Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • Last Day of Our Acquaintance_FINAL MASTER_24bit_48.wav

Missing 25 full-res photos, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Hello Loves.

I'm reading and responding to comments tonight and tomorrow....please say hi down there, and let us know what you think of the track.

{{AND, QUICK - For the local Dresden Dolls fans coming to Woodstock, NY, for the sold-out shows @ Colony Aug 31-Sept 2...there's an entire guide with things to do + a Massive Smörgåsbord of side shows/gatherings at Graveside Variety, our little clubhouse piano cabaret purpose-built for this community (and funded by patrons)! Starting tomorrow (Aug 30th) - my choreographer friend Coco Karol is leading a movement class at 4-5:30pm, and John Coons is kicking us off at 9pm with first of four performances of their super-queer, super-dark musical, "Bleak!" All tickets/info here. Come be with your people!!}}

..........

NOW...I've been talking about it all month, and today is the day we put it out.

You can play the song directly through this post.  $3 patrons, watch your inboxes for a direct download link, it's coming in a moment.

PLEASE ENJOY THE TRACK (with headphones if you can) and SHARE THIS POST, or share the song any way you know how.....the track is now up on:

Youtube
Spotify
Apple music
or
Bandcamp 

..............

A portion of the money from this post is going to be donated to The Irish Women's Survivor Support Network.

Sinéad survived. Until she didn't. I survived - and am still surviving - the ricochet of pain that is left in the wake of sexual assaults, sexual abuses of power, and the long, complicated web of agony that is created by sexual violence in general. I have watched at close range (and have digested heard thousands of stories from others at this point) what sexual violence, and the lack of accountability and truth, can do to rip apart families, lives and livelihoods. Sinéad knew all this, and she sang truth to power over and over again. She pointed her finger. She demanded accountability, justice. I don't think she got it. We still have so much work to do, people. If you'd like to donate on top, please do, at:

https://iwssn.org.uk

.....

I am so proud of this release and how quickly me, Jherek Bischoff, and The Righteous Babes put this together to pay tribute to this woman's songwriting. The cover artwork is as powerful as the recording itself, and I'm so honored that Niki McQueen took my call and made the cover art with only a few days' notice.

None of this would have been able to happen, as usual, without patronage. We had the money, we had your faith, and we just hit the recording studio, spent the money, and made the thing our hearts wanted to make.

I first heard this song and the gorgeous album it lived on, "I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got" - when I was fourteen, and it all changed my life. I never would have thought that I'd be recording it at 47 for a community of people like you.

Feeling so much camaraderie,

Music is like nothing else.

It threads together time, space, loss; it helps me make sense of the world.

I've done so many of these fast-covers with Jherek. When Bowie died, we put out this whole collection of covers in the weeks following. When Dolores Riordon of the Cranberries died, we put out this version of Zombie. When Prince died, we put this out.

Every time I do this exercise with Jherek, I always have to quietly pray that it isn't seen as opportunistic. Money, art, time...you know I spend a lot of time thinking about it. But every time we lose an artist we love - who has influenced us deeply - it's like our little musician-version of a wake. This is how we process, how we grieve.

The day Sinéad died, I was driving from the Hudson Valley to Boston to do some heavy duty cleaning and dealing with old artifacts in my old Cloud Club apartment (which is still there, with other people in and out of it). My fella from Boston had been out to my place in Woodstock for a visit. He was driving back to Boston too, in his own car, about an hour behind me. He was heading to his dad's house.

I got a call while I was driving. Someone told me that Sinéad was gone.

I pulled over to a gas station. I called my fella. He knows me, he knows her, he knows us. Hew knew everything. He was right behind me. He told me he'd meet me in the parking lot.

I sat there in the car and I couldn't quite cry.

I thought about Sinéad, how horrible the world had been to her. I thought about her mental health struggles, so many of which had been aired in the public, I thought about her desperate cries through twitter for company and help. About her son committing suicide. About the immensity of her talent. About how now everyone would sing hger praises, because it's so much safer to praise the dead icon than the living, complicated breathing human-being artist.

I thought about what the music industry did to her. The media. The world.

And then I did what I always do, when I'm trying to process a difficult feeling. 

I read through a few of the immediate obituaries, and I felt sad, and angry, becausew they weren't getting it right. And I decided to just....write.

I wrote this rage-elegy, and posted it to Facebook (and crossposted it everywhere else).

It began:

If I were a different kind of person I would let it settle and wait a few days to collect my thoughts and do this the right and grown-up way but I think she’d be more proud of me for writing like this….pulled off to the side of the highway writing from my fucking heart because that’s she did, all her life, made from the heart...

(you can read the rest here: https://www.facebook.com/amandapalmer/posts/pfbid0NRhCMjZsVjD5FceCwyQYJivWrANfMoPVxb4aXpoSWHjq3ZkwAiGPh6g3bykGgiQrl)

(photo by Robbie Jones)

It went viral after I posted it. 

It's been seen almost 3.5 million times on Facebook.

Sometimes urgency just fucking works, because that's where the truth sits.

I feel the same way about music. The faster the better, sometimes.

That's why I wanted to make this cover quickly.

............

When he pulled up to the parking lot, where I was sitting waiting in my car, I was in the middle of writing this. I didn't see him pull up, and he watched me write from his own drivers' seat.

After ten minutes, I looked up and saw him there.

After I hopped out of my car and into his, he did an impression of what I'd looked like  - to him, from his car - while I was writing my rage-piece. The windows in my car were up, and it was 90 degrees that day. I had turned the engine off and was just baking in this hundred and ten degree car-sauna. My body was covered in sweat; completely wet.

He scrunched up his face and clutched his phone and clenched his jaw and gritted his teeth and started muttering to himself, taking deep gasping breaths, with his brow knitted furrowed so far it into itself that it looked like he was about to explode.

"That's what you looked like through the window."

I knew he was right. I'd felt it.

I sat in his passenger seat, and read him what I'd written, aloud. We were quiet.

Then he said:

"Listen".

And he queued up a Sinéad song I'd never heard. This one: "In This Heart", from Universal Mother.

We sat there in his car, with the volume up load, windows rolled up, trees in front of us, sky blue. Oh god.

We sat there, wordlessly, listening to her voice.

It was so impossible to think that the person who sang this song was never going to sing a song again.

I put my head on his chest.

That's when the tears came. I wept. That voice.

I am waiting for you
For only to adore you
My heart is for you
My love
My love
My love

This is my grief for you
For only the loss of you
The hurting of you
My love
My love
My love

Her voice filled up the car, filled up my head, filled up my heart, filled up the whole world. Her voice that nobody will hear again, singing live. Her voice that came into my head when I was a little girl and taught me how to sing unapologetically. With so much conviction. With so much heart.

With so much honesty.

That moment in the parking lot is one of the truest, most beautiful moments I've ever felt in my life. To feel so connected to a moment, to a person, to a dead person, to my past self - through art. Through sound.

This is what music can do.

This is everything.

.........

So I hauled my sorry ass back to Boston to confront my own past, and fate would have it that the very cassette tape I'd referenced in my little obituary was still on the dusty shelf of my old art joint, with all my old Prince and Cure and Depeche Mode and Pixies tapes, Xerox cover art and all.

I had listened back to the album - the entirety of "I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got" - in the car.

I had listened to "The Last Day of Our Acquaintance".

FUCK. This song. This is the song, Amanda.

I know you all know what's going on in my life, more of less.

This song spoke right to the core of me.

I texted Jherek that night, from the heat of my apartment.

He'd been one of the first people I'd reached out to when I gotten the news that she'd died (along with Alina Simone, one of my oldest friends from High School, who worshipped at the Sinéad altar more than any other musician I've ever met). I said "Are we doing it?" He said "Which song?" I said "The Last Day of Our Acquaintance".

He said

"You're on."

........

A few days later, Jherek sent me a sketch of what he was going to record with the string quartet. It wasn't quite working for me, which surprised me. Jherek usually nails this on the first go. So he ditched the draft and went back to the drawing board, and sent me another midi-string sketch the night before the session he'd booked with the strings. It ... still wasn't working. The strings just weren't sounding....right. I called him, he's in Los Angeles.

"This is crazy. This never happens. But it's not what I was hearing. What do we do?"

He said "I don't know. We can cancel the session. But it's gonna cost two grand if we do, and we don't get it back."

I thought. It had to be right.

I said: "Here's the thing. It has to be NOTHING and then EVERYTHING. Maybe you can improv some stuff in the studio...and we can fix it in the mix. Have you ever heard the version of Another World, by Anohni, where it's just this long, drawn out, dissonant orchestra?"

"No..."

I sent it to him. I said: Do the session tomorrow. I'm praying for you. It'll work.

I think Jherek stayed up most of the night reworking the arrangement, and I spent the next day biting my nails, wondering how it was going. The next night, he sent it over.

It was perfect. He got it. He CRUSHED IT.

I listened to the strings in my car - again - while driving home from the grocery store, with tears streaming down my face.

I'm always crying in this story. But god, the tears nowadays are so much happier than they were a few years ago. Music is bringing me back to myself.

........

I wrote to Niki McQueen that night - a fellow survivor and South African artist who's been slamming out incredible art for The Dresden Dolls, and asked if she'd be up for a SUPERFAST commission, paid for by patronage. She said yes. I described what I imagined: the ripping, the paper, the strength, the survival, and she got to work.

........

A handful of days later, I went into Applehead Studio in Woodstock to record the vocal, along with my last-minute back-up vocalists, who met me there about two hours after my session started.

My final take - the one that I did after the babes came into the control room - was the best one.

They know what's happening in my life. Having them there to do vocals was a coup, but having them there to be witness was even more important. My circle of safety.

I posted a little video of my conducting the babes HERE on Instagram.

.......

Here's some process photos and a little more about my collaborators on this one.

Can I say: THESE PEOPLE ARE SO GOOD, AND SO GAME.

What an incredible group of artists, who came together SO QUICKLY to make this fucker happen. My god.

First of all, the ARTWORK....created by South African artist Niki McQueen.

Me to Niki:

This reference figure popped up at me, and I suggested we have her ripping up a piece of paper, and dropping it, calmly....

This draft was the first version of what she finally drew...but the paper wasn't reading boldly enough against the background figure...

It took dozens of texts of back-and-forth but this is such a powerful final image - it took my breath away when she finally nailed it. Just like Jherek's arrangement. Sometimes it just WORKS.

This image says so much to me, and it could mean so many things.

I just love it.

Here's Niki's final physical drawing.

Some words from Niki about the process...

Hello Patrons...

The collaboration process with Amanda is often fast and furious and always hugely inspirational and satisfying. 

This one flowed very smoothly. Sinead and what she, her spirit, and her struggles meant to me, and her significant influence on my own life had been much on my mind since her passing. 

Amanda chose such a powerful song that finding a vision to speak to it came powerfully and quickly with her input. We went from idea to digital mockup to finished drawn and painted artwork in a couple of days. I hope this image speaks to both her strength and her vulnerability.

-Niki

...............

More about Niki....

Niki McQueen is a visual artist and communications and graphic design specialist from Cape Town, South Africa, with a background in Marine Biology. After obtaining her MSc, she changed careers and pursued work in web, graphic design, and communications.

As the COVID pandemic swept the globe, she felt compelled to create and rediscovered, developed and expanded on an old technique using hand-printing and mixed media that she first learned studying art at school.

Enamoured with the extraordinary, she draws inspiration from multiple sources, from vintage medical and scientific collections to surrealism and magical realism. She creates digital compositions using public domain images which are expertly and painstakingly hand-printed and drawn onto archival papers.

Her art explores the places beyond reason and the familiarity of everyday existence. Themes include anatomy, biology, psychology, archetypal interplay, eroticism, decay and rebirth. Every work tells a story, be it personal or magical – the viewer is invited to explore meaning in their own interpretation of the work.

Niki has struggled with worsening health over the past year. She is living with Long Covid, Fibromyalgia and other chronic illnesses, which have resulted in her being unable to work for an extended time, and facing challenges creating art. 

You can support her and buy beautiful prints of her work HERE:

https://nikimcqueen.com/

........

THEN....there's 

The Righteous Babes.

This is a weird and beautiful collection of folks. I met Holly Miranda first, about a year ago when I moved back from New Zealand to Woodstock, and then our connection through Ani Difranco sealed the network. We're neighbors now, and spend a lot of time together. She's my good friend, she's seen me through a lot of pain this year. And vice versa.

The babes are an unlikely band made up of musicians and label-mates brought together Ani Difranco and her label, Righteous Babe - and they happened to be at my house, rehearsing for their upcoming tour in the Dolls Band Barn, when I decided to record this track. I asked them to do the back-up vocals and about 48 hours later, we rehearsed and they came into the studio with me.

From left to right: Holly Miranda, Gracie Coates, Jocleyn Mackenzie, and Rachel Ruggles (at Applehead studio in Woodstock, NY, recording back-up vocals):

Yours truly in the studio, singing my little heart out...

The whole crew outside the studio...photographed by Addy Vogt.

Here's a handful of photos of me and the babes doing a rocking LIVE version of the song, the day after we tracked it, at their show at Colony in Woodstock (they were SO GOOD).

(photos by Sam Margevicius)

And if you want to see the performance - we livestreamed it to Facebook, and it's still up to watch.....

https://www.facebook.com/amandapalmer/videos/604753948453718

.....

Some words from the Babes about what this cover means...

It was a true honor to be asked by Amanda to sing on this song by such an influential artist of our times, gone to soon. The pure power of having five women's voices screaming into the abyss was a viscerally cathartic experience that we hope resonates through the track. 

We love Sinéad, we love Amanda, we love each other, and we hope you love this rendition of Last Day of Our Acquaintance.

......

More about the babes....

(photo by Anthony Mulcahy)

The Righteous Babes are a supergroup of powerhouse female artists, banded together under AniDiFranco's legacy label, Righteous Babe Records. Think boygenius meets Bonny Light Horseman with an air of Lilith Fair – currently the band is comprised of three independent groups: Gracie and Rachel (chamber-pop piano-violin duo who have appeared on NPR's Tiny Desk), Holly Miranda (sultry folk rock guitarist who has toured with Karen O), and Jocelyn Mackenzie (percussionist, electric ukulele player, and former member of Pearl and the Beard.)

The artists perform one another's original songs in fresh, unique arrangements that highlight technical prowess and deliver a stage show that is acrobatic and heart-pounding. Their distinctive vocal blend and powerful musicianship shine as they support one another as fellow artists who delight in sharing the stage, righteously.

THE RIGHTEOUS BABES:

www.therighteousbabes.com
Instagram / Facebook / Twitter

GRACIE AND RACHEL:

www.gracieandrachel.com
Instagram / Facebook / Twitter

HOLLY MIRANDA:

www.hollymiranda.com
Instagram / Facebook / Twitter

JOCELYN MACKENZIE:

www.jocelynmackenzie.com
Instagram / Facebook / Twitter

......

And last but not least....

a little more about Jherek Bischoff...

(photo by Christian Faustus)

Like I said: he put this all together in UNDER A WEEK and got a KILLER quartet to record his arrangement live in Los Angeles.

Here's a note from Jherek about this song...

................

Ahoy Amandaland!

It is always such a pleasure to collaborate with Amanda and all of you!

This song is another in a series of covers by Amanda and me celebrating heroes who've passed on. It has been an interesting and wild way to process these losses. When I heard Sinéad had passed, I knew immediately that we would make a cover. Amanda and I have never talked about Sinéad, but what she represented in my mind, I knew that Amanda must feel the same way. What inspires me about Sinéad is not only her incredible voice and powerful songs but also how truly punk she was.

Many writings circulated after her passing, and one that stuck out talked about her famous SNL performance. Regardless of whether or not you agreed she could get her point across by ripping up the picture of the pope, what she did was so PUNK.

Imagine being in her shoes: a rising star getting your big break on SNL performing for millions of people, deciding to perform a song a capella, and using this gigantic platform to bring awareness to the horrific things happening in the Catholic Church. She knew what it would mean for her career, yet she did it selflessly.

It's about the most punk thing I can imagine.

I listened to her music a lot in my late teens. I would close my eyes and imagine what it would feel like to sing like her. What it would feel like in my body, what it would feel like in my mind. It was such an intense superpower that she had. I am not a synesthete, but I always saw silver when I heard her voice. I looked up Silver on Wikipedia just now for kicks, and it says it's a conductor metal. She was undoubtedly a conduit.

This song was a hard one to arrange! The music is minimal, and there is so little going on. It's all about the words and the delivery. In my first couple of drafts, I created something true to the song but with a bit of my interpretation. I couldn't get it right, and we almost shelved the song. The evening before heading into the studio, I tried to make a version as stark and minimal as possible. It turned out even better than my first ideas and reminded me how much I love collaborating, especially with Amanda.

I want to thank Amanda, team AFP, and all of you patrons for allowing us to show love for our heroes.

Thank you to our wonderful string quartet and engineers.

Thank you to the Righteous Babes!

I hope you enjoy it.

Love, from hot as hell LA,

Jherek

.........

Jherek's Bio: Jherek Bischoff is an American composer, arranger, producer, and multi-instrumentalist. His credits include over a dozen albums as a solo artist or band member (The Dead Science, Parenthetical Girls, Xiu Xiu); over sixty albums as a musician, arranger, producer, or engineer (Kassa Overall, AngelOlsen, Regina Spektor); music for symphony orchestra, opera, film, theater, and ballet (Andersen's Stories, Organ Trail); and concert performances around the world (Carnegie Hall, Royal Albert Hall, Glastonbury Festival).

https://www.jherekbischoff.com/

https://www.patreon.com/jherekbischoff

Instagram / Facebook / Twitter

.............

(photo by Ellius Grace)

Rest in Power, Sinéad.

Thank you.

................

FULL SONG CREDITS:

Lead Vocals - Amanda Palmer
Backing Vocals - The Righteous Babes (Gracie and Rachel, Holly Miranda, Jocelyn Mackenzie)
Vocals recorded by Christopher Bittner at Applehead Studios

Violin 1 - Adrianne Pope
Violin 2 - Andrew Tholl
Viola - Marta Sofia Honer
Cello - Isaiah Gage
Conductor and Drums - Jherek Bischoff
Recorded by James Riotto at Altamira Sound

Upright Bass, Electric Bass, Synth, Acoustic Gutiar - Jherek Bischoff
Recorded by Jherek Bischoff at Sweethaven

Co-produced, Arranged, Mixed, and Mastered by Jherek Bischoff

------THE NEVER-ENDING AS ALWAYS---------

1. if you are a patron and new to my work, don’t forget your patronage allows you access to ALL of my patreon releases to date. HERE is the link to download my latest big solo record, “There Will Be No Intermission”, and HERE is a link to download the PDF of the art/essay book that goes with it.

2. if you’re a patron reading this post via an email notification, please click through to comment on this post. at the very least, if you’ve read it, indicate that by using the heart symbol. that's always nice for me to see, so i know who's reading.

3. see All the Things (over 150 of them) i've made so far on patreon:

http://amandapalmer.net/things

4. JOIN THE SHADOWBOX COMMUNITY FORUM, find your people, and discuss everything: https://forum.theshadowbox.net/

5. new to my music and TOTALLY OVERWHELMED? TAKE A WALK THROUGH AMANDALANDA….we made a basic list of my greatest hits n stuff (at least up until a few years ago, this desperately needs updating) on this lovely page: http://amandalanda.amandapalmer.net/

6. general AFP/patreon-related questions? ask away, someone will answer: patronhelp@amandapalmer.net

Files

Previews only

Comments

Jenny Hippensteal

I will be reading this when I get home from work as I’m about to start right now but! So excited to see you and Brian perform again! And got tickets to bleak on Friday night too! So hello and all the love 🖤🖤🖤 you’re amazing!

Karen Krebser

I'm sad that the drawing shows her naked. Among all the other things she was, Shuhada' Sadaqat died a Muslim, and perhaps she would have preferred the protection of clothing. I haven't read her autobio or all the recent interviews so I don't know how she felt about the hijab, but she wore it at least sometimes and I really appreciated when interviews with photographs included and respected that. All the misogyny of it aside (as much as is possible anyway), women's nudity is a point of intense vulnerability for some women, and not all of us want to be represented that way (i.e., naked).

Tym Rourke

"In this Heart" is one of my favorite Sinead songs. My wife and I walked out to our wedding together with it playing. So many people don't know it - you should watch some of her performances of it available on YouTube - they are transcendent and beautiful. I am so broken over the loss of her, in ways I was not expecting, having worked through losing Bowie, Prince, Dolores, and a few others on my playlist these past few years. I am still processing, feeling the need to add to the written discourse on the meaning of her to me, like you and many others have. Not yet though, I'm just listening to her music on repeat and remembering all of the ways she intersected my life.

Janet in Georgia

This gave my knees AND my scalp goosebumps. Highest of compliments from my whole body. ❤️ love you.

Shan NOS

I am appreciative of this deep project. Writing to share my concern that a nude image is not what a Muslim woman would find appropriate as a tribute. Feeling very sad about this.

AnnaLatchman

This came to mind too, although not the second point. She has been photographed and painted nude so I understand why the choice was made

Sahrami

Red football has always been my favorite of her songs and i come back to it time after time. The raw energy always draws me in, giving me a voice giving her a voice and then theres us singing in unison. Rest now Sinead, you wont be forgotten💔 I'll listen to the song when i get home in the evening, cant wait to see what an amazing thing you have made.

Marley Kendrick

It's really risky to cover a song I consider perfect in its an original form but you've nailed it. It's a wonderful tribute. I love Sinead so deeply and I can hear how much you do too

Thomas Herlofsen

Love this song. Love you. Love the arrangement. Adore the illustration (although I sympathize with Karen Krebsers point I think she truly was naked when ripping up that picture). I do have some nitpicks, as I sometimes do when you do songs that are as deep a part of my soul as of yours (you do those a lot, our musical influences and growing up stories are very similar) but that's hardly the point is it? The journey to this piece of music is the point. Sinead / Shuhada' is the point. And you singing this song in particular is, of course, immensely powerful shit. Which is the point. Love you so much. Already said that I guess.

Thomas Herlofsen

And that final picture of Sinead is astoundingly beautiful. I might get that as a tattoo one day.

Lindsey Lubow

Just popping over to acknowledge I'm aware of this; I'm... Not in a headspace where I can be listening to this. But I know it's there for eventually once that changes.

Hayley Rosenblum

Damn, that breakdown when the drums and guitar kick in. Damn.

Michael Strobl

How can you listen to this song and not cry?

Michael Strobl

How can you record this song and not cry?

Steven Panzek

Great cover Amanda and excellent work jherek. I went back and listened to the original since I never heard it. I’ll admit wasn’t much of a sinead fan back in the days. I was just into different music then. I do remember vividly the controversy she caused after SNL. I thought it was great and respected the hell out of her. It takes a lot of courage to potentially piss off hundreds of millions. Thx Amanda

Robyn Pearson

My last 3 shows before lockdown in 2020 were Ani, Sinead, and Midtown social. It's the only time I saw Sinead live. It was in a little theatre here in Santa Cruz. Her voice was mixed higher than I've ever experienced in a live show. It was physically penetrating. You know when bass is turned way up you vibrate? Her voice was doing that. It was unbelievable. I am so happy I have that night to cherish and that feeling to remember. I don't have my earbuds and I'm not where I can listen to the song yet but I know it will be amazing. ❤️❤️❤️

Franz(i)

Thank you (and everyone involved with the song) for this beautiful cover! I feel like i had just discovered Sinéad proberly last year. I had seen the documentary "Nothing compares". And now I had just missed her it feels like :( But I really hope her art and spirit lives on in artists like you. They didn't know she was a seed (a quote from Sinéad from the documentary)....

Nicole Prehoda

It really is lovely. I got chills. I'm so happy for you and all your collaborators! I also learned a new song--wow is In This Heart haunting. She had such a unique voice. Thanks again for all you do.

Tracee Kafer

It's a dissonant, devastating, delicious tribute - thank you.

Tara Timmsy

Bravo to every artist who contributed!

Jennifer Harnage

Oh, Amanda, per usual, your timing couldn't be better. I want to write a "proper " thing about it, but I'm too emotional right now, so here's what I put on Facebook right before you posted this.... "To the women who gave birth to me. The one who left me at daycare overnight when I was three-four and terrified. The one that told me her cat was more important than me. The one who locked me in the house like Rapunzel and made me terrified of the world. The one who ignored me in my bedroom. The one who allowed me to be around my father's abusive alcoholic wife. The one who pawned me off on whomever so she could have her party-time weekends. The one who never made me feel comfortable so I didn't even tell her I started my period for months. The hypersexual, inappropriate freak who simultaneously sexualized everything while also making me feel like my having sex would be the worst thing in the world, causing me to have A LOT of issues to this day. The one who sent me to her weird fucking sister when I was 12, who then got me smoking cigarettes and drinking schnapps and telling me horror stories about how my biological grandfather tried to murder my Nana, stealing my innocence, because she was lonely and needed a friend. The one who constantly uprooted my life and told me she "doesn't need my grief" when I'd inevitably cry. The one who told me I should be grateful for my sexual assault, because when I get to be her age I'll be hard up. The one who ruined my engagement by calling me and telling me that my then boyfriend called and asked for Nana's ring, which was always meant to be mine, then dicked us around about it for months. The one that told me I was gross for still breastfeeding my 11 month old. The one who, after I was told I'd be losing my baby and possibly my life, immediately said "I just keep thinking about Lily's sweet face". Lily was her dog who was home alone. Her daughter was in a hospital bed dying in front of her face. The one who votes for people who directly hurt my family. And finally (there's more, but I'm spent): The one who treated me like a criminal when my GIRLFRIEND DIED! Did not support me or get me help. Never got my belongings back from the cops. Treated me like absolute shit, sent me to spend the summer with my homophobic father and so much more wrapped around that time.... Today is your birthday. Why did you have me? That's all I want to know. I wasn't an accident. So why did you fucking bother? 42 years of repressed emotion and I will never be the same. God, I think I fucking hate you."

Jennifer Harnage

"Just so we're clear, my dad is a piece of shit too. He never prioritized me and stopped paying child support when I was 12. I could go on, but my feelings about him haven't been repressed as long, so I'm more at a place of indifference with him. The mom stuff is very new, as in I only really started processing it within the last few months. Plus, a lot of political things are triggering my experience with the dead girlfriend when I was 16. Desantis's actions are very personally triggering, and not just because I'm a mother of queer children, but because I've been a student in Florida public county schools. My guidance counselor, Mr. Carey, is a big reason I survived the aftermath of Liesl's suicide. It breaks me....literally, I was in the fetal position sobbing...that Florida queer kids won't have a Mr. Carey to help them. What if they have parents like mine, or worse? 💔"

Parker

Damn. I cried again… As someone else has said, I was slightly hesitant about listening because it’s one of my cherished favourites and I often find covers of those…disparate pieces of my history…discordant, and oddly disorienting. But damn guys. Y’all nailed it. Truly. Oof. All. The. Feels. Thank you Love and light to everyone feeling it. …It’s a comfort to me to know she’s now free from the infinite pain that traumas engrave so deeply into our operating systems…and reunited with her boy. And if I’m deluding myself and our souls don’t live on - she’s still free of the burden. 💗❤️‍🩹💗

Jennifer Harnage

And then you posted this cover, and I shared it with... "Amanda Palmer joined up with The Righteous Babes to cover "This Is The Last Day of Our Aquaintance", a song Sinéad wrote about divorce. I listened to a LOT of Sinéad after Liesl died, as so much of her music is about loss and death. This song, in particular, was in heavy rotation in the summer of 1997. The lyric, "I will meet you later in somebody's office" , made me think of all the dreams I had that she showed up in the front office of our school, everything having been a misunderstanding or prank. How perfectly timed that Amanda released this on Patreon and YouTube today, my mother's birthday, when so much of the misery I felt during that time was due to how terribly my mom treated me.... I really hate her, I think. Really!" I love you, Amanda!

Kimberly P. Coburn

Haven't been around much, but continue my patronage always. Just stuff going on with the strike (I haven't worked all year) and son's divorce and his spiral. Ugh. I know grief. But I also know hope.

Sarah Williams

This song has always had a special place in my heart. You cover it so well. Thank you

Lisa Jackson

Thank you for this 🙏 I’ve seen Sinead many times live and I’ve heard her sing “In this heart” there is nothing purer. My heart aches at our collective loss. The world is a darker place, we shall never see her like again 🖤

Jen

I listened to the track on band camp this morning. I still don’t have words. I got chills. I put on my headphones and listened again and then another time. The song wrapped me in her arms and took me deep. There is something magical in the way Jhereck and you create together that I can’t put into words but it pulls me into the song like in machete and drowning in sound and this. The harmony is divine. Sinead’s lyrics are biting and take me back into my own divorce now a lifetime ago. And your voice over all of it- ethereal and full and raw. I love words but these don’t do the song justice. Thank you is the best I have. ❤️❤️❤️

Aimsel Ponti

fucking love this. When you first mentioned you were going to do a Sinead song I KNEW it was going to be this one. It could ONLY be this one. I love what you and Jherek and the Babes did with it so so much. Still kept its essence but inhabit it differently and it's fucking GORGEOUS and POWERFUL and my god...I love it. When I heard the news that Sinead had died I cried so fucking hard and couldn't stop for a while. I've loved her since the winter of 1986 when I was in Montreal with my parents and found a 12" single of the song "Heroine" she had done with U2's The Edge. I got to see her three times in my life and even met her briefly. She signed an album for me. My friend Julie feels the same way I do about Sinead so we booked a super cheap flight from Boston to Dublin and are venturing to Bray to visit her grave in November. Anyway..THANK FOR THIS. With all my heart. xx

Jim Lloyd

It's perfect. It all comes together to both evoke everything about the original and yet remain new. A beautiful homage.

Kelly Rainey

I really love these tribute covers that you do for so many reasons. They always feel so exactly right and I think that's because they are done so quickly and with so much feeling. They help. They make a difference. Thank you. and well done!

Erika Blumberg

This was every bit as beautiful as I expected. I loved how mournful the first few verses sounded, and I think the dissonance with the strings was a good call. Thank you.

Phil Parkman

Best tribute to Sinead I've heard yet - and I've heard many as a fan for nearly 40 years. Amanda channels her energy not just her vocals

Daniel Allen

Oh, my God. I am . . . I am right in the middle of this song. My marriage is ending, though it's not finalized. So . . . God, it hurts. And to hear it said in these words, by you and everyone else who put this together is . . . Stephen King wrote in 'The Shining' that “The tears that heal are also the tears that scald and scourge". And that's what's happening. Cauterizing the wounds. Thank you for this. You and everyone else. Thank you for your reasons, and your effort, and your love.

Laura Wellner

This recording is so amazing, as I knew it would be--the emotion in your voice brought me to tears. Hugs & Love!

Allyvin

I love it so much, there is so much emotion that you can feel through it. Thank you <3

Bane

Gorgeous, ladies and Jherek!! The timeliness of it all.

Luciana Amorim

Hello Amanda! My best friend is your biggest fan. His name is Felipe, and his birthday was on August 27th. Would you wish him a happy birthday? ~ I love the track, it’s so powerful!

Madison

This hits home hard for me right now. Cannot wait for the healing power of the Dresden Dolls this weekend 🤍🖤

Jane Sharp

Oh Amanda what a beautiful version! I got all the shivers! This song and album were so influential to me too. It came out just as I moved out of the family home at the age of 18. I loved Sinead’s fearlessness and wanted to be like her so badly, but alas I also wanted to fit in and be loved. In those days I thought that meant diminishing myself. It didn’t work. It’s taken a lifetime to find my inner warrior and hearing this song again is a perfect bookend. Rest well Sinead, you blazed so brightly through all of your pain and joy. Thank you Amanda 💗

Christine Leov-Lealand

As I’m reading this in NZ the sun is rising and the screen on my phone is getting brighter. Thank you for doing what you do Amanda - you have an amazing network of people around you and you deserve it. The veins of sexual abuse and violence wind through far too many families of every faith and no faith. Mine included - I feel seen in your writing and send you love and power to continue and grow in your mission. Hugs from us: Christine

T Nonya

I listened to this having not heard the original, then listened to the original. Y'all did a great job! Wonderful to get all the behind the scenes news about it too. Thank you.

Teresa Toro

When I heard the news that Sinéad had died, this was the song that came immediately to my mind and the one I played first — bursting into tears as I did so. It's always been one of my favorites by her, and personally meaningful. Of all the songs you could have covered, this had to be the one. I always think Niki's artwork is beautiful but in this case I echo and support others here who question the choice of portraying a woman of Muslim faith in the nude — however respectfully it was intended.

Alicia Webber

I re watched the Sinead documentary, last night, in preparation to listen to your tribute. As a mom of a 14 and a 15 year old daughter, these are the voices I want in our home, car, world. I've used music as a tool in my parenting; sometimes to say the things I don't know how or to emphasise an, already, meaningful moment. My kiddos requested 'Amanda" to set the tone for their first day of school, this year. It's going to be a good year. When the hair on my arms goes down, from listening to your tribute, I can't wait for this to be my kiddo's gateway to Sinead. Simply, Beautiful. Thank you. Alicia Webber (we hope to hear back about the Dolls staying in our NYC apt! The offer stands!)

Alison Nishi

I love reading about how all of this came together. Your post about Sinead was exactly what I needed on that day. I love reading about your emotional journey and growth and friend network. Thank you for sharing.

Emma

The Sinead cover sounds astonishing. Absolutely brilliant you and jherek and all involved should be very proud. Im

Emma

Im

Emma

im in the Uk and realistically may never make it to Graveside but I am totally happy to be contributing to it - please keep it going!

Marija Milisavljević Grdinić

The song is beautiful, every single word in this post is beautiful, and the art is beautiful too. You all did something magnificent to honor Sinead and it did not steal the spotlight, it couldn't possibly. It wasn't about you, but how she affected you, how she affected the world I guess. Thank you Amanda, and Jherek and Niki and Righteous Babes. ❤️

amandapalmer

Someone said this on Instagram and I responded there, too. There was thought put to this; there was one rendition of this drawing that Niki did where it was an exact likeness of Sinéad, and I nixed it. Not just for the above reason, but because this song and the themes - and the ripping - feel universal to me. Then we discussed whether or not the figure should keep her hair, and we cut it. But the idea is that this figure is an Everywoman. In retrospect, we probably should have kept the hair on. But the ship had sailed. Thank you for the note. X

Jillene Moore

* head-to-toe gooseflesh * Starts out so vulnerable. Ends up strong. So. Fucking. Strong. 🧡

EmVT

Hi Karen, I guess we don't know what Sinead would have thought. Definitely agree it would need to be carefully considered, which it sounds like Amanda and collaborators did, I see it as art inspired by the ideas, like vulnerability, evoked by the song. Amanda (and Nikki) don't seem afraid of artistic nudes so...I'm not surprised, and I think it's artistic. Again, who knows what Sinead would have preferred or not, but I don't think making the figure nude is automatically wrong. I don't know if the following is a real article, it's not on snopes as fake: "https://www.uncut.co.uk/news/sinead-o-connor-a-naked-playboy-shoot-is-on-my-bucket-list-31976/"

EmVT

"In This Heart" is a song I sing when I miss my late mom, it's so beautiful. The opening lyrics "In this heart lies for you a lark, born only for you, who sings only to you" remind me of unconditional love. I sing it to myself when working in the garden sometimes, for strength. It is amazing more people don't know it! :) Sinead's songs saved me when I was young and her death affected me a lot, still processing, like you ❤️ "I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got" is a great song too, possibly my favorite on that album. The album was named after it. But Nothing Compares to You overshadows it even though I don't think it's quite as good a song (not that I'm qualified to judge).

Chris Bowman

I was blown away by the raw pain, sorrow and resignation I heard in your voice and the absolutely gorgeous work of the Righteous Babes. Thank you to everyone who helped birth this song. Thank you Amanda for your continued vulnerability. 🩷💜💙 Right now I'm waiting with my family (husband, 3 kids, 3 pets) while Hurricane Idalia passes through. We just found out that this is the biggest storm to hit Alachua County (we're inside the county in Gainesville, FL) since 1890 via an evacuation order for mobile homes & unsound housing from the county. Fortunately, we have a good home to stay put in & are prepared if the power goes out.

amandapalmer

Thank you all for these beautiful comments…..just heading to bed and reading them all. I feel so fucking lucky. ♥️♥️♥️

Len Tower Jr.

Hmmm, so a part of being punk is satyagraha. -Len

Tim

Thank you, Amanda, for helping me process my own grief at her passing. I love you. Rest in power, Sinéad.

Helen Shaw

Dammit, Amanda. I didn't know I remembered 'In This Heart', because I was sure I hadn't had a copy of Universal Mother on hand in twenty years. Now I remember why [snivels] because that song made me randomly cry on the tube even back then, and it appears I still knew the words. Thank you. [disappears in search of more hankies.]

Jen G

The FEELS are real! What an incredible homage and interpretation! 🤍 (sand in my eyes)

Marie O'Reilly

Heart over flowing. Eyes over flowing. I'm in a little cottage on the Ring of Kerry in Ireland, half way up a hill. The walls of our holiday home are three feet thick and there's no WiFi. So I've wedged myself into this little upstairs window sill so I can get enough reception to listen, read and weep with you all.

Brian Fitzgerald

This is absolutely a masterpiece of a tribute, from the image to the arrangement to the execution to the make-me-freaking-cry-every-time-I've-listened raw emotion of it. And only today, on my umpteenth listen, did it hit me that the glorious jump into the anthemic at the end had the power and feel of a song to another martyr to truth: Biko. Well done Jherek, well done Amanda, well done Righteous Babes, well done Niki.

Jeremy Morton

I got my first cassette for my 14th birthday in 1990, 4 days after it came out: I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got. I played it over and over again; I read the lyric sheets over and over again, and it was... everything. Thank you so much for doing this song from this amazing, life-changing album.

Brett Gleason

I never heard this song before. I'm getting chilled just thinking about listening to your version yesterday. You and the babes. Wow.

Tamsin

Thank you! Bawled and bawled relistening to the album that I'd listened to over and over and over when I was a teenager....every song so deep and meaningful....so sad at her death and the loss of her. Devastating. This is a wonderful tribute. (also happy to hear you've got a fella!)