not a huge harm but definitely not a benefit to the life there either. If ethical, sell & donate = my vote.

Susan Drake

Similar but different situation: years ago I had gem stones and crystals that I wanted to get rid of (tainted by association from the person who gave them). Didn't want to sell or give away (gotta keep my karma as clean as I can). Someone suggested putting them in a stream or lake, as the water purifies them. And if someone should come along and find them, they can have the anonymous gift. My long winded reply: ocean.

Rue Bix Queue

Ritual burial? Less likely to harm any wildlife and if I am interpreting the intent would still have the desired effect.

Nikki

I dunno. Part of me says yeah, go dump them in the deepest part of the ocean and the other part says to figure out how to repurpose or reuse or sell them. But honestly, used engagement/wedding rings hold such little value that it's not likely to be worth bothering.

xannybee

It is harmful, animals will swallow those rings and risk injury or death from an obstruction

Douglas Roark

Does your heart tell you that you *need* to do it? If you do it, can you handle the pushback you'll receive? If you answered "Yes" to both, do it. I'd wager good money that the odds of this doing any significant damage to any part of the ocean is vanishingly small, especially compared to all the other garbage we toss in there one way or another. If you answered "No" to either question, don't do it. Figure out an alternative. I have no suggestions. It's your art. :) Either way, good luck.

Mikala - Backstagerider

My take: Everyone is focusing on blowback which is the wrong focus. The ocean doesn’t need any more human garbage, however small. Platinum is a heavy metal. Melt and rebirth them. 🐠

Michael Cavanaugh

generally I’m in the inert mettle, shouldn’t hurt category, but the breaking them down to sell components and donate to women’s shelter sounded really good

Sydney Fowler

I'll leave the ethical discussion to other folks, but I wanted to say that in times of great stress, change, and transition, my own risk profile becomes quite small. I'm terrified to make a mistake or to do the "wrong" thing. I struggle to trust my instincts, to listen to my body, to commit to letting go. I wonder if this is a moment where you can extend yourself some compassion and take the risk to follow through on what your heart is telling you.

Michelle

I like the volcano idea. Not as convenient though. I love our oceans and want to protect them and I mean somebody do some research and if there's any real possibility of an animal swallowing it and getting injured or something then maybe go with a plan B, but otherwise, fuck the haters. You're popular and all, but I don't think you're going to set a new trend for everyone to chuck the rings in the ocean but they're done with them. Or do it and just film it for the people involved; we don't all have to see it for it to matter.

Cyrrise Locke

They are not the worst things to be thrown into the ocean, but it’s still technically human debris being tossed into the ocean which can wash up in any number of places and possibly cause harm. Personally, if someone else can find joy in a thing I prefer giving away the object than throwing it away.

Coquelicot Shirey

While the impact to the ocean is presumably minimal, I have an undeniable (and pun-intended) sinking feeling in my stomach. Even for Art, I think the visual of littering in the ocean is bad and if I saw it out of context with a headline “Amanda Palmer litters in ocean” I would be jarred and confused. In the spirit of CHUCKAGE, I would destroy them in some other artful way. Another commenter (Emma) proposed melting down the rings and donating the profits. Why not make new art of the liquid metal? Chuck the rings into the smelter perhaps?

Tony Amis

I think you are right. Everything changes. However I think sometimes it might be better to make Art from Pain even when that pain is unfathomable. I have been amazed by your silence on all the noise that caused you to come to this point. Melt them, remake them, rescue them from the memories that are attached to them and move forward as you have been doing for years. We love that you ask, we love you asking, power to you.

Jeanette-o-saur

Melt down and make a new piece of art from them. It's better symbolism to transform and rebuild than to discard. Perhaps the final art could be displayed in a funky local gallery and then auctioned for charity?

Frédéri POCHARD

Well... to me it's pretty much as littering as the waves eroding a cliff with an outcroping silver vein. Basically it's not like it is plastics you're throwing in the sea.

Amanda cozens

And once ingots/ gemstones, an artist could be commissioned to make a piece/ talisman/ fetish to reflect the transformation, cleansing, dark to light etc. And sold for charity

Priya Sridhar

I think it may be more practical to sell the rings and donate the money to the original wearer's charity of choice. It would have more value in the long run.

Stephanie Hannahs

Ceremonial Cleansing / Anointing in the Ocean then sell for $ to donate?

Liz Grammaticas

I like the melt and rebirth idea . Also maybe make a biodegradable stand in? Or throw them attached to a small string under a dock or something and retrieve them in X amount of time if they’re still there.

Isabel Vogt

I'd say rather bury them or melt them down.

Holly Behanna

In this spirit, perhaps but then instead. Less likely to do harm to an animal. Our leave them for the crows or such birds. They love shimmer objects and present gifts/tokens to those who help or provide for them.

Jo Brown

The struggle you're having with undoing these symbols of undone promises......is sort of haunting me. Sticking with me when I try to sleep and stuff. I watched them rattle on the piano during your live stream and though about the life still in them.....idk. no point. Many thoughts and brain aches

Amy Michalik

Find a section of beach you can rent for 24 hours. Host a bonfire Chuck-it party for all who want to rid themselves of ‘______’, have a cleanse & release and toss said items onto the beach and bury them where they lie. Next morning, host a pirate booty event with metal detectors for all who wish to discover the discarded treasure. 🔥🏖️🏴‍☠️

Tapio Peltonen

I'd say it's okay if it's far enough from shore and at least somewhat deep water. They are heavy things and fall straight to the bottom, and are relatively inert, so I'd guess the ecological and environmental effects are very minuscule; mainly they disturb the seafloor a little at the location where they hit it. Gold and silver are both toxic heavy metals, but in metallic form gold is almost completely inert and silver dissolves so slowly that it will not even locally increase silver ion concentration enough to have any biological effect even after a long while. If you'd want to dispose of a literal ton of them, then I'd suggest asking an environmental authority if you need a permit, but a handful of jewelry is probably not enough to piss off anyone.

Len Tower Jr.

Yes, get them to a goldsmith to melt/reuse the metal & reuse the gems. Donate the funds to a charity that fits the purposes of this art project.

Amy up North

Nope. No litter is no litter. One turtle or fish swallows and the art is canceled. Than it’s just harm.

Mair Jones

I would imagine this would cause minimal damage, and someone with a metal detector will have the best day when they find it

Madison

I really don't think 8 rings is going to make the situation in the ocean any worse.

Frédéri POCHARD

Now these thing have value. And as mentioned by Robin and probably others, the question is: is this value better used for an artistic gesture or for some other purposes like giving to charities? That one is entirely up to you. Art is impactful too or it can be at least.

Valerie Jaruzel

I say go for it, but maybe send the video only to those who entrusted you to dispose of their material culture of hurt. If you decide against it, even the local community college might have an accessible forge in the sculpture/art area should you wish to alchemize the moment - melt them down into something greater.

Evelina Dineva

Throwing metal and stones is not polluting the ocean along with any symbolic meaning attached to the stories of those rings. It’s plastics and artificial chemicals that we should try to keep away from the waters. Melting and recycling the rings materials might be a bit more ecological way of disposing as extracting precious metals and stones hurts the earth. But the water will eventually make the stones to sand and erode the metals. Unless there are some odd coatings (teflon or such), i would not worry about pollution. Best way to recycle is avoiding unnecessary consumption anyway such that the symbolic meaning of the art act overrides the waste of precious materials in a ring.

Gail Gallagher

Can you donate the valuables to a charity? There is so much need in the world.

Anna Bruce

As a jeweler myself, we love found objects and I think giving them off to be repurposed into better objects might be a better way…. A beautiful catharsis of a new piece from them…..But I don’t see why they can’t be tossed into the ocean if that’s what needs to be done with them. They are rocks and metal- things from the earth. I don’t see it as litter in this case… 🤷‍♀️🖤

Ralph M.

Unless they aren't worth much, maybe sell them and donate the money to charity instead? I definitely get the emotional and artistic significance of tossing them into the sea though.

Amanda Sandia

Maybe you can put them in bottles and include a rolled up peice of paper with a poem written on it.

amacker

Assuming this is metal and mineral, not man-made in the sense of batteries or plastic, you aren’t littering. You’re returning to the source that which came from there.

EmilyKoester

What a person gives to the ocean, and how they give it, is entirely their own business. As is how public or private that gift. The ocean takes everything it wants, in the end, regardless

Matt XYZ

I also am not a fan of publicizing the act of throwing things into the ocean - maybe the actual harm of this littering is pretty minimal in the grand scheme of things, but video-ing and then publicizing the event also adds a little to the bigger impulse that claims 'yeah, respecting the environment is good, but I'm a good person so my little act of pollution doesn't count' - If you do throw them , I'd prefer it just happened and you didn't make a big thing [or "Thing"] about the act.

James from Wellington

Personally, I think throwing them would be beautiful, casting away inherently unlucky things to sit on the ocean floor to one day maybe rediscovered and their story wondered about

KEN HAZLETT

As a way of practicing “The Art of Asking”…in this case asking the universe for closure…I like this for you if it’s your choice. Just my opinion (though perhaps pertinent that I dayjob in Environmental Compliance) but as you are returning natural materials, albeit refined, to nature I think you are morally and ecologically on good footing. Will someone seeing it be Angry On The Internet? Maybe…but when are they not?

Adam Cronin

First thought is that it's amazing for you to ask. It kinda? feels wasteful if they are expensive, but I also still have my wedding ring and plan to personally throw it into a volcano, so... 🤣 Can rings harm sea life? Much smaller than the plastic bottle rings that harm loads of animals, but unlikely something any animal could break. (IMO, that could be fixed by cutting them in half, and that could even be an amazing addition). Are there expensive gems that could be removed and then donated for a good cause? Might cost more to remove than the stones value, though. I see no egregious "OH MY GODS I cannot believe she did this." in this act. But if you're brainstorming alternatives, 8 rings sounds like raw material to make something new (a tiara, a scuplture, one ring to rule them all 🤣). There is beauty in the "release" of returning them to the sea, and beauty in using them to create something new. TL;DR for me is that I don't see an issue if it doesn't hurt wildlife.

Nicole

I love this …. Melt them all down, have someone create a new piece and auction it off for charity.

Joanna Lindblad

I understand the positions people have taken here. But consider a ring could get caught on or in an animal causing pain, harm, or death. I would recommend doing something else. Donate, sell, or melt it down to create a new work of art you could auction off and donate the money to a worthy cause. Why pollute or harm a living thing when you don't have to 🙏❤️

Anna Bruce

Just saying, I’d volunteer if you wanted some new artistic something cool made from it 🖤🤷‍♀️🖤 👀

Niki McQueen

There are plenty of diamonds under the sea already and traces of gold in seawater. You're not adding anything that isn't naturally occurring apart from the closure this may bring you. Go ahead. (And you do immense amounts towards raising funds for people in need, so to all those saying 'get the money' because that's what they would do, there are more important things than money. You more than make up what you would raise with the work you do and the art you make. )

Gabby

Practically and symbolically, I think it is not loving to throw discards into the ocean. Aside from the pollution of the material itself, a sea creature might choke on it or carry it around unnaturally and destructively in his stomach. Even someone's dog might swallow it and land in hospital. Please don't do it.

Anthea Peck

I love the idea of melting them down and making something new and beautiful from the tainted.

Holly Behanna

I love the concept/reason for throwing into the ocean... But fear not only the backlash, but for wildlife. Could you possibly achieve a similar (or even better) sentiment by maybe planting a tree with them? Allowing them to become a part of the tree as it grows? Releasing the bad juju, but also creating something new and beautiful...a positive use of the energies, renewal, and creating the new energy needed for moving forward (plus a place to 'visit' to remember where one has been, and how far one has come...a place and symbol from which to draw strength).

Ryan Stuck

I would only worry if the rings were composed of strange metals like pewter or something. Gold, silver, platinum won't directly react with salt water, so they won't contaminate anything. The only consideration is the solder used to affix gems to the rings. The older the ring the higher likelihood of solder containing lead. That lead can contaminate the water, however the amount held by one or two rings isn't enough to cause any real issues (we're talking micrograms). It's unlikely anything will try to eat them, so that shouldn't be a problem. So all in all, I don't think you'll be making the ocean any worse off. Depending on where you drop them maybe they'll anchor some new coral or something!

Adam Cronin

If you went the reforge route (if there is enough material), auctioning off the final piece, especially if it was used for a video, could generate more money for charity that the raw materials, too!

amacker

The Earth is what we use to ground out our energy when we are working positive. Energy doesn’t stop existing. We just call it to one place and disperse it into another. What is one person’s “negative” energy doesn’t affect another whatsoever. And the Earth is impervious to all of this. Human Life, on the other hand, is not impervious at all! But what we are doing is not ruining the Earth, but destroying our chance of existing upon its face. The Earth has seen atmospheres of sulfuric acid. It’s not going to be at all kerfuffled by anything we can throw at it.

Kurt C Siegel

I understand this from an art perspective, but... what is the value of the pieces, from the perspective of "How many people would that jewelry feed?"

Art Popp

I can't speak for the cathartic effects on others. But I have had precious objects that I needed to let go of, that conjured memories too disruptive... And after the fact I can say contributing them to someone else's joy has been a big win. It helped me tie a bow on that memory-box with the ribbon of someone else's happiness. Letting someone like Anna melt them down and make something beautiful out of them would be great. For those with deeper wounds than mine, watching them melt down in the crucible and seeing a picture of the delightful custom thing that was built from them might work even better.

Molly McOsker

You could sell them and donate the profit to a good cause. Bonus points if the person who bought the rings would disapprove of the good cause. It would feel great in the moment to throw them in the ocean, but I'd personally feel better knowing that I turned pain into progress instead of discarding a physical object of value. If not trading them for cash, find a cool artist who can repurpose them and share the catharsis with the world in a beautiful way.

amacker

Re: REpurpose, REcycling… i’m an artist and I work in found art sourced from found, & recycled materials. However, the scenario of taking these materials and giving them to other women to do art or repurpose these bothers me on that completely mortal failing of jealousy. If I want my relationship to someone who failed me to be banished and sent to oblivion, the last thing I would want is to see some other woman finding joy in what caused me pain. At this stage of grief where you need to condemn and destroy and send to the depths the symbols of that relationship, that would be akin to watching that man go off with someone else and find happiness where we couldn’t have it ourselves.

s

metals and diamonds are natural materials so I don't think of it as "litter". My personal perspective is that I would rather sell something and donate the proceeds to a charitable cause, one that is relevant to why I'm getting rid of the thing, whatever it is… a women's health center, a nonprofit counseling group, whatever makes sense to me. so that the negative is transformed into the positive.

Kayleigh Griffiths

That’s an interesting and valid perspective. Along with my own feelings about energy and how it transfers, it just feels like a respect thing for me.

Jamie V.

I think it's irresponsible in this day and age. So many of us (me included) do so much to harm the plant and it's occupants claiming it's only this time or only a small amount or everyone else is doing it so it doesn't matter. But there are so many of us. And once you know, you know. So each time we make that decision we're being irresponsible. (Me included) You asked so now you know better. I love that you asked. Also folks on this thread have fantastic ideas.

bluefoxx

It was the owners of the rings decisions to banish them. They sent them to you to take them to Mordor 🔥🙂 You are trusted. You are chosen to dispose of these trinkets in the way you decide is best! Whatever decision you make, I will stand by you ❤️

Brian Kelly

Jewelry is art and valuable. Donate them to someone who cannot afford extravagance. It is shameful to waste.

Robert Hays

I also don't see this as litter. We scatter ashes, I don't see a problem with this request. And donation may be an acceptable alternative to the parties involved, I suspect sale would violate their intent (unless it was for a charity the clients support).

Joni

I mean... I'm pretty sure that they didn't actually leave the diamond down there... Movie magic and all that... 😉 I don't feel like casting them into the sea is the right thing to do... For all the reasons you've said. My two cents... Find a white witch (you must know one and if not, I can help), and completely cleanse them of their past... Then find a knifesmith (Again, I can help if needs be). Have each of the rings melted down and incorporated (including their gems) into daggers. Then auction / raffle them in support of a charity (I'm think domestic violence or women's health). Take the dark and crack that motherfucker open.

Kati Loux

Not into the sea. You're right that the ocean has taken enough shit from us. I like the idea of finding a jewelry artist and melting them down.

Tanya

Great word!—- trans·mute /tranzˈmyo͞ot/ verb 1. change in form, nature, or substance: "the raw material of his experience was transmuted into stories"

TheGratefulNed

This is a complicated one and definitely requires a lot more context, possibly including context that simply will never be available. In general, I agree with most of the sentiments of "don't do it, donate/sell/re-Art them instead" From a littering/environmental-damage standpoint, as long as they're not being thrown in a protected area, known habitat for endangered animals/plants, or so close to shore that they'll be carried back to land by the tides, a small handful of rings is entirely moot in comparison to the amount of debris from rockets, ships, planes, etc. that are sunk, sometimes intentionally, every year. From a resource perspective, there's absolutely no good reason to throw out already mined and manufactured metals and gems that can be given away or sold to fulfill their original purpose or reused by an artisan to make something new. Whether they were mined and processed ethically or not, multiple people's labor has already gone into the crafting of these objects. Simply discarding them when there's nothing wrong with the actual materials is wasteful and necessitates new mining/processing to fill existing demand. I fully understand getting rid of the emotionally-charged things for yourself or if you're helping friends who need some sort of assistance in the process and get that how you dispose of them can sometimes help or hinder the emotional journey. But sometimes the help we provide friends is also helping them with recontextualizing their thoughts and feelings, giving them some different frame of reference against which to consider their situation. If there's not some deep significance to them being disposed of specifically in the ocean and in whole, then having them melted or cut down and reworked into new pieces (for the original owners or not) could be just as cathartic. If there's not some kind of intention that the object never be seen/touched by another human being, then giving them away to someone who can't afford an engagement/wedding ring or selling them and donating the money to a cause that's meaningful to the original owner and knowing that in some way they're actually bringing more joy in the world could be even more rewarding than simply knowing they were tossed in the ocean.

Kati Loux

i agree , dont sell them even for donations unless the individuals who sent them want that

Heath Breneman

I don’t see that burying them in soil would be any different from immersing them in sea water. They’re about as purely earthly as anything can be, they only got pulled out into sunlight for a short time for a human use. There is no harm in returning them to the earth/sea.

DrWex

I would not. Likely they will wash up someplace and some stranger will be confronted with a potentially distressing object. It feels wrong to make this someone else's problem.

Doyle Casey Ray

Some comments say, “do this” or “do that” but what I hear you saying is that you NEED/WANT some symbolic psychic drowning and LOSING of these items. So fucking do it. Film it. Address it. Move on because the world will. The Tribe will still be here.

Jason Haug

Silently throw them one by one into different oceans. Tell no one.

Rebecca Starodub

Have the rings cleansed then go to the courthouse and find someone that needs them. Destroying the negative energy and giving them a new chance to bring joy for others.

DebbieG

Recycle and give them new life. As mentioned above, sell them and donate the proceeds to an appropriate charity. Or have them melted down and create new life and art from old pain. I would not throw them into the sea. Blink blink. 💕

Phil Parkman

art is art - the meaning is the same if you throw environmentally safe facsimiles in your video - and convert the actual rings into cash.

JesValentine

All of my ocean thoughts aside (I don’t think it’s littering but I would be worried an animal might swallow), if you’re worried about ppl trying to cancel you for it then they probably will try to. Cancel culture is insane right now and if we are already hesitant about it it’s probably best to err on the side of caution. Just my thoughts

Xander Hartman

I vote toss em. Very cathartic and pretty. Just a little more metal in the ocean. It's not like you're throwing plastic or something.

Howard DiNatale

Adding to ocean litter isnt the best thing though they wouldnt have a huge impact. Melting them down and turning them into a middle finger would be a cooler video.

Lorelei Rivers

It feels like inappropriate littering to me. I like the idea of melting them down.

Heath Breneman

I strongly dislike the “sell them” option; stomach turning. The monetary value of a thing is its least pertinent attribute, and they were given to you for disposal, not donation or some other economic transaction.

Ria

They aren’t my rings but if they were I would want them far away and the 8 rings won’t do much harm. So i would say throw them.

Clyde Johnson

My immediate feeling is meltdown/repurpose or cleanse/regift sounds more in tune. The chuck-age may not be littering but it does resonate less.

Smashy Baren

I think giving them to someone to melt down and make something new will be a stronger artistic statement. It's an exorcism through fire and what comes out is something that wasn't there before.

Mark Matteson

If you said you’d do it, you should do it.

Andrea Hasenberger

I threw my wedding ring into the Danube and it was immensly freeing and healing. From the littering point of view I can't see a problem. They are metal, came from the earth, go back to the earth. I like the idea of melting and transforming them into something new also

Livvy C

I'm a jeweller's daughter so take this however you please... The thing about jewelry is that it's essentially still life that we attribute a lot of meaning to. I don't know when or why we decided that jewelry held so much emotional responsibility, but here we are. For many, jewelry is the only heirloom of value they can pass on to the next generation (that's certainly the case for me), so it isn't even about the inherent worth of the jewels but about the concept of worth being embodied by a shiny piece of metal. Sometimes it's also the story that's attached to it, and stories of love are so often carbonized in jewelry. So with that in mind, who is this jewelry you're referring to valuable to? What part of it is valuable? Because I feel like there's a good chance that value might mean something to someone else, even if the value it once had for you or whoever has passed. If the metal or gems are worth a lot, monetarily, to someone who's not wealthy, gift the jewelry to them. I don't know how that transaction would work, but there must be a way. If the pieces themselves would have a lot of sentimental value to your circle of loved ones, gift it to them. Tell them the story of the jewel, or not, whatever works best for the situation. More than anything: encourage them to build a new story for the jewels. Because no matter how tainted you might think the jewelry is, it's not. Jewelry is not a living thing; the story around it is. To that end, you can lie about the jewelry's origins (a tradition that's older than tossing jewelry into the ocean). And if that helps, then lie, because more than anything, jewelry is meant to be passed on. Its purpose is to live through history while its own history evolves and twists into something new. Think of all the jewel artefacts we've found over centuries; those stories were started fresh the minute the jewels were unearthed because we knew nothing about the original owners. Does it really matter what the story of that jewelry is right now? Will it matter a century from now? Five centuries from now? I get the need to purge and to throw something so far away that it has almost zero chance of making its way back to you. But it's not the ocean's fault that humans pump so much meaning into pieces of metal and gems, and somehow, sealife will now have to deal with the consequences of some random human's big feelings. Lots of sealife is small enough to get tangled in rings, and some metals are unforgiving once they hit salt water. It would be wasteful in more ways than one. Sure, there's a lot of jewelry already in the ocean, but that's not a good reason to add more. Instead, find another way to pay that jewelry forward, and if you're really looking to ritualize your purge, write down what the jewelry meant to you, write the story of that jewelry, then burn the paper you write it all down on and wish it well.

Elaine Wilson

If the people who sent them were specifically expecting them to be chucked into the ocean, either do that or clear doing something else with the owners. I think making art with them—or donating them—might be kinder to the earth. Wouldn’t worry about the legality of littering, only the morality.

Drag Queen Jesus

I hate to think transactionally but I think you should sell them and give the money away. They’ll be just as gone to you and you’ll ease someone else’s suffering.

Erin Jones

Posted on the socials, but will say again here: if the stones can be removed and the metal melted down and sold, then donating the moneys to charity would be nice. I think it would also be poetic to get footage of the metal being engulfed in fire, and possibly of any stones being destroyed and turned into dust that can be scattered as sand.

Paul Willett

Do it. This is several dozen orders of magnitude less than any of thousands of other things (natural and human waste) going into the ocean every day. Have we REALLY gotten so petty that this needs to be a thing?

Theresa Jarosz Alberti

I'd say donate them somewhere, to an organization that takes "things" and let them live on elsewhere in the world. I'm a part of a local Buy Nothing group, and I love the idea that my junk is someone else's treasure and it will keep it out of the landfill (or ocean) for awhile. Maybe do some smudging or incense before donating as a meaningful ritual to release them.

Maya Gottfried

At first, this didn't strike me as problematic BUT now that you mention it... rings are exactly the kind of shiny things that animals mistake for food. One of these (or all of them) could actually kill animals in the water. It's not just a matter of them sitting in the ocean, never to be swallowed up by nature. They could actually take the life of a sea creature or bird.

Marie

I say do it! Just make sure it’s not possible to triangulate your position from the footage so divers don’t go looking.

Michael Murphy

What if you just make a video with Ash all blinged out, ice grilled, stacking cheddars forever? Then earn royalties off of that video, and then sell it all and donate to charity.

neely

love you. messaged on Instagram, but I 1. love the ritual. 2. consider how much you could get from it and donate it to a relief fund. 3. someone suggested melting it down and reselling and donating. I like 3 a lot bc of the parallel in my head between melting the bands and tossing them into the sea.

Paul Giffney

Give them new life - focus on them having new beginnings - donate to a charity/jeweller to do something else with them - melt them all into one big 'art' thing and then auction it - gift it - hide it - turn it into a treasure hunt in a book and raise money for charities... If you just want to get rid quickly due to emotional attachment, say you will put them, in a box, in a park, at midnight online.

Allyson Salisbury

100% agree. I'm slightly less bithered by the littering than by the waste of precious metals and gems that a lot of resources went into extracting.

Simon Hoerder

I don't know if they can do any damage in the ocean (lots of metal does get washed into the ocean naturally but I can imagine jewellery might cause issues if a fish eats it) but I do know that the way metals and precious stones are being mined is massively polluting. Even if it's just a small amount in the grand scheme of things, recycling the jewellery would be preferable, I think. If you have a way to make your art without actually chucking them into an ocean I'd prefer that.

marci🦇

spy pond/walden pond is my 2¢

David Hartley

I am with the recycle/donate/gift/etc sort of things. We already litter the oceans (and land & air) too much already.

Mika Antonia

I don't see why anyone would complain about your depositing into the ocean substances that, however artistically labored over, originally came out of the earth (metal, minerals). But I bet some people would figure out a reason anyway, especially if you filmed yourself doing it & posted the film anywhere—so you could just not make the record of it public (though I'd personally like to see it). The artists who devoted significant thought & physical effort to making those rings might not be enthused about such a fate for them (though maybe some would be). Personally, I think it would be cooler to film yourself melting down the metal & saving the stones (which obviously the artists might not like either) & giving them a new meaningful life somehow. Or just give the rings to those who would really treasure them? But, at least from a littering perspective, throwing them into the sea seems unexceptionable to me.

marci🦇

you could put them in a glass jar first i guess 🤷🏻‍♀️

James G Watt

You can burn diamonds, in pure oxygen. Take some professional advice though. I'd feel bad if I were responsable for exploding my favourite musician.

Heather at Highway Mind

Nope. The tiny thing / giant maw sense of “just this once” is a component of how we end up with trash islands.

marci🦇

also get yer butt to honk festival today/tomorrow 💜

Maggie McNally

Please do not put in ocean. Repurpose the items and make into art to sell & donate if you have neither heart or mind for the art piece then give to someone who does. 💖

Celia Nolan

Recycled gold and gemstones releases their form & history and gives them a chance to bring beauty & love to other lives. Maybe a Catbird NYC collab?

Aleta

It’s such a romantic notion, throwing something into the ocean to feel it is truly and forever gone. But odds are high that some living creature would be harmed. The first image that came to my mind was a fish having to permanently wear the ring and grow around it. That seems pretty awful. The point is, as I recall, that things were sent to be burned. I think the choice most in line with that is melting them down.

Michelle CB

The people/relationships were problematic/painful, and the rings are just rings. They could cleansed energetically and donated so an organisation could benefit by selling them. But, if you committed to chucking then maybe that’s what needs to happen. Grief’s a bastard and sometimes shit just needs to get chucked.

Kamil Dzielinski

It’s littering. But It’s also art. So the intent matters a lot. Personally I believe that the art is more important than some relatively harmless littering.

James G Watt

Given .. well, you know, blood diamonds, the cultural shift that could result in trash islands made from diamond jewellery would be quite a thing :) Sort of want to see it.

Joe DeRosa

Yeah. I don’t love the idea of some marine life swallowing and dying from something like this. I agree with those who suggest making something of these that will draw attention, and possibly even raise support for a cause that is important to you.

Kai Taylor

There's a way to turn it into money through making them into art and auctioning to donate proceeds. That seems like the right balance.

Steohen Secrot

I love the idea, and the art. Personally don’t have a problem with it. Then I thought back to a family story. My grandfather (who raised me) had passed and we were having a family dinner with his brother in law. His kids were there, and my grandma. His memory was starting to go. He asked to see my grandma’s ring. Then he surprised everyone but my grandma. He had bought a ring to give to his sweetheart while he was serving in Korea. She said no, but he held onto the ring. My grandfather was about to propose to my grandma, and his brother in law offered the stone. 60 years of marital bliss from a “reused” ring. Whatever pain was in those rings can be brought anew with some love. Maybe a mix of both? Art and giving the rings a new chance at happiness?

Wordsmith Lynn

Now you’ve mentioned it, I too have unhappy visions of fish swallowing them and that’s not good. But I think melting them down is going to get hugely complicated and/or expensive. Selling them & donating the cash to charity is probably the least difficult option. Although—creating some sort of found art project out of them (with an accompanying song full of appropriate angry/cleansing lyrics) could work too. If you have a record of who sent what, could your team try to message everyone concerned, explain the environmental concerns, and ask what their preferences are?

Beth

I don’t personally like the idea of throwing something else into the ocean that doesn’t belong. Another person who commented suggested taking the rings and having them melted down by a jeweler to sell and donating to a women’s shelter. I thought that if this was in my control I would do the whole jeweler/selling situation and donate whatever came of it to RAIIN.org

Krissy Jarvis

It’s sad that the damage done to the ocean by capitalist greed and disregard for the natural world makes it so we can’t just have an artistic ritual offering with the ocean. I imagine them being crushed into dust & foil by a hydraulic press (like a mechanic would have). I know whatever you create with them will be beautiful. ♥️

angela b

Tough one. It is littering for sure, but with a biodegradable material? My main concern about this when you first mentioned it was disposing of diamonds that were likely mined by unwilling participants and gold, one of our most precious metals. I just think it's sad to dispose of materials that were likely hard to source. I feel like using them for another kind of art or selling them for capital for a good cause or something would be more ethical. That said, I wouldn't cancel you for it. People symbolically burn and toss things like this all the time and the therapeutic benefits are certainly a consideration. I say meditate on it. Ask the jewels what they want. 💓

EmVT

Throwing them in the ocean doesn't feel like the right method. Maybe take photos of them and burn the photos, write a song about them, and call them purified. After you "eat the sins" of the rings you could decide what to do with their physical existence. I trust you! (they're not mine tho) 🩷

Laura Morland

Yes, I agree, and so well put! It's a waste to dispose of materials that were likely hard to source.

Stephen Montagna

Add my vote to the "no" column; appreciate the conversation here; I also think it opens the door to an even richer artistic opportunity – I hope that whatever avenue you end up taking you use it to explore themes about loss/letting go/moving on –> that everything is interconnected and any small thing that happens to us has ripple effects across others lives and generations; how do we individually mourn and set ourselves free from what's happened to us while still honoring our obligation to each other? This conversation reminds me of the Native American Indian-Iroquois saying “In our every deliberation, we must consider the impact of our decisions on the next seven generations.”

Laura Morland

I'm thinking of some poor young man from a poor neighborhood in Central or South America who would love to give his fiancé a beautiful ring. If you truly want to be rid of any karmic energy, perform a ceremony, and then mail them to an organization South of the border... perhaps with no return address on the envelope. You will be gratified thinking that someone who could normally never afford a nice ring can wear them1 And they will be free of the "bad karma," because they'll have no knowledge of the sender/giver.

Christina M

I wouldn’t toss anything like that into the ocean. Animals can be harmed. We have no idea how many are able to swallow or get stuck in them. You are lovely.

Dea

Perhaps someone already made this suggestion in the comments and I just haven't seen it yet, but...what of a fountain? The sort people throw coins into for good luck (or other ritualistic purposes) and said coins are then gathered up, cleaned (cleansed), blessed, and used for good (charity)? I am thinking of e.g. the Trevi Fountain? Then you have the purge aspect...the cleansing-by-water aspect...the spectacle (if you film it)...the ritual...the paying it forward to charity? Wouldn't be the first time an engagement/wedding ring was thus depurated and donated, methinks. Might even be jewellers who work with the churches or public entities who own the rights to their fountain riches, for just this purpose. Am not necessarily suggesting a trip to Rome but some more local fountain equivalent...

Rebecca Potylycki

I assume you've come to your decision. I've read a number, a good number of the responses from our community, and I agree after reading them. Actually that the ocean doesn't feel right. Do you know anyone who has a crucible - a literal crucible who could melt them? It would make for pretty fascinating footage. I don't know if it would fit with what you're working with.

Scott Fornwall

All materials gathered from the Earth, so putting it back can't be littering. Harming animals? Doubt it...think of all the actual dangerous items put into the ocean every day...like plastics. You could argue endlessly about this, either way.

Len Tower Jr.

Kai: Takes a lot more Team AFP time. Amanda's choice whether to add that overhead to further her art.

Len Tower Jr.

Mika: Small shiny objects are very likely to be eaten, Quite possibly killing the eater. -Len

Rebecca Potylycki

I apologize. I meant a crucible as in a "literal Jeweler's crucible." Re-reading, I realized saying "a literal crucible" could mean a lot of different things. Amanda, my biggest thought of connection was along the line of destroying the items from your Patreons in the great fire. 🖤😘 Taking precious metals sending them back to their simplest state by melting. Taking away their form and function. Perhaps like burying something dead or at least dismantling something that was given for the specific purpose of documented destruction? Items for which the original & true meaning has been adulterated for the owner. Does any of that make sense to anyone here? (I've been pretty sick for a few days and slow To read all posts and comments & many things are just bouncing off the walls of my own mind. Haven't had a ton of outside discourse recently... lulz). F**k me though, I really love our community here. 🤍🤍🤍

Margaret Motheral

I don't believe they will harm the ocean. Under water nuke bombs hurt the ocean-- Make a song to heal the ocean and sell that song and use that money to loving the ocean in some way. OUR MOTHER OUR OCEAN OUR FISH OUR FOOD OUR HUNGRY BABIES OUR MOTHER OUR OCEAN OUR FOOD OUR HUNGRY BABIES OUR HAPPINESS OUR LIFE OUR SPARKLE IN OUR SOUL LIKE A DIAMOND LIKE SILVER LIKE GOLD and DIAMONDS ON THE WAVES THAT COME TO US EVERYDAY_I THROW MY DIAMONDS BACK TO YOU. _

James G Watt

The counter argument being, if you re-sell the diamonds you are perpetuating the market that makes them so valuable that people get exploited to obtain more of them. I had this dilema years ago when I made jewellery and someone gave me a quantity of ivory. This was before it became illegal to use uncertificated ivory. It was very old ivory though. The argument went, use and sell it, so new ivory isn't sought, or do not use it so you do not participate in and help to perpetuate the market. It went in a drawer and eventually in the bin.

Cindi Conti

Cleansing them in the ocean, yes. Melting the metal to alchemize and transform them maybe. But I agree about donating them to a non profit to support flood victims or others in need.

Scott Meekins

Do what sets you free. Carry no cumbersome troubles or bad memories on your shoulders. Take with you only the learning experiences. Scars may still exist, but their pain will be long vanquished. In time, nothing will hurt anymore. This is a wonderful community!

Samuel Burns

I say sell them on and donate the money to a good cause. Gone is gone from the lives of the people that sent them to you

Eve

Not advice, just a little story.I did this with my wedding ring, though not intentionally. I kept wearing it for a couple of years after my divorce, just not on my wedding ring finger. I just couldn't get used to not having something on my hand. I spent a month in Nicaragua in early 2023 and swam in the ocean every sunrise and sunset. One sunset I felt like the ocean was tugging on the ring, like it wanted it. It felt persistent, and I hadn't felt it before. So I slipped the ring off and let it wash away in the waves. It was a tiny silver thing, not valuable (we'd spend $6 on it at the farmers' market).

Bay Le Sage

Darling Amanda, If even part of your brain is going "littering in the ocean" I would suggest giving all those bits and pieces to a talented jeweler to make into something lovely for yourself or someone you love. Transform ALL THE THINGS into something beautiful and meaningful for you or them now. Cleanse with fire.

Tracie Winslow

When I got divorced, I put the green sapphire from my engagement ring into a pendant with black diamonds. I call it my Life Choices necklace. It reminds me to make good choices, especially about men.

Kathryn Drew

After reading a few of the comments i want to direct people to the Albatross documentary movie. It shows albatross dying from vast amounts of plastic they ingested ... prob wouldn't happen with the rings since they would sink, however, the movie is so profound because as well as the death, it shows unbelievably close footage of the entire life cycle of the albatross and is really beautiful and moving. And free to watch. www.albatrossthefilm.com