Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Thumbnail Help! - Please Vote

  • Uniform Color Background 46
  • Natural Background 88
  • 2021-12-04
  • 134 votes
{'title': 'Thumbnail Help! - Please Vote', 'choices': [{'text': 'Uniform Color Background', 'votes': 46}, {'text': 'Natural Background', 'votes': 88}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 12, 4, 22, 40, 43, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 134}

Content

Working on the edit for Part 6 of the GPZ series right now, but I took a break to do the thumbnail. This is always one of my least favorite parts of the process. I never want to make it tooooo stylized or click-baity, but I also want to make it as enticing and inviting as possible. 

I tried a uniform colored background on Part 5 and that has been my worst performing video haha (which is why I changed it). Of course, a lot of factors affect video performance, but I'm still wary! What do you guys think though? For Part 6, should it be a uniform colored background? Or natural?

Also, I'd love to hear why you prefer one over the other!

EDIT: I've added Green and Purple Options as variations, but can't add more choices to the poll

Files

Comments

Boudewijn Redeker

I like the uniformly colored one. Warning though:1) I have no taste and 2) I'm colorblind.

Ticho Ooms

Where's your "mouth-wide-open face pointing at the thing" for added value? Lol

Nubbles

oh this is a hard one

Bram Steenbrink

I feel like the uniform one is more clear, text is better readable, etc

David Block

Uniform color, because the shop is "secondary", it is the bike that is important, and should "stand out".

Alexander Bloedbarsch

Uniform color is way better, as it is much more clear when displayed at a small resolution. But maybe you should change the color, as blue is more of a low energy color.

Stuart Kay

Uniform directs ur attention to the bike, but can i also suggest putting ur face on the thumbnail? I hear it makes a big difference in terms of viewing figures if u have ur face on it

Alexander Bloedbarsch

I kinda dig the purple one, as it's close to the red, but still providing a contrast.

Scott Peterson

Uniform to catch the eye. Green is best of the choices available.

Silent Cartographer

My wife says clean natural background. I trust her on stuff like this, her dad is colorblind and has been helping him pick out color combinations for years.

Timothy Ambre

Do the one the gets the most views. Everyone needs more Fingerprints Workshop. Even if they don’t know they do yet.

Calvin Jilek

I like the uniform backgrounds as it makes the bike/project stick out more, but I picked natural because I like having the shop in the background (maybe with a skosh more background blur so the bike sticks out a smidgen further).

Chris Crujedo

I feel like this is one of those things where you pick between satisfying yourself artistically ("trying to make it complimentary to the red body work") or you chase the algorithm. Neither is inherently wrong and the latter makes financial/business sense. In the end, it kind of is what it is (see this video from LinusTechTips https://youtu.be/DzRGBAUz5mA from 4 years ago, or this Veritaseum video https://youtu.be/S2xHZPH5Sng from 3 months ago), and the tools that YouTube provides to allow you to A/B test thumbnails to choose the "best" one (quotes = "best performing in the sense of views/watches count") are there for a reason. Sadly, I feel like the truth is that aesthetics don't mean a lot in this case, LOL. That said, I like the natural color one 🤓. EDIT: To bring some balance, there's SmarterEveryDay https://youtu.be/ZVaUoyabjAg from 3 days ago, though I feel like he has some luxury of choice in his established position, as cynical as that sounds.

Paul Barwick

I like the natural shot. The bike still sticks out as it is more in focus than the background. I can't really state why I like the natural, it just is more appealing to my eyes.

Richard Farmer

I like the natural background, I think the bike stands out enough without the need for color.

Ronald Finger

I think that's very true for personalities or talking head youtubers! However, I don't think my face is at the forefront of my videos enough for the casual/average viewers of my videos to want to click when they see it. I'll consider it though!

Ronald Finger

I actually watched the Veritaseum video two weeks ago! That video's the reason why I went back and changed some other thumbnails of mine. Something he briefly touched upon in the video is something that Jack Conte said (the creator of Patreon), and that is that how you package your art does not matter, so long as your art is still true to you. As long as my video's are how I want to make them and it's the story that I want to tell, then I'm okay with the title/thumbnail being whatever it needs to be to attract the most people. I just gotta find out what that is haha. I'd love to be able to not care and just upload something that I'm proud of regardless of packaging, but since YouTube is my livelihood, it maters a whole lot.

Gary kromer jr

I really like green but natural caught my eye more.

Jasper

The natural background is easier to process visually.

Boudewijn Redeker

Yeah, but chasing the marketing can be frustrating and also somewhat useless. Better to choose the thumbnail you enjoy and would click on. It's not an exact science, so at least make it YOUR choice.

Steffen Hafsmo

Coloured background I believe looks better, but the natural background looks a bit less like an advertisement, so I'd vote the latter. It is sad that click-baiting is indeed necessary to achieve the highest amount of views. Remarkable quality alone is not enough.

Ariamaki

Uniform always looks terrible, natural 100% of the time.

Joey Bergeron

Stay true to what you like as an artist and don't worry about the numbers. Especially if it's just the color of a background.

Ben Edwards

I do like the stylistic approach.. but maybe split the difference. If you were to do the natural one but grade the back plate image and add some vignetting it may look nice. I am a retoucher would be happy to show what I mean if you have a PSD file I can play with. Also keep up the great work Ronnie, love the content.