Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Leave questions for Whole Cake and Reverie below! Please no leading questions or spoilers!!!

Files

Comments

Name

How was your opinion on Sanji changed from this ark because this is where a lot of people think, Sanji’s character turned around from the last couple where he had just been pervert guy compared to what he was in prayer times skip

Zoodinger

Some people think pre-timeskip One Piece is better. Now that you're far enough to form an opinion, what do you think about this?

Daemedeor

Aside from Brook, Sanji and Luffy, who do you feel has the best showing in the arc (and it can include big moms pirates as well)

Optyzma

honestly id probably say they should just catch up before giving their opinion on post ts as a whole

Sanji Joestar

The Live Action Season 2 coincided with many of the story elements you explored in this arc, giving you guys a very unique experience. With that in mind, what's your perspective on the story currently and moving forward?

Seanthebomb

Katakuri is one of the first major opponents Luffy fights who isn't truly a villain. Did that change how invested you were in the fight compared to fights against characters like Crocodile or Doflamingo?

Kiki Varas

What was your favorite part about Whole Cake Island? And after watching the arc what do you think of Sanjis character? Has your views of him changed for the better or worse? And lastly, What was one thing you disliked about Whole Cake Island overall?

Sanji Joestar

You often get asked what your opinions on some of the Supernovas are. Now that you've explored another one of them, what's your opinion on Capone Gang Bege?

100Rainy

This arc finally provides us with our first in-depth look into what an Emperor and her crew is capable of, did the Big Mom pirates live up to all the hype and expectations? Was our victory/escape far too clean or did we lose just as much as we gained in Whole Cake Island?

Sanji Joestar

What are your thoughts on the various kind of familial bonds explored in this arc? And what do you think of Brulee choosing to announce that Katakuri lost to her siblings?

Bootyman555

I seem to recall Carson being rather suspicious of our bird friends over at the news coo in earlier arcs. I’m curious how both of you feel about Morgan’s (the goat) and what he means to the story. You know, how does he fit in, why do you think Oda decided to introduce him now of all times, what’s his purpose, where will he go, what has he done, will he be important? Things like that. Also follow up, wedding cake or donuts??? 🤔🤔🤔

100Rainy

A sizable number of fans like to claim that if Zoro were there to witness Sanji attacking Luffy so fiercely, he would've fought or even killed Sanji on Luffy's behalf. In the moment Nami seemed shaken enough to distrust Sanji despite being so close to him, it's interesting to wonder how Zoro would react. I have my own opinions on this but what do you think, is that an accurate assessment of Zoro's character and of their crew dynamic in general? If Luffy had brought the other half of the crew along would the arc play out any differently?

Bootyman555

Can’t believe I wasted my whole cake question on big news morgans

Niru

During the fight, Luffy instantly sees through Sanji's facade, screaming that Sanji is the one who is hurting the most. This shows an incredible amount of emotional maturity. If we compare this to Water 7, Luffy took Usopp’s defiance personally, resulting in a devastating, prideful duel. How does the fight in Whole Cake Island showcase Luffy's growth as a captain? Do you think Luffy handled Sanji better because he understood Sanji’s self-sacrificing nature, or was the situation with Usopp fundamentally different because it wasn't forced by outside blackmail?

Swoobmeister

What did you think of each of the Sweet Generals and their role in the story? Were they utilized well?

myridiann

"who do you think is more likely to be the last enemy of the show, imu or blackbeard ? " "what is your opinion on Big Mom? was she underwhelming for you?"

100Rainy

So these days you hear nothing but near-constant praise for One Piece. Such as "the greatest in all shonen" and "the best of the big 3". It's really blown up in the west post-covid. Even during the publication of this arc there was full force OP glaze like that, just not as widespread. For context WCI in the manga ran for 3 years between 2016 and 2018. By this time Naruto and Bleach had already finished their manga runs and AOT was in the middle of the Return to Shiganshina arc. With all this considered and after getting this far yourselves, do you feel like One Piece had earned all those acclamations at the time or does it still have more to prove in your opinions?

Nole_05.

What do you think of big mom as a character and as a villain? Because she is often described a great character but a mid villain,which personally i think is wrong because she is one of the scariest characters in the show with is power.

100Rainy

When it concluded I remember a good handful of fans were left unsatisfied with the outcome of Luffy vs Katakuri. Many felt Luffy's victory was hollow and unearned especially since the battle was so one-sided for most of the arc. On the other hand some would argue this fight was less of a trial of strength and more like a triumph of spirit. Where the one with a broken will would fall in defeat. So what's your verdict? How does Luffy vs Katakuri stack up to all his previous fights?

excel

Whole Cake Island contains a number of thematic parallels between numerous characters in this arc, but perhaps the most central parallel is between Luffy and Big Mom. In the clash between these two characters, we learn about Big Mom as an abusive mother whose entire worldview is built upon a lie and her neurotic obsession with her past as just a malignant form of childishness and arrested development. Why do you think Oda decided to mirror and focus upon these aspects of Luffy (his child-like innocence, authenticity, and unconditional love for his crew) at this point in the story and what do you think Oda is trying to illuminate about these ideas and Luffy himself through Big Mom?

Kiki Varas

Overall, What is somethings you wished the arcs would overall improve on? And in terms of Writing, Plot, Characters etc, What is something you liked in this arc that you’d wish would be in the next arcs as well?

Daemedeor

What are you talking about. He’s BIG NEWS

Daemedeor

How do you feel about the world having a god above the gorosei and ruling the world as its leader in the center of the world as soon as the concept of an empty throne was introduced

Porco

What do you think future themes are going to be that Oda hasn’t covered? Any you would like him to cover?

Irfan Ishraf

What do you think about whole cake island arc comparing to enies lobby because there's some similarities that luffy want to bring back one of the crew

Stinky Pete

How do you feel about Big Mom now vs when she was first introduced in Fishman Island?

Cheddah Slammer

If you could live on one of the islands around whole cake island which Island would you live on?

Mo za

Do you think mother caramel had a soul pocus? And if so did it or didnt work because people might've not be afraid of her since she was pretending to be a good person.

Zoodinger

From your reactions I think Whole Cake is your favorite arc so far. Is this correct?

rune

We usually get the crew divided, that's just how arcs really go. Now major arcs take this to another level with Dressrosa and Whole Cake Island having only half of the crew + Luffy. Which do you prefer the Dressrosa half of the crew or the WCI half of the crew in terms of their roles in their respective arcs?

rune

Who are your favorite(?) Big Mom children? Maybe name 3-5. As a whole, where does the Big Mom crew land on your list of pirate crew rankings? Be it based on strength, creativity, scope, etc. whatever metrics you have on pirate crews and how you rank them.

Oussama Essamadi

Wholecake Island Arc: Wholecake Island arc explored a buried and an unexpected hidden origin of one of the strawhats, Sanji. What do you feel about it and how has it changed your perspective on him? Was it warranted? Do you think Oda might pull a similar move on another Strawhat? I have always viewed Big Mom actually a failed version of Luffy? Both build huge “families,” love food, attract strange allies, and reshape islands around their desires. But Big Mom’s dream of equality becomes authoritarian, while Luffy’s freedom remains personal. Is Oda showing what Luffy could become if his hunger and charisma were corrupted? Do you think Luffy actually “won” Whole Cake Island? He rescued Sanji and escaped, but Big Mom’s crew remained mostly intact, Pedro died, Jinbe stayed behind, and Luffy did not defeat the main villain. What counts as victory in One Piece? The conflict and resolution of this arc present a very interesting question. Is food the moral center of Whole Cake Island? Sanji feeds people regardless of whether they deserve it. Big Mom consumes without restraint. Streusen enables her. The wedding cake saves everyone. Is food being used as a test of character? Levely Arc: Do you guys think Levely make the world feel bigger or more claustrophobic? We see kings from everywhere, but also realize how much of the world is controlled by a tiny elite. Did the arc expand the setting or reveal the cage around it? Does the existence of Imu reframe the entire series? Before Levely, the World Government seemed like a corrupt institution. Now it may have a hidden singular will. Does that make the conflict more mythic, political, or sinister? Does Saint Charlos being punched again feel satisfying, or does it expose how little the system changes? Luffy punched a Celestial Dragon at Sabaody. At Levely, the same ugliness still exists. Is individual heroism enough against systemic power? I think this saturates well with how Mjosgard was charged for good but not using violence, instead it was Orihime’s kindness and patience.

Allain Gumapon

At the start of the arc you both thought that Luffy was gonna be able to beat Big Mom but that slowly changed throughout tbe arc. What moment started that thought? Also, as the first Yonko who's powers and capabilities were fully shown, what did you think of Big Mom as an antagonist to the Straw Hats? Did this change/solidify your thoughts on the Yonko's strengths and influence?

Oussama Essamadi

A question about Big News Morgan’s is an investment, not a loss.

weiweiwei

Theories on the fallouts of Reverie

SD Reunion

As the plot gets more grand and epic, it’s getting more and more difficult to provide equal development to each member of the straw hat crew. After watching Whole Cake, what straw hat member focused arcs or flashbacks do you guys feel are necessary for the series to conclude in a satisfying way?

Samrathpal Singh Thind

“Stabbing in the back isn’t fair red nose” to buggy in episode 3 to “there is no such thing as fair duel in a fight between pirates” to katakuri, what are your thoughts about luffy’s growth as a captain( and as a character).

Harold

Rank your favorite strawhats so far.

Samrathpal Singh Thind

What devil fruit would you eat post-timeskip? as I remember Marco’s fruit being your favourite during marineford discussion.

Samrathpal Singh Thind

Even though Pedro died perespero is still alive, and pekoms and pound’s condition is still uncertain. In your opinion what do you think happened to them, are they dead or the Will of P live on.

Samrathpal Singh Thind

Who is your favourite character between Caesar Clown, Pharmacist Cedar and Gangster Gastino?

Daniel Assis

As someone who's been in the community for a long time, I've always felt this arc is underrated because of Big Mom's and Whole Cake Island's Alice in Wonderland-inspired aesthetic. Some fans even say it doesn't feel like One Piece. (I disagree) Yet it's one of the most unique arcs in the series, with a melancholic ending instead of the usual celebration and some of the few real deaths in the present-day story. As the first Yonko crew to be fully explored as villains, do you think Oda delivered the level of threat and hype the Big Mom Pirates deserved? Did this arc give us any characters you'd like to see return? And overall, did it surprise you more positively or negatively?

BoldCast

Top 3 favorite characters you got introduced to?

Daniel Assis

Since the Straw Hats were split up, if you could swap one Straw Hat from the Dressrosa group into Whole Cake Island, who would you choose and why?. I'd also like to hear your thoughts on the new characters introduced in this adventure, especially Carrot and Pedro. Personally, I love Carrot, but do you think they were good additions to the story?

Copper Nickus

What is your take on the Straw Hats joining an assassination attempt? Luffy has always stood up against the big bad but always with the ambiguous "I'll kick your ass" sentiment, never the "I'll end your life" sentiment. Did you find it strange or question it at all? Do you believe it makes sense at this stage in the story?

Moe Zee

Not a question, but hear me out. Now that you've finished Whole Cake Island, I need some one to pitch this idea to Oda, a spin-off morning kids' show with the sole purpose of indoctrinating future generations into One Piece. The show would take place entirely on Whole Cake Island since it already has those heavy Disney and classic kids' show vibes with all the singing food and colorful aesthetic. The protagonist would be one of Big Mom’s youngest toddler kids, and the show would just be about their silly daily adventures. Plus, they could constantly reference the Straw Hats throughout the show like treating Luffy like some mythical bedtime story legend or a cryptid who steals food. Honestly, Oda would probably love it since he’s a huge Disney fan

Lūthér Hölâyèãhmé

What are your thoughts on the show revealing a possible final Big Bad this late in the story? Who/What do you imagine is/are the final antagonists that will need to be defeated by the end of the story?

Alex Recorde

For a lot of fans, after punk hazard they keep updating their favorite arc, everything keeps ramping, lore going deeper. It can be recency bias but is this happening to you guys too? Or you guys still feel like Marineford/Enies lobby its still at the top? Enjoying this Post punk hazard stretch is what separates the pre time skip enjoyers vs post time skip enjoyers.

Gralthator

This arc completed many long term setups. Jinbe and the Tamate Box from Fishman Island. Lolas vivre card from thriller bark. North blue Sanji in Jaya/Mr. Prince in Little Garden. What are your opinions on how the story handled these extended payoffs?

idziman

Now that you've seen Tankman and Snakeman, what animal/form of Gear 4 do you want to see next? What would differentiate this form from what Luffy's shown off before with his forms?

Ty

Thoughts on Luffy as a captain this arc?

BTImelesS

The Reverie reveals that there is a ruler in the empty throne and that the Gorosei (five elder stars) are going to extinguish/erased a light from "history". Knowing that the void century is lost in history and it's a crime to research it, what do you think of the role of history and politics in the story so far and where do you feel like this story is going to? What do you think it means to erase someone from history for the world government vs for example for someone like Hiriluk and his speech?

Clockwerk9000

with pudding being the twist villain of the arc then later redeemed what are your final thought on her character? Do you agree with her final decision with what she did to sanji?

David P

I believe this comes from exoerience. Dont forget to mention what Crocodile said to Luffy. "there's no rules when pirates fight each other, anything is fair game."

Gamemetrician

Luffy, Blackbeard, and Big Mom in a food eating contest. Who win?

Rojo

Gotta ask. Any thoeries about what the one piece is? This isn’t arc specific but I’d love to know if your thoughts and theories have changed or been updated.

Ramiro Quijada

Given what we know about big mom having different partners and knowing that kaido and big mom share a past do you guys think katakuri , daifuku and Oven are kaido kids

David P

This is my take on the FINAL fight. My question is, after reading this, what is your opinion and thoughts on Oda, when it comes to shonen battle fights? His growth during the series and in comparison to other mangaka (sorry if it’s too long for your discussion segment). The Katakuri and Luffy fight is pure poetry. They fight in the mirror World and just as a reflections, they start to look more and more similar to each other. While they both start fighting to protect their "family" as hours go by, it becomes about respect and surpassing each other. Katakuri stabs himself for a fair fight and leaves the "Charlotte" jacket behind, while Luffy, who could have left Katakuri trapped in the mirror world after he escaped with Brulee, could have gone to Chocolate town but instead decided to come back to the mirror world because, as he said, "I want to supasss him, I want to beat the Billion Bounty Man at his best !" A fight in the mirror world where Luffy becomes more like Katakuri, by staying calm and learning future sight, and Katakuri, who becomes more like Luffy, by accepting himself. Luffy completely ignored the deformity that people made fun of, instead focusing entirely on the fight. Luffy’s unapologetic freedom and authenticity acted as a breath of fresh air. Katakuri saw in Luffy a man who didn't care about appearances or pretending to be perfect, so he took off his scarf and fought him head on. Indeed, a mirror fight where both characters became more like each other, by growing both physically and mentally to match one another in the ultimate honor bound fight. Personally, this is Oda’s best fight when it comes to themes, choreography and payoff. Maybe top ten in manga : )

Daniel Assis

This might be a silly question, but now that we know Sanji's siblings, it feels like the perfect time to ask and I never see anyone ask about this, and since it's my first time participating here on Patreon, I wanted to ask what may be the most important question of all: WHICH SIDE OF SANJI'S CURLY EYEBROW DO YOU PREFER? I must confess, his post-timeskip look with the fringe covering the right side and the eyebrow curl at the beginning drives me CRAZY (I don't even know why). I really wish Oda would switch his fringe back to how it was pre-timeskip. Having the curl at the end of the eyebrow just looked so much cooler and more stylish to me! There, I said it! SOMEONE PLEASE START AN SBS CAMPAIGN FOR THIS!!!

ednapls

The Gorosei first appeared back in 2002, during the Jaya arc, and then sat in the story as a vaguely sketched concept for roughly sixteen years. Clearly important, never fully explained, just present, until the Reverie finally revealed they answer to someone above them. For an author where do you think the line sits between disciplined patience, knowing exactly what you're holding back, and simply leaving yourself a deliberate blank space you can fill in later once you've decided what it means?

SolitaryLark

Since we’ve now had several supernova return if you where to hazard a guess who do you think from the group is appearing next?

Sonicluis

I’m just a little sad we never got film z, film gold, and stamped. Right after there respect arc. Where already in Wano and we skipped over those 3 fun and added content oda made for us.

Julio Martinez

The fight of Luffy vs Katakuri, do you think Katakuri let himself lose? There's a big debate, at least in Latin America (I don't know about the Anglo-Saxon community), but most people think Katakuri let himself lose (I don't believe that).

Indy Bruining

Do any of the songs from this arc stand out to you specifically? Do you have favorites?

100Rainy

Edit or remove this comment please. You're getting mixed up by future events and unintentionally spoiling. The connection between these characters has not yet been revealed at this point. Re-read their separate introductions if you want proof, there's nothing they've seen so far to suggest they have anything to do with each other.

Oshidi

I think you’re misunderstood. I only caught up to the beginning of Wano, and I remembered they have the same name that’s all. Apologize.

100Rainy

They don't. Go back to their separate introductions and review their introductory boxes. No similarities in their presented names at all.

Oshidi

The media really mess with ppl’s brain😭. I thought for sure it was introduced that way.

charlie

the last like 300 episodes have been building up to Wano where do you think the story will go after Wano and what do you hope to see after Wano (sorry if these questions are about too far in the future)

Nicolas LeBlanc

The Whole Cake island arc main villain was too strong for Luffy and his crew to face and win (W Brook fight vs Big Mom). Would you want to see this scenario happen again and against possibly who?

Nicolas LeBlanc

Will Carson or Lindsay be wearing a nun outfit for the podcast?

100Rainy

In the past you guys would sometimes comment how you wished Brook would get more shine to feel more integrated with the crew, and you expressed similar sentiment towards Franky. Many fans consider WCI to be an excellent showing for Brook and label him as the arc MVP. Much like how Dressrosa gave Franky some choice character moments, WCI does the same for Brook. Are you satisfied with Brook's place on the crew now or are there still some things lacking for you?

Emergency

What’s your expectations after Imu reveal to the story? And dofy secret

Sanji Joestar

Oda probably chose to make them that way because they look like 66 for his siblings and he's the black sheep so his go the other way.

RanSim

Which crew fight made you suffer more? Luffy vs Usopp or Luffy vs Sanji?

gWg834g42t

I don't think they should answer this until after Wano & the arc after that.

zeldro

Has your opinion of Sanji as a character changed after finishing WCI?

Jack Shadow

In the One Piece community, there is a lot of arguing going on about the Shadow King Imu. What are your thoughts on this? Did Oda plan this, or just add Imu as Sultan? The question is important because the Gorosei were introduced long before, but we never saw them serving the Shadow King, despite all Masonic pyramid references.

Monkey D.offy Lucci

How did you like the handling of spitting the crew in half during Dressrosa arc and then in Whole Cake Island arc?

Ryan

Wouldn't be bad to answer now, then see if the next 2 arcs change that in any way, answering it again in the future

beannie

You’re halfway through post timeskip!! Congrats❤️ Now that you’ve spent more time in this part of the story, I would like to know who are your current favorite straw hats and characters, and why!!

Terrance Matthews

@BOLDcast You have now been introduced to an advanced form of Observation Haki in Future Sight. What do you think of it and the fact that Haki blooms in the heat of battle?

Fabulous

opinion on luffy vs katakuri fight and katakuri as a character

Chris

What’s your biggest Whole Cake Island conspiracy theory based ONLY on information available through the end of the arc? No manga or future arc spoilers. Mine is the one that Mother Caramel necer actually disappeared but that Big Mom ate her purposely or on accident