Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello my loves.

I just wrote a little thing for social media and it made me so weepy I wanted to share it over here as well. I know we thinged this piece with Luke recently - but….it’s so good and it’s #worldpianoday!!! 🎹♥️🎉

So: a word.

Maybe someday I’ll play a piano to a stadium of 50,000 people like Elton John, Billy Joel. Maybe someday I’ll finally get my Beethoven down and play Carnegie Hall in a black dress.

Who knows.

But to be able to play piano in spontaneous and perfect harmony like this - with a fellow pianist - surrounded by friends and food and kids and wine and dogs….this is what success feels like to me.

If you do it right: this is how it ends. You get to do THIS.

I have been playing (and struggling with) pianos all over the world for 40+ years. i had a difficult relationship with the instrument when I was growing up. I didn’t like practicing, and I didn’t have the skills - or patience, perhaps - for sight-reading. I often felt like a failure.

I’ve learned to overcome all of that. The way I play music is the way I play music. I no longer let “good/real piano player” and “bad piano player” exist as a binary in my mind. We are all just playing.

And nothing has brought me pleasure like this eleven minutes I spent improvising with my piano-brother Luke Gajdus on a mountaintop in New Zealand a few months ago, the day before I flew home to America.

I was so full of hard feelings. Joy. Sorrow. Ambivalence. Confusion. Gratitude - so much gratitude.

The piano caught it all, held it all.

The film was released here via patreon. Had I not had patrons, I probably wouldn’t have made this film. I am always indebted to them for inspiring and cheerleading me.

You made this with me. You are holding me in this moment.

Luke and I made this entire piece up as we went along.

But it took us decades to be able to play like this. We speak a language. Piano-ese.

Play for the joy.

Play for the joy.

Sing cause it’s obvious.

Sing with your strings, with your drums, with your hands, with your brush.

It doesn’t matter how or where or when or why.

Just sing.

I love you all. I’m reading comments for new r hour or so, then again in the morning.

Althing tomorrow (probably). I’m working on it.

xx

AFP

Files

Previews only

AMANDA PALMER & LUKE GAJDUS - Neither Here Nor There

Filmed live on January 25th, 2022 at Bob's Cove, Te Waipounamu, Aotearoa New Zealand. Host: Simone Flight Cameraman: Ben Farry Song composed by Luke Gajdus & Amanda Palmer This undertaking was supported and funded by over 10,000 gorgeous art-loving patrons at patreon.com/amandapalmer. A portion of the the funds from this project will be given to recently-needed flood relief efforts run by Māori Iwi/locals. If you want to help, wherever you are in the world: please do so here: https://www.manaakimatakaoa.com/floodrelief I tell the whole story of this project (with more photos) here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/79051495 Most important: Luke is a full-time piano busker who I met out in the streets of Queenstown, on the South Island of Aotearoa New Zealand. If you'd like to learn more about Luke's work (and see some more of his beautiful outdoor piano videos), please go to: https://lukegajdus.com/. Leave him a tip. It'd mean a lot. A copy of the audio recording was sent to digital-download level patrons, you can follow the link and download the recording here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/79051495 Kia kaha koutou. Arohanui. -AFP

Comments

Shane Thornton

I’ve been listening to it the past two days. It really is beautiful, thank you. I love you

Tammy Meier

Just wanted to send love and support, and say thank you for all the love and support you give.

Nechyfer5

Thank you as always for telling us your experiences. I want to share this with my 10year old who plays by ear and can/does get frustrated. It’s beautiful music, setting, and a piano friend!!! Much love!!! 🥰🤩

Joanna Lindblad

This reminds me of my Mom who passed away a while ago from cancer. She loved to play the piano. But also used it to take out frustrations when my Father was running late, and the rest of my family had to wait. Even though she played to find the calm, I listened and found the joy. Thanks for the reminder... the memory (((❤️)))

Kris Smerick

“Sing” is the very first song I heard by you, on a lonely New Year’s Eve with my silent absent husband asleep in our bed. And that is all it took. Suddenly I wasn’t so alone. I too play piano and question my identity as a “player.” It has taken me til now to just throw myself into playing music, well or poorly. Just Sing.

Carmen J

Needed that for my hour plus drive to the hospital for my oncology review. Thank you. 💜

Justine Rydzeski

So love this Thing - Patreon at its best. I know how hard it is to get there. (Piano was my primary instrument.). It takes soooo much time and attention and muscle memory and practice to get to a place of letting go, of just playing. And joy. Thanks for sharing all that! While we’re on pianos, do you find playing electronic pianos frustrating, not having the dynamic range and the hammer on strings strike of an acoustic? You kind of play beyond an electronic piano’s capabilities….

Kristin Ryan

This gives me so much hope that soon I will write again. I love you. 💜

Dave R

Love this!!!

Sara Nelson

Thank you. I needed this. I just had a miscarriage and I'm really lost and sad. Thank you Amanda, for making the music I can't.

Kym Dorst

That was gorgeous, thank you so much for sharing that with us! 💜

Douglas Neudeck

Good lord, what a journey in sound. At some point I got lost (found?) and pictured you with a variety of seeds in your hands, walking along a path. The seeds were sharp, and you were looking for somewhere to plant them- they didn't belong to you anymore. As you planted them and said goodbye, the burden eased. When you were finished, you had come full circle, and the seeds had sprouted, then flowered. You walked along, collecting the blooms, which were also sharp, and cutting- but each had their beauty and purpose.

EmVT

beautiful counterpoint to the ice pellets pelting my window :) very happy making watching you two play together, easy on the eyes, and easy on the heart after a long day. looking forward to Carnegie Hall! dream setlist - hoping for Leeds United, and of course The Ride and Drowning in the Sound, maybe On an Unknown Beach 👀

Kirsten Dallas

World piano day… oof. Ok… I don’t usually comment on things because I’m just kinda taciturn (though I always love reading your words!) but this is a weird coincidence and I don’t want to ignore it. I would love some advice from anyone who sees this and might have helpful knowledge or experience. My father was an amazing pianist. Super magical. Childhood was a dream within a piano fort, while he played Nocturnes overhead. A few months ago, he passed away, and left his piano to me. (I’m rusty, but promise the cosmos I’ll practice now.) It is currently still in Colorado at his girlfriend’s house, and I need to get it to my house in rural Washington. I keep reading horror stories from people who have used moving companies, and so I’ve been too paralyzed to move forward, even months later. But it causes me anxiety every day the piano is not here with me. If anything is a symbol of my father, it is this piano. So… does anyone have experience moving a precious piano across the country? Any companies you really really trust? Any to absolutely avoid? Should I just fly out there and have someone pack it and then drive it back myself? I’m so very stuck. Thank you in advance, anyone seeing this, for any insight. Happy piano day, y’all. ♥️ Oh and ps. lovelovelove this video! Poetry. (edited to add: the piano is a baby grand, so a little trickier to move)

Coila

Sometimes it blows my mind how parallel our lives are. In the last week, I've realized not only all the piano means to me but that my kind of playing and my kind of music is ok. It's ok that I've never learned a piece 100% through without mistakes (though I still want to and have a piece I'm working on). It's ok if I play a lot of pop, musicals and Disney songs. I miss my jam sessions and need to find new jamming friends. Most importantly, I need to stop being so picky when I can't just play for 3-4 hours at a time. I love my life the way it is and 10-60min blocks will do fine for now. I speak piano-ese. I'm rusty but I speak it and the ache in my soul that's been longing for more will no longer go unnoticed.

Jeremy Sliwoski

As in life, you're not given 88 keys to play with only ten fingers.

Tara Goddard

Damn, that is just gorgeous. The years and years and callouses and struggles for motivation and discipline to get to a point where you can improvise like that, and with someone else to boot, well. Thank you.

Bruce Cooper

Methodically whimsical 🎶🎶

Andrew Funk

I'm sorry for what will be a long post. But the story as much as the music got me in all the places of my heart. And it reminded me of one of my own journeys with music. When I first picked up the guitar, I tried lessons for a few months. But due to my cacophony of mental illnesses, I just couldn't wrap my head around the lessons. So I quit and I taught myself. It took years and many nights of bloodied fingers but I taught myself well enough to write the songs that stirred in my soul. I'm a terrible technical player but I know how to write my songs. And that's all I ever felt I needed. About two years ago, something extraordinary and bizarre happened to me with music. I got devastating news that my cousin had lost her fight, and was going into hospice from her breast cancer. I wrote and recorded her a little piece of music which thankfully made it to her in time before she passed. From the day she passed and for a few months after, I started composing all kinds of classical pieces. What's strange about it is that I don't know the first thing about playing or writing classical guitar. I've never been able to play it before. Not even remotely. Yet here I was, day after day writing and playing in ways I never dreamed I could. And then one day a couple months later, it was gone. I could no longer play any of it. I video recorded many of the compositions on my phone so I could remember how to play them. But the ability to do so was and still is gone. And I haven't written a single song since. Music is strange and beautiful. And apparently sometimes it gives you superpowers so you can heal from those moments where nothing else seems to help.

Dawn Grib

Everything about this is WONDERFUL. <3 <3 <3

Jen

Sending love and light to you ❤️❤️❤️

Jen

❤️❤️❤️

Christina C.

I'm new here so I've been doing an AFP deep dive into all "the things" which has become a sort of rehab for me the past few days. After being a background fan of yours for years, and even though I was a backer on one of your things in the past, I took way too long to come over here and be part of your Patreon. But I'm here now and wow what magic. Your IG video last week about lube and church bells was the tipping point. Coincidentally I watched the one you've posted here just last night before I fell asleep. And exactly what I was thinking when I took it all in is that, hell yes, this is the life. Everything in one video. Piano music to light a fire in the soul, beautiful cinematography, landscape that makes that easy, dogs children tents, food, kids running around, friends pulling up lawn chairs with their plates, and no jackets required. There is nothing else more that matters in this world. The terrain in parts of NZ and Australia remind me a lot of where I live. Summers here are spent outside just like that with family friends & tribe folks on mountains where you have to take dirt bikes and horses to get to or on the shores of the lakes and rivers you can make simple hikes to. 9 years ago my father died from a heart attack during a two week family / friend camping and boating trip he planned for us all on the lake here. It took years for me to go back to that lake even though I practically grew up on it. But as sad as it is we lost him, he died having lived two work/stress free weeks of bliss on the water he loved so much as a fisherman. The last time I ever saw him we were laying on the boat staring up at the stars with zero light polition talking about the constellations. I'm at a cross roads right now. As much as I love it here where I live, there has been so much trauma, much of it condensed into the last five years and a few lingering years before that, pandemic hell squeezed into all of it. Just non-stop crisis, incident after incident. Even before that I never truly felt I belong here in this place as a person. Some people here are my people, but this is not my place. My hometown is like your piano and I'm not sure Im bad or good at this intrument, I simply feel like it's not mine anymore. The political landscape is a nightmare- especially for myself and the rest of the LGBTQ community. The culture and arts (while not entirely dead anymore like it used to be) are mostly stale. Every place has its artists music makers theater nerds performers and muralist. But mixed into the small amount of beauty that is blooming in those areas, there is still a lot of trash heaps to navigate, a lot of Karenism, and a lot of fake it till you make it happening from folks who are just fine with the fake part and probably have no real intentions of making anything. All artists, many people, feel imposter syndrom. But there is truly nasty amounts of fraudulence here. I'm not trying to be a judge because we all do it, we are all hypocrites from time to time and who am I to determine if one person's type of messiness is less elite and punk than mine? But something is in the Kool Aid here. The ignorance and pride prevalent here, even in the cultured places and music places and art places and performance places is fierce and embedded into everything. It leaves little room for vulnerability intimacy and authenticity. Those things must be fought for in any place one find themselves, I know that. But here it is Its relentless and awkward and dominant. People flee here like cultural refugees every day. Ive never seen anything like it not even in Hollywood. It doesn't help that we have one of the largest mega churches in the world here, globally famous for their *contributions to the "arts" and locally famous for digging corrupt tentatcles into all aspects of local governement and visits with Trump. I told a friend at dinner tonight who was visiting from LA that this city is like something AI created... haunting and beatiful in a weird way but also not authentic, so unreal and quite obviously robotic. I miss the rich authenticity found in the more diverse places Ive lived in the past. I want to go back or somewhere new. But I also dont want to leave my family or my lifelong friends or the warriors I stand side by side working to-without many victories-prevent a total and outright destruction of our commmunity by megamaga hatred and lunacy. I don't want to leave any of them behind but I do not feel at home here. The moment captured in this video reminds me of something very important though. Something obvious. Something I dont want to be reminded of because of how fatigued I've been. And that is that what I'm actually hungry for can be created anywhere I am and that even though I'm fatigued maybe it's time to try again instead of leaving. Yours, particularly this video, are part of a string of creations I've been finding reading hearing and ingesting to help me decide what comes next and finally process what just happened. I think what happened to you with NZ has become a great gift for you to bestow on us. I was there in the background lurking watching it play out in real time on social media but I wasn't truly paying attention because I haven't truly been able to pay attention to much over the last few years but whats in front of my own nose. It's truly been some therapy to come here on Patreon and scroll back to how you navigated those seas. I wish I had looked harder for your lighthosue when I was still out on the seas, I could have really used it then. But retrospect is sometimes a better teacher and hearler than real time and my heart mind and soul are prepped to receive from all the great poets of right now. My pandemic years were an unreal technonic shift for me in some of the same ways you express. My mother was diagnosed with cancer in May of 2020, her sister (basically my second Mom) died from cancer one month after that and in the middle of it all we had to somehow run a business in COVID-19 lockdown and protocol situations. And, like Austrailia, our city and surrounding areas had just been recovering from three deadly life altering wildfires. And now the political/ governmental upheaval destroying the careers of my friends, luring other friends into hysteria, the removal of county programs that help the most marginalized and destitute, removal of important LGBTQ recognitions and partnerships. A fuck ton of trash burning in dumpsters every where you turn. It has been a whirlwind with very little catharsis. Until now. Pretty much JUST now. Like literally only a few months have I been out of that dark tunnel and able to feel the trauma and the growth, with clarity and rawness. And with that, it's decision time. Do I stay, in the midst of a political / governmental nightmare and cultural black hole, refuse to abandon my beatiful friends also livijnf that nightmare, get my strength all the way back from the fatigue that stole it and go back to creating the communal tapestry I crave with the small handful of my people who "get it"? Or do I flee as a cultural and political refugee to real safety so I can find that tapestry or creat it somewhere in an environment where I am allowed to exist more free as the person I am? Like most people my hand might be forced by what professional opportunities exists. We may have to shut our business down leaving me with a true clean slate. Part of my AFP rehab isn't just soaking up the pure heart you offer us in your creations, but also, as an artist and entrepreneur, being re inspired by the possibilities of true professional freedom and community as you and yours have brought forth. Well, that was a lot of words. (I get wordy when I'm triggered and mass shootings that involve children tend trigger me.) Back to deep dive rehab I go so I can Enjoy The Silence.

Robyn Lees

I was learning the piano, though I do better going by sound than sheet music sometimes, but when Biscuit passed away last year, I stopped. When I tried a few times to play again, I couldn't bear not having him next to me while I played. He was always next to me either snoring his head off, chewing his feet or pestering for strokes. I need to get back to it

Hannah Schumacher

AH! This beauty. I feel this so much. I've just finished recording my very first very own banjo improvisation over a friend's song, and it's far from perfect but it's undeniably GOOD, and it actually expresses what I feel. What is this magic? And why can you dance to it? I love you, Amanda, I love Luke, I love the piano, keep channeling the flow. <3

AnnaLatchman

I remember last year in a liveshow I asked if you ever sit at the piano "for fun" or outside of practising for shows. And it was a pretty sad time, and you said it's been a long time. It's nice to see this piano relationship grow again. I don't play any instruments but I can see what they do for people. Looking forward to your lighthouse video!

Angel Rosen

Over the weekend, my good friend had a birthday. For her birthday, she wanted all of her talented friends to get together and make art. Five people playing instruments (drums, guitars, omnichord, tambourine) while she sang and I recited poems that fit her lyrics. I even sang a little. It was so cool. Sitting in a dark basement with people who were just freely connecting their art with no goal other than connection...? I thought to myself this is what "making it" looks like. We are going to do it again & try to get some cool recordings of the song x spoken poem experiments. I can't wait to see you in one month 🥰

Drag Queen Jesus

I was not in a good mood when I started watching this video, actually I'm not in a particularly good mood now, but every now and then, while watching this, a grin would sneakily stretch across my face that was representative of something deeper within. Hello deeper-within. Thank you for playing to that part of me!

Stewart Witt

It's like this "improvising with my piano-brother Luke Gajdus on a mountaintop in New Zealand" just happened in my heart. :- )

amandapalmer

Oh Sara. I have been there, as you may know. I’m sending you peace and slowness. It’s such a hard thing to navigate and recover from, especially given how our culture is built to sweep it away. Feel your grief and do your rituals and call in your friends. I love you. I see you. ♥️

amandapalmer

I mean….sounds quite on point for my life at the moment. This was a beautiful dream. Sending love, Douglas.

Nicolai Burchartz

What a magical musical moment. I am in tears right now. Thank you so much for sharing! Isn't it great that patreon makes these moment s happen? I love being part of it.

amandapalmer

Hi Kirsten! I can help with that. There are shit movers and there are pros, and they’ll be rated online. It’s hard to fuck up a piano if you’re a pro piano mover: and the ways a piano can get fucked up are external (it gets banged against a wall and a bit breaks off or the finish gets fucked) and internal (if someone lets it accidentally slide down a flight of stairs or the truck gets in a crash and rolls over, the piano can be toasted). but it’s more than likely your piano will be fine. good piano movers do this allll day and pack up the piano like a babe in a ton of swaddling padding and buckles, then have dollies and a crew of 4 to maneuver. BUT if you’re feeling nervous or like having a spiritual piano journey: go there. get a local piano mover to do the packing, rent a truck and have them move it in, do the drive yourself, and arrange for a piano move to meet you on the other side with their local crew. then you have your piece of mind. but i would trust that hiring some pros will leave your piano okay. if you want further reassurance, most things about broken pianos can be repaired even if something goes wrong. it just costs money. xxx

Sara Wright

An incredible gift. Thank you! x

amandapalmer

wow. your grief was a portal. i wonder what oliver sacks would have to say about that one. if you haven’t read “musicophelia” it’s a great, great, great read. sending love. keep playing. xx

amandapalmer

oh christina!!! what a comment. thank you for coming aboard. this patreon has been a life-changer for me, and such a huge haven. you didn’t name exactly where you are. somewhere north of LA in CA, i assume. bay area maybe. maybe more north. there is no safe haven right now. but this shit is real. parts of the world and the climate - literally and figuratively - are changing and burning so fast it is so hard to know where to go, especially when what tethers us is thin or fragile. i am struggling with this myself as we speak. but we have this, we have here, there will always be this community, soft spaces to share with who’s there, intimacy among humans won’t die. it moves with you. you move with you. experiment. go. you can always return. and if you can’t return, well, then there’s your answer. love xxxx a

Andrew Funk

Thank you Amanda. I will order that book today. I grew up loving reading. But a continued decline in my mental health with an increase in the effects of my ADHD have made it extraordinarily difficult to read anymore. But I'll give this one a shot, even if I have to read one page a day to do it. Thanks for the recommendation. 🙏❤

Fiona Southwood

Being able to do this is so amazing. Making music with other people is such a gift

Tim Rodriguez

I have recently been rediscovering my identity as a musician. I took some piano lessons when I was young, quit. Picked up the guitar around 13 hoping to play music at campfires or be in a band…. Never really got there. But I’ve only ever temporarily put them down, and each time I picked it back up, despite being out of practice, I had learned more along the way; taking in different music and information and quietly (unknowingly) assimilating it. I sang at my fathers funeral earlier this month and it brought so much connection with family that I’m far from and so am just a little less well connected by default. And tonight I’m in a real show with other people; I’m playing guitar, singing, and somehow this is exactly what I have needed. Thank you, Amanda!

Drag Queen Jesus

There's so much here! I'm going to try to come back to this but wanted to send you a quick {{{EMPATHY ZAP}}} 💜 in the meantime.

Christina C.

Far far far Nor Cal. I live in Redding. North of Sacramento, about an hour and half drive south of the Oregon border. Anyone who road travels to Portland or Seattle from more southern CA cities drives right through us on the 5 freeway. Im originally from the Bay Area, my father moved our family north to start a business in the early 90s and to be closer to nature. I obviously left as soon as I fucking could. At 17. But I stupidly joined the Army to pay for film school. And then one day when my life was falling apart from all that my Dad asked me to come home and heal up and help him run a second business making civic monuments and memorials. So many crises (and romances) occurred where I felt there was no way I could really leave without outright abandoning family (or girlfriends) I just never truly went back to my own "life" in San Francisco. I did manage to finish my art degree. And have also since learned the art of detachment. But yeah this far up it is waaaaay different here than what some people might imagine progressive California to be.

Peter (Reet) Glass

Thank you. For some reason this made my eyes all wet!

Laura Wellner

I truly love this music. I listen to this and the other New Zealand song every Sunday morning. They're on a playlist with Zoe, Jherek, and Beethoven. Good company!

Teri swartzel

Achingly beautiful. I cried thru most of it. Thanks.

Kirsten Dallas

Thank you so much for taking the time to write these kind words of reassurance. It means a lot. I’m generally leaning toward spiritual piano journey, but you’re right… it’s likely all fine, either way. ♥️

Lynn Robinson

You are an amazing piano player/ musician. Such talent ❤️❤️❤️🤩

Mark Gerard

Thank you for being you..I love you so much, your beautiful inside and out

Shane Thornton

Shit I forgot to say thank you to the camera person! You did great at capturing that moment for us! Thank you thank you thank you

Maitri Libellule

This is just positively STUNNING! Kuddos to all involved for making this happen. It just took my breath away! 🥰

Molly McEnerney

Just beautiful. This is what life is about.

Anonymous

Finally had the chance to watch and listen. Thankyou for this. It was perfect and full of joy. You all did an amazing job with this. Thankyou thankyou thankyou

Ashleigh M. Ferreira-Bartlett

Listening to this while I make cookies from scratch and ponder alone v. lonely. Why does it feel right to me that I could cry absolutely at any moment at any thing I say or any one ever says that matters that much or any thing I feel so passionately for- chest ACHING like demonstrably worse now while a little more quiet but ever present in a foundation of...like, I've explained to friends in the past in just whatever label it may find but I always used this analogy that my mind was running like a river but even when we were talking, when we were creating speaking interacting bleeding breeding breaTHING I had an undercurrent of thought that didn't always align. What I feel now is we need reparenting. But fuck I won't keep going off ITS JUST ALSO HELPING WHILE GORDON RAMSEY YELLS AT SOMEONE NOT ME IN THE BG Three seconds of scanning for edit and I think I'm saying or trying to say.. I think it's not my undercurrent anymore it's my fucking main water supply and we are learning to be symbiotic and it is absolutely HARD and scary and seems like I don't trust myself.......etc..... but I think it's good work

Julie Dean

Beautiful! And, your words are inspirational. As a teacher/coach/guide to many adult singers who are just beginning voice exploration, I'm always telling them that we're just playing. Get in the sandbox - there is no good/bad - just sing/play!

Shawn Inwards

Truly incredible moment! That was a gift!

Michele G

Beautiful & Inspiring. Thank you

Laura Damone

So beautiful it touched my heart Amanda. This is the second time I listened to this piece you wrote. ❤️☮️🌹