Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello my loves.

This is a Thing. It’s…an arm warmer? A leg warmer? I found it in my woods. I asked Coco if it was hers. She had been shooting a music video in the woods the day before, so it seemed like an obvious match.

This is not her thing. What is this thing and who does it belong to and how did it get in the woods? I may never know.

It is a beautiful Thing. I know, like many Things in my life, do not know what to do with it. Throwing this Thing away seems criminal. It’s a beautiful, possibly hand-knitted, Thing of beauty.

Since I am Amanda Palmer, I am tempted to ask here in the community if anybody needs or wants this thing. I would mail it to you. But that would mean adding one more Thing to Do and Mail to my now catastrophically long list of Things to Do and Mail.

This is a good note on which to open what I wanna talk about right now.

I have a Thing backlog that is very, very, very long. The pandemic and my waylay in New Zealand destroyed my work flow, and my capacity to organize (which was never top-notch to begin with), and my release schedule (and my brain, and many parts of my heart).

There's a beautiful video recording I did about a month ago - of a live sunset four-handed piano performance I did at the top of a mountain at sunset with Luke the genius street performing piano-player - with the intention of maybe Thinging it. I'm getting good at making things again but worse at relasing them to the patreon. I get overwhelmed.

The Thing-shoebox Explodeth.

Now I am home and truly confronted with the Things that never got finished, or put out. The podcasts, the video projects, the half-done ideas, the old recordings….it’s all THERE.

I have no anger at myself. My god, none.

It has been such an arduous few years.

I spent many months just surviving, digesting, mothering, keeping my head above water. I forgive myself for starting things and not finishing them.

It's okay. I say it because I need to say it to myself.

Meanwhile, as the Things confront me, I am putting together a team for the Dresden Dolls and all of the work that I made five years ago seems like a distant dream. I am not sure what has value anymore - to the world, or to me.

I asked and received permission and am seriously thinking about Thinging a poem this month. Alex and I have also been working on a kind of “Best Of” Thing-retrospective, and I’m also spending time with some new musician pals in Woodstock who have great gear and I’m wondering if it might be nice to just MAKE some music, some cover songs, some beautiful sounds. I also wonder if it isn’t time to just rent the gear and do a long piano session - like the “Emergency Soothing Music” session / webcast that I did in New Zealand, which everybody seemed to love.

I have a lot on my mind and heart, and I’m exhausted. I am still trying to catch up with the friends and family I haven’t seen for four years. I’m trying to mother my culture-shocked kiddo. I am trying to empty, empty my brain in order to figure out what the next right decisions are: and I have many huge life decisions heading my way. I am trying to SORT. It's so hard.

So I do what I usually do in these situations, and I come to you, the patrons, the denizens of this backstage haunt.

What do you ... need?

What would pacify your heart right now? I mostly just want to ask and see what you say. It may not change the nature of what I release - and how - too very much. But it helps to ask, as I want to be more in dialogue with the world. I've missed the world. I don't want to music and art into the void. I have so much to put out, and so many questions, but I also want to cast my eyes around the room and see who's here, and who's listening, and what it is that you crave. This is why I love the patreon so much.

Because you're real, and you're here.

So I supposed I'm not asking a very direct question, and I suppose I often know the answers deep in my heart, but like with many things, I need to talk out loud with my pals to understand what's going on.

So talk to me about Things, and I'll be listeing, and slowly, I'll start the long haul of excavating the Art Pile.

What do I do with this Thing?

I'm reading comments for the next day or so.

Talk to me, dear ones.

Love from the woods...

XX



Files

Previews only

Comments

Em the Robot

The fairies left it behind I think

Marley Kendrick

Maybe get someone to.make a snake or giraffe toy and this can be it's sweater/scarf?

Lisa Hamilton

The things can always wait. Take time to heal your heart and soul. Looking forward to seeing you in Boston and hoping to also get to see you when you are ready to tour with the Dolls. I don’t feel you “owe” me anything. Just continue being you.

Drag Queen Jesus

I think the whole AFP community needs to be aware: "Tramalamadingdong" is now officially a song...my friend recorded a first take and is working on the finished version. If you want a copy hit me up. <3<3<3<3

DrWex

I don't think there's anything I _need_ but if you're asking what I'd like? I'd like more smaller Things. I worry that the list/box/whatever fills and each potential Thing in it demands a level of work and finish that takes time and resources not always available. So it stays in the box. Big Things are awesome, but so long as we're paying a fixed amount per thing, and can keep our monthly cap where it's comfortable for us I would much rather have a handful of smaller Things more often and maybe a few bigger Things for work that really really REALLY demands a lot of resources. I have no idea how big the Things are in that box, so maybe my preferences don't match up well with your reality. That's OK. This opinion is worth what you paid for it.

Jill

Probably a leg or arm warmer, but I would use it as a hand holder, either with yourself or with another. Personally I need time. I need time to work, but also to care for my loved ones. I’ve been helping take care of my uncle while he is recovering from brain surgery last month. He has been having trouble communicating and finding the right words sometimes; he gets caught on what was last talked about and can’t let it go and repeats himself, which is obviously frustrating for him and sometimes he just gives up because he can’t find it quickly. There’s been a lot of talking about dying and crying and getting emotional. I am enjoying my time that I’m spending here with him, watching TV and when he feels the energy taking walks, and then staying up a bit later after he goes to bed to work on some art projects.

Meg Higgins

I think what i’m looking for right now is connection to individuals and the world and so I think poems or raw little proto songs or any sort of art that feels like connection to you would likely make me feel connected also. I’m also dealing with a recent Bad Thing and my attention span is hideous so shorter stuff is more accessible for me. But really i think what works for me about thinking is that it works for you. Like when it seems like undue stress i’m less into it. I hope that makes sense.

Kristin Ryan

I'm happy with anything, but I just want you healthy, and well rested. I do have a deep ache to give you the biggest and safest hug. The time will come. I love you.

Issa Rodri

what a lovely leg warmer! I hope it finds it's home soon. also, it's okay to just be- we're here, trying to enjoy the finite time we have. your poetry is the backbone of your art, and witnessing how things grow and evolve in tandem is necessary for making sure your heart is full. thing what you need to keep things afloat and take time with your son unashamedly. after the hell of the past few years, you deserve it.

Philipp Windgassen

I want a lot - or a break. I'm in a complicated place with a baby and a teenager at home. But TBH, I would love to see that sunset video. I'd put it on the "big TV" with the good sound system and really take it in...

Claudia Rapp

I think it's totally valid to just pick something, anything from the pile (maybe the one that needs the least work to get "finished") of the as-yet-unthinged, and thing it. I don't know what I need right now, honestly. But I know that I like surprises :)

Lauren Calhoun

I can't say I know what you're feeling exactly, but there is a special kind of exhaustion/decision paralysis that comes from being the One in Charge, and that exhaustion makes the sort of decisions you're weighing in terms of next steps particularly hard. I sometimes find myself wanting someone else to be the One in Charge for a while and just tell me what my next action will be. If it's helpful, I'll say I love your poems and if you released any you have hanging around, my heart would be very happy. I keep a copy of empathy is nothing at my desk for when I'm feeling like my coworkers are assholes. Sometimes it helps them seem like less asshole-y assholes and sometimes it helps me remember they're just people, trying.

Amy Bellingrath

I would take this odd looking sleeve. I love wearing them to cover scars. I would give this Thing a good home, Amanda. I would love it.

Amanda Eckert

Since you asked for our input, my vote is (and always will be) for anything that helps make us feel connected. To you, to each other, to the world…just more connected in general I guess, across the many Life Divides ❤️

Azucena

Yes! Just rest! Turn off and be with you. Have a mom watch Ash

Leticia Gimeno

I’d say since as things go (and no thing is ok too… back to the “take time to heal and go monthly” discussion) go with the thing that brings you the most joy/solace/healing and is the lightest one to get out energy wise

Drag Queen Jesus

It's OBVIOUSLY a thing for a really big thingy...{{{blush}}}...um...

Aqualynne Carnahan

I have an associate who recently let me know she is expecting. Before she found out she was in the process of managing (a known) issue with her heart. I panicked as the thoughts crashed together at once. "Will she be okay???" and, "What are her options is she needs to terminate?" Fortunately, all the specialist feel she is good to go. But I am still dealing with this anxiety. Which I dare not tell her about. She can tell I'm stressed, but it would be irresponsible to tell her why. Compound that with the very real knowledge that people IN AMERICA are facing choices like this with uncertain and sometimes tragic outcomes. What I need is to find a way to let her know my stress was only triggered by her pregnancy and the world at large. Any recommendations from the community on art that I can share with her to express both my joy and fears for her would be amazing.

Martin OHare

The possibilities. Are endless. Have some musical jams with some friends and record it. Let's have some jherek strings. And maybe date the studio for the dolls album to come. Hello my name is sonu. Can we have a mn mp3 download of that I love it so much. X

Malvine

Personally, I would love to see/hear some of the older, unpolished, unfinished things. I think it would be a lovely reminder that not only in my life are things unpolished and unfinished. It will feel raw and connected, and maybe like a message from simpler times. Like the sort of world and feelings that we can rebuild, or that we are glad are left behind. I agree with DrWex that I would love some smaller Things. Just throw at us what you've got, no big fuss, no big officialness. Just thing the things, finished or not. And if eventually you finish them and they go out to the world? Great! If not then they can stay our little treasures, our reminders of how it's not perfection that brought us or keeps us here, but connection and truth.

Leticia Gimeno

Also, that healing music improv session from a few months back was truly wonderful (and healing indeed) Music as a healing connection 😀

cosmicdancer

I have all I need. It's a humbling place to be in. If I were asked to wish for something - it's music, always music. (I bypassed a spot where you did a musical gettogether once, Vienna, underneath one of the flak towers. Many lifetimes ago, in the snow. It's nearing spring here. So it's funny you should ask today, of all these days.) I hope you find the rest and comfort you need and that the neverending to-do-list will grow shorter. I know these lists. They are. They always will be. Thanks for checking in, Amanda!

Francine Hibiscus

I got nothing. Life is hard, eh? I am here to offer my cup of coffee to the purpose of art, and not tell you what to make. The opposite of classical Patrons! I have to say it made me sad to see you wacking around like a pachinko ball from project to project, from podcast to this to that. I also understand! When nothing is working, nothing is HAPPENING, you have to do something, to make something, so that you can justify yourself. It's okay to just toss projects permanently. Write the idea down, turn the page. Focus on what you do best and don't do every single thing. Thing what feels right. The folks that want to engage with it, will. Give the legwarmer to Ash, he can use it for dozens of things. Big big love to you, Amanda. Spring is coming. The season of mud brings new ideas!

Amy Bellingrath

Also, my love. You need to prioritize what YOU need for you and Ash and all of your people right now. I know we're not going anywhere so we'll be here when you're ready. There is love here for you. 🌸🌸🤘🤗

Janine Eden

I don't think we get to dictate the things. You choose to support an artist and allow them to their thing, not your thing. We're patrons, not commissioners. Take your time, and do what you need to do, tbh, I'd be happy with you thinging the updates on the things.

worm32b

I'm sure everyone else says similar, but do what feels right. Especially when it comes to art and you're *writhing* with it in the moment. To every lost poem idea I had, that you had... I hope they find good homes. As a poet myself, there isn't much that reaches such a level of clarity in a cathartic realm than either reading or writing some does. Even if it isn't your best... you don't usually make a poem and think, "this will be the one everyone likes", it just might happen though. So, I'm always up for some poetry, and being one of my favorite pieces of media to properly sit down, garnish, savor, and digest, (that doesn't give me a stomache-ache....) sounds delicious. Also the warmer almost looks kinda like a fish tail! It's lovely.

Jacob

Hi Amanda! One of my favorite things to explore as a hardcore fan of artists is those deep cuts or discarded songs/demos that never make a record and may never see the light of day again. Imogen Heap does this with her Supapass app, and it’s something I’d happily pay for separately for your work as well. You mentioned a few demo tapes you had that would be a real treat for the geeky fans like myself. I’ve got a bunch of notes and titles in a spreadsheet I’d love for you to either explore or release if demos/studio versions exist: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1EiR6kSf97yXe4s8QEPl8ygm9-QYwCvdnj6XjUKP0lAQ/edit Too much time on my hands? Yes. But it’s a love letter to the artists I do it for haha. But yes I would love some old demos and tunes if you decide to share them in one way or another.

Superball

If I were you, I’d wear that Thing. I recently found a purple knit fingerless glove that I ended up wearing because I spilled beer on one of my tan-and-brown llama fingerless gloves. As a patron, what do I seek from you? Whatever speaks the most to your heart, including possibilities like ditching all the old Things and starting over, Thinging every one of the things on your list over time, and quitting with being “productive” altogether. (You and your life are not products. The simple fact of your existence is inspiring.)

Janine Eden

Elephant cock-warmer? Awesome. I think AFP and Ash need to head to the nearest natural history museum and gift it to an exhibit.

Drag Queen Jesus

Okay I def need the thing and would be willing to mail you a thing to put the thing in to send it to me so all you have to do is plop the thing in the thing and then place it in a thing so the guy can put it in a thing to get it to into my things for my thingy... but I guess what I need most from the art world now/AFP community is some sort of acknowledgement of how likely fucked we are and how it doesn't matter because humans were never going to be around forever and art still matters and life still matters and how we will still find joy amongst this unimaginable amount of suffering. And also something acknowledging how abusive and fucked up the police are in America these days....okay I'm off to scrape some shitty icing off of a gluten filled cupcake. Love you tata.

Bill Ward

Write a song about a single solitary arm warmer left in the woods. I'm sure that's a good story you can make for that

Wtcher

I need you to take care of yourself! Take a nap! Take a walk! Sing to yourself! That doesn’t really help your Thing List of course. But I think we all need those sounds in the air, wind rustling our hair, a gentle respite from the world. Maybe afterward, can half your list disappear, errant legend lost to time? Some Things really ought to just be things… often things can just stay thoughts, and then maybe forgotten. Easier said than done of course…

Jemima Louise Johnson

Music. Live music. Raw music. Just as this pinged through I was listening to your cover of 'the mess inside'. I love that cover that moment and the messy beauty of it all. That was nearly five years ago now. And before that I was listening to Nine Inch Nails 'Still' the pared down not acoustic album. I want people in a room making music together. The connection the reading eachother and blending and cracking of voices and squeaking of strings and clanging of piano wires. I don't want things mixed up and fancyfied. I want people together breathing the same air. Or something. Feeling nostalgic I guess.

amandapalmer

I am feeling this to the core of my bones. Sometimes I feel like just shutting up and playing instrumental piano, a one-woman titanic quartet.

Sarah Allen

Hey Amanda, My best guess is that thing is a legwarmer perhaps. I also suspect it's inside out (have you tried turning it inside out, is there a lovely cable pattern suddenly visible?) I've got no answers for you on the Thinging of Things, other than I think we're mostly all happy to see whatever you come up with. Old stuff, new stuff, surprise stuff, quick and easy stuff, bring on the stuff as you have the time to deal with it (or not, no pressure). I do love the idea of you doing something to benefit your second home in the southern hemisphere.

Rachael

I’d want music more than poetry right now. Maybe even Amanda covers Amanda - ... play some of your own stuff from your current place. My bandwidth is low so music is one of the best things to bolster me up.

Ashleigh M. Ferreira-Bartlett

I know this is probably cathartic, and you're so giving that this process is inevitable- but I desperately want you to do what feels right and best to you, most therapeutic, most relaxing, most WHATEVER IT IS YOU NEED. You. What you need. For once??

Drag Queen Jesus

I'm trying to figure it out. What's the best way to do it? Right now it's just an audio clip in my text message

Angel Rosen

What I need most is to feel connected with you & as many people here as possible. The best things you Thing are "places" we can collect at. For me, that's stories (anecdotal or otherwise), poems, webcasts with patron participation. I'd love for you to bring out a few old songs and tell us a story about them... we are so in tune with your Now, I'd love more visits from the past. Any post you make where people talk to each other in the comments is worthwhile to me. I just love being here. I'd rather you be taken care of than be available to make things for us, even if that means we miss you. I want you to make things that heal you, and share them because you need to, not because you're worried about not living up to an expectation. We want to know what is on your mind even if it's nothing, especially if it's everything. I don't have any expectations. I've been along for The Ride for almost fifteen years. If you posted once a week just to say I love you, that's enough, if that's what you need. You can't make something for everyone, but everything you make is beautiful and necessary to someone.

Janine Eden

I can be a bit of a zombie patron, and check in occasionally. However, something I really valued was when you live streamed the arrangement process for Surface Pressure. Maybe a live stream of a thingy organisation session as a thing would help hou and be valued by patrons? Alternatively it could feel like hell on earth so feel free to ignore.

Melissa Terras

I want you to wash that thing before you put it on, but make sure to hand wash that thing at a low temp so it doesnt shrink xxx

nikita

dearest, please let yourself rest. all your notes to us you outline this harrowing journey you've been on since march 2020. over and over again. how you must feel so trapped in that, in justifying your overwhelm. you say over and over again, your tender heart and your exhaustion. i see though, that you are doing what you need to do. you do not need to release or finish anything. you have campersand coming up. you have a child you are tending so beautifully. if you wind up with gear and other music folks around you, play. allow, darlin. do you have a fucking therapist? are you operating from scarcity, fear of going quiet, of losing us? you've saved some of our lives, please trust us. we love you. and if some folks don't stay, aren't satisfied, well, they have their own journey they're on. leave them to it. i adore you and your bleeding heart. please take care.

Tara Timmsy

Amanda, it's Tara. Currently rereading your Art of Asking book. I like how you ask. its super brave. As an answer to your query: I say this: grab a PREVIOUSLY made Thing and Thing that shit. You made it. It has value. Your bandwidth is limited, these are lean times. lean Times are when we into the cellar and pull something off the shelf. Something we made before intended to us sustain later. sometimes we don't know what we have made is for later. that's ok. cellar stuff may be dusty now, but it was fresh and exciting when it was made. I say: do not add to your ever growing list/do not tax your bandwidth further, you will just glitch even more. Reach into the cellar. Pick a dusty thing, show it around, tell the story of how it became. Call it a fucking day. You deserve it. I deserve it, and just did this myself. gave a previously made piece of art to a dear person, feeling slightly whatever that I made it a while ago/wrapped up in my head that i didn't make it for the gift purpose/didn't have bandwidth to do more. the gift was loved by the recipient and for double delight, i got to relive the making process of it and enjoy it once again as he placed it carefully on his desk to look upon each day. it literally was in my cellar until that point. Now it has a much better life! I say again: reach into the cellar, grab a good dusty one, tell us all about it, we will enjoy it, and you will eat and feed your family and pay your people. keep it simple. Also, I hope your knee is feeling better! xo

Emily

Would love to see the nz piano duo, and nz benefit sounds like a great idea right now.. But totally understand the overwhelm, I'm just here for whatever :)

Laurie Penny

I'm pretty sure it originally belonged to me and you are welcome to have it but CHECK IT FOR TICKS. Omg.

Drag Queen Jesus

I just sent it as an attachment with they lyrics in the body of the email to management@amandapalmer.net

Drag Queen Jesus

I want to put that thing on my thingy (not THAT thingy) and crawl into my bed and sleep and dream of better things to come.

KarenD

This thing - should be a big hug and and thank you from us to you. Collectively. All your posts, putting what so many of us are feeling into words. Is simply perfect. Consider it done. Thank you. ✨💕

Yael Mehl

I think the Thing is meant to warm someone long and narrow. Find a giraffe in need of a scarf, or a snake in need of a sweater. It feels good to wrap someone up in warmth. ❤️

cati

Since I moved to Iceland I've become used to seeing lost knit things all over - scarf on a tree, hat somehow jammed onto a park bench, and especially so many fence posts wearing mittens. As the finder of a thing, ones aims for the best compromise of readily visible, near where you found it, and secure no matter what the wind does. Some of the things are picked up within hours by the kid who lost them, some stick around for months before apparently being claimed/needed/rescued by who knows who. Considering the sheer number of lost things around, it feels like a pretty good system. That looks like a pretty nice leg-or-arm-warmer though. The ballet company I grew up with had one (yes, one) that ended up getting passed down through generations of dancers.

KJ Hawkwood

Like so many of us, what I want most is for you to be well. And I have tears rolling down my face as I type because so many of us are so beaten down...and yet when you ask, "What do you need?" the unforced, immediate answer in this group of people is, "I need YOU to be well, to care for yourself, to be human and humane." This community never fails to astonish me, and to remind me of how it can actually be to gather with good, flawed, messy, gorgeous, insecure, exhausted, magnificent...but under all of it deeply GOOD...human people. If you ask me what I want, I love your poetry most right now. Second vote would probably be just you and a piano, creating in real time. But also - Thinging something to help New Zealand would make my heart so happy. I can donate, and I have, and I will. But to have that connected to you and through you - to help nourish and care for the incredible island-person who held you and Ash so magnificently, who has woven themselves into your very beingness - that would feel really good. Also, not that you need advice, but if it helps - let go of the Thing backlog, or at least as much of it as you can without dying inside. Learning to live by snatching a single fragment of a moment as it whirls by seems to be how it is now, more than ever. Accumulating fragments "to get back to" has a special kind of grind, a particular weight and wear, and my gods, we're all worn to bare boards. :-/ Just a thought - you know what you need to do - but FWIW. Sending (parasocial but still heartfelt) love, no matter what.

Bethany Latham

Make some music things….music is a balm to the soul and we all need it more than ever. You’re not alone in the long list of things and deciding what needs to be done with them.

Kathryn Drew

Oooooooh.... please please please release the piano duet with Luke Thing. I cannot express how much i crave this, and how much i have adored listening to the busking duet you did over and over and over!! (and Luke's album too), and how it has influenced me to start playing piano again after many years, and to finally be able to actually Improvise. It was always something i 'couldn't do' and now i can ! Partly thanks to you and Luke. And also to Fyfe Dangerfield's improv piano album 'Ludlow'. The arm warmer, i would say wash it and wear it or give it to Ash to turn into a monster, or donate to an op shop (what are they called in USA, thrift stores?) :) And the other Thing i would love to see/hear is the doco on the Tasmania confessional booth. I hear you though, on the overwhelm of mass Things to figure out. And where to begin, or which to prioritise. Piano music is my top vote :) Whatever you choose, you are doing Great Job. Thank you xxxx

Laura Morland

Personally, I think you should make some music. When I sent you a PM yesterday (suggesting you might want to update your author page on Amazon), it was in reply to a PM you sent to all of us on April 21st of 2021. You wrote: "p.s. i'm sending this little reminder message to ALL 13,000+ of you, so don't y'all message me back at once, please." The other day, you mentioned that you have 10,000+ patrons. So if you have really lost ~3,000 patrons in 22 months, that's a bit scary. That's why I'm voting that you create some music... in whatever form suits you!

LJ

I want whatever makes your heart sing and come alive and helps you express your wisdom and work through your doubts and fears and love and… because I know that those things will resonate with me and my heart and my fears and love. And at a pace that is sustainable and life giving for you.

Caz

Does the sunset piano playing show the sunset? That combination sounds lovely, I want to see sunsets in places I’m not in. Love to you, and everyone here this morning (my time). Such a comfort being reminded of the support and embraces being shared.

Vicki Callanan

I thought about the random Thing and I thought about what I need, and both seem as bewildering as each other. I feel like a lot of the things I thought, the old truths I relied, on have proved flimsy, or have damn well just dematerialised in this new present. I know a million techniques to keep myself well, to soothe myself, to Triumph over Adversity … but none of them are really up to the job. Because the truth is that nothing can smooth over these cracks or make this manageable or take the edge off the sting. Perhaps I need something new altogether. Something strange and dislocated and vaguely bizarre? Perhaps we should just all Mail each other obscure objects and laugh and cry at them arriving. Perhaps I should go on a walk and look for discarded objects. I don’t know. Here I am trying to find the Thing That Will Fix It again. I think I probably might need to scream and smash some things up. I think maybe I need to just survey the destruction for a bit. I’m no good at these things.

Caz

Oh yes, DrWex that wpuld be delightful. To be content with smaller things.

Tom Callan

Hey Amanda, I've been a fan of The Dresden Dolls and you for a while now, but just joined the Patreon. My wife and I saw you and Brian many years ago in Clifton Park. I love all kinds of music and would really be interested in hearing what you and the others that you met in the Woodstock area are doing would really be interested in any cool different versions of cover songs. As for getting myself organized from time to time, as we all get overwhelmed, an activity that takes me away from all of it for a bit seems to help refocus me. For that most of the time it's photographing nature, it forces me to look for the beauty all around us. This time of year sucks for this, especially this year as it has been a terrible year for photos (at least just north of Albany) but spring is just around the corner.

KJ Hawkwood

The award goes to And for The Most Gratuitous Use of the Word Thing In a Serious Screenplay. :-D (To be clear, as we're in a text medium, I am completely delighted by your linguistic dexterity and your appreciation of a good old-fashioned SASE (or modern equivalent.)) Art matters more than ever. And being kind to each other. And finding joy amonst this unimaginable amount suffering. Even in America - perhaps especially in America. Raising my coffee to you, And, with great appreciation.

Voëlvry

I loved how Regina Spector used to put bootleg recordings and covers of her own songs people had sent her on her website. It meant I got to hear songs she didn’t officially release for over a decade and it’s so cool to see how they change and grow over time

Jennifer Harnage

Make music! I would even love instrumentals because your piano playing takes me to other places. But mostly, take care of yourself!!!! Please!!!! I love you!!!! ♡♡♡

Lynn Anderson

Momma - Thing or don't Thing, we got you. Poems are like raw art journals. They can be cathartic too. Hit us up and do some healing. But ....... rest your heart, head and body ♥️♥️ I love you.

Marie O'Reilly

I really feel this Vicki - especially feeling confused and bizarre and "trying to find the Thing That Will Fix It again". So I just wanted to say, you're not alone.

Deeslee

The music video in the woods. It’s probably perfect already and you can live with a pretty good version of it. Trust your editor to know what they are doing without making more changes.

Sarah Williams

I don't really travel much, and that makes your shows out of my reach. I loved that while you were in New Zealand you did a concert, a real concert and shared it with the rest of us. You said at the time that you were able to do that because of the support of us, your patrons. I would love if you could find a way to do that again. That's my ask.

Katie Player

I’d love to see the cliff top piano recording at some point. The spontaneous duet with teenage cinematography unwound something in me that had been tied far too tight. For everything else on the pile I vote old school cyberpunk- use what you want and throw the rest away. Start as clean as you need. We all need to forgive ourselves for the things that didn’t happen and burn the creative to do lists. I want to see/hear/cheer on what comes next, from a place of YOUR creative joy. Use the rest for mulch. I’m here for experiments and flawed beauty too. Just let go and be you sweetheart 🔥❤️

Taylor Zartman

I know that what I need in my life right now is a sense freedom. So I suggest do whatever makes you feel free - maybe it's finally thinging and crossing things off the list, maybe it's never looking at them again, maybe it's improvised piano, maybe it's reading Frank O'Hara poems. I know how heavy I feel, so my wish for you is that you might find some freedom even within the heaviness you are carrying. 💚

Elizabeth Gunn

I think I need songs. I play songs and write songs and perform songs for people for money and spend a lot of time doing the things around songs, making little nests for the songs to live in in my head, in my fingers, on the internet and on cds and in bars and clubs. But sometimes that doesn't leave quite enough space to just play the songs. Or just listen to the songs of others. I would like to hear your songs. I would like to sing along with them while I wash the dishes.

ece

Write each thing in your current list of ‘things I wanna do’ on pieces of individual paper , read each one aloud, say sorry and burn it. Start afresh and unburden your heart and head - look forward. It’s like coming back from a long holiday and finding 1000 unread emails- press delete on all and move forward. If it’s important , it will come back to you and you will be fresher, energized and ready for it.

Joanna Lindblad

Yes you do know the answer :) Whatever is easiest and speaks to you to complete, I (for one) will humbly accept. If it’s a poem close to completion, you’re feeling the want/need to play piano/songs, or a video already recorded. Whatever is easiest and not overwhelming I vote for that. As for what to do with what I believe is the leg warmer, if no one claims it I would suggest donating it. I realize it’s just one from a set, but maybe someone just needs one. [There might be a metaphor in that ;)] Much love, Jo <3

Raven

I need to know things are gonna be ok. 🖤

Marie O'Reilly

What you do really well is help us feel connected to you and each other. Every time you post you do that. I love your Hello Lighthouse improvisation because of the story, the love, the connection and the beautiful music that I still often play. Whatever is easy for you to thing is good. I love the idea of the sunset duet. It's kind of a duet between your past and present life too. And I have a soul friend who lives in Wellington. I saw her for four hours on 9 January IRL and I don't know when I'll hug her again (i'm in the UK) So the Aotearoa connection is very meaningful for me. Also, on thinging the older stuff - don't be a perfectionist - be realistic about what is good enough and get it off your list with the right balance of finished enough and sent with love

Natalie Fades

The thing I’ve been thinking about is how much we’ve all been through. I’ve been thinking about PTSD and CPTSD and chronic fatigue of the body and nervous system. And I never was good at history, I should look it up, what happened after the plague? Whoever survived, how did they get back to a or create new “joy” in their lives. I’ve friends who have said fake it til you make it. And I can totally fake it, but it doesn’t move me towards making it real. We REALLY want have some fun feel some joy..how do we get there? How do we put out music that resonates with people when we all feel so isolated as we fake it or stigmatized if we show how we’re hurting, forgetful, messy, tired, ill, pissed-off. Happy Happy joy, joy. The thing I’ve been doing is trying to recognize little moments that bring me joy or give me a sense of purpose. No matter how weird or insignificant it may seem. Last week it was a huge earthworm that crawled out from my new (old) flower bed. I didn’t realize I’d destroyed it’s home, tunnels and passages it had created. I wiped it out in an instant with my little shovel to put in a lavender plant. It was running away (picture a worm running as fast as it can) and I apologized and said I’d protect it from the crows and this one particular red breasted robin that had its eye on it. I thanked it for aerating my flowerbed. It was really cold outside and this worm wouldn’t just borough down real quick. So, I gently tossed soil to cover it. I wanted to leave. I thought oh I hope it stays under but nope! It popped his head back out the other side l, still pissed off at me, and said that that just wouldn’t do! after about 13 minutes I was begging this worm to just pick a place so it could be safe and I could leave. The whole thing took about 25 minutes. I’ve got 17 of it on film if anyone’s interested. 😆. It finally found a new place to make its home, and I felt a bit of joy, gratitude and luck for having that worm still in my flower bed, and for protecting it from the robins, I felt like I had filled a purpose. I want to write about my pain and anger of getting dumped on December 1. My friend who plays guitar while I sing wants songs about happiness and the feeling of freedom. We found ourselves, he’s a great friend, at a stale-mate. I can’t write a song about how happy a worm made me. Amanda, I think many of us are lost and discombobulated. Maybe the thing is their are just too many things in general, and you have this pressure on you to come up with “a” thing. I would pay per month for no-thing, knowing I was helping support financially your ability to have housing, food , medical/health, support your son maybe even get a chance to go to your own therapy (you are going through some shit), while you get a chance to heal, breathe, and create what comes to you authentically in ….time. I know the big Thing coming, your next album, whenever it is birthed will be just the right thing. I struggle with patience, too, but I trust that the wait for this thing is sooooo worth it!

Nicole Werner

I need to know we’re all in this together. Because we are. Everyone I talk to is struggling and the existential dread is palpable. Climate change, student loan debt, housing crisis, our generation has no retirement money, most don’t have kids. Nobody has savings. Everyone is paycheck-to-paycheck and hanging on by a thread but we pretend the pandemic is over and the unemployment and jobs numbers are good so everything must be okay. BUT IT’S NOT. We need a social safety net and I think the only way we get it is for good people to band together, pool resources, and change the game. I don’t remember specifics but a bunch of millennials got together to buy an old warehouse and turned it into livable space. I have an idea for a non-profit bank. I already own the domain www.carebandb.org. This was originally intended for a post-Roe non-profit. But Care Bank and Borrow might be a way to serve more people. I envision C.A.R.E. as an acronym for “Community Assets Restoring Equity.” Good idea? Bad idea? Any insight?

Raven

and sorry if that was vague. it is true tho. I am feeling lost myself and barely able to stay above water as you’ve mentioned you’ve felt. I love your regular check ins on patreon and writing. It helps.

Lindsay Hannon

The Thing-shoebox Explodeth? My god women, I hope you weren't hurt in the blast...Im always up for your music, in whatever state; done, undone. I like a voice ramble too, but your poems, collabs, writings , all happily received. x

Jen

I’m longing for connection. Maybe that’s why I went out on a huge for me limb and signed up for campersand. The last several years have left me feeling raw and isolated. I crave community and support. I need us to all scream and cry and sing and laugh together. I’m feeling pretty needy to be honest. Whatever you thing and throw out into the world I’m listening and singing beside you ❤️❤️❤️

Marija Milisavljević Grdinić

Darling Amanda, the last couple of years have been destroying all of our minds, with bad news coming out from all sources. So I think that we've all become sensitized by words, even beautiful and gentle ones become harder to read because we wait for the plot twist and something horrible to happen. Music does not have the same potential to wound so any piece of music - vocal, instrumental - is more than welcome. ❤️

Amy Bellingrath

Omg if it's yours by all means take it! I just woukdve given it a good second home. And yeah, ticks are badness !! 🌸😻

Rosemarie Ison-Edgington

I would like new music. An album would be great, but any new songs, or parts of songs, or random ukulele noises would be welcomed by me.

Teresa B.

I would love to see/hear the sunset piano performance! Your piano playing always feels meaningful to me.

Michael Murphy

Right now, the Thing I have been craving the most is Season 2 of the podcast, even if it is the last Season. Also, if there's a way for you to just piece together a new actual album of all the here-and-there new singles (both studio, live, and culled from Crowdcasts) of the last 5 years. You know: everything from Small Hands, Small Heart and Mr. Weinstein Will See You Now to Hello Aoteroa, The Man Who Ate Too Much, and The Ballad of The New York Times, through the Blurred Lines/Rape Me mashup, the "Emergency Soothing Piano", New Zealand Part 2, City Hall, plus all the random covers in those years, ending with Another Christmas. I'm sure all of us have probably downloaded MOST of these at some point or another, but not necessarily ALL, hence the album suggestion. So, consider it like your own Odds And Sods of albums -- the greatest hits of what never made it anywhere.

Edith Solarski

as a fellow mum: do what is easy. put out whatever is ready(ish). i learnt long ago: if there is an easy way: do that. even if it isn't perfect. it's good enough. we are all good enough <3

Bob Wait

One way of sorting through the wanna-do's could be sorting the piles into celebrations of the past, celebrations/workings out of your present ideas and circumstances, and self-permissions to develop some crazy Things for the future, and pick and choose from these columns going forward as the spirit moves you. At the risk of looking backward, which I realize can be death to a forward-looking artist, my favorite piece of DD memorabilia is the Live at the Roundhouse DVD. I watch it all the time! I also attended one of the Woodstock reunion shows, and it was the best live show I've attended. Could you hire/engage a video editor to Thing or Double-Thing a similar DVD compilation of the Woodstock shows, even if it's choppy because shooting and editing it was unplanned?

Sahrami

All I really need right now is a break. I also need to break, reach the point again where I realise where my limits are, cross them just to feel them on my ripping heartstrings. I need to quote Queen and break free. Let go of alllll the expectations and just fucking breathe. And listen to some great tunes by the AFP xx

Tracey Stokes

You did a show in Tasmania with the Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra. It was excellent. You had it filmed. Could that be a thing?

BoredDinobot

Oh I don’t even know what I need. I think I need a donut. And I need to move more, and move expansively, and take up more space. I need a dog. But from you? I just need what you feel like you can give. New music? Yes! Covers of old music? Wonderful! Pictures of you at your cool house? Awesome! Voicerambles? It’s like a voice mail from a friend. I love it! You’re an important part of my little corner of the world, and I appreciate what you do. Thanks. And The Thing From The Woods? Clean it, stuff it with fiberfill or clean rags or beans, and sew up the ends and put some googly eyes on it, and you have a friend for Ash.

Damian Masterson

A thing that resonated for me last Crowdcast was when you talked about the next dolls needing to be joyful, and I’m down for some joy. You once said I tempted you to cover some Cat Stevens, like Tea for the Tillerman or some of the songs from Harold and Maude. I could really go for something like that right now. Something with warmth and a big cheesy smile.

Robert Williams

I went onto YouTube to find it … a music video the John Butler Trio did years ago for one of their songs called “Better Than”. Great little song and great video done in ‘street art’ theme. As it rolls along a piece of graffiti scrolls past as if seen as you walk down the street … and it grabbed me, hard. “The best things in life … aren't things” I have posters I’ve made with photos of my family and friends with those words prominent in the image. ‘Things’ are nice, pretty, comfortable … but they’re just stuff. People can be monsters, seriously so, and they can be grubby angels … but i need them, more the grubby angels than the other type. Please do things you want to Amanda and share that joy with us … I’m happy to take any help i can to get through each day.

Rose Cooper

When I first joined the patreon you painted your body and stood in front of New York Public library for a book drive. That was followed by cool songs with amazing film clips that spoke to the human condition, The divide… And certain sexual predators. I became a fan because I loved the fearlessness, The awareness raising & the Pushing of the envelope. You were using your platform to say things. You raised money for the Aussie Bushfires. Etc. everything had A Point. I know this takes energy and planning and resources, but if any of your upcoming releases could focus on raising money for Iran, Syria/Turkey, Aotearoa, Yemen, etc or directing awareness towards the hideous anti-trans legislation and abortion issues in your country. The trans community, especially could use your support. The so-called Western World is supposed to be progressive. The USA sate govts are shitting on women & the marginalised and the world is looking on. And the Andrew Tates are popping up through the cracks everywhere. Releasing art for its own sake never seemed to be the point when you started the Patreon. Being the voice for the voiceless was your jam. Whatever you choose to do, Engage your passion and outrage. Those of us who are fighting without big platforms and no resources, need folks like you to inspire them. I don’t mean to overwhelm you. Just letting you know that it’s not necessarily what you make - but WHY you are making it, that matters to me. The. Bigger Picture. Spend more time with your beautiful son. Friends. Family. Recharge your batteries - and then do things that matter. One a year would do - if it has impact. You said it yourself. “I am Amanda Palmer” You stand for things. So do I. But I’m 61. No job. I only have 4 patrons. But I’ll still give you money if you use your platform to metaphorically spit into the world’s microphone and do Things That Matter X

Andi Probert

I think... that it feels like whether or not a thing is a THING is becoming something that too much thought goes into. And I wonder if it would be better if this just worked on a monthly subscription and things could be Things with less fear of if they're worthy of being Things or should stay as just things. Just my pov ;-) Much love to you x

Joelle trousdale

Music as it’s the most calming I think. The sunset piano piece sounds wonderful. But as always whatever works best for you is what works best for me x

David Rodwin

Thanks for this message. I need hope in my future. In art and entrepreneurship. I need the courage to bring my work to the public again. I'd like to do so and make that part or all of my career. I need to see examples of other people doing it as inspiration. And I need to know it's even hard for "successful" people - like you. It makes my struggles feel less lonely. So thanks for sharing all this. I need to exercise more and to lose the weight I put on from my Thyroid Eye Disease and the treatment for it. I'm glad I no longer look like Marty Feldman, but I still see double in most of my field of vision which makes doing things including exercise hard. I need to see things that uplift me. I need to see them live in person. I need The Hemlock Tavern back. That last time I was there was with kSea to see Brian play. It was loud and the vibrations felt so good. And real. I need a relationship that lifts me up, not the one I have that drags me down. And I need things that help me cry so I get the catharsis that frees my soul to try again. So what would pacify my heart right now? A simple song. (Lauda, Laudē)

EmVT

hi Amanda! a random assortment of things of yours I love love love: - covers and collabs (à la Enjoy the Silence, Blurred Lines) - poems; Ask Amanda; voice rambles and videos; Emergency Healing Piano; hand drawn writings and sketches The other day (or could be an old interview, not sure) I think you said something like, you don't necessarily know what some of your early DD songs were about. this was helpful. words have their own strange meaning from an emotional standpoint, they make their own reality, they have their own truth and integrity. like coughing up a diamond or a snake sweater 🙃 thank you 💜 is a fundraiser to help people affected by the earthquakes in Turkey too heavy a lift? I know it's a lot of work for the whole team. I just can't wrap my head around the loss of life. having some spring fever right now (warm)! a snowstorm cometh later this week to my neck of the woods. the times they are a changing. that's all I've got! thank you so much for asking, I love writing in 🙏

Amy Mottola

I’m in need of joy and quiet from the general mayhem that is the state of the world. I agree with whoever said it earlier that maybe the conversation about whether something should be Thing-ed is necessary. Poems, cover songs, conversations, videos..if it cost you time and resources, I am willing to partake in it. I love the free form piano playing/ healing cuz who doesn’t need healing right now?! Maybe something for Syrian/Turkish earthquake relief? Do what you do best, Amanda, whatever that fills you with joy first.

DebbieG

Thank you Marie for the perfectionist comment. I know it's meant for Amanda, but it speaks to me today. I am trying to let go of that tendency in myself because I think it is causing more stress than I need.

Coila

I'm in a place where I've done enough grieving (though it's not all over, probably) and it's time to Do A Thing. Move on to a new part of my life... And I'm not sure where to go... The sky is the limit in many ways and that's helpful but... It doesn't get me moving... And there are, as always, real restraints that matter... For me, I'm finding something I'm interested in and doing that. I'll see how far it gets me... And then decide the next thing from there... I dunno. This likely isn't helpful. But I hear you. I see you. I love you.

AC

If you have the bandwidth. . . Spontaneous songs are amazing - loved ‘Drowning in the sound’ and ‘8 in 8’

Melanie Meilleur

I have two pairs of arm-warmer things very similar to that arm-warmer thing, but neither just like it, and I'm poetically missing one. I haven't been in the woods of upstate for a long, long time (since...well before you left to tour TWBNI, probably 2017ish). It's not my Thing, but I love that some other lost Thing that looks like my lost Thing that could have been lost in the woods near Bard has shown up in your woods to inspire this (very small and not very significant) complete circle of Things in my world. The vast majority of us, I think, just want you to do what makes you feel the best, because the Things you put out when you feel good about them are generally the best Things. I do love the idea of some charity-directed project, since there's so much pain in the larger world that needs more money and attention, and putting some Aotearoa New Zealand Thing out to help focus attention there would be a beautiful thing to do. For me, personally, I get the most excited about getting music, no matter what the genesis - piano done spur of the moment, random ukulele ditties, demos, covers - whatever it is that you put into music that no one else does is a thing (Thing?) I crave. I'm still envious of everyone who got to hear the new song at the Colony shows - maybe a video of that for Patrons only would be a good Thing? Or the recording of you and Reb doing Reb's song that got done at the end of the Enjoy the Silence (I think?) recording session? I love Reb's version but the two of you create magic together. No matter what you decide to do, I have so much unfettered faith in you that it will be the right and best choice you could make in the moment it gets made. I know you can't talk about all the things that've happened over the last few years, but the thing that you don't really say but feels glaringly obvious is how badly damaged your willingness to trust has been, so I can't think of any more important return on the trust you give us here than returning it in kind. You are good and kind and we see you and love you and trust you to do your best. Buckets of love from a fully-swinging Mardi Gras week in NOLA. <3

Nicholas

Hi AFP, from a tent in Snowdonia. I don't need an arm warmer, even one as nice as that. I hope you are looking after yourself? There's a lot going on in the world but sometimes it is very OK to make your own world small enough for just you and those that are close. Just saying. As for Things? I like poetry and other Things but what I like most is you at the piano doing your Thing. That's what I like. Anyway, much love as always from the UK.

DebbieG

I think right now I need music the most, and the sunset piano sounds lovely. But I agree with others who have said don't stress about the Things that haven't been Thinged yet. Maybe they didn't speak to you as strongly as other Things that you released quickly, so maybe they are not ready to go out into the world yet. Follow your heart. I'm in no hurry for anything that isn't ready to emerge. I'm just happy to be here and read and listen to you and the rest of our community. And learn.

Sally

Sunset piano sounds sublime.

Michelle Brun

What I crave most is the music. I’m ever so excited about the new Dresden Dolls material, but it’d be such a shame to lose half-finished or near-finished songs into the ether. So if you’ve got old songs in the list of things you’re thinking of thing-ing, that’s where my vote goes. But only if you feel up to it and it’s what you want to do, of course. 💜

Emily Bek

In the spirit of goodnight moon, I give you answers in the form of a children’s book xx

Stephanie Rowe

I get the overwhelm and wanting to finish things but also start new things and not knowing which is the best direction to go towards. I just need a hug.

Jessica Petty

Did you decide against the monthly subscription? Don’t be too hard on yourself, just release the things you want to! :) I enjoy your songs, albums and your short writing pieces the most. :) Really loved the podcasts but also had to properly sit down and concentrate on them - I found I completely lost the topic of conversation when I tried to multitask! I never really tuned into a webcast due to the time zone (uk) and life getting in the way and the feeling I’d have to be 100% committed to however long it is… but I know it’s probably not so strict and I know others enjoy them!

Shiranne

It’s hard to see if someone else already asked, but do you know about Buy Nothing groups? Assuming no one already claimed the warmer thing, I’d post it to a local Buy Nothing group, and then someone will just come and take it. Zero effort. Nice interaction with a new local. It feels like something you’d like, if you don’t already do it. It’s helped me pass on so many things to people who can actually use them. I literally posted 3 partially used salt containers (we had too many) and people came and took them!!!!!! I don’t know if I can weigh in on what to Thing because with my own life chaos of the last 4.5 years, I haven’t been able to keep up with what you’ve already Thinged 🙈 So…do what makes you happy. And use clickbait style post titles so that I am more motivated to click through 😂💜

Tom Steiger

It’s obviously a snake sweater. Somewhere in the woods right now is a very chilly snake.

Dahlia

My vote is always for make some music, even if it’s reviving something old or a cover. Or how about a Patron only webcast with you AND Brian Viglione where you let us listen to you share ideas and talk about the excitement of playing more shows and discuss the meaning behind old songs or favorite songs and reminisce, but with us as active audience?

Mark

As an old time dolls fan and with the lead up to the dolls new album I’d love to hear some old unreleased songs/demo tapes/Aberdeen city sessions… I’d love to see some dolls archive Things - maybe a monthly related Dolls Thing could be a fun idea? It may also be less effort to put out if it’s from the vaults/not finished/polished. I’m only speaking for myself here but I love the Thinged Demos and BTS of the making of the songs and learning more about your creative process in crafting your music. Also loving all the Instagram piano streams and looking forward to seeing if some of these end up on the new album. The sunset piano video also sounds fabulous. Perhaps the Patreon can just all vote on a poll and whittle down the next thing to be put out? Like an elimination round type thing? Might be the easiest way to gauge it?

Emily

I didn’t see it until I read your comment, but that’s totally what it is! 🐍

Emily Tamas

Music - most especially piano music - remains my lifeline. And words - so thing the poetry ✨

Clair Rook

If you’re looking for something to thing, what is it that brings joy to your heart right now? What makes you happy? Thing that. That would make me happy ❤️

Corinna Naumann

If there was some music, it would be wonderful; if another thing is better for you now, I know there'll be music a bit later, and enjoy what you offer. Mainly, I want to offer you a hug and send you some love.

Elaine Wilson

I’d like a story about a true thing that happened, no matter how minor. I’d like a piano cover of a song released in the late ‘80s or early ‘90s, which is my era.

Erin Mannion

I vibrate to the idea of a story or a poem, something simultaneously wonderful & excruciating at the same time. That's how life feels to me these days, and has for quite some time now, and I find myself always snagged on things that strike these dual chords at the same time. I imagine it's how a lot of your existence feels through the strangeness that has unfolded over the last fews years 💙 but really, I find that most anything you share with the world rings with a rare note of authenticity & truth, which is why I love to support you and all of scraps & bits & baubles you put into the universe.

Rebecca Brisbin

I wouldn't mind hearing the piano piece you mentioned, but everything in it's own time as you feel the need. Thank you. I always feel like I get far more than my money's worth. I'm excited to catch you live in Tacoma. My friend surprised me with a ticket. :)

Greyson

Music is always welcomed! And I am super curious to see what comes out of the thing shoebox in due time if you and the team have the energy or motivation to do some excavation.

Fannie

I agree with the patrons who said they'd enjoy some small things rather than big projects which might be too complex and time consuming for now, and also to maybe just release some old things in the imperfect state that they're in. Also, what I often enjoy the most aren't necessarily the "things" but rather your other posts in which you just talk about something in your life or on your mind and your thoughts about it. For example, in 2020 you once wrote about taking a different way than usual on your walk home with Ash, and how Ash suddenly wanted to go back and take the old way, and you said, we're too far along. It's too late for the old way. That really struck me, it was exactly what I needed to hear at the time, as I had a hard time letting go of some things although I knew they were basically over and no longer good or right for me. And what you wrote helped me so much at that moment. I also loved your short video of yourself singing the little tune about thanking the women dropping her kid off to camp in lipstick and high heels. For me that was about showing up just as you are, in whatever way feels right to you at the moment, and I loved that. I also really love the livecasts. My favorite was the livecast with Sophie Strand and Holly Miranda. So for me, it's often not so much the "official things" which I like the most, it's rather that you show up as you are, authentic and imperfect, and sometimes you write or put out things which are inspiring and exactly what I need to hear. So, yeah... I don't know if that helps :) If you ask me, just do whatever you feel like and what you have the time and energy for. If it has to be a "thing", it can basically be anything, imo, it doesn't have to be big or perfect or new.

Amber Rhapsody Jet

As a full-time knitter, I must say that your Thing is Inside-Out. It does look like it is hand knit. Either an arm-warming sleeve or a legwarmer. It is difficult to tell without other objects in the pic to give a sense of scale. A pair of these things would have taken about a week to knit, possibly longer of it has a complex texture. I hope you can return it to the fiber artist or knitworthy recipient that still has the Thing's mate. 💖

Hannah Schumacher

Oh my god, yes, the lighthouse stream! That thing last year was one of the most beautiful musical experiences I've ever had. If not this month, I'd love to have one of those again sometime :) What would pacify my heart right now. Huh. Super honestly: Knowing that somewhere out there really is a village for me. I still haven't found what I'm looking for. Those who love me most don't ever seem to get along. And these days I'm just so tired from trying and failing to connect with new people, I constantly hear Eleanor Rigby playing in the distance like the jaws theme. So yeah: Hope that new love can still grow from my life, somehow, someday, something real.

Nathan Williams

Music or poetry music is my favorite . Creatively mangled and interesting cover songs are fun too !

Skyeanna Malito

For me the thing I need right now is music. Everything else feels too hard to take in well with how frazzled my brain is.

Wendy Dale Williams

Over the years that I have followed you, I notice that in almost every post, you say that you are exhausted. All this stuff(except Ash) is not worth it. You don’t have to do everything.

amandapalmer

there has been a lot of downturn across all of patreon. the world is belt-tightening. it’s …. a thing.

Aimsel Ponti

music is always top of my list. also the abortion podcast stuff. Xx

Aeryll McGuire

As someone who writes and creates, I’m overwhelmed in this existence we have now with everything going on in the world. I am positive everyone here would be grateful for whatever feels good to you (and doable) to put out, no matter how big or small.

Nancy Shanteau

I always want you to do what makes your heart sing, to think of us as Amanda-genius facilitators, and not to owe us anything. Please rest, ditch the to do list, listen to the flow within you. Thing being Amanda-Fucking-Palmer if you need to do that. How you do being you is SO worth it! <3

Nancy Shanteau

Also, I find myself overwhelmed and can barely handle anything right now. I like reading your poems, and listening to music. I can hardly do anything of any length though. Short, easy things; already done things that don't need launching; you sitting with Ash -- any of that is fine with me. This message is already enough

Daniel Allen

What do I need? That's a heavy question with a lot of different answers. Took me a while to sift through and actually grasp the question the way you were asking it. And with that question, I need music. I need something to sing along with. In short, I need a moon to howl at.

Fiona Southwood

Read The Myth of Normal by Gabor Mate and use the thing as a bookmark

amandapalmer

it seems to me that people just want to be calmed. calming things. i wonder honestly what’s the best way to do that.

Laura Morland

You thinged nothing in January? I was so surprised that I had to go into my account and look -- and indeed, I see you only charged me $10 last month, plus $2 tax. That's never happened before! Well, I'm sorry, Amanda -- that must be a major cut into your monthly income. On the other hand, you did have the New Year's Eve concert outside L.A., and perhaps that made up for it a bit. On the other hand, you got to spend a nice chunk of time with Ash in Aetearoa, and not pressuring yourself to produce something (besides the Althing) must have been worth it! Is the pressure to "thing" part of why you're thinking of changing to a flat monthly fee? In that case, I'll switch up to the $25 level. (I'm currently at $10, capped at three, but you haven't gone past three in a while, I don't think, or even past two.)

Laura Morland

Hmmm... interesting, because the economy is apparently getting better. Maybe in a year's time the numbers will reflect that? Anyway, you give so much more of yourself than anyone else on this platform, so far as I can tell. I've joined about eight or nine other creators' Patreons at your suggestion (and a few more on my own), but nobody compares 2 U.

Caroline Gaudy

I'd be happy with whatever is easiest for you AND makes your heart happy. If Mama A isn't happy, ain't nobody around here gonna be happy, right? If those two questions, what's easiest? and what makes me happiest? are too hard right now... get a pile of post-its, write the top of your head list of possible Things, lay them out and literally throw a dart or a penny or something at them and where ever it lands, there's your THING. It could work, yanno? much love to you, always.

Mike C.

Calm us! Lots of love Mike

Tony Ivanova

Well, if you ask - Emergency Soothing Music session would definitely help. I'm still listening to the Hello Lighthouse piano improvisation that you did in New Zealand once in a while, when my mind is completely overwhelmed. But, of course, almost everything helps. It was very calming to see the video of your walk with Ash and to hear the zombie rabbit story. Love.

Avren Keating

I saw someone earlier mention a Cat Stevens cover. A Peace Train cover would be calming and also the OOWWAHHEEEAAHHHOOWAHHH is silly and joyful and you'd slay

Kaleigh

I love when you read short poems, or play short music sketches........ Those small moment things are really calming.. Take the time you need that is the most important thing. The Sky is perfect. <3

Titus

A friend of mine knits them to order and sells them on eBay. I had her make a pair in deep green with golden woolen fibers in the pattern of dragon scales for a loved one.

amacker

First a thing about the thingy… if it were my thingy, I’d make a pair of fingerless gloves from it. If you would like that, I’d be happy to make them for you!

amacker

Now about a Thing… I crave some good dance music done by someone who’s songwriting is not often categorized as dance music these days at least. Some real AFP dance music, with a wicked beat, and perhaps some Arabic drumming so I could belly dance to it as well? Just thinking out loud. I love dictation, even though it fucks up many of the most obvious words, and doesn’t understand more obscure words at all.

Ariel

I need thunderstorms, and growing things, and sunlight on my face. I think we are in that point of winter where it seems as if it should already be spring, but the forecast says there is at least on more cold snap on the way. By which I mean, I think I need hope?

Caitlin Brown

I am fairly lonely in my thinking, but sometimes I still fantasize about you burning all the Things you used for the There Will Be No Intermission art book. Would still love to see all the artifacts, stories, and trauma go up in glorious flame.

Dolly

We want ALL the things. Give us whatever thing, you're ready to thing

Cyn

I am in such a state of overwhelm, I'm paralyze for what to do next, what to do first, how to get help, it's a lot. I wish I had a backlog of creativity but I'd LOVE to see yours.

MrsLilisha

The warmer looks pretty, but what I need is spring. I want to work in my little garden. I need the feeling of the warm sun, the look and smell of fresh green, the flowers. But I don't have to wait that long anymore. 1-2 month. I can do it. Greetings from Germany.

Lynn Robinson

Sunset piano sounds what my ear and soul need right now .Much love to you my exhausted friend. ❤️

Ryan Stuck

This will likely sound cold, and I really don't want it to, but I'm an engineer so I just think like this (apologies in advance). I recognize you have to deliver; seems like the best path forward for your model is like @DrWex and others said - release something small, easy to encapsulate and complete. Monthly small Things seem perfectly reasonable. Hell, I'd be happy with a sky picture. From reading the comments, music seems to be a very popular choice - not sure if it's really small enough, but covers seem the way to go. I'm personally totally down for a cover or two. Pick a cover, any cover, I think people would be happy, I would. I know you joked, but with the right tweaking I think you could do NWA, or perhaps some Wu Tang 😉 I think ODB (edit: yes, I know ODB isn't in this song, and yes, I know that the main riff is a piano sample) would've been proud of a piano rendition of C.R.E.A.M. Now that I've typed it, I think it has to be Thinged. Think about it 😁 Just dawned on me, Biz Markie - Just a Friend is already arranged for piano! Slam dunk!

braincolor

Maybe you need a currator? You are the Indiana Jane of Things. You search for them, find them, create them, dig them up. And then you bring it to your curator so that she/he/zir/them make it ready for exhibition, which you then only have to give your blessing. That would at least be something that I need, because I am also a Thing Finder. :)

Deniz Bevan

Ooh, if I could knit faster, I'd make a matching one for you! I like the idea of an NZ thing for charity. I'm here. Processing every day as it comes. Having a creative outlet (in this case, storywriting) helps a LOT with dealing with the every day and with grander scheme things <3

Michael Hargreave Mawson

If I could pick someThing - anyThing - for you to Thing, it would be a new AFP song. A Thing Song. Perhaps a Sing Song Thing Thong?

Michael Hargreave Mawson

Oh, and the Forest Thing? It's a Unicorn's horn warmer. Perhaps Ash could track down its owner and return it?

Lucy Russell

Music thing, any music, that's my shout. But anything that is created is enough. Am getting braver about putting my things out there. I love your music things. Just start chucking them at us from the pile. I have piles and piles of things. Real and metaphorical. And I need to let them go, too. So just let whatever thing comes to the top of the pile go to us. It will then be the right thing in that moment.

Kirrabelle Lovell

1. Something for NZ 2. The poem Or whatever you like!

Soso

Wow... so many people have commented already! I trust the group, whatever floats to the top, I'm good with it. Soothing piano would have been my first choice and that'd maybe help you ease into songwriting more than a poem would. ANYTHING GOES! Sending warm hugs and strength as you go through this triage period. We are here!

Soso

Don't stress too much over it and don't be afraid to ask for help. It will come to you eventually! <3

Laura Wellner

The forest thing...if there isn't a thumb hole, it's a leg warmer, it's too pretty to throw away, someone must be missing their thing, reuniting it might take some time, a lost n' found sort of thing, make signs and post them in the area...hopefully the person attached to the thing will be happy to see their thing again! Other things to thing...definitely a thing for New Zealand, yes, absolutely! Seeing what I have seen of the damage is a reminder of how fragile everything is; it's scary. I have played your Soothing Piano thing every Sunday morning, and it's very much made a home in my life (I've been fairly sad lately. My wee donkey has been feeling poorly, but she keeps on keeping on, all I can do is keep feeding her lots of love and maintain her quality of life.) I hear you about having too many projects hanging around one's neck. I am slowly picking through them and then always finding new ones to start in the process...I've been overwhelmed lately and have ended up doing everything else but those things. I'll get back to them; a busy brain break is necessary at times to refocus. Pick a thing, do it. Get it done. Love & hugs!

kat_ahead

I absolutely support the "any music will help" party. The long NZ-Tho h might be also something I'd enjoy. Lately, for last couple of years it's your insight on motherhood, that helps me navigating through my own mess of parenting, friending, working and meing. Sending love and hugs and soothe.

wombat_67

Emergency soothing piano really helped me last year. So I would vote for that. But really, anything you want to do (or nothing at all) is fine. Take your time ❤️

Claire

i don’t know how others feel about this, but i think it’s okay to release an unfinished Thing. sometimes releasing something partially finished allows us to step back and do More Things.

EmVT

hi David, I connect with so much of this, thanks for writing!

Hanna Mokijewska

Voicerambles, videos.........behind the scenes when you're creating Things. Discussing artists, and world and how to be an artists and how to be a woman and an artist and a mother and a daughter and How to fit all of those personas INside and not feel disconnected? Songs, people....emotions....

Wendy S. Katz

I so relate to the TOO MUCH problem. For me it's too much to take in on top of too much to do. So soothing music sounds wonderful. I enjoy the posts that are small bites of your wisdom, but anything that takes prolonged attention on my part gets put in the "later" folder.

Lauren Wilde

It’s probably too late now, but I loved the emergency soothing piano thing, and I would be more than happy with something else like that. I don’t mind unfinished or in-progress Things - you give a lot of yourself and your process, you’re one of the most giving Patreon creators I’ve ever supported. Do what feels right. But I did love the piano thing from NZ. I listen to the mp3 all the time.

TMR Bennett

One of the aspects of your Patreon I have always loved is the real time humanity of it. You are vulnerable and real with us in a way that is difficult and brave for anyone to do, much less someone with a very public career. Given that, I am happy to receive Things in whatever order or nature feels right to you, whether that is a sequence of things you enjoy or an order entirely random. Life is messy, and you are letting us into your life, so I have no prescriptions.

Alexander McKenzie

Music, please. Your own music if possible. Or whatever you decide.

Drag Queen Jesus

I'm SO sorry to tell you this Amanda/AFP community. That is not a thing. I emailed Fox News and they got back to me...

Lilai

I got on the Patreon just before the pandemic hit. And then for a year i kept all the patreon emails and read none of them. And i then i learnt it's okay to delete them when i don't have the brainspace to read them. And I keep thinking I'm going to stop supporting the patreon because, do i even take in any art that Amanda makes anymore? But i haven't. And sometimes i think it's just because those kind of post reminds me that we're all just pretending we've got it together, when we don't. But that's okay.

Amy Tobol

Wear the thing. Adorn it, get it dirty, pin little gifts on it, give the gifts away and add more. Then, if the owner steps up, give it back.

Josh Harrison

What would pacify my heart right now? Honestly, having you share your creative struggles in the wake of /waves hands vaguely at the world/ helps me. I feel less alone when it comes to my own creative difficulties. My wife passed in November 2020 (complications from Covid). I've always had a little bit of executive dysfunction when it comes to long-term projects. Finding myself a single dad of two (wonderful) kids sure didn't help that. (It's getting better.) There's value in sharing. It's important to recognize what we have gone through (and *continue* to go through). Sometimes it feels like "the world" just wants to move on and ignore the suffering and trauma we've endured. Back at the beginning of the year, I wrote a blog post (my blog having languished for years) looking back at what I *had* accomplished, rather than what I hadn't. I resolved to be kinder to myself, and grant *myself* the space and empathy I need. It's not always easy, but... at least it puts the thought in my head.

Gabrielle Shearer

I am just reading this now, as I procrastinate starting what will be a long workday. As I look at the glove, and think, as I always do, that I'm surprised and moved by your reaching out to ask what we need, and even more so, by the struggle not to feel guilty or pressured to catch up, to do more to produce. Then I thought, in a bout of self-pity, hang on. I work more than full-time, and have been a single parent with full support of my kids for over a decade. Each month, that adds up to 160-200 hours in which h I write for a paycheck and have no energy nor time to write my stories . Then I do for my kids, friends, life and of course it's not enough. I can't keep up. But I don't want you to do that with your art. I want your art to be a thumb in the eye of produce, keep up, never enough. Because it feels like if we can't have a little space here to support art, to create breathing room for art and one another, where and when is it ever possible? Thank you for all this, and for this little moment to take a break and think about something besides what i must do next. ❤️

Aleisha Hobson

I often don't even find the energy to read or listen to the things I am a patron for so at least you're actually thinking about achieving something! I love your livestreams when I catch them, would love some new songs or even new versions of old songs to listen to. I miss your voice! But mostly I just want you to be kind to yourself cos this life shit is hard. Keep the thing. Wear it. Add it to ash's costume collection. Or hang it up in the woods and hope it is reclaimed.

Jenna Tomlin

Your Voice Rambles live in my heart. Otherwise, I might suggest plunging your hand into the exploding box of "half done projects" grabbing one and finishing it. Just one.

Anne Morgyn

there's a visceral satisfaction to completing something half done that I wish for you to feel and revel in. if one item speaks to your heart maybe do just that one to get the endorphin rush of completing just. one. thing. then fill in the gaps with whatever to pay the bills. this is the advice I'm giving myself anyway as I sit at my desk working my way through my list of long overdue items in favor of putting out immediate fires and being happily waylaid in doing anything to come here on patreon to read about and commiserate with your (and probably everyone else's) similar mundane struggles.

Fannie

Just wanted to add that I loved the Instagram live you did today, playing the piano, that was so beautiful :)

Meredith Cohen

Do not try to “catch up”. Release yourself from the burden of the backlog and start fresh from where you are now. Those things are not “unfinished”. They were a part of your process. I want you to have the relief of letting go of that sense of obligation, and feel light and free to do what you feel now. If an old project calls to you, follow that call - or just thank them for their part in your journey and let them go and see what new awaits. LET IT GO 🎶

EmVT

Josh, I'm so sorry to hear of the loss of your wife, sending healing thoughts your way. Glad to hear it's getting better :)

Lindsay Rickman

This post is what I needed. Exactly what I needed, thank you. I feel like we're all going through similar... uh... things...lol

amandapalmer

Oh Josh. This makes me feel very wonderful and terrible. I’m sorry about your loss. And I am so glad to know I have been any kind of company in the wake. xxx

Josh Harrison

Thanks, Amanda. (You also expressed condolences to me in Twitter ages ago, not that I expect you to remember.) I'll be seeing you live in Boston (for the first time) in April (with my new girlfriend). I'm really looking forward to it.

DebbieG

I am sorry for your loss. There has been so much over the past few years. Best to you and your wonderful kids.

Joe Kirkus

I just enjoy reading your words, seeing your pictures, and hearing your music. I can’t afford to give much at all for it, but I do enjoy these things you share with us.

Hazel Sound

Love you Amanda. As so many others have said, let the old half done thing shoebox explode. Don't try to pick up threads of the old - let yourself do some tiny new thing, small and fresh. Doesn't matter if it's a bit squashed. Newborns often are. In writing this I realise that I need to do this myself. So many hanging threads here too. But incomplete is okay. It's the way of things 🌻💛🌼

Laura Morland

Us getting to be a fly on the wall for Surface Pressure was amazing! I was able to watch the entire afternoon/evening session. What a revelation. I loved every minute of it... being in the control room, in the studio, in the sound booth....

MPB

I think others have probably already said it better but I’d suggest leaving the backlog behind. Start fresh. Free yourself. And if there’s something in the backlog you can’t bear the thought of leaving behind then it’s no longer in the backlog. It’s in the Now, it’s resonating with you for a reason, so claim it and keep moving forward. I also love the voice rambles.

Meghan Sutherland

I am here for the pieces of yourself, your life, your authenticity and your creative process you so freely share. I’m learning (so late in life) how to be vulnerable, creative, how to ask and feel worthy of receiving. You are showing me how. I want to be reminded of the hardness and heartbreak of it all while still being firmly oriented towards hope and love. Just keep showing up and so will I.

Kacy Pate

What do I need? No one asks me that- that’s what make you so special to me. I need for you to be free to be you. Your art helps me find the unspoken parts of

James Paladino

One thing that I only recently realized I needed was community outside of my family and friends. Tangible events where everyone is in a space and ready to receive what’s to come. That really came into focus when my fiancé and I attended your Home Alone screening this winter. You handed us mulled cider as we walked in, and it just felt so comforting to be recognized and shown kindness in that way. Often, I feel very transitory in daily life when I’m not at home or work. Event excursions for events take place in a bubble between my friends/fiancé and I. Despite being an introvert, I’m nourished by meaningful and intentional interactions with people. That Home Alone screening felt like I was part of a community for almost two hours, and I can’t even describe how much I needed something like that. Thank you for that, Amanda. Community is an action, and it was nice to be reminded of that.

Birdy Black

I need you to wash that thing, amanda.

Timothy Kreuter

Exactly! If it’s important/necessary to be Thinged, it’s not really backlogged. I mean, a lot of us were waiting for ages to hear Dresden Dolls perform again or release more music, and we stuck around. Staying power isn’t at a deficit with this group, so if it takes a month to complete, it takes a month. The only things (not Things) we all want is for you to keep engaging as best you can, and continue being gentle but badass with yourself.

Charlene Tarsa

I’m late to the party as usual, but yes to all of this.I joined the patreon when I realized i missed you perform at the O positive festival and have been trying (and failing) to “catch up” since then. Not. Possible. You have made so much! And I love knowing I’m supporting one of my favorite artists, and it’s worth it to me to know I get to see you perform in April. In addition, I just took a trip to a very red, very anti abortion rights part of the world to support my grieving aunt. I love my aunt but vehemently disagree with her on politics and religion, and being surrounded by the , ah, EXTRA right wing American Catholic community, and biting my tongue practically in HALF… knowing I’m supporting you really helped me get through it. Thank you. Please be kind to yourself and let go of that capitalist mindset. Much love