Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hello my loves.

I’m still jet lagged, still staggering-gathering my thoughts and heart, they’re scattered all over the place. But three things today, all mooshed together, because life is like that. First, about Valentines. Second, Gaza/Israel/Ceasefire. Third, ideas and input. I’m reading all comments today, all day, and responding to what I can. There’s a lot.

Write to me about politics or love. Sometimes I can barely see the difference.

The doors are closed, this is a private, patron-only post.

First.


Valentine’s Day. Oof.

Let’s begin this post by stretching our hearts open. Then we can talk politics. Anyone who’s an expert in writing or social media would advise me never to post about these two things in one setting. It’s bad business.


I’m not a business. I’m a fucking person.



We made cards for the whole class.

Oh, but my own achy heart, and his.

Five of my good friends are going through the agonizing heartbreak of divorce right now. These love-and-together-themed holidays can be bitterly confronting.

If you’re getting divorced right now, or are recently divorced, or have recently been through a bad break-up, let me tell you something:

Hold steady.

You need to sit through this bit to get to the next bit.

Love flows. It flows. It comes and goes. Your brain seeks company, but your heart knows.

Your cup will not always be full. Pour it out, let that old vinegar drain into the sink. Let it be empty, sometimes, so that you can wash it out. Start afresh. Go slowly. Steady. Slowly. Easy now.

My job right now, at this table, it feels, is to make sure this kid isn’t infected by cynicism. The idea of showing affection? It’s grand. It’s everything. It’s the best. Send it wide.

This Valentine’s Day, think big. Send affection where it needs to go. Send a text to your divorcing friend. Call up the lonely. Post a comment here for those who aren’t heading out to romantic candle-lit dinners but are stuck in the hospital, caring for ailing parents (I know two at the moment). Just take 2 minutes and think about who might want a text-hug.

Be the flow. Feel the flow. Send that fucking love where you know it needs to go.

It all comes back around, beauty.



……


Second - I’d like to hear the group’s thoughts about Gaza, Israel, the ceasefire, the horror and the way it feels to see this all playing out in our internet spaces and our family tables.


It’s a lot, and there’s no easy answers. It’s a mess.


Please comment with thoughts. Please be kind to one another in the comments.

When I read The NY Times article about the horrors inflicted on Oct 7 - the graphic and unspeakable acts of sexual violence - I nearly lost it and threw up while reading the paper.

It’s horrific. And also: Palestinians are suffering. There is clearly no big right or wrong here. I’m not pulling a Trump and saying “There are fine people on both sides”. I see violence and suffering on both sides and want to scream for peace. It feels very futile.

It seems that everybody on the internet is now an expert in Mideast politics and that frightens me. It seems that a lot of people are yelling, parroting, performing, trying so hard to help and feeling powerless. Nobody knows quite what to do to help. This is the hardest part about it.

I wrote this several days ago on socials:

A note about the call for a ceasefire / the situation in Gaza, and how we talk about it.

People have been commenting and criticizing me (and many other artists I know lately, yes, we share notes) for not saying more / posting more about the ceasefire.

First of all: when you tell a person they are being “silent” about an issue because they haven’t posted about it on the one single social media feed you follow, you are making an assumption.

I write and speak on Instagram, Facebook, Substack, Twitter/X, threads, What’s App, 8 different tiers of Patreon, on stage, at gatherings for my audiences, and at meetings in my local community. Until you follow me and hear what I say - or any artist says - on all of these platforms, please don’t generalize and tell them they are being “silent”. You do not know that, and the world does not end with Instagram (or Facebook, or any platform).

Second: I could call for a ceasefire until I’m blue in the face with daily posts on social media.

I spent the entirety of 2019 calling for abortion rights every day, on tour and through near-daily posts across social media. Where were these critics when millions of people were not posting daily about THAT impending catastrophe? Do you think it would have been wise for me to start going to random peoples feeds saying “Why are you posting about art or your family and being silent about the abortion rights catastrophe”?

We will not create peace overseas by building an online stadium for the Shame Olympics here on American soil.

Now Roe V Wade has been overturned, and honestly: I’m exhausted as fuck.

I despair for my world, as you do. I’m scared for my fellow humans, I see the atrocious war zone overseas and I feel the way you do. I think Israel should stop firing. I hope the guns and bombs stop killing people; I hope the Palestinians find peace and healing, I hope a solution can be found, I hope hostages get returned. I hope that complicated world over there can turn into a place where innocent little kids don’t die and suffer.

I call for a ceasefire. I pray for peace. And I call for Israel and Hamas to both get their shit together. Will it matter if a songwriter from America screams this?

So: I believe I am also allowed - and my fellow artists are allowed - to post about our art and our work in peace.

If you shame and bully an artist into being an activist, you’re gonna wind up with a fear-driven, inauthentic, fucked-up activist.

That’s not the kind of activist you want in the world.

We are all aiming, I hope, for a better and more peaceful planet.

Let artists make their art and posts and do what we can to help, in our way. I want to believe my art, indirectly, is helping people who are in other zones: political zones, activist zones, war zones, health care zones, mother zones. Sometimes I’m overtly political. Not always, and not every day.

You need us artists to make art. Don’t chase us offline. Many of my artist friends have left the internet because they cannot post in peace about their art OR their politics. We lose them. We lose the art.

We need the art.

We all gotta work together.

Do your work. Shine in your zone. Activate. Protest. Call for a ceasefire. But don’t shame your artists. We are smart. We know what’s going on. Let us do our work and activist-ing the way we need to do it, at the pace we can handle.

…..

I got a lot of flack for the above post; but I also got a couple dozen private texts from artist friends of mine thanking me deeply for the sentiment.

I lost 1,000 instragram followers.


I cannot care about that.

……


So, here we are today.

I have read up more on the situation. It just goes darker with every link. It does seem clear to me that calls for a ceasefire are increasingly important. But I wonder where those words will land. And if there’s money to donate, where?

Today, I joined Glennon Doyle, whose org I’ve supported before. They’re called Together Rising and I trust her deeply to get money where it needs to go to help actual human beings. She’s good at that. So I donated, and I made a call on socials for donations, and I’ll pass the call on here. (You can share this here on Insta and here on FB):

Since getting off tour and back to the states last week, I’ve been synthesizing and unpacking, listening to so many calls and thoughts and reading so many messages about Gaza, and thinking about how I can best help here on FB in a concrete and not performative way.

Today, I’m joining Glennon Doyle in this call she is leading, and I trust that the money that flows through her org, Together Rising, will get where it needs to go.

If you know Glennon’s work, you’ll hopefully trust that, too. I’ve just made a donation and I hope you join

I’m also about to send out a post to my patrons; I have a piano-fundraiser idea brewing that I may be able to organize for when I get back from Ash’s February vacation.

To some of the comments here: it's a yes, and. I'll add that the things that I've read and learned about the horrors - especially the sexual violence - inflicted against Israelis on Oct 7th is not to go without decrying. It sickened and sickens me. Release the hostages.

This whole thing is a mess. There's no easy way to tackle it. We know this.

///

More than one million Palestinians evacuated to Rafah - a Gaza region that is now one of the most densely populated places on Earth - because Israeli forces promised safety "further south."

Last night, the 1.4 million Palestinians trapped in Rafah endured relentless Israeli bombardment, which killed approximately 100 Palestinians - including Majed al-Afifi, a one-month old baby boy. Two Israeli hostages, Fernando Simon Marman and Louis Har, were rescued in the attacks.

Gaza's largest functioning hospital is operating at 300% capacity.

More than half a million people in Gaza are literally starving.

Since 2021, @Together.Rising has invested over $550,000 to provide humanitarian aid and relief to Gaza.

Today, we are committing another $100,000 to our long-standing partner Middle East Children's Alliance (MECA), Which is operating in that region, providing urgent relief to trapped people, and food to those with nowhere else to turn.

All the money we raise in the next 48 hours will be added to our $100,000 and immediately sent to support urgent relief and food to the people of Gaza.

Join us by donating at the link in bio:

http://TogetherRising.org/Give

………

And now back to us.

An idea, an ask.


You all asked a few months ago - when I queried - for more “Emergency Soothing Piano Music”.

We are a group of nearly 18,000 human beings.

I have this platform. This reach.

I’m also a tired ass mother.

But I’m uniquely situated to make art and activism and use the funds we have here for anything I / we want.

So I ask YOU:

If I did a thing to help / fundraise / call attention to this situation ….

What would help? What would end suffering? What would bring peace? What would ADD? Stitch? Aid? For real?

I have wanted, for a long time, to do an improv piano marathon - sort of like John and Yoko’s “Bed In” - for peace. Play for 12-24 hours. Bring guests. Stream. Fundraise. Make music for the people and bring peace through sound and donations.

Where would the money go?


Is there a way to help all sides, all those suffering, without getting caught in the crossfire?

How could we do this?

You’re smart.

You all tell me.

I’m reading. Hit me.

X

A


l

Files

Previews only

Comments

Hold my kombucha

Punishing/seeking to obliterate a people for the actions of a few is not justified self defence. Ceasefire is overdue. How horrific that Israel has followed in the footsteps of that which its founders suffered in the first place.

Angelica Sather Hodgetts

I want to add a thought i've been having since last night, on the back of a comment I saw here that said Amanda Palmer wouldn't be welcome to play a concert in "one" of these two countries, that "they" hate her and everything she stands for. I don't want to respond to that comment directly and start some kind of comment war, but I wanted to share my thoughts with all of you in general, because I do think it's important to discuss. What is it that you think these people hate, what to do you think Palestine is, honestly? There are gay people in Palestine. There are Jewish people in Palestine. You don't have to be Muslim to live there, you don't have to wear a headscarf in public to live there. Do you think there are no artists in Palestine? No musicians? No feminists? No activists? There are. There are mothers who love their children. The culture there is different than it is in the US, or in New Zealand, but that will be true for anywhere you go on this Earth. Los Angeles culture differs between neighboring blocks. Would Amanda Palmer be welcome to play a concert in the middle of the Japanese grocery store where I work in California? I don't think so...does that mean everyone working there should be wiped from the face of the earth? It's such a bizarre way to look at the world, EVEN IF IT WERE TRUE, because not everyone is welcome to do everything everywhere in the world, and that does not mean they don't have a right to live. I feel like AFP is in general a "live and let live" kind of artist; I don't think whether or not she personally would BE welcome in a venue should be relevant to a discussion concerning the violent execution of thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands of innocent children. Even if that perception of Palestine WERE true. And I think that the perception of Palestine that many people have/had is being stripped away, but also being made a reality, now, this year, in this moment. Thanks to journalists like Bisan and others, we have seen, through photos and videos, exactly what Palestine was like before this year. People there use iphones. People there live in apartment complexes. Palestinians have blogs and post on twitter and have brunch in cafes and drive their cars through roundabouts (traffic circles). Just like us. Just like Amanda. Just like anyone in 2024. But we have also seen dozens of before and after photos. Those traffic circles are mud now. The cafes are gone, the hospitals are gone, the thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands of children are gone, and so are their parents, either dead or pushed far out of their home, almost out of their homeland. And the final irony of that comment which inspired my train of thought, they failed to mention the most obvious reason it would be dangerous for Amanda Fucking Palmer to play a concert in Palestine...because it is, still, currently, bombed into the mud by Israel. If she did go there to play a concert now she would have trouble finding food, finding water, finding a piano. And she would also be in danger of being brutally murdered by either bombs or ground invasion at any moment. Not because she is Amanda Fucking Palmer, but because she would be in Palestine, and that is what is going on there.

EmVT

hi Angelica, when I read the comment you are talking about I thought it was referring to Hamas, not civilians in Palestine, but I will go back and read more carefully. To me the warring parties are, specifically, the armed forces of Israel, and the armed Hamas terrorists. I think all agree that the civilian casualties on both sides of this war are a horror. I agreed with the intent of that post which I thought was to be careful about making assumptions about what peace looks like, that not everybody shares the same vision that we might generally share in this chat--specifically about what freedom and compassion looks like. Definitely agree care is needed about not imposing one set of values as "right" which is the mistake colonizers make (i.e., colonizers say "we don't recognize what you're doing as 'right' through the lens of our belief system, so we have the right to step in"). This is where I personally find a "human rights" lens to be an important differentiator (I support Amnesty International).

EmVT

Patti Smith posted on IG about a group of Irish artists auctioning art and lyrics as a benefit. It would take coordination for team AFP but perhaps less so than mounting an entire benefit show. So, auctioning set lists, handwritten lyrics, other historical artifacts from videos etc