Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hallo loves

A bunch of people screenshotted and sent this to me yesterday, apparently there’s a thing called #dailycalm and they used this quote from “The Art of Asking”. I’m honored.

Also, it hurts to read. It sorta does not make me feel calm. So thanks Daily Calm, you’ve fucking stressed me out.

I wrote that book in 2013. I was in such a different place. I knew less. I’d been hurt, but I felt invincible. I spilled and loosed the truth and suffered the consequences, I was less careful, I listened to people’s stories constantly, I thought truth was God, it all felt very binary and simple. I wrote this at the time and it was true. Yes.

And yet: I have ten years’ worth of new experience now, and I want to ask this young writer questions that I know she couldn’t answer.

What if the person you are with has a mouth sewn shut? What do you do? Pry it open? Beg them to change? To escape? What if you cannot speak? What if they cannot speak? At all? What then? What do you do?

I think of a story from a few months ago.

I visited a friend who is going through a divorce - painful, kids, abusive, communication is dark. A cold war. I found myself wanting so badly to fix it, to shake her free, to loan her my car, my bank account, my anything, just to see her be able to fly out of the hell-cage in which she’s trapped.

But sometimes, you just have to listen. Listen without fixing, listen without saving, listen even without sympathy.

Just listen. Yes.

This morning I got a text from a young friend in Africa whose boss just perved on her and she doesn’t know whether to rock the boat and say anything. I listened. I can give her all the advice in the world about What To Do, but mostly I needed to tell her that she is not alone. That we all deal with this shit and there are a million different moves and oh my darling, you are not alone.

With both of these women:

just give her a place to put the unsayable, the horror story, the grossness.

I have been on the other side of this listening so many times. It is golden. It is priceless. It is everything and more: to have someone hear your story, keep it safe, and look deeply into your eyes with awe, simply saying: you are alive, you are amazing…you survived that.

Come here - let me give you a hug.

You survived that.

For all of those who have listened, to me, to your loved ones, to women who have to carry the horror stories - I bow. Keep listening.

I love you all.

X

AFP

PS. If you have never read my book, it’s really good. I sometimes forget I wrote it. You can find it pretty much anywhere books exist and I also read the audiobook myself and people seem to love it. Info here. https://amandapalmer.net/theartofasking/


Files

Previews only

Comments

Sam Allen

"The ministry of presence" is what chaplain folks call it. Love to you!!

Amy Cox Henderson

I just downloaded the audio book. ❤️❤️❤️ I’ve been meaning to read it for a while, but today will be the day. Next, I (personally 😂) need you to reprint Evelyn Evelyn, so my AFP collection can truly be complete. ❤️ Thank you for creating (all the art you provide) for yourself and for us.

Suzanne

Psst… remember to give yourself grace as well, Amanda dear.

Kris Smerick

So many of the songs on Theatre is Evil resonated with my own (now dead) marriage. To be linked—chained—to one who cannot speak, whose face won’t move an inch, is agonizingly lonely in a way I don’t know many can understand. It *looks* like you have a Companion, but in reality “two can be as bad as one (it’s the loneliest number since the number one).” I’m so sorry you lived that too. It’s funny how being alone can be less lonely. We are listening—even when you must be silent. We sit with you in the silence.

LJ

Amanda, I want to say to you. Look at you. Look at all that you have survived and endured. You are incredible. You are amazing. You are resilient even when you don’t feel like it. You are not alone. You are enough and you are so so so so loved. (And yes. Ministry of presence is what us chaplain folks call it, but you know that from your work with Wayne💜)

Stacy Litwin

That was the first audiobook I ever listened to, I had already read the book and found out after that you read the audio version so I started it over, it really is incredible

Deborah Hartmann Preuss

Q: "What if the person you are with has a mouth seen* shut?" (I assume "sewn"?) A: Ah yes, I recognise this scenario, from personal experience. I stand by the "letting them" part, I guess. I have well-trained intuition, but it serves no one to tear their truth out of them. In fact, it may be a violence. Also, if I feel I have trust, and permission (I'm a life coach), I may *invite* them to tell me their truth. If it's the right moment, they may want to - if only a part of it. They must always feel it's their choice. Take the flower. You can give it back to me, if you wish. And sometimes it is my mouth that's sewn shut, yes. In all cases, compassion is a key component of this interaction. Compassion for self liberates compassion for others. I love that the Insight Timer app is free and has many variations of the Loving Kindness (aka Metta) meditation guidances - I use it with my clients, to build compassion muscles :-) 🙏

Melody

This speaks to me this morning, thank you. I've survived all *that*, and I don't plan to stop now. That alone is incredible.

Len Tower Jr.

Still one of the best books I've read. Truth: "But sometimes, you just have to listen. Listen without fixing, listen without saving, listen even without sympathy. Just listen. -Amanda Palmer" As a man of my generation, this has been one of my harder practices. I'll be sharing this around my socials. -Len

Julie Steele

It’s a beautiful book. I hope that maybe you can write a follow up some day especially with how much the world and all of our lives have changed dramatically.

Anna McCotter

Amanda, You are ALIVE, YOU are amazing. You have SURVIVED THAT. & to tell you the truth , you have left me in awe. ….. maybe if I knew words could comfort or heal, I’d actually have something to say to you, besides I love you and how are you doing and are you okay….. I’ve seen you, more importantly ; been alone with you SIX times…. And I never find words important enough to fill the moment; it always feels like the more I try to find something to say, the guiltier I feel; if I have to think that hard… I must be flailing for more time. Yet I’ve become so in love watching you interact with others and others with you. It leaves me speechless…. I am aware —that you’re aware and when I stare too long— but something about the beauty of those moments , soaking me in gratitude and leaving me so speechless, I lose track of time… I lose my place. Because you are alive, you survived that , you are amazing. And you are here, I enjoy this kind of silence , at this point your presence is too sacred for words. Fuck my life, im so grateful you have returned. I love you.

Pamela Kirsch

Thank you for always listening🤍❤️ & we are listening too

Daniel Allen

I've the book both in hard copy and the audiobook. Both very rewarding experiences.

Aqualynne Carnahan

I train clinicians to talk to patients. One of the things I teach is empathetic listening, reflection and then asking how we can help. Often the answer we get is, "You already did." Because we know when things are messed up, sometimes we even have plans to make it through. Personally, for me just having someone say, "I'm so sorry." was gold. It opens a door so I can step outside my head. Kinda like listening to my, "I need to cry" songs. A reminder that I am part of a much broader community and that is okay.

Lexy Green

Where can I get the audiobook?! I’ve read it, but audiobook? I thought it didn’t exist!

Chris P

Hi Amanda, yes, your old quote from the book is a little simplified maybe, but not less true (and the Calm picture is a bit cheesy, lol ;-)), your additional years of wisdom and listening have given you insight to expand on that as you have above, but the kernel of the matter still seems good to me! Hope all is well on the roadThanks, keep it up, and Cheers, Chris

Eliza

I read the ebook. Then I listened to the audiobook. I've used your words a lot in my business and personal growth. I even did my college thesis on the art of asking, and your tedtalk. Thank you for that.

Sara Wells

I work in the anti-violence sector, and what you say echoes the work we do. To sit with someone, and let them share a piece of themselves without being bombarded with judgment or solutions is a gift.

Ria

“Don’t just do something; stand there.”

Tom Steiger

The operative word being “sometimes.”

Hev

I refuse to believe that it was released 10 years ago. This is unacceptable to me.

Jodina Meehan

Yes. It's not all rainbows and purple unicorns when you ask the universe for the truth. Thank you. And, I just re-read your book, cause I'm getting ready to publish one, and I needed it. Thank you again. LOVE YOU

Michael Clark

Writing a book with the line “how I learned to stop worrying” was bound to be a big medicine. I love the audacity of that line. I truly believe you have many, many important insights in the art of learning how to “stop worrying,” and I imagine when you have found yourself worrying, this line probably doesn’t necessarily bring you ease. Maybe. I don’t know. I’m not you nor do I know you beyond your songs and publicly shared words and such. Still. I am so glad for this book. For you. For what you have done. For what you haven’t. I admire your boldness and your bigness and your heart and your willingness to share your pain pretty much every day since I discovered you were real. I feel so happy knowing you live out there. That you love out there. Anywho. Cheers Amanda. *lifts invisible glass*

Fleassy Malay

Yes, THIS. This is why I created Mother Tongue Poetry. Ten years of monthly spaces for women to speak their stories, FOR THIS REASON. So women could hear other women, so women could be LISTENED TO by all genders, so women could say what the so rarely are given space to say. I had a woman on that stage still wearing the wrist band from the institution she left that morning after trying to end her life. She came to our stage for the first time that night just to say she survived. We've seen women do performance pieces about their IVF journeys whilst living with chronic illness, only to find out they are pregnant and return to do another poem...only to lose the baby and return to speak about that, only to get pregnant again and not return for years because they were busy being a mama. We've seen women in hijabs do erotic poets. Women over 65 doing erotic poetry. Trans women doing erotic poetry. Non-binary people doing erotic poetry. Proudly fat women doing erotic poetry 😊 Reminding us that we all deserve and belong in our pleasure. We've seen heartbreak stories. Abuse stories. Divorce stories. Coming out stories. Food stories. Racism stories. Ableism stories. Ageism stories. 12 year olds talking or singing about love whilst people older than their parents in the audience nod in understanding. I've seen women talk about finding out the father of their child was sleeping with their best friends. About the pain and the heartbreak...about losing both their partner and their friend for a while. About how they are Reminding their friendship...all the while their friend sat in the audience supporting them. If opposite I've seem people talking stories of falling in love with someone they shouldn't It pulls down the conditioning we have been given to other other women. It reminds us to see ourself in each other. It reminds us that we are stronger when we listen, when we share our stories. I wish you could see it Amanda. We celebrated our 10 year anniversary at a Gala Event on IWD...250 people came out to hear the stories of diverse and complex women. It was profound. I'll let you know when the videos come out 😊

Ofel Epicorus

Thank you Amanda, for all your wisdom, holding space and just being you. I love your book so much that I actually own two copies. One to always keep here in case I want to read it, and one to land to people I think will benefit from it. The second is almost never in my hands, it always has somewhere else to be. In many situations, we sure can't fix things for other people. But just being there, and listening nonjudgmentally, can mean a lot for someone who is gathering the strength to help themselves. Sending love and appreciation to you, Amanda. Thank you.

Doctor Worm

BENE BROWN WROTE YOUR FORWARD?!?!!!??!?

Lindsay Rickman

Yes. And yes, it is a very good book. I am currently reading a copy checked out from my library and telling everyone I'm close to, "THIS IS AN EXCELLENT BOOK!" When I own my own home, I will have five copies in my library to give to friends. Thank you, Amanda.

EvilElitest

I got this book when you did the concert in Kingston as a present for my GF, who introduced me to you, one of the best nights of my life

Titus

Did someone already write "The Art of Listening"?

Kayla

Wise words

Anonymous

I really appreciated this post. I work as a spiritual and bereavement counselor for a local hospice in Albuquerque, so I found myself wanting to engage with the questions and stories you shared. Professionally, the terms "ministry of presence" and "pastoral touch" are both used when caring for people, and they both can be helpful when people are non-verbal or more quiet. Ministry of presence speaks to the power that resides in the simple act of witnessing and being in proximity with another who is struggling. It is an offering that honors the divine humanity of both/all parties by emphasizing that we need not "do" anything in order to comfort. Like the quote says, it is a gift wonderfully given to hold space for someone's truth. Pastoral touch is the gentle use of touch, holding a hand, caressing someone's hair while they are sleeping, a welcomed hug, a physical sensation that is made with only the pure intention of saying "I am here, I see you, and I love you." Your stories speak to that reality, and I can't help but wonder how much space the 8 Foot Bride held in her days. I can imagine that many MANY people would be able to say that putting in a DD and AFP CD into their car or stereo, or streamed the jams digitally, have been held by the space your music has created. I know I have, and what's better, I know I will be. Thank you for your ministry, then and now and always and never.

LT

Oh, this timing is so apt. Thank you for sharing, Amanda. I lost a friendship that was extraordinarily important to me back in December. She was in a situation riddled with addiction and abuse. I feel like spoke too loudly, offered too many solutions when (I think) all she wanted was someone safe to share this painful information with. After years of friendship, I never heard from her again after this. I feel like I scared her away. I wrote her a letter last week apologizing/acknowledging: “….Crawling into your world when things had gone dark and just being with you in that space was a rare privilege, not a burden. My deepest regret is that I wasn’t more careful with that trust. I am sorry I tried to throw open the curtains, tried to fix everything that had gone wrong in your life, instead of just listening to you. Please don’t let my foolishness convince you that no one is capable of being there for you in this way…” I may never hear from her again, but I’ve learned a lot from this situation. <3

Natalie Rose Apar

So, I've had your book on my shelf for literally years (for a long time I didn't even want to read it for embarrassing parasocial reasons we won't get into here), but I finally picked it up about a month ago in anticipation of traveling to Santa Fe. And sometimes it feels like a book finds you at just the right time in your life, you know? Like the book itself was waiting for the right moment to be read, rather than me being deeply dedicated to procrastinating. Anyhow, I don't want to blather, but I'm glad the book found me now and Thank You for writing it--even if you don't entirely agree with younger Amanda anymore. Just don't forget to have compassion for that version of yourself. Hold space for her, too.

Teresa Toro

I've always been the one who Fixes, who Solves. It's been an ongoing process for me to learn to simply Listen, sitting in the discomfort of inaction. Not every problem is mine to solve and that's a big life lesson. I'm getting better but it'll always be a challenge.

Samantha Harlowe

I’d like to buy the audiobook but I don’t use amazon anymore. Is there another place to find it?

Chiqui Pineda

I have this book. In audio format so it’s double delight. Thank you, Amanda F. Palmer 🥰👊