Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello my loves.

I meant to write today and there’s plenty of business to tend to (esp regarding upcoming Boston events) but


Late night question.

I was just writing a text to a musician friend, and I stopped in my tracks because I realized something really weird.

I was texting her to see if she’d give me some dirt/feedback/a reference for a collaborator (let’s call them “X”) that I’m thinking of hiring.

I was in the middle of typing “I heard that you’re working with (collaborator X)”. Then I realized this wasn’t quite true: I KNOW she works with Collaborator X because it says so on Collaborator X’s website, and also, I was writing the text precisely because my management was like: Collaborator X works with your friend.

So I deleted what I’d written, and I re-typed “I saw that you’re working with Collaborator X.”

Then I stared at what I’d written and was really confused for a split second.

Apparently “I heard” means: I got some information, but it is not verifiable.

Whereas “I saw” means: I got some information, and it’s seemingly true.

This is so weird.

Do we really mean to say that we trust our eye-information more than our ear-information?

As a musician, I’m feeling sort of offended. Like: don’t trust those sounds, people. Believe the painters.

WHAT DOES THIS ALL EVEN MEAN? Please tell me.

It’s also 2 am and I’m perimenoupausal and I can’t sleep so there’s that.


I love you all so very much.

Xxx A

Files

Previews only

Comments

Juliet Andrien

seeing is believing ¯⁠\⁠(⁠°⁠_⁠o⁠)⁠/⁠¯

Mary Alice Fraughton

Sight is (most of) our most relied upon sense, though. If you asked my dog she’d probably tell you not to believe anything unless you smelled it for yourself.

Drag Queen Jesus

Well it depends on the situation dear. If one is detecting laugh-sharts we should actually trust what we smell more so than what we see or even hear.

Hilary

No answers but strangely I had exactly this conversation (heard versus saw) with my partner on the weekend. I hear you.

Juliet Andrien

but it's the sweet sound of amazing grace that facilitated the return of the narrator's sight, so.

Genevieve Smith

To me, “I heard” when conveying info feels like it leans in rumor mill or gossip lane, whereas “I saw” implies you saw the info somewhere in a reliable place. There are SCADS of holes in this theory but it still rings true for me.

Elyte Blansjaar

I’d probably play it safe and say something outright, like ‘so what’s it like working with x?’ And be damned the formality!

Chicca

Oh Amanda… I can’t answer which is true or more valid (why one sense should be more trusted than another, I trust an artist no matter what their art is!), but I feel your perimenopausal pain. And for that I send you the biggest sister hug ♥️

Gabrielle Shearer

I can't sleep either and now that I've heard about this will have to lie here pondering.

Wayne Francis

We don't trust our ears because they hear lies. Our eyes can see through lies (or one would hope!) and so we see clearly but hear the words we want to hear. Frankly it's believe anyone over me... I've been seeing today's in my head since I could tell people about then and probably before. (Not literal ghost. Wrote my first poem when my dad was driving me home from the bar at 3)

James from Wellington

I would guess it's derived from the idea the to hear = you were told, and to see = you saw the event

Lynnise

Old school it and call her periodt.

Gudrun

But when I say „I hear you“ vs „I see you“? …. Still it seems that „see you“ goes deeper, or what?

Ingrid de Beus

All of our senses are fibbing to us, gently in the dark. We choose what to lean on. Follow your nose. Also, regarding the specifics, you can use the passive voice to get around the dilemma, e.g. "Collaborator X's website mentions that you worked with you. Can you share any details?"

Alison Waddy

I think it's just a piece of language evolution. You say "I Heard a rumor" or "a little bird told me". Or like how you play the telephone game and the words and meaning get changed as they pass through mouths and ears and mouths and what you're hearing might be true or it might be changed. It's more fluid than sight but not necessarily any less true or certain

Deniz Bevan

Guess what? In Turkish, there's a whole verb tense for this! If you say "something something [verb]muş" it means you found out about it from someone and didn't see or hear it with your own eyes 🤗 So you could be convoluted and polite and say "it appears that you are collaborating with X" and in Turkish it would be one word (in the Sie form not the Du form). Languages are so cool ❤️

Dea

Yes. In English, heard = conjecture/gossip. Saw = has been witnessed/confirmed. As if seeing is believing. Yet think about the agreement of "hear hear". Not "see see". Language is a slippery eel of a thing. I'd be more inclined to believe a voice before a vision, myself:)

Rhiannon Marshall

In the industry you are in, I can understand that seeing in writing that someone has worked on someone else's project might not always mean they were ever in the same room together - a producer may have had X in the room at a later date to add to Y's track, either as an additional element they felt would be good or because X wasn't avaliable at the original point of recording - so you're right not to assume that there has been a collaboration in the traditional sense of things. 'Seen', therefore, is a safer statement than 'heard'. Also, while I'd not trade as I'd not want anyone else to be in my shoes, I'd take your perimenopausal insomnia over my persistent 'so itchy you want to rip your skin off' perimenopausal heat rashes any day *sigh*... The perils of womanhood 🙄

Dea

In utero, we hear before we see. And as infants, we follow our Mother's voice, not her image. Sound is more primal, vision more learned, perhaps hence the distinction between believing what we 'witness', rather than what we 'hear' -?

Gerry Lipnowski

I think we have more confidence in things we control…and we definitely have more control over seeing than hearing. You can go into a room and decide what to look at. You can even close your eyes. But you can’t (literally anyway) close your ears. If there’s a sound in a room, you’ll hear it, whether you want to or not. And it’s sometimes difficult to identify a sound. I had a friend who had a baby and cat that made virtually the same sound when they were vying for attention. I had to look to see which one it was….So, the sound was less trustworthy I guess? My 2:30 a.m. theory that likely will make no sense to me when I wake up tomorrow…

Jamy Ian Swiss

“I heard” might be cowardice, it could be disingenuous. But I prefer to think of it as a kindness of sorts. Instead of trapping the other person with “I saw” — which is to say, I KNOW — you are giving them to option, in fact the invitation, to say otherwise, to modify, to clarify, to offer their point of view and what they need their perspective to be. I prefer “I heard…”. Unless it’s an antagonistic negotiation in which it’s my intent to go in strong from the start.

Gabrielle Shearer

Ok but is it as simple as see/true and hear/doubtfhearwhen we report hearing something we see, might it signify a more emotional response? If I read of something that moves me, do I say "I saw that..." or "I heard that..." Will keep pondering

Smashy Baren

I think it's more that "I heard that..." refers to second hand information while "I saw" is a first hand account. Of course, "I heard..." Can also refer to first hand accounts like "I heard the audience sing the end of Trout Heart Replica like a choir." Of course, saying "I heard that..." Also acts as a slightly indirect means to get more details about a situation versus "I saw". I don't know if i have a point here but language is fuckin weird.

Makyla

My sense is…

Katrina Love

"A picture is worth a thousand words". *Seeing* that she worked with someone means it's out there and public... documented so to speak. *Hearing* someone did something could be a falsehood from anyone with a grudge, with ulterior motives, trying to spread misinformation/rumours. Hearing could be gossip; seeing could not.

amandapalmer

Someone on socials (I also posted a shorter version of this there) mentioned something about object permanence. That you can SEE something a second time and verify it. But you cannot re-hear something. Interesting.

Ariel

I love how this is quite literally talking about the art of asking, how to phrase that art, checking to see if the words we use are the right words to hear the message. I wonder if prioritizing sight over sound is a reflection of our cultures obsession with believing our own lived experiance over the experience we hear of others. I have been thinking a lot lately about how often we think of our experiance is more true than what we hear from others, without accounting for the vast amount of experiances and people in the world, and the nuance that carries.

Philipp Windgassen

"I had to see it with my own eyes"... It's a fact that visual information is by far the most intense and most complex sensory information we absorb. Half of our brain capacity is used for processing visual information. What we hear is much more subject to interpretation than what we see...

Clair Rook

Music is seeing with the heart, if I can express it that way? Seeing is believing vs feeling is believing. We see and it provokes feelings in us, meaning. And so does hearing. Seeing is physical stuff, hearing is ethereal stuff. Thing is, what we feel will always be more powerful than what we see, even if seeing is considered the ultimate evidence of truth, whether we feel agreement with what we see or not. Nothing exists without first being felt. Nothing can be seen until it is first perceived, and it’s first perceived and exists in the mind and in the HEART, which is then acted upon and becomes ‘real’ in the world of matter. So, don’t feel offended, there’s no need. I can’t ‘see’ the Ukulele Song or ‘see’ In My Mind, but I know how I FEEL when I’m singing my heart out to them…and that’s REAL ❤️ xx

Mary Alice Fraughton

I wonder if that’s just an imaginary distinction, though? Our eyes interrupt and interpret the light reflected or produced by the thing we’re “seeing.” If we want to see it again, we’re interrupting different/new light. So are we really seeing the same thing again?

Francesca Reed

Just speaking quite literally, if no one told you personally about the collab in words that you took in with your own ears, then you didn’t actually “hear” it, whereas you did indeed “see” it in print.

Jacqueline Goulbourne

Protestant culture, maybe? The primacy of the post-Caxton, post-Reformation of written word over earlier oral transmission? A permanent downgrading of priests and the mass and encouraged primacy of ‘finding out for yourself’ through vernacular Bible translations.

Elaine Wilson

In this day and age, "I heard" means "my friend/acquaintance told me," and "I read" means "I saw it on the internet." Depending on who you're talking to, there are several possibilities: 1. Both the friend/acquaintance and the online source are trustworthy, fact-based sources. 2. What the person heard is probably crap, and what the person read is probably from a crappy biased source. 3. What the person heard is probably crap, BUT what the person read probably came from an honest-to-god truth-telling publication. 4. Other way around (rare). I put a LOT more stock in "I read," because "I heard" just screams MAGA at me. "Well, I don't care what you read in your fake news/liberal media/etc. because my friend said etc." It's actually something that drives me BANANAS. Everyone has sources, and it feels like only half of us give a damn what those sources are and whether we should really trust them. Half of us think "research" means double-checking what you heard on a site that will always agree with you! The fact you're even asking the question is good. (In this particular case I'd say "Collaborator X says on his website he worked with you. Anything you can tell me?" Simple and TRUE.)

Scarlette Baccini

"Believe half of what you see, and none of what you hear"

Ryan Stuck

Well, from a scientific perspective, neither sensory input is reliable. So you can just safely assume that what you saw and what you heard are equally flawed, despite what language may imply. Human recall of almost anything is riddled with problems. Except maybe smell. We should change our phrases to emphasize smell.

Ruth

Eye information is generally our own experience (I saw you do this.)... ear information is frequently secondhand (Robin told me that they saw you do this).

Tini

Although I'm on the "hearing second Hand of xy" Team here (vs f.e. "I heard the explosion" = same Level of Truth as "seeing the crash" ), as a musician myself, it is soo interesting to think about the different validation of Sound vs sight I (seem to) have a Form of aphantasia, meaning that I don't really have an "inner picture" in my mind when I think about something (& thus also struggle with visual memory & imagination) - but f.e my sound-memory of song-melodies, f.e., is amazing! (..not for lyrics though, again - written words are more like pictures, obviously.. until I sang them often enough to have memorized the sound) So, "visuals" have a bit of a lesser meaning for me, Personally, then it seems to be for (most of) other people. That is what I wanted to point out -- Humans are very visual creatures, until (because of some conditions f.e) they are not, I guess

Samir Malak

Over the summer, you had mentioned that every musician has a limited number of songs in them, and, at the time, I was listening to a lot of Larkin Poe, but had never seen them perform, and I found that I could *see* them at the Cambridge Folk Festival and I did. While I love their music and have even watched a few of their performances on YouTube, nothing compared to seeing them perform live. I saw you live at the Fringe Festival in Edinburgh many years ago and, while I had heard you before, that night, I became a fan, after *seeing* you perform. Thanks for all you do, hope this helps with the “as a musician” reaction to the observations around hearing and seeing.

Kimja Cobsen

2am, universally recognised as the magical hour of profound insight I also think it is a language thing, but there’s poetry in semantics too

Jana

This. If Amanda saw them actually collaborating, we would not need to go through any of this. But we are sorting out whether she only heard or only read abut the collaboration from one of the collaborators and not the other. For some reason, this kind of thing seems to require verification with the other collaborator for us to believe that it was real?

Debz michaela

This is my perimenopausal brain too!! 🤣 I think the rationale behind it is back to the days before the written word, when all knowledge was passed down verbally and inevitably would be altered, amended and such therefore not credible to the original, whereas what you saw with your eyes was as definite as your brain could control. I see it now, so it is there. However, this was loooong before the days of photoshop, AI, and all of that malarkey where we cannot trust our eyes anymore. So.. new language time??! 🤣💜

Daisee

Pictures or it didn't happen?

EmVT

Sounds like a great question for "A Way With Words" on NPR! As usual I think context matters, there are times when I would say "I heard you won X, that's great!" and I'm not asking for verification, I'm taking it as true. That said, "hearsay" and "saw it with my own eyes" does seem to clearly be biased. "I heard" can be taken as true though. You could say "I understand you work with x" without implicating any specific senses. It's more of a conversation starter than casting doubt on the facts of it, more of a salutation. 330am, time for some carrot cake. 🍰😃

Drea

OK because i love these kinds of questions : - if you've heard, the implication is that someone told you, so it's second-hand information you might want to verify. - if you've seen, it implies you have first-hand information (which is why reading it on a CV is not exactly a clear-cut case). It's the whole not believing without seeing it with your own eyes thing. - BUT IF you've heard first-hand, you'd say "I heard you working with X," not "I heard you're working with X," in which case you're not expressing any doubt as to the reality of it. No?

Sadie

Poincare made the point (I think in Science and Hypothesis) that while we have instruments to render precision, ultimately it's the act of observation that is the fact observed. Now, today I take measurements en mass aided by computation, and those may be aggregated, however ultimately it's still my observation that matters. Hearing has been my first input for experiments with a neutron detector that happens to have audible output. Your point about smell is a good one :-).

Simon Hoerder

Exactly my reaction. If you say “I hear the bell” and “I see the bell” there’s no qualitative difference. If you say “I see on Xs webpage that X list you as collaborator” then there’s no qualitative difference from “I heard from X that you’re collaborating”. One caveat though. Often we tend to remove those additional tidbits of information and just say “I heard” for 2nd hand information and “I see” for information that’s either first hand or at least 2nd hand backed up by multiple sources. There’s a certain laziness and implicit understanding in those shortened phrases; that does seem to somewhat prefer sight over sound but maybe I’m reading too much into that.

Kthonis

I think "I've heard" implies you've heard from another human- you haven't verified with your own senses, you don't philosophically and empirically *know*. You _can_ also use "I saw" to indicate that you observed something but aren't certain of it's interpretation or absolute truth, so there's that. I think it's simply a situation where English overloads it's terminology- like saying sorry as an apology versus an expression of sorrow. It's a little rough sometimes when you like precision, but our language is so beautiful partially because it's a flexible mutt, I think.

Kthonis

Well, I do always know the puppy pooped in the kitchen when I smell it, so this tracks.

Sadie

Amanda, I think you're mixing metaphor with how we use language to report experience? Already noted by others.. "I heard" often refers to secondhand, and we would often express it that way even if the knowledge had come via reading.

Sadie

p.s. at your 2 am, I was going back to sleep in Giverney after an excursion to play under the stars.

Nicole Davies

I suspect the problem here is patriarchy. I just read about how gossip was a good thing before men decided women having information and sharing ideas were bad for them. So the stigma of gossip being bad started. It also led to women (wives) being more isolated and kept in the home. “ gossip was originally tied to an empowered idea of women, before it shifted to its current association with wayward morality and shame.” Now this part I have no facts on but I suspect since women previously shared ideas and information through positive gossip the stigma of “I heard” being less reliable probably developed from the anti gossip movement. 🤷‍♀️ https://www.thegoodtrade.com/features/benefits-of-gossip/

Michael Hargreave Mawson

It isn't anything to do with sound being unreliable; it is to do with hearsay being unreliable when compared to the evidence of your own eyes.

Beth

I had a comment and then I read everybody’s very intelligent and not 2:30 in the morning brains coming up with really wonderful observations and facts. I just sort of thought of seeing is believing and knowing something from the horse’s mouth. Those interesting phrases don’t really apply to art for me. Seeing or hearing doesn’t make one form of art better. We do know that hearing things straight from the originating person is wise and discerning, otherwise it’s hearsay or gossip or second had knowledge. Seeing something written down can be a forgery or fake news or it can be a llegal document. I think all art is really bringing truth and a story so if we are speaking about painters or musicians being better or worse than each other, being more true or more false than the other, then I would just have to say that art is beautiful and both have their appeal. If you’re looking for a true fact, seeing and hearing from a direct source are what belief is based. But literally still perimenopausal(me) and closer to three in the morning that I would like it to be as I have shit to do in the (later)morning. I have no idea if what I said made any sense at all. If there is any nuggetof anything please take it, it’s yours

Marija Milisavljević Grdinić

I feel that we really do tend to believe our eyes more than our ears, which is so wrong. In fact, I was shocked to find out during my studies that visual hallucinations are not that big a deal - apparently anyone can have those when tired, distressed, sick, etc. However, auditory hallucinations are considered an important symptom of schizophrenia and some other serious diseases and conditions as they don't occur just because your brain is having a slight hiccup. For me, this means that we should actually trust our ears more - eyes are those more easily deceived. And yet, there is something about our eyesight that makes it the dominant sense for many people.

Marija Milisavljević Grdinić

Yes but in this case I see on Xs webpage does not make it true. X could lie. As could the person reporting that X and Y are collaborating. I mean, you are not wrong, but there is a whole network of assumptions that we make when we choose what to believe and whom to trust.

Amanda Junay

Its uncanny how relevant this is to my life right now. I am currently at the center of some local drama between vendors (all of which are moms around my age) And it's turned into a lot of he said, she said, "but did you see?" As the ringleader to all the gossip and tension stirs the pot and slanders my name and business. Simply because she's jealous, and apparently we are back in HS?? So as I now block folks, establish my boundaries, and am keeping quiet and thriving in the silence as these caddy women tear me down and others with them. And as I try to warn others NOT to work with this group, especially the woman in charge of events and, the gossip as well. I'm having to produce screen shots and receipts because if I say "I heard you dragging my name and saying I steal art." No on believes me. When I produce texts, posts, messages of the slander suddenly folks believe me. Why is it as this vicious gossip is spread, and my business and reputation tarnished as it's just barely began..why is it my word can't be trusted about what I hear? What i KNOW is being said? Why do I have to produce receipts in order for it to be true?? Its honestly exhausting and the amount of energy I have to put into clearing my name and rep? Ain't worth it. So I block, I let these women gossip. I keep making art. And teaching journaling/soundbowl workshops. And I'll continue to believe what I see AND hear

Jenetic

As someone with audio processing issues on occasion, I do generally trust the evidence I can see much more than the things I hear. It's just more easily verifiable.

Rebecca McFarland

As a musician, I am more likely to believe things I hear but you are right about the societal implied accuracy.

AmarA * jk

As a painter I feel strangely proud to apparently be the purveyor of verified truth.

Tamara

I hear means I received the information from someone else; I saw denotes no other people in this message. Reliability is an outside judgement -- perhaps more people means less reliable? Anyway, I have a doctor's appointment in a few minutes and then my daughter and I are evacuating from the path of Milton, from Florida to Georgia. Have plenty of thoughts this morning!

Christine Leov-Lealand

True true: hearing is ‘hearsay’ and not verifiable evidence but ‘eyewitness testimony’ is said by a person who saw it. Legally it’s definitely a thing.

James G Watt

I guess "I saw" implies first hand knowledge whilst "I hear" implies second hand knowledge. Not sure why it does but that's how it strikes me. What would "I read" imply? if it's any consolation, a while back you were discussing the merits of reading your book verses listening. I read an article that suggests listening to audio books makes the listener more inclined to trust and believe the author. So they may say "I'll believe it when I see it with my own eyes", but we believe our ears over what we read.

Rebecca Potylycki

I believe it's all about the sources of information one gathers, think "truth social" vs. the Guardian? And audibly it's the same thing... Your management is hopefully a good reliable source of information. What if you were to pose your question like, "Hey friend! Are you still working with 'Individual X' much lately?"

IonaWhale

Painter here 👋 😆 My professional life was genealogy too, so I definitely can say that truth finding is a messy process. To me, art is an invitation to be self reflective. When it comes to others, context and Occam's Razor are my rules of thumb.

Damian Masterson

Saw structurally implies first hand knowledge - “ I am the one who saw it” Heard could be first hand, but allows for mediation in a way saw doesn’t. You can say that I heard from X that Y heard this about Z, but images aren’t transitive in that way. X can tell me about Y, but can’t just show me Y

Nancy Chandler

It's nice to know I'm not the only one up in the middle of the night with the hamster wheel of thoughts going full blast 😂

Len Tower Jr.

1) You saw the info on a websight, so: "I read on Collab X's website, that ..." or "I read on the web, that..." 2) The human brain has many many more neurons devoted to sight than hearing. The eye as well compared to the ear. (Helped us survive better in the niche we evolved in.) The shakedown from that might have creeped into English. 3) If this saw/heard veracity occurs in most languages, it increases the likelihood of the hardware influencing the software. (Forgive me that sloppy comparison. In the brain, the hardware is the software. Opps forgive me a 2nd time, ;-) 4) You might try asking one of those new fangled AI programs (which are not Intelligent, just sophisticated pattern matching, and full of both the Web's knowledge & lies). Or several via one meta-site (with increased privacy): https://duckduckgo.com/?q=DuckDuckGo+AI+Chat Z) Beyond that a deep research dive, I'll leave to those with more interest. Love to all, Len

Len Tower Jr.

More accurately, our senses have evolved to give us the slices of info, that most help us survive & reproduce. Love, Len

Paul Means

To me, 'I heard' implies hearing from a rumor, and 'I saw' implies seeing in print. Which is more trustworthy than the other I believe depends on your personal experiences.

Len Tower Jr.

Nice: object permanence over sound impermanence We are getting a second set of photons from the same object. That's verification. -Len

Len Tower Jr.

I note that live musical performance adds sight (& other senses) into the mix over recordings, -Len

Teresa Toro

Thinking about truth and the senses, it does seem like hearing takes a back seat to sight in all the cliches and idioms. I like connecting the dots -- and you have to see those. The truth can get lost in that infernal game of telephone, which is audible and often untrustworthy. Then again in ancient times some of the most revered were the storytellers, who were charged with learning oral histories word for word and teaching them so precisely because they were that important. You weren't allowed to go forth and do it yourself until your elder was satisfied you could do it. If only we still placed such importance on that, today.

Teresa Toro

To your example, if someone said "I heard" I might question where; the source is less defined. But "I saw" implies a specific source which can be pointed to and either verified, or not. Either way, a fact can be verified. Or you can sidestep this altogether and just ask: "Hi! I was wondering, can I ask you about working with Collaborator X?" I generally go for the direct approach XO

Len Tower Jr.

The apprenticeship that in most cases earns a PhD, has elements of an elder teaching an elder-to-be.

Len Tower Jr.

Just read all the comments to here. Lot's of knowledge amongst the Patrons. Love to all, Len

Larissa Rook

i often say, “a little bird told me” which i assume means “i heard but not sure if it is true”. i imagine snow white singing to birds and i love to anthropomorphize. but if seeing is believing… i might say “i read somewhere”. but honestly i doubt what i read AND see so much on social media. and i overthink everything i write and post. and add menopause to the equation and i just quit and chuck deuces. ✌️

Betsy Cacchione

Don't worry - it's just semantics. I "heard it through the grapevine" is a lot different than I "heard it from you". It's not the "heard" that makes it vaguer than the "saw". It's the implied vagueness of the surrounding phrase. I hear you and I see you.

Zena Darling

In my mind, "I saw" implies first-hand knowledge, and "I heard" implies you got the info second-hand from someone else. This is disregarding what form the information in question was presented (in print, via conversation, etc) in the first place, which of course might affect phrasing and context.

Melanie Johnson-Moxley

I know this phenomenon of having epistemological questions at 2 am! The bias toward vision as the most reliable and informative of unreliable senses has a long history, but it''s an arbitrary bias. We see and hear and feel everything from a limited, contextualizing perspective; no one grasps the true nature of the elephant, even with the eye. If we let go of the notion that objective observation is the only and ever-appropriate approach to knowledge, we can make room for realizing that sometimes, only hearing a familiar song or heartbeat or voice can show us to the truth when we are lost. Sometimes only a touch helps us cut though the bullshit of what we think we see and know. 🌿

Anna

I would say that hearing is ephemeral. Not in the times of speech messages and podcast but back when the usage of this phrases might have been established. As soon as I heard a sentence it is gone. Even if i ask for repetition, that repetition would sound different, at least its tone and probably its words too. Something written remains so i could come back and read it again. It's a bit of a bold move to step in a conversation on linguistic topics in a foreign language, but it's such a captivating question. 😊

Dan O'Hare

I wrote about this very thing in my novel I'm working on:

Dan O'Hare

“I mean, you can’t know that. We can’t know anything. Not really, like not external stuff. Everything outside of your own mind that you are certain of as fact is likely to someday change. You can’t trust it. All you can trust is what you know about yourself. I guess. Maybe. I mean we change too. And trusting your mind is a fool’s errand. So I guess, it’s probably just the base senses that give us real truth.” “You mean you believe what you see?” Jessica scrunched up her nose and closed one eye as she thought about the question. “Emmm… not really. I honestly think sight is the most bullshit sense we have. The one most likely to deceive us. I don’t think we see half of what we think we see, and we don’t see half of what is there. Taste is kinda weak, too.” “Because you smoke too much.” “True. But even if I didn’t, it constantly changes. Hormones, mood, illness, lighting, all those things can affect taste. I believe, I think, at least maybe, scent and touch are real. There, above all other things. That’s where, it’s the only place I can find truth.” “Ummm… What about hearing? Come on, music!” “Oh yeah, well, hearing is the most complex sense we have. There’s no truth in all in what people say, right? Half the time we don’t even know what people are saying, we just assume we know what they are going to say. Most conversations are just pastimes, that’s all. Like all games, like, you know, like now. I guess certainly the sounds that surround us matter, but in the same way we quickly learn to ignore the sounds that are most familiar. Our hearing tends to ignore that which is closest to us, which is, like, really sad. And of course, yes, the best of sound, is undoubtedly, music. But one cannot find truth in music. Music is beyond truth. Truth becomes withered and sick and dies when consumed by the music that matches our soul.”

Megan

I read this when it was posted and I’m still thinking about it! ETA it also makes me think about how even eyewitnesses can be unreliable, right? Weird

Skyeanna Malito

It's personal witnessing vs secondary witnessing. We believe what we personally experience, but something coming from another must be taken with a grain of salt.

Esteban Montemayor

This post reminds me of my American Sign Language professor (one of my fave teachers I ever had) in college from 20 years ago. According to him, in general, when we talk with each other, we mostly derive meaning from another person's eyes, regardless of their body language, volume, tone of voice, or words. I don't recall the rough percentage he mentioned that comprises that "mostly." However, I do remember that it was, for me just learning about it, a shockingly high percentage, like upwards of 80.