Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

You will be changed... for bad?

An entire year has gone by since Wicked caused a rift amongst the Showmen, but the film adaptation of the second act of the stage musical, Wicked: For Good, is here to either bring them back together or tear them apart once and for all...

Double the length of act 2 of the stage production but refusing to flesh out any of the rushed parts and instead wasting that time on original songs that will not win them the Oscars they were written for, this movie is a goof fest from start to finish... but it's not totally the fault of the film production. Whether you've experienced it for yourself or heard it from others, act 2 is an insane mess, and attempting to adapt it into a movie was sort of an impossible task.

Hey, at least it made for a super fun commentary track! Which btw is full of spoilers, so be warned if you have yet to see the movie or the stage show.

Close your eyes, tap your heels together three times, and think to yourself... there's no place like Wicked: Part One.

PS. Pay no attention to that roll of paper towels... (it's NOT toilet paper, I swear!)

Guests: Miles, Showmen

Ready for another commentary track? Browse the full library!

Comments

screamussy

I can’t wait to watch this!!!

Amanda Askin

Omg I saw WFG last night and I’m dying to know what y’all think of it!!!!

Amanda Askin

33:55 I’m so glad you noticed the “this is me” vibes there too!! I laughed in the theater cause I thought it was about to turn into a This Is Me or You Will Be Found moment

Cam'ron

My wife and I legit had an argument the other night over if Spongebob was a munchkin or not, and I ended up being wrong and yelling BUT HE'S FULL SIZED THOUGH

Gillian

Random question for the Showmen: would y’all ever do commentary tracks for musicals that already came out: ever since you mentioned doing the Halloween classic remakes a few years ago I’ve been dreaming y’all watch Phantom of the Opera. Also I’d love if y’all did the Wiz, Rock of Ages with Tom Cruise, Hairspray, Moulin Rouge!, or the blockbuster hit with Meryl Streep as a supporting actor to James Corden - Into the Woods!

haley powell

i feel like they changed nessas whole thing cause media literacy is dead and no one realized depiction is not endorsement. so they were like nah scrub all the ableism. wish the replaced it with something that made sense tho cause what they did was so eh

Leezzyzz

About the yellow brick road: in the Wizard of Oz movie the yellow brick road DOES go in a bunch of directions, but Dorothy is still told to just follow "the" road. It’s when she comes to a fork in the road and doesn't know which direction to head in after Munchkinland that she meets the Scarecrow (which does bring up some timeline issues here around the Scarecrow, but whatever lol)

Steevn Sonder

Them: You seen Wicked 2 yet? Me: No, but I listed to the commentary for it twice!

Ethan Brundeen

You guys are absolutely on fire in this commentary, you immensely improved on the viewing experience of this snoozefest

Colson Verheul

I love all PMI content, but Showmen tracks are literally my favorite tracks.

Macauly Leiher

Starting to think this guy isn’t that good of a director and only made one dope movie an forgot how to put sauce in his work

Iain Coughlan

Can’t wait for the wicked x dune x woman in the yard collab

Ashley Lynne Evans

I felt seen when y’all reacted the same way I did to deepfake Jeff Goldblum’s Polar Express-lookin ass. But I gotta say, the mental image of House MD falling out of the sky onto Nessarose is my favorite takeaway from this track 😂

Turnip Crazy

I came back to this video cause I just had a thought, do you think the Showmen boys would ever want to watch the Spongebob proshot with Ethan Slater. Since you know you guys have a bit about cheering Boq, it could easily transfer over to be a funny commentary video. Ethan does a really good job embodying Spongebob

awfultaco

I kind of interpreted the end scene with the pages turning in the Grimmerie as Elphaba's way of showing Glinda that she's still alive!

Bryanna

If this was made 2015-2020 the lion would’ve be voiced by James corden. Also the scene when nessa gets crushed by the house is unintentionally so funny to me.

Patrick Hale

They should’ve incorporated the scene from Muppets Wizard of Oz where Toto rubs Tin Man’s nipples. Would’ve made it line up more with the goings on in the Wicked book. And that isn’t a bit, I swear

Nikki Beckett

HARD agree that Michelle Yeoh is kind of miscast and that she absolutely doesn't want to be there, I was quite distracted by her performance in this one and not in a good way but good for her, get that money

Cam Silas

you 4 are so electric together it's just the best everytime you make a track

Cam Silas

i need minimum of 4 showman tracks in 2026

Vince D

Missed this in theatres but now I can catch up on some Showmen! Also, is this the first 4 person van/drive in track?

HoeMalone

I really loved the first one, and when Eric said part two would be bad, I thought he was exaggerating. Nope. The plot feels rushed yet drags. The songs are bland at best. And this film has weird MCU moments. So thankful I can watch it with you this time around and laugh. Edit: Eric also CALLED a Rhino being in this movie during the monkey transformation scene in the last.

Simon

I HAVE CHANGED FOR GOOD: My Wicked Witch Apology Video (I did nothing wrong) SING-ALONG (lyrics on screen) !!ELPHABA HAT AMC POPCORN BUCKET GIVEAWAY!! #dontsaythemword

Josh

tin-cel and boq-corn going on my christmas tree next year

Abby Mason

I love the musical and absolutely hate these movies. There's some shining moments, but it's so unbelievably dull visually and boy does it it drag. The Showmen are the only ones who could save it

Steevn Sonder

I was tryna figure out why Nessarose’s legs curled up like a roly poly when she’s killed by Dorothy’s house and it occurred to me that the writer of Wicked must’ve made that character disabled because of those roly poly legs. “Well if her bones do that then she was probably disabled!” ✍️📖 Broadway drugs must be crazy…