Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hi loves.

This is a fun one! I'm rading comments all day, so hit me. You know me. Tell me what you think, always. I've done some wild things with your money, but this one's extra-specially spicy.

So, about two+ weeks ago, I posted (unwittingly), an A.I.-generated image to my Instagram and Facebook pages.

It was this...here's a screenshot...middle on the left.

I didn't know who the source was; it had come in on a text thread from a friend.

I'm that kind of person. I post, and I always try to credit where I can. but if it looks meme-y, I give myself a wide berth.

I loved this image. I loved everything about it.

Lots of people shared it....but I also got a boatload of comments like THIS:

...and many, many people pointed out that this was obviously an AI-generated image.

Because....fingers!

COUNT 'EM.

Check out these comments.

.........

OKAY SO.

Back the truck up.

Remember when - last Easter + Trans Awareness Day - I posted this AI-generated Jesus + Drag Queens Last Supper Image?

People got really up my ass about this one, too. There were a ton of SHAME ON YOU AMANDA PALMER comments. And again, I hadn't known this image was AI-generated. It was just tossed to me in some hilarious What's App thread full of theater queers and I thought it was PERFECT. But....lookit the fingers. It's AI up the wazoo.

I gotta say, I understood the point people were making.

I also saw how much joy the image was bringing.

What to do?? 

Hm.

We are at such an insane tipping point in the conversation around art, music, AI, truth, news, communication...and....EVEYRTHING.

With this Jesus debacle - this was last April, and I was on tour in Nashville - I considered how to respond, and I decided to make some art Lemonade.

Instead of simply apologizing, I decided to commission an ACTUAL artist (a great one, and a trans one at that) to ACTUALLY paint this above painting, but in a totally original way. So, patrons, EARLY CHRISTMAS SURPRISE!!! You've funded some seriously weird AI-shitshow-inspired art. That one is coming next month, with ALL fanfare.

BUT MEANWHILE....here I went, putting my foot in it again with this "Revenge" image.

So I thought quickly, and I reached out to one of my favorite painters du jour, Niki McQueen, from South Africa. She's been drumming up some of the most beautiful poster artwork I've ever seen for the last year of Dresden Dolls and Solo Amanda tours. And she's a really important person in this community now. She's even coming to the upcoming Dolls shows in Boston - CROWDFUNDED by our community...FROM SOUTH AFRICA. If that isn't amazing, I dunno what is. This art family astounds me, and moves me to tears, constantly. (OH, and if you want to contribute to that fund, it's still open! She's just a few hundred dollars shy of a $5k goal!: https://www.gofundme.com/f/get-artist-niki-mcqueen-to-the-dresden-dolls-shows)

Anyway.

I texted Niki in the middle of the night (we text a lot) and I asked if she might be down to make a REAL - from scratch - art-version of this image, based pretty much directly on the AI-generated screengrab.

It's not for nothing to mention that Niki, like me, has been in a serious era of triage and emotional recovery, and she's been using her artwork to speak for her soul.

It was not a hard ask.

She put her hand up and went to work that following week.

Your patronage funded all of her time and materials.

Here are some pix of her process:

AND....here's a little video on Instagram Reels of some of Niki's process (it's public, don't worry).

https://www.instagram.com/p/DBMScAsRYcO/

Here's the finished (ACTUAL) pen-and-ink artwork, photographed in Niki's studio!!!

WHAT DO WE THINK, PEOPLE???

AND NOW!!!!

The FUN BIT.....

What shall we do with it?

I'm tempted to hang her in my living room.

But that feels selfish?

AUCTION IT FOR CHARITY?

I'm wide open to ideas!!! I'm reading comments so HIT ME.

Selling this puppy and giving the $$ to a domestic violence shelter sounds good to me, something local here in Boston, or maybe in South Africa, where Niki's from (and they need plenty of help down there)....or RAINN?

Hit me with ideas, please. You're often smarter than me.

I would love one of you to be able to hang this on a wall.

It's pure power, in every sense.

......

Here are links to:

Niki's Patreon

and

Niki's Website (where she sells prints, and every sale helps her....so please support!!)

and

Niki's Insta and Facebook, please follow along.

......

And while we are on this topic, don't forget that TONIGHT (Oct 16th!) - no tcoincidentally - I am holding a talk @ Harvard with Evan Greer from Fight for the Future and Judith Donath, author of "The Social Machine"!!!

It's being held TONIGHT from 7-8:30 pm EST at The Berkman Klein Institute at Harvard Law School in Cambridge, Mass.

THE LIVESTREAM WEBINAR LINK is available to $10 patrons only since the webinar can only host about 500 people at one time!

And if you're in Boston....and you wanna come....just bump yourself up to the $10 tier! WE have had a good handful of RSVPs and there's probably about 5-10 seats left, and they're...FREE! GRAB! Here's the $10+ only link with the free ticket & webinar link!:

https://www.patreon.com/posts/10-patrons-only-114053231

More coming, always.

I love you all so much.

Thanks for being weird me with.

There's hope.

There's hope.

It's beautiful here right now...

Love from a Real Live Artist living in The Real Life World....

xxx

AFP

------THE STUFF I SAY AT THE END OF THE POST---------

Some of this is a little outdated. I need to do some work on it. But:

1. If you are a patron and new to my work, don’t forget your patronage allows you access to ALL of my patreon releases to date. HERE is the link to download my latest big solo record, “There Will Be No Intermission”, and HERE is a link to download the PDF of the art/essay book that goes with it.

2. If you’re a patron reading this post via an email notification, please click through to comment on this post. at the very least, if you’ve read it, indicate that by using the heart symbol. that's always nice for me to see, so i know who's reading.

3. You can see All the Things (over 150 of them) I’ve made so far on patreon…though this page badly needs updating

http://amandapalmer.net/things

4. JOIN THE SHADOWBOX COMMUNITY FORUM, find your people, and discuss everything: https://forum.theshadowbox.net/

5. New to my music and TOTALLY OVERWHELMED? TAKE A WALK THROUGH AMANDALANDA….we made a basic list of my greatest hits n stuff (at least up until a few years ago, this also desperately needs updating) on this lovely page: http://amandalanda.amandapalmer.net/

6. General AFP/patreon-related questions? Ask away, someone will answer: patronhelp@amandapalmer.net

Files

Previews only

Comments

Deniz Bevan

Awesome, Niki! So excited for the other art coming in December! ❤️

Sofia Lopes

Ahhh I love Niki!! Her work never disappoints! (Quite the opposite, really; she always seems to come up with the most stunning concepts and artworks) I'd be all for auctioning this piece and maybe donating the money to a South African charity. And later, if you still feel like you need it in your living room (and if it's feasible for you, of course!!) you could commission a similar one from her? If it came to that, I don't think having two—instead of one—of these beauties out in the world would make it any less special!

Zoltanina

I love this!!! Great idea 💚 If you want to have her in your living room, put her there. And when you've seen enough of her after one year or five or whatever, go on with the auctioning or selling or giving away bit. She'll probably not be outdated until then 🥲

Marija Milisavljević Grdinić

It's beautiful and I love the idea so much! I don't know if this would be viable, but perhaps you could keep it and make the reproductions or posters for sale, with Niki getting her share and perhaps a part of it going to charity? Not everything has to be un-selfish, you have the right to have nice things, just like everybody else 🥰

Kim Morton

This is such an amazing piece! Niki is incredible. Amanda you have such a way of transmuting people’s mob mentality nonsense into beautiful moments to help others out. You continue to inspire me every single day 🫶🏼

Ashleigh M. Ferreira-Bartlett

I just left a DV situation that has my hair still falling out, he has my late fiances ashes, there is so much mess… I’m in a tizzy and a panic and when I read the bit at the end I figured it could not hurt to mention that I have a GFM (go fund me.com/help-ash-make-it) to help me…make it there. It looks like now I’ll be going alone and with police and doing so much driving and I am so sick and I am so scared. If it auctions for like a lot or a helper happens to catch this I would give anything I can for a helping hand regardless thank you and also this was an incredible idea and I love everything about it

Amanda Denery

I’ve got to say, some members of this community are pretty tightly wound up with regard to AI. I made the mistake of trying to engage and was positively pounded for it & told I have no idea what I’m talking about. After 25 years in copyright licensing, royalties and compliance for music and the most notable IP holders… I have thoughts but honestly don’t feel like it’s worth the battle here. Anyone is welcome to rage against emerging technologies, but that won’t make them go away. The purist attitude progresses nothing. Ensuring attribution and contribution for living rights holders is crucial, especially where income is involved. Your efforts to appease for every silly little meme are admirable, but I wish we could collectively save the rage for more impactful purposes. meanwhile, huzzah for some kick ass new arts!

Len Tower Jr.

rage creates a shield that keeps people from healing, growing, & learning how others think & feel.

Samantha Lewandoski

As someone currently dealing with the fallout from domestic violence- I love the idea of it going to a DV shelter. The art is beautiful as always, thank you Niki. 🥹 Sending my love to you all! 🫂🎢🖤

Natalie Crespo

The thing about that protest poster is it's not just AI, it's whitewashing a Black activist talking about the BLM marches in 2020. If that phrase doesn't make you think of Kimberly Jones, it SHOULD. And I hope that Nicki could get this message and credit Kimberly Jones as well! It's really important to acknowledge where this phrase originated, especially when it comes from Black voices. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llci8MVh8J4

Natalie Crespo

Amanda, I realize you weren't in the US for those, though Kimberly's video went viral, so I'm not trying to hate on you, but highlight this epic moment being obscured by AI nonsense.

Natalie Crespo

I work in Tech, and we use AI/LLMs in my company. It's great all models run against our own data, nothing exploitative, but rather saving time so we can focus on less tedious taks than hand-coding data.

Ryan Stuck

It may be considered selfish or not impacting enough people, but I think the proceeds of an auction could go to Niki. I know she'd be getting paid twice, but it just feels right to me, for reasons.

Valentin Shauger

hey there amanda. it is kind of really beautiful to me how deeply we all at least CARE about art and artists. for me, ai or not its all allowed. maybe im wrong for that. but that jesus pic you shared of last supper tells me otherwise. was cunty as fuck! anyhow, id love for you to know nikis been so friggin kind to me. shes genuinely a very sweet human to her core in all my expierences with her. im so excited to do back to back to back dresden dolls parties with everyone. i do a horror/hardcore show w my drag the night before driving to boston for more dolls. 365 dresden dolls!! 365 dresden dolls!! haha! the dolls ARE brat. ok. im done rambling. i love you so much amanda. so much. you matter. lets fucking rage everyone!!!! punk cabaret for life. love you amanda!!! ✨️ ♥️ 🎩 🎊

James G Watt

Too few fingers, otherwise I love it.

Niki McQueen

That is so kind, Ryan. I wouldn't feel right though, I know domestic violence and no-one who has lived through it should be without help. Poverty and lack of resources are so rife here...to help is to heal.

Niki McQueen

Coming from a country where racial inequality is still rife, I acknowledge and respect you making me aware of this. These words have power in MANY contexts, I'm sure you will agree, they apply very appropriately to victims of domestic violence. I will attribute them to Kimberly when I post the work.

Carrie Kelley

I’m so behind sometimes and was completely unaware of the issue with AI taking from artists. I still don’t even completely understand let alone comprehend the ways AI has integrated into the human condition by way of science and collected (*cough* stolen *cough*) data to supposedly advance what humans can do - which from my understanding is basically the reason it exists. I don’t know, it’s exciting but scary and I go back and forth between embracing it and resisting it. It kind of makes my brain feel like it’s a boiling over pot of stew. Oh and thank you for sharing Niki’s work… Her art is just brilliant. I’ve been changing some stuff around in my house and I just found a piece of art I didn’t know I needed until I saw it and I’m getting a print as soon as I finish this comment. I say put the art up where you can enjoy it for a bit and auction it off to RAINN. They’ve been a great resource for a long time but they are doing really great work over recent years by using grants and donations to refine existing services and build new services to meet the needs of victims who are POC and victims of all gender identities. Any organization would be greatly deserving of any funds raised, I just had RAINN fresh in my mind after reading that Tori Amos had been named this year’s Inspirational Artist award from the Women in Music awards and her work with RAINN was honored. Wherever the art ends up, I’m sure it will land exactly where it should land and good things will come. In this fucked up world, we have so many amazing people who want to make life less of a living hell for others. People like you, Tori, Ani, Ruth, Alicia, so many patrons from this community, countless people all over the world just doing their best to fight for change, and me! Knowing I am of the side of humanity using logic and compassion and respect as a tool to be better individually and collectively is getting me through so much these days.

Tamara

I teach K-8 Computer Science and have taught AI for about six years now. You receive the absolute shittiest comments about whole world disruptions, Amanda. Jesus Promptwriting Christ, how could you unleash generative AI on the world and steal from artists?! I do love the lemonade-outta art reply. This is my kind of activism! ✊

Amanda Denery

Yes! The value of AI in this area is going to be immensely helpful for artists. If people really understood how much $$ sits around unmatched to assets because of bad data at all levels it would blow their minds. I’m excited to see this problem solved.

Beth

This is amazing and I think it should be auctioned off or sold with the proceeds going to RAIIN.

Anneloes Fickweiler

“With this Jesus debacle - this was last April, and I was on tour in Nashville - I considered how to respond, and I decided to make some art Lemonade.“ Imagine if Pontius Pilate had said that :-D

Natalie Crespo

Thank you! I trust your intentions and your work is lovely! <3 Also, sorry for misspelling your name!

Jamo_Peaceout

As soon as I saw this picture I had a laugh. Had no idea that the quote was used in 2020 in a racism sense and now that I know I like it even more. Kudos to Niki and AFP for commissioning the new work. As long as the effort has gone into acknowledging the origins of something then I’m happy. I would love to have a print of this on my wall knowing that Amanda is enjoying the original on her wall. Proceeds to whatever charities are deemed suitable.

Douglas Roark

"I made the mistake of trying to engage and was positively pounded for it & told I have no idea what I’m talking about." Heh. Welcome to the Internet. Somebody I know was raging out a couple of months ago over not being able to buy Chappell Roan tickets, thinking Chappell had charged $400 for them. The whole thing immediately devolved into a circle jerk over Ticketmaster being more evil than Satan, nevermind that AXS sold the original tickets (probably for $40-50) and the lady had been looking at a secondhand vendor's site. (Her boyfriend - a touring musician, no less! - told her that was what everybody used.) Crickets when I (mostly) calmly explained what happened. I wouldn't have minded so much if this lady didn't make a big deal about how smart she is on a semi-regular basis. On one hand, I'm so ready to return fire whenever the screambots try to shut down discussions and generate false consensus. (That includes AI, where the loudest voices are almost always the most ignorant of the technical details and how society tends to adopt new technologies.) OTOH, I have a million other things I should be doing with my time. It's a tricky balance. That said, when people are trained so deeply to rage out in any one particular direction, that does hurt people who don't do their own independent research (which, let's be honest, is most people), and especially those who just go along with the loudest voices.

Shawn Rourke

There is so much good stuff here. Im loving it!

Omer Raviv

My hot take is: art is theft. Generative AI models are doing nothing different than what us humans do. I can see the argument against using AI to steal someone's voice or likeness and make money off of it, but other than that, I just don't get it.

helwolves

While I appreciate the effort, I think it would have made a lot more sense to do a completely NEW piece with the same sentiment, not one so heavily based on what's still an AI-generated image (that was derived from someone else's photos, someone else's words, etc.)

Jeanette-o-saur

Just here to point at this cause it's important. I've only seen this message in the hands of black and indigenous folks. I know putting the white lady in was AI and not a choice made by the humans in the room, but it feels jarring to see a white lady holding that sign.

Danielle

Given the comments of others that AI basically ripped this sentiment from BLM, would it make sense to auction it and donate the money to a BLM related org or an indigenous org? Tis the week for that, btw.

Dorit

Yes! Auction it to raise funds to support a charity in South Africa! I'm South African so I'm biased but that sounds like an incredible idea! Women need all the help they can get down here! Thank you Niki and Amanda!

Gabrielle Motola

I fucking love what you did with this the whole thing. I get the sense that it needs to be like a chain mail “letter” that gets loaned out on display - it goes on tour essentially. To many different places where it will be seen. Or the original gets auctioned off but first you make a bunch of posters and sell them as signed by you and Niki (and even flypaper some?) and she gets some more income from her art (life costs $€¥£! so she can come to Boston for example) and you send a large portion to charity.

Tamara

I love this piece and am sharing with colleagues! I teach CS, K-8.

Kathryn Drew

after reading the comments which explain that this slogan is from the BLM movement i think it only right that any money from auctioning it be donated there. Also, i don't quite understand it - getting an artist to draw an almost exact copy of an AI generated image, somehow doesn't make sense to me. Especially regarding the slogan being used. Can anyone explain?

Lisa Millraney

hey Amanda--I missed all this, because I was in NYC this week, and as fate would have it, seeing a play that is all about art and AI! It's called McNeal, and if you can get down there before it closes I HIGHLY recommend it. The script is a mindfuck in the best possible way, and the cast is amazing and led by ROBERT FREAKING DOWNEY JR. Ahem, anyway. lol. Auctioning the art piece & donating the proceeds seems like an excellent idea :)